Minor v. Tyson Foods, Inc.
Filing
16
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/7/2014. (mab)
CEKARxj .vTTUT
LR'OFEo DA( (y
STosS I. R
FI x S (
C
F. v(
lo w
t
n
2C' 27 2 1
f
29
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I I I
CT
RG N A
CH A RLO TTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI
j
'
J I%D D E,
ULA
YC
'
.
UI t R
' =
'
Y
BY:
K
'
LEW I S A LLY ' M I OR , R .
St
W
' N
J ,
Ci lAc i N o. 1
vi ton
3: 4CV 0001
9
Pl ntf
ai if,
M EM O R AN D UM O PI I N
N O
By: on.G l n E.Conr d
H
e
a
Chi fUnied St t sDititJ
e
t
a e src udge
TYSON FOODS, I C. A
N T/
TY SON FA RM S, N C.
l ,
De e nt
f nda .
ied hi c i n he r t
t
s
Le i $W aly' M i , r , oc di pr K ,fl t sa ton i t Cicui Cour ofLoui a
w s $ 1 ' nor J . pr ee ng o
.
Count a i tTys Foods l (i on' . Tys r
y gans on
,nc.$Tys '
)
on emovedt aci t t sc t t bas
he ton o hi our on he es
o f d rl u sinj rs ito a ddiest u id ci n a dt e mo e t d s s t ec mp an
f e ea q e to u idcin n v ri rs ito , n h n v d o imis h o lit
yj
purua t Rul 1 b)6 oft FedealRul ofCi lPr e e. Fort f l ngras ,t
s nt o e 2( ( ) he r
es vi oc dur
he olowi e ons he
cour w ilg a Tys sm oton.
t l r nt on'
i
Backzround
M i i a A f i n- e i a f r e . On Fe ua y 1 2009, e e ed i o at e - r
nor s n r ca Am r c n a m r
br r 3,
he nt r nt hr e yea
c nr c wihTy o t r ieb o lrc c e o h sfmi sfr i Lo s Co ny, r ii (h
o ta t t s n o a s r ie hik ns n i a l am n uia u t Vigna t e
y'
û oduci Conta f'. Unde t tr oft Pr ton Conta t M i wa r ponsbl fr
d
pr ton
rc )
r he ems he oduci
rc, nor s es i e o
S c sngf dgndlme ci ,..., ngpr negas...i or rt ke pt bidswam
f ha i ee a
pur
di nes
buyi opa
n de o e he r
r
durngt coola c dmont ,a s ygngla ot rne esay gtms s ha wae,srw,
i he
nd ol
hs nd uppl i ny he c sr ie ) uc s tr ta
h y, t.no d rma i z (h c ik n ' weg tg i it mau ain. Co l 3 !3 Do k t
a ec i r e xmie t e h c e sq ih an n o t rto ' mp . , , c e
'
No.1 1;seas Pr tonCo rc 1 j3,Compl Ex.A, Doc tNo.1 1(s oduc wil
- e lo oduci
nta t ,
.
ke
- C
pr er l
f ni h l ,m at i s,and utltesnecess y f t r ptofchi
ur s abor
er al
iii
ar or he ecei
ckens and t pr
he oducton of
i
Br l and w ilw hen appr i t s Com pany' t
oiers
l
opr a e eek
s echni advi ...Pr
cal
ce.
oducerw ilm ai ai
l
nt n
.
bi e r housng f Compa sc c ns f e andm e ca i a wilpr
os cu e
i or
ny' hi ke , e d,
di ton, nd l omot adie e-r e
e s as fe
e r
nvionme .'.
nt'
)
l 201 M i madeove $ 000i r par t oneofhi c c ho esa t r que tof
n 0, nor
r 40, n e is o
s hiken us t he e s
Chuck M oo e,Tys s Li Pr
r
on' ve oduc i M a ge . The f l i Febr r Tys dr f s d t
ton na r
olow ng
ua y, on te u e o
s p l hm wi a yb b c c . .' 1 a 4 !7 Al o g t i C a s d g i r n a
u py i t n a y hiks . . d. t , . t u h h s d u e M no l e r
h
'
h
c
c t s r c f na i ll s' he d a s cond s c ofi
a a t ophi i nc a os ,' k
had e
our e ncom e a hi pa e spr de hi l ns
nd s r nt ovi d m oa
f rhso eaint c n iu . l a 4, ! 89.
