Siquic et al v. Star Forestry, LLC et al
Filing
64
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/22/16. (jcj)
CL
i
ERKS OFFI U. , DI COuR7
CE S ST,
ATRG NOKE,
VA
FL D
Iq
I THE UNI S
N
TED TATES DI TRI COURT
S CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STW CT OF VI GI I
R NA
CHA RLO TTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI
APR 2 2 2 1
25
J
ULI
BY; A c.
clsax
-
'
DE
L K
:
CARLOSHUM BERTO CAB SI C,e a1,
QUI t .
!
Ci lA c i N o.3: 3CV 00043
vi ton
1
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
M EM O R A NDUM omxl
ok
-
I
By:H on. G l n E.Com 'd
e
a
i
ChifUniedSttsDititJ
e t ae src udge
STAR FO RESTR Y,LLC,e a1,
t .
I
D e e nt .
f nda s
1
Pli if Ca l Humbe t Ca Si ca Sa igo Ya lCuz fl d t saci n on
antfs ros
ro b qui nd nta
xca
ie hi to
be l oft m s vesa a1o he ssmia l st t d a ns de e nt StrFor ty,LLC,
ha f he el nd 1 t r i lry iua e gai t f nda s a
esr
I pe ntLa Se vies LLC,W iiePi Re or t to LLC,Amy Spe r - m as a
nde nde
bor r c ,
lt ne f esai n,
a sTho , nd
De n Spe r vi
a s Thom a f vi ai nsoft M i a a Se ona Agrc t a W or rPr eci n
s or ol to
he gr nt nd as l i ulur l
ke ot to
Ac (t
t(
AWPA', 9U. C. j1 01e sc.a teFarLa o Sa ad Ac (TLS ' 19
' 2 S. j 8 t el nd h i b r tnd rs tç A',
)
,
)
U. C.j201e s Thi matri c r nl befr t c tonpli if'motonf akâ d
S.
t eu. s te s ure ty o e he our
antfs i or t war
ofa t e sf esa ltga i e ns . f nda sa e c r nty i de a ta havenot
tom y' e nd ii ton xpe es De e nt r ure l n f ul nd
rs n e t plitfs mo in. rt er a o ss tfrhb lw,hemo inwil eg a J
epo d d o an if ' to Fo h e s n e o t eo t
to l b ' ktd.
r
B ac ound
kzr
r
Pl
)
antfsa em i a a i ulm a wor r fom Gua e awho we e a te t t
i if r gr nt grc t l ke s r
t mal
r dmitd oi
he
.
!
UntdSae t e teH-Btmpoayvs p o rf t wokfrdee d ns te - a tn
ie ttsmd r h 2 e rr ia r gan o r o fn a t'replnlg
I
c
ompanis On Oc obe 21 2013, antfsfl d ac a sa ton c
e.
t r ,
pli if ie l s c i ompl i a ns defndM t f
ant gai t e
s or
vi a i oft AW PA a FLSA.Spe ii a l pl i if al ge t t i e ai ,de e nt
oltons he
nd
cfc ly, antfs le d ha , ntr la f nda s
!
fie t ( ) ymi ml a do e t wa e ; 2 p o i ep yd ume tto ;()p y wa e
ald o: 1 pa ni l n v ri
m
me g s ( ) r v d a oc n ain 3 a g s
i atmeyma n r ()p o i etr a dc ndto so e ly n ; n ()ri l s ta e
n i l n e; 4 r v d ems n o ii n f mp o me t a d 5 embz e rv l
r
'
a dv s e pe s st a weei u rdf rt ed fnd ns b n t . fnd n sf i dt fl a y
n ia x n e h t r nc re o h ee a t' e ei De e a t al o ie y
t
e
?
r s nsvepladi ,a t c e k e e e de a ta i tt m on M a c 1 201 Pl i if
e po i e ngs nd he l r nt r d f ul ga ns he
r h 2, 4. antfs
,
?
t n fl d am oto f rl a t t kedico r on M a 1 201 wlih t cou tgr nt d. I
he ie
i n o e ve o a
s ve y
y , 4, lc he r a e On
I
Augus 19 201 pl i if de e Amy Spe r - m ason be fofhe s fa StrFor ty.
t , 4, antfs pos d
a sTho
hal
r el nd a
esr
Neihe St rFo esr norAmy Spe r - m a pr uc d doc e si r s
t r a r ty
a sTho s od e
um nt n e pons t pl i if
e o antfs'
di c r r quess
s ove y e t .
