BioVeris v. Wohlstadter

Filing 34

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 06/11/2014. (ssm)

Download PDF
ctERK' OFFI U, DI COURT - s 7 CE S. sT. ATROA NO , A F FLD ' ( t( I y V ,U I I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STRI CO U RT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN D I STRI OF V I I A CT RG NI CH A RLO TTESV I LLE D I I ON V SI J 11 2 1 UN 29 JULf BX ,C l ' DEPUW CLE BI ERI C ORPOR ATI , OV S ON Ci lA c i N o.3: 3CV 00022 vi ton 1 Pl i i f a ntf , M EM ORANDUM O PI ON NI SAM UEL J W OHLSTADTER, . By:Ho Gl n E.Co la n. e rr d ChifUnie Stt sDititJ e t d a e src udge D e e nt f nda . l t s di r iy a t o Bi e i Cor a i a s r st tSa ue J. o s a e br ac d n hi ve st c i n, ov rs por ton s e t ha m l W hl t dt r e he t tr ofagua a y agr e e by f ii t pay c ran fna i lo i i owe t Bi rs he e ms r nt e m nt alng o e ti i nc a blgatons d o ove i Cor a i by a t r pa t The c s i pr e l bef r t c t t pl i if s m oton f por ton hid r y. a e s es nty o e he our on he a ntf i or s mmayj g n .F rt er a o st a f l w,h moin wil g a td. u r ud me t o h e s n h t ol te to lbe rn e o Backzround Thepli if Bi rsCor ai (d oVei',i abi ec ogy c antf, ovei porton 1Bi rs' s ot hnol ompanyi mor t ) nco aed i De a r wih isprncpalpl c ofbusne si I a M r W ohlt t r a Vigi actze i n l wa e t t i i ae i s n ndi na. . sad e , r ni ii n, s t prsde a c e exe utveofierofW elsa Vac i s LLC (/ a32M otSte t he e i nt nd hif c i fc ltt cne , fk/ t re Ac ston 1LLC)(k cneNe o'orçva ci s),abit hnol c quiii , s i vac wc ' s c ne ' oec ogy ompanyf us dont oc e he m a a t e, al,a diti i ofvac i s nuf c ur s e nd srbuton c ne .Thef ct oft sca ea eundiput d. a s hi s r s e l J n 2 0 , c eHo dn Lt . c u rdBive i.Co l!8' s r!8 Asp r o n u e 0 7 Ro h l ig d a q ie o rs mp . , we ( . at f An t tta a ton, ovei e ee it a a stta fra e ntwihVa i .Co . ! 8 ' ha rnsci Bi rs ntrd no n se rnse greme t ccnes mpl! -9, Ans r!9.Unde t tr oft Va ci Ase Trnse Age we r he ems he c nes st a fr remen (C t$ VATA' , ovei ' Bi rs ) pr de a s t r l t d t t r s a ch,de opm e ,m a a t e pr ovi d s e s e a e o he e e r vel nt nuf c ur , oduo i t s i s l ton, e tng, a e, di rbuton,and use ofvacci i exchange f a s esofpaym ent f om V acci sti i nes n or eri sr nes. V ATA 1, Y ' / Docke N o.1 4. Spe f c ly,Se ton 2. oft tans e a e e r qui e V a i t m a t t 4cii a l ci 5 he r f r gr em nt e r d cc nes o ke he f l wi pa nt t Bi vers: 000, a cl i $50, on ea h oft frt s ond,a olo ng yme s o o i $1, 000 t osng; 000 c he is, ec nd t r am i r a i oft cl i da e;a $2, 000 on t t r a verar oft cosng da e. hid l ve s res he osng t nd 709, he hid nni s y he l i t Se t. a 1 Thecosngdat f t a e me wasJ 26, e t, t 0. t li e or he gre nt une 2007.La r De l!7, ke No. nne t c. Doc t 1 2. M r W ohl t dt r sgned t a s tta f r a e e i hi c ciy as c efexe tve of i er 4. sa e i he s e r ns e gr em nt n s apa t hi cu i fc ofVac i s VATA 29, ke No.1 4.Thea ee nti dae Aprl4,2007.Compl!9; cne . Doc t 4gr me s td i . Ans r!9. we A l o on Apr l4, s i 2007,Bi e i e e e i t a agr e e w ih M r W ohlt dt r i w hi h ov r s nt r d n o n e m nt t . sa e , n c t dee ntpe s l l bs utl unc tonal , a ir voca ygua a eeg a1 he fnda ronaly,d ol ey, ondii lygj nd re bl r nt dl 1 a oblgai of...Va ci Ne t ma pos-l i pa t t g oveijpurua t Se ton i tons