PBM Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Method Pharmaceuticals, LLC et al

Filing 285

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/19/17. (jcj)

ERKsOF I
Dl
s
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STW CT COURT cL 'A FCEuskvmcoue TRFI 6K A .
oN
A
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI UCT OF V I GI I
STI
R N A
LED
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON

J 192 1
UL
27
J J-' (. U
' t, '
! ;
A
jsJ
rf
.

CON CORD I PH A RM A CEU TI LS,
A
CA
I C.
N ,

'
.

,
C
'

Ci lA c i N o.3: 4CV 0001
vi ton
1
6
Pl ntf ,
ai i f

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
Nt
V.

M ETHOD PHAU ACEUTI
CALS,LLC,
etal,
.

!
:
..
.'
x

.:'
*

By: on.Gl n E.Conr d
H
e
a
Unie St t sDititJ
t d a e src udge .

D e e nt .
f nda s

Thi c ei pr s nty be or t c ton t bilofc t fld by t pl i if Co or a
s as s e e l f e he our
he l
oss ie
he antf , nc di

P r c uias Ic (ç nc r i' ,pms n t Rul 5 d ()o t e Fe e a Rulso Ci l
hama e tc l, n . ç o da'
co
) ua t o e 4()1 f h d rl e f vi
Pr e le. Fort r s t tf l t c ur wila r Conco di cossi t n ot of
oc dtr
he ea ons ha olow, he o t l wa d
r a t n he m mt

$1 377.
5, 59.
ProceduralH i t
s orv

Co c r ap e aldb f r aj r o i cam t a d fn a t M eh d P nn c u ias
n o di rv i e o e u y n t li h t ee d n s t o ha a e tc l,
e
s
LLC a dMa te S o t c e (olciey ( eh d'e g g di f lea vetsngi voain
n th w c t Tu k r c le tv l ,ç to ' n a e n as d rii n ilt
M
)
o
o t e La h m Ac,1 U.. j 1 25a( )B) Th j r a r e Co o da $ 3 , 00 i
fh nn
t 5 SC. 1 () 1( . e u y wa d d nc r i 7 320 .0 n
a lOrc
dua
ompens t ' da a s On M a c 2,201 t co tg ant Conco di sm oto f
aol m ge .
y
rh
7, he ur r ed
r a'
i n or

e h nc d d ma e . Th c u te rie isds rto t te l t eju sd ma e a r Se
n a e n g s e o r xecs d t icein o rb e h ty' n g s wad. e
1 U. C.j1117a .
5 S.
()
Conc di alo s ug t r c r is ltga i c t . S ej. ( r vdngt tap e iig
or a s o ht o e ove t ii ton os s e Js p o ii ha rval
n

c
he
e he
panifi e tte t rc ve Ghec sso tea to ' On M ar h 2,2017,t courtdenid t
litf s n i d o e o r E o t f h cin).
l
t

motonf rltgain c t wihout eudc ,bec us Conc dadi notr s as cfcnmount
i o ii to oss t prj ie a e
or i d eque t pe i

ofcossor s i a e de e i s
t
ubm t ny vi nc n uppo toft r ques. Concor a wasgi n t ry da i
r
he e t
di
ve hit ys n
whih t fl abilofcossal wih s
c o ie l
t ong t uppori docl e a i
tng lm ntton.
The c e i now bef r t co ton Conc di s r ques f a a d o coss i t
as s
o e he ur
or a' e t or n war f t n he
i o es
o he l
t
xpied,
hod
n ountof$1 007. Thetm et r pond t t bilofcosshase r and M et hasnot
m
7, 69.
fl a o
ed ny pposton. The ma tri rpef r vi w.
ii
te s i or e e
Sum m aa o t A pplcabl Law
f he
i e

