Eramo v. Rolling Stone LLC et al

Filing 270

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/13/16. (jcj)

R.FRK' OFFI U. DI COUR)
l
S
CE S. ST.
AT M M NOKE,
VA
I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FI
LED

FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I N I
CT
RGI A
CH A RLOTTESVI
LLE D I SI
VI ON

0CT 13 2 1
06
J

C,

EY CL
ERK

BY;

N I LE P.ERA M O ,
CO

CLERK

Pl ntf ,
ai i f
Ci lA cton N o.3: CV vi
i
15- 00023

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
RO LLI G STON E,
N
LLC,e a .
t l,
Dee ns
f nda t .

By:H on.G l E.Conr
en
ad
Chi fUnie St t s D it i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge

N i ol Er m o fl d t s d a a i a ton a i t de e
c e a
ie hi ef m ton c i
ga ns f ndant Roli St
s
lng one, LLC

(s lng Stne',Sa i Rubi Er l a W e rM e aLLC ts enne' Thedee nt
tkoli o ' brna
l
)
n dey, nd nne di
i
W
rl.
fnda s
tld a moton i lm i s e ng t e ude a r por by t Col
ie
i n i ne, e ki o xcl
e t he umbi SchoolofJ na im a
a
our ls nd

evi nc r r ng t co l i rac d i t trpor (hei t aJ naim Re t'or
de e egadi he ncusons e he n ha e tt s unbi our ls por'
col
ûCJ '.Fort ras stf t beow,t motonwilbede e
1 R'
)
he e ons e orh l he i l
nid.
The ba kg ound f c soft c e ar s touti t c ts pr vi usm e or nd opi o
c r
at
he as e e
n he our ' e o
m a um
ni n
a a e not r ie a e he e. Se Er o v.Roli St , N o. 3: CV 23, 201 W L 5234688
nd r
et r t d r
e am
lnc one
15
6

( . Va Sept 22, 201 .Afe i pe nt e iis uncovee deal undemi ng t
W D. .
.
6) lr nde nde ntte
rd tis
r ni he
c edi lt ofJ ki sac ount Roli St ne a W e m e r a d outt t Col bi Sc olof
r biiy
ac e' c
, lng o nd r r e che
o he um a ho

J na im t i si t ' ny l ps s i r pori e tng a f tche ki be nd t so y.
our ls o nve tgae ç
a a e n e tng, dii nd ac - c ng hi he t r '
'

W ila Da A Not fo t Edior Ro lng St a UVA:The Col a Uni r iy
lim
na,
e r m he f , li
one nd
umbi
ve st

GrduaeSc ofJ nals Re t( i 5,201 ) l f maii t sr ltons p,W emer
a t hool our im por Aprl
5 . n or lzng hi eai hi
l
M e a pr ie t tt CJ woul be publs i Roli St maga i a on Roli
di om s d ha he R
d
ihed n
lng one
zne nd
lng
St s webst W e r r t i
one'
ie. nne e a ned t a lt t e t t r por t s m e e e , ha f r t
he biiy o di he e t o o
xt nt d i s
publcaton r ght and agreed t r m burs t Col bi SchoolofJour im f t expenses
i i i s,
o ei
e he um a
nals or he
i r i cr i t r t W hen t CJR w as publs on Roli St s w ebst i w as
ncur ed n eatng he epor.
he
ihed
lng one'
ie, t

pr e e al i a not fo W ilDana M a gi EdiorofRoli St I t no e Da
es nt d ongsde
e rm
l
, na ng t
lng one. n he t , na

sae t t Roli St wa i ommitng (tell t a s res of r omme tons a
ttd ha
lng one s ç
c
ti is f o ei
ec
ndai
bout
j r lsi prci st taes le outi t rpor. I
ounaitc a tce ha r peld n he e t' d.
'
I t r m oton,de e
n hei
i
f ndan s a g t tt r por s d be e ude unde Fe r lRul
t r ue ha he e t houl
xcl d
r de a
e
of Evi nce 403.Pl n i f c e t t t CJ i a a m i s on of a pa t o
de
ai t f ont nds ha he R s n d s i
ry ppone a not
nt nd

u f il p eu iil On Oco e 7 2 6 te c u th l a h a i o t e p ris mo in i
n ary rj dca.
tb r , 01 , h o r ed e rng n h a t ' to s n
e
lm i The i s ha bee f ly br e e a i now rpe f r vi w .
i ne.
s ue s n ' l i f d nd s
u
i or e e