o i p rto o o tn e' d. t ! '
M i al st tTys e oye atmpedt C co- nage' m. 1 a 5, 1
nor lege ha on mpl es te t o d r ma 'hi d. t ! 2.
mi
The woul e e hi f r C ihou notc a w ihoutpe m i son, a i r abouthi
y
d nt r s a m t t t i e nd t
w
r s i ' nd nquie
'
s
wheea swhe hewasno t r 1 a 5,! 1 3. On o oc son,aTys n e oye
r bout n
t he e. d. t ! 0,
ne ca i
o mpl e
C bsr e g io 'lsse-n lw, Ca c sa fmae' 1 a 5, 1 . Ar u t es met ,
û e v d M n rs itri-a a u a in e l. d. t ! 3 o nd h a i
o
'
me
M i pur s d ane t u k a hi pa e t fnihe consr tng ane hom eon t f r .
nor cha e
w r c nd s r n s i s d
tuc i
w
he a m
M i ra s t t t$( l oft s obs r tonsweesgnst g-s s e o st tt sS r
no sers ha ia1l he e evai
r i o 'y on'j mplyee ha hi neg o
l
w asbec i uppiy'a Af i a Am e i n f r e s s d notow n a new hom e ora ne tuc
om ng
t s r c nrca a m r houl
w r k
a mar Ca sa . l a 5, 1
nd ry uca ins' d. t ! 5.
'
M i alege t tTys e pl s i bl f d't tTys n w a goi t do a
nor l s ha
on m oyee s uf e ha
G
o
s ng o
way w ih
t
ir shous s lket onest tg i lowned. I a 6, l The as S mpl ne ofe
tus
e ' i he
ha M nor
' d. t ! 6. y lo i
'
co ai d tn
t tg io lwa a y fo t fnnt omu h, a dt td sc ik weetoc l o sc ' I
ha M n r s wa r m he a o c ' n ha C hc s r o od r ik. d.
'
hi
'
A ts e poi ,M i a i d f a l n f om Fa m Cr di Bur u i Fr derc bur
om
nt nor pple or oa r
r
e t ea n e i ks g,
Vigi a. Thea i tonwasde e M i ç tongl s pe ts't tt sr ule fo Tys
r ni
pplcai
nid. nor s r y us cgl'ha hi es td rm on
s
e oyee C xpr si d gai crdiwo t nes rmar . l a 6, 1
mpl s i es lngj ne tve e t rhi s' e ks' d. t ! 7.
e
'
By l t dat Januar 11,2012,Ca1M oor Tys sBroierM anager,advi ed M i t
eter ed
y
e, on'
l
s
nor hat
t Pr
he oduc i Contac w oul be t r i t d i 90 da d t ûs rousa m alw e f e i s s on
ton
r t
d e m na e n
ys ue o û e i
ni
lar s ue
2
g io 'l am c u e b g i o 'lna ii t p o d u iiis' Co . . Do k t .1 1
M n rs f r a s d y M n rs i blt o r vie tl e . mplEx B, c e No - .
y
t '
M oo e e pha i ed t tM i had r n ou ofpr ne t he t0ne ofhi c c n hous s i
r m
s z ha nor
u t
opa o a
s hi ke
e n
De embe of2011 a t tei - ol bidsha bc ns j t t tmpe aur asl a 66
c r
, nd ha ghtday- d r d e ubeced o e r t es ow s
de e . M oor al o not d t tM i ' pr ne t nksw e e l a i on J nua y 2,
gr es
e s
e ha nor s opa a
r ow ga n
a r 2012,a
nd
t tTys hadt or ra pa f a tonalpr nei or t ma n a npr rtm pe a ur i
ha
on
o de nd y or ddii
opa n der o i t i ope e r t es n
t c c n hous s
he hi ke
e.