!
On J 1 201 ,pl i if fl amoton t ce tf t i pr pos d c a sa c l c i
une , 5 antfs ied
i o riy he r o e l s nd ole sve
a to Th tsmed y plitfsfldamoin frd fut u g n s e n a ta a d
cin. a n a , anif ie
to o ea lj d me t e kig cu l n
lqui t d da a unde t FLSA,a m a a sa u or da
i da e m ges
r he
c l nd t t t y mage unde t AW PA,a tm e s
s
r he
to y'
fe a dc ssa dijmcierl f OnOco e 1 , 01 ,hec u t' ne pli if' jo t
e s n ot, n nt tv ei
e
tb r 0 2 5 t o rg a td ant s mo n o
r
f
c riyt eca sa dto t emoinf rd fulj d me t nd ra v s me tp ndn n tc t
e t h ls n o k h to o e a t u g n u e d ie n e ig oie o
f
pot talFLSA opti cls m e r .On M a c 1 201 t cour gr nt d pl i if , moton
en i
-n a s mbe s
r h 7, 5, he
t a e antfs ; i
f rd fulj d me tb td lye e tyof fn lu g n a an t ee a t t i a trAp i 4
o e a t u g n u ea d nr a i a j d me t g is d fnd n s mtl fe rl ,
201 s a t alow c a sm e r t o outoft cls a ton a pli if 'c
6, o s o l l s mbe s o pt
he a s c i nd antfs ouns lt fl
e q ie
l
'
t rf epeii n.l i t c rtsunde sa pg t tno c a sm e
hei e tto t s he ou '
r tndi ha
l s mber ha opt d outoft e
s ve e
h
.
ca sacin.Pu s ntt Loc lRul 5 pli if fldt i moto f a a dofat e s
ls to rua o a e 4, antfs e her in or n war
tonjy'
.
l
f esa c t o Aprl7,2016, eque tngf e i t n mtof$1 31 00 a e nl si
e nd oss n i
r si e s n he mot
37, 3. nd xpe e n
?
t n
he mountof$5, 61 A sdefnda sa ei def ul, hem o i i no rpef diposton.
884. .
e nt r n a t t
ton s w i or s ii
;
!
D i cus i
s s on
1.
A t orne s Fees
t v'
E
i
unde t s ca ld Ame ia r e t pa test cvi ltga i or na iybe rt i
r he o- le
rc n ul, he ri o i l ii ton di rl a her
!
0Wnato
tmey' f e a coss unls t r i e plctsautr a hort t t co rr i
s e s nd t, e s hee s x ii tt o y ut iy o he ntay.
'
:
Hu l . l, 61 - 0 0 2, 2W L4 8 5 a *1( . Va J l 1 , 01 )(ing
mme v HalNo. :1CV-0 1 201
45 4 0,t W D. . uy 8 2 i ct
i
2
1
I
Bucc nnon Bd. Ca eHom e I v. . De tofHe 1h & Hlm a Re . 532 U. 598,
lha
& r
. nc. W Va. p'
at
l n s,
S.