ç d rRul 5 ( )1 o t F d rlRue o Ci l o e u e c sstho db alwe t
G e e 4 d ( ) f he e ea ls f viPr c d r , o t s ul e lo d o
un
t pr va lng pa t t l s a f de als a u e pr vi s ot r s ' W ila s v.M e r Li e l .
he e ii
ry' m es
e r t t t o de he wi e.
'
li m
t o f ns

Co.6 9F.d6 2, 3 ( t Ci. 01 )(u tn Fe . Ci P. 4()1) Th ,henzeC rae
, 0 3 2 6 6 4h r 2 0 q o ig d R. v. 5 d (). us t l t e ts
c
t pr umpton t tc t a et be a r d t t pr valng pa t ' Che r v.Cha pi I '
he es
i ha oss r o
wa de o he e ii
ry.
'
rv
m on ntl

Co p,1 6F.d4 2 4 6( t Ci. 9 9 . Alh u htec u t st ed sr to t d n a a r
r . 8 3 4 , 4 4h r 1 9 ) to g h o rha h ic ei n o e y n wad
e on or ng o ' n de o s r
he
of c t,i mus t tc a gq s good r as f doi s ' i or r t Gove com e t
oss t t t iulte ome
ar

p e u to . l (n en lctto a dq oainmak o te )
r s mp in' d.itr a iain n u tto r s mi d .
'
t
Th p riu a e pe s sta ma b tx d a c sst e Rue5 () 1 aes tfrhi 2
e a t lr x n e h t y e a e s o t md r l 4 d ( ) r e o t n 8
c
U. C.j 1 20. Tha saut pr vi s i pe tne pa tasf l :
S.
9
t tt e o de ,n ri nt r, olows

A j g o cek o a c u t ft eUntd S ae ma tx a c ss
ud e r lr f ny o r o h ie tts y a s o t
t f lwi
he olo ng:

()
1
()
2

Fe so t ceka dmas l
e f he lr n rha;
Fe sfrp itdo ee tol al rc r e ta s rp s
e o rn e r lcr rc l e o d d rn cit
i y
nec s a iy o ane f us i t c e;
e s rl bt i d or e n he as

()
3
()
4

Fe a dibure nt f prntnga wine s s
es nd s sme s or i i nd t s e ;
Fe s f re e iiai n a t c ss o ma i
e o x mpl c to nd he o t f kng
f
c e of ary m a e i l whe e t co e a e
opi s
l
tra s
r he pi s r
necessa l obt ned f us i t cas
riy ai
or e n he e;

(
5)
(
6)

Doc tfest rs to 1 23oft stte a
ke e mde ecin 9
hi il; nd
Compe ain of c t a ntd e rs
ns to
our ppoi e
xpe t,
c pe a i of i e pr t r , a s l res f es
om ns ton
nt r e e s nd a a i , e ,
e ns s a c t ofs i i e r t ton s r ce
xpe e , nd os s pec al nt m e a i e vi s
t de s to 1 28 oft s tt e
m r ec i n 8
hi il .

28U. C.j19
S.
20.

Di cussi
s
on

I t s c e t pa tc a c ss a is e i cu e () $1 ,285 i ta cit a d
n hi as , he riulr o t t su n ld ' 1 34 .2 n rnsrp n
.

v d o rp y fe ; 2 $ ,0 .7i wi s fe a dta e e p n e ;a d ( )$ 5 20i p itn .
i e g a h e s ( ) 30 69 n t s e s n rv l x e s s n 3 5 2. n rn ig
ne
a c ng f s Thec t ila e sea h ca e r i t n.
nd opyi ee .
our w l ddr s c t go y n ur
Transcri and vi
pt
deozrapl fee,
a

Thefrtc t or ofexpe e c it of$1 428. i f espai f obt i ng de ii
is a eg y
ns s onsss
3, 52 n e
d or ani
poston
ta crpt,vi r co di o de ii , nd ada l ti lta c i .
r ns i s deo e r ngs f postons a
iy ra r ns rpt

