Eramo v. Rolling Stone LLC et al

Filing 345

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 10/31/16. (jcj)

ntpprs OF CE U. , sm COURT
FI S Dl
A
Tc* 0= s R V
WL A
FI
LED

I THE UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STR I CO URT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I N I
CT
RGI A
CHA RLOTTESV I
LLE DI I ON
V SI

02T 31 2 1
25

gu , LMCEK
E LR
RK

N I LE P. AM O ,
CO
ER
Ci lA c i N o.3: - vi ton
15 CV 00023
Pl n if
ai tf ,
M EM O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

ROLLI STONE LLC,e a .
NG
t l,

H on.Gl n E.Co 'd
e
ma
Chi fUnied St t Dit tJ
e
t
aes sdc udge

D e e nt .
f nda s

F o Oco e 1 ,2 6t r u h Oco e 28 2 6 abf rae j r tilwa c n u td o
r m t b r 7 01 h o g t b r , 01 , iuc td u y ra s o d ce n
pli tf ' cai ofde a a i a def ma i by i i ton.Att cos ofpli ifse de e,
a n ifs l ms
f m ton nd n ton
mplcai
he l e
antf vi nc

d fn a t mo e f rj g n a amatro lw p ru n t Fe ea Rue o Ci i Pr c d r
ee d n s v d o ud me t s
te f a u s a t o d rl l f vl o e u e
5 () Th c s i c re l b f r te c u to d f n a t'mo in a t p an ifsd fmain by
0 a . e a e s u rnty e o e h o r n ee d ns to s o litf ea to
i i to c am a pli ifs m o i t clrf he cli .Fort f l ng r as ,t kour
mplcai n l i nd antf
ton o a iy r am
he olowi e ons he
t
wilgr ntde e nt 'm o i n.
l a
f nda s to
St
andar ofR e e
d
vi w

Rue 5 ()o t eFe e a Ru e o Cii Pr c d r p nni apa t t s b tamoin fr
l 0 a f h d r l ls f v l o e u e e t
s ry o u mi
to o

j dg n a amatro lw a trt o po i p ryh sbe n f l h a d t t s a tt Ru e5 ()
u me t s te f a fe he p sng a t a e ul e r .t l u n o l 0 a ,
y
pr
t c u t l n ts b ta is et t j r u ls s f in e i e c e it t j siy a a lg l
he o r wil o u mi n su o he u y ne s u sce t v d n e x ss o u t , s e a
f
matr afn igi fv ro tepr p n n . noh rwo d ,ft ej g c n l e t a t panif
te , i dn n a o f h o o e t I te r s i h ud e o cud s h t he litf s

c s i, samatro lw, owe kt a n rto lur c udfndi fvo o teplitf,hej d e
ae s a
te f a s a h t o aina j y o l i n a r f h an if t u g
ha t ea t o iyt e tr u g n i fv ro ted fn a ts. Bek l . M e e Co .U. ,
s h u h rt o n e j d me t n a o f h e e d n gj' l nc v. y r m s S.
'
679F.d 1 1 ( hCi. 2)
3 46, 60 4t r 201 .
Di si
scus on

The f t oft s c e a e ou lne i de a l i t co ts m e o a
ac s hi as r ti d n t i n he ur '
m r ndum opi o g a i i
ni n r ntng n

Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 345 Filed 10/31/16 Page 1 of 5 Pageid#: 16983

p r a d d n ig i p r t p ris co smoinsfrsl r j dg n .Se Ermo v Roln
a t n e yn n a t he a t ' r s to o l
e
mmay u me t e a . lig
S o e No. 1 CV23 2 6W L 5 3 6 8 ( . Va Se t2 2 6 .nhe c mpan, litf d d
t n , 3:5
, 01
2 4 8 W D. . p . 2, 01 ) l r o litp an if i
note e sy i ude a c
xpr s l ncl
ountf de n ai n by i plc ton.De e an s howe r ac
or f m to
m iai
f nd t ,
ve , knowl dged
e
t t pl i ifs % ompl nt ar dy a s rs cli s t r a t r of def ma i by i ia i '
ha antf' s
c
ai lea s e t am mde
heo y
a ton
mplc ton.
'

