Smart Choice Construction, Inc. v. Ceco Building Systems et al

Filing 46

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 12/3/2012. (mab)

cœ v s OFFI U. ol .
CE s. r LOURT
ATRX OKE,V
A

C gl
Fjz
I .
L
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGW I
A
CH ARLO TTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

23 2 1
02
J I ,
ULA
EP

<
c

SM A RT CH O I CON STRU CTI ,l C .
CE
ON N ,
Ci lA c i N o. 1
vi ton
3: 2CV00021
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O

CECO BUI NG SYSTEM S, 1/,
LDI
: 1,

By:Hon. e E.Co a
Gln
nr d
ChifUnie Stt sDititJ
e
td ae src udge

Dee ns
f nda t .

Sma t o c Co t cin Ic (tma t oc ' fldti a to f rb e c o c n rc i
r Ch ie nsnzt ,n .t r Ch ie' ie l s ci n o ra h f o ta tn
o
s
)
l
teCic i Co r f rt Co nyo Cule e a an tCe oBul igSy tms(t c ' a d
h rut u to he u t f p p r g is c idn se ç o' n
Ce )
W a nesErcig, Ci a nesEr ci f'. Afe t c s wa rmo e t ti c u t nt e
y ' e tn LLC W y ' e tn ) tr he a e s e v d o h s o r o h

b sso dv riyj rs ito , r Ch ien n e isc mplit oicu etes b e t o ka t
a i f iest u idcin Sma t oc me d d t o an t n ld h u j c c n cs
wih Cec a W a ' Er c i Rel ng ont f u s l ton ca eco ane i t Ce o
t
o nd yne s e tng.
yi
he or m eec i lus nt i d n he c
c r c a t he t t a e d co pli t Ce o hasnow m o t ta f rve t t Unied
onta t tac d o he m nde m a n , c
ved o r nse nue o he t
St t s Di t i tCo tf t Sou he n D it i tofTe ,H o t D i son.
a e sr c ur or he t r s rc
xas uson vi i
B ackground

Ce i aDea r c por tonwih isprncpalplceofbusne si Houson. l 2008,
co s
lwa e or ai
t t i i
a
i s n
t
n

Ce oe tr dit ac nr c wi M . Ru s lCo sr ci n(M . Ru s l), u s a t owhih
c nee no o ta t t D. s el n tu to ç D. sel p ru n t c
h
$
'
Ce agr e t pr vi t ma e i sf t c tuci n ofam ealofie buidi i Cul pe ,
co e d o o de he t ral or he onsr to
t fc
l ng n pe r
Vigi a. M . Rus ele eed i o a s pa a ec r c wih W ay ' Er c i aNo t Ca olna
r ni
D. s l nt r nt e r t onta t t
ne s e tng,
rh r i
lm ied labiiy c
i t i lt ompa pu s ntt whi h W a sEr c i ag ee t co tuc t ofi e
ny, r ua o c
yne' e tng r d o nsr t he fc
buidi us ng t m a e i l pr de by Ce
l ng i he t r a s ovi d
co. Bot c r t wer l t ras i d t Sm a t
h ontac s e a e s gne o
r
Choi a buidi contact bas i Boson,V igi a.
ce,
l ng
r or ed n
t
r ni

qx

I teisa tc s , ma t oiecamsta Ce ob e c e isc nrc (h t c
n h n tn a e S r Ch c li h t c ra h d t o ta t te t o
ce
c n rc )b p o ii t ewr n srwsf r h r o o t eb idn . S r Ch ieas cams
o ta f' y r vdng h o g ce o t e o f f h ul ig mat o c lo li
t tW ay sEr c i br a he isco r twih Smar Choieby i t li t buidi
ha
ne' e tng e c d t ntac t
t
c
nsalng he l ng
i r e ty.
nco r c l

Afe t c ewasr m o dt t sc t Sma tChoiea e d isc
tr he as
e ve o hi our, r
c m nde t ompl ntt i l
ai o nc ude

tes b e tc nr csa e hbt. Aril 1 o t eCe oc nr c p o i e a f l ws
h u j c o ta t s x iis1 t e 0 f h c o ta t r v d s s ol :
c
o
Buye herby a knowl s si aesa ag ee t t... ny a alca ms
r e c
edge , tpul t nd r s ha
a nd l li ,
a tons pr ee ngso c us sofaci n r ai t t valdiy, ror nc ,
c i , oc di
r a e
to eltng o he i t pe f ma e
i e r tton, nd/ e or e e the e s l bes itd e l i l t ac t
nt m ea i a or nf c m n r of ha l ubm te xcusve y o our

