PBM Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Method Pharmaceuticals, LLC et al
Filing
285
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/19/17. (jcj)
ERKsOF I
Dl
s
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STW CT COURT cL 'A FCEuskvmcoue TRFI 6K A .
oN
A
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI UCT OF V I GI I
STI
R N A
LED
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON
J 192 1
UL
27
J J-' (. U
' t, '
! ;
A
jsJ
rf
.
CON CORD I PH A RM A CEU TI LS,
A
CA
I C.
N ,
'
.
,
C
'
Ci lA c i N o.3: 4CV 0001
vi ton
1
6
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
Nt
V.
M ETHOD PHAU ACEUTI
CALS,LLC,
etal,
.
!
:
..
.'
x
.:'
*
By: on.Gl n E.Conr d
H
e
a
Unie St t sDititJ
t d a e src udge .
D e e nt .
f nda s
Thi c ei pr s nty be or t c ton t bilofc t fld by t pl i if Co or a
s as s e e l f e he our
he l
oss ie
he antf , nc di
P r c uias Ic (ç nc r i' ,pms n t Rul 5 d ()o t e Fe e a Rulso Ci l
hama e tc l, n . ç o da'
co
) ua t o e 4()1 f h d rl e f vi
Pr e le. Fort r s t tf l t c ur wila r Conco di cossi t n ot of
oc dtr
he ea ons ha olow, he o t l wa d
r a t n he m mt
$1 377.
5, 59.
ProceduralH i t
s orv
Co c r ap e aldb f r aj r o i cam t a d fn a t M eh d P nn c u ias
n o di rv i e o e u y n t li h t ee d n s t o ha a e tc l,
e
s
LLC a dMa te S o t c e (olciey ( eh d'e g g di f lea vetsngi voain
n th w c t Tu k r c le tv l ,ç to ' n a e n as d rii n ilt
M
)
o
o t e La h m Ac,1 U.. j 1 25a( )B) Th j r a r e Co o da $ 3 , 00 i
fh nn
t 5 SC. 1 () 1( . e u y wa d d nc r i 7 320 .0 n
a lOrc
dua
ompens t ' da a s On M a c 2,201 t co tg ant Conco di sm oto f
aol m ge .
y
rh
7, he ur r ed
r a'
i n or
e h nc d d ma e . Th c u te rie isds rto t te l t eju sd ma e a r Se
n a e n g s e o r xecs d t icein o rb e h ty' n g s wad. e
1 U. C.j1117a .
5 S.
()
Conc di alo s ug t r c r is ltga i c t . S ej. ( r vdngt tap e iig
or a s o ht o e ove t ii ton os s e Js p o ii ha rval
n
c
he
e he
panifi e tte t rc ve Ghec sso tea to ' On M ar h 2,2017,t courtdenid t
litf s n i d o e o r E o t f h cin).
l
t
motonf rltgain c t wihout eudc ,bec us Conc dadi notr s as cfcnmount
i o ii to oss t prj ie a e
or i d eque t pe i
ofcossor s i a e de e i s
t
ubm t ny vi nc n uppo toft r ques. Concor a wasgi n t ry da i
r
he e t
di
ve hit ys n
whih t fl abilofcossal wih s
c o ie l
t ong t uppori docl e a i
tng lm ntton.
The c e i now bef r t co ton Conc di s r ques f a a d o coss i t
as s
o e he ur
or a' e t or n war f t n he
i o es
o he l
t
xpied,
hod
n ountof$1 007. Thetm et r pond t t bilofcosshase r and M et hasnot
m
7, 69.
fl a o
ed ny pposton. The ma tri rpef r vi w.
ii
te s i or e e
Sum m aa o t A pplcabl Law
f he
i e
ç d rRul 5 ( )1 o t F d rlRue o Ci l o e u e c sstho db alwe t
G e e 4 d ( ) f he e ea ls f viPr c d r , o t s ul e lo d o
un
t pr va lng pa t t l s a f de als a u e pr vi s ot r s ' W ila s v.M e r Li e l .
he e ii
ry' m es
e r t t t o de he wi e.
'
li m
t o f ns
Co.6 9F.d6 2, 3 ( t Ci. 01 )(u tn Fe . Ci P. 4()1) Th ,henzeC rae
, 0 3 2 6 6 4h r 2 0 q o ig d R. v. 5 d (). us t l t e ts
c
t pr umpton t tc t a et be a r d t t pr valng pa t ' Che r v.Cha pi I '
he es
i ha oss r o
wa de o he e ii
ry.
'
rv
m on ntl
Co p,1 6F.d4 2 4 6( t Ci. 9 9 . Alh u htec u t st ed sr to t d n a a r
r . 8 3 4 , 4 4h r 1 9 ) to g h o rha h ic ei n o e y n wad
e on or ng o ' n de o s r
he
of c t,i mus t tc a gq s good r as f doi s ' i or r t Gove com e t
oss t t t iulte ome
ar
p e u to . l (n en lctto a dq oainmak o te )
r s mp in' d.itr a iain n u tto r s mi d .