OnM a c 18, 2, .
r h 201 Dr Geor A . t s ntTys n alte onM i ' be f i whi he
ge Baes e
o e tr
nors hal, n ch
of e ed t pr de k e a i a a bir ton s r ce . Com pl Ex. ,D oc tN o.1 1. By
f r o ovi l di ton nd r t a i e vi s '
m
'
. D
ke
l te da e M a c 3 201 Tys de i t of e .
e t r t d r h 0, 2, on clned he f r
M i fl t i t nta ton agans Tys on Aprl9,201 M i ra s t t tt
nor ied he nsa c i
i t on
i
4. no s ers ha he
aci i ç oughtpurua t 42U. C.
ton s d
br
s nt o
S. 2000()oft 1 Ci lRi sAc ... ndAril X of
e he 964 vi ght t a
tce
t U nie St t s Cons iuton,f vi a i oft Thi t e h Am e
he t d a e
tt i or ol tons he r e nt
ndm e oft U nie St t s
nt he t d a e
Cons iuton pur uan t 42 U . C .1 1 1
tt i
s to
S. 98 , 982,a 1985 a f va i usot rf der la s a e
nd
nd or r o
he e a nd t t
c us ofac i s h a br c ofcon r ta t tc ai s oft St t ofV i g ni . . ' Com pl a
a es
ton uc s ea h
t ac nd or l m
he a e
ri a . .
'
.t
Unde t he di S m a s'M i as e t t f l ng:
r he a ng l
Da ge ,' nor s rs he olowi
ForDef ndan ' br ac ofc r c ge r l i no ofe i t Pl i ifmuc
e
ts e h onta t ne aly n t f rng he antf
h
co t uc i gui nce a notg antng t Pl i i ft be ftoft Co lc
nsr tve da
nd
r i he a ntf he ne i he nfi t
Res uton Pr dur t Pl ntf de
ol i
oce e, he ai if mandsda a i t a
m ges n he mountofONE
HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS( 00, 00)
$1 000. .
2. ForD e e nts i e i lda age t t Pl i if s fna i lc edi, he
f nda ' nt ntona m
o he a ntf i nc a r t t
Pl i ifde a da a i t a ountofON E HUN D RED TH O U SAN D
a ntf m nds m ges n he m
DOLLARS( 00, 00)
$1 000. .
3. Fort Pl i if sde rm e t r la e u t D e enda ' m a
he a ntf
t i n al e i nc pon he f
nt s nage e
m nt
diectves,t Pl ntf dem ands act dam agesofFO RTY - O TH OU SAN D
r i
he ai if
ual
TW
DOLLARS( 42, 00)f e ndiur t di noti ovec c pr to
$ 000. or xpe t es hat d mpr hik oducin.
3
4. Fort Def nda ' vi ai nsoft 1 Ci lRi ht Ac a t l h
he e nts olto
he 855 vi g s t nd he 3t
Ame ntoft U. Consiuton(a a dici nai ,hePli ifde nds
ndme
he S. tt i rcil s rmi ton) t antf ma
da sofTW O HUNDRED THOUSAND DOLLARS( 000. .
mage
$200, 00)
I a 8d. t 9.
On J 1 201 Tys m ove t d s ist co pl nt The f l ng da t c t
une 2, 4, on
d o im s he m ai .
olowi
y, he our
ie r tng nor o ie es ns t n i t n ys
is d aRos o1notc dieci M i t fl ar po ewihi tfee da . On J y 8, 4,
s ue
cbor
ul 201
M i tl d a m oton t q s t notce ofr m ova . M i ' m oton w a de e on J y 23,
nor i e
i o ua h he i
e
l
nor s
i
s ni d
ul
i o s s
201 a hew asdi e t d t f l a r pons t Tys sm oton t di m i s The m oton t di m i s
4, nd
r c e o ie es
eo
on'
i o s s.
ha now bee f l br e e a i r pe f di poston.2
s
n uly i f d nd s i or s ii
St
andard ofR evi w
e
Tys hasmo dt dimist c antfrf l et saeacai unde Rul 1 b)6)
on
ve o s s he ompli o aiur o tt l m
r e 2( (
o teFe ea Rue o Ci l o e u e A Rue 1 ()6 moinc alng st elg l u fce c
f h d rl ls f viPr c d r .
l 2b () to h le e h e a s fiin y
oft c ant Fr i v.Gic li588F. 1 l ( hCi.2009) t t
he ompli . ancs
a omel,
3d 86, 92 4t r
. s hough apr s
Al
oe
ltga ' pl a ngs a e t be c tued lbe a l hi c pl i tm us c ai f ct la l ga i
ii nt s e di
r o
onsr
i r ly, s om a n
t ont n a ua le tons
s f c e to r s a r ghtt r le a
uf i i nt t ai e i o e i f bove t s c a i l vel a t t C t t a c ai t r le t t
he pe ul tve e ' nd ha s a e l m o e i f ha
i plusbl onisfce.' Hodgev. nser 5 F. x209,2l ( hCi.201 (uoi Bel
s a i e t a ''
Ga l , 47 App'
0 4t r 3) q tng l
At. Twombl 550U. 544,555(
lv.
v,
S.
