Price Automotive II, LLC v. Mass Management, LLC, Edison 2 Motors et al

Filing 75

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/22/2015. (ssm)

CLERK' OFFI U t. DI COURT
S
C: 7 ST.
AT F<s.r Ki,
k' j .) i VA
7N

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
'
FO R THE W ESTERN D I f CT OF VI I I
STRI
'
RG N A
*
'
CHA RLOTTESV I
LLE DI I ON
V SI

FLJ
1tl
'
a

'

..' : '''!'
* r ,,'à-r
' '' .-:è,'r
1.i 7-----r'
! d --i--,'
1;
.
t
'
. r-' :
- l'1 -g
r -.l :.. l
.

,--;
..
-

JU(!
-A

. ,
-

?, '.zj cu -'
trL- f :q
I
f

PR I AU TO M OTI E I LLC,
CE
V I,

Pl i if
a ntf ,

Ci lA c i N o.3: 4CV 00029
vi ton
1

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI
M A SS M AN A G EM EN T,LLC, SON
EDI
2 M OTORS,a V igi a lm ie la lt
r ni i t d i biiy
com pany,eta1,
.

By:
Hon. e E.Co a
Gln
nr d
Chi fUnie Stt DititJ
e
td aes src udge

Def nda s
e nt .
I t s di r iy a ton,t pl i if Pr c Aut otve 1 ,LLC,c a m st tt de enda s
n hi ve st c i he a ntf , i e om i l
l i ha he f nt
c pie t s la ve c et twasr pr en e t be a a he i 1 6 M as r t 300S t t
ons r d o el
hi l ha
e es t d o
n ut ntc 95
eai
o he
pl i if sas i , nd t wha t pl ntf a isas i
a ntf ' s gnor a hat t he ai i f nd t s gnorac ua l pu c s d wasa c e f t
t ly r ha e
ount r ei
vehi l The c e i pr s nty be or t cou ton t de e nt 'm otonst di m i st de Rul
c e.
as s e e l f e he r
he f nda s
i o s s m r e

12( ( )oft Fe r lRulsofCi lPr ce e. Fort r s stf t bel t moto wil
b)6 he de a e
vi o dur
he ea ons e orh ow,he ins l
be g a e wih r s c t t pli ifscli f s i da es butwilot r s bede e
r ntd t e pe t o he antf
am or pecal mag ,
l he wie
ni d.
Bac ound
kzr
The f l i f t , a f o t pl ntf ' s c a e d c pl i t a e a c t d as
olow ng ac s t ken r m he ai i f s e ond m nde om a n , r c ep e
t u f pu pos oft de e nt 'm otons t di m i s Se Er c o v.Pa dus 551 U . 8 94
r e or r es he f nda s
i o s s . e i ks n
r ,
S. 9:

(
2007)
.
M a e a i a lala c rm an a t e , oduce a lm ie num be of 3
s r t, n t i n a
uf c ur r pr
d i td
r 00S r ci c r
a ng a s

bewe n 1 a 1
t e 955 nd 958. Thos sili e se a ehi hl c t d by a omobiec lc o s
e tl n xitnce r g y ove e
ut
l ole t r .

l 200 Olve Kutner(i t r',heprncpa ofM a sM a me ,LLC, s 2
n 4, i r t ç ne')t i i l
Kut
s nage nt
Edion

Motr (s sM a ge f', r ha e ac ssf aM aert3005t twasde i dbyPee
os ç
Mas na men )pu c s d hasi or s ai
ha
sgne
tr

$3. 000USD (hr milo t hundrdffyt a USdola s wilbedue
250,
t ee lin wo
e i' housnd
t
lr) l
f ( wee fom daeofsgni Thebuye ha t rg t wihhol $1 000
our 4) ks r
t i ng.
r s he iht o t d 00.
USD ( hu ed t a US dola s fom fna pa e t s lri f a
one ndr hous nd
lr ) r i l ym nt o ele f or ny

r s nt r tr i me ine a i no c ee wihi t f ( we ks
ea o he esoaton nto d bove s t ompltd t n he our 4) e
fom da e of s g ng.
r
t
i ni

I buye i no ha wiha ofhi tndi durngt t ( wee d
f r s t ppy t ny s i ngs i he wo 2) ks ue
dii nc pe i ors ner he c n t r i t t s c t a t Sha lbuye t r i t
lge e rod oo , a e m na e hi on r c .
l
r e m na e
t s c r t he w ilr ce ve fom s l rhi de i, c i f l t be bal w ie
hi ontac ,
l e i r
ele s pos t ba k n ul, o
z rd
k
bac t Cl s i l s m e s l wihi t e b i s da ofve ba orwr te
k o a s c nve t nt nc. t n hr e usne s ys
r l
it n
t r i to oft sc r t
e m na i n hi ontac .

2 Am .
d
Compl Ex.E. TheAm e d Bilo Saef t pr de t tt i or ton c ai d
.
nde l f l urher ovi s ha he nf ma i ont ne

i t a re n i çr ea dc re t'a t th a re n ds d u d r n liso p ru y'
n he g e me ts i u n o rc, nd ha t e g e me t s ma e n e pe ate f ej r .
t
'
i
'
I
d.
The pl i ifpr de t tna i f t pur ha e oft V e c e,a Cl s c
a ntf ovi d he i nc ng or he c s
he hi l nd as i

I t e sas i d t Am e d BilofSaet t pl ntf. Afe wii $3, 000t
nvesm nt sgne he
nde l
l o he ai if
tr rng 200, o
Kutne a M a sM a
t r nd s
nage nt t pl ntf la nedt tt Ve c ewa no a he i . The
me , he ai if e r
ha he hil s t ut ntc
pl i ifde i t t ke pos e son oft Ve cl a r quese ar f
antf clned o a
ss i
he hi e nd e t d e und. Ho ve ,Kutne
we r
t r
r us t r tzn t pl ntf sm one
ef ed o e tr he ai i f
y.
ProceduralH i oa
st

On M a c 21 201 t pl i iffl t i t nta ton a i tK utne ,M a s
r h , 4, he a ntf ied he nsa c i ga ns
t r s

M a ge e ,Amse , Re Li i t Unie Stt Diti tCour f t Dititof
na m nt
tr and d ne n he t d aes src
t or he src

Coo a o. OnJ n 3 201 t ec s wa ta serdt t i dsrc o tepat s j it to
lrd
u e , 4,h a e s rn fre o hs itit n h ri ' on moin.
e
The ea t r t pl ntf tl d is fr ta e
r fe , he ai i f i e t i s m nded c pl i a i tt de e
om a nt ga ns he f ndan s whi h
t, c
a s r e t f l i c a m s a t lf a aga ns Kutne , a sM a
s e t d he olow ng l i : c ua r ud i t t r M s
nage e ,a A m se
m nt nd
tr

(
Count1;fa e co e me agans Kutner Mas Mana me ,a Amser( unt1)
) rudulnt nc al nt i t t , s
ge nt nd
t Co 1.
,
co tuci fa ag ns aloft de e nt ( nt11.cvic piac ag ns a1oft
nsr tve rud ai t 1 he f nda s Cou 1) i l ons r y ai t l he
,

defnda s(
e nt Count1 ;saut yc piac a i taloft dee nt (
V) tt or ons r y gans l he fnda s CountV) r s si of
; ecison

c nr c a an t tne a M a s a a e n ( u t ) a db e c o c nr c a an t t r
o ta t g i s Kut r nd s M n g me t Co n V1; n r a h f o ta t g is Kut
ne
a M a sM a ge nt( tVI)
nd s na me Coun l.
The def nt s eque l m ov t di m i st fr ta e d co pl nti ise ie y
enda s ubs
nty
ed o s s he i s m nde m ai n t ntr t

purua t Rul 1 b)6)oft Fe rlRul ofCi l oc dur Thec ur hedahezngo t
s nt o e 2( (
he dea es viPr e e.
o t l ai n he
de e nt 'm o i nson Se e r1 201 Durng t hea i i r pons t a gumen s
f nda s to
pt mbe 0, 4.
i he rng,n es e o r
t
r ga di t s fcinc oft a lga i wih r s tt Am se , heco ta s t pa tes
e r ng he ufi e y he le tons t e pec o
tr t
ur dvied he ri
t ti woul pe m i t pl i ift fl as c a
ha t
d r t he antf o ie e ond mend c
ed ompl i ,a t ti woul r er e
ant nd ha t
d es v
r i on t pe ng m oto .
ulng he ndi
i ns

