Barnes v. Johnson et al

Filing 192

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/03/2014. (ssm)

CL SOFFI U.S. ST
ERK'
CE
DI . COURT
ATRDA
NOKE,
VA
FI ED
L

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I I I
CT
RG N A
CH AR LOTTESVI
LLE D I I ON
V SI

J 23 2 1
UL
2#
J A
BKULI C. D

Ci lA cton N o.3:
vi
i
12CV00053

Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM O R AN DU M O PIN I N
O

By: on, e E.
H
Gl n Conr d
a
Chi Unied St es D it i J
ef t
at
s rct udge

D ef
endant
s.

Fa Ba ne , af
ye r s onne i a e oft Fl
r nm t
he uvanna Co r c i lCent r f W om e
r e tona
e or
n

l
j

i

(s uva ' ,ie t scvi rg sa tonpurua t 42U. C.j 1 algi t tt 1
i
Fl nna' tld hi i l iht ci
)
s nt o
S.
983, le ng ha he I
i

dfnatfr r orcin Letnn JhahnBadue ecsieoc aantj
eedn,omeC ret s i eatonta l ,sd xes fre gislr
o u
n
v
!
Whi s ewa ic r eae ,nvolto of h panifsEih hAme d n rg t. Th l te
l h s n ac rtd i i ai n t e litf g t
e
n me t ih sl ematr
1

I

i p e e tyb f r t ec u t nt ed fn a tsmo inf rs mmayj dg n .Th mo in
s rs n l eo e h o r o h e e d n ' to o u r u me t e ts
ha ng be n f l bref d a t pa te ha ng ag e t s i t m oton w ihou a he rng,
vi
e uly i e nd he ri s vi
r ed o ubm t he
i
t t
i
t m a t ri now rpe f r diposton. Fort f l w i r s ,t m oton wilbe de d.
he te s
i o s ii
he olo ng ea ons he
i
l
ni

Bac ound
kar

I

i
i
I

T ercr rvash fl wigrlvn fcs rsne i tel h motaoast
h eod e elte ol n eeatatpeetd n h i t sfv rbe o
o
g

I
!
t pli if Se Anderonv.Li ryLobby,nc, U. 242,261n. ( 986) Thepl ntf,
he antf. e
s
bet
I .477 S.
21 .
ai if

FayeBane , a i t a Fl nnabewe nFebr r 2009a Fe uay201 Unil
r s was n nmae t uva
t e
uay
nd br r 2. i
I

Novembe 201 t de e nt J t Blnd,wa e pl d asaCore tonsLi t nà a
r 0, he f nda , ohnahan a
s m oye
rci
eu e 1nt t
Fl nna. I Se e be 201 w hie a tng ast ofi e i c r oft pl i if sho ng
uva
n pt m r 0, l c i
he t c r n ha ge he a ntf ' us
uni,Bl charged t pl ntf w ih Cgat i and appr
t and
he ai if t t her ng
oachi i a t eat ng w ay.' hid
ng n hr eni
'
r
1

CLE

é'

FA Y E BA RN ES,

GEN E JOHN SON ,etal,
.

,

I

Thepl ntf alo na e t ot rdefndant,i udi addii c r ctonalofi r a m e be sof
ai if s m d en he e
s ncl ng
tonal ore i
fce s nd
r
Fl nna' m edi saf . The cl m saga ns t e de enda sha bee f l r ol a J t n Bl d i t
uva s
cal t f
ai
i t hos f nt ve n uly es ved, nd ohna ha a s he
onl de enda r ni i t c e
y f nt emai ng n he as .