Emalfo Als n Sc ay t Lib Lo ke ( ac 1 ,201 6:3 p. ) Ata h a g h l o
i r m io h r o b y c M rh 6
6 1 m..
e dn ed n
Ocobe 11 2016,def nda sr que t t tpl i ifs c f t de n aor m e ni s cai
t r ,
e nt e sed ha antf pe iy he f m t y a ng he l med
de e
f ndan si i He ng Tr 42- Dkt 263. ai ifa ee t 'o s a s ei t r afe ,
t mpled. mi
. 43, .
Pl ntf gr d o d o nd, om tpe he e tr
pr de a sa e ntde i a i t alege de a aor i i ton.1 Pl ntf a s re lha t
ovi d tt me
lne tng he l d f m t y mplcai d. ai if s e td ç t he
t
Roli St
lng one a tc e I Ra on Cn pus ' t ken a a w hol a vi wed i c e w ih is
ril A
pe
m , a
s
e nd e
n ont xt t t

he dlne ,il ta i ,c ptonsa pr
a i s lusr tons a i
nd omotonalma e i l i ple a i i ua e t tNi eEr mo
i
t ra ,m i s nd nsn t s ha col n
a t d a a f l e find t J cde pr tndi t be o he sde whie a t s m e tme d s our gi
c e s a s re o a l , e e ng o
n r i
l t he n i
i c a ng

J ki fom pu s ng a f malcompl ntorpolc i tga i r r ng he r pe al ga i i
ac e r
r ui
or
ai
ie nvesi ton ega di
r a le tons n
or rt s es t a s ul a pr e tt Uni r iy' r putton. Afe r si a prort t
de o uppr s he s a t nd ot c he ve st s e a i ' tr e tng nd i o he
'
de e nt 'pr s ntton ofe de ,pl ntf ove t ca iy he def ma or i plc ton cai .
f nda s e e a i
vi nce ai ifm d o lrf r a t y m i a i l m
l Vigi a a de n ai by i i a i pli if mus de onsr t t tGt saeme s
n r ni ,
f m ton
mplc ton antf
t m ta e ha lhe t t nt

we e d sg e a d itn e b t e d f n a t t i l (h d f mao y i e o o wh c te
r e in d n n e d d y h ee d n s o mpy t e ea t r r nd f ih h
mu
plitf c mpli sl'Pe d eo v Ne o ,2 0 Va 1 2 1 5( 1 ) W he a p an ifalg s
anif o an .' n ltn . ws me 9 . 6 , 7 20 5 . n litf l e
e
t ts ha be de a e by i i ton,çhe al ge i ia i mus be r as
ha he s en f m d
mplcai t le d mplc ton
t
t e onabl d a fom
y r wn r

t ewo d a tal us d'W e b v. r ii- l tM e i Co .LLC,28 Va 8 8 ( 01 )(ii
h r s cu l e . b Vignapio da s.
y
'
7 . 4, 9 2 4 ctng
Ch pn v.Kng tli d r I c,9 3 F.d 1 7 1 9 - 3 ( t Ci. 1 9 );s e as Ca wi v.
ai
ih-td e. n . 9 2 08 , 0 2 9 4h r 9 3 ) e lo r l
e
Rihmo 1 Va 1,9 ( 954)(ç me ni oft alege den t y lngua c no,by
c nd, 96 .
1
çfhe a ng he l d fmaor a ge nn t
i
nnue
ndo,be e e d beyond is or na y a com m o a ce a i n.The pr nc oft im ue
xt nde
t di r nd
n c pt t o
ovi e he r ndo

it s
s o how how t wor us d a e def ma or a how t y r lt t t pli if buti c nno
he
ds e r
n t y, nd
he ea e o he a ntf,
t n t
i r
ntoduce ne m a t r nor e e t m ea ng of t w or us d,or m ake t t c r a n w hi h i i
w
te ,
xt nd he
ni
he
ds e
ha e t i
c sn

2
Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 345 Filed 10/31/16 Page 2 of 5 Pageid#: 16984

fc unc ran.)
a t t ti ' .
'

Cli frd fmain a es b e tt noiepla ig rq ie n sstfrh i F d rlRu e
ams o ea to r u j c o tc e dn e ur me t e o t n e ea l
o Cii Pr c dze 8 a .No ehee s a d fmain plitf û u h t s e iy te d fmao y
f v l o e l () n t ls, e n to an if ç g t o p cf h en t r
r
o
sa e e t ,e n unde t lbe alf de a pl a ng r me. J
tt m n s ve
r he i r e r l e di egi ' ohns v.La z,2:
'
on
nt 02CV001 2002
20,

W L 1 21 0 a #1( . Va Au 8 2 0 ) Fo e mp e i Co e v. t M o ta eI c,t e
8 61 , t W D. . g. , 0 2 . r xn l, n mp l Cii rc c n . h
dititc tdim is d a de nma i cl m whe t c
src our s s e
f ton ai
n he ompli f l ç o i n iy whi h s cii
ant aied ç de tf
t
c pe fc

sae nsplitf c nsd re )d fmao y o lb l u . 10 CV01 7 ,2 0 W L 4 0 1 ,a *1
ttme t an if o i e ld e a t r r ieo s' :4
'
37 05
9 48 6 t
( D.Va Fe 23,2005)
E. . b.
.
Tra c rsha c it nty r le upon t i
i l ou t ve onsse l ei d
he nnuendo al ged i t pl ntf c
le
n he ai ifs ompli
ant
i de e mi ng whe he apli ifha s fcinty saed a c am .Se e. ,Cha n v.Gr ve 787 F.
n t r ni
t r antf s ufi e l t t
li
e g.
pi
e ,