On Se e r24, 4,t pli tf fl d as ond a e d c
pt mbe
201 he a n if ie ec
m nde ompl nt t whi Am se
ai , o ch
tr
a Red Li fl a he m oton t di m i s Them otonst dim i sha be n f l bref d a
nd
ne ied not r i o s s .
i o s s ve e uly i e nd
ar rpe f rr vi .
e i o e ew
St
andard ofRevi
ew

W he de di amotont dimisfrf l et saeacam t rRul 1 b)6) t
n ci ng
i o s s o aiur o tt li mde e 2( ( ,he
c tmus ac e a tuealwe lpla al tonsa dr w a1 r as bl f c ua i e e si
our
t c pt s r 1 l- e ded legai
nd a l e ona e a t l nf r nce n

t pl ntf' fvo . ViolS. v.Prmeos Shi ngCo.708F.d527 53 ( h Ci.201 .
he ai ifs a r t , A. i r e ppi
,
3
, 9 4t r 3)
lW hieaco aitatcke byaRul 1 b)6)motont dimisdoe notne deaiedfcua
t l mpl n ta d
e 2( (
i o s s s
ed t l a t l
alegai , pli ifso i tont pr det gr
l tons a a ntf blga i o ovi he oundsofhi en ilm e t r le r r mor
s tte nt o ei f equies e
t n lbel a c usons a af mul i r cia i o t e e nt ofac us ofa tonwilno
ha a s nd oncl i , nd or ac e t ton f he l me s
a e ci
l t

do.' Bel lCor v.
' lAt. p. Twombl 550U. 544,55 ( )(ntr ct i a quottonmaks
y,
S.
5 2007 i enal iaton nd ai
r
omit ) To s vvedimis lf fiur t saeacli k c an mus co an s fcint
ted .
ur i s sa or al e o tt am,k omplit t nti ufi e
a
f ualm ater accept astue,t ' t e a cl m t r i t i pl i e on is f '' A s oft
act
t ,
ed r o s at
ai o elef hat s ausbl
t ace.'
hcr

v.Iba,55 U. 662,678( 9)( i Twombl 550U. a 57 . l rvi ngaRul
g l 6 S.
200 quotng
v,
S. t 0) n e ewi
e
1 b)6 moton,hec tma c i rt c ant isatc nt,a doc nt G ta he
2( () i t our y onsde he ompli ,t ta hme s nd ume s t tc d
a

t ()mo int ds s , oln a t e aeitg a t t c mp an a da t e tc' Se ' o
o a to o imis s o g s h y r ne r lo he o lit n u h ni . cy f
'
Stt f Dee v. i eNavcai Lt ,484F.d700,705( hCi. )
ae or fnce Trmbl
i ton d.
3
4t r 2007 .
Di
scusson
i

Fr Cl m s(
aud ai Count 1 1 1
s -1)
A l oft de e nt ha m ove t di m i s t f a cl i sas e t d i Count 1 1 ,a
l he f nda s ve
d o s s he r ud a m
s re n
s , l nd

IIoft s c a e d co pli t Asi cae a
I he e ond m nde m a n .
ndi td bove, hepl i ifa s rscai ofa t l
t
antf s e t l ms cua
f a f a ul ntc ea m e t a c tuc i f a
r ud, r ud e onc l n , nd ons r tve r ud.
A.

Sum m aa of t A pplcabl Law
he
i e

The pa te agr e t tV igi a s t ntve l w a i t t pl i if scl i s To pr va l
r i s e ha r ni ubs a i a pples o he a ntf
am .
e i

on acli ofa t lf a unde Vigi a lw,apl n ifmus pr t f l ng eeme sby
am
c ua r ud
r r ni a
aitf
t ove he olowi l nt

ce ra dc nvn i e ie c :ç1 aflerp e e tto ()o amaeil a t ( ) d
la n o icng vd n e 1 ) as e r sn ain,2 f tra fc, 3 ma e
(
itni n lya dk o n l, 4 wi itn t mila , 5 r la c b t ep rymild a d( )
n e to al n n wi gy ( ) t n e t o se d ( ) ein e y h a t se , n 6
h
r s tng da a t t pa t m ild. Eval ton Re e r h Cor v. e n,439 S. 2d 387,
e uli
m ge o he ry se '
'
ua i
s ac
p. Alqui
E.

390( .1 . dconsr tvefa difr fom a t lfa i t tt mirprs ntto of
Va 994) d tuci r ud fes r cua rud n ha he se e e ain
m a e i lf c i notm ade wih t i e t m i l ad, i m a i e l orneglgenty a t
t ra a t s
t he nt nt o s e but s de nnoc nty
i l lhough
r s tng i da a t t one r yi on i. 1 Vi g ni 1 w al o pr de t tt
e uli n m ge o he
el ng
t' d. r i a a s ovi s ha he
'

ûlj nc ame oro si ofamae ilfct onewhoknowst tt ot rpa t i a tngupo
tc o e l nt mison
tra a by
ha he he ry s ci
n
t as u pton t tt f tdoesnote s c tt e aci na efa ' Ale Reat Cop v.
he s m i ha he ac
xit onsiut s to bl r ud.
' ln
ly

Hol r, 18S. 2d592,597( 1 4) Aswihacua fa bohc tu tvefa a
bet3
E.
Va. 98 .
t t l r ud, t onsr ci r ud nd
faudul ntc e m e m us be pr n by cl a and c nc ng e de e Eva u i n R e e z h
r
e onc al nt t
ove
ez
onvi i vi nc .
l ato
s ac

Cor ,439 S. 2da 390;Spe ev. ifn,3 S. 2d595,598- ( 1 )
p.
E. t
nc Grfi 72 E.
99 Va. 988 .

Frudcai ar s j c t ahei e pl di sa r und t Fedea Rul ofCi l
a l ms e ub e to ghtned ea ng tndad er he rl es vi
Pr e e. Fe r Rul ofCi lPr ed e9( r uie apa t al ngfa t itt wih
oc dur
deal e
vi oc ur b) eq rs ry legi rud o s ae t
s

patc aiyt cr umsa esconsiutngfa .... Fe R. v. 9( . Tostsyt s
riulrt he ic tnc
tt i r ud ' d. Ci P. b)
'
aif hi
s a r t pl i ifm us pl a w ih pa tcul rt S he tm e, a e,a c e s oft f s
t nda d, he a ntf
t e d t r i a iy ' i pl c nd ont nt
t
he al e

r pr s nttons a wel a t i ntt oft pa t m a ng t m ir pr s nt to a wha he
e e e a i , s l s he de iy he ry ki he s e e e ai n nd
t

obti dt r ' Hars nv.W etnghous Sa
ane heeby.' rio
si
e vanna Ri rCo.1 F. 776,786(t Ci.
h ve , 76 3d
4h r

1 9 ) Cll c o c mpl n ewi Ru e9 b ' p e dn rq ie n si te tda afiu et
9 9 . d wa k f o i c t l ( )s la ig e ur me t s rae s alr o
g
a
h
saeacli unde Rul 1 b)6)' J.a 783n.
tt am
r e 2( ( .' 7.t
a
5.
B.

