Bell v. Charlottesville Department of Child Protective Services et al

Filing 34

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 9/11/15. (jcj)

CLERKSOFFI U.S. ST K URI
CE
DI ,
AT ROANOG ,
VA
FI ED
L

I THE UN I
N
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I I I
CT
RG N A
CH AR LOTTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

sEP 112 1
25
J
BYULK C.

RK

,

:

DE

CL

'

J REE BELL,
A
Ci lA cton N o.3:
vi
i
15CV 00031

Pl i if
a ntf ,
M EM O R AN D UM O PINIO N

CH A RLO TTESVI
LLE D EPARTM EN T

H on. e E.
Gl n Conr
ad
Chi Unie St t s D it i tJ e
ef t d a e s rc udg

OF CHI PROTECTI SERVI
LD
VE
CES,1g
ç L,
Def nda s
e nt .
Ea le t syea , a e Be lsm i c l r n w e er m oved f om he cus ody a pl c d i t
r i r hi
r J r e l' nor hid e
r e
r
r t
nd a e n he

cusody oft i ma e na g a
t
he r t r l r ndmot . Bel c me e t sa ton r l t t t c t de son
her
l om nc d hi c i e aed o he usody cii
om a nt ul ,
m d
f nda s he t l tes le
cha
by f lng a pr yq c pl i on J y 1 2015. Shenn e asde e nt t t r o t vil
ii
o
-

De rme ofChid Pr e tveSe vi s'.lr em pl ee oft Charote vil De rm e o
pa t nt
l ot c i
r ce '1 ttee
oy s he
l t s le pa t nt f
,
Soci lSe v ce , e Sa pe,Sha
a r i s Br nda m
nnon M a r , nd El o Rei t gua di a lt m a
gui e a
m na d; he r an d ie ppoi e
nt d
f herc l e St phani Cangi ,a Cha l t vil J nie a Dom e tc Re a i Di t i
or
hidr n, e
e
n' nd
r otes le uve l nd
s i l tons s rd

Co tJ
ur udgeEdwa d Be r The c ei pr s nty be or t cour on t de e nt 'm oto t
r ry.
as s e e l f e he
t he f nda s
i ns o
di m i s Fort f l i r as , he c twilgr ntt de e nt m otons
s s.
he olow ng e ons t our l a he f nda s' i .
Fact Backeround
ual

O n J nua y 1 201 t Cha l t s le Depa t e tofSoc a Ser c t l d t o pe ii i
a r 2, 5, he
rote vil
rm n
i l vi es i e w
ttons n
t Cha l t vil J nie a D om es i Re a i nsD i ti tCour , s ntt Vi gi a Co
he
rotes le uve l nd
tc l to
s rc
t pur ua o r ni de

jj1 1252a o 1 1253. Thepeii s
6.- nd/r 6.ttons oughtt rmovalofBelst mi c l e fom
he e
l' wo nor hidrn r
he c t
r usody. The we es po tdby a a fda tfom Sha
y r up re
n fi vi r
nnon M a r a s i lwor empl
guie, oc a
ker
oyed
by t Charotesvil D epart entofSoci Servi
he
l t le
m
al
ces. The af i ti cat t Bel w as
fdavi ndi ed hat l

'Thecour hasbee adviedt tt se iy i pa4oft Fa iy Ser cesD i son oft Charotes le
t
n
s ha hi ntt s l he m l
vi
vii
he
l t vil
Deparm entofSoci Ser ces
t
al vi .

i r e aed o c r ofdomesi vi e e,ma ii wou ng,a c l a easar s tofa
nca c r t n ha ges
tc olnc
lc ous ndi nd hid bus
e ul
phys c la t r ton w ih D e m ond Ra s y, he f t rofBe ls one ye r ol da
i a le ca i
t
s
m e t a he
l'
- a - d ught r who w as
e,
pr s nti t ho e a t tm e oft i i nt t ta pr ec i or rw a i pl e pr bii B e l
e e n he m t he i
he nc de ; ha
ot tve de s n ac ohi tng l
f om havi a con a tw ih R a s y ort one- ar ol c l t tBe lhad pr e t d as
r
ng ny t c t m e
he
ye - d hid; ha l
es n e

e o i ly unsa e'a t tt De rme ofSocilSe vi e wasconc r d t ts woul
m tonal
tbl , nd ha he pa t nt
a r cs
e ne ha he
d