o c mp tn j rs ito i Ho so , ri Comt , xa . . Bu e irvo a l
f o ee tu id ci n n u t n Hars t y Te s . . y r re c by
s bmisis l t t ee lsv j s ito o teSaea dFe ea c u t i
u t tef o h xcu ie midcin f h tt n d r l o rs n
Houso Ha rsCount Te .. .
t n, ri
y, xas . Buye ir voca y wai s t t f les e e
r re
bl
ve , o he u l t xt nt

p r te b lw, n o j cint a i ma n w o h r a trh v t t ely n o
emitd y a a y be to h tt y o r e e fe a e o h a i g f
e usveve ofa ltgai a ii outofori c me i wih t s
xcl i
nue ny ii ton rsng
n or cton t hi
A g e m entora ot a e m e orta ac i br
re
ny her gr e nt r ns ton oughti a s c t....
n ny uch our
Buye ir voc bl wave a ca mst tltg ton br
r re a y i s ny li ha iia i
oughti a s h c t
n ny uc our has
be n br
e oughti a i ve e f u .
n n ncon ni nt or m

( Co l Ex 1 Ar.1 . Th Ce oc nr c as c n ansaTe a c oc - flw p o iin.
Am. mp . . , t 0) e c o ta t lo o ti
x s h ie o -a r vso
Reyi on t f u s e ton ca eco anedi Aril 1 oft Cec c r t Cec
l ng he or m elc i lus nt i n tce 0 he o ontac, o
ha m ove t ta f rt c e i ise iey,t t Houson Di son oft Unie Stt sDiti t
s
d o r nse he as , n t ntr t o he
t
vii
he td a e src
Cour f t Sout r DititofTe or i t atr i t s ve t cai a ns Ce o a
t or he
he n src
xas , n he le natve, o e r he l m gai t c nd
ka f rs h cli t t Houson Di son.2 The c the d ahe rng o t m o i on
nse uc am o he
t
vii
our l
a i n he ton
N ovem be 1 201
r 6, 2.

1 Ceco pr ousy m oved t di sst orgi com pl nton t ba i t t prcepr alatac t
evi l
o smi he i nal
ai
he s hat he i opos t hed o
t c pl ntwasnotan enf ceabl contact Be et compl nthasbe a ende t cor ec t s
he om ai
or
e
r . caus he
ai
en m
d o r t hi
det incy,Ceco acknowl
k e
edgest ispe ng moton t dim iscan be deni asmoot
hat t ndi
i o s s
ed
.

2 Ce o' motoni b o ht rua tt 28U. C. 1 6() Und rt ssa ue i t c r d tr ne
c s i s r ug pu s n o
S. j 40 a .
e hi ttt, f he ou t eemi s
t tve uei i o r imus tds s, i ibei tei e etof u tc ,r nse s c c s t a yditit
ha n s mpr pe,t tsimis or f t n h ntr s j sie ta fr u h a e o n src
ordi son i whi i coul have been br
vii n ch t d
ought'
.'

2

Di c s on
s us i

TheUnie St t sCo tofAppe l f t Fourh Cic tha hel t tf rl s l ton
t d a e ur
a s or he
t r ui s d ha o lm eeci
c a esa epr e la m a tr gove nedby f r ll w. Al ma l Cor v. ta nec UK
l us r oc dtr l te s
r
ede a a 3
be re p. Asr ze a

Lt , F. 643,650( hCi. 0) f he consr ngf um slci ca esf rlc t
d.628 3d
4t r201 . s n tui oz ee ton lus ,edea ours
W
ha f
ve ound dipostvet pa tc a lngua oft ca ea whehe i a horz sa he
s ii he ri ulr a
ge he lus nd
t r t ut i e not r
f r asa ale ai t t f u oft ltg ton orwhe he i ma t de i t d f u
o um
n tm tve o he or m
he ii a i
t r t kes he sgna e or m
e l i .' I A f u s e ton caus t tc anst pecfclng geofe uson'wilbe
xc usve' d.
or m elc i l e ha ont i t i a ua
s
xcl i ' l

i epr t a ma t ya e udi ve ele r . L.a 650- Abs ntacea s ng
ntr eed s ndaor nd xcl ng nue s whe e 4, t 51.
e l r howi
t te or e e ofam a t r f um s lc i c a ewoul beunr as
ha nf c m nt
nda o y or ee ton l us
d
e onabl t clus s d
e,he a e houl

bee or d. J at651. A f um s l to clus maybef dunr s bl onl i;
nf ce #.
ol eecin a e
oun eaona e y f