T he K ut ner D efendant
t
s

I movi t dimist pli ifsfa cli , tne a M a sM a eme (he
n
ng o s s he antf' rud ams Ku t r nd s nag nt t
C t rdefnda t' a g t ta pr tpes i si i casi r cngc r woul ha
' ne e n s' r ue ha ny uden ron nve tng n l sc a i as
Kut
)
d ve
m a a s nc e e f t o a ce t i t t ue c ton a pr na e ofaca prort pur hasng i,
de i er f or t s ra n he r ondii nd ove nc
r i o c i t

a t tt pl n ifi unabl t e t bls t ti r s bl r le on t mir pr e a insa
nd ha he aitf s
e o sa ih ha t ea ona y e id he se es nt to nd
omisonsa is
si
t s ue. Att ssag oft pr ee ngs howe r t co ti una et a ee The
hi t e he oc di ,
ve , he ur s bl o gr .
i s ofwhe he a pa t sr la wasr as bl i or na iy a que ton f t t i roff c t
s ue
t r
ry' e i nce
e ona e s di r l
s i or he re
ato

d tr ne S eBa ko M o te lv S g e Bat,1 3F.d 8 8 8 4( t Ci.1 9 )( tn t t
eemi . e n f nra . in t r 9 3 1 , 3 4h r 9 9 noig ha
k

ter a o a ln s o apa t srla c i ai u sinl t bed cd db t ej r i lg to ,ne
h e s n be e s f ry' ein e s i e t ) o e i e y h u y n ih f itr
q o
a i,t naur oft pari a t ta aci t r pr s n a i ,omisons a ditaci ns
la he t e he tes nd he r ns ton,he e e e t tons
s i , nd sr to

pr e e byt def nt a t dute o i si tona s dbyt pli if';M ilrv.
es ntd he enda , nd he is f nvetgai sume
he antf ) le
PrmirCor ,608F. 973,982(t Ci.1 (mphaszi t tt (is ofr inc a
e e
p.
2d
4h r 979) e
i ng ha he lsues ela e nd

r a o a ln s, o n a te d t s be tv sae o mi a a pl ain o o j cie
e s n be e s g i g s h y o o u jcie tts f nd nd p i to s f b e tv
c
sa r ofr a ona ene s aepre ne l fcua is sf t tiroffc ) As umi t
tndads e s bl s , r e mi nty a t l sue or he re a f'. s ng he
t t oft pl ntf s alegatonsregar ng t m i epr
nlh he ai if' l i
di he sr esent i m ade by Kutnerand Am ser,
atons
t
t

t c tc l
he our onc udest tt a l ga i pl us bl s ts y t sel m e . See e. , lo' v. r a
ha he le tons a i y a i f hi e nt
- g. Eli t G e t
t

Poi Pa t rsLLC,No.1:Oc 01 2011U. DitLEXI 8 ,at*1 20( D.Va J 5,
nt rnes
1 v1 9,
S. s.
S 27
9- E.
. an.
8

2 1 (-ha Plitfsdi no c n uc t i o iv siaini n t na ou eb r oterfa d
01 ) ll t an if d t o d ther wn n e tg to s o a bs lt a t h i ru
tc am . l i plusbl t tt i lc ofi tgai wasnoti is l unr s bl ,a i i
li
t s a i e ha her a k nvesi ton
n te f ea ona e nd t s
pl usbl t teve t n t y m a be e us d f o t tdut A s um i t ve ac t ofPl i if '
a i e ha
n he he
y
xc e r m ha y. s ng he r iy
a ntf s

al ga i a tki t m i t c nt xtoft Compl ntasawhol t Compli plusbl
le tons nd a ng he n he o e
he
ai
e, he
ant a i y

s ssane ilme t rle .)
ugget
ntte nt o eif' .
'

Th c u t s l e s rj d t eKu te d f n a t'ag me t h t h fa dcamsae
e o r mu t i wie ee h tn r ee d ns r u n t a t e ru li r
k
ba r d by t pr sonsoft Ame d BilofSae,whih pe tedt buye t i pe tt
re
he ovii
he
nde l
l
c nnit he
r o ns c he
Ve cea t tr i t t a e nti t buy wa ( ha wih a ofhi fndi durng
hil nd o e m na e he gr eme f he er s k
not ppy t ny
s i ngs i

t t ( wee duedii nc pe i ' 2dAm.
he wo 2) ks
lge e rod.
'
ComplEx. Unde Vigi alw, nta t l
. E.
r r ni a co rcua
dicai r a ei a p o a tc'a i tfa cli s Hia hiCr di Am , p . Si ne
s l me s r '
not r phylc i' gans r ud am . t e
e t
Co v, g t

Bank,1 F. 61 630( h Ci.1 ) Thus kfa i vi li d
66 3d 4, 4t r 999 .
,s n ndi dua s upedi oe ei i oa
i
nt ntrng nt n
a r e e t ts m e a e e c o t ke a a t i vi l sr gh t s f fa '
g e m nt ha a
gr em nt mm t a w y he ndi dua ' i t o ue or r ud.
'

Na ginv.unoLoudon,
hi a J
LLC, F.
684 Supp. 731 740( D. 201 ;s as FS Phot I
2d , E. Va. 0) ee lo
o.nc.

v Pitrviin.n .61F. p 2d47 , 81( D. .1 9 )(( meg rca eb r o fa d
. cu e so I c,
Su p.
3 4 E. Va 9 9 iA) r e lus o n f ru
(
s d notbea l
houl
lowedt i
o mmuni et fa e co
z he r udulnt nduc ; d t r bee nofa t r woul be
t ha he e n r ud he e
d

nomege ca e' . Att ssa oft pr ee ngs t c ti c nc t tt plitf has
r r lus .'
)
hi tge he oc di ,he our s onvi ed ha he anif
ale d s f c en f c st e t bls t tt Am e d BilofSal w ast pr uc off a
l ge uf i i t a t o s a i h ha he
nde l
e
he od t r ud.

Cons que l dhetr oft tagee ntc nnotpr e t(leg y)fa e pa tesfom
e nty,d ems ha r me a
t
otc al edl rudulnt ri r
r pons biiy f t i ac i . N ahi a 68 F.Supp. a 740. Fort e r s ns t
es
i lt or he r tons'
'
gi n, 4
2d t
hes ea o , he
Kutne def nda s m o i w ilbe de e wih r s c t t pl i if sf aud c ai s
t r e nt ' ton l
ni d t e pe t o he a ntf r
lm .
B.

The A m st D ef
er
endant
s

l mo ngt dimist faudcai a i tAmse andRe Li (heçAmse
n vi o s s he r l ms gans
tr
d ne t i tr

d e nt',t Amse defnda sfrta g t tt pl ntf' fa cli aes j ctt
efnda s' he tr e nt is r ue ha he ai ifs rud ams r ube o
)
9

dimis lbe a et s ond a e d c
s s a c us he ec
m nde ompli f ist aleg t ta f ler pr s nttonsof
ant al o l e ha ny a s e e e a i
m a e i f c w e e m a by A m s e . Fort f l i r as ,ho e r t cour i una et
t ral a t r
de
tr
he olow ng e ons w ve , he
t s bl o
agr
ee.

Acc di t t s c
or ng o he e ond a e d co pl i , m s e pr pa ed a r por t tf l e y
m nde m a nt A t r e r
e t ha a s l
de c i t V e c e' c s i a a num be 3 c s sr t rt n a Sha Chas i ,a
s rbed he hi l s ha s s s
r 067 has i a he ha
w
s s nd
a t m pt d t di tngui h t Sha Cha s sf om t V e c e' c s i . The pl i ifa l gest t
te e o s i s he w
s i r he hi l s ha s s
a ntf le
ha

t sr por w a ge r t i a e f t o c nceW at rBa e t tt Ve cewasa he i ,
hi e t s ne aed n n for t onvi
le um r ha he hi l
ut ntc

a t tBa e i r a e Amse ' f ler pr e ai nsi hi o wrte r por, c
nd ha um r nco por t d
t rs a s e es nt to n s wn it n e twhih
Am s e pr de t Cl s c l t e s The pl i ifa l gest tAm s e kne t tBa e '
t r ovi d o as i nvesm nt .
a ntf le
ha
t r w ha um r s

r por i or aed Am se ' f ler pr e ai nspe ti ng t t Ve cl sc ss a t t
e t nc por t
t rs as e es nt to
rani o he hi e' has i, nd ha
Am se i e d f t po e ilpur has rt r l on t r por. As u i t tut oft
t r ntnde or he t nta c e o ey he e t
s m ng he r h he
pli tf sa lga i , heeo tc l
a n if le tons t
ur oncudest tt s o ame d c
ha he ec nd
nde ompl ntsaesapl usbl
ai t t
a ie
ca m f fa bas d o Am se ' m ir e e t tonsr ga di t Vehil sc ss Se
li or r ud e n
t rs sepr s n a i e r ng he
c e' hasi . e