I
6 2( 0 ). eFLS c n an s ha e e to b pr vdngt a t ec u tth l,n a dto
0 2 01) Th
A o tis uc n xc pi n y o ii h t h o r ç ali d iin
s
:
I
t a yj g n a r e t te .. an if, lo ara o a l atr e sf et b padb t e
o n ud me t wad d o h . plitfs alw e s n b e to n y' e o : i y h
d fn a t a dc sso t ea to ,'t p e iigpanif . 9U. C. 21 ( ) seas
ee d n , n o t f h cinlj'o rvaln litfs 2 . S. j 6 b ; e lo
Bu nlyv. ho t7 0F.d 1 6 1 ( t Ci.1 8 )(çh pa me t fa tm e ' f e t
r e S r, 3 2 3 , 41 4h r 9 4 çf e y n o to y s e s o
emplyee pr valngi FLSA ca e i man or ' . a et c tgrntdpl ntfs
o s e ii n
s s s dat y.' Bec us he our a e ai if'
)
moinfrd futu g n,he aee tidt ri usme tfratre sfe a dc ' .
to o ea lj d me tt y r nie o emb re n o ton y' e s n oss
t
t
Then o ofa t ne sf si wili t c tss
m unt tor y' ee s tln he our' ound dic e i Bt nl y,730 F. a 1 .
s r ton. u- e
2d t 41
Topr pe l ca c a ear a ona ef e a r t c tmus de e net a opiae
o ry l ult e s bl e wa d, he our
t t nni he ppr it
ld sa fgle M c e v. c a , 38F.d81 8 ( t Ci. 01 ) Th sfglei c lu ae b
o e tr it . Afe Bo z r 7 3 , 8 4h r 2 3 . i i t s ac ltd y
r
r
mulpligt n mb ro holsr a o a l e pe d db ar a o a l h u l r t.Jz TJ
t yn he u e f t e s n by x n e y e s n b e o ry ae # .
i
r
l
a c ra nwha i r s na e i t m sofhou se nde a r t c r d, heco tc i r
s e ti
t s ea o bl n er
r xpe d nd aes ha ge t
ur onsde s
tet l f co ss tf rhi J l o v. o caHih yEx rs .nc, 8F.d71 ( t Ci.
h weve a tr e o t n oms n Ge r i R wa p e s l .48 2 4 5h r
'
.
1 7 )(heG o n o f co s).J= s eas Ro n o v Eq ia I f . r s.
9 4 t ç h s n a tr' # . e lo bis n . u fx n o Se v .LLC, 6 F.d
l
;
50 3
2 5 2 3( t Ci. 0 9 (ç d cdngwh tc n tttsale s n b e nl e o h u sa' rts
3 , 4 4h r 2 0 ) Gn e ii
I
a o siu e r a o a l ' l r f o r n ae ,
mb
d
weh v isnztdt tadsrc c u tsd sr to s o l beg ie byt e(o ns n fco s'.
a e n t ce ha itit o r' ic ein h u d ud d h J h o ) a t r.
)
Thos f c pr a e a f l s
e a t s r s olow :
( )Th tmea d lbo e p n e ()t en v ly a d dfiut o
1 e i n a r x e d d; 2 h o et n ifc ly f
te q eto r ie ;( )t s l r q ie t p o ry p ro m t
h u sins as d 3 he ki e urd o r pel e fr he
l
lg l st c s rnd rd'( ) $ e atr e ' o po tnt c ss i
e a ewie e ee , 4 h to n ys p ru iy o t n
p e sn t ei tn l iain;()t c t ma yf ef rl ewo k
rs ig h nsa t i g to 5 he uso r e o i
t
k r;
( t at ne se pe tto a t o sto t ltgai ( t
6) he tor y' x cains t he ute f he ii ton; 7) he
t l tto s i o e b t cin o crt tnc s ()t e
i i ain mp s d y he le t r icl a e ; 8 h
me mi
ms
n u ti c nr ves a d ters lso ti d ( )t e peinc ,
mo n n o to ry n h e ut b ane ; 9 he x re e
rp tto a da l yo t eatr e ( 0 t u d sr blt o t e
e uain, n bit f h to n y; 1 ) he n e ia ii f h
i
y
c s wihn t elg lc mmu iy i whc te s tao e ( 1 t e
a e t i h e a o nt n ih h ui r s ; 1 ) h
na e a lngt oft pr e sona r l tons p bewe n a t ne
mr nd e h he of s i l e ai hi t e tor y
a dint a (2)atr ys f e a r i smiarc es
nd le ; nd 1 tone ' e s wads n i l as .
