BioVeris v. Wohlstadter

Filing 34

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 06/11/2014. (ssm)

ctERK' OFFI U, DI COURT
- s 7 CE S. sT.

ATROA
NO , A
F

FLD ' ( t(
I y V ,U
I

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I I A
CT
RG NI
CH A RLO TTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

J 11 2 1
UN
29
JULf
BX

,C

l
'
DEPUW CLE

BI ERI C ORPOR ATI ,
OV
S
ON

Ci lA c i N o.3: 3CV 00022
vi ton
1
Pl i i f
a ntf ,

M EM ORANDUM O PI ON
NI
SAM UEL J W OHLSTADTER,
.

By:Ho Gl n E.Co la
n. e
rr d
ChifUnie Stt sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

D e e nt
f nda .
l t s di r iy a t o Bi e i Cor a i a s r st tSa ue J. o s a e br ac d
n hi ve st c i n, ov rs por ton s e t ha m l W hl t dt r e he

t tr ofagua a y agr e e by f ii t pay c ran fna i lo i i owe t Bi rs
he e ms
r nt
e m nt alng o
e ti i nc a blgatons d o ove i
Cor a i by a t r pa t The c s i pr e l bef r t c t t pl i if s m oton f
por ton
hid r y.
a e s es nty o e he our on he a ntf
i or

s mmayj g n .F rt er a o st a f l w,h moin wil g a td.
u r ud me t o h e s n h t ol te to lbe rn e
o
Backzround

Thepli if Bi rsCor ai (d oVei',i abi ec ogy c
antf, ovei porton 1Bi rs' s ot hnol ompanyi mor t
)
nco aed
i De a r wih isprncpalpl c ofbusne si I a M r W ohlt t r a Vigi actze i
n l wa e t t i i
ae
i s n ndi na. .
sad e , r ni ii n, s

t prsde a c e exe utveofierofW elsa Vac i s LLC (/ a32M otSte t
he e i nt nd hif c i fc
ltt cne ,
fk/
t re
Ac ston 1LLC)(k cneNe o'orçva ci s),abit hnol c
quiii ,
s i
vac
wc ' s c ne '
oec ogy ompanyf us dont
oc e
he
m a a t e, al,a diti i ofvac i s
nuf c ur s e nd srbuton
c ne .Thef ct oft sca ea eundiput d.
a s hi s r
s e

l J n 2 0 , c eHo dn Lt . c u rdBive i.Co l!8' s r!8 Asp r o
n u e 0 7 Ro h l ig d a q ie o rs mp . , we ( . at f
An
t tta a ton, ovei e ee it a a stta fra e ntwihVa i .Co . ! 8 '
ha rnsci Bi rs ntrd no n se rnse greme t ccnes mpl! -9,
Ans r!9.Unde t tr oft Va ci Ase Trnse Age
we
r he ems he c nes st a fr remen (C
t$
VATA' , ovei
' Bi rs
)
pr de a s t r l t d t t r s a ch,de opm e ,m a a t e pr
ovi d s e s e a e o he e e r
vel
nt nuf c ur , oduo i t s i s l
ton, e tng, a e,
di rbuton,and use ofvacci i exchange f a s esofpaym ent f om V acci
sti i
nes n
or eri
sr
nes. V ATA 1,

Y
'

/

Docke N o.1 4. Spe f c ly,Se ton 2. oft tans e a e e r qui e V a i t m a t
t
4cii a l
ci
5 he r f r gr em nt e r d cc nes o ke he

f l wi pa nt t Bi vers: 000, a cl i $50, on ea h oft frt s ond,a
olo ng yme s o o i $1, 000 t osng; 000
c
he is, ec
nd
t r am i r a i oft cl i da e;a $2, 000 on t t r a verar oft cosng da e.
hid l ve s res he osng t nd 709,
he hid nni s y he l i
t

Se t. a 1 Thecosngdat f t a e me wasJ 26,
e t, t 0.
t
li
e or he gre nt
une 2007.La r De l!7, ke No.
nne t c. Doc t
1 2. M r W ohl t dt r sgned t a s tta f r a e e i hi c ciy as c efexe tve of i er
4.
sa e i
he s e r ns e gr em nt n s apa t
hi
cu i
fc

ofVac i s VATA 29, ke No.1 4.Thea ee nti dae Aprl4,2007.Compl!9;
cne .
Doc t
4gr me s td i
.
Ans r!9.
we
A l o on Apr l4,
s
i 2007,Bi e i e e e i t a agr e e w ih M r W ohlt dt r i w hi h
ov r s nt r d n o n e m nt t
.
sa e , n
c

t dee ntpe s l l bs utl unc tonal , a ir voca ygua a eeg a1
he fnda ronaly,d ol ey, ondii lygj nd re bl r nt dl 1
a
oblgai of...Va ci Ne t ma pos-l i pa t t g oveijpurua t Se ton
i tons
c ne wco o ke tcosng ymens o Bi rs s nt o ci
2. oft V a i A s e Tr ns e A gr e e . G ua a y A gr m e ,D oc tN o.1 l The
5 he cc nes s t a f r e m nt'
'
r nt
ee nt
ke
-.