c ne wco o ke tcosng ymens o Bi rs s nt o ci 2. oft V a i A s e Tr ns e A gr e e . G ua a y A gr m e ,D oc tN o.1 l The 5 he cc nes s t a f r e m nt' ' r nt ee nt ke -. g a ya e me pr dedt ttgl oblgai oft unde sg unde ori rs c oft s uarnt gre nt ovi ha ithe i tons he rined r n epe t hi g a e a ei pe ntoft gua a e o i tons'a t t$ s pa a ea i orac i ma uar nt e r nde nde he r nt ed blga i ,' nd ha t e r t cton a tons y be br oughtand pr e ut d aga ns t unde s g t e or t s g a e ir s c i ofwhe he os c e i t he r i ned o nf ce hi uar nt e, r e pe tve t r a ya to i b o g a ans Va cn Ne o. . rwh t e Va cn Ne o . .s on d i a y n cin s r u ht g i t c ie wc . o eh r c i e wc . i j ie n n s ha ton. Jl Theguaa ya ee ntwa t xpr sl c tone upont cl i oft uc ci ' -s 't rnt gr me s s e sy ondii d e he osng he V a ci A s e Tr ns erA gr e e ' a w oul d e na e a om a i aly a be ofno f rhe f c c nes s t a f e m nt' nd d i nni t ut tc l nd t u t r or e a efe tupont tr nai oft Va ei Ase Trnse Agee t' lz nd fe he e mi ton he c nes st a fr r men . k. ' V a i s m a t r r pa e s u n c os ng a u cc ne de he equied ym nt po l i nd pon t tr ta s c he i s nd e ond anni r a i oft c osng da e,butf l t m a t r quied pa ent t B i e i on t t r ve s r es he l i t aied o ke he e r ym s o ov rs he hid a ver a y oft cl i dat J 26,201 I a s pa a e ac i br nni s r he os ng e, une 0. n e r t ton oughtby Bi e i a i t ov r s ga ns Vac i s t Unie St esDititCou tf t DititofDelwaee ee j cne ,he td at src r or he src a r ntrd udgme i nt n Bivei' fv ri t ea u to $ , 9,0 , l p eu g n a dp t u g n itr s. o rss a o n h mo n f 275 0 0 pus rj d me t n os- d me t n ee tl j Se t D e .Ex. , ocke N o 1 1 Bi v e i ha no r ce ved a paym e - f om eiher nne t cl B D t 4- 6. o r s s t e i ny nt r t Va cn so M r W o sa tr i stsa to o t ij d me t La n l De l! 1 -1 .Bivei c ie r . hltd e- n aifcin f hs u g n . n e' c. ! 4 5 o rs t se s$ 7 90 0 plsp eu g n itr s, o t u g n itr s, ndt ec sso t i a to e k 2,5 ,0 , u rj d me t n ee tp s- d me t ne et a h o t f h s cin. j Th c s i p e e tyb f r t c u t nteplitf smo inf rs mmayj g n .Mr e a e s r sn l e o e he o r o h an if to o u r ud me t . W ohlt dt o sa er ppos st m o i n o t s eba i t tt f u -elcton caus i Se ton 1 5of e he to n he ol ss ha he or m s e i l e n c i 0. t unde l ng V a ci s A s e Tr ns erA g ee en r qui e t pl i ift s i D e a a e r t r he ryi c ne st a f r m t e r s he a ntf o ue n l w r a he t i t s court han n hi : A 1 a tons a pr ee ngs a i i out of or r l tng t t s A gr em e s l be 1 ci nd oc di r s ng e a i o hi e nt ha l he r a de er i d i t Cha r Co tof t St t of Del w a e or a f de al a d nd t m ne n he nce y ur he a e a r ny e r c t s ti i t St t of D el w a e, a t pa te her t her by ir voca y our itng n he a e a r nd he r i s e o e re bl s b t t t e e cu ie j rs ito o s c c u t .. .i a y s c a to o u mi o h x lsv u idcin f u h o rs n n u h cin r pr e i a ir voc bl wave t de e e of a i nve e t f r t t oc ed ng nd r e a y i he f ns n neo ni n o um o he mane n eo a ys c a to o p o e dn Thec nsn st j rs ito stf rh i tna c f n u h cin r r c e ig. o e t o u idcin e o t i t spa a a ...s l no be de d t conf rrght on a Pe s ot rt n n hi r gr ph ha l t eme o e i s ny r on he ha tep rish rt . Th p rish rt a ret tafn l u g n i a s c a to h a t eeo e a t eeo g e ha ia j d me t n ny