2007). Thi i a i lt sandadr uiesaplitf t
)
s k usbiiy t r eq r
pl
anif o
de ons r t m or t n a s e pos i lt t ta de e nthasac ed unl w f l ' Fr nci ,588
m tae
e ha
he r s biiy ha
f nda
t
a uly.' a s
F. a 1
3d t 93. W hie t c ' m us t cc ptt w e lpl d a l ga i oft c pl i astue '
l he oul
t t û e he l- e le tons he om a nt r ,'
a
l rav.UniedStts 1 F.d 472,474( hCi.1 ) ûsaeme sofbaelgalc usons
bar
t ae , 20 3
4t r 997 ,çtt nt
r e oncl i
1Ros bor v. Gars n 5 F. 3 9(t Ci.1 5 .
e o
rio , 28 2d 0 4h r 97 )
2 Net sder quesed ahea i ont moton, a t cour ha de e nedt or ar
iher i e t
rng he i nd he
t s t nni hat al gume woul
nt
d
notad i t de sonalpr s
i n he cii
oce s.
4
k r note il d t t as um pto oftut a a e i uf i i ntt s a e a c a m .' Azi v. l ol c.
ae
ntte o he s
i n r h' nd r ns fc e o t t l i '
z Ac a
l , F. 388,391( hCi. 1 ( i As of v.nbal556U. 662,679(
nc.658 3d
4t r 201 ) quotng hcr t l ,
S.
2009:.
Di
scuss on
i
1.
C l m s under f
ai
ederall
aw
I mo i t d s s t ec mpan u d rRu e1 ( )6 , o a g e t a M io h s
n vng o imis h o lit n e l 2 b ( ) Tys n r u s h t n r a
f ie t sae a a tona e c am f r le unde a oft f der lsaut y orc tt i l
al d o t t n c i bl l i or ei f
r ny he e a t t or
onsiutona
pr sonsr er nce i t co pl nt Fort f l i r as ns t c ta e .
ovi i
ef e d n he m ai .
he olow ng e o , he our gr es
A.
42 U. C.$ 2000( )
S.
e
M i rtrta s rst tt sa toni br
no is s e t ha hi ci s oughtpurua t ( U. C.
s nt o $ S. 2000( giloft
42
e) sc he
Ci lRi sAc of196 ' Com pl a 1. Til Vl oft Ci lRi sAc ,c fe a 42 U. C.
vi ght t
4.
'
.t
te 1 he vi ght t odiid t
S.
jj2000et 2000e- 7,pr bisC mpl rs'fom e
o
1 ohi t i oye gl'r ngagi i dicrmi t y i mpl
e
ng n s i naor c oymen
e
t
pr cies' 42U. C.j2000e- a)l. l i welstl t tt saut spr e tonsextndonl
a tc .
'
S.
2( ( ) t s l eted ha he tt e' otci
e
y
t e pl s a nott i pe ntc r t s See Fa l v. a hovi Ba z ofN . . N . .
o m oyee nd
o nde nde ontac or .
row W c
a lk
C. A,
259F. 309,31 ( hCi. ) Cie ekv.novaHe 1hSvs Se vs,11 F. 256,261( hCi.
3d
3 4t r 2001 4 lc I
at . r . 5 3d
4t r
1 .
997)
U pon r vi w oft c pl i a t a t c Pr
e e
he om a nt nd he ta hed oducto Conta ,t c tc ude
in
r ct he our oncl s
t tM i hasf l t s a e a c ai unde Til V 1 . U nde t t r soft Pr
ha nor
aied o t t l m
r te l
r he e m
he oduc i Cont a t
ton
rc,
M i a e d t pr depr ton s l ce f rTys a a i nde
nor gr e o ovi
oduc i ewi s o
on s n k pende c r t 'f a
i
nt ontacor' or
t e - a peid. ComplEx. a j8. Mi rdoesno cl m t thewa a e o eofTys
hreye r ro
. A t
no
t ai ha
s n mplye
on,
5
a hi c pli l c s fcintf t t e t bls t e se eofa e oye - m pl
nd s om a nt a ks ufi e ac s o sa ih he xitnc
n mpl re oyee
rlto hi. Co s q nl , io ' Til V1 cam i s be t od s sa u de Rue 1 b ()3
eains p
n e ue ty M n rs te l li s u j c t imis l n r l 2()6 .