3
I
M c e , 3 F.d a 8 n. Ov r l t c u t s b c nvn e t a t eS u e o ho qf r
Afe 7 8 3 t 8 5. eal he o r mu t e o ic d h t h t mb r f ur o
,
n
J
whih .. embtre nti (o hti)ras bl a doe no i l hour t ta ee s1ve
c .r i zsme s srug s e ona e nd s t ncude s ha r xce k ,
i
r dundant orot rwiel ce s r 'Tr vi v.Prme Le ng, 3: v00065,2008W L
e
,
he s mne s a y.' a s
i
ndi No. 07c
2
i
:
,
39 3 , t* ( . Va J n 1 , 08 .
73 0 a 4 W D. . u e 2 20 )
I teisa tc s, anif se ri u sme t o atr ysfe i tea t J
n h n tn ae plit s ek emb re n fr tone ' es n h momt f
f
$1 31 00. sfgtr c ve s436ho sofwor whih wa bil a hotryr t r ngi
37, 3. Thi i le o r
ur
k, c s led t zl aes a ng
1
fom $200t $450pe hotr Appl ng t r lva J on f c o s t cj tsndst tt
'
r
o
r t. yi he ee nt ohns a t r , he tur
ha h:
r quese a t e sf sa er s na e.
e t d tom y' ee r ea o bl
I
!
nsp ro t iferq etplitfss b td ti drc rsd c me tr tetme
u pot fher e e u s, anif u mi eal eod o u ni h j
e
k
i
a dlb re p ns di ti c s , swela d caain fo M ayBa rfo t eLe a éi
n a o x e e n h s a e a l s e lrto s rm r ue r m h g l d
J tc Ce e a R. Ant
usie ntr nd
Ii
hony Lo zfom Co ngt & Buri LLP.I a e r i eofbilng
pe r
vi on
lng
n n xe c s
l
v
I
1
ds rto , o ms l e ve l n c sa yho r fo t erbi igrp rsm1 teho r s e to
icein c t e rmo d l e e s r u s r m h i l n e o t 1 h u s p n n
n
l
1
pl ntf s cl i s t de t AW PA , hi h, m lke t FLSA ,doe no c a n a f e s f i
ai i f ' a m m r he
w c t i he
s t ont i e - hi tng
pr son.Co ela s r pr s ntt tt e g a t ne whowor d ont c s coo di t d
ovii
uns lo e e e ha he i ht tor ys
ke
he a e r na e
t re f t t a d duplc tvewor Alhough t t alnumbe ofhotr bil d i t sa ton
hei fors o voi
ia i
k. t
he ot
r
ls le n hi c i
a ar t behi h gi n t tde e nt ar i def ul,t c ta e swih c ms lt ttls
ppe s o
g ve ha f nda s e n a t he our gr e t ot e ha li
'
c ew a co 1x f rantmbe ofr as ,i l ng t l to oft esi aed 200 cas
as s mp e o
l r e ons nc udi he ocai n he tm t
ls
p
me be si Gua e al,t lng geba e be we n com s a t c a sm e r , hetm e
m r n
tm a he a ua
ni r t e t el nd he l s mbe s t i
i
c ta nt on c a sm e r 'abiiy t s ak wih cou e ,a t l k ofe oym e r or
onsr i s
l s mbe s lt o pe
t
ns l nd he ac
mpl
nt ec ds
7
i de enda s pos e son.SeeVilne Gonza e v. ana rFa ms I , 2: CV- ,
n f nt ' s s i
la uval z Gr i e r . nc.No. 09- 716
;
2 1W L 5 3 7 a * ( . Fl. . , 01 )( rni gplitfs f ep tto a dfndn
01
8 46 7, t 3 M D. a Aug 9 2 1 g a tn anif ' e ei n n 1i ig
i
t
h
l
a çgjt
t talhoughge r ly a FLSA c s i notc e i t i t ca e t ea enp ry 1
ne al n
a e s omplx,n he nsant s ,her r al 00
'
pl ntfs wholvei M e c a a eno s siae ltga s'. s h,c e hajs nt
ai if,
i n xio nd r t ophitc td ii nt' As uc ouns l pe
)
!