Alxa rv.Sout senW hols l Co p.9 F.Supp. 61 623( D. 201 )($n
e nde
heatr
e ae r , 78
2d 5, E. Va. 3 ;
I
V i g ni a c ai off a doe notr r diec co a torprviy be w e n t de e
r i a, l m
r ud
s
equie r t nt c
i t t e he f ndan a t
t nd he
pl i if A c pl i m us m e el a l t tt d e ntkne o had r a on t know t tt
a ntf .
om a nt t r y lege ha he ef nda
w r
es o
ha he

pli ifwoul rl o t mirpr e ai ' (ii M orarnov. ula tEng' Ser .I ,
antf
d ey n he se esntton.) ctng t i Cons tn
'
g vs,nc.
46 S. 2d778,782( 1 ) s eas Brni v. C Entr.LLC,832F.Su 2d646,653
7 E.
Va. 996)* e lo a n TM
,
es.
pp.
( . Va. 1 ( di t tt pl ntf sae a a tona ecam f acua fa basdon
W D. 201 ) hol ng ha he ai if ttd n ci bl li or t l rud e
f l e r pr s nt to m ade t a t r pa t r r ng a ca ' m iea ,whe e t pl ntf a l ge
a s e e e a i ns
o hid ry ega di
r s l ge
r he ai i f le d
t t def
hat he endanttm i r
' s epres ed t m ieage w ih t know l
ent he l
t he
edge t t m ir
hat he s epresent i
aton

w oul be r pea e t i e a pur has ri t be i vi t ca ha l s m iea t n i a t l
d
e t d o nduc
c e n o le ng he r d e s l ge ha t c ualy

di '
d'
)
10

Thepl ntf alo a lge t tAm serf ley r pr e t d t Ca pe eron muli e
ai if s le s ha
t as l e es n e o r nt
tpl
occ i t tM a e a iw o d c r iy t V e cl asa he i The pl n i fcl i st tA m s e
asons ha
s r t ul e tf he hi e ut ntc.
ai t f a m ha
tr
m a t sr pr s a i t Ca pen e wih s i k l dg t ti w a f s ,a t the di s
de hi e e ent ton o r t r t uperor now e e ha t s al e nd ha
d o

wiht expe tto t tCa e e woul r a t r pr s nt ton t t pl n ifand Cls i
t he
c ai n ha p ntr
d ely he e e e a i o he aitf
a sc
I t nt , nd t tt pl i ifa Cls i I sme swoul r l o i. W hiet Am se
nvesme s a ha he antf nd a sc nve t nt
d ey n t
l he
tr
def nda sc e t tt sal dm ir pr s ntto i nota tona e snc i pe t nst f lr
e nt ont nd ha hi lege s e e e ai n s
c i bl i e t rai o utze
conduc by a t r pa t t co ti unpe s ed.
t
hid r y, he ur s
r uad

k age a r e, fa mus r l t t apr en orpr - xitngf c , nd c nnotor na iy
s
As ner l ul (r ud
t e ae o es t
e e si a t a a
di rl
be pr ca e on unf led pr i e o sa e e t a t f t e e nt .' Pa rck v.Stm m e s 369
edi t d
il
om s s r t t m n s s o u ur ve s '' t i
z
r,

S. 2 1 2 1 4( . 98 )( u t g S bev. r n, S, 2 45 , 6 ( .1 4 ). Ho v r
E.d 6 , 6 Va 1 8 q oi o l Hema 9 E.d 9 4 4 Va 9 0)
n
we e,
t sr ei notwiho e e i . Fori t nce t Supr me Co tofVigi a ha r c ze
hi ul s
t ut xc ptons
nsa , he
e
ur
r ni s e ogni d
t ta cl i f f a t a s m e i e be pr di t d o pr i e w hi h a e m a w ih a pr s nt
ha
a m or r ud t y o tm s
m
e ca e n om s s c r
de t
ee
i t nton nott pe f m t m ,oron pr i e m a w ihouta i t ton t pe f m t m .
ne i
o r or he
om s s de t
ny n en i o r or he '
'

Ll v. t 1 S. 363,365( 1 . i bassfrt e e i i t tçhesaeoft
oyd Smih, 42 E.
Va. 928) '
The i o he xc pton s ha t tt he
pr s ' m i a t tmehema st pr m iei af c s t t i hem ir pr s nt hi sa eof
omior s nd t he i
ke he o s s a t' o ha , f
se e e s s tt
m i ; m i r pr e s at e s i f d .' M e e t i v. . ul r & M a i l .Co. 1
nd, he s e es nt hen xi tng a ''
r ns e n St Pa Fie
rne ns
, 42

F. x 1 1 ( h Ci. )( i Ll 1 S. a 366)
App' 36, 39 4t r2005 quotng ovd, 42 E. t .
Thi e e i ha bee a i d i ca esi vi mir pr e ai çr lt t t
s xc pton s n pple n s nvol ng se es nt tons sea ed o he
pr pe tve c
os c i onduc oft r pa te .' I a 1
t hid ris' d. t 40. l M e e t n,t pli ifalege t toneof
n r nsei he antf l d ha
t de e n ' a nt ,i a e f t o i e t pl i tf t a r e t a m al a tc s tl m e ,
he f nda t s ge s n n f or t nduc he a n if o g e o
pr c i e e te nt
sat 'i unequi
t ed tn
vocalt m st t pr
er hat he oposed s tem ent...woul have no advers or negatve
etl
d
e
i

efec whas ve on(hepli ifs a lt t obt nla lt i u a ec r .' 1 a 1
f t toe r t antf l biiy o ai ibiiy ns r nc oveage' d. t 37.
Si t pl ntf aleged t t agentiknew t hi r esent i w as f se att tm e ofis
nce he ai if l
hat he
û
hat s epr
aton
al
he i
t
11

m a ngn t Fourh Cicui hel t tt ag tsas ur nc whi h c d be k onsr e a a
ki ' he
'
t r t d ha he en ' s a e, c oul
' tu d s
c
pr s ma wih pr s ntfa ulnti e , c tt e as tc e pr di a ef t pli ips
omie de t e e r ud e nt nt' onsiut d ufi i nt e c t or he antf
'

cli ofa t lfa I a 1 s eas Boyki v. r tgeRe t 3 S. 2d 1 17 (
am
cua rud. d. t 40; e lo
n Hemia
alv, 60 E. 77, 9 Va.

1 ( di aveditf t pli if onfaudcamst tweeb edOna s a s
987) uphol ng r c or he antfs r li ha r as
surnce
r r ngt f ur conduc ofat r pa t deveope)
egadi he ut e
t
hid- ry
l r.
l t sca e t pli ifale t tAm se une vocal r pr s e t tM as r t
n hi s , he antf lges ha
t r qui ly e e entd ha
eai
wo d c riy t Ve cl asa he i i or rt i uc t pl i ifa Cl s i l smen st
ul e tf he hi e ut ntc n de o nd e he antf nd a sc nve t t o
pur has t V e cl Thepl i iff t ralege t tA m s e kne t tt sr pr s n a i w a
c e he hi e.
a ntf urhe l s ha
t r w ha hi e e e t ton s
f l e att tm e t ti w a m a
as
he i ha t s de, Co i t w ih t f r oi de s ons t c t
ns sent t he o eg ng cii , he our conc udes
l

t tAmse ' pr s r ga di t f t ec
ha
t r s omie e r ng he ' ur onduc ofat r pa t whi h wa al ge y ma
u
t
hid ry, c
s le dl de
wih pr e fa e i e , onsiut a s fcintpr di ae f t pl i ifscai offa
t es nt r udul nt nt nt c tt es ufi e e c t or he antf l ms r ud.
TheAm se de e nt alo a g t tt sr pr s ntto i nota tona e be a ei i a
tr f nda s s r ue ha hi e e e ai n s
c i bl c us t s
me ee es i ofopi on. W hiem e ee es i ofopi on ge r l ca
r xpr son
ni
l r xpr sons
ni
ne aly nnotf m t bass
or he i
ofa cl i f f a t Su e e Cour ofV igi a h C t...e t bls d a b i lne t s t
a m or r ud, he pr m
t
r ni as d
no
s a ihe
rght i e t o
a c r a n w he he f s r pr e a i c tt t m a tr ofopi o o s a e e s off c .'
s e ti
t r ale e es nt tons ons iu e te s
ni n r t t m nt
a t'