()( s fr to wa i u e byfa do o er a h n ;2 tec mpann pa t
1 i ) omai n s nd c d ru r v re c i g () h o li ig ry
t
ç l f alpr tc lpur esbede i d of(tlda i c t be a eoft
ç l or 1 acia pos
wi
prve is y n our' c us he
'
gavei ve e eorunfines oft sl t f nl ( t f ndn nt
r ncon ninc
ar s he eeced o m; 3) he u me al
t ar soft c e lw ma de i t pl ntf ofar me o ( (t)
mfines he hosn a y prve he ai if
e dy; r 4) is
e or e e woul co r ve a sT publc polc oft f u sa e.
nf c m nt
d nt a ne t ong
i i y he or m t t

Al nv. o d' o Lo d n 9 F.d9 3 9 8(t Ci. 9 6 (l rzn t sa d r f r
l Llv s f n o , 4 3 2 , 2 4 h r 1 9 ) sl iig he tn ad o
e
mma

t e s n b e e sstf rhi Th Brme v. paaOf- oeCo, 0 U. 1 1 - 8( 9 2 )
mra o a ln s e o t n e e n Za t fsh r .4 7 S. , 5 1 1 7 ).
l t sc e, hef u s l ci clus c ane i Aril 1 oft Cec c r cti
n hi as t or m e e ton a e ont i d n tce 0 he o onta s
une vocal m a t y. Ass tf rha ve i pr de t tça l a ms aci ns pr e ngsor
qui ly ndaor
e o t bo ,t ovi s ha çl cli , to , oc edi
ca e ofa ton r l tngt t valdiy, ror a e,i e r t ton,a ore or me 'oft
us s c i e ai o he i t pe f m nc ntp e ai nd/ nf ce nt' he

Ce oc nr c çhal es b te e cu i l t ac u t c mp tn j rs ito i Ho tn,
c o ta tt lb u mitd x l svey o o r of o ee t uid cin n uso
s
Ha sComt , xa , a dta t eé y r(h panit irv c bys b t isl t t e
ni t y Te s' n h t h t e t e litfl re o a l u mis tef o h
'
Bu

3Th rs lt no ti moind e n thn eo ti is e h we e, e a s b t Vignaa dTe a
e eoui fhs t o s o ij n hs su , o v r b c u e oh r ii n x s
o
o
ha a ed t f r sandar f det ml ng whet a f um s ec i cl e i vald a
ve dopt he ede al t
d or er ni
her or el ton aus s i nd

e f re bl S ePa Bus Sys.nc v. n n U. A.l .3 S. 2 8 4,8 - ( . 9 )(p yig
n oc a e. e ul . .I . Ca o S. .nc, 97 E.d 0 0708 Va 1 90 a pl n
t f dea sa da df a l igt ee or e bii o af r m s lc i ca s ) I r Al I s Co. 1
he e r l tn r or nayzn h nf c a ly f o u ee ton lu e ;n e u n . , 48
t
S. . 1 9 l 3 1 ( x. 0 (a )
W 3d 0 , 1 - 4 Te 20 4) s me .

e l iej rs ito o t eS aea dF d rl o rsi Ho so . ( Co lEx 1 Ar.1 .
xcusv u id cin f h tt n e ea c u t n u t n' Am. mp . . , t 0)
'
Gi n s h çs ik lnguageofe uson,'hec a ei ma t y a mus bee or e t es
ve uc çpect a
xcl i 't l us s nda or nd
t nf c d ml s
i woul beI ea onabl t do s Se Al mare 628 F. a 650- .
t
d mr s
eo
o. e be l,
3d t
51
l opposng Ce o' moton,Sma tChoieprm a iy a g st tt W ese n Dititof
n
i
c s i
r
c i rl r ue ha he
t r src

Vigni i at r c n n e t e u f ra1 a t s' ( .n Op n!7. Ho v r i o d rt
r i a s : e o ve in v n e o 1 p ri .4 Br i p' ) we e ,n r e o
mo
e'
i lda eaf u s l c i c a e f i onve e ,t opposng pa t m us s
nva i t or m e e ton l us or nc
nince he
i
ry
t how t tt
ha he
ha ds p ofta f rt t s l c e f r m woul bes tg a 't tt pa t woul bede i d of
r hi
r ns e o he e e t d o u
d o tr ve'ha he ry
d
prve
sç
hea ' de
i y t e
tn
is da i c t A l m a l ,628 F. d a 651 Thi t vy'bur n hassmpl no be n m e i
t y n our . be r e
3 t .
t i t n c e. TheBr m e 407U . at1 Cec scom o a ehea
he nsa t as
e n,
S. 7.
o'
rt
dqua tr ae l atd i
re s r oc e n
H ous on,a E he e i no e de t tt s f nl wasfxed a a way t di c a po e i l
t nd d r s
t
vi nce ha hi o m
i
s
o s our ge t nta

pl i if fom purui lgii aecli s' Smih v.
antfs r
s ng e tm t am .
'
t AEGON USA.LLC,770F.Supp. 8
2d 09,

