PBM Pharmaceuticals, Inc. v. Method Pharmaceuticals, LLC et al

Filing 287

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/19/17. (jcj)

@ F @ PF I M, , 4 ,
M
FCq @ RIT GQQR
AT q- oc ,V
A
Ff l
kgi

I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO URT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STM CT O F V I I A
RG NI
CH AR LOTTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

CONCORDI PHARM CEUTI
A
CALS,
I C.
N ,

J 19 2 ?
UL
2
J
UL C,
DUD
BY;
D

LERK
ERK

Ci lAc i N o.3: 4CV 0001
vi ton
1
6
Pl i if
a ntf ,

M EM ORANDUM OPI
NION
M ETHOD PHARM ACEUTI
CALS,LLC,
e a1,
t .

By:H o Gl n E. lad
n. e
Corr
Unie Stt sDititJ
t d a e src udge

D e enda s
f
nt .

Co o daPh r c uias I c (t n o da' p e ald b f r aj r o iscam t a
nc r i n ma e tc l, n . ç c r i' r v ie e o e u y n t li h t
co
)
d fn a t M eh d Ph r c uias LLC a d M ate S o tTu k r(o lci l,ç eho '
e e d n s t o n ma e tc l,
n
th w c t c e c le tvey ç t d'
M
)
e a e i fle a v riig i v oain o te Ln hn Ac,1 U. C.j 1 2 ()1( . Th
ng g d n as d e t n n i lto f h n m t 5 S.
s
1 5 a( )B) e
j r a r e Co c r i $ 3 2 0.0 i a ta o c mp nst r d ma e . On Ma c 2,2 7
u y wad d n o d a 7 3,0 0 n cu l r o e ao y n g s
r h 01 ,
t c ti s d a o ni a o de gr ntng Conc di s m o i f el nc d
he our s ue n pi on nd r r a i
or a'
ton or zha ed amage ,
s

d n n i rq e tf rp eu g n itr s,a d nyn ismo in f ratr e s f e . Th
e yig t e u s o rj d me t n ee t nd e ig t to o ton y ' e s e
s
c u t xecsd isd sr to t te et j r sd ma e a r t e 1 U. C.j1 1 () Th
o r e rie t ic ein o rbl he u y' n g s wad md r 5 S.
1 7a. e
cour de e m i d t t a a r of tebl dn a s wa ne s a y t f il a a qua ey
t t r ne ha n wa d
r e m ge
s ce s r o ary nd de t l
compe a e Conc di f t a r e e f ct ofM e hod' ac i . M ehod ha m ove t aler
ns t
or a or he dve s fe s
t s tons
t
s
d o t

o a n t ej g n u e Ru e5 ()o t eFe e a Ru e o Cii Pr c d e Thec u t ed
r me d h ud me t nd r l 9 e f h d r l ls f v l o e m .
orhl
a he rng on t m oton vi c e e e ca lon J 9,201 Fort r a ons t f l t
ai
he
i
a onf r nc l
une
7.
he e s
hat olow, he
m o i wilbede e
ton l
ni d.

% Rul 59()moto ma begrntd o y i t e st ai t1 t ac ommodaea
ç
A e e
in y
a e nl n hre iu tons: () o c
t n
i e v ni c nge i c r lng lw;( t a co f ne e de eno a lbl a til or
ntr e ng ha n ontoli a 2) o c unt or w vi nc t vaia e t ra;

( )t c re tace rer ro 1w o p e n malfs ij sie'' M a fed v Na' As ' f r
3 o o rc la ro f a r rve t r et n u tc .' v il . tl sn o
i

S o kCa Au oRa ic 6 4 F.d 3 9 3 (t Ci. 01 )( u tn Zik n v Br wn, 7 F.d
t c r t cn , 7 3 6 , 78 4 h r 2 2 q o ig n a d . o 4 8 3
6 4, 3 ( t Ci. 0 7 ) ç i a e ta r iay rme y ta s o l bea pid s rn l ' nd
3 6 7 4h r 2 0 ).Ct s n xr o dn r e d h t h u d p le paigy'a
l
onl i l xc ptona c r um sa s' I The r l ç a no beus d t r ltgae o1 ma tr ,or
y n s e i l ic t nce . d.
e
'
ue s y t
m
e o e ii t d te s
t r s a g e s or pr s nt e de e t t c d ha be n r s d pror t t e r of
o aie r um nt
e e vi nc ha oul ve e aie
i o he nty

j d me t' Ex o S p i Co v Ba e ,5 4 U. 471 4 6 n5 ( 00 )(iain a d i tr l
u g n . x n hipng . . k r 5 S. , 8 . 2 8 ctto n nena
'
quotto maksomitd)
ain r
te .
A ppl ng t s pr nc pl ,t c tc l
yi he e i i es he our onc udes t M e hod i note il d t r le t de
hat t
s
ntt e o e i f m r

Ru e 5 () I ra hng is d cso o Co c r i ' moin f re h n e d ma e ,te c u t
l 9 e. n e c i t e iin n n o d as to o n a c d a k s h o r
c e u l c i r d e h oft f c o ss tf rh by t Unied Stt s Cour ofAppeas f t
ar f ly onsde e ac
he a t r e o t
he t
ae
t
l or he

Fo rh Cic ti S n r itcI tr ain l LLC v Ko ma ,4 0 F.d 1 2,1 5 (t Ci.2 0 )
u t rui n v e csi n en to a.
. r n 7 3 6 7 4h r 0 6.
Th c u t li tl d tnnie t t h mao i o to ef co sweg e i fvo o el n i
e o r utmaey ee n d ha t e j rt f h s a tr ih d n a r f r cng
y
ha
t da a s a r d t Conc di . M ehod do not i ntf a clar e r i t c r '
he m ge wa de o
or a
t
es
de iy ny e ror n he ou ts
a ys s A lhough M e hod di a e w ih t c ts de s on a de t m uc of is bre i
nal i . t
t
s gr es t he our ' ci i nd vo es
h
t i f ng
t r a gui is pos ton t t t Svne citc f c or w e gh a ns a e nce e , C e e
o e r ng t
ii ha he
r si a t s i
gai t n nha m nt t r
m

ds g e me td e n ts p r aRul 5 ()moin. Hu c i o v. ttn, 9 F.d 1 76 1 8
ia r e n o s o u po t
e 9 e to ' thns n S ao 9 4 2 4 , 0 2
'
( t Ci.1 9 )
4h r 9 3 .