M o trn 46 S. 2 a 7 1 l ta ,ta hc s mu t nalr eme s r b a j d e fo is
raio, 7 E.d t 8 . nse d ' c a e s i ag a u e e du g d r m t
e
own f t ,tki i o consde a i t naur oft r pr cn a i a t m ea ng oft
acs a ng nt
i r ton he t e he e es t ton nd he
ni
he

ln u g u e a a pidt t es j c matra da itprtdb t s ro ndn
a g a e s d s p le o h ube t te n s ne ee y he u r u ig
crumsa s' 1 (ntr ctto a q tto makso te ;seas M ee ti 1 F.
ic tnce . d.i enal iain nd uoain r mitdl e lo rnsen, 42
'
App' a 1 (i ngt sprncpl û riulrysgniian'whe t undel ngc anti
x t 4l fndi hi i i e d tc al i fc t' n he
pa
ryi ompli s
rviwe a t Rul 1 b)6)sa ) l t sc e,hee de ema s t tM a eaiwilnot
e e d t he e 2( ( tge . n hi as t vi nc y how ha s rt l
c r iy t V e c e asa he i ,a t tAm s e wasa a e oft sa t tm e he m a t
e tf he hi l
ut ntc nd ha
tr
w r
hi t he i
de he
r es atonst t contar Becaus A m st sassurances coul be constued asaf im atons
epr ent i o he
r y.
e
er'
d
r
fr i

off c i t sc e , hec 'i una et c l , tt ssageoft pr e di ,ha t y a e
a t n hi ontxt t oul s bl o oncude a hi t
t
he oc e ngs t t he r
no a tona e.
t c i bl

TheAmse d e nt ne aguet tt cli f fa e c eame (
tr efnda s xt r ha he am or r udulnt onc l nt Countl)i
Is

s b e tt ds sa b c us Amse h dn d t t ds l ea yi fr to rg r i gt e
u j c o imis l e a e tr a o uy o icos n n omain e ad n h
a te t i o teVe il . Un e Vign alw,'a d t t ds l ed e n t r lyaie
uh ni t f h hce
cy
d r r ii a i j uy o icos o s o no mal rs
g
w he pa tesa e e
n ri r ngage i a a m ' l ngt ta ac i n. Ba ofM on r l 1 F. d a 8
d n n r s e h r ns to '
' nk
t ea , 93 3 t 29.

Howe r s hdut i y aie( )i t fc i maeila t oneco e i ha s ror
ve , uc y s
ma rs 1 f he a t s tra nd he
nc alng s upei

k wld ea dk o t eoh ri a t u nt ea s mp inta tefc d sn te iti o ()
no e g n n ws h te s ci po h su to h th a t oe o x slj r 2
ng
i onepa t tkesa tonswhihdi r t ohe pat fom ma ngpr ntivetgai ( g.by
f
ry a ci
c ve the t r ry r
ki ude n si tons e. ,
ma ngapataldicos e. I (nenalcttonsomit )
ki
ri sl ur l' d.itr iai
'
ted .
Att ssa oft ca e, hepl i ifha a l e s fce f c st s
hi t ge he s t antf s leg d ufiint a t o uppor t e se eof
t he xit nc
bot oft s c r um sa e gi ng r s t a du y t di c os A sf t fr tc r um sanc t
h he e i c t nc s vi i e o
t o s l e.
or he is i c t e, he
a l a i i t s c a e d c pl i pl us bl es a i h t tA m s e had s r o
leg tons n he e ond m nde om a nt a i y t bls ha
tr
upe i r

knowldgeoff c spe ti ngt t au he i iy oft Ve ce, ha hee ce a i e dt t
e
a t rani o he t ntct
he hil t t xpe td nd nt nde ha
Cl sc I s m e s a t pl i ifw oul ac on t a s pton t tt V e c e w asa he i ,
as i nve t nt nd he a ntf
d t he s um i ha he hi l
ut ntc

a t thede i r t l de i t dicl et em ae i lf c s Asf rt s ond cr um sa e,
nd ha
lbe a ey clned o s os hes tra a t .
o he ec
ic t nc
t a l ga i i t s cond a e d c pl i lke i e pl us bl e t bls t tA m s e a
he le tons n he e
m nde om a nt i w s a i y s a i h ha
t r nd

Ku t t se t di r Cl scI t e sa t pl i iffom dico rng t c e e
tner ook t ps o ve t as i nvesm nt nd he antf r
s ve i he onc ald
f c s s h asby r pr s ntngt tt ma a t e woul c riy t Vehi ea a he tc,a by
a t , uc
e e e i ha he nuf c ur r
d e tf he
cl s ut n i nd
pr vi ng wrten m a e i l pur r i t s
o di
it
t r a s po tng o how t Vehi l ' hi t y a pr na e asa or g na
he
c e s s or nd ove nc
n ii l
M as at 300S w ih chass snum ber3067. l lghtoft
er i
t
i
ni
hese alegatons t courti convi
l i , he
s
nced t
hat
t pl ntf has s fci l pl t A m serhad a dut t di cl e t f si hi pos i
he ai if
uf i enty ed hat
t
y o s os he act n s sess on
r atng t t aut i t oft V ehi e.
el i o he hent ciy he
cl

The c ti a s oft opi on t tt pli if ha pld t i fa cai swih
our s lo he ni ha he antfs ve e her r ud l m
t

s fcentpa tc aiyt s tsyFe r Rul ofCi lPrce e9( a t pu pos sf whih
ufii
riulrt o aif deal e
vi o dur b) nd he r e or c
t r ewa dr fe Afe r vi ngt s ii al gai i t s co ame
he ul s a t d. t r e ewi he pecfc le tons n he e nd
nded c
ompl i ,
ant
t c ti s ts id t tt de e nt a ea y a eoft t ri a cic sa esf
he our s a ife ha he f nda s r mpl war
he s tculr r um t nc or
pa

whih (he wilha t prpar adefns 'andt tt pli if ha de tae ûs tnta
c t yj l ve o e e e e,' ha he antfs ve monsrtd tubsa il
pr - s ve y e de e oft e f c s ' Ha rs n,17 F. a 784. A cc di y, he f a
e di co r vi nc
hos a t .' r i o
6 3d t
or ngl t r ud

camswilnotbedimis unde Rul 9( .
li
l
s sed
r e b)

Fial,h c u t t ee tteAmse d fn ns ag me tta t ep an ifh sfie
n ly te o r mus rj c h
tr ee da t' r u n h t h litf a ald
t al f c ss fcintt s
o lege a t ufi e o how t tRe Li i via i l la ef a f a ulnt
ha d ne s c rousy ibl or ny r ud e
r pr e a i orom i s onsby Am ser The Supr m e Cour ofV i g ni hask ong a r d t t
e es nt tons
si
t .
e
t
ri a
'
l
dhe e o he

nlet tC prncpa i bound by r pr e ai ofhi a nt m a eihe i t s ope ofhi
l ha a i i l s
e es nt tons
s ge , de t r n he c
s

e o me to i f rh r n eo teo j c f rwh c h i e l y d ' Nain d I . v.
mply n r n u te a c f h be t o ih e s mp o e .' to wie ns Co.
'
P te s n, 1SE.d4 0 4 3( .1 8 )(u tn Cergi v. ti, 5S. 3 3 3 7( .
atro 33 . 2 9 , 9 Va 9 5 q o ig rilo Pet 7 E. 0 , 0 Va
t
1 2 ) Sine r s hc e,heprncpa hol ou hi a ntasc
91 ). il ve y uc as t i i l ds t s ge , ompee ,a ftt betuse
tnt nd i o r td;
a t r by,i ef e t he war a s hi fde iy a good c
nd he e n f c ,
r nt s i lt nd
onduc i a lm a t r w ihi t s ope of
t n l te s t n he c

t age y.' 1 ( i J f s Stndad LieI .Co. He ik,27S. 2d 1 202(
he nc '' d.quotng eferon a r f ns v. drc
E. 98, Va.
1 43).
9 )
I t sca e asi Nai
n hi s , n tonwi , healeg tonsi t s co a e
de t l a i n he e nd m nded c
ompl ntplusbl
ai a i y
e t bls t tA m s e wasd d out'a Red Li sa nt 1
s a ih ha
tr
i
hel
' s
ne' ge . d. D urng t r l va tm e pe i
i he e e nt i
rod,
A m s e r gul r y c m uni a e by us ng Re Li st l phone num be a e a la ount ,a
t r e a l om
c td
i
d ne' e e
r nd m i cc s nd
A m s e ' e a l i l ed a s gna ur bl k s ti f t Re Li s f lna e a es ,a
t r s m is nc ud
i t e oc e tng orh d ne' ul m , ddr s nd

tlphonenumbe . Se I ( di t ta i vi lwashel outasa ag f t i ur nc
ee
r e d.hol ng ha n ndi dua
d
n ent or he ns a e

co ny,wheeCl ewass lsedi t l alt e
mpa
r shj
o it n he oc elphonediecor ' çg eus dNai de'
r t y'and ihj e tonwi s

ltehe d' . Thealgai i t sc a nde c an as plusbl e tbls t t
etr a '
)
le tons n he e ond me d omplit lo a i y sa ih ha
Am s e w asa tng i t s ope ofhi e pl e a t tm e ofhi alege m i r pr e a i nsand
tr
c i n he c
s m oym nt t he i
s l d s e es nt to
om i s o r ga di t a he i iy oft V e cl The pl i i fa l s t tRe Li w a
s i ns e r ng he ut ntc t
he hi e.
a ntf lege ha d ne s
r pons bl f r a s m blng and r s o i t V e c e, ha Am s e e r i e contolove t s
es
i e o se i
e t r ng he hi l t t
t r xe c s d
r
r hi
pr es a Red Li sf iiy i Conne tcu ,a t tAm s e a Re Li sood t r c i a
oc s t
ne' ac lt n
c i t nd ha
t r nd d ne t
o e e ve

c mison fom t s l Ac or ngl t Am se de e nt 'moto t dim ism us be
om s i r he ae. c di y, he
t r f nda s
i ns o s s
t
de e t t e e ti s e t dimist fa cli sag ns Am se a Re Li
ni d o he xt n t e ks o s s he r ud am
ai t
t r nd d ne.

l
I.