B.
A r i l X o t U nied St e C ons i ut o
t c e f he
t
at s
tt i n
M i r a s a s r st tt s a ton i br
no l o s e t ha hi c i s oughtpur ua t A ri l X oft U nie St t s
s nt o tc e
he t d a e
Co tt i
nsiuton. AsTys expl nsi isbre i s
on
ai n t if n uppor oft i t ntm o i n, heCo tt i
t he nsa
to t
nsiuton
c it ofonl s ven Ar i es Ac di y, hi a l gaton f l t s a e a cl i upon whi h
ons s s
y e
tcl . cor ngl t s le i ais o t t
am
c
r le m a be g a t d.
e if y
r ne
C.
Thi t ent A m e
re h
ndm e t t U nied St e C ons i ut on
nt o he
t
at s
tt i
M i rscam u d rt eThite t Ame me ti as s be tt ds sa u e Rue
no ' li n e h re nh
nd n s lo u jc o imis l nd r l
1 b)6 . Tha Ame me sae t tkg eihe sa r nori unt ys r t ,e e a a
2( ()
t nd nt tts ha ûnq t r lvey nvol ar eviude xc pt s
punihm e f c i e w he eoft pary s l ha bee dul c c e s le s w ihi t
s nt or rm
r he t ha l ve n y onvi t d, hal xi t t n he
UntdS ae , ra yplc s b e t ot ij rs ito ' U. Co tAm . 1. l i itn e to
ie tts o n a e u j c t her u idcin. S. ns. XII ts n e d d d
'
t
c rt e f r s ofcom pul or l bora n t Af i a s a r whi h i pr c i alope a i w oul
ove hos o m
s y a
ki o r c n l ve y
c n a tc
r ton
d
tndt pr elkeunde ia er uls' Unie Stt v.Koz ns ,487U. 931 942( 988)
e o oduc i
srbl es t.' td aes
mi ki
S. ,
1
(ntr lcttona quottonma ksomitdl seas HendonbyHendo v.Cha l
i ena iai nd ai
r
te ; e lo r
r n
pe
Hilcar oCiyBd.ofEd .89F. 1 1 1( hCi.1 )( di t tac
l- rbor t
uc,
3d 74, 8 4t r 996 hol ng ha ommuniy
t
s r ierq rme t sinn wa c mp rbl t t eh ni l ij sieo h ma sa r 'a ,
evc e uie n wa û o y o aa e o h o be nu tc f u n lvey' nd
i
t ,di t vi aet Thite hAme ntprhi tonofi untr s r t ' ;Stierv.
hus d t olt he re nt
not
ndme o bii
nvol ay eviude' er
l
Behlhe Ar Sc Dit,987F. 98 999( Ci.1 (k odenda e mpl of
t e m ea h. s.
2d 9, 3d r 993) d
M r y xa es
3EvniMi rh dalg ds fce tfcst etbihta h wa a e oy eo Tyo hsTil Vl
e f no a le e ufiin at o sa ls ht e s n mjl e f sn, i te l
cam woudn neh ls b s j c t ds sa f rlc o s be t te j rs ito ,snc t r i n
li
l o tee s e ube t o imis l o a k f u j c ma tr u idcln i e hee s o
i cai t tM i fl achar ofdicrmi i wih t Equa Empl e Opporuniy Commison.
ndi ton ha nor ied
ge
s i naton t he
l
oym nt
t t
si
Se Baa v Hu tngo l al ld .l .711F.d4 , 06( t Ci. 01 )CçF e ea c rslc s b e t
e ls . ni tn ng l n us,nc,
s
3 01 4 4h r 2 3 ll d rl ou t a k u jc
matr u idcino e Til Vl camsf rwhc apantf ha fie t e ha s a mi srtv rme e .)
te j rs ito v r te l li o ih li if s ald o x u t d nitaie e dis'
'
(iigJ ne v. l r Gr , d.55lF.d29 ,3 0(t Ci. 00 :.
ctn o s Cavet p.Lt ,
3 7 0 4h r 2 9
i unt r s r t ha bee lmie t lborca ,iol t r lgi s t , f ce
nvol a y e viude ve n i t d o a
mps s aed ei ous ec s or or d
c i men .)