g a ya e me pr dedt ttgl oblgai oft unde sg unde ori rs c oft s
uarnt gre nt ovi ha ithe i tons he rined
r n epe t hi
g a e a ei pe ntoft gua a e o i tons'a t t$ s pa a ea i orac i ma
uar nt e r nde nde
he r nt ed blga i ,' nd ha t e r t cton
a
tons y
be br
oughtand pr e ut d aga ns t unde s g t e or t s g a e ir s c i ofwhe he
os c e
i t he
r i ned o nf ce hi uar nt e, r e pe tve
t r

a ya to i b o g a ans Va cn Ne o. . rwh t e Va cn Ne o . .s on d i a y
n cin s r u ht g i t c ie wc . o eh r c i e wc . i j ie n n
s ha ton. Jl Theguaa ya ee ntwa t xpr sl c tone upont cl i oft
uc ci ' -s
't
rnt gr me
s s e sy ondii d
e
he osng he
V a ci A s e Tr ns erA gr e e ' a w oul d e na e a om a i aly a be ofno f rhe f c
c nes s t a f
e m nt' nd
d i nni t ut tc l nd
t
u t r or e

a efe tupont tr nai oft Va ei Ase Trnse Agee t' lz
nd fe
he e mi ton he c nes st a fr r men . k.
'
V a i s m a t r r pa e s u n c os ng a u
cc ne
de he equied ym nt po l i nd pon t tr ta s c
he i s nd e ond
anni r a i oft c osng da e,butf l t m a t r quied pa ent t B i e i on t t r
ve s r es he l i
t
aied o ke he e r
ym s o ov rs he hid
a ver a y oft cl i dat J 26,201 I a s pa a e ac i br
nni s r
he os ng e, une
0. n e r t ton oughtby Bi e i a i t
ov r s ga ns

Vac i s t Unie St esDititCou tf t DititofDelwaee ee j
cne ,he td at src r or he src
a r ntrd udgme i
nt n

Bivei' fv ri t ea u to $ , 9,0 , l p eu g n a dp t u g n itr s.
o rss a o n h mo n f 275 0 0 pus rj d me t n os- d me t n ee tl
j
Se t D e .Ex. , ocke N o 1 1 Bi v e i ha no r ce ved a paym e - f om eiher
nne t cl
B D
t
4- 6. o r s s t e i
ny
nt r
t

Va cn so M r W o sa tr i stsa to o t ij d me t La n l De l! 1 -1 .Bivei
c ie r . hltd e- n aifcin f hs u g n . n e' c. ! 4 5 o rs
t
se s$ 7 90 0 plsp eu g n itr s, o t u g n itr s, ndt ec sso t i a to
e k 2,5 ,0 , u rj d me t n ee tp s- d me t ne et a h o t f h s cin.
j
Th c s i p e e tyb f r t c u t nteplitf smo inf rs mmayj g n .Mr
e a e s r sn l e o e he o r o h an if to o u r ud me t .
W ohlt dt o
sa er ppos st m o i n o t s eba i t tt f u -elcton caus i Se ton 1 5of
e he to n he ol ss ha he or m s e i l e n c i 0.
t unde l ng V a ci s A s e Tr ns erA g ee en r qui e t pl i ift s i D e a a e r t r
he
ryi
c ne
st a f
r m t e r s he a ntf o ue n l w r a he
t i t s court
han n hi
:

A 1 a tons a pr ee ngs a i i out of or r l tng t t s A gr em e s l be
1 ci
nd oc di
r s ng
e a i o hi
e nt ha l
he r a de er i d i t Cha r Co tof t St t of Del w a e or a f de al
a d nd t m ne n he
nce y ur
he a e
a r
ny e r
c t s ti i t St t of D el w a e, a t pa te her t her by ir voca y
our itng n he a e
a r nd he r i s e o
e re
bl

s b t t t e e cu ie j rs ito o s c c u t .. .i a y s c a to o
u mi o h x lsv u idcin f u h o rs
n n u h cin r
pr e i a ir voc bl wave t de e e of a i nve e t f r t t
oc ed ng nd r e a y i he f ns
n neo ni n o um o he

mane n eo a ys c a to o p o e dn Thec nsn st j rs ito stf rh
i tna c f n u h cin r r c e ig.
o e t o u idcin e o t
i t spa a a ...s l no be de d t conf rrght on a Pe s ot rt n
n hi r gr ph
ha l t
eme o
e i s
ny r on he ha