atmp t tk h rt c id e o to saewh n s ewa rla e fo j i.
te t o a e e wo hlr n u f tt e h s ee s d rm al
J
udge Be r f
r y ound t tt c l r n w e e a e o ne ec ed,o atrs ofbe ng a e or
ha he hid e
r bus d r gl t r i k
i bus d
ne e t d, Be l On J nua y 21 2015 J
gl c e by l .
a r ,
, udge Be r e e e a pr i i r r m oval de a di
r y nt r d elm na y e
or r war ng

tm por r c t y oft chidr t t i m ae nalgr ndmot , oceyn Bel. On M a c 11, 5,
e
a y usod
he l en o her tr
a
her J l
l
r h 201
J
udge Be r e e e a dipos to or rta f r i cus o t t m a e na gr ndm ot .
r y nt r d
s ii nal de r ns e r ng t dy o he t r l a
her
Be lsco pl ntars s f o t e c t y pr e ngs Bel c a m st t whie s w a
l' m ai i e r m hes us od oce di .
l l i ha , l he s

i a c rtd,heDepat ntofChidPrtci Sevi s(k 'wr ulytanse rdc t of
nc r eae t
rme
l oe tve r ce C
CPS' ongf l r fre usody
)
he c l r nt t i m ae na g a
r hid e o her t r l r ndmot r Bel c endst tf s alegai r ga di he m e t
he .
l ont
ha ale l tons e r ng r n al
he t we em a t CPS, ndt tt de rme ' e oye si ude t a lga i i a fda t
alh r de o
a ha he pa t nts mpl e ncl d he le tons n fi vis
a i the e t
ga ns r ven hough t e w a no C
her s d i lpr of' o s
physca o t uppor t a l atons Be la l ge t t
t he leg i . l le s ha
Ca n, he c l e sgua di n a lt m , f l t r t n he m es age . Bel f rhe a l gest t
ngi t hidr n'
r a d ie has aied o e ur r
s s
l u t r le
ha
CPS,Ca i a J
ng n, nd udge Be r havem a i i pos i e f rhe t r unie w ih he c l e
ry
de t m s bl o r o e t t r hidr n.
Bel doesnots e a m one a y da a s I t d,s as t tt sc t os t c t y
l
e k ny
t r m ge . nsea he ks ha hi our cl e he us od
ca e c i i l pr e ut t e pe s who pr de f l e i o m a i a ns he , r a nty
s , r m naly os c e hos r ons
ovi d a s nf r ton gai t r pe m ne l

r m ovet i vi lde e nt fom t i postons a r uniehe wih he c l e Bel not s
e
he ndi dua f nda s r her ii , nd e t r t r hidr n.
l e

t ts ha I lpa r ka e ist frfom CPSandwilber si mor gthejAug.
ha he s s pewor nd mal hus a r
al
l equetng e a r
2nd hearng' bef Judge Ber y.
i ' ore
r

ProceduralH i orv
st
B el,pr
l oceedi pr yçandj f ma p
ng o
. or aupe i,tl d t i t ntaci n o J y 1 201 The
n
rs ie he nsa to n ul , 5.
.
.

defnda ss e ntymo dt dimist complitpurua t Ruls1 b) 1 a 1 b)6)of
e nt ubs que l ve o s s he
an s nt o e 2( () nd 2( (
t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr du e Thec tnotfe Be lo t de e nt 'm o i a r r d
he de al es
vi oce r .
our iid l f he f nda s tons s equie

byRosbor v. rion,5 F. 309( hCi.1 , s di nottl a r pons Thematri
e o Gars 28 2d
4t r 975)but he d ie ny es e.
te s
rpe f di pos ton.
i or s ii

st
andar o Re q
ds f yiw

Rul 1 b)1 oft Fe r lRulso Ci l oc r per t apa t t mo f dimislof
e 2( () he de a e f viPr edu e mis ry o ve or s sa

a a to f rlc o s b e tmatr u idcin Theplitf b a st b r e o p o i t t
n cin o a k f u j c te j rs ito .
an if e r he u d n f r vng ha
s be t te j rs ito e it. Eva sv. F. r isCo,1 6F.d6 2 6 7( t Ci.1 9 .
u j c matr u id cin x ss
n B. Pekn . 6 3 4 , 4 4h r 99 )