4
c n iea etmesn etefl go t c mpliti Oco ro 2 3itriwigcas j
o sd rbl i ic h ii fhe o an n tbe f 01 neve n ls
n
1
me be s de i de e nt , nd c l ultng dn es Thi c i r bl tm ee ndiur
m r , posng f nda s a a c ai
mag . s onsde a e i xpe t le
I
pr cude t a t ne i t sc efom de i t i tm et ot rm a tr .Theca ea s I
e l d he tor ys n hi as r
votng he r i o he te s
s lo;
r quied c ms lt bef m iirwih t H- r gult ys he a wel a t FLSA.The'o t
e r ot e o a la t he 2B e aor c me s l s he
c ur
bei ve t ts h c
le s ha uc omplxii swoul ha m a t sc s undesr bl t ot rfr si t l ga
e te
d ve de hi a e
ia e o he im n he e l
c
omm uniy,whih wasco m e i one l a a t he sde l z ton. naly, ms lsf ùs
t
c
nfr d n
oc l tor y' c a a i Fi l cot e ' e.
j
n
we ec i ntupo pr va lngi tlsaci at
r ontnge
n e ii n li ton, lhough co ms ha s t i ldoubtt t
t el d ubsanta
ha
ï
;
d fn a t wo l h v t ers u c st pa a yj d me t e d r da an tte .
e e d n s ud a e h e o re o y n u g n r n ee g i s h m
Theco ta s fndst tpl i if pr
ur lo i ha antfs oduc d s fce e de et e t ih t
e ufi int vi nc o sabls he
r s na e s oft houry r t bil i t sca e Thef ea i n bea st sbtr n..
ea o blne s he
l aes led n hi s .
e pplca t r hi lde
M c e 738 F. a 91. n ac or nc wih e si pr c nt pl i if s i t
Af e,
3d t I c da e t xitng e ede , antfs ubm t wo
'
,
deca ai nsfom l ale pl e t1w a t ne ,J E. a ds ofDa ds & Kik a
lr to r oc m oym n a tor ys ohn D vi on
vi on
t m nn,
PLC a dTi t yE. ppo S ely Cu p S h l , C. e i (; ee d n eweh v
n moh Cu f h le p c ut P. S e d.G
e
Th vie c
ae
de m e c
e d ompee t s
t nt o how pr va lngm a ke r t i l sa fda t ofo he l allwyer who
e ii
z t aes ncude fi vis t r oc a
s
ar f m ii rbot wih t sclsoft f ea i nt a m or ge r ly wih t t ofwor i
e n la h t he lil he e pplca s nd
e ne al t he ype
kn
t erlv n c mmlnt ' (n en lq tto makso te ) I t erd ca ains M r
h ee a t o li ' itr a uoain r mitd .n h i e lr to , .
y.)
j'
Da ds a M r Cupp i c t t tt y a e f m ii rw ih t l ls r i e pe f r d i t s
vi on nd .
ndia e ha he r n la t he ega e v c s r o me n hi
'
ca e a wela c e' e ai lba kgound,e re e a e rie. de a ains
s , s l s ouns ls duc tona c r
xpeinc , nd xpe ts The cljto
!
c i t tcom s ' holry r t sa er a ona ea c it ntwih t ec r d byl a
onfnn ha t els zl a e r e s bl nd ons se
t hos ha ge
oc l
1
!
a t neysa o he 1 w fl sw ih c pa a e know l dge co pe e y,and e r e
tor
nd t r a im
'
t om r bl
e , m t nc
xpe i nce.