onfne t'
'
He e,t f c salege i s
r he a t l d n uppor ofM i ' Thite h Am e e cli smpl do not
t
nors re nt
ndm nt a m i y
m e tt ssa r He ha notale d a hi Skki t Afi a sa r ora m ode n
e hi tnda d.
s
l ge nyt ng ka n o rc n lve y' ny
r
a aog . Za l v W a- a t tr sI .6 F.d 5 , 40(d Ci. 01 ) Ac o dngy h s
n l ue' vaa . lM r So e nc, 91 3 27 5 3 r 2 2 . c r i l, i
'
Thite h Am e e cai m us bedim is
re nt
ndm nt l m
t
s s ed.
D.
42 U. C.kk 1
S.
981.198 and 1
2.
985
Mi 'c
nor s ompli alo f ist sa ea aci na e ca m sf r edic i nai i
a nt s al o t t ny to bl li or ac s rmi ton n
vi ai of42U. C.jj 1 ,1 a 1
olton
S.
981 982, nd 985. Amongot deiinci , i ' co l or
her fce es M nors ncus y
a srinta Tys na tdwihrca a i si s p o tdo l b s e uain a dc n e tr .
se t h t o ce t a il nmu s u p re ny y p c lto n o j cu e
o
Se Compl! 1 1 ( udi wihoutf t s ' t thi new tuc a hi pae s ne
e
. ! 4- 5 concl ng, t acual uppol,ha s
t
r k nd s rnt' w
homek r sgnst g ys emplyee t tt snegowasbec ngu t ). Hedoe not
s e i o ' onl
we
r
o s ha hi r
omi ppiy'
s
alege a f c st tpl us bl s
l
ny a t ha a i y ugges t tTys s de i i n t t m i e t Pr
t ha
on' c s o o er nat he oduc i Cont a t
ton
rc
w asm otva e by r c l t a e ofs h f c s t c t us di m i sM i r sc a m sunde
i td
a e. n he bs nce uc a t , he our m t s s
no ' l i
r
t ciedcvi rg ssat e . SeeFrnci v.Gi omeli588F. l 1 ( h Ci.2009)
he t i l iht t uts
a s ac l,
3d 86, 97 4t r
(fimi t dimis oft pl nif'cli unde j1 wheet plitfsfie t plad
afr ng he s sal he aitfs am
r 985 r he anif ald o e
s cii f c sde ons r tng t tt def nt w e e éi otva ed by a s cii c a s ba ed,
pe fc a t m t a i ha he enda s r im i t
pe f c l s - s
iviiu l d srmi aoya i t g d p i teplitfl jo t e u l n o me to rg t
n do sy ic i n tr nmus o 1 e rve h an its f he q a e j y n f ih s
s c e byt lw t al' (uoi Si
e urd he a o l'' q tng mmonsv. 47F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) J r n
)
Poe, 3d 370, 376 4t r 995); o da
v. tr tveRes Co .458F. 332,347(t Ci.2006)(fimi t dimis oft
Alenai
. p,
3d
4h r
afr ng he s sal he
pli ifsdici nai cai unde j 1 lwher t pl ntf sf t lalegai pr vi dno
antf s rmi ton l m
r 98
e he ai if acua l tons o de
s
uppor f t û oncl or ' s ri t rcewa amotvai f t i hi tr nain)
t or he ' us y'ase ton hat a
c
s
i tng acor n s emi to .
Il.
R em ai na cl m s
ni
ai
M i a t m pt t a s r a num be ofot r c a m s i s cton 11 ofhi c pl i . Fort
nor te s o s e t
r
he l i n e i 1
s om a nt
he
f l' i r s ns t ec u t o cu e ta e c o t s camsi s b e t od s sa.