Cons r y Cl m s(
piae ai Count I and V)
sV

I CountI oft s c
n
V
he e ond a e
m nded c pl i ,t pl i ifa s rs a c m on l
om a nt he a ntf s e t om
aw
c pia c ai aga ns t de e nt . I Cou V , he pl ntf a s r sa r l t d c a m unde
ons r cy l m
i t he f nda s n
nt t
ai i f s e t e a e l i
r
t V igi a Bus nes Cons r c A c .
he r ni
i s
pia y t
To pr va lon t c vi co piac cl i , he pl i t f i us s w t tçw o orm or pe s
e i
he i l ns r y a m t
a n i f i t ho ha t
m
e r ons

co bi t a o pls by s
m ned o cc m ih, ome c e td a ton,s m ec i i lorunlwf pur eors m e
onc re c i o
rm na
a ul pos
o
unlwf pur eby ac i na orunlwf m e ns'' Shivi kiv. t d St t sCo tGua d,
a ul pos
rmi l
a ul a ,'
r ns
Unie a e as
r

673F. 308 320( hCi. 2)( i Commeca Bus SyssI v. l h Sevs,l ,
3d , 4t r 201 quotng
ril . . nc. Belsout r . nc.
45 S. 2d261 267( .1 ) Towihsa amotont dimis apli ifmus d e dt
3 E.
, Va 995).
t tnd
i o s s, antf t s a he
pl
r s t c e tofa ton a uniy ofpur e i m or t n m e e c us y l nguage ' Ba
equi ie onc r
c i nd t
pos n
e ha
r oncl or a
.' y

To c LLC v. l OuaiyToba coPr .LLC, F.Supp. 483,499- ( D.Va.
bac o.
Bel lt
c ods.
261
2d
500 E.
2003) dgj i note hmeeyt saet tac pia yt kplc ' J onv. ucas,1
. tlt s noug rl o tt ha ons r c oo a e. ohns Ka r 4
'
Va. r 1 1 ( Ci.1 )
Ci, 72, 76 Va. r 988 .
Und t Vigi aBusnes Cons r c Ac,ij edpatesca obt nte eda ges
er he r ni i s
pia y t nur ri n ai rbl ma
a ns Cl n t ormor pes nswhoc ne,a s it agee, ual u rakeorc e t
gai t cajy wo
e ro
ombi socae, r mut ly ndet
onc r
t t rf t pur eof. ..wilulyandmaii l ij i a he i hi r putton,ta
ogehe or he pos
. lf l
lcousy nurng not r n s e ai rde,
15

b sne so p o e so b a yme n wh tv r' Va Co ej 1 .- 9 - 1 .- 0 . dAj wih
u i s r r f sin y n a s ae e . . d j 82 4 9 82 5 0 t s t
'
g
c
omm onl w ci lc piac t ssa u er quie pr (ha t de e
a vi ons r y, hi tt t e r s oof t t he f ndan sha c
t ve ombi d . . o
ne . t
a co pls s e pum os noti is fc i i lorunl w f , c i i orunl wf m e ns ''
c m i h om
e,
n t el rm na
a ul by r m nal
a ul a .'

Shivi ki673F.d a 321( i Pot cVal & Fitngl v.Crwf dFitngCo.829
r ns ,
3 t
quotng oma ve ti nc. a or ti
,

F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) Towihsa amotont dimis Cheal tonsmus alw
2d 280, 284 4t r 987).
t tnd
i o s s ,s legai
t
t lo
i e e e ofa m e tng oft m i and notm e epa a l c nd t' K a i v. t St t sBa
nf r nc
ei
he nds
r r lel o uc .
' m n Unied a e nk

Na 'As ' No.11
tl sn,
:3CV00058,2013U. DitLEXI 1
S. s.
S 72935,a *8( . Va De 9,201 .
t W D. . c.
3)

Th panifn e n t o eta t ed f n a t'i rmay a do erdngp r s ( s t ij r
e litf e d o pr v h t h ee d ns s i r n v rii u po e wa ) o nu e
p
a he , bu r t rt tt d e nt k c e i e i na l pur e uly,a w ihoutl w f
not r' t a he ha he ef nda s i t d nt nto ly, pos f l nd t
'
a
a ul

j siiain. Ad a c dM aieEn es v. RC. n .5 S. 2 1 8 1 4 4 ( . 99 )
u tfc to ' v n e rn tr. P l c, 01 E.d 4 , 5 - 4 Va 1 8 .
'
I movi t dimi st c pia y c t ,hedefnda sc le t s fc e y oft
n
ng o s s he ons r c oun s t
e nt hal nge he ufii nc
he
pl i ifsalegai wihr pec t t e e ntofco e td a ton t ti c
antf
l tons t es t o he l me
nc re c i ha s omm on t bot
o h
cli . Upon r vi oft s c a e d c
a ms
e ew
he e ond m nde ompl i ,
ant howe r t c ti s tsi t tt s
ve ,he our s aifed ha hi
elm e hasbee a quae ypl d. Ass ma i d a
e nt
n de tl e
um rze bove t pl ntf a l est tKutne a
, he ai if leg ha
t r nd
Am se ha a t d i conc r t pa sof t Ve c ea an a he i M as r t 300S wih t
t r ve c e n
e t o s f he hil s ut ntc
eai
t he
orgi l3 c s i s nc a l a t2008,whe t y i
i na 067 ha s s i e t e s
n he nduce Ros n t pur has t V e c e.
d
e o c e he hi l

W he Ros n quesi d t Ve c e sl gii c a c
n
e
tone he hil ' e tma y nd omm isoned W at rBa e t
si
le um r o
a he t c t t V e c e, utne a Am s e t a l d t Ge m a t m ee w ih Ba e a
ut n i a e he hi l K t r nd
t r r ve e o r ny o
t t um r nd
c nce hi t tt V e el w a a he i A spa to t i ef o t ,Kutne a A m s e g ve
onvi
m ha he hi e s ut ntc,
r f he r f r s
t r nd
tr a

Ba rt r por pr pa e b Am se , c f ley r pr s t d t tt Ve ce' c s i was
ume he e t e r d y
tr whih as l e e en e ha he hil s ha ss
t 3067 cha s sr t rt n t Shaw c s s a a t m pt d t ditngui h t Sha Cha s sf om
he
s i a he ha he
has i , nd te e o s i s he w
si r
t V e cl s c s s A fe Ros n di co e t tt V e cl w a nota he i a f ce
he hi e' has i . tr e s ver d ha he hi e s
ut ntc nd or d
K utne t r t n hi m one K utne a Am s e e a r t s l t V e c e t Cl s c
t r o e ur s
y, t r nd
t r nde vo ed o e l he hi l o as i

I t nt wih t unde sa ng t tt y wo d bot be i fna i l fom t s l l s
nvesme s t he
r t ndi ha he
ul h neft i ncaly r he ae. n o
doi Kutne a Am se pr de doc e t t teihe c nt i d,orwer bas d on,f s
ng, t r nd
t r ovi d um n s ha t r o ane
e e
ale
r pr s nt i r a di t Ve ce' a he i iy,a Amse f s l r pr s t d t tt
e e e atons eg r ng he hil s ut ntct nd
t r aley e e en e ha he
m a a t e woul c riy t Ve ceasa he i . Consr i t a lga i i t lg mos
nuf c ur r
d e tf he hi l
ut ntc
tung he le tons n he iht t
f a e t t pl i tf ,t c ti c
avor bl o he a n if he our s onvi e t tt aleg tons a e s f c e t s po tt
nc d ha he l a i
r uf i i nt o up r he

r r d elm e ofc e t a ton. Ac or ngl t de e n s motonswilbede e wih
equie e nt onc red c i
c di y, he f nda t ' i
l
nid t
r pec t Count I a V .
es t o
s V nd

11
1.

