Eramo v. Rolling Stone LLC et al

Filing 265

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/11/16. (jcj)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI COURT
S
CE S. ST.
AT U NOKE,V
A
FI
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO URT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I N I
CT
RGI A
CH ARLOTTESVI
LLE D I SI
VI ON

0CT 1 12 1
25
J
K

C, U EY CLERK

NI
COLE P. ERA M O,

LERK
Ci lA c i N o.3: CV vi ton
15- 00023

Pl i if
a ntf ,
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O
RO LLT G STON E LLC,e a1,
N
t .

Hon. l n E.Conr d
Ge
a
Chi fU nied St t D i ti tJ
e
t
a es sr c udge

Def nda s
e nt .

Niol Ermo (d a ' fl t sdefmai a ton agans defnda sRoli St ,
c e a ( mo') ied hi a ton ci
Er
i t e nt lng one
LLC ,Sa i Rubi Er l a W e rM ed a LLC.On Se e be 22,201 t c tgr nt d
br na
n de y, nd nne
i,
pt m r
6, he our a e

pli ifsmoton f pa tals
antf
i or ri ummayj
r udgme ast t quesi ofwhehe t c le d
nt o he
ton
t r he halnge
s a e e s w e e t or c e ni ' Er m o. The c s i pr e l be or t cour on t
t t m nt
r '
of
onc r ng' a
a e s es nty f e he
t
he
de e nt 'm o i f r ons de a i Fort f l w i r s ,t m oton w ilbe g a e
f nda s ton or ec i r ton.
he olo ng ea ons he
i
l
r nt d.

The r lva f c s a a ia e 1w of t c e a e s t out i t co ts pr vi
ee nt a t nd pplc bl a
he as r e
n he ur' e ous

me a
morndum o ni Ermo v.Roli St ,No.3:5CV23,201 W L 5 4688 ( . Va
pi on, a
ln: one
1
6
23
W D. .
Se .22,201 .On Ocobe 11 201 t c thel ahe rng ont i t tmoin.l ha bee
pt
6)
t r , 6,he our d ai
he nsan to t s n
f l bref d a i now rpe f r dipos ton.
uly i e nd s
i o s ii

I r viwi a moton f rr consde ai t c ti t ded by t g r lprncpl s
n e e ng
i o e i r ton, he our s s
gui
he ene a i i e

o Rue 5 ()a d Rue 6 ( )moi n f rrc n ieain o fn lj d me t. Mir s rtg
f l 9 e n l 0 b to s o e o sd rto f ia u g n s' co tae y
'
Sevs Cor v.Ope s LLC,No.1 c 1 2015 W L 21
r . p.
nRik
4-v- 244,
26924,a +1 ( D.Va.M a 6,
t E.
y
2015 .Thus t cour hasdicei t de r fom apr ousr i ( 1 t a co
)
, he t
srton o pa t r
evi ulng : ) o c mmodaea
(
t n
i erveni change i cont lng l ;
nt
ng
n
roli
aw

t account f new evi
o
or
dence not avaiabl
l e

g e ousyl or( t c rc ace rer o lw orp e ntma fs ij tc ''M a i d v.
prvi l ; 3) o ore t la ror f a
r ve
nie t nusie.' vtel
Na'As ' f St kCa AuoRa nz,1 , F. 369,378(t Ci. 2)( i Zi nd
tl sn or oc r t ci nc.674 3d
4h r 201 quotng nka

Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 265 Filed 10/11/16 Page 1 of 3 Pageid#: 13729

v.Br
own,478 F. 634,637 ( h Ci.2007).Howe r dlj uli t rs nsbiiy oft
3d
4t r
)
ve, tthe tmae epo i lt
he
fde a c t,a allves i t rac t cor tj me unde lw. Am.Ca As' v.
e r l ours t l e l, s o e h he rec udg nt r a '
'
noe sn
M up hy Fa m s l , 326
r , nc.