;
)
'
I s ,t c tfndst tt tme e nde a r t sc r d by c
n um he our i ha he i xpe d nd a e ha ge
ouns lwe e
e r
r s na e,a t tt r lva J
ea o bl nd ha he ee nt ohns f c or s
on a t s uppor t a ountca me Acc di y,he
t he m
li d.
or hgl t
co twilg a pl i if 'r que tf a tnwy' f e i t n o of$1 31 00..
ur l r nt antfs e s or to
s e s n he m unt
37, 3.
5
I.
I
Lii t on Expe s
t ea i
nse
I a ton t t a t m e sf spr son i t FLSA, e 5 o t Fe r lRul sof
n ddii o he to y' ee ovii n he
Rul 4 f he de a i
Cii P o e t ep o i e t a Su nls afd r l tmt ,h s r ls o ac u t r e p o i e
vl r c dl r v d s h t ç l e s e ea sa e t e e ue , r o r o d r r v d s
r
l
o he wie, t- he t n a t ne sf s s dbeal d t t pr vaii pa t 'Fe R.
t r s coss -ot r ha tor y' ee - houl
lowe o he e lng ry. d.
'
Ci P. 4 d () Dititc u t h v ds rto i a s sigc ssa an t lsn d f n a ti
v. 5 () 1. src o rs a e icein n se sn o t g is a o ig e e d n n
FLSA c es
as .
Ro v. t . fLe n m S. ,1 F.d5 3 5 9(t Ci'1 9 ) Th s c ss
y Cn y o xido C. 41 3 3 , 4 4h r 9 8 . e e oJ
.
t
ma icu eCe s n bl o to - c e e p ns si ur db t atme wh c aen r ly
y n ld t a o a e u - fpo k t x e e nc re y he to y ih r o mql
r
c r t af e- yi ci nt i t c zs ofpr di l gals r ce . Spelv.M c ni ,852
ha ged o e pa ng le , n he olr e
ovi ng e
e vi s' l
'
Da él
F.d7 2 7 ( t Ci.1 8 ) I teisa tc s , an if s e ri u s me tfrl iain
2 6 , 71 4h r 9 8 . n h n tn a e plitfs e k emb re n o i g tb
t
e ns si t a o of$5, 61 Thes e ns i udeta lng cossf de ii nsand
xpe e n he m unt
884. .
e xpe es ncl r ve i
t or posto
cintmeei ,a we lascon r c wo k wih anon- o i a l a a t ne i Gua e a a The
le
tngs s l
ta t r t
pr ft nd oc l tor y n
t m l'
.
co ttndst tt e ns we er a ona y i ure a t tpl ntfsa ee ild t
ur i ha he xpe es r e s bl nc r d, nd ha ai if r ntte o
r m blr e e f s h cos s
ei z s m nt or uc
t.
C oncl on
usi
Fort f e ngr as , hecour wilgr ntpli if m o i f a t e sf sa
he or goi e ons t
t l a a ntfs' ton or tom y' ee nd
ltg to c ss F n l u g n wi b e trdi fv ro p an if a ans d fnd nsi te
ii ai n o t. i a j d me t l e n ee n a o f litfs g i t ee a t n h
l
a ot of$1,25, 4. whi h c it of$98191 76 i dn a a $1 1 61i
m mt
1 11 37, c ons ss
, 6. n m ges nd 43, 97. n
atr e ' f e a dc ss p u p s-u g n i tr s p ru n t 2 U. C. 1 61
to n y s e s n o t, l s o t d me t ne et u s a t o 8 S. j 9 .
j
The Cl k i die e t s nd c r ii d c e oft s m em or ndum o ni a t
er s r ct d o e e tf e opi s hi
a
pi on nd he
ac om pa ng or rt de e nt a a 1c m s lofr or
c
nyi
de o f nda s nd 1 ot e
ec d.
ENTER:Thi 4 X
s
da ofAprl 2016.
y
i,
Chi fU nie St t s Di ti tJ
e
t d a e s r c udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?