Huckstep v. Colvin

Filing 16

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/6/14. (hnw)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI .
S
CE S. ST COURT
AT RM NOKE,
VA

E;
G

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I N I
CT
RGI A
CHA RLOTTESVI
LLE D I I ON
V SI

'Y

MA2 2 2 1
29
J I C Dj L , K
UA.
CL
œ
x
.

.

-

SAN D M

.y ' ,

'

'

#

/

w

.

ER

S.H U CK STEP,

Ci lA c i n N o. 3: 3CV 0001
vi to
1
4
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M E M O M N D UM O PI O N
NI
CAR OLY N W .COLV W , c i
A tng
Com m i sone ofSoc a Sec iy
si r
i l urt ,

By:

H on.Gl n E.
e
Conr
ad
Chi U nie St e D it i tJ
ef t d at s s r c udge

Def nt
enda .

Pl i ifhasfl t sa ton c le ng t fnalde son oft Comm isone ofSocil
antf
ied hi c i hal ngi he i
cii
he
si r
a
Sec iy de ngpl i tf cl i f ape i ofdi a lt a di a lt i ur nc be ft undert
urt nyi
a n i fs a m or rod
s biiy nd s biiy ns a e ne is
he

SocilSe urt Ac, a
a c iy tas mende 42U. C. 41 i a 423.Jziditonoft sc ti purua
d,
S. jj 6() nd
lrs ci
hi our s s nt
t j205( oft Ac, U. C.j405g) Asrtece byt me a a agume s te
o
g) he t42 S.
( . el td he mornda nd r nt ubmitd
b t pa tes t i s now be or t c tar whe he t Com m i s one ' tnalde s on i
y he r i , he s ues
f e he our e
t r he
s i rs i
ci i s

s
uppore by s t nta e de e, whehe t r i ' ood c us ' st ne es ia er mandi t
td
ubsa il vi nc or t r he e s '
g
a e'a o c st t e
ng he

c s t t Commisone f f t rc i r ton.Se 42U. C.j405g)
a e o he
si r or urhe onsde ai
e
S.
( .
Thepli tf , nd aS. kse wasbor on Oc o r28,1
a n if Sa r Huc t p,
n
t be
957,a e nt l r c d t
nd ve ualy ea he he
t nt g a i s hool t a nitai he rng,M r .Huc t p t ttedt t whie i s hool
e h r de n c .At he dmi sr tve a i
s
kse esii ha , l n c ,

s wasi s cale tonca ss a t ts i now una et radorwrt.( 1 .Pl ntf
he
n pe i ducai lse , nd ha he s
bl o e
ie TR 5) ai if
ha be n e pl yed a at hbnz h a s m bl r w i
s e m o
s oot s s e e , ndow/
doora s bl , onve e e s or cl r de i
s em er c
ni nc t e e k, l
wor r and r c vi c e k. Appa e ty,s l s w or on a r ul ra s t ne bas si 2007.
ke ,
e ei ng l r
r n l he a t ked
eg a nd us ai d i n
On M ay 13,2011,M r H ucksep fl an a i i f a per od of di lt and di abiiy
s.
t ied
pplcaton or
i
sabiiy
s lt

i tr nc be t . She a l ged t t s be n e di a ed f a l f m s of s t nta g nf
nsz a e ne ks
le
ha he c m
s bl or l or
ubs a i l ai ul
e pl e ton Aug t31,
m oym n
us
2007 duet bi a di or r bor ri pa a d s hi ophr ni ;m a c
o pol r s de ; de lne r noi c z
e a ni

de es i , ndchr cobsr c i pul
pr son'
a
oni t u tve mona ydie s Pl i ifno mant i ha s ha r m ane
r s a e. antf w i anst t he s e i d
di a e t t pr s nt tm e. The r or r vea s t t M r . H uc t p m e t i ur d s a us
s bl d o he e e i
ec d e l ha
s
ks e
t he ns e t t

rquie nt oft Ac t ought frtqua trof2011 but tt rafe.Se ge , U. C.
e rme s he t hr
he is re
, no hee tr e, n.42 S. jj
41 i a 423( .Cons que l pl ntf i e ildt dia lt i lrnc be tt onl i s ha
6() nd a)
e nty, ai if s ntte o s biiy nsza e neis y f he s
e tbls d t ts be media e wihi t mea ng oft Ac ,on orbe or M a ch 31 2011
sa ihe ha he ca
s bld, t n he
ni
he t
f e r
,
.