Fo te s me ra o s t c u tmus rj c M eh d' a gl n t a a a r o te l
r h a e s n , he o r t ee t t o s r l t h t n wad f r be
me
da a s i e s i l pt ii
m ge s xce s ve y m tve. Af e t oughl r vi w i t t tm ony a e de e
t r hor
y e e ng he es i
nd vi nc

pr s nt d a til t c tuli t l f
e e e t ra , he our tma ey ound i a opra e t te e t n mt of dn age
t ppr i t o r bl he mot
m s

a r by t jly i or rt fil a a quaey c
waded he tr n de o ary nd de tl ompe ae Conc di f t a re
ns t
or a or he dve s

efcso M eh d' flea ve t i . S e 1 U. C.j 1 1 ()(uh rzn t ec u t o a r
fe t f t o s as d ri ng e 5 S.
s
1 7a a to iig h o r t wad
u t t e tm es t a ountf
p o hr e i
he m
ound a a t alda a s but i t u tng t t s h a awa d Gs l
s cu
m ge ,
ns r c i ha uc n
r thal

c tt e c
onsiut ompenston a notape ly'l s e as Badce M ee.I v.GrnnelCom . 1
ai nd
nat '; e lo
r tr nc.
i l
,3

F.d 1 4 ,1 5 (t Ci.1 9 )(x liig ta ç e a s plitfs ls p o isa enoo iu l
3 1 5 1 7 7h r 9 4 e pann h t û c u e anif ' o t r ft r t ro sy
b
difc tt pr ' s ci 111 a pe mis a dititcou tt ç wad up t t e tmest
fiul o ovey e ton 7() r t
'
src r o l r
a
o hre i
he

d ma e panifc na tal p o e'no d rt S p r xi t af i r c v r f rt p an if'.
a g s litf a cu l r v 'i r e o ç p o mae ar e o e y o he litf )
y
a
The c ur c r f ly c i r d whe he a a r of te e dn a
o t a e ul onsde e
t r n wa d
r bl m ges woul c tt t a
d onsiu e n
i r s i epenat a uli t l co l d t ti woul not Se Conco di Phn m s.I
mpe misbl
ly nd tma ey ncude ha t
d . e
r a r . nc.
v.M e hod Phn . LLC,N o.3: 4CV 0001 201 U . D i t LEX I 29342,a * 201 W L
t
nns ,
1
6, 7 S. s .
S
t 20, 7

8 7 8 ,a * ( . Va M a.2 2 7 (ç e c u tb le s t a t i e ha c d a r i
3 6 8 t 6 W D. . r , 01 ) $
Th o r eive h t h s n n e wad s
ne es a y t f ry a a qua ey c
c s r o ail nd de t l ompens t Conc di f t adve s e f c s of t
ae
or a or he
r e fe t
he

d fn a t' s o uc, n t a i d e n tc n ttt a i e misbeç e at ')( u tn 1
ee d n s mic nd t a d h t t o s o o siue n mp r si l p n l ' q oi g 5
y.'
U. C.j 1117( ) W hieM ehod o ousy dia e wih t c tsc l i M ehod has
S.
a). l t bvi l s gres t he our' oncuson, t

fie t e tbiht a i wa t ep o uc o ce rer ro ama f sl u j s a plc to o lw.
ald o sa ls h t t s h r d t f la ro r nie ty n u t p iain f a
A cc di y, r le i n t u h rz du d rRu e5 ()*
or ngl eif s o a t o ie n e l 9 e .

F rte ra o ssae ,M eh d' mo in t atro a n t ej g n wi bed n e
o h e s n ttd to s to o l r me d h ud me t l
e
l e id.
The Cl r i die t t s nd c esoft sme or ndum opi o a t a ompanyi or rt
e k s r ced o e opi
hi m a
ni n nd he cc
ng de o
a lc
1 ouns lofr cor
e
e d.

DATED: i W & d yo J l, 2017.
Ths
a f uy

Unie Stt sDititJ
t d ae src udge

#

l is iiilb if i s pp to te p n ig mo in,M eh as ij ce a n w p blc p iy
n t nta re n u or f h e dn to
tod lo ne td e u i ol
c
a gumentt was notpr vi l pr e e Thi ne a gument whi M ehod chos nott purue a t
r
hat
e ousy es nt d.
s w r
, ch t
e
o s t he

rc n he rn as p o ie n b ssf rrle un e Rue5 () Se Pa .ns Co. Am. tl r l s Co,
e e t aig, lo r vd s o a i o eif d r l 9 e. e c I . v. Na'Fie n . .
1 8 F. 3 ,4 4 (t Ci.1 98 (mp szn t tç e59 e ma no beu e t rien w ag n so
4 3d 96 0 4 h r 9 ) e haiig ha t
Rul () y t s d o as e rume t r
prs n n v llg lhe ista c l h v be nrie pro t j dg nt)
e e t o e e a t ore h t oud a e e asd ir o u me n.