u h cin e e o p o e d n s alb c n lsv a dma bee f re i oh rj rs cin b s i r r c e i g h l e o cu ie n y n o c d n t e u idito s y ut ont j he udgmen ori a ot ma rpr de byap ia eLaw. t n ny her nne ovi d plc bl VA TA 26,D oc tN o.1 4. I i undiput d t tt gua an y ag ee e doe notis l c a n a ke 4- t s s e ha he r t r m nt s t e f ont i f um - e e ton cl us nor doe i e e s y r f rt t o i t unde l ng ag e m e . The or s l c i a e, s t xpr s l e e o he ne n he r yi r e nt co t l a hea i on t m oton on M a 28, 4. H a ng be n f l br e e t m a t ri rpe ur he d rng he i y 201 vi e uly i f d, he te s i f r ew . or evi St andard ofR e e vi w Ana r o s mmayj d me t sa p o raetf h mo a ts o ta teei n g n i e wa d f u r u g n i p r p it k t e v n h ws h t h r s o e u n i d s u ea t a ymaeilfc a dtemo a ti e tte t j d me ta amatro lw. Fe R. ip t s o n tra a t n h v n s n ild o u g n s te f a ' d. ' Ci. 5 () l d tn nngwh t e t g a tamo inf rs mma yj d me tt c u t s v e v P. 6 a . n ee uii ch r o rn to o u r u g n ,he o r mu t iw 1 eDea r Cout loe trdj d me t g is Weltt a n sis LLC (rig osis' a oh r Th lwae r as nee u g n a an t lsa Dig otc , ç a n tc', n te ) c pan w h epayment M r W ohltdtrhadguarnt d i t c r ta is On J nuar 21 201 Dignosis om y os s . sa e a ee n he ontac t s ue. a y s 4, a tc wie p y n t Bivei i stsa to o tejdg n.Bivei d e n t e kd ma sfo MrW o ltde wi rd a me to o rs n aifcin f h u me t o rs o s o se a ge r m . hsa tr t h r pe tt D i es c o agnos i . tcs 3 t r or i t lghtm os f vor et t nonhe ec d n he i t a abl o he mova .Ande s v.Li ry LobbysI . 477 U. nt r on be t nc, S. 2 2 2 5( 98 ) Towih tndas mmayj d me t to t en n mo n mu tp o u e 4 , 5 1 6. t sa u r u g n mo in,h o - va t s r d c s tce e de efom whiharas bl gac fnder c drt navediti hi fvor I a ufi int vi nc r c e ona e f t i l oul eur r c n s a . d. t 249 -50. tconc us y o s ul tve a l ga i do nots fce nordoesa d e e s ntla of û l or r pec a i le tons uf i , m r ci il e de i s r of(henon- nts c s ' Thomps v. oma El .Powe Co.31 F.d vi nce'n uppo t t mova 'l a e. ' on Pot c ec r , 2 3 645,649( hCi.2002)( i Philnsv.CSX Trns sl ,1 F.d 285,287(t Ci.1 ) 4t r quotng li a p. nc. 90 3 4h r 999). D i si scus on Bi rsmove f s ove i s or ummayj me ba e onM r W ohltdt ' undiputdf l et r udg nt s d . sa ers s e aiur o pa t a ounto d t Bi rsbyVac i sa r quiedbyt e e st r soft gua a y y he m we o ove i c ne s e r he xpr s e m he r nt agr e e . M r W o s ad e oppos t m oton on t s e bas st tt f m - e e ton cl us i e m nt . hl t t r es he i he ol i ha he onl s l c i a en t unde l ng V a i s A s e Tr ns e A gr e e r quiest pl ntf t s i D e a a e r t r he r yi cc ne s t a f r e m nt e r he ai i f o ue n l w r a he t a i ti c u t Th d fn a t loc ne t t panifsr q s f rp eu g n itr s.Th h n n h s o r. e ee d n as o tss he litf e uet o rj d me tn ee t e c tw ila es ea h i s i t n. our l ddr s c s ue n ur For - l c i Cl e um se e t on aus The de e f ndantco c t tt f um - e e ton c a e i t unde l ng agr e e r quies nt nds ha he or s l c i l us n he r yi e m nt e r t sltga i t pr e d,i a al i Deawar . I t a e e ofa s h clus i i ce t t hi ii ton o oc e f t l, n l e n he bs nc ny uc a e, t s lar ha ve i pr ri t sco tsnc M r W ohlt d e i ar i ntofM a s Cot y, r ni nue s ope n hi ur i e . sa t r s esde dion mt Vigi a, wihi t sditita di son.Compl!7.Ans r!7,s e28U. C.jl ( ( )(1 ci l t n hi src nd vii . , we ' e S. 391b)1 ( vi A a to ma beb o g ti . . u iildsrc i whc a yd f n a t e ie ,fa1d fn a t ae ci n y r u h n . aj dca itit n ih n ee d n r sd s i l ee d n s r r sde soft Stt i whiht dititi l ae ' ;At.M ai Consr Co. U. Dit Cour e i nt he ae n c he src s oc td.l l rne ' t. v. S. s. t f t W . s. Tex. 1 S.Ct 568,578( 3 Civjnuei pr rs l a t r rme s or he Dit of , 34 . 