Se g n.42U. C.j423()
ee ,
S.
a.
M r . uc t p' c a m w asde ed upo i ta cons d r to a r co i r ton.She t n
s H ks e s l i
ni
n nii l
i e a i n nd e ns de a i
he

rqueseda rc ve aX novohe rng a rviw beor a Admi srtveLa J
e t nd e ei d
ai nd e e f e n
nitai w udge.I an
n
opi o da e Nove r28, 2,heLa J
ni n t d
mbe
201 t
w udgealo deer i d t tpl ntf i no dia e The
s t m ne ha ai if s t s bld.
La J e f
w udg ound t t pr o t t t r i ton of i ur d s a us M r .Huc t p s f r d f o
ha , i r o he e m na i
ns e t t , s
ks e uf e e r m

hy c et olmi c oni o tu tve pul na y die e a afci dior r ( 59)
perholser e a, hr c bsr ci
mo r s as, nd fe tve s de. TR .
Ho ve ,heLa J
we r t
w udger e t t t o h he daels i ur M r . kse di nots f fom
ul d ha, hr ug r t a t ns ed, s Huc t p d
ufer r

as veei r ntwihi t me ngof20C. R.j40 1 21.( 60 .Acc di y,t La
e r mpaime t n he ani
F.
4.5 TR )
or ngl he w
J
udgede edpl i ipsa i atonunde t s c s e oft s ue i di a lt na ys ss t or h
ni a ntf pplc i
r he e ond t p he eq ntal s biiya l i e f t

unde 20C. R.j1
r
F.
520.TheLa J
w udgealoe l tdpli ifscli unde t f u' a ffh
s vauae antf am
r he ot t nd it
h
s e oft s que i di a lt a l i . Re yi on t s i ony f om a voc tona e r a t
t ps he e ntal s biiy na ys s
l ng
e tm
r
a i l xpe t t he
a i s r tve he rng,t La J
dm ni ta i
a i he w udge he d t t M r .Hucks e r m a ne c pa e of pe f
l ha
s
t p e i d a bl
r onni
ng
s ver lofherpa tr l va wor r esa a 1r l nttm eson orbef r M a c 31, 1and,e
e a
s e e nt k ol t 1 e eva i
oe rh
201
ven

i dia e f rpas r e twor s pos e s dr i ualf tonalc pact t pe f m ot rwo k
f s bl d o
t elvan
k, he s s e esd unc i
a iy o ror he r

r e e si i sgnii nt
ols xitng n i fca numbe i t nai e nomy.( 70- ) Uli tl iwoul s m
rn he tonal co
TR 71. tmaey,t d ee
t tt La J
ha he w udge r l d t tM r . uc t p w a notdi a e t de s e t o,f ,a f ve oft
u e ha s H ks e
s
s bl d m r t ps w our nd i
he

s que i dia lt a l i.Se 20C. R.j40 15 c ,t,a ( .TheLa J e' o ni
e ntal sbiiy nayss e
F.
4. 20()() nd g)
w udg s pi on

wa a ed a t fna decson of t Com misone by t Soci Se urt Admi sr ton'
s dopt s he i l ii
he
s i r he
al c iy
nita i s
Appe l Counc l Havi e us e al a ia e a i s r tve r m edi s M r . uc t p hasnow
as
i.
ng xha t d l va l bl dm nit a i e
e , s H ks e
a
ppea ed t t sco t
l o hi ur .
W hie pl i if m a be diabl d f ce t i f m s of em pl ent t c ci f t
l a ntf
y
s e or ra n or
oym , he nl al ac ual

de e mi toni whe he pli ifwa dia edf a 1 onnsofs t nta ganf e oyme .See
t r na i s t r antf s s bl or 1 f
ubsa il i ul mpl
nt

