Eldridge v. Astrue
Filing
17
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10-30-12. (jcj)
CLERK' OFFI U, . sT COURT
S
CE S DI .
AT ROANOKE, A
V
q Fu .
y
lj
.
.
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI C OU RT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI O F V I NI
CT
RGI A
CH ARLOTTESV I
LLE DI I ON
V SI
02T 32 2 1
22
JUUA . L CL RK
D EX
B;
Y
.
k
P 1- Ct
7Y .
E
N AN ETTE D .W .ELDRI GE,
D
Ci lAc i N o. 3: 2CV 0001
vi ton
1
7
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
M EM O M ND UM O PI I N
N O
MI
CHA EL J.A STRUE,
Com m i s one ofSoc alSe urt
si r
i
c iy,
By:
H o r l G l n E.Con a
no ab e e
zd
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge
De e nt
f nda .
Pl ntf ha fl t sa ton c l ngi t fnalde s on oft Com m i s one of Soc a
ai i f s ied hi c i hale ng he i
ci i
he
si r
il
Se urt n ngpl i ifsc am sf s biiyi lr ncebe ft a s pl me a s trt i m e
c iyde yi antf l i ordia lt nsza
ne is nd up e nt l ectiy nco
be isunde t SocilSe urt Ac,a ame d, U. C.jj41 i a 423,a 42U. C.j
neft
r he a c iy t s nde 42 S.
6() nd
nd
S.
1 1 s q.r pe tvel J iditonoft sc r i purua t 42U. C. 405( a 42U. C.
381 e ,es ci y. urs ci
hi ou ts s nto
S. j g) nd
S.
j 1 c)3) Thi c t rviw i lmiedt adeemi ton a t whehe t r i s tntal
383( ( . s our' e e s i t o tr nai s o t r he e s ubsa i
s
e de e t s
vi nc o uppo tt Com m i soners c l i n t tpl ntf f ie t e t bls e ttem e t
r he
s i ' onc us o ha ai i f a l d o s a i h n il nt o
be i sunde t A c . l s h s t n i e de e e s s t fna de i i oft Com m i s one
neft
r he t f uc ubs a tal vi nc xit , he i l c s on he
si r
mus beafr
t fimed. La v.Celbrz ,368F. 6 ( hCi.1 .Sttdbrel s t tal
ws
e e ze
2d 40 4t r 966) ae ify, ubsani
e d eha be n de i a s h r l va e de e, ons de i t r or asaw hol a m i be
vi enc s e tned s uc e e nt vi nc c i rng he ec d
e, s ght
f
ound a
dequa e t s
t o uppor aco us o by ar as bl m i R i ha ds v. a es 402 U . 389,
t ncl i n
e ona e nd. c r on Per l ,
S.
400( 971.
1 )
Thepl i if N a te El i w a bo n o M a 6, 969, nd e t lycom pl t herhi
a ntf , ne t drdge, s r n y 1
a ven ua l
e ed
gh
s ho e aton.M r . drdgeha be n e pl d a ar t i s l m a r s esas oc a e, e a y
c ol duc i
s El i
s e m oye s e a l a es nge , al s i t di t r
a de, nd f tf w o ke . She l s w o ke on a r g a and s t ne ba i i 2007. n Se e ber
i a as ood r r
at r d
e ul r
usai d s s n
O
pt m
5,2008,pl i if fl a i tons f r di a lt i ur nc be ft a s em e a s c liy
a ntf ied pplca i
o s biiy ns a e ne is nd uppl nt l e trt
Comm isone i s
s i r s uppore by s t nta e de e. I f l t tt fnalde son of t
td
ubsa il vi nc t olows ha he i
cii
he
Com m i s one m us be a fnned. La s v.Ce e e e,s a
si r
t fi
w
l br zz upr .
l afim i t Comm isone ' fna de ii t cou t esnots
n fr ng he
s i r s i l cson,he r do
ugges t t r . drdg
t ha M s El i e
i fe of a lpan,dic f r,we knes a f tgue. l e pl i ifs own t si
s re
1 i s om o t a s nd a i
nde d, antf
e tmony a t
t he
a i s r tvehe rng s
dm ni ta i
a i ugge t t ts i s gnii an l i paie Them edi l e r c i t t
s s ha he s i fc ty m r d.