I

Sum m . .2,Doc tN o.1 Shes ksdnma i t a o of$1 000, 2 Thi d A m .
J
ke
87.
ee
ges n he m unt
0, 000. r

Complj21
.f 9.
The de e ntde est the r s r i d t pl i ifi ha cuf son Se e be 30,201
f nda
ni ha
e ta ne he a ntf n nd f
pt m r
0,

a s kss
nd ee ummayj
r udgme i hi fvoront meis Bl pr fr t tkl r lwa
nt n s a
he rt. and ofes ha iBanes s
t a por e t s r ga i by t o ya d of i er and wasunr s r i d untls r ac d t
r ns t d o eg e ton
w
r fc s
e ta ne
i he e he he

s gr to buidi ' De.sM ott Se Asd Enr ofDea t6, 15, ke No.1 The
e egain l ng. f' .o t ie ty
'
ful ! Doc t
76.
de e ntù ns r t d t ya d of i r nott r s r n Pl i ifdurng t a por be a e t r w as
f nda t tuc e he r fce s
i
o e tai a ntf
i r ns t c us he e

move ntont yad.'J sThedee nte ai t ttft ofiesha rsr i dBane t
me
he r ' ê
fnda xpl ns ha s he fc r d e tane r s o
i
ta por he ... o t s gr ga i buidi t entr yar w oul ha bee r qui e t go on
r ns t r t he e e ton l ng, he ie d
d ve n e r d o

l kdown. L= tv boo fom t buidi s dpr dee de es
oc
' d sog ks r he l ng houl ovi vi nc uppori Blnd'
'
l
tng a s
de ens t the di no ta por Pl ntf on Se e be 30,201 ' l a 8. A lhough C ai i f
f e ha
d t r ns t ai if
pt m r
0. d. t
'
t
d ntf
pl
s d ha bee r tai be o e s e er d t s gr a i buidi ' Bl nd idi not
houl ve n esr ned f r he nt e he e eg ton l ng, a d d
'
pe s ly wines Pl i ifbe ng r s r i a he di notac om pa he t t buidi ' I
r ona l t s a ntf i e t a ned s
d
c
ny r o he l ng. d.
'
M or r e n i Bl nd ha ha uf ed t pl ntf o Se e be 30,201 a a l ge
eove , ve f a
d ndc f he ai i f n pt m r
0, s le d
i t c pl i ,he a guest thi co
n he om a nt
r
ha s nduc w o d notha vi a e he r gh s unde t Ei h
t ul
ve ol t d r i t
r he ght
Am e
ndm e ,m uc l s a c e r y e t bls cons iutona r ght H a l v.Fizge a d,457
nt
h es ny l a l s a i hed
tt i l i . row
t rl

U. 8 ( 98 ( c i ngt t pr e quaiidi
S. 00 1 2) desrbi he wo- ong d lfe mmuniyts) The eor,t dee an
t et. r f e he fnd t

ague ,hei e ildt s
r s s ntte o ummayj
r udgmentont bai ofqualfedi
he ss
ii mmuniy, wela ont
t as l s he
m ert
is.

2Thepli ifdi notie i he pr ye f dama agans ea h i vi de e nt Rat r s m a
antf d
tm ze r a r or
ges i t c ndi dual f nda .
he , he de
acoleci dema i t a
l tve
nd n he moun of$1 000, fom aldefnda s.Thec tnoest tt pl ntf s tld he
t
0, 000 r l e nt
our t ha he ai if e te r
r a e cl m saga ns def ndant Be ry Ros era Corz He t I f a undi c os d a ount
el t d ai
i t e
s ve l
s nd i on aIh, nc, or n
sl e m
.

3

wa usd; 3 t ee tn o teij l ; 4 tet ra ra o a l p r eve b ter s nsbe
s e ( ) h xe t f h nu' ( ) h h e t e s n by ec i d y h epo i l
y
ofiilbasd o t f t knownt hi a ( a ef t mad t t rt s ve iyofa
tca e n he acs
o m; nd 5) ny fors e o empe he e rt

f c f lr s ns W hilv,475U. a 321,Theob e tvec
ore u epo e. te
S. t
j ci ompo ntf us onçhenau eof
ne oc es t tr
t
t f r e'whih mus beC ti a. W iki v. ddy,559U. 34,39( 0) dWhe
he o c ,' c
t ' rvil' l ns Ga
non
'
S.
201 . i n
pr s ofi i l m alci l a s di tc l us f r e t ca e ha m ,c e por r sa ar of
i on fc a s i ous y nd a s i aly e o c o us r ont m a y t nd ds