201 ) g e s ope o ong s he equie nt ofj 1 ( aeme,ir peci ofa f u s l toncaus ' .Howe r ûg he t pa te 391b) r t res tve ny orm-eeci l e.' ) ve ,swj n he ris ha a ee t a va i f um - e e ton cl us ,a dit i tc ts d or narl t a f rt c e t ve gr d o ld or s l c i a e s rc our houl di iy r ns e he as o t f um s cii d i t tcl us ' At . a i Cons r Co. 1 S.Ct a 581. l i undiput d t t he or pe f e n ha a e. l M rne ' t . , 34 .t ts s e ha 4 t g r nt agr em e doesnotis l c ai a f m - el c i cl us nordoesi e es l r f he ua a y e nt t e f ont n onz s e ton a e, t xpr s y e er t t one i t unde l ng V a ci A s e Tr ns e A gr em e . Ra he ,M r W o s a e a gues o he n he ryi c nes s t a f r e nt t r . hlt dt r r t tt gua a y i plc ty i por t st f um - el c i cl us expr s d i Sec i 1 5 oft ha he r nt m i il ncor a e he or s e ton a e es e n ton 0. he underyi a e m e . l ng gr e nt Se r lf de a co t ha c i r whe he a g r nt a ee ve a e r l urs ve onsde ed t r ua a y gr ments d bei e pr t houl ntr eed t i l a f um - el c i c a e expr s e onl i t underyi agr em e esa i hi t o nc ude or s e ton l us e s d y n he l ng e nt t bls ng he gua a e oblgato The f t sr i upo by o he cours i m aki t tde e m i ton i o r nt ed i i n. ac or eled n t r t n ng ha t r na i nf nn ' s on n he ns a as 2 t i e a t s ven ont oli ght t courtsdeci i i t i t ntc e. A lhough no s ngl f c ori gi c r lng w ei , he cou t r l hea l on t l ngua oft a ee en s W he et guar nt e es l sa e t tt r s e y viy he a ge he gr m t . r he a y xpr sy t t s ha he g a o ' oblga i a e i pe ntoft oblga i de c i i t unde l ng ag e m e , uar nt r s i tons r nde nde he i tons s rbed n he ryi r e nt c t ha de lned t i or r t t f r - e e ton c a e. Se e. ,Pi r Co m e c a ours ve c i o nc po a e he o um s l c i l us e. g. onee m r i l Fundi Co . No ik.2006W L 335 41,a * ( D. Nov.1 2006)( lni t ng p v. rc 41 t 2 E. Pa. 7, deci ng o i op or t a f um - e e ton cl us e e s i t unde l ng a ee e w he e t g r nt nc a e or s l c i a e xpr s ed n he ryi gr m nt r he ua a y k xpr sy saest tkheoblgai hee raei pe toft oblgai ofghepat t t esl tt ha t e i tons runde r nde nden he i tons t ry o t undel nga e nt.' . he ryi greme j'' ) W he e t gua ant undera t pe f m al oblga i c a ned i t unde l ng r he r or t kes o r or 1 i tons ont i n he r yi ag ee e , ur s ha cons r ed t ag e m en s t t ra i op or t t f u - e ec i n r m nt co t ve t u he r e t oge he nd nc a ed he or m s l to cl us i o t gua a y. Se Am e ir tCo. atlA s ' v.Cha l ,8 F.Su 893,895 a e nt he r nt e rt us N ' sn ns or 03 pp. ( D. . 