'
t
Th p riu a e pe s sta ma b tx d a c sst e Rue5 () 1 aes tfrhi 2
e a t lr x n e h t y e a e s o t md r l 4 d ( ) r e o t n 8
c
U. C.j 1 20. Tha saut pr vi s i pe tne pa tasf l :
S.
9
t tt e o de ,n ri nt r, olows
A j g o cek o a c u t ft eUntd S ae ma tx a c ss
ud e r lr f ny o r o h ie tts y a s o t
t f lwi
he olo ng:
()
1
()
2
Fe so t ceka dmas l
e f he lr n rha;
Fe sfrp itdo ee tol al rc r e ta s rp s
e o rn e r lcr rc l e o d d rn cit
i y
nec s a iy o ane f us i t c e;
e s rl bt i d or e n he as
()
3
()
4
Fe a dibure nt f prntnga wine s s
es nd s sme s or i i nd t s e ;
Fe s f re e iiai n a t c ss o ma i
e o x mpl c to nd he o t f kng
f
c e of ary m a e i l whe e t co e a e
opi s
l
tra s
r he pi s r
necessa l obt ned f us i t cas
riy ai
or e n he e;
(
5)
(
6)
Doc tfest rs to 1 23oft stte a
ke e mde ecin 9
hi il; nd
Compe ain of c t a ntd e rs
ns to
our ppoi e
xpe t,
c pe a i of i e pr t r , a s l res f es
om ns ton
nt r e e s nd a a i , e ,
e ns s a c t ofs i i e r t ton s r ce
xpe e , nd os s pec al nt m e a i e vi s
t de s to 1 28 oft s tt e
m r ec i n 8
hi il .
28U. C.j19
S.
20.
Di cussi
s
on
I t s c e t pa tc a c ss a is e i cu e () $1 ,285 i ta cit a d
n hi as , he riulr o t t su n ld ' 1 34 .2 n rnsrp n
.
v d o rp y fe ; 2 $ ,0 .7i wi s fe a dta e e p n e ;a d ( )$ 5 20i p itn .
i e g a h e s ( ) 30 69 n t s e s n rv l x e s s n 3 5 2. n rn ig
ne
a c ng f s Thec t ila e sea h ca e r i t n.
nd opyi ee .
our w l ddr s c t go y n ur
Transcri and vi
pt
deozrapl fee,
a
Thefrtc t or ofexpe e c it of$1 428. i f espai f obt i ng de ii
is a eg y
ns s onsss
3, 52 n e
d or ani
poston
ta crpt,vi r co di o de ii , nd ada l ti lta c i .
r ns i s deo e r ngs f postons a
iy ra r ns rpt
Se to 1 2 alwsac u t otx a c ssEfe sf rp itd o ee to ial r c r e
cin 9 0 lo
o r t a s o t s l e o rn e r lcr nc l e o d d
l
y
ta s rp s n c saiy o t ie f ru e i te c s . 28 U. C.j 1 2 ( ) The c s o a
r n c it e e srl ban d o s n h a e'
'
S.
9 02.
ot f
de ii ta c i i ge r l r c r bl i i i f e s bl ne s a y a t tme of is
poston r ns rpt s ne aly e ove a e f t s i a ona y ce s r t he i
r
t
tkig' La y Co v Do no Fe S v. Lo n As ',8 0F.d 5 2, 2 (t Ci. 9 7 .
a n . va p. . mi in d. a & a sn 3 2 2 5 8 4h r 1 8 )
'
I t sca e t co ta e t ta1 oft de ii nsa is we e r s bl ne es a y t t
n hi s , he ur gr es ha l he posto t s ue r ea ona y c s r o he
ltga i a t tmet y we et n. Li wie,i t spa tc a c e,hec t soft o ni n
ii ton t he i he
r ake
ke s n hi riul r as t our i
he pi o
t tt ta c i oft tilt si ony ofM a t w Sco tTuc r a Chrsophe Boone w a
ha he r ns rpt he ra e tm
the
t
ke nd
it r
s
ne s a y obt i d f us i t c e. Ac r ngl t pl i ifwilbe a r d t f spa d
ce s dl
ane or e n he as
co di y, he antf l
wa de he ee i
f t de ii n a ti lta c i s
or he posto nd ra r ns rpt .
Ont ot rhand, hec tde lne t t x t c tofo de i vi r c di ofc ran
he he
t our ci s o a he os
r rng deo e or ngs e ti
de ii ,s ii a l t de ii ofTuc ra W iln Fas e t whot tfed i pe s n a
postons pecfc ly he postons
ke nd lim
s t,
esii n r o t
ti l a t de ii ofAs e Rodden a J W il,who we e notc le a wine s s
ra , nd he postons
hl e
nd ohn ls
r
a ld s t s e .
Conc di obt i d t wr te tans r pt oft de ii ,a i ha f ie t de ons r t t t
or a a ne he it n r c i s he pos tons nd t s a l d o m ta e ha
vi r or ngs oft e pa tc a de ii w e e a s nec s a y. Cons que l Conc di '
deo ec di
hes ri ul r postons r l o e s r
e nty,
or a s
bilofc t wilber duce by $141 00.
l oss l e d
, 5.
B.