Se to 1 2 alwsac u t otx a c ssEfe sf rp itd o ee to ial r c r e
cin 9 0 lo
o r t a s o t s l e o rn e r lcr nc l e o d d
l
y
ta s rp s n c saiy o t ie f ru e i te c s . 28 U. C.j 1 2 ( ) The c s o a
r n c it e e srl ban d o s n h a e'
'
S.
9 02.
ot f
de ii ta c i i ge r l r c r bl i i i f e s bl ne s a y a t tme of is
poston r ns rpt s ne aly e ove a e f t s i a ona y ce s r t he i
r
t

tkig' La y Co v Do no Fe S v. Lo n As ',8 0F.d 5 2, 2 (t Ci. 9 7 .
a n . va p. . mi in d. a & a sn 3 2 2 5 8 4h r 1 8 )
'
I t sca e t co ta e t ta1 oft de ii nsa is we e r s bl ne es a y t t
n hi s , he ur gr es ha l he posto t s ue r ea ona y c s r o he
ltga i a t tmet y we et n. Li wie,i t spa tc a c e,hec t soft o ni n
ii ton t he i he
r ake
ke s n hi riul r as t our i
he pi o
t tt ta c i oft tilt si ony ofM a t w Sco tTuc r a Chrsophe Boone w a
ha he r ns rpt he ra e tm
the
t
ke nd
it r
s
ne s a y obt i d f us i t c e. Ac r ngl t pl i ifwilbe a r d t f spa d
ce s dl
ane or e n he as
co di y, he antf l
wa de he ee i
f t de ii n a ti lta c i s
or he posto nd ra r ns rpt .
Ont ot rhand, hec tde lne t t x t c tofo de i vi r c di ofc ran
he he
t our ci s o a he os
r rng deo e or ngs e ti
de ii ,s ii a l t de ii ofTuc ra W iln Fas e t whot tfed i pe s n a
postons pecfc ly he postons
ke nd lim
s t,
esii n r o t
ti l a t de ii ofAs e Rodden a J W il,who we e notc le a wine s s
ra , nd he postons
hl e
nd ohn ls
r
a ld s t s e .
Conc di obt i d t wr te tans r pt oft de ii ,a i ha f ie t de ons r t t t
or a a ne he it n r c i s he pos tons nd t s a l d o m ta e ha
vi r or ngs oft e pa tc a de ii w e e a s nec s a y. Cons que l Conc di '
deo ec di
hes ri ul r postons r l o e s r
e nty,
or a s

bilofc t wilber duce by $141 00.
l oss l e d
, 5.

B.

W ine s f e and t a le ns s
t s es
r ve xpe e

The pé ng bilofc t alo i udes$3, 97 i wine sf esa ta le ns . A
ndi l oss s ncl
006. n t s e nd r ve xpe es

p e al p ry ma rc ve f e f rwin s e u d r28U. C. 1 2 4 ) Avalbee p n e
rv ing a t y e o r e s o t e s s n e
i
S. j 9 0 3 .
ia l x e s s
i udeatndanc ta l a s itncefes ass cii i 28U. C.j1821.
ncl te
e,rve, nd ubsse e , pe fed n
S.
I t sca e Conc di s e t r c
n hi s ,
or a e ks o e overa tnda f sa ta e ns s i uaed f
te nce ee nd r vel xpe e nc
or
f o iswine s s e c ofwhom wa r quie t sa o r ghta a hot li Cha l t vil
our f t t s e , a h
s e r d o t y ve ni t
e n
rotes le,
Vigi a. Addii ly, wo oft wines e ,
r ni
tona l t
he t s s whopr de e r t tm o ta ld by arfom
ovi d xpe tesi ny, r vee
i'
r
M i ss i a Te . The c ti of t o ni t t a 1f tr wines e we e r as bl
s isppi nd xas
our s
he pi on ha l ol t s s r e ona y
nec s r a t tt i a iabl f s a e ns we e pr ry doc e ed by Conc di
es a y nd ha her pplc e ee nd xpe es r ope l
um nt
or a.