S p 5 7 5 4 ( D. .1 9 )(G ed s stv q sinp e e tdi whehe o n tar a o be
u p. 5 , 6 E. Va 9 2 C
Th ipo iie ueto r s ne s t r r o e s na l
f c fnde c d c l t tt a tce o saeme si t a tce sae ori y,i t i pl i a
a ti r oul oncude ha he ri l r t t nt n he ri l t t
mpl n her an nd

naurls ns ,t den tr me ngsa ci d t t m hy pli if L t i co ai .)(ii
t a e e he fmao y ani s rbe o he . antfs q her mpl nt' ctng
'
M ikovih v.Lori J na Co. 497 U. 1 20- ( :; Pe eon,290 Va. a 1
l c
ane our l ,
S. , 21 1990
ndlt
t 75

(o cu ig t tt e sae n sa is e wee de s n by c pa l o c n e ig t e d fmao y
c n ldn ha h ttme t t su r t a o a l a b e f o v yn h e n t r
r
i ndo pfwh c panifc mp an ' W e b 2 7 Va a 8 ($ u ,teq e to f rt ecrut
nnue
ih litf o lis); b , 8 . t 9 G s h u sin o h ic i
Th
.

c twhe nzi on t de u r rwa whehe ,a am a trofl w,t a tc ei r s na y ca bl
our
n lng he m r e s t r s
te
a he ri l s ea o bl pa e

o te d f mao y me n n g an if a c d ! i) Fo e mp e n Pe deo v.Ne o ,
f h e a t r a i g plitfl s dbe . 1. 4 xa l,i n lt n
Q
ws me
pl i ifa lged t tdef nda sçf lel i i i e r d,a ori i ed,t ough r lva f t,
antf le
ha
e nt la s y mpled, nf r e nd/ nsnuat hr
ee nt acs

a du eo in e d ,ha g c l s d ahwa c usdb ( rmohe 'jalg dia to . 29 Va
n s f n u n o t t a hi j e t s a e y he t rs le e n cins' 0 .
d'
'
a 1 I isopi on r ve sng a r m a ng,t Supr m e Cour ofVig ni sa e t tpl i if
t 67. n t
ni e r i nd e ndi he
e
t
r i a tt d ha antf
w o d bea t blr n ofpr ng û ha t s a em e s ...w e e de i d a i e d ...t i pl
ul
r he zde
ovi ç t he t t nt
t
r s gne nd nt nde
om y
t tt pl i ifw a r s
ha he a ntf s e pons bl f rhe c l s de t ' 1 a 1
i e o r hid' a h.' d. t 75.

3
Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 345 Filed 10/31/16 Page 3 of 5 Pageid#: 16985

He e t c tbele s t t pl i if m e he f de a notce pl a ng r quie nt whe
r , he our ive ha antf
t r e rl i
e di e r me
n
pl ntf dei r d t de e nt he sa e e o i ia i a trt Oc obe 11 2016he rng.At
ai if lve e o f nda s r t t m nt f mplc ton fe he t r ,
ai
t t poi i tm e de e nt ha e
ha
nt n i , f nda s d nough i or ton t t mdert nd t de e e a lbl t
nf ma i o t
t
sa he f ns s vaia e o

g e a d ho E e )s ul p o e d' Co l 20 5 W L 4 0 1 ,a * M o e v r o l u n
t m) n w t y ho d r c e . mpe, 0
h
h
'
9 48 6 t 2. ro e , n y po
de i atng t def ma or i plc ton c d pl ntf a tmptt pr t tt i iaton wa a
lne i he a t y m i a i oul ai if te
o ove ha he mplc i
s
f le f c ua as e ton t tde enda s G sgned a i e d, as r quie by Vigi a lw.See
a s a t l s ri ha f nt ' i
de
nd nt nde '
' e rd
r ni a
Pe e on,290 Va. 1 - Thus t c tc l st ti mus us t de n aor m e ni a
ndlt
at 71 75.
, he our oncude ha t t e he f m t y a ng s
a lge by t pl ntf i e ua i whe he t ize e coul be ç e s bl dr wn fom t
le d
he ai if n val tng
t r he lf r nce
d
t a ona y a
r
r he
wo ds acua l us d' a whehe t de e nt i e d s h a i ia i W e 28 Va.a
r
t ly e ' nd
t r he f nda s ntnde uc n mplc ton. bb, 7
t
89.