tep rish rt . Th p rish rt a ret tafn l u g n i a s c a to
h a t eeo e a t eeo g e ha ia j d me t n ny u h cin
e
e
o p o e d n s alb c n lsv a dma bee f re i oh rj rs cin b s i
r r c e i g h l e o cu ie n y n o c d n t e u idito s y ut
ont j
he udgmen ori a ot ma rpr de byap ia eLaw.
t n ny her nne ovi d
plc bl
VA TA 26,D oc tN o.1 4. I i undiput d t tt gua an y ag ee e doe notis l c a n a
ke
4- t s
s e ha he r t r m nt s
t e f ont i
f um - e e ton cl us nor doe i e e s y r f rt t o i t unde l ng ag e m e . The
or s l c i
a e,
s t xpr s l e e o he ne n he
r yi
r e nt
co t l a hea i on t m oton on M a 28, 4. H a ng be n f l br e e t m a t ri rpe
ur he d
rng
he
i
y
201
vi
e uly i f d, he te s i
f r ew .
or evi

St
andard ofR e e
vi w

Ana r o s mmayj d me t sa p o raetf h mo a ts o ta teei n g n i e
wa d f u r u g n i p r p it k t e v n h ws h t h r s o e u n
i
d s u ea t a ymaeilfc a dtemo a ti e tte t j d me ta amatro lw. Fe R.
ip t s o n tra a t n h v n s n ild o u g n s te f a ' d.
'
Ci. 5 () l d tn nngwh t e t g a tamo inf rs mma yj d me tt c u t s v e
v P. 6 a . n ee uii
ch r o rn
to o u r u g n ,he o r mu t iw
1 eDea r Cout loe trdj d me t g is Weltt a n sis LLC (rig osis' a oh r
Th lwae r as nee u g n a an t lsa Dig otc ,
ç a n tc', n te
)
c pan w h epayment M r W ohltdtrhadguarnt d i t c r ta is On J nuar 21 201 Dignosis
om y os
s .
sa e
a ee n he ontac t s ue.
a y s 4, a tc

wie p y n t Bivei i stsa to o tejdg n.Bivei d e n t e kd ma sfo MrW o ltde wi
rd a me to o rs n aifcin f h u me t o rs o s o se a ge r m . hsa tr t
h
r pe tt D i
es c o agnos i .
tcs

3

t r or i t lghtm os f vor et t nonhe ec d n he i
t a abl o he
mova .Ande s v.Li ry LobbysI . 477 U.
nt
r on
be t
nc,
S.

2 2 2 5( 98 ) Towih tndas mmayj d me t to t en n mo n mu tp o u e
4 , 5 1 6.
t sa
u r u g n mo in,h o - va t s r d c
s tce e de efom whiharas bl gac fnder c drt navediti hi fvor I a
ufi int vi nc r
c e ona e f t i l oul eur
r c n s a . d. t
249
-50. tconc us y o s ul tve a l ga i do nots fce nordoesa d e e s ntla of
û
l or r pec a i le tons
uf i ,
m r ci il

e de i s r of(henon- nts c s ' Thomps v. oma El .Powe Co.31 F.d
vi nce'n uppo t t
mova 'l a e.
'
on Pot c ec
r , 2 3
645,649( hCi.2002)( i Philnsv.CSX Trns sl ,1 F.d 285,287(t Ci.1 )
4t r
quotng li
a p. nc. 90 3
4h r 999).
D i si
scus on

Bi rsmove f s
ove i
s or ummayj me ba e onM r W ohltdt ' undiputdf l et
r udg nt s d
.
sa ers s e aiur o
pa t a ounto d t Bi rsbyVac i sa r quiedbyt e e st r soft gua a y
y he m
we o ove i
c ne s e r
he xpr s e m
he r nt
agr e e . M r W o s ad e oppos t m oton on t s e bas st tt f m - e e ton cl us i
e m nt
. hl t t r
es he
i
he ol
i ha he onl s l c i
a en
t unde l ng V a i s A s e Tr ns e A gr e e r quiest pl ntf t s i D e a a e r t r
he
r yi
cc ne s t a f r e m nt e r he ai i f o ue n l w r a he

t a i ti c u t Th d fn a t loc ne t t panifsr q s f rp eu g n itr s.Th
h n n h s o r. e ee d n as o tss he litf e uet o rj d me tn ee t e
c tw ila es ea h i s i t n.
our l ddr s c s ue n ur
For - l c i Cl e
um se e t on aus
The de e
f ndantco c t tt f um - e e ton c a e i t unde l ng agr e e r quies
nt nds ha he or s l c i l us n he
r yi
e m nt e r

t sltga i t pr e d,i a al i Deawar . I t a e e ofa s h clus i i ce t t
hi ii ton o oc e f t l, n l e n he bs nc
ny uc a e, t s lar ha
ve i pr ri t sco tsnc M r W ohlt d e i ar i ntofM a s Cot y, r ni
nue s ope n hi ur i e .
sa t r s esde
dion mt Vigi a,