Cont ac Cl m st
r t ai count VIa Vl )
s
nd I

l Co V l t pl i ifas e t a cl i f r c s i ofc r ta i tK utne a M as
n unt , he a ntf s rs a m or es i son ontac ga ns
t r nd
s
M a e e . I Coun V l , hepl i ifa s ' a c ai f b e h ofconta a i tKutne a
nag m nt n
t lt
a ntf s els l m or r ac
t
r ct ga ns
t r nd
M a sM a
s
nage e . I bo h c s t pl i ifa l ge t tt A m e d BilofSa e ç a f
m nt n t ount , he a ntf le s ha he
nde l
l û s or
w

tes l o a 1 5 M a eai3 0 wi S hcel e tfc to Nu e ( N)3 6 En ie
h ae f 9 6 srt 0 S t ve il d n i ain mb r Vl 0 7 gn
h
i
#3 2,' and t tt K utne de e nt k a e i ly b e c d t i o i a i unde t Sal
06 99
ha he t r f nda s t t ra l r a he he r blg tons
m
r he es

Agr e e ... f ii t dei ra 1 M a e a i3 wih ve cei ntfcai numbe 3
e m nt by a lng o lve 956 s r t 005 t hi l de ii ton
r 067,

e i n mb r3 6 ' 2dAm. mpl! 8 , , 6 9 .
ngne u e 0 2.
'
Co . ! 8 91 9 , 9
Thepli ifa t Ku t rdef nda sa e t tAri l 2 o t Vigi aUnionn
antf nd he tne
e nt gr e ha tce f he r ni
f

Commeca Code(t ' g r t Ame dBilofSal be us i i ac r c f t s l
ril
dUCC') ovens he nde l
e ca e t s onta t or he ae
ofgoods Se Va.
. e Codej8. 1 2(t es t c ntxtohewierquies t sttea i t
2- 0 d
unl s he o e t r s e r ,hi il pples o
ta a tonsi g
rnsci n oods.. .) seas Cr diAc e a eCor v. t , Va. r 267, (
.' ; e lo e t c ptnc
'
p. Coaes 75 Ci. 270 Va.

Ci. .
r Ct2008)( di t t$ s l a ee ntf ramotrve ce... onsiut air a toni
hol ng ha k aes gr me o
a
o hil c tt es tansci n
g ds a i t g ne byAril 2oft UCC'. Unde Aril 2oft UCC,Sgl
oo ' nd s hus over d
tce
he
'
)
r tce
he
kany
afi m a i off torpr i e m a by t s le t t buye w hi h r l t s t t goodsand
fr ton ac
om s
de he e l r o he
r c e a e o he
bec espa toft ba i oft ba gai c e t s a e e sw a r nt t tt g
om
r
he s s he r n r a e n xpr s r a y ha he oods s l c or
ha l onf m

t t eafr to o pr mie' Va Co ej82 31 () Lie s ,tan d srpino t
o h fimai n r o s . . d .- 3 1. k wie ' l y e c ito f he
'
l
goodswhi i madepa toft ba i o t ba g n c e t sa e es wara y t tt goods
ch s
r he ss f he r ai r a e n xpr s r nt ha he

s lconf m t t de ci i ' J Ssuc a exprs warnt i br c dwhe t goods
hal or o he s rpton. #a k h n e s za y s ea he
'
n he
f i t c or t t a fr a i off c orde c i i m a byt s l .' Al v. lr n USAS
a l o onf m o he f m ton a t
s rpton de he eler' i Ale ca

l , 1:2- 11 201 U. Dit LEXI 1 1 7,a * ( D. .Aug.23,201 .
nc.No. 1 CV- 5, 2 S. s.
S 2 41 t 45 E. Va
2)
I t sc e t K utne de e an s c nc de t tt Am e d Bilof Sa e i nt m pl t d
n hi as , he t r f nd t o e ha he
nde l
l i e ae
co

(halt c rbei s dwa apa tc a i ni dc ra pa t, s met de iidc r....
t t he a ng ol s riulr de tfe a nd rs not o mi ntfe a
'
'
K u t r Def . Br i Opp' 8. M or s cii aly,t K utne de e nt a fr e S
tne
s' .n
n
e pe fc l he t r f nda s f im d, i r
unde

p n l e o p ru y't a te weea ren t s lap riua mo o ve il d s rb da a1 5
e at s f ej r , h th y r g e ig o el atc lr t r hce e cie s 9 6
i
'
M aert 300Swih ( hi el nttc tonNumbe ( N)3067Engi #206 andals r pat
s ai
t k cl de ii ai
ve
r V1
ne
2
1 pae rs
(ncl ngs r bl ka hea ecl' 2dAm.
i udi pae oc nd d t .
'
ComplEx.E. W hiet Kutne dee nt
.
l he t r fnda s
nonehel sa guet tnot ng c ai d i t a e m e tc dha f
t es r ha hi ont ne n he gr e n oul ve onne t ba i oft
d he ss he
pa te 'ba ga n i lghtoft ag ee e ' i pe ton pr s o , heco ta e sw ih t pl i if
ris r i n i
he r m nt s ns c i
ovi i ns t
ur gr e t he a ntf
t tt sa gum e i w iho m e i .
ha hi r
nt s t ut r t

l i eprtngt i ssoft bagai 'a gec ai di Vigi aCodej8. 31 1,
n ntr ei he û i he r n'lngua ont ne n r ni
ba
2- 34)
t Su e Cour ofVigi ahashedt tCanafi tono fc i prs
he prme
t r ni
l ha t l fnnai f a t s e umedt beapa toft
g
o
r he
ba ga n,a a f tt tw oul r m ove s h a t r a i outoft a e m e Ce r s c e r
r i nd ny ac ha
d e
uc fi m ton
he gr e nt r qui e l a

afr tvepr .' Yaesv.Pima M f .l ,51 S. 2d605,607( 1999 ( i
fimai oof'' t
t n c. nc. 4 E.
Va, ) quotng
Da ryv. he,41 S. 2d33 339( 1 ) s eas M a tnv.Amei nM e ca Sys,
uahte As
3 E. 6, Va. 992); e lo ri
rca di l .

l . 1 6F.d 1 2 1 5( t Ci.1 9 )( mp a ii gt a, n e Vigni lw,sth e p e s
nc, 1 3 0 , 0 4h r 9 7 e h szn h tu d r r i a a i l e x rs
l
w anunt i r f eson whati i t t s l agr t s l and,abs cl pr t t
y nquiy ocus
t s hat he eler eed o el,
ent ear oof hat he

pa tesdi noti e t rba ga n t i l t s le ' de c i i oft goo ,t tde c i i
ri d
nt nd hei r i o nc ude he e l r s s r pton he ds ha s rpton

i a exprs warnt '. Appl ngt s prnci es t cou ta e wih t pli ift tt
sn
e s ra y'
)
yi he e i pl ,he r gres t he antf ha he

des r p i n oft V e cl i t Am e d BilofSa e i pr um ed t be pa toft pa tes
c i to
he hi e n he
nde l
l s es
o
r
he ri '
bargai abs cl and afir atve pr t t cont ar Att s s age oft pr
n ent ear
tm i
oof o he
r y.
hi t
he oceedi t
ngs, he

c ti una et c ude t tt i pec i n pr s o i t Am e d BilofSa e,whi h do
our s bl o oncl ha he ns t o ovi i ns n he
nde l
l
c
nOtafi m a i y di c a m a1 e es wa r ntesore i il i c t t ta f iu e t i pec w il
fr tvel s l i 1 xpr s r a i
xplc ty ndi a e ha a l z o ns t l

c tt eawave ofal conta t lr m e e , e udet pli iffom r c rng u
onsiut
i r
1 r c ua e di s pr cl he a ntf r e ove i ndera
br ac ofe es w a r nt t or
e h
xpr s r a y he y.
To t e e t Kutne def nda s a t r tve y a g t tt V e cl c o m st t
he xt nt he t r e nt le na i l r ue ha he hi e onf r o he
afi m a i a de c i i i t A m e d BilofSa e a t ,t tt r ha be n no br a
t r tons nd s rptons n he
nde l
l nd, hus ha he e s e
e ch

ofa e e swa r nt s h a gume i i ppr it a t ssa oft c s Thei s of
ny xpr s ra y, uc r
nt s na opra e t hi t ge he a e.
s ue
whehe any e es wara te we ebr c i aquesi off c t tc l bede i d on a
t r
xpr s r n i s r ea hed s
ton a t ha amot
c de