1 2)(uaa orunc tonalyguarnt dt ( ror nc a obsr nc ofal S. N Y. 99 g rnt ondii l a ee he s f ma e nd e va e 1 pe oblgai ,rpr s nttonsa war nte 'i t undel ngag e me l Ce ur 21Re Esae i tons e e e ai nd ra is'n he ryi r e nt; nt y al tt. 2A fder c tsti i di r iym us a yt f u sae' confitof1w r e . K l e al our i ng n ve st l t ppl he or m tt s lc a uls axon Co. St nt v. e or Elc Mf. .31 U. 48 , 9 -9 (9 ) Un e Vignalw,tth n tr, aii a ditrrtt no c nrcs e . g Co, 3 S. 7 4 6 7 1 41. d r rii a t le au e v l t n nep eai f o ta t g dy o a egov n by t l oft pl ewheem ade unls t con rr a ar t bet e es i e i oft pa tes' r er ed he aw he ac r , e s he ta y ppe s o he xpr s ntnton he ri . ' W o d o v. ln M u . n . ,l 7 S. 2d61 , 3 ( .1 7 ) He e c n r c it r r tto i a is e o s n Cei a t l s Co. 7 E. 0 61 Va 9 0 . r , o ta t n e p eai n s t s u s ciialy,whehe t gua a yagr m e i or aest f um s lc i cl e i Seci 1 5 oft unde l ng pe fc l t r he r nt ee nt nc port he or ee ton aus n ton 0. he ryi Vac ne A setTr nserAgr m e bu net rparyw a a et a s t c ta t hea i ont i tntmoton ci s s a f ee nt t ihe t s bl o dvie he our t he rng he nsa i wher t c r c wasm a Cons que l t cour hass veye r eva f der ca e e he ont a t de. e nty, he t ur d el nt e al s s. LLC v.Gae yReat LLC,2011W L 1 twa ly, 322006,a *5( uarnt explctysae t tt t g a y iil ttd ha he guaa or woul unde tke$ l oblgai ofFrnchie 'unde t fa hiea e nt; rnt s d ra k l i tons a se' r he rnc s greme ) a Hadee' Food Syse .I v.gbal2005W L 2333897,a *1( D.Mo.Sept22,2005 r s tms nc. l , t E. . ) ( r nt ska e dlpes l t beboundbye ha e r pr soni 'heunde l ng gua a or ûgreg ronaly o ac nd vey ovii n't ryi a e me i t lmiai '.Si lry,wheet guaa ya e me i af m conrc,c t gre ntd hout i tton' mial wi ) r he rnt gr e nt s or ta t ours ha i ve mpore tnnsfom t unde l ng ag e m e , whe t g r nt a ee tc ans td e r he ryi r e nt but n he ua a y gr men ont i ne i t t r s t g a y i m or lke y t s a o is own. Com pa e Am e ir s ,8 F. gota ed e m , he uar nt s e i l o t nd n t r rt u t 03 Su a 896(nc portngf um-eeci caus whe etheg uarnt i af m doc nt' pp. t i or ai or s l ton l e r s gj a ee s or t ume ' whiet undel nga ee nt i r s ii lyprpa e f t ta aci i quesi ',wih l he ryi gr me s l e pecfcal e r d or he rns ton n we ton.' t ) Pi r 2006W L 33541 ,a *2(i ngt g a yt beaspaaewrte ag e me whe e onee, 41 t fndi he uarnt o e rt itn r e nt r t guaant tc ai manyne itdtr '. he r y iont ns gotae ems' ) Co t ha al o c i e t i ntt oft pa test e ch a ee e . Se A m e ir t ur s ve s onsder d he de iy he r i o a gr m nt e rtus , 803F. Supp. t896(xpli ngt ti r t ormor wrte i tume sbewee t s me a e ani ha s e wo whe e itn nsr nt t n he a pate c er ngt s mes j c matraecone r ne l e c e t ywilber da ris onc ni he a ub e t te r tmpo a ousy xe utd,he l ea nd i er ee t t r' (mpha i a dl s ealo Pine r 2006W L 33541 at* ( clni t nt prtd ogehe') e ss dde ; e s o e, 41, 2 de i ng o i r r t af um-elcin ca ee e s donl i t unde l nga ee ntwheeûghe ncopo ae or s e to lus xprs e y n he ryi gr me r it g aa t r i n tap ryt t egn e lig a r e n , bu rt e $ s p rt m itn a re n u r no j s o a t o h u d ryn j g e me t' t ah r t e aae te g e me t ' a e ssg r ngt rltons pbewe n gheguaa ora guaa ee' . xit oveni he eai hi t e t rnt nd r nt l' ) O t c i r tonsi l whe he t gua a y agr e e t e er t t c r tw hos her ons de a i nc ude t r he r nt e m nt d f s o he ontac r e per o m a i gua a ee ' A m e ir t 803 F.Supp. t896,a t pr m iy w ih w hi h t f r nce s r nt d, ' rt us , a nd he oxi t t c he guar y and underl ng agr entw ere si ant yi eem gned. See.e. ,Cent y 21,2011 W L 1322006,at*5 :. ur (onsr ngt t ragee nt e ut o t smedae;Ameinzt 803F.Supp.a 8 c tui ogehe