olow ng ea o , h o r c n ld s h t a h f hee li s u j c t imis l
I pa a a 1ofs ton11M i s e t rc rda sigl Defnda ' br c of
n r grph
eci 1, nor e ks o e ove mage lfor e nts ea h
c nr c g n r l i no o frn (i mu hc n tu tv g i a c a dn tg a tn gi te
o ta t e eal n t fe ig hmj c o sr cie u d n e n o rn ig hm) h
y
be i oft Cont c Re ol i Pr e e. Compla 8,! 1 Asdefom t salegai
neft he lit s uton oc dur '
'
.t
. i r hi l ton,
not ng mor i s d a
hi
e s ai boutt cli f br ac ofc r c . M i doesno ct t a pa tc a
he a m or e h onta t
nor
t ie o ny riul r
c r c ua pr vi i ,orpr de a a to lalega i t s
ont a t l o s ons
ovi ny ddii na l tons o uppo thi as e ton t tTys s
r s s r i ha
on'
ac i c tt e abr ac oft Pr uc i n Co r c . B e a e t br c o c r c c a m i
tons ons iut d
e h he od t o
nt a t
c us he ea h f ont a t l i s
nots
uppored by i noug f c st s a ea cl i t r le t ti pl usbl on isf ce ' Tw om bl 550
t
d
e
h a t o tt
a m o e i f ha s a i e t a ,'
v,
U . a 570, hi por i oft c pl i m us be di m i s d.
S. t
t s ton he om a nt
t
s se
l paa rph2o s cin11 M io r q et $1 00 00 ito Dee d n ' i tn in l
n r ga
f e to 1, n r e u ss 0 ,0 .0 sl r f n a ts ne to a
l
da g t g s fna ca ce i. Co l8 !2. Th seam i as s b e t d s sa ,i c t e
ma e o hi) i n il r dt' mp . ,
'
i li s lo u j d o imis lsn e h
c ti u bl t dice n wha pa tculrc us ofa to M i ri at mptng t a s t Se ,e. ,
our s na e o s r
t ri a a e c i n no s te i o s er. e c.
Nanc v. tmorg ae l , l:3CV1 201 U. DitLEXI 1
e Cii tt e nc.No. l
a
062, 4 S. s.
S 08871 a *31( . N.
, t M D. C.
Aug.7,201 ( s si t pli ifscam f rS glge a ori e i lda get cedi
4) dimisng he antf' li o k i nt nd/ ntntona ma o r t
ne
rpor'sncet c t unabl t deemi ( tt ofcli ghepl ntfs i ende t
e t' i he our was
e o tr ne û
wha ype am t ai if) nt d o
b i f'. Mo e v r t c mplitma e ce rt th cam i b s do mees c lto , ih
rn )
r o e,he o an k s la ha te li s a e n r pe u ai n wh c
i i ufi intt s tsyt pladi r quie nt ofRul 1 b)6) Se Compl6, 1 ( antf
s ns tce o aif he e ng e rme s
e 2( ( . e
. ! 7 Pli if
C us t t t.. t Def nda ' e pl es . . xpr s d S ga i c e t o t nes ' e a kst
û pec s ha . he e nt s m oye . e es e ne tve r diw r hi s r m r o
s
t g r Cr tBur uqwhihca e t m t de t Pli ifsl n .. .)(mpha i a d)
he Fam edi ea
c us d he o ny he antf oa .' e
'
ss dde .
Fi l i paragr 3 ofs i 1 1 M i atem pt t as a cl m f Sdet i ent
naly, n
aph
ecton 1 , nor t
s o sert ai or i rm al
r inc upont Def ntsma ge ntdie tve ' I a 9, 3. Howe r i i pe nt
ela e
he enda ' na me r ci s. d. t !
'
ve,t nde nde
no
c eofa ton f derm e a r la e e ss'
aus
c i or ti nt l ei nc xit'underVigi alw . Gua di n Pha ofEa t nl
r ni a
r a
nn.
se
N C.LLC v.W e rCiy H e lhc e N o.2: 2c
be t
a t ar ,
1 v00037,201 U . D it LEX I 9937,a * 3 S. s .
S
t 21 22
( . Va.J n.24. 3)(ii c s s. Acc di y,hi cam mus bedimis d.
W D.
a
201 ctng a e )
or ngl t s li
t s se
C oncl i
us on
Fort r s nssa e t c t l gr ntt de e
he ea o t t d, he our wil a he f ndan ' m o i n t dim is TheClr i
ts to o s s .
ek s
die t t s nd c rii d co e oft sme o a
r c ed o e e tfe pis hi m r ndum opi on a t a ompa ng or t t
ni nd he cc
nyi
der o he
pl ntf a a1 c
ai if nd 1 ouns ofr cor
el e d.
'
y - obe, 4.
oc
Ex 'ER : s -N da ot t r 201
r
Thi 1
+1
i4- .7
. .
Chi U nie St t D i t i tJ
ef t d a es sr c udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?