Minor v. Tyson Foods, Inc.
Filing
12
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 07/23/2014. (ssm)
CL S OF CE U. DI
ERK' FI S. E
AT ROM OKE,
Và
FIED
L
J 23 2 1
UL
29
I TH E U N I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI O F V I I I
CT
RG N A
CH A RLO TTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI
J
UL C.
DUD - $
C
BY:
D P
,. '
*.
t
LEW I 'W A LLY' M I O R,J .
SS
' N
R,
Ci lAc i N o. 1
vi ton
3: 4CV0001
9
Pl i if
a ntf ,
M EM O R AND U M O PI O N
NI
V.
Ho Gl n E.
n. e Conr
ad
Chi Unie St t D i ti tJ
ef t d a es s r c udge
TY SON FO OD S,I C. A
N T/
TY SON FA RM S, N C.
I ,
De enda .
f
nt
Le i M i , oce di pr j ,f l d t sac i n i t Cic tCour ofLoui a Coun y
w s nor pr e ng o q ie hi to n he r ui
t
s
t
-
a i tTys Foods I (1 on'. Thedefnda r
gans on
,nc. û
Tys '
)
e nt emove t ca et t sc ta t n
d he s o hi our, nd he
movedt dimist compli purua t Rul 1 b)6)oft FedealRul ofCi lPr ed e.
o s s he
ant s nt o e 2( (
he r
es vi oc ur
l r s e,hepli tf fl d a( o i t qua h d e ntsr m ova pe ii un i Vig ni Code
n e pons t a n if ie û ton o s ef nda ' e
m
l tton tl r i a
j8.1266i s tsid. Fort f l ngr a ons t moint qua hwilbede e a t
0 - s aife '
'
he olowi e s ,he to o s l
nid, nd he
pl i ifwilber quiedt fl ar s
antf l e r o ie e pons t t def nda ' motont dimiswihi ffee days
e o he e nts i o s s t n i t n
.
Backzround
The pl i ifor gi ly f l d t s a ton a ns Tys i t Cicui Co tofLoui a
a ntf i na l ie hi c i gai t on n he r t ur
s
C o y. On M a 1 201 Tys n r m o d t ac i t t s c ' on t bas sofdi r iy
unt
y 2, 4, o e ve he ton o hi oul
t he i
ve s t
j rs ito a tefc t a M io ' c mp an a srsvoain o fd rllw.
u idcin, nd h a t h t n rs o lit se t ilto s f e e a a
On J
une 1 201 Tys m ove t di m i st c pl i f f iur t s a e a cl i . The
2, 4, on
d o s s he om a nt or a l e o t t
am
f l ng da t c ti s a Ros bor notc die tng t pl ntf t f l a r s
olowi
y, he our s ued
e o* i e r c i he ai i f o ie e pons w ihi
e t n
ffeen days and advi i hi t t case w oul be di m i ed f f l e t pros e i he di
it
,
sng m hat he
d
s ss or aiur o
ecut f
d
notfie s e r
l om esponse w ihi t ffeen- peri
t n he il day
od.
*Ro e o ov Gars n 5 8F. 30 ( t Ci.1 5 .
s b r . rio , 2 2d 9 4h r 97 )
O n J y 8,201 t pl ntf fl d t i t ntm o i n t quas t r m o lnotc The
ul
4, he ai if ie he ns a
to o
h he e va
i e.
pl i tf con e t he i e il d t tflng f s a ot r c t ' pur ua t V i g ni Code
a n if t nds hat s ntte o cii ee nd he os s ' s nt o r i a
j8. 1266,a t tt sc es dno pr ee i f rlc tuntlt f sa c t a epad
0nd ha hi as houl t oc d n edea our i he ee nd oss r i
by t de e nt
he f nda .