r me s xec ed n he a t) rt s. t 96 (onsr ngt t rdocume st twer t c e t he') Pi r 2006W L 33541 ,a *2 c tui ogehe nt ha e t utd oget r'; onee, exe 41 t ( ci ngt c tuet ehe doc nt t twe ene itdfvemont apa t. de lni o onsr og t r ume s ha r gotae i hs r) 6 Afe we g ng t r e ntf c or i c e wih t f t oft i t tca e,t c ti tr i hi he elva a t s n ont xt t he ac s he nsan s he our s c nc d t tt gua a y ag e m e bewe n Bi rsa M r W ohlt t ri s c ptbl of onvi e ha he r nt r e nt t e ove i nd . sad e s us e i e onl oneras bl i eprtton, t ts y e ona e ntr eai and ha ummayj r udgmen i t pli ifsfvori t n he antf a s a o it Se l r Fara M e ca Ce e Asocitsl,1 F. 698,a *4(t Ci.Se . ppr prae. e n e ifx di l ntr s ae 1 21 3d t 4h r pt 2, 1 ( 997) unpubls dtbl de son)(xpli ngt tdipostonofamatrons ihe a e cii e ani ha s ii te ummayj me i r udg nt s i ppr praewhe aconr ti s c ptbl oft ras bl i epr ttons.Alho ht na o it n tac s us e i e wo e ona e ntr eai ) t ug he a e me sbe rt s medaea dglfrnc i ma 'i t guaa yagee ntt t Vac i gre nt a he a t nd sreee e s de'n he rnt r me o he cnes A s e Tr ns e A gr em en ,G ua a y A g e m e 1, oc tN o.1 5,t r m a ni c r um s a s s t a fr e t r nt r e nt D ke 4- he e i ng ic t nce cl a l e t i h t tt gua a y a e m e ti a r a e buti pe nt s a a one c r c , e r y s abls ha he r nt gr e n s el t d, nde nde , t nd- l ont a t s h t tt f m - el c i n c a e i t a s tt a f r a ee e doe note e t t gua a y uc ha he onz s e t o l us n he s e r ns e gr m nt s xt nd o he r nt agreem ent . He e t c r c lnguagei c t t tt a s tta f ra e nta g r nt a e r , he onta t a ndi a es ha he s e r nse gr eme nd ua a y r s pa a e a ee e s The unde l ng a ee e be w e Bi e i and Vac ne c i t oft e r t gr m nt . ryi gr m nt t en ov r s ci s ons s s he t a ci A s e Tr ns e A g ee e , oge he wih al a xe ,e bis s hedul a ot r ' c nes s t a f r r m nt t t r t l nne s xhi t , c V es nd he doc nt atche gheet ' Va i Ase Trnse Agr me 1 Doc tNo.1 4.The ume s ta d t rlo.' ccnes st a fr ee nt , ke 4gua a y ag ee e i neihe at c d norot r s me i r nt r m nt s t r ta he he wie ntoned. Asi Pi ne r whe et f r m n o e , r he o u s l ton c a ei t underyi a e ntdi note e t t g r nt a e nt t g r nt eec i l us n he l ng gr eme d xtnd o he ua a y gr eme , he ua a y agee nta is e e sysaest tSll oblg tonsoft undesg unde ori r s c of r me t sue xpr s l tt ha tthe iai he rined r n e pe t t s guar ee ar i hi ant e ndependentoft guarant oblgatons.' Guarant A gr ent D ocketN o. he eed i i ' y eem , 1 5. A ddii l t guar nt a e m e s ii a l pr dest t$ s pa a e a ton orac i 4tonaly, he a y gr e nt pec f c ly ovi ha t e r t c i a tons m a be br y oughta pr ec e a ns t t r i d t e or t sguar nt e ..., Gua a y nd os ut d gai t he mde sgne o nf ce hi a e ' ' r nt A g ee e ,D oc tN o.1 1 w ihoutlm ii w he e s h a a ton m a be br ht r m nt ke -, t i tng r uc n c i y oug . The desclpton ofM r.W ohlt er' oblga i undert guar y agr ental o i i s adt s i t ons he ant eem s sugges st t guar y and ass t ans er agr ent ar s at U nlke C ent y 21, t hat he ant et r f eem s e epar e. i ur 7 Am e ir t a H a de s w he e e c g r nt r a e d t be bound by e r t r oft unde l ng rt us , nd r e' , r a h ua a o gr e o ve y e m he r yi a e ent M r W ohl t dt r s o i ton i e e s y lm ie t m a ng t pos - l i pay e s gr em , . s a e ' blga i s xpr s l i t