42U. C.j423( ( .Theeaef elme sofpr whihmus bec i rdi ma ngs h
S.
d)2) r r our e nt
oof c
t onsdee n ki uc

a a ay i.The eee n saes mmaie a f l ws ( )o j ci eme ia f csa d ci c l
n n l ss
s lme t r u rz d s ol : 1 b e tv d c l a t n l a
o
ni
fndn s ( ) h o no sa dc n l ins te tn p y iins ( ) u jciee i e c o p y ia
i ig ;2 t e piin n o cuso ofraig h sca s3 s be tv v d n e f h sc l
'
ma f ttonsofi r nt,a de ci dtr ughacai ntstsi
niesai
mpaime s s srbe h o
l ma ' e tmony'a ( t cama '
, nd 4) he li nts

e u ain, o ai n l itr , e iu l kls a da e Vie v Fnc , 3 F.d 1 5 ,1 5 - 0(t
d c to v c to a h soy r sd a s il, n g . tk . i h 4 8 2 1 7 1 9 6 4h
Ci.1971) Under
r
;
woodv. biof,298F. 85 851(t Ci.1 .
Ri c f
2d 0, 4h r 962)
A fe a r vi w of t r c d i t s c e t c t i t abl t conc ude t t t
tr e e
he e or n hi as , he our s m e o
l
ha he
Com m i s one ' fna dec s on i s
s i r s i l i i s uppored by s t nta e de e. The m or r c m edi al
t
ubs a i l vi nc
e e ent
c
e de e c im st tM r . ks e e re e s ve ee o i l obl m s I ed, ts e st t
vi nc onfr ha s Huc t p xpe i nc s e r m tona pr e . nde i e m ha
pl i ifw a hos t lz d f tea m e to de es i a s c dal e nc eson t ve y l s da on
a ntf s pia i e or r t n f pr s on nd ui i t nde i
he r a t y

whc s esi e j y di s rd sau .Se ea o t eme tl e l p o i eswh te tdp an if
ih h tl no e n u e tt s v rl f h n a h at r v d r o rae litf
l
h
j tbef ea i t mont a trhe ps hiti hos tlz ton, vepr edrporsi c tng
us or nd n he
hs fe r yc arc piaiai ha oduc e t ndiai
t tpl i ifi di a e f a lf m sofwor a tviy. H oweve ,t di fc t i pl ntf ' ca e i
ha a ntf s s bl d or 1 or
k ci t
r he fi uly n ai if s s s
t the m e a a phys c c ndii n prort t t r i ton ofhe i tr d s a usi l st n cl r
ha r nt l nd
i al o t o i o he e m na i
r nsle t t s es he ea .

l r ol ngt c lc si t me c l ec d, ndi ma ngfndi unde hes nta dia lt
n es vi he onfit n he di a r or a n ki i ngs
rt eque i l s biiy
a l i ,t La J
na ys s he w udge pum ore y r i d on r c d r vi w s c pl t d by s a e a nc phys c ans
t dl ele
e or e e
om e e
t t ge y
ii

andps hol ssi come tonwiht e rira nitai pr ce di i pli ifscae.(
yc ogit n l ci t he ale dmi sr tve o e ngs n antf s TR
3

69) Howe re nastmi t thesaea nc e t fom no xa ni
.
ve ,ve sl ng ha t tt ge yrpors r
ne mi ngphyscansa
ii ndme al
nt
he t s c a i t s d be a cor d gr a e w e g t n t r por sofm e al lh pr de sw ho
alh pe i ls s houl
c de e t r i ht ha he e t
nt hea t ovi r

s w pl i ifi t m ont a trhe ps hiti hos t lza in,t c tbe ives t tt La
a
antf n he
hs fe r yc a rc piai to he our le
ha he w
J
udge' t e t e ofpl ntf sca e i notc it nt ih t es a ea ncyr pors.Thecou t i
s r a m nt
ai i f s s
ons s e w t hos t t ge
e t
r fnds
lg
t ood ca e 'f r m a of pl i i f s c e t t Com m i sone f f t r de opm e a
us ' or e nd
a ntf as o he
s i r or ur he vel
nt nd
c i rto
onsde a i n.
Forpur e ofa i a i oft s co se oft s que i ldi a lt ana ys s s tf t
pos s pplc ton he e nd t p he e nta s biiy l i e orh