de enc awa a evi ae ' Huds 503U. a 9.I s tt û or j ca i r gs ...
c y l ys r oltd.
'
on,
S. t n hor,he t e udiilnquiy i)
c
t na ur oft f c s i ly, t ri wasnonti a a wasa i d ...ma ii l
he t e he or e pecfcal whe he t
rvil nd
pple
lc ousy

a s ditc lyt ca eham. W iki ,559U. a 39(ntr lquottonmaksomitd) I
nd a sial o us r ' l ns
'
S. t i ena
ai
r
te . f
t c tfnds t tC he e de e, e e i t lghtm os f vor bl t t pl ntf ,wils
he our i ha k vi nc vi w d n he i
t
t a a e o he ai i f l uppor
t

arla ei eenc ofwa onne si t i lci ofpanunde ghi t pa t tndadj'
eibl nfr e
nt s n he nfiton
i
r t s wo- r sa r ,'
s
ummayj me i t dee ntsfvo i i pprprae W hily, U. a 3
r udg nt n he fnda ' a r s na o it. te 475 S. t 22.
A f lr vi w oft r co d r a fr st c m en s m a by t co ta t he i on
ul e e
he e r e f im he om
t de
he ur t he arng

t motont sta i t e r ofdea t s
he i o e sde he nty
ful- ummayj
r udgmen i i ppr praei t sc s
t s na o it n hi a e
bec us Ba ne pr s nt ge neis ofmae ilf twihr pec t boht s j ci a
a e r s e e s nui sues
tra ac t es t o t he ub e tve nd
ob e tvecompone sofhe Ei hAme me exc s i f c cai ag ns Blnd.M os
j ci
nt
r ght
nd nt e sve ore l m ai t a
t
f
unda nt ly,af t ldipu ee ssa t whe he t def nda ha ufedt pl i ifo
me al
acua s t xit s o
t r he e nt ndc f he antf n

Se e r30, 0.Co r ThidAm.Compl!44 (( ora Se e r30,...gj
ptmbe 201
mpae r
.
(On bout ptmbe
the
pr dur Bl nd e pl d f s c i Pl i ifm ea tt the w r nc he a m sbe nd he
oce e a m oye or ha klng a ntf
n ha
e hed r r
hi
r

ba kt mee a t nc fdt m t t .) a BanesDe 49, ke No.1 1((was
c o t nd he ufe he ogeher', nd r
'
p. Doc t
87- dI
s c e a handc f d by Li utna Bl nd,a Li u e ntBl us d t sngl ha uf f
ha kl d nd
ufe
e e nt a
nd e t na
and e he i e ndc f or

t wrs.)wihBl Af. 8,Docke No.1 4(6 as t d( antf sc eqt t1ha
he it', t and f !
'
t
76- $1 lo ol pli if ouns l ha d
no s c e Baneswhe s wa move t s r ton, Banesalgesi he c ant')
t ha kld r
n he s
d o egegai as r le n r ompli . ,
'

u u u l u ih n ) eeo e t ed fnd n ' moi nfrs mmayj d me t s b d n e .
n s a p n s me t.Th rf r ,h ee a ts to o u r u g n mu t e e id
C oncl i
uson

Fo t ef r g igra o ,h moinf rs mmayj g n fldbyd fn n
r h o e on e s ns te to o u r ud me t i
e
e e da t
J
ohna ha Bl nd w ilbe de e The c s w ilpr e d t a be h t i c r nty s hed e t
t n a
l
ni d.
a e l oc e o
nc ral ur e l c ul d o
be n on J y 1 201
gi
ul 5, 4.
The Cl r i diec e t s nd c r ii d c esoft sm e or nd opi on a t
e k s r t d o e e tf e opi
hi m a um
ni nd he
a c pa ng or rt al c
c om nyi
de o 1 ouns ofr c d.
el e or

ENTER:Ths 3*2 d yo J l, 01 .
i
a f uy 2 4

Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ
e
t d a e sr c udge