5
05,

(t Ci. 2003) Theeor , ig oins f
4h r
. rf e dmlto or

rc nsd r to o gu r j d me t o d r a en ts be tt t esrc sa a d a plc bet
e o i eai n f s mmay u g n) r es r o u j c o h tit tnd r s p ia l o
mo in f rrc nsd r to o afn l ud me t'I . t51 (iig M o e H. n M e Ho p.
to s o e o ie ai n f ia j g n . d a 4 ctn
'
s s Co e m. s
v.M ecuv Cons.Cor ,460U. 1 1 ( 983) ( i t t(e r o de s to afna de r e
r r
t p.
S. , 2 1 ) notng ha Gvey r r hor f i l c e
i s j c t r pe nga t dsr to oft ditit udge'.
s ub e t o eo ni t he ic ein he src j '
)
Appl ng t s prnc pl s t c t be i ves t t de e nt a e e il t
yi
he e i i e , he our
le
ha
f nda s r ntted o

r consde a i oft c ur' Se e r22,201 me o a um o ni r r ng whehe t
e i r ton he o ts pt mbe
6 m r nd
pi on ega di
t r he
s a e e s a e i orconc r ng' t pl n if Ce t i y,t e i no di put t tt s a e e s
t t m nt r '
of
e ni ' he ai tf . r a nl her s
s e ha he t t m nt
t t s c f c ly m en i Er m o a e to o co e ni 'her a t co ti e t s i tuc
ha pe i i a l
ton a
r d f r nc r ng' , nd he ur nt nds o o nsr t

tej r Ho v r whi te c u t le e ta te rmann c aln e sae n sc u dk
h u y. we e , l h o r beiv s h t h e iig h le g d ttme t o l
e
k o c
k r once ni 't pl i if whehe t e saeme sa t l a e C orco e ni ' Er mo
of
r ng' he antf, t r hes t t nt cualy r ç
of
nc r ng' a

i aquesi f t fcfnde .Se Fons l..Rudd 891F.Su 1
s
ton or he a ti r e r hi)y
y,
pp. 062,1 ( M d.1 ,
070 D.
995)
afd,89F. 828( hCi.1996 (iT) quesi ofwhehe apublc toni ofa c er ng
f'
3d
4t r
) ûr he ton
t r
iai s nd onc ni

ad fmainplitf i amatrfrt j r t d cd .) Ac o dngy ted fn a t'mo in
ea to an if s
te o he u y o e ie' . c r i l , h ee d ns to
'
f r c i r to w ilbe gr nt d.
or e ons de a i n l
a e

TheCl r i diece t s c riid co e oft sm e o a
e k s r td o end e tfe pis hi m r ndum opi on a t
ni nd he
a c pa ng o de t a 1c
c om nyi r r o 1 ouns lo r cor
e f e d.

ENTER:Thi lt
s V

da ofOcobe , 2016.
y
t r
Chi Unied St t D it i tJ
t
a es s r c udge

Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 265 Filed 10/11/16 Page 2 of 3 Pageid#: 13730

CLERKS
OFFI U
CE
DI
AT ROANO S. ST. COURT
FI KE,
L
VA
ED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
CHA RLO TTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

0C 112 1
T
06
UL
Y;

,

C RK

RK 'k
'
1
'
.. =
;>

N I LE P,ER AM O ,
CO

C i lA c i N (.3: 5- 00023
vi ton ) 1 CVPl i if
a ntf ,
O RD ER

H on.Gl n E.
e
Conr d
a
Chi fUnie St t D i ti J
e
t d a es s rd udge

R OLLI STON E LLC, ta .
NG
e l,
D ef nda s
e nt .

Fort r as s a e i t ac om pa ng m e or ndum opi on,i i now
he e ons t t d n he c
nyi
m a
ni t s
O R DER ED

t tt defnda s moton f r co i r to i G RANTED.
ha he e nt ' i or e nsde ai n s
TheCl r i die t d t s nd ce tfe c e oft sor ra t a co nyi
ek s r c e o e
riid opi s hi de nd he c mpa ng
m e or nd opi on t a lc
m a um
ni o l ouns lofr co d.
e
e r
EN TER : s
Thi

lfR day ofoct ber 2016.
o ,
1
Chi f nie St t D it i tJ
e
t d a es s rc udge

Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 265 Filed 10/11/16 Page 3 of 3 Pageid#: 13731