unde 20C. R.j404.520() 20C. R.j404. 21a c a trz as veei ime a o
r
F.
1 c,
F.
15 4) harceies e r mpar nt s ne
w hi h s gnii a l lm ist physca orm e t a lt t do ba i w o k a tvii .A snot d a
c i t c nty i t he
i l
n al biiy o
s c r c i tes
e bove,
t La J
he w udger le on s a e a nc e t ge r t a hei ta co i r ton a r ons de a i
e i d t t ge yr pors ne a ed tt nii l ns de a i nd ec i r ton

l l i fndi no s ve ei im e a nt sr s t t La J
eve s n i ng
e r mpa r ntlI hi e pec, he w udgecomme e asf l :
nt d olows
Thel der i d g ne a l a ed t D D S physc a i ta m e a as e s e s
m s gne e r ly dopt he
i al nd nii l nt l s s m nt

( .1A & 3 be us t y a eco itntwih t ot rc e bl e de of
Exs
A) ca e he r nsse t he he r di e vi nce
r cor Evi enc w hi h ha be n r ce ve i o t r c d a t r t D D S
e d.
d e
c
s e e i d nt he e or f e he
de e m i tons doe notpr vi ne or m a e i li onna i t tw oul ale t i
t r na i
s
o de w
t r a nf
ton ha
d t r he r
fndi a
ngs bout hes ve iyoft cl i a ' i pa r e st ough he da el ti ur d.
t e rt he a m nt m i m nt hr
s
r t as ns e
The t de sgned di a r e t tm e ca e d e asouti d a
m ri
s g e s ha di l vi enc ,
lne bove s st tt
, how ha he
cl i a ha a s ve em e a i pa r e pr o t he da e l ti ur H o e i t
a m nt d e r nt l m i m nt i r o r t as ns ed. w ver f he
cli a ' me a condii n c dbec i r d s ve et oughherdae ls i lr d
am nts nt l
to oul
onsde e e r hr
t a t nsze
f 1 co e i m ont , i ii he t s m pl , ou i wor ha i vesw or ng
or 2 ns cutve
hs lm tng r o i e r tne kt t nvol
ki
m or w ih t ngsr t rt n pe e a onl oc as o l nt r to w ih c wor r
e t hi a he ha opl nd y c i na i e ac i ns t o- ke s
a onl i de a i e a tonswiht publc, s
nd y nci nt lnt r c i
t he
i as uggesedbyt DDS ps hol s
t
he
yc ogit
onr c i r ton, hew oul s il bedi a e
e ons de a i s
d tl not
s bl dbec us s c d s il r or pa t
a e he oul t l pe f m s
r l va w or a ot rwor ac or ng t t vo to e r .
e e nt k nd he
k, c di o he ca i nal xpe t

1I pas i g,t courtnot t s r i
es hat uch elance i s ewhatsus , i m uc ast sa e agenc
s om
pect nas h he t t
n sn he
y

h sca s n s c oo it e kwe lit fs ie lb fr h e ep f e eq o te e o tfo
p y iin a dp y h lgssrv dpani ' tl wel lo gterc ito sv rl fh rp rs rm
h
f

e tetngme a h at secalssf lwi h rhos t lal Furh r e,i l welstldi t
r rai ntl e lh p i lt olo ng e pi z ton. temor t s l ete n he
al

Fou t Cic t h t diale rsge e ae a tr emi tonofis e sausma ber e n i a s s i
rh r uit a mg c r po t n rtd fe tr nal
n ur d tt
y elva t n se sng
t cama tsco tonpro t tr n tonofi urdsaus Bidv. mmiso r69 F.d3 340( t
he li n ' ndil ir o emiai
ns e tt . r Co s ine , 9 3 37, 4h
Ci. 2) W ool i ev.
r 201 )
drda Bowe ,81 F. l 7,1 ( t Ci.1 7) M o ev: n , 8F.d 1 24,1 6
n 6 2d 5 60 4 h r 98 ; or Fich 41 2 2 22
( h Ci.1 9)On t ot rh nd i i f i t noet a te saea e y rvlw pr c s t k plc atr
4t r 96
he he a , t s ar o t h t h tt g nc e e o e s oo a e fe
t mi ton ofpl ntf si ur d sa us
er na i
ai if ns e tt .