Dimisl o lc o s b e t te j rs it ni a p o raet n yi temaeilu idcin la t
s sa f r a k f u j c matr u id ci s p r p it s l f h tra j rs it a fcs
o
o
o
a eno i ds ea t movngpa t i e il t prvaia amatro l ' l (ntr lctton
r t n iput nd he i ry s ntted o e l s te f aw. d.i ena iai
'

a dq o ai nmakso te ) I d cdngamoint ds s frlc o s be t te jzidcin,
n u tto r mi d . n e ii
l
to o imis o a k f u jc matr l s ito
r
t co ts ul ' ega d t pl a ngsasm e e e denc on t i s a m a c i re de e
he ur ho d ç r he e di
r
r vi e he s ue, nd y ons de vi nc

o tiet pe dn swi o t o v rigt p o e d n t o ef rs mma yj d me t' 1 .
u sd he la ig t u c n et he r c e i g o n o u r u g n . d
h
n
'
Rul l b)6 oft Fe r lRulso Ci l oc r pelnisapa t t mo f dimislof
e 2( () he de a e f viPr edue n t ry o ve or s sa
a com pl i f rf iur t sa e a cl i upon w hi r le c n be g a e To s vi di m i s lf
a nt o a l e o t t
am
ch e i f a
r nt d.
ur ve s s a or
f l e t s a e a c ai , pl ntf m us e t bls tf c al a i lt ' pl adi C a t lc e t t
aiur o t t l m a ai i f t s a i h ia i pl us biiy' by e ng s c ua ont nt ha
f
a l st c t o dr w t r s bl i e e t tt de e nti la e f t m i c
low he our t a he ea ona e nf r nce ha he f nda s i bl or he s onduc
t

alged.' As r tv. qba,556U. 662,678(
le ' hcof I l
S.
2009) ( botom,apli ifmus
. $
At t
antf
t

S
nudger r cl msa r st lnefom c i et plusbl t rss dimisl' W agM or
hej ai cos he i r oncevabl o a i e' o e it s sa.'
e
Dols LLC v.Coz r, 0F. 359,36 65( hCi. 2)( i BelAt. p. Two y,550
,
a t68 3d
4- 4t r201 quotng l lCor v. mbl
U. 544,570(
S.
2007). W hieapr . ltga ' pla ngsaet belbeal c tu d,Gor v.
)
l oï ii nts e di r o i rly onsr e
q
don
3

Le ,574F. 11 11 (t Ci.1 ,apr K c antmus silc an s fcintf csCo
eke
2d 47, 51 4h r 978) o ompli
t tl onti ufi e a t t
t
r i e a rghtt r le a
a s i o e i f bove t s c a i l ve ' a C t t a c a m t r le t ti pl usbl on is
he pe ul tve e l' nd k a e l i o e i f ha s a i e t
s

fc ' Twombl 55 U. a 555,5 l c i rngaRul 1 b)6 moton,t cour may
a e.'
y, 0 S. t
70. n onsdei
e 2( () i he t
c i re bis a t c t orr f r e t i t c pl i . Se Philpsv.
onsde xhi t ta hed o e e r d o n he om a nt
e li
LCll ' l ,1 F.
ntl nc. 90 3d
,

609,61 ( hCi.1 )
8 4t r 999 .
D i c s on
s us i

Th d fn a t h vemo e t ds s t epanifsc mp an f rlc o s b e t te
e ee d ns a
v d o imis h litf o lit o a k f u j c matr
J i di i a f f iur t sa e apl us bl c ai f rr le . The c t l c i re h a g e
' s cton nd or a l e o t t
ur
a i e l m o e if
our wil ons de ac r um nt
i t n.
n ur

1
.

M oton t Dimisf La o Subj tM ate Jurs c i
i o s s or ck f ec
tr iditon

Th d fn a t frtag eta ti c u ta k s b e tmatr u idcint a r ij n tv
e e e d n s is r u h t h s o r lc s u j c te j rs ito o wad nu cie
r le r ques e i t c pl nt s c fca l t r ues t tt s c toverur J e Be r s
ei f e
t d n he om ai , pe ii ly he eq t ha hi our
t n udg
r y'
c t de s on a r unie B e lw ih herc l r n. The c t ee . U nde t Rooke - l m a
us ody ci i nd e t l t
hid e
our agr s
r he
r Fe d n