Fe r lRul ofEvi nce801d)2)a t a opposng pa t ssae nt i o e de e
de a e
de
( ( dmis n
i ry' ttme s nt vi nc

as nonheas y.Fe R.Evi 801d)2)
ra
d.
d. ( ( .Notbl a opposng pary' saeme ma be
a y, n
i
t s tt nt y
a s i e when i is one t pa t m a f td t ti ado e or bei ve t be tue' i s
dmisbl
ti
i
he ry niese ha t pt d
le d o
r ,' i
wa

ma ebyap ro wh m t ep lya t o ie t ma easae n o t es b e t'o S sma e
d
e s n o h a' u h rz d o k ttme t n h u j c, r k
t
' wa d
by t pa t s age or e pl yee on a m a t r wihi t s o of t tr a i hi a w hie i
he ry'
nt
m o
te t n he c pe ha el tons p nd
l t

e se ' 1 .S a miso o ap ry o po n i, y isv r nau e awa sp eudca.Rue
xitd. d û d sin f a t p ne t s b t ey tr , l y rj iil l
' An
4 3 h we e,p o e t o l to esae n st a a eu f il p eu iil'Be tn v S ab c s
0 , o v r r tcs ny h s ttme t h t r n ary rj dca. co . tr u k
'
Cor ,No.2: CV- 1 2007 W L 26881 t* ( D.Ohi Se .6,2007)(mphassi
p.
05- 1 43,
28,a 3 S.
o pt
e
i n
orgi l.To t e e t CJ i ba e on he ra a
i na)
he xtnt he R s s d
as y, nonymous s c ,a c ans t
oures nd onti he
a hor 'opi ons a conc usons t e ar m e sa e s ii a l a es e i t c m e a y
ut s
ni
nd
l i , hes gu nt r pec fc ly ddr s d n he om nt r

t t Fe a Ruls Fe R.Evi 8 ( ( not ()C)2)(' fe dom whih ad s i
o he derl e . d.
d. 01d)2) e l( ( ; r e
The
c misons

h v e j y d fo tc n c ld ma d o s ac n f ra a s awe o t swo t n s gl.
a e no e r m e h ia e n s f e rhig o n surl f nlt rhie s,
f om t r s r c i i l nc oft o ni r e a t nle r qui i fr t nd know l dge ...
r he e ti tve ntue e he pi on ul nd he l e rng is ha
e ,

c l f ge r teame oft sa nueofa si lt '
als or neous r t nt hi ve
dmisbiiy.).
H er t courtbeleves t t CJR i a sat entof a part opponent W el er asked
e, he
i
hat he
s t em
y
. m

t Col bi Sc
he
um a hoolof J nals t m a t s s a e e s a pr i e i a nc of t
our i m o ke he e t t m nt nd om s d, n dva e
he

sa e nt,t publs t m .A c oft CJ a a son Roli St ne swe ie aongsde a
tt me s o
ih he
opy he R ppe r
lng o ' bst l i
w rte c m im e f om Roli St t c nge is pr c i s bas on t r po t Se
it n om t nt r
lng one o ha
t a tce
ed
he e r . e

Trns Aut Sev.I v.Che on USA.I ,807F. 11l 1 1 (t Ci. 5 (çW j
a bay o r , nc.
vr
nc.
3d 3, 1 8 9h r 201 ) kl hen
a pa' a s i co or iy wih t co e s of a doc e . s h a a ton co tt e a
ly ct n nf m t t he nt nt
t
um nt.. uc n c i
nsiut s n

a i oft sae nt conti dt ri ' ;se as M BI l .Cor v.Parac Pa t r
dopton he ttme s ane heen.l e lo
'
A ns p.
tirh rnes

Vll LLC, ,2 2W L 25 8 7 a * ( D. Y. u y3 2 2 (l u i r h v b e h l
le
No. 01
6 9 2, t 4 S. N. J l , 01 ) t Aj dt s a e e n ed
k
o
t beag sofapat f pupos sofRul 8 ( ()D)a t r f e sae nt by a ior
o
ent
ry or r e
e 01d)2 ( nd, he eor, ttme s udt s
aede me non- ra satme sofaparyoppone .l Rei Br .LocangCo.v. thi n
r e d heas y t e nt
t
nt'; d os
'
i
Kec ka
Pul Co. 6 F. 1 1 ( h Ci.1 )(dmitnga ousderpor whe t rpor wa
p , 99 2d 292, 306 9t r 983 a ti n ti e t n he e t s
made a t de e nts r ques, cr a e t de e nts ofi er a ma
t he f nda ' e t icult d o f nda ' tc s nd nage s a t
r , nd he

i tgaorhad f lac es t dee ntsbooks a rc ds;Unied Stt v.Sa r,749
nvesi t
ul c s o fnda '
nd e or l t aes
ndes

F. 1 1 ( t Ci. 1 ) ( tng t t t r e çncudes sae nt ma by a nt
2d 95, 99 5h r 984 noi ha he ul i l
i
ttme s de
ge s

a t rz d t s e k c n e nn a s b e ta a miso sb a p ry o p n n .Th r f r,t e
uho ie o p a o c r ig u j c s d sin y at p o e f) ee o e h
c tbele s t CJ i ad s i e unde Fe rlRul of Evi nc 8 d)2) a i not
our ive he R s misbl
r dea
e
de e 01( ( nd s

u fil p eu iilTh c u t l d n d fn a t' to i l n .
n ary rj d ea . e o r wil e y ee d n s moin n i e
mi
The Clr i die t d t s nd c eso t sme o a
e k s r c e o e opi f hi m r ndum opi on and t a c
ni
he c ompa ng
nyi
or rt a1 co elofr co d.
de o l uns
e r

t>
%
DA TED : s
Thi

da ofo c obe , 6.
y - t r 201
Chi fU n'e St t D i ti tJ
e
d a es s r c udge

3