W ine s f e and t a le ns s
t s es
r ve xpe e
The pé ng bilofc t alo i udes$3, 97 i wine sf esa ta le ns . A
ndi l oss s ncl
006. n t s e nd r ve xpe es
p e al p ry ma rc ve f e f rwin s e u d r28U. C. 1 2 4 ) Avalbee p n e
rv ing a t y e o r e s o t e s s n e
i
S. j 9 0 3 .
ia l x e s s
i udeatndanc ta l a s itncefes ass cii i 28U. C.j1821.
ncl te
e,rve, nd ubsse e , pe fed n
S.
I t sca e Conc di s e t r c
n hi s ,
or a e ks o e overa tnda f sa ta e ns s i uaed f
te nce ee nd r vel xpe e nc
or
f o iswine s s e c ofwhom wa r quie t sa o r ghta a hot li Cha l t vil
our f t t s e , a h
s e r d o t y ve ni t
e n
rotes le,
Vigi a. Addii ly, wo oft wines e ,
r ni
tona l t
he t s s whopr de e r t tm o ta ld by arfom
ovi d xpe tesi ny, r vee
i'
r
M i ss i a Te . The c ti of t o ni t t a 1f tr wines e we e r as bl
s isppi nd xas
our s
he pi on ha l ol t s s r e ona y
nec s r a t tt i a iabl f s a e ns we e pr ry doc e ed by Conc di
es a y nd ha her pplc e ee nd xpe es r ope l
um nt
or a.
Ac o dn l,hewi e sfe a dta l x n e aea p o raeytxe u d rj 1 2 4 )
c r i gy t t s e s n rve e pe s s r p r p itl a d n e 9 0 3 .
n
C.
Pri i and copyi expenses
ntnz
nz
Thefna c t r ofr se e ns i ude $55 20f co e pr uc d i hous a
i l aego y eque t d xpe es ncl s 2. or pis od e n- e t
ac s o $ 1 p rp g . Pt s a tt 28U. C.j 1 2 4 ) t ec u t y tx fe f rç kig
o t f 0.0 e a e t u n o
r
S.
9 0 4 , h o r ma a e s o ç n
mn
co e ofa m ae il whe et c pi a ene s a iy obt ne f us i t c s ' 28U. C.
pis ny tra s r he o es r ce s rl ai d or e n he a e.
'
S.
j 1 2 ( ) W h l txa l e pe e icu e c p e G u mitd t te c ur a d p o i e t
9 0 4 . ie a be x ns s n ld o is d b te o h o t n r v d d o
s
opposng co el'co esm a f apa t sown c
i
uns ,' pi
de or ry'
onve e e a enota l d. Ke dv v. oy
ni nc r
lowe
nne
J
Te h .I c, 4F. u p. d 5 2 5 5( . Va 2 0 )(o e , .; e as W e v. o e Lt .
c s. n .48 S p 2 0 , 0 W D. . 0 7 J n s J) s e lo bb Kr z r d
P'hi 1 No.72 6- 00036,201 U. Dit LEM S 94775,a *1 201 W L 2651 ,a *
s p ,
1 CV7 S. s .
t 2, 7
721 t 5
( . Va J n 1 , 1 )( ba s , .; c waz& S h r o Va. v. ranUn ev ies
W D. . u e 9 20 7 Ur n kiJ) S h r c waz f .LLC Ceti d t tr
a Ll s N o.6: CV t ovd' ,
07- 00042,201 U . Di t LEX I 1
0 S. s .
S 0753,a *28,201 W L 452743,a *9
t
0
t
( . Va F b 8 2 0 ( o n J)
W D. . e . , 01 ) M o , ..
He e, he ie i d ls ofc ng e ns i l sc t as oc aed wih prntng c e
r t tm ze it opyi xpe es ncude oss s i t
t i i opi s
ofConco di s ti le bis f r isow n us a ti l Cons s e w ih t f ego ng de s ons t
r a' r a xhi t o t
e t ra .
it nt t he or i
ci i , he
c tde i t t x t cos oft e c es t a i $215.0,a i tM ehod. Howe ,t
our clnes o a he t hes opi , otlng
1 gans t
ver he
4
cossoft r m ani pa c e ,whi h we epr vi d t t c ta opposng cot e,wil
t
he e i ng per opi s
c
r o de o he our nd
i
ms l l
be a r d t Co or a.
wa de o nc di
C oncl i
us on
I ac or nc w ih t r i s s tf t a
n c da e t he ulng e orh bove t c t ilgr nti pa ta de i pa t
, he our w l a n r nd ny n r
Conco di sr ue tf ra a r ofc t. Lii ton c t i t n ot of$1 377. wilbe
r a' eq s o n wa d oss tga i oss n he m mt
5, 59 l
t xed aga ns M e hod.
a
i t t
The Clr i diec e t s nd c riid co e of t s me or ndlm o ni a t
ek s r td o e
e tfe
pis
hi
m a l pi on nd he
ac om pa ng or rt a 1c m s lofr co d.
c
nyi
de o l ot e
e r
D ATED : s
Thi
l d yo J l, 2017.
Q a f uy
Unie Stt sDititJ
t d a e src udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?