8 2( . Va 2 1 (n o cn aca s r q ii ltg to i Ce a Ra i s I wa. Lie s ,
1 W D. . 01 ) e f r ig lu e e urng i ain n d r p d , o ) k wie
i
t r i no e de et tr quii Sma tChoiet ta lt Ho t woul be s l y
he e s vi nc ha e rng
r
c o r ve o uson
d
o mdul

i c n e in t a i wo de sn ilyd p ieS r Ch ieo teo po t t t a j d c t is
n o v n e t h tt ul se tal e rv ma t oc f h p rt y o du iae t
mi
cli a i tCe o. Coursha r og z t twhe pa te e t ri t a ag ee ntwih a
am ga ns c
t ve ec nied ha
n ri s n e n o n r me
t
f u s e ton c a e S he e f c i l r pr s ntt e c ot rt tt ag ee f r m i nots
or m elc i l us , i y fe tve y e e e o a h he ha he r d o u s
t
o
i onve e t te or ng t c a e wilde i eihe pa t ofisda i c t he he f c t
nc
ni nt ha nf ci he l us l prve t r ry t y n our w t r or os s

orot rr as . Ba r t f & Cas I Lt v.
he e ons' nc of Lie
'
. CC. d. FFD Re ou c 1sLLC, 1 - - 4,
s r es I
No. 1 11238
4 Sm ar Choi al s
t
ce so uggesst Ce wai t rghtt enf cet f m s ectoncl eby el i t
t hat co ved he i o or he oru el i aus
ectng o

i ok t jtidci o ti c ur. Ho ve, u hag me i u up re b e si c s lw. Se ,
nv e he trs iton f hs o t we rs c ru nts ns potd y xitng ae a
e
eg.Kigalnv. t r Sol i slc, 9F. up 2 1 5, 2 ( Mas20 )(ee tngt plitf'
. , l le Newok uton.n .9 S p. d 2 1 9 D. s. 00 rjci he anifs
a g me tt t h d f n n wave terg tt o j c t v nu b no r iigt ob e toni t ermov l
r u n ha t e e e da t i d h ih o be t o e e y t asn he j ci n h e a
n ie ; re v.
otc ) To r s SOH Diti.Co.No. l - 1 ,2 0U. Dit LEXI 474 , t* n. ( D. .
srb , 3:0 CV- 79 01 S. s.
S 48 a 9 3 E. Va

Ma 1 , 01)Cq ikydsad ig'tepani 'ag me th th d fn a t ie terg to
y 3 2 0 tuc l ic rl l h lit fs ru n ta te ee d n wav d h ih t
n '
f

e f r et ef r m s lclnca eb rmo ngt c s fom saec r t fdea c ur) Mor o e , s
n o c h o u ee to lus y e vi he a e r tt ou t o e rl o t.
e v ra
Ce o no e i isr pl b if t c ta tc n i ng t e f r m s e ton c a e wa no m a e apa t t
c t s n t e y re k he on r c o o ni h o u elc i lus s t d
r of he
r d untla ert c wasr m oved fom sat cour and Smar Choi fl an amended compl nt
ecor
i ft he ase
e
r te
t
t
ce ied
ai .

4

2 2U.. s.
01 S Dit LEXI 1 8 9 , t* 9( D. x. g 2 2 1 )(n en l iai na dq o in
S 0 2 3 a 6 S. Te Au . , 0 2 itr a ctto n u uto
mar omitd) M orove ,i t sc e,heCe oco r c co ansa e e swaverofa
ks te .
e r n hi as t
c nta t nti n xpr s i
ny
c am t tTe woul bea i nve e f um . Ont sr co d,hec ta e wihCec t t
l i ha xas
d n nco nint or
hi e r t our gr es t
o ha
Sma tChoie,a a sg t t Ce o c r c ,S houl notbeal d ... o e or e c rai
r
c s s i nee o he c onta t l
s d
lowe
t nf c e t n

pr sonsi t (ontacqwhiea t s metmea di isoblgai unde ot pr vii ,
ovii n he c r t l t he a i voi ng t i tons r her o sons
s h a t f r m s l c i n cl us ' Ada Li s Gr
uc s he o u e e t o a e.
'
s oup.Lt v.Sa a Lee Cop . N o.1 06CV 61
d.
r
,
:
0,

di y, he
t
2 0U. DitLEXI 1 2 , t* ( . N. No 2 , 01 ) Accor ngl t cour
01 S. s.
S 25 08 a 8 M D. C. v. 4 2 0 .
c l st tt f u s e ton c a em us bee or e
onc ude ha he or m elc i l us
t nf c d.