ca r co d onfnns ha
pl ntf ha s htte men f s rousba k pr e ,a t the docor do notquesi t
ai if s oug r at t or e i
c obl ms nd ha r t s
ton he
s ve iyofhe c
e rt
r ompl i s Howe r im us ag nbeno e t tt teai physca i t sca e
ant .
ve ,t t ai
t d ha he r tng
i ins n hi s
ha no pr
ve t oduc c i c fndi c it ntw ih a di a i m us ul ke e ali pa r e . The
ed lni al i ngs ons s e
t
s blng
c os l t m i m nt
o jcietssh v as p o nn g tv .No d co h ss g etdt a Mr. d i g i ttly
be tv et a e lo r ve e aie
o tr a u g se h t s Elrd e s oal
dia e f a lf m sofwor I mus be r c ze t tt i biiy t do wor wihouta
s bld or 1 or
k. t t e ogni d ha he na lt o
k t
ny
s b e tv ds o o t o s t is lrn r cama t oal d s be Cri v. ae , 6F.d
u j ci e ic mf r d e no oftef e de a li n t tly ia ld. az Ch tr 7 3
585,594- (t Ci.1 96 .Thec tfndst tt Admi srtveLa J consdeeda1 of
95 4h r 9 )
our i ha he
nitai w udge i r 1
tes b e tv fco sra o a l s p re b t eme ia r c r i a j d c tn p an ifscams
h u j cie a t r e s n b y u po td y h dc l e o d n du iai g litf li
f be ft . l f low s t t a 1 f c t of t Com m i s o ' fnal de i i a e s ppo t d by
or ne is t o l
ha l a e s
he
s i ner s i
c s on r u r e
s t i e de e.
ubsantal vi nc
l pa s ng,t c tno e t t t r i s e i c i t tt m e c lpi t e i M r .
n s i he our t s ha he e s om ndi aton ha he di a c ur n s
El i e' ca e ha c nge Att tm e ofor la g en i t c e, a ntf r pr e e t t
dr dg s s s ha d.
he i
a r um t n he as pl i if e es nt d o he
cou t ha s ha s ughtte t e f om di f e m e c pr de s and t ts e c st r c ve
r t t he s o
r a m nt r
fer nt di al ovi r ,
ha he xpe t o e ei
be t r di nos a t t c us and ext of he l r ba k dys unc i
te ag es s o he a e
ent
r owe c
f ton. W hie t r i no
l he e s
i c tont t he ei ne e d ne whihwo di caet t heComm isone ' c r ntde son
ndi a i ha t r s w vi e e c ul ndi t ha t
s i r s ure
cii
s dber c i r t c t e t tM r . drdgem a wiht fl new a i a i i m or
houl
e onsde ed,he our not s ha s El i
y s o ie
pplc tons f e
r c ntm e c le l tons doc e a w o s ni ofhe m us ul kel t c
ee
di a va ua i
um nt
r e ng
r
c os e al ondii n.
to
4
A sa g ne a r e, es uton ofc lcsi t e denc i am at rwihi t pr nceof
e r l ul r ol i
onfi t n he vi e s
te t n he ovi
t Com m i s one e i t cour m i r ol t c l c sdif r nty. Ri ha ds v. r e ,
he
s i r ven f he
t ght es ve he onti t f e e l
c r on Pe al s
s a; nhem v. nc 495F. 396( hCi.1 .Fo t r a onssae t c ti t
upr Oope i Fi h,
2d
4t r 974) r he e s ttd,he our tnds he
Co m i sone ' r s uto oft pe tne c lc s i t r co d i t s c s t be s ppore by
m s i rs e ol i n
he r i nt onf i t n he e r n hi a e o
u
td
s tntal vi nc Ac r ngl t fna de ii oft Commi sonermus beafi d.La
ubsa i e de e. co di y,he i l c son he
si
t
fnne
ws
v. lb e z , u r .Ana p o raej d me ta do d rwil ee tr dt i d y.
Cee r z e s p a
p r p it u g n n r e lb nee h s a
Thecer i die t d t s nd c rii co e oft so ni t alc
l k s r c e o e e tted pis hi pi on o l ouns lofr o d.
e
ec r
y
t r 01
DATED:Th s -o N da ofocobe , 2 2.
i '
?
Chi Unie St t sDititJ e
ef t d a e src udg
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?