d o ki he t c os ng m nt ow e t Bi e i by V a i s a D i gnos i s u rSe ton 2. oft i r s c i a s tt a f r d o ov r s cc ne nd a tc nde c i 5 he r e pe tve s e r ns e agr e e s G ua a y A gr em e 1 Doc t 1 5. U nlke t f contac i Am e ir t t e m nt . r nt e nt , ke 4i he onu r tn rt us , he g r nt a ee e i s cii aly t ior d t t t a a ton be w e n Bi e i a M r ua a y gr m nt s pe tc l a l e o he r ns c i t e ov rs nd . W ohl t dt ,a i c a nss ve alnego i t d t r s s a er nd t ont i e r ta e e m . Furhe ,a t ug M r W ohl t t rs g t as e t a f r a e m e i hi ca c t as t r lho h . sad e i ned he s t r ns e gr e nt n s pa iy c e e utveofi e ofVac i s hei notapa t t t ta ee nt Ra he , s pa a egua ant hif xec i fc r cne , s ry o ha gr me . t r a e r t r y ag e me lgovenglt rltons p'bewee Bi rsandMr W ohlt e .Pi e ,2006W L r e nti r s he eai hi ' t n ovei . sadtr one r 33541 ,a *2.By ise e st nns t f um- eec i caus i t Va i As e Tr f r 41 t t xpr s e , he or s l ton l e n he ccnes s t ans e Agr m en onl a i s t di put s be w ee Bi e i a V ac i s VA TA 26, oc tN o.1 4 ee t y pple o s e t n ov r s nd c ne . D ke 4- (i' c e st j iditons f t i t spa a a ... halnotbede me t c e rght on ll ons nt o urs ci et orh n hi z grph s l -he e d o onfr i s a Pes ot rt nt pa teshert ') ny ron he ha he ri eo. . ' Fi l t r i an a tonala ve y pe s s ve f t i t i t ntc e t ti not naly, he e s ddii nd r r ua i ac or n he ns a as ha s m e i d i any o he cas s ve by t c t ntone n t r e ur yed he our .The gua an y ag ee e w asdr f e a r t r m nt a t d nd exe ut d w ih t as i t e of s s i a e cot s on bot s de - t s m e co e w ho c e t he s sanc ophi tc t d m el h i s he a uns l pr pa edt Vac i sA s e Tr ns e Agr eme .l t pa tesit nde t i l af um e r he cne s t a f r e nt f he ri n e d o ncude or s e ton cl us i t g r nt ag e en ,c el c i a e n he ua a y r em t ouns c ea l knew how t dr f l nguage t t t el l ry o a ta o ha e f c . Fora 1oft e r as ,t c t fe t 1 hes e ons he our conc ude t tt gua a y a e m e doe noti por t l s ha he r nt gr e nt s m t he f um - el c i cl us f om t unde l ng a s ttans era ee e . or s e ton a e r he ryi s e r f gr m nt Si e t f um - e e ton cl us i Sec i 1 5 oft V ac i s A s e Tr ns e A gr m e nc he or s l c i a e n ton 0. he c ne s t a f r ee nt doesnote e t t gua a y a e m e , he de e nt spr dur lde ens m us f l M r xt nd o he r nt gr e nt t f nda ' oce a f e t ai. . W ohl t t rha no of e e i m i i ora t hea i on t i t ntm o i n,a s t ntve sad e s t f r d, n tng t he rng he ns a t o ny ubs a i def ense t t pl ntf s alegat ons. Ther i no genui diput ast any m at i f ,and M r. o he ai if l i es ne s e o eral act 8 W ohlt t rhaspr de noevi nc fom whi h ar s bl f c fnderc dconcl t the sad e ovi d de e r c ea ona e a t i oul udc ha di notbr a h t t nnsoft gua an y ag e m e . A nde s 477 U . a 249-50. A cc di y, d e c he e he r t r e nt r on, S. t or ngl teplitf smo inf rs mmayj d me t s b g a td. h anif to o u r u g n mu t e rn e II . C al aton ofI erest cul i nt Ha ng f vi ound i f voroft pli ifi t sma tr i bec e nec s r t de e mi t n a he antf n hi te , t om s es a y o t r ne he p o e rt of rj dg n itrs,fa y t whc Bive i i e tte t h t e p eu g n r p r ae p eu me t ne e ti n ,o ih o rs s n ild.i eh r rj d me t W i e es s d bea a de ... samat rwihi t s nt r t houl w r d i te t n he ound