( 69) Theprmay s tomi i t La J sa l i i t te h oft saea nc
TR .
i r horc ng n he w udge' nayss s ha ac
he tt ge y
m e c l r vi s ls pl ntf' c oni obs r tve pul ona y di ea e, c oni br hii , a
di a e ew it ai i f s hr c t uc i
m r s s hr c onc ts nd

afci dior a s veei r nt.( 41 49) W ihoutq si bas dont r porson
fe tve s der s e r mpaime s TR , . t
ueton, e
he e t
w hi h t La J
c he w udge a or d t gr a e tw e g ,M r Huc t p hasesabls t e s e e of
cc de he e t s i ht . kse
t i hed he xit nc
s ve ephys c and e otona i pa r e s The c tc l
e r
i al
m i l m im nt .
our onc udest tt Co m i s one ' de s on
ha he m s i r s ci i
t t c t a y i nots
o he on r r s
uppore by s t nta e de .
td
ubs a i l vi nce

Asnot a
ed bove,heAd i sr tveLa J
t
m nita i
w udgewe ont c i rpl ntf sc et rt
nt o onsde ai if as mde he
f t a ffh se oft s nta dia lt a l i . l fndi t tM r .Huc t p r t ne
ourh nd it t ps he eque il s biiy nayss n i ng ha s
kse eai d

s f ce t u cin l a a i t p rom h rp s rlv n wok, swel soh r o e itn i t
u t in f n to a c p ct o e fr e a t ee a t r a la t e j bs xsi g n he
i
y
na i lec
tona onom y,t La J e r le on t tm ony gi n by a voca i na e r i r pons t
he w udg e i d
es i
ve
to l xpe t n es
eo
hy t tc que tons Theta c i of hehea i r ve l t f l i e hang be w e nt La
po he i al s i .
r ns rpt t
rng e a s he olow ng xc
e t e he w
J
udge a t voc tonale r :
nd he a i
xpe t

Q ( J:
M I

Ok y a s mey ur d ai gwihap ro wh c nd smp e ru ie
a , su o ' e ln t es n o a o i l, o tn
e
w o k t ti ve w o ki m o ew ih t ngsr t rt wih pe e
r ha nvol s r ng r t hi a he han t opl
a onl oc as o i e a tons wih c
nd y c i nal nt r c i
t owor r a onl i i nt
ke s nd y nc de al
i e a tonswiht publc Co ds hape s dot cai 'pa t
nt r c i
t he
i . ul uc
r on he l mant s
s
wor asa ua l pe f m e
k
ct ly ror d?

A( :
VE)

I ivet theas e ywor co dbedoneunde t elm ia i
bele ha t s mbl
k ul
r hos i ttons.
Tha w o k i s m pl r tne wor l ha ve y lm ie c ac wih cot r s i e, ou i
k. t s r i t d ont t t
wor r and no c ac wih t publc a t w a s des r be t
ke s
ont t t he
i nd he y he c i d he
r e vi w o k, ha w o k woul lke i e bea et do i w ihi t e
ec i ng r t t r
di w s
bl o t t n hos
lm iatons.
i ti

Q'
.

Andt tss m eastueasacua l g r lype f medi t na i l
ha ' a
r
t ly ene a l ror
n he tona
econom y?
hr .
es

Q:

Now,iwef t ra s t pes i t smea ast cli nt
f urhe sume he ron s he a ge he ama ,
hast s
he ame e to ba kgr
ducai nal c ound,pa twor e re e,co d
s
k xpe i nc
ul

s h ape s do ot rj bst te s i sg t a number i t
uc
ron
he o ha xit n ini nt
k
s n he
r gi n orna i le onom y?
e o
tona c
I m y o ni gi n t t a i nal otl a t e lm ia i ,i '
n
pi on ve ha voc to pr i e nd hos i t tons t s

myo i inta teeae o sha apes nc udd a dl eiveta ,
p no h th r r j b t t ro o l o n b l h t
e
f ri tnc , wo l ls t e earp e e ttv , o a adeayad
o nsa e I u d it h s e r sn ai e aj b s itr i
whc i l h a d u s ild.Th r' 2 ,0 o t o ej b i t
ih s i t n n k l
g
e e es 210 0 f h s o s n he
na i lec nom y.The es 5, 00 i t s a e ofV igi a.l' alo m y
tona o
r ' 1 n he t t
r ni ts s