Afe r tng he ca e pli ifno s ks t ca iy o n e he cli s a t alege a
tr esi
r s , antf w ee o lrf r m nd r am o s o l

dfee ti lc to W h l la et n ndac mpan i G rey gv n whe j sies r q r s'
ifrn mpiain. ie e v o me
o lit s ç e l i e
f
n u tc o e uie y
'
t c ts d de gr tng l a whe e g r a on e ss s h aswhe t n nd e wo d
he our houl ny an i e ve
r ood e s xit, uc
n he me m nt ul

b ' rj dca t t e o p sn pa t ' Ho a k v.Do ,7 1 CV0 71 ,2 5 W L 5 5 7 5 a *1
e t eu iil o h p o ig ry. b c
p
'
e :4 0 1 01
534,t
( . Va S p .1 ,2 5 (ii g Fe .R.Ci P.1 ().Th f d rlr ls c ne ae n tc
W D. . e t 8 01 ) ctn d
v. 5 a) e e ea ue o tmplt o ie
pladi s t tt o he pa t ha t o runiy t de e is l.Se Eve e tv.Prs He lh
e ng o ha he t r ry s he ppo t t o f nd te f 4
rt
ion at

Se v ,41 F.App' 604,606 ( h Ci.2011 .Her,t c u'beive t tal ng pli ift
rs 2
x
4t r
) e he ot t le s ha lowi antf o
a nd on t e ofde enda s'ca ewoul no pr dedef nda swih s fcen tme t de l p
me
he ve
f nt s
d t ovi
e nt t ufi i t i o ve o
or he o r wil e y h litf
t erd fn e c u igp eu ieiTheref e, t c u t ld n t ep an ipsmo int caiy.
h i ee s , a sn rj dc .
to o lrf

Ha ig he r t e e i e c ,te c u tb le e ta n r a o a l j r rc ud fn t a G
vn ad h v d n e h o r eiv s h t o e s n b e u o o l i d h t W
R a on Ca pus' r a a a w hol and i c e of t con e por ne pr m o i nalm a e i l
pe
m ,' e d s
e
n ont xt he t m a ous o t o
tra ,

r a ona y i i t tEr mo wa a f le find t J c e who pr t nde t be on J ki s sde
e s bl mples ha a
s a s re o a ki
ee d o
ac e' i
w hie s ki t s
l ee ng o uppr s s xua a s ul r pori Si ia l ba e o t e de e a
e s e l sa t e t
ng. m l r y, s d n he vi nc dduc t
ed, he

1
Thi i e pe i lyt' i aca es h a t si whi h pl ntf c led ma oft wine s s
s s s cal l n
ue
s uc s hi n c ai if a l
ny he t s e
i ntfedby de e nt a adve s wine s .
de ii
f nda s s
r e t s es
4
Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 345 Filed 10/31/16 Page 4 of 5 Pageid#: 16986

c u tf rhe beiv s t tn r a o a l jzo c u d fnd ta an if h s etbihe b a
o r u t r le e ha o e s n be l r o l i h tplitf a sa ls d y
r
pr po er nc oft e de e t tde e nt de i d a i e
e nd a e he vi nc ha f nda s sgne nd nt nded t sde a a o y i i a i
hi f m t r mplc ton.

Theeo e t e c u twilg a td fn a t'moi n f rj d me ta amatro 1w i r lto t
rf r, h o r l rn e e d n s to o u g n s
te f a n eain o
pl i ifsdef ma i by i ia i ale tons I s hol ng,t c tde e pl ntf moton
antf
a ton
mplc ton lga i . n o di he our nis ai ips i
f l ve t c a iy ora e he c ai .
or ea o l r f
m nd r l m
Co l i
nc us on

Fo t er a o sae ,d f n a t'moin f rj d me ta amatro lw a t plitf
r h e s ns ttd e e d n s to o u g n s te f a s o an ifs
de ama i by i ia i c am i gr nt d a pl ntf moton t c a iy i deni The Clr i
f ton
mplc ton l i s a e nd ai ifs i o l rf s
ed.
ek s
dieced t s nd ce tfed c e oft sm e andum o ni a t a ompa ng or t a 1
r t o e
rii opis hi mor
pi on nd he cc
nyi
der o l
c m s lofr c d.
ot e
e or

sxvsR:Ths 3 1 da o tb r 2 6
i Jr y roco e, 01 .
Ch'fUnied St t DititJ
t
aes src udge

5
Case 3:15-cv-00023-GEC Document 345 Filed 10/31/16 Page 5 of 5 Pageid#: 16987