dic e i oft diti tcour. Hia hi s r ton he src t' t c ' Cr di Am.Cop.v.Si tBa 1 F. 61 633( h Ci.1 . et cne nk, 66 3d 4, 4t r 999) S r ni lw govenst a r ofprj s gi a a vi r he wad eudgme i ee ti adi st ca e. Sine Ba nt ntrs n veriy s ' g t nk, ' 1 F. a 633.Unde Vigi alw,lina ... to a lw o s ti e t ...t fna or r 66 3d t r r ni a igj ny acin t a r ui n quiy he i l de . . . ma pr def i e e ton a prnci lsun awa de ora pa tt r of a fx t pe i a y ovi or ntr s ny i pa t r d, ny r he e , nd i he rod t whiht eitr s s al o n e' Va Co ej8013 2.(l ea r o p eu g n itr s i c h n ee t h lc mme c . . d . - 8 t- wad f rj d me t n ee t s ' -h t eo pe a e Pl i t f f t l s s t i d by notr e vi t a ountt w hi h he w ase il d o m ns t a n i f or he os us a ne ec i ng he m o c ntte a t tm e he w ase il d t r c ve i,a s h a a d i c i e nec s r t pl ce t t he i ntte o e ei t nd uc w r s onsder d es a y o a he g antfji t postonhewoul ha occ edi t pa t i dea tha f tledhi oblg e pli if n he ii d ve upi f he ry n ful d ulil s iatd dut ' M aksv. nz 3 S. 2d263,267( .1 ( i Empl rTe msesJ nt y.' r Sa o, 45 E. Va 986) quotng oye - a tr oi C o i N o.8 H eat & W e f r Fund v. e t r l Conc e es nc ,468 F.Supp.11 11 unc l 4- 1h la e W a he a l rt l . 67, 71 ( D. . 1 ) tft c r c ...doe notfx a i ers rt,t c ts l a yt S. W Va. 979). d he onta t l s i n nt e t ae he our hal ppl he j d me trt o sxp re tt c lult p eu g n itrs p ru n t j8013 2 . .' Va u g n ae f i e c n o ac ae rj d me t n ee t u s a t o . - 8 . . . ' Codej6. 30 B) 2- 2( . Unde t fcsoft sca e a a r ofprj r he a t hi s , n wad eudgme i ers i a o it Thepl ntf nt nt e t s ppr prae. ai if wa e il d t r e ve$2, 000 fo et rVa i orM r W ohlt dt ron J 26, 0.An s ntte o ec i 759, r m ihe ccnes . sa e une 201 a r ofprj me i ers i nec s r t plc Bi rsi t postoni woul ha oc upid wad eudg nt nt e t s esay o a e ovei n he ii t d ve c e i M r W ohl t dt rhad f t led hi oblg i unde t g r nt a e en . Se M a ks 345 f . sa e uli l s i aton r he ua a y gr em t e r , 9 S. 2d a 267. Be us t r i no i e e tr t s tf t i t gua a y ag e m e , he pl i ifw il E. t ca e he e s nt r s a e e or h n he r nt r e nt t a ntf l bea r dprj me i ers a t r t ofsxpec ntfom J 26,201 untlt daeofe r wade eudg nt nt e t t he ae i re r une 0 i he t nty o fn l u g n .Thep an ifi as e tte t po tj d me titr s a t ert s tf rhi 28 f ia j d me t litf s lo nild o s-u g n n ee t t h ae e o t n U. . .j1961 SC . C oncl on usi Fo ter a o ssae ,h c u t lg a t h plitf smo ina e tr u g n i fv r r h e s n ttd te o r wil rn t e an if to nd ne j d me tn a o o Bivei Co p rto i t ea u t f$ 75 0 0 plsp eu g n i tr s a t ert o sx f o rs r o ai n n h mo n o 2, 9,0 , u rj d me t nee t t h ae f i p re ta dp t u g n itr s a t ert s t o t i 2 U. C. 1 61 Th plitf sp n i g e c n n os- d me tn ee t t h ae e f rh n 8 S. j 9 . e an if e d n j m oton f l a t a ara t i lw ihoutl alc i or e ve o ppe t r a t oc ouns lw ilbe di m i s d a m oot a t ac i e l s se s , nd he ton w ilbe s rc n f om t a tve doc toft c t l t i ke r he c i ke he our . The Clr i die t d t s c rii d c esoft smemor nd opi on a t e k s r c e o end e tte opi hi a um ni nd he a com pa ng or rt a lc c nyi de o 1 ouns lofr co d. e e r ENTER:Thi l1 s da ofJ 201 y une, 4. Chi Unie St esD i ti tJ ef t d at s r c udge 10

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?