o no t a ap ro wi i to elmiain c u d d t ej b o a
piin h t e s n t n h s i tto s o l o h o f
h
s t r s h as a s t i a l nd y. Tha w o k i al o lg and
ore , uc
orer n au r
t r s s i ht

u s ild,h r ae 2 00 o to ej b i t en to a e o my
n kle tee r 4 ,00 f h s o s n h ain l c no .
The e a e a oxi a e y 5, i t s a e ofV i g ni a a pe s
r r ppr m t l 200 n he t t
r i a nd
r on

wi n tos l tt nsc u dd t ej b o ace ne, a t ual a
t h e i ai o l o h o f la r p ri lry
hi
mi o
c
lgh cl a r Tha w or i lghta u kil The e a e o r850,
i t e ne . t k s i nd ns led. r r ve
000

o to e o i t n to a e o o a 25 0i tesaeo Vign a
fh s j bsn he ain l c n my nd ,0 n h tt f r ii
a d t o e aej s rp e e ttv o j bst a c ud bed n wi n
n h s r u t e rs naie f o h t o l
oe t
hi
t e lm ia i
hos i t tons a a l t e s ls a e ri nal l ve s a e
nd l hos kil nd xe to
e l r
c i t tw ih t DO T
ons sen t he

( 31 3 .
TR - 2)
O nc ag n,e n a s l i t tt La J
e ai ve s lm ng ha he w udgepr pe l r i on t r po t f om t s a e
o r y eled
he e r s r he t t
a nc s ci i t i as es i pl i tf r i
ge y pe als s n s s ng a n if esdualf nc i lca c t i a pe r t t cour t tt
u tona pa iy, t p a s o he
t ha he
La J
w udge di no i l a loft lm ia i do m e ed by t e none m i ng s c a i t i
d t nc ude 1
he i t tons cu nt
hes
xa ni pe i ls s n
f mul tngt hy t tc lq s i f rt voc to l xpe tzD r Pa rci Br r aps hol s ,
or a i he po he i a ue tons o he a i na e r . . t i a une , yc ogit
pa tc pa ed i t i ta r vi w ofpl i if sm e ca r or A st pl i i f ss ver i pa r e on
r i i t n he nii l e e
a ntf
di l ec d. o a ntf e e m i m nt
t ba i ofa f tv di or r ,Dr Br nernot d t tt r w a i uf i e e de e t as es t
he s s f ec i e s de s . u
e ha he e s ns fci nt vi nc o s s he

f tona i c oft s c to .( 42) Ho ve,byt tmeoft s c rcor rviw,
unci l mpa t he e ondiins TR . we r he i
he e ond e d e e
c
onduc e aspar oft r o i r to pr ce s a t rps hol git Dr J Kall s c fc l
td
t he ec nsde ai n o s , nohe yc o s, . ohn i, pe i aly
2Thecour r
t ecogni t i wasnotabs ut y neces ar f t Law J
zes hat t
ol el
s y or he
udget r ei i f om
o ec ve nput r
avocatonale ti det mi ng whe hert cl mantcoul have peror e pas r evantwor See20
i
xper n er ni
t he ai
d
f m d t el
k.

C. R.j4 1 60 b)2 .Ho v r on et La J ec os t dos a gi nteLa J e se plci
F.
04.5 ( ( ) we e , c he w udg h e o o, nd ve h w udg ' x i t

r inceon t voc i exper ' t tmony i fndi r i f i capaciy f pas wor t court
ela
he atonal
ts esi
n i ng esdual unctonal
t or t k: he
belevest iw asappr i ef heLaw Judget pr
i
hat t
oprat ort
o opoundacom pr
ehensi hypot i quesl f he
ve
hetcal ton ort
vocatonalexper ' consde aton.
i
ts
i r i

sae t tpli ifsa f c i dio der r ul i mode a ei panne i a tvii ofda l lvi ,
tt d ha antf fe tve s r s es t n
r t m i nt n c i tes
iy i ng'