Di cussi
s
on
H a ng c i r t pl i t f ' m oton,a t def nt sr pons t r t t c t
vi ons de ed he a n if s i nd he enda ' es
e he e o, he our
c l
onc udest tt m oton m us be de e The s a ut on whi h t pl ntf r le a ho i es
ha he
i
t
ni d.
tt e
c he ai i f e i s ut r z
s a e co t t S w a d a am ountne es a y t c pe a e a pa t f r s h i onve e
t t ur s o i r n
a
c s r o om ns t
ry o uc nc
ni nce,
expe e a dea a hema ha be nca e byt c
ns , nd ly s
y ve e us d he omme eme ofgjs ti af m t
nc nt a ui n onz o
whc a o j cin g ve u l p ru n t j8. - 6 , ss san do t b igngo afio o
ih n b e to t n e , u s a t o 012 4 i u ti e r he rn i f rv lus
o
moi nt ta se ( e u l' Va Co ej8012 6. Th c u'a r e wi Ty o t a tesaue
to o r n f r v n e .
' . d . -6
e o l g e s t s n h t h tt t
t
h
i c ea l i pplc bl i t sca e Tys di nots e t i r f ' ve w ihi t s a e c t
s l ry na i a e n hi s .
on d
e k o i ans er' nue t n he t t our
t
s t , h l sfl a S rvol m oto t ta f r' l I t d,Tys r m ove t c e
ysem muc es ie t i ous i n o r nse . d. nsea
f
'
on e
d he as
fom saecour t f r c tpurua t 28U. C.jj1 a 1
r tt
t o edeal our, s nt o
S.
441 nd 446. Ac di y,he
cor ngl t
pl ntf i notentte t rle unde j8. ai if s
ild o eif r 01266.
To t e e t pl ntf sf lng c d be c t e a a m o i t r m and,t m oton i
he xt nt he ai if ii oul
onsnz d s
ton o e
he
i s
untmey. Purua t 28U. C.j1 c ,ia motont r ma t ca eont bassofa
i l
s nt o
S. 447() Sgl i o e nd he s he i ny
d fc oh rta lc o s be t te j rs ito mus b ma ewi n3 d y a tr h fl go
e e t t e h n a k f u j c matr u idcin t e d t 0 a s fe t e ii f
hi
n
t notc ofrmo lunde s ci 1 a . Hee,hepli ifsmotonwa no maieduntl
he ie e va
r e ton 446()' r t antf
'
i
s t l
i
J y5,201 nea l e g wee afe Tys snotc ofr m ova wasfl a i i undiput t t
ul
4, ry i ht ks tr on' i e e
l
ied, nd t s
s ed ha
t ec u t a s be tmatr u idcino e t sa to S e2 U. C. 1 31(t dsrc
h o r h s u jc te j rs ito v r hi cin. e 8 S. j 3 (
The itit
c t s l ha orgi j iditonofalcviaci aii unde t Consiuton,aws or
ours hal ve i nalurs ci
l i l tons rsng
r he
tt i l ,
te tesoft Unie Stts' ;28U. C.j1 a (1 dititc t s lha orgna
rai
he td ae .'
l
S.
332() 1
The src ours hal ve ii l
2
j rs cino al i i a to swheetematri c nr ves e c e st es m o v l o
u idito f 1cvl cin
r h te n o to ry x e d h u r aue f
$75, excusveofi eessa c t,a i bewee . . tze ofdifr tStts'
000, l i
ntr t nd oss nd s t n . Cii ns feen ae .).
C oncl on
usi
Fort r as s a ed, he pl i if sm oton t quas w ilbe de ed. The pl ntf w ilbe
he e ons t t t
a ntf
i o
h l
ni
ai i f l
die t d t fl a r pons t t de e
r c e o ie es
e o he f ndan ' m oton t di m i sw ihi f fe n days
ts i o s s t n ite
.
The Cl r i die t d t s c esoft s m e or ndum o ni n a t a com pa ng
e k s r c e o end opi
hi m a
pi o nd he c
nyi
or rt t pl i if a a lc
de o he a ntf nd l ouns ofr co d.
el e r
ExvER: i :. d yo Jl, 4.
r Ths 3 a f uy 201
Chi fU nie St t s D i ti tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?