wihi t sditita di son.Compl!7.Ans r!7,s e28U. C.jl ( ( )(1 ci l
t n hi src nd vii
. , we ' e
S.
391b)1 ( vi
A

a to ma beb o g ti . . u iildsrc i whc a yd f n a t e ie ,fa1d fn a t ae
ci n y r u h n . aj dca itit n ih n ee d n r sd s i l ee d n s r
r sde soft Stt i whiht dititi l ae ' ;At.M ai Consr Co. U. Dit Cour
e i nt he ae n c he src s oc td.l l rne
'
t. v. S. s. t
f t W . s. Tex. 1 S.Ct 568,578( 3 Civjnuei pr rs l a t r rme s
or he Dit of , 34
.
201 ) g e s ope o ong s he equie nt

ofj 1 ( aeme,ir peci ofa f u s l toncaus ' .Howe r ûg he t pa te
391b) r t res tve ny orm-eeci l e.'
)
ve ,swj n he ris
ha a ee t a va i f um - e e ton cl us ,a dit i tc ts d or narl t a f rt c e t
ve gr d o
ld or s l c i
a e
s rc our houl di iy r ns e he as o
t f um s cii d i t tcl us ' At . a i Cons r Co. 1 S.Ct a 581. l i undiput d t t
he or
pe f e n ha a e. l M rne
'
t . , 34
.t
ts
s e ha
4

t g r nt agr em e doesnotis l c ai a f m - el c i cl us nordoesi e es l r f
he ua a y e nt
t e f ont n onz s e ton a e,
t xpr s y e er
t t one i t unde l ng V a ci A s e Tr ns e A gr em e . Ra he ,M r W o s a e a gues
o he
n he
ryi
c nes s t a f r e nt t r . hlt dt r r
t tt gua a y i plc ty i por t st f um - el c i cl us expr s d i Sec i 1 5 oft
ha he r nt m i il ncor a e he or s e ton a e
es e n
ton 0.
he
underyi a e m e .
l ng gr e nt

Se r lf de a co t ha c i r whe he a g r nt a ee
ve a e r l urs ve onsde ed
t r ua a y gr ments d bei e pr t
houl
ntr eed
t i l a f um - el c i c a e expr s e onl i t underyi agr em e esa i hi t
o nc ude or s e ton l us
e s d y n he
l ng e nt t bls ng he
gua a e oblgato The f t sr i upo by o he cours i m aki t tde e m i ton i o
r nt ed i i n.
ac or eled n
t r
t n
ng ha t r na i nf nn
'
s on n he ns a as 2 t
i e a t s ven ont oli
ght
t courtsdeci i i t i t ntc e. A lhough no s ngl f c ori gi c r lng w ei ,
he
cou t r l hea l on t l ngua oft a ee en s W he et guar nt e es l sa e t tt
r s e y viy
he a
ge he gr m t .
r he
a y xpr sy t t s ha he

g a o ' oblga i a e i pe ntoft oblga i de c i i t unde l ng ag e m e ,
uar nt r s i tons r nde nde
he i tons s rbed n he
ryi
r e nt
c t ha de lned t i or r t t f r - e e ton c a e. Se e. ,Pi r Co m e c a
ours ve c i
o nc po a e he o um s l c i l us
e. g. onee m r i l

Fundi Co . No ik.2006W L 335 41,a * ( D. Nov.1 2006)( lni t
ng p v. rc
41 t 2 E. Pa.
7,
deci ng o
i op or t a f um - e e ton cl us e e s i t unde l ng a ee e w he e t g r nt
nc
a e or s l c i
a e xpr s ed n he
ryi gr m nt
r he ua a y

k xpr sy saest tkheoblgai hee raei pe toft oblgai ofghepat t
t esl tt ha t
e
i tons runde r nde nden he i tons t ry o
t undel nga e nt.' .
he
ryi greme j''
)
W he e t gua ant undera t pe f m al oblga i c a ned i t unde l ng
r he r or
t kes o r or 1 i tons ont i
n he
r yi
ag ee e , ur s ha cons r ed t ag e m en s t t ra i op or t t f u - e ec i n
r m nt co t ve
t u he r e t oge he nd nc
a ed he or m s l to
cl us i o t gua a y. Se Am e ir tCo. atlA s ' v.Cha l ,8 F.Su 893,895
a e nt he r nt
e
rt us
N ' sn
ns or 03
pp.