Ac o dn l,hewi e sfe a dta l x n e aea p o raeytxe u d rj 1 2 4 )
c r i gy t t s e s n rve e pe s s r p r p itl a d n e 9 0 3 .
n
C.

Pri i and copyi expenses
ntnz
nz

Thefna c t r ofr se e ns i ude $55 20f co e pr uc d i hous a
i l aego y eque t d xpe es ncl s 2. or pis od e n- e t

ac s o $ 1 p rp g . Pt s a tt 28U. C.j 1 2 4 ) t ec u t y tx fe f rç kig
o t f 0.0 e a e t u n o
r
S.
9 0 4 , h o r ma a e s o ç n
mn
co e ofa m ae il whe et c pi a ene s a iy obt ne f us i t c s ' 28U. C.
pis ny tra s r he o es r ce s rl ai d or e n he a e.
'
S.

j 1 2 ( ) W h l txa l e pe e icu e c p e G u mitd t te c ur a d p o i e t
9 0 4 . ie a be x ns s n ld o is d b te o h o t n r v d d o
s
opposng co el'co esm a f apa t sown c
i
uns ,' pi
de or ry'
onve e e a enota l d. Ke dv v. oy
ni nc r
lowe
nne
J

Te h .I c, 4F. u p. d 5 2 5 5( . Va 2 0 )(o e , .; e as W e v. o e Lt .
c s. n .48 S p 2 0 , 0 W D. . 0 7 J n s J) s e lo bb Kr z r d
P'hi 1 No.72 6- 00036,201 U. Dit LEM S 94775,a *1 201 W L 2651 ,a *
s p ,
1 CV7 S. s .
t 2, 7
721 t 5

( . Va J n 1 , 1 )( ba s , .; c waz& S h r o Va. v. ranUn ev ies
W D. . u e 9 20 7 Ur n kiJ) S h r c waz f .LLC Ceti d t tr
a Ll s N o.6: CV t ovd' ,
07- 00042,201 U . Di t LEX I 1
0 S. s .
S 0753,a *28,201 W L 452743,a *9
t
0
t

( . Va F b 8 2 0 ( o n J)
W D. . e . , 01 ) M o , ..
He e, he ie i d ls ofc ng e ns i l sc t as oc aed wih prntng c e
r t tm ze it opyi xpe es ncude oss s i t
t i i opi s
ofConco di s ti le bis f r isow n us a ti l Cons s e w ih t f ego ng de s ons t
r a' r a xhi t o t
e t ra .
it nt t he or i
ci i , he

c tde i t t x t cos oft e c es t a i $215.0,a i tM ehod. Howe ,t
our clnes o a he t hes opi , otlng
1 gans t
ver he
4

cossoft r m ani pa c e ,whi h we epr vi d t t c ta opposng cot e,wil
t
he e i ng per opi s
c
r o de o he our nd
i
ms l l
be a r d t Co or a.
wa de o nc di
C oncl i
us on

I ac or nc w ih t r i s s tf t a
n c da e t he ulng e orh bove t c t ilgr nti pa ta de i pa t
, he our w l a n r nd ny n r

Conco di sr ue tf ra a r ofc t. Lii ton c t i t n ot of$1 377. wilbe
r a' eq s o n wa d oss tga i oss n he m mt
5, 59 l
t xed aga ns M e hod.
a
i t t

The Clr i diec e t s nd c riid co e of t s me or ndlm o ni a t
ek s r td o e
e tfe
pis
hi
m a l pi on nd he
ac om pa ng or rt a 1c m s lofr co d.
c
nyi
de o l ot e
e r
D ATED : s
Thi

l d yo J l, 2017.
Q a f uy

Unie Stt sDititJ
t d a e src udge