manti ngs i f toni ,a mai ai ngc e rton, ritnc orpa e.( 49 .Dr
i ani ocal unci ng' nd nt ni onc ntai pesse e, c TR ) .
Kalldi not t tM r .
i d e ha s Huckse e re e m ode a elm ia i i he a lt t i e a twih t
t p xpe i nc s
r t i tton n r biiy o ntr c t he

ge rlpublca wihs r s s ( 51.Howe r i pr
nea
i nd t upe vior . TR )
ve,n opoundi t hy hei lquesins
ng he pot tca
to
f t voc tonale r t La J e o y i l d lm ia insivol ng pe s
or he a i
xpe q he w udg nl ncude i t to n vi
ronali t r to .
n e aci ns
N o m e i w as m a of pl i if s m ode a e i pa r e i t r s of he a lt t m ai i
nton
de
a ntf '
r t m im nt n e m
r biiy o
nu n
c nc nt a i n, r i t nc o pac i a w or s ti
o e r t o pe s s e e, r e n
k e tng.

l W akerv.
n l
Bowe 889F. 47, ( hCi.1 9)t Unie Stt Cour ofAppe sf
n,
2d 50 4t r 98 ,he td aes
t
al or
t Fo t Cic tc me e a f l :
he urh r ui om nt d s olows
The pur e of b i ng i a voca i nale r i t a s s t ALJ i de er i ng
pos
r ngi n
to
xpe t s o s i t he
n t m ni
whehe he ei wor a lbl i hena i l conomywhiht spa tc a cai nt
t rt r s k vaia e nt tona e
c hi ri ulr l ma
ca pe f m . l or r f r a voc tona e r ' o ni t be r l va t o he pf ,i
n r or
n de o
a i l xpe t pi on o
s
e e n r l ul t
mus bebas uponac i r ton ofa1ot re de ei t r c d, nd i mus be
t
ed
onsde a i
l he vi nc n he e or a t t
i rs
n e pons t pr r hypot tc quesi w hi h f ry s t o al of c ai a ts
e o ope
he i al
tons c ail e ut 1
l m n'

i ime s (iai o te .
mpar nt. cttons mitd)
l t i t nt c s t c ti smpl unabl t c l t tt a s s e t ofe ed b t
n he nsa a e, he our s i y
e o onc ude ha he s es m n f r y he
vocai le pe twhih wa ado e byt Ad i sr tveLa J
tona x r, c
s pt d he m nita i
w udge, sba e o a1t wor
wa s d n 1 he kr lt dlm ia i ct di t r porswhihwe ee i l c e t dbyt La J
e ae i t tons ie n he e t
c r xpldty r die
he w udge.Ac r ngl
co di y,
t c t su bl t c l t t heLa J
he our i na e o onc ude ha t
w udge' r la eont voc tona e
s ei nc
he a i l xper' t si onyi
ts e tm
n
a s s ng pl i t f sc a m a t f t a ffh s e of he s que i l s biiy a l i i s
s es i a n i f l i t he ourh nd i t t ps t e nt a di a lt na ys s s uppore
td
by s t nta e de .
ubs a i l vi nce
l pa s ng, he c t est ti pl i tf s c a m i pr r y c i r d a t f fh s ag of
n s i t our not ha f a n if l i s ope l ons de e t he i t t e
t s
he eque i ldi a lt a l i , he La J
nta s biiy na ys s t
w udge ha notm a al t ne es a y fndi i o de t
s
de l he c s r i ngs n r r o

pr ry e l et c eunde t me c lvoc ton g delnes See20 C. R.j 404.569.
opel vauat he as
r he dia ai al ui i .
F.
1