( D. . 1 2)(uaa orunc tonalyguarnt dt ( ror nc a obsr nc ofal
S. N Y. 99 g rnt
ondii l
a ee he s f ma e nd e va e 1
pe
oblgai ,rpr s nttonsa war nte 'i t undel ngag e me l Ce ur 21Re Esae
i tons e e e ai nd ra is'n he
ryi r e nt; nt y
al tt.
2A fder c tsti i di r iym us a yt f u sae' confitof1w r e . K l
e al our i ng n ve st
l
t ppl he or m tt s
lc a uls axon Co. St nt
v. e or

Elc Mf. .31 U. 48 , 9 -9 (9 ) Un e Vignalw,tth n tr, aii a ditrrtt no c nrcs
e . g Co, 3 S. 7 4 6 7 1 41. d r rii a t le au e v l t n nep eai f o ta t
g
dy
o
a egov n by t l oft pl ewheem ade unls t con rr a ar t bet e es i e i oft pa tes'
r
er ed he aw he ac
r
, e s he ta y ppe s o he xpr s ntnton he ri .
'

W o d o v. ln M u . n . ,l 7 S. 2d61 , 3 ( .1 7 ) He e c n r c it r r tto i a is e
o s n Cei a t l s Co. 7 E. 0 61 Va 9 0 . r , o ta t n e p eai n s t s u
s ciialy,whehe t gua a yagr m e i or aest f um s lc i cl e i Seci 1 5 oft unde l ng
pe fc l
t r he r nt ee nt nc port he or ee ton aus n ton 0. he
ryi
Vac ne A setTr nserAgr m e bu net rparyw a a et a s t c ta t hea i ont i tntmoton
ci s s a f
ee nt t ihe
t s bl o dvie he our t he rng he nsa
i
wher t c r c wasm a Cons que l t cour hass veye r eva f der ca e
e he ont a t
de.
e nty, he
t
ur d el nt e al s s.

LLC v.Gae yReat LLC,2011W L 1
twa
ly,
322006,a *5( uarnt explctysae t tt
t g a y iil ttd ha he
guaa or woul unde tke$ l oblgai ofFrnchie 'unde t fa hiea e nt;
rnt s
d
ra k l i tons a se' r he rnc s greme )
a
Hadee' Food Syse .I v.gbal2005W L 2333897,a *1( D.Mo.Sept22,2005
r s
tms nc. l ,
t E.
.
)
( r nt ska e dlpes l t beboundbye ha e r pr soni 'heunde l ng
gua a or ûgreg ronaly o
ac nd vey ovii n't
ryi
a e me i t lmiai '.Si lry,wheet guaa ya e me i af m conrc,c t
gre ntd hout i tton' mial
wi
)
r he rnt gr e nt s or
ta t ours
ha i
ve mpore tnnsfom t unde l ng ag e m e , whe t g r nt a ee tc ans
td e
r he
ryi
r e nt but n he ua a y gr men ont i
ne i t t r s t g a y i m or lke y t s a o is own. Com pa e Am e ir s ,8 F.
gota ed e m , he uar nt s
e i l o t nd n t
r
rt u t 03

Su a 896(nc portngf um-eeci caus whe etheg uarnt i af m doc nt'
pp. t i or ai or s l ton l e r s gj a ee s or
t
ume '
whiet undel nga ee nt i r s ii lyprpa e f t ta aci i quesi ',wih
l he
ryi gr me s l e pecfcal e r d or he rns ton n
we
ton.' t
)

Pi r 2006W L 33541 ,a *2(i ngt g a yt beaspaaewrte ag e me whe e
onee,
41 t fndi he uarnt o
e rt itn r e nt r
t guaant tc ai manyne itdtr '.
he r y iont ns
gotae ems'
)
Co t ha al o c i e t i ntt oft pa test e ch a ee e . Se A m e ir t
ur s ve s onsder d he de iy he r i o a gr m nt e
rtus ,

803F.
Supp. t896(xpli ngt ti r t ormor wrte i tume sbewee t s me
a
e ani ha s e wo
whe
e itn nsr nt t n he a

pate c er ngt s mes j c matraecone r ne l e c e t ywilber da
ris onc ni he a ub e t te r tmpo a ousy xe utd,he l ea nd
i er ee t t r' (mpha i a dl s ealo Pine r 2006W L 33541 at* ( clni t
nt prtd ogehe') e
ss dde ; e s o e,
41, 2 de i ng o
i r r t af um-elcin ca ee e s donl i t unde l nga ee ntwheeûghe
ncopo ae or s e to lus xprs e y n he ryi gr me
r it

g aa t r i n tap ryt t egn e lig a r e n , bu rt e $ s p rt m itn a re n
u r no j s o a t o h u d ryn j g e me t' t ah r t e aae te g e me t
'
a
e ssg r ngt rltons pbewe n gheguaa ora guaa ee' .
xit oveni he eai hi t e t
rnt nd r nt l'
)
O t c i r tonsi l whe he t gua a y agr e e t e er t t c r tw hos
her ons de a i
nc ude
t r he r nt
e m nt d f s o he ontac
r
e
per o m a i gua a ee ' A m e ir t 803 F.Supp. t896,a t pr m iy w ih w hi h t
f r nce s r nt d,
'
rt us ,
a
nd he oxi t t
c he
guar y and underl ng agr entw ere si
ant
yi
eem
gned. See.e. ,Cent y 21,2011 W L 1322006,at*5
:.
ur