Rul 1 b)6)moint dimis Ac or ngl t Kutne defnda s motonwilbede ed
e 2( ( to o s s. c di y,he t r e nt' i l
ni
wih r pectt t pl ntffs contac cl m s.
t es
o he ai i
r t ai
Cl m f punii and ot speci dam azes
ai or
tve
her
al

I isp a rf r le , hepl ntf s e t r c rpunii a tohe s i da
n t r ye or ei f t ai if e ks o e ove
tve nd dt r pecal mage i
sn

a a ntt bedetr ne a tila i te h g ee ntf t i fa ' 2dAm.
n mou o
emi d t ra gans ac dlfnda or her rud.
'
Compl 1
. 5.
The c r wilfr ta es t pl i i f scl i f rpunii da a . Unde Vi gi a l w ,
ou t l is ddr s he a ntf ' a m o
tve m ges
r r ni a
û tve da a m a be r co r d on a c m on l w f a c a m - i l ng a f a cl i
i
punii
m ges y
e ve e
om
a r ud l i
nc udi
r ud a m
a i i f om t pur has ofa ve cl - onl upon ' oof e t rdiec orcic s a tal s
r sng r he c e
hi e
y
pr , ihe r t
r um t n i , howi
ng

a t malc .' Ad nsv.Cr wnAut l .488F. 225,234(t Ci. )( i J da
cual ie'' ki
o
o. nc,
3d
4h r 2007 quotng or n
v.Sa 247S. 2d739, ( 1 :. û t lmai 'maybee tbls dbys wi t t
uve,
E.
741 Va. 978 t ua lce'
Ac
sa ihe
ho ng ha
adee ntsa tonsweeç ompt by ilwilmalvolnc gr ,s t,( )wike
fnda ' ci
r l
pr ed l l, e e e, udge pie or c d
i e i ' ort tt w e e i o r c e sorne i ntast e nc a c c ousdi r ga d oft
nt nton,' ha hey r s e kl s
s
glge
o vi e ons i
se r
he

pl ntf srg s' J da 247S. 2da 7 142(ntr lciai omitd)
ai if iht. or n,
'
E. t 4 - i ena tton te .

l J da t Supr e Cour ofV igi ahe d t r w a s f c e e de e t s
n or n, he
em
t
r ni l he e s uf i i nt vi nc o uppor a
tn
a a d ofpu tve da age f f a i co c i w ih t s l ofa ve c e The Supr m e Cou t
w r
nii
m s or r ud n nne ton t he a e
hi l .
e
r
not d t tt e de oft d e nts m i r pr e a i n t tt ve cl wasne ,c ed
e ha he vi nce he ef nda ' s e es nt to ha he hi e
w oupl

wih hi m isaeme sa utt ve ce' m ie ,br ke ,sike prc and fna i wo d
t s st t nt bo he hil s lage a s tc r ie,
i ncng, ul

h v j si e t ej r i tn i ted fn a tsmic nd c t b o s c arc e sa n gie t
a e u tt d h u y n i dng h ee d n ' s o u to e f u h e kls nd e l n
i
g
c r c e ast evi e a c c ous di r ga d f t pl i if sr g s I Acc di y, he
ha a t r o nc
ons i
s e r or he a ntf ' i ht . d.
or ngl t
Supr m e Cour r ve s d t t i lc tsde s on t s rke t pl i if' punii da a cl i .
e
t e r e he r a our ' ci i o t i he a ntf s
tve m ges a m
l
d
Com pa i t f c sa l ge i t sc e t t e i J r n, he co tc l st tt
rng he a t le d n hi as o hos n o da t
ur onc ude ha he
pl ntf ha ade t y s a e a c ai f pu tv dam a a t s sage oft pr ee ngs A ta
ai i f s qua el t t d l m or nii e
ges t hi t
he oc di .

mi mum ,hepl n if sa lga i plusbl s s t tt de e nt 'mir pr e t tonsa
ni
t aitf le tons a i y ugge t ha he f nda s se es n a i nd
om i s ons r ga di t a he i iy oft V e c e we e s r kl s orne i n ast e nc a
si
e r ng he ut ntc t
he hi l r o ec es
glge t o vi e
c c ousdi r r f rt pl ntf sr gh s A c or ngl t punii da a c a m w ilno be
ons i
s ega d o he ai if i t . c di y, he
tve m ges l i
l t
di m i s d a t stm e.
s s e t hi i
On t ot rhand, he c tm us d s i st pl i tf scl i f rd he s i ldam a .
he he
t our
t i m s he a n if a m o t r pec a
ot
ges'
'

Fedea Rul ofCi lPr ed e9()r uie t ts cilda gesbets ctc l sae 'nt
rl e
vi oc ur g eq rs ha pe a ma
ûpe ii aly ttd'i he
c pl i . Theprm a y pu pos oft she ght ne pl a ng r quie e ( s one ofnotc ,bot
om a nt
i r r e hi i e d e di e r m nt i
i
ie h

t i or def ngpa te a t t naur oft da a sca me i or rt a d s prs ar
o nf m endi
ri s s o he t e he m ge li d n de o voi ur ie; l
d
t i or t c t t s t nc oft c pl i . Ca nel Cons r Cor v.D a le
o nf m he our of he ubs a e he om a nt'
' r l
t . p.
nvil
Rede lpme & Hous Auh.745F. 703, ( h Ci. 1 (ntr cttona quotton
veo nt
. t,
3d
725 4t r 20 4) i enal iai nd ai
-

m a ksom it d) l t sc e,hepl n if sc l or de a f rt he s ci da
r
te . n hi as t aitf oncus y m nd o ç r pe al mage i a
ot
sn n

a
mountobedeemi da ti 'i clal i ufii tt mee t ssa r Seei ( di t t
t
tr ne tral's e ry ns fcen o thi tndad.
d.hol ng ha
t pl i t f f l d t a ua el pl a s ci ldam a i co
he a n if aie o deq t y e d pe a
ges n nnec i n w ih isbr c ofco r c
to t t ea h
nt a t
20

cli swhe et br ac ofco r c cou S r y pr ye f ragg e t da
am
r he e h
nta t nt s el a d o
me
r ga e mage in a amountt
si n
o

bepr na ti butnotl st n$41 5 pl i ee t' ;eeas M cmtSe v . Ilnoi.nc.
ove tral
es ha
9, 75, us ntrs'' s lo
l
. r s of li s I
v, at M c .Sys l .907F.
He lh mt ,nc.
,
Supp. 294( D.1.1 (imisngt pli ifscai
289, C. 11 995) ds s i he antf l m
f s ci lda ag , he e t pl ntf m e e y r
or pe a m es w r he ai if r l eque t d a a ou ofda a t be pr
s e n m nt
m ges o
oven a
t

tilanddi notsaewha t eda gesweeorhow iwa da
ra,
d
tt
t hos ma
r
t s mage . Ac di y,t
d) cor ngl he
pl i if scl i f ot r s i ld a w ilbe di m i s d.
a ntf
a m or he pec a nm ges l
s se
Concl on
usi

Fort r as s a ed, he de enda s m oto t di m i sw ilbe gr nt d i pa ta
he e ons t t t
f
nt ' i ns o s s l
a e n r nd
de e i par. The Cl r i die t d t s nd c ri i d c esoft sm e or ndum opi on a t
ni d n t
e k s r c e o e e tfe opi
hi m a
ni nd he
a com pa ng o de t a1 c
c
nyi r r o 1 ouns lo r or
e f ec d.
Ix 'sR :rhi
ï r
' s

Jzd a o Jn ay2015.
dy faur
,

Chi fUnie St t s D it i tJ e
e
t d a e s rc udg

21