De pie ha ngr a hed t t nt g a i s ile a i c a s ,M r .Huc t p t tfe a t
s t vi e c
he e h r de n peca duc ton l s es s
kse esii d t he

a nitai he rngt ts i t bl t rado wrt ( 15 .TheLa J ma nofndi
dmi sr tve a i ha he s ma e o e r ie. TR )
w udge de i ngs
i t sr ga d. A sum i t tM r .Huc t p i ilt r t ,a gi n t Law J
n hi e r
s ng ha
s
kse s lie a e nd ve he
udge' fndi of
s i ng
r i
esdualf tonalc pa t f no m o et n lghte ri aswel aspli ifs a a l k of
unc i
a ciy or
r ha i xe ton,
l
a ntf ge nd ac

ta fra ewok s ls( 33) Rul 202. ofAppe x 2 t Subpa tP oft Admi sr tve
r nser bl r kil TR , e 02
ndi o
r
he
nitai
Reg a i nsPa t die t a de er i ton ofdi a e i pl ntf sc s Upon r m a i w il
ul to
r 404 r c s t m na i
s bl d n ai i f a e.
e nd, t l be

ne s a y f t Commi sone t dee m i whehe pl ntf i f tonaly ilt r t
ce s r or he
s i r o tr ne
t r ai if s unc i l lie a e.
Ona pe t t sc tpli tf mai ai t thee si r c di s tcint oe t bls r
p alo hi our, a n if nt ns ha t xitng e or s ufi e t sa ihhe
di abiiy f al f r s of s t n i lga nf e pl m e . The c tagr e t t s ver l of t
s lt or 1 o m
ubs a t a i ul m oy nt
our
e s ha e a
he

ps hi ti r po t ge r t d i 201 s
yc arc e rs ne a e n 2 uppor afndi oft a d s biiy.Howe r t f c r m ans
t i ng ot l i a lt
ve ,he a t e i
t tt me c e de ede l
ha he dial vi nc veopedprort t tr i tonofpl i ifsi ur d sausi muc ls
i o he e m na i
antf ns e t t s h e s
t n co l i A 1 i al,t c tbe i vest tt be t r cou s i t r m a t s ca e t t
ha nc usve. 1 n l he our le
ha he te
r e s o e nd hi s o he
Com m i s one f f r he a i s r tve pr ee ngs s t tt de i i nci a i ons s e esi
s i r or u t r dm ni t a i
oc di , o ha he f c e es nd nc it nci n

t r c d ma bepr ry r ol d.Theco t est ti c s si whi ht cl ma hasbe ome
he e or y
ope l es ve
ur not ha n a e n c he ai nt
c
dia e a t dae ofdiabiiy ons ti a g
s bl d, nd he t
s lt
e s mbi uous i i a o i t f t Co mi sone t
, t s ppr prae or he m s i r o
r c ve a s sanc f om a m e c l a s i or r t pr r y a s s a de e m i t da e of
e ei s i t e r
di a dvi or n de o ope l s es nd t r ne he t

dia lt ons t Baie v. tr 68F. 75( hCi.1 .
s biiy e. ly Chae, 3d 4t r 995)
On a a ,pl i if s it d ne m e ca e de di e ty t t co t Pl i i f s e
ppe l a ntf ubm te w
di l vi nce r c l o he ur . a ntf e ks

r nd ofhe ca et t Com misone f c i r to oft ne m e c le de . Gi t
ema
r s o he
s i r or onsde a in he w di a vi nce ven he
co tsdiposton a outi d a
ur' s ii s lne bove,hec t i i unnec s a yt c i rpl ntf smoton t
t our fnds t
e s r o onsde ai if
i o
r m a f rco i r tonof w m e ca e de e.l t Co m i sone tndsi ce s r o c
e nd o ns de a i
ne
di l vi nc f he m s i r i tne s a yt onduc
t

8

s e e t a m i sr tvepr e ngs M r . kse m a s
upplm n al d nitai oce di , s Huc t p y ubmi he ne r porss t tal t
t r w e t o ha 1 he
e denc ofr or i he ca e m a be c i r d.
vi e ec d n r s
y
ons de e
For t r as
he e ons s a e t cou t fnds E
t t d, he
r i
t
good c us ' f r m a of t s ca e t t
a e ' or e nd
hi s o he

Commiso rfrf t rde l ntandco i r i See42U. C. 405( .Ana oprae
sine o urhe veopme
nsdeaton.
S. j g)
ppr it
j
udgmen andor rwilbee ee t sda TheClr i die tdt s ndce tte c e oft s
t
de l ntrd hi y.
ek s rce o e riid opis hi
opi on t a lc
ni o 1 ouns lofr cor
e
e d.
DA TED :Thi
s

t
z

d yo M ac , 2014.
a f rh

ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

9