(onsr ngt t ragee nt e ut o t smedae;Ameinzt 803F.Supp.a 8
c tui ogehe r me s xec ed n he a
t)
rt s.
t 96
(onsr ngt t rdocume st twer t c e t he') Pi r 2006W L 33541 ,a *2
c tui ogehe
nt ha e t utd oget r'; onee,
exe
41 t

( ci ngt c tuet ehe doc nt t twe ene itdfvemont apa t.
de lni o onsr og t r ume s ha r gotae i
hs r)
6

Afe we g ng t r e ntf c or i c e wih t f t oft i t tca e,t c ti
tr i hi he elva a t s n ont xt t he ac s he nsan s he our s
c nc d t tt gua a y ag e m e bewe n Bi rsa M r W ohlt t ri s c ptbl of
onvi e ha he r nt r e nt t e ove i nd .
sad e s us e i e

onl oneras bl i eprtton, t ts
y
e ona e ntr eai and ha ummayj
r udgmen i t pli ifsfvori
t n he antf a s
a o it Se l r Fara M e ca Ce e Asocitsl,1 F. 698,a *4(t Ci.Se .
ppr prae. e n e ifx di l ntr s ae 1 21 3d
t 4h r pt 2,

1 (
997) unpubls dtbl de son)(xpli ngt tdipostonofamatrons
ihe a e cii e ani ha s ii
te
ummayj me i
r udg nt s
i ppr praewhe aconr ti s c ptbl oft ras bl i epr ttons.Alho ht
na o it
n
tac s us e i e wo e ona e ntr eai ) t ug he
a e me sbe rt s medaea dglfrnc i ma 'i t guaa yagee ntt t Vac i
gre nt a he a
t nd sreee e s de'n he rnt r me o he cnes
A s e Tr ns e A gr em en ,G ua a y A g e m e 1, oc tN o.1 5,t r m a ni c r um s a s
s t a fr e
t
r nt
r e nt D ke
4- he e i ng ic t nce
cl a l e t i h t tt gua a y a e m e ti a r a e buti pe nt s a a one c r c ,
e r y s abls ha he r nt gr e n s el t d,
nde nde , t nd- l
ont a t
s h t tt f m - el c i n c a e i t a s tt a f r a ee e doe note e t t gua a y
uc ha he onz s e t o l us n he s e r ns e gr m nt s
xt nd o he r nt
agreem ent
.

He e t c r c lnguagei c t t tt a s tta f ra e nta g r nt a e
r , he onta t a
ndi a es ha he s e r nse gr eme nd ua a y r
s pa a e a ee e s The unde l ng a ee e be w e Bi e i and Vac ne c i t oft
e r t gr m nt .
ryi gr m nt t en ov r s
ci s ons s s he
t a ci A s e Tr ns e A g ee e , oge he wih al a xe ,e bis s hedul a ot r
' c nes s t a f r r m nt t t r t l nne s xhi t , c
V
es nd he

doc nt atche gheet ' Va i Ase Trnse Agr me 1 Doc tNo.1 4.The
ume s ta d t rlo.' ccnes st a fr ee nt , ke
4gua a y ag ee e i neihe at c d norot r s me i
r nt r m nt s t r ta he
he wie ntoned. Asi Pi ne r whe et f r m n o e , r he o u
s l ton c a ei t underyi a e ntdi note e t t g r nt a e nt t g r nt
eec i l us n he
l ng gr eme d
xtnd o he ua a y gr eme , he ua a y

agee nta is e e sysaest tSll oblg tonsoft undesg unde ori r s c of
r me t sue xpr s l tt ha tthe iai
he
rined
r n e pe t
t s guar ee ar i
hi
ant
e ndependentoft guarant oblgatons.' Guarant A gr ent D ocketN o.
he
eed i i '
y
eem ,

1 5. A ddii l t guar nt a e m e s ii a l pr dest t$ s pa a e a ton orac i
4tonaly, he
a y gr e nt pec f c ly ovi ha t e r t c i
a
tons

m a be br
y
oughta pr ec e a ns t t r i d t e or t sguar nt e ..., Gua a y
nd os ut d gai t he mde sgne o nf ce hi
a e
'
' r nt
A g ee e ,D oc tN o.1 1 w ihoutlm ii w he e s h a a ton m a be br ht
r m nt
ke
-, t
i tng
r uc n c i
y
oug .
The desclpton ofM r.W ohlt er' oblga i undert guar y agr ental o
i i
s adt s i t ons
he
ant
eem
s
sugges st t guar y and ass t ans er agr ent ar s at U nlke C ent y 21,
t hat he
ant
et r f
eem s e epar e.
i
ur
7