Un e j 1 0 () tec u t yo l ta se amatrt ad src i whc t ematr
d r 4 6 a,h o r ma n y z n fr te o ititn ih h te
t ul ha be nbr
d d ve e ought' 28U. C.j1 a. Bec us t br c ofc r c cai ag ns
co
.
'
S. 406()
a e he ea h onta t l m ai t
W a ' Er tng i ba e on a s pa a e c r t ha c ai no f m s l c i c a e a s nc
yne s ec i s s d
e r t ontac t t ont ns onz e e ton l us , nd i e

t ei no i ca i t tt cli a i tW ayne' Er c i c d ha be n br
her s ndi ton ha he am gans
s e tng oul ve e oughti Te ,
n xas
t c tdeci st ta f rt c s i ise ie y. I t ad, hec t l e r ieisdic ei n
he our lne o r nse he a e n t ntr t nse t our wil xe c s t s r to
t s ve t c am a ns Ce o fom t cai ag ns W a sEr c i and ta f rt cai
o e r he l i gai t c r he l m ai t yne' e tng,
r nse he l m

a an tCe ot t eS uhenDitit fTe s Th c u t lrti trs ito o e tecam
g is c o h o t r src o xa . e o r wil eanjlidcin v r h li
a i tW a ' Er tng- Se Fed. R. v. 21(emit gtec u tosv racam a an t
ga ns
yne s ec i s e
Ci P. p r ti h o r t e e li g is a
n

pa t) s eas Co t nTrn miso S s. n . . rio 3 F.d2 , 9 (dCi.1 9 )(i
ry ; e lo tma a s sin v .I c v Ma t , 6 3 91 2 6 3 r 9 4 çn
n
d
t st ton whe eve i pr rf onedef nda butnotf a t ra dim is i
he iua i
r nue s ope or
e nt
or no he nd s s al s
i ppr i t t dititc tha ac c . Oneopton ...i t s ve t cli s r a ni
na oprae, he src our s hoi e
i
s o e r he am , eti ng

jlidcino e o ed fn a t n ta sern t ec s a t t eoh r e e d n t a a p o rae
t s ito v r n e e d n a d z n frig h a e s o h t e d fn a t o n p r p it
r
ditit' ;Ch vse Crdi Cor v.CountvChr lr I ,928F. 1 09,151 - ( 0t Ci.
src .) r lr e t p.
'
r
vse .nc.
2d 5
8 19 1 h r
5 Alhough ltga i i s r e f umsmay be l sconve entf Sm ar Choie, he cour i convi
t
ii tng n epa at or
es
ni or
t
c t
ts
nced
t ts i onve enc ca
ha uch nc ni e nnotover
comet valdiy oft f um s ec i cl e c ai i t Cec
he i t
he or el ton aus ont ned n he o
c r .
ont act

1 91 ( g l e ec rancamsi a a to aep o e l s v rd . . t s p rt a to srs l;
9 ) çW h r eti li n n cin r r p ry e ee . ,wo e aae cin e uta
ç

d src c u t yta fro a to wh l rtiigj rs it no e t eoh r'
itit o r ma rnse ne cin ie eann u id ci v r h te .
o
).
Conc us on
l i

Fort r s nss ae t c twils ve Sma tChoie' c am a i tCe o fom is
he ea o tt d, he our l e r
r
c s l i gans c r t
cli a i tW a sEr ci t r by c eai t s pa a ea tons Thec t l gr nt
am ga ns yne' e tng, he e r tng wo e r t c i .
our wil a
Ce sm o i t ta f rt Ce o a tont t Houson Di son oft Sout r Diti tof
co' ton o r ns e he c c i o he
t
vii
he
he n src

Te a . Th c u t lrti t idcin o e t ea to a ans W a n ' Erci .
x s e o r wil eanjl s ito v r h cin g i t y es e tng
r
The Clr i diece t s ndce tfe c esoft sm e a lm o ni a t
e k s r td o e
rii d opi
hi mor ndl pi on nd he
a com pa ng or rt a1 cot s ofr or
c
nyi
de o 1 m el ec d.
EN TER :Thi
s

da ofDec m be , 2.
y
e r 201

Chi fUnie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

6