Am e ir t a H a de s w he e e c g r nt r a e d t be bound by e r t r oft unde l ng
rt us , nd r e' , r a h ua a o gr e o
ve y e m
he
r yi
a e ent M r W ohl t dt r s o i ton i e e s y lm ie t m a ng t pos - l i pay e s
gr em , .
s a e ' blga i s xpr s l i t d o ki he t c os ng m nt
ow e t Bi e i by V a i s a D i gnos i s u rSe ton 2. oft i r s c i a s tt a f r
d o ov r s
cc ne nd a
tc nde c i
5 he r e pe tve s e r ns e
agr e e s G ua a y A gr em e 1 Doc t 1 5. U nlke t f contac i Am e ir t t
e m nt .
r nt
e nt , ke 4i he onu
r tn
rt us , he
g r nt a ee e i s cii aly t ior d t t t a a ton be w e n Bi e i a M r
ua a y gr m nt s pe tc l a l e o he r ns c i
t e ov rs nd .
W ohl t dt ,a i c a nss ve alnego i t d t r s
s a er nd t ont i e r
ta e e m .
Furhe ,a t ug M r W ohl t t rs g t as e t a f r a e m e i hi ca c t as
t r lho h .
sad e i ned he s t r ns e gr e nt n s pa iy

c e e utveofi e ofVac i s hei notapa t t t ta ee nt Ra he , s pa a egua ant
hif xec i fc r
cne , s
ry o ha gr me . t r a e r t
r y

ag e me lgovenglt rltons p'bewee Bi rsandMr W ohlt e .Pi e ,2006W L
r e nti r s he eai hi ' t n ovei
.
sadtr one r
33541 ,a *2.By ise e st nns t f um- eec i caus i t Va i As e Tr f r
41 t
t xpr s e , he or s l ton l e n he ccnes s t ans e
Agr m en onl a i s t di put s be w ee Bi e i a V ac i s VA TA 26, oc tN o.1 4
ee t y pple o s e t n ov r s nd
c ne .
D ke
4-

(i' c e st j iditons f t i t spa a a ... halnotbede me t c e rght on
ll ons nt o urs ci et orh n hi z grph s l
-he
e d o onfr i s
a Pes ot rt nt pa teshert ')
ny ron he ha he ri
eo. .
'
Fi l t r i an a tonala ve y pe s s ve f t i t i t ntc e t ti not
naly, he e s
ddii
nd r r ua i ac or n he ns a as ha s
m e i d i any o he cas s ve by t c t
ntone n
t r e ur yed
he our .The gua an y ag ee e w asdr f e a
r t r m nt
a t d nd
exe ut d w ih t as i t e of s s i a e cot s on bot s de - t s m e co e w ho
c e t he s sanc
ophi tc t d m el
h i s he a
uns l

pr pa edt Vac i sA s e Tr ns e Agr eme .l t pa tesit nde t i l af um e r he
cne s t a f r e nt f he ri n e d o ncude or
s e ton cl us i t g r nt ag e en ,c
el c i
a e n he ua a y r em t ouns c ea l knew how t dr f l nguage t t t
el l ry
o a ta
o ha
e f c . Fora 1oft e r as ,t c t
fe t
1 hes e ons he our conc ude t tt gua a y a e m e doe noti por t
l s ha he r nt gr e nt s
m
t he
f um - el c i cl us f om t unde l ng a s ttans era ee e .
or s e ton a e r he
ryi s e r f gr m nt
Si e t f um - e e ton cl us i Sec i 1 5 oft V ac i s A s e Tr ns e A gr m e
nc he or s l c i
a e n ton 0.
he
c ne s t a f r ee nt
doesnote e t t gua a y a e m e , he de e nt spr dur lde ens m us f l M r
xt nd o he r nt gr e nt t
f nda ' oce a f e
t ai. .
W ohl t t rha no of e e i m i i ora t hea i on t i t ntm o i n,a s t ntve
sad e s t f r d, n tng
t he rng
he ns a
t o ny ubs a i
def
ense t t pl ntf s alegat ons. Ther i no genui diput ast any m at i f ,and M r.
o he ai if l i
es
ne s e o
eral act
8

W ohlt t rhaspr de noevi nc fom whi h ar s bl f c fnderc dconcl t the
sad e
ovi d
de e r
c ea ona e a t i
oul
udc ha
di notbr a h t t nnsoft gua an y ag e m e . A nde s 477 U . a 249-50. A cc di y,
d
e c he e
he r t r e nt
r on,
S. t
or ngl

teplitf smo inf rs mmayj d me t s b g a td.
h anif to o u r u g n mu t e rn e
II
.

C al aton ofI erest
cul i
nt

Ha ng f
vi ound i f voroft pli ifi t sma tr i bec e nec s r t de e mi t
n a
he antf n hi te , t om s es a y o t r ne he

p o e rt of rj dg n itrs,fa y t whc Bive i i e tte t h t e p eu g n
r p r ae p eu me t ne e ti n ,o ih o rs s n ild.i eh r rj d me t
W
i e es s d bea a de ... samat rwihi t s
nt r t houl
w r d i
te t n he ound dic e i oft diti tcour. Hia hi
s r ton he src
t' t c
'

Cr di Am.Cop.v.Si tBa 1 F. 61 633( h Ci.1 .
et
cne nk, 66 3d 4, 4t r 999)
S r ni lw govenst a r ofprj
s gi a a
vi
r he wad
eudgme i ee ti adi st ca e. Sine Ba
nt ntrs n veriy s ' g t nk,
'
1 F. a 633.Unde Vigi alw,lina ... to a lw o s ti e t ...t fna or r
66 3d t
r r ni a igj ny acin t a r ui n quiy he i l de
. . .

ma pr def i e e ton a prnci lsun awa de ora pa tt r of a fx t pe i a
y ovi or ntr s
ny i pa t
r d, ny r he e , nd i he rod t

whiht eitr s s al o n e' Va Co ej8013 2.(l ea r o p eu g n itr s i
c h n ee t h lc mme c . . d . - 8 t- wad f rj d me t n ee t s
'
-h
t eo pe a e Pl i t f f t l s s t i d by notr e vi t a ountt w hi h he w ase il d
o m ns t a n i f or he os us a ne
ec i ng he m
o
c
ntte
a t tm e he w ase il d t r c ve i,a s h a a d i c i e nec s r t pl ce t
t he i
ntte o e ei t nd uc w r s onsder d es a y o a he

g antfji t postonhewoul ha occ edi t pa t i dea tha f tledhi oblg e
pli if n he ii
d ve upi f he ry n ful d ulil s iatd

dut ' M aksv. nz 3 S. 2d263,267( .1 ( i Empl rTe msesJ nt
y.' r Sa o, 45 E.
Va 986) quotng
oye - a tr oi
C o i N o.8 H eat & W e f r Fund v. e t r l Conc e es nc ,468 F.Supp.11 11
unc l
4- 1h
la e
W a he a l
rt l .
67, 71

( D. . 1 ) tft c r c ...doe notfx a i ers rt,t c ts l a yt
S. W Va. 979). d he onta t
l
s i n nt e t ae he our hal ppl he

j d me trt o sxp re tt c lult p eu g n itrs p ru n t j8013 2 . .' Va
u g n ae f i e c n o ac ae rj d me t n ee t u s a t o . - 8 . . .
'
Codej6. 30 B)
2- 2( .

Unde t fcsoft sca e a a r ofprj
r he a t hi s , n wad
eudgme i ers i a o it Thepl ntf
nt nt e t s ppr prae.
ai if
wa e il d t r e ve$2, 000 fo et rVa i orM r W ohlt dt ron J 26, 0.An
s ntte o ec i
759, r m ihe ccnes
.
sa e
une 201

a r ofprj me i ers i nec s r t plc Bi rsi t postoni woul ha oc upid
wad
eudg nt nt e t s esay o a e ovei n he ii t d ve c e
i M r W ohl t dt rhad f t led hi oblg i unde t g r nt a e en . Se M a ks 345
f .
sa e
uli l
s i aton
r he ua a y gr em t e r ,
9

S. 2d a 267. Be us t r i no i e e tr t s tf t i t gua a y ag e m e , he pl i ifw il
E. t
ca e he e s nt r s a e e or h n he r nt r e nt t
a ntf l

bea r dprj me i ers a t r t ofsxpec ntfom J 26,201 untlt daeofe r
wade eudg nt nt e t t he ae i re r une
0 i he t nty

o fn l u g n .Thep an ifi as e tte t po tj d me titr s a t ert s tf rhi 28
f ia j d me t
litf s lo nild o s-u g n n ee t t h ae e o t n
U. . .j1961
SC
.
C oncl on
usi

Fo ter a o ssae ,h c u t lg a t h plitf smo ina e tr u g n i fv r
r h e s n ttd te o r wil rn t e an if to nd ne j d me tn a o

o Bivei Co p rto i t ea u t f$ 75 0 0 plsp eu g n i tr s a t ert o sx
f o rs r o ai n n h mo n o 2, 9,0 , u rj d me t nee t t h ae f i
p re ta dp t u g n itr s a t ert s t o t i 2 U. C. 1 61 Th plitf sp n i g
e c n n os- d me tn ee t t h ae e f rh n 8 S. j 9 . e an if e d n
j
m oton f l a t a ara t i lw ihoutl alc
i or e ve o ppe t r a t
oc ouns lw ilbe di m i s d a m oot a t ac i
e l
s se s
, nd he ton
w ilbe s rc n f om t a tve doc toft c t
l
t i ke r he c i
ke
he our .

The Clr i die t d t s c rii d c esoft smemor nd opi on a t
e k s r c e o end e tte opi
hi
a um
ni nd he
a com pa ng or rt a lc
c
nyi
de o 1 ouns lofr co d.
e
e r

ENTER:Thi l1
s

da ofJ 201
y une, 4.
Chi Unie St esD i ti tJ
ef t d at
s r c udge

10