d crn , e e a d src c u t d n t a es be t t r u idcint h a d a e b o g tb
o ti e fd rl itit o rs o o h v u j c mat j rs ito o e r i s s r u h y
e
c
saec u to esc mp an n o ij re c usdb saec u tu g n srn rdb f r ted src
tt-o r ls r o lii g f nu is a e y tt-o rj d me t e dee eo e h itit

c u t r c e i sc mme e a divingd src c u t e iw a drj cin o t o ej d me t.2
o r p o e dng o nc d n n t itit o r rve n ee to f h s u g n s,
i
,
Ex o M o l r v. u i scl d s Co'.5 4U. 28 , 8 ( 0 5 . Ac o dn l t t e
x n biCo p. Sa d Ba i n u . l , 4 S. 0 2 4 2 0 ) c r igy,o h
p
e tn Bel e k rv e o , r eif r m,ud eBer sc so yd cso , e c mpan i s b e to
xe t ls e s e iw fo r le fo J g ry' u t d e iin h r o lit s u j c t
dimis lunde Rul l b)1.
s sa
r e 2( ( )
ll.

M oton t Di m i s f Faiure t St e a Cl m Upon W hi R elefC an Be G rant
i o s s or l
o at
ai
ch
i
ed

Belsc anti as s j c t dimislunde Rul 1 b)6)f anumbe ofr a ons
l' ompli s lo ube t o s sa
r e 2( ( or
r es .
2TheRooke - dma docrnei namedafert Supr Cour c es Rookerv.Fi iyTr tCo.263
r Fel n ti s
t wo
eme
t as ,
delt us
,

U. 41 ( 9 3 , n Ditito Col aCo t Ap asv. ed n 46 U. 4 ( 98 )
S. 3 1 2 ) a d src f umbi urof pe l F lma , 0 S. 62 1 3 .
4

Fis ,o t e e Bel a kst scou tt cl e t c t ca e orot r s i ewe i ongoi
r t t he xtnt l s hi r o os he usody s
he wie nt l ne n
ng
pr e ngsbe or J e Be r s h r le i ba r d by t a t nton doc r ne s tf t i Y o
oce di
f e udg
r y, uc e i f s r e
he bs e i
t i e orh n unge
r

v. ri,401U. 37( 971. TheYounge docrnepr dest taf r c ts da ti
Hars
S. 1 )
r ti ovi ha edeal our houl bsan
fom i ef rngi asaepr e di e ni ihasj iditont r a ht meis i ()t r ae
r ntrei n tt oc e ng, ve f t urs ci o e e he rt,f 1 hee r
ongoi sat j ca pr ee ngs ( t pr e ngsi iaei tntsaei eess a (
ng t e udiil oc di ;2) he oc edi mplc t mpora tt ntr t; nd 3)
t r ia a
he e s n dequa eoppor uniy t r i e a f de alc ai si t sat pr ee ngs M a tn M a i ta
t
t t o a s ny e r l m n he t e oc di .
ri
ret

Cor v. avlndComm' o Huma Reltons 38F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 .
p. M r a
n n
n ai , 3d 392, 396 4t r 994)

Appl ngt s prncpls t c tconcude t Belscli f ij tver le ae
yi he e i i e ,he our
l s hat l' ams or nunci eif r
s j ctt dimis lunde Younce. Fis,ii ce rfom t c antt tt saecusody
ube o s s a
r
r rt t s la r he ompli ha he tt t
pr ee ng we eongoi a t tmet sa tonwasfld,snc t c
oc di s r
ng t he i hi c i
ie i e he ompl i i c t st tBelwa
ant ndia e ha l s
s he ed t a a f ahe rngbef r J
c dul o ppe r or a i
o e udge Bery onAugus 2,201 Sec
r
t
5.
ond,i i wel
ts l
esa i he t tc l c t m a t r i plc t i po t ntsa e i e e t . Se M oo e v.Si s 442
t bls d ha hid us ody te s m i a e m r a t t nt r s s
e
r
m ,

U. 415, ( 9 (a l r ltonsar ata tona a e ofsaec r . Thid,t r i no
S. 435 1 79) fmiy eai
e rdii l r a tt oncen)
r he e s
i c ton t Be lc nno r i e he c ai s i t s a e co tp oc edi . Be us Bel hasnot
ndi a i hat l a t a s r l m n he t t ur r e ngs
ca e l
i tf e a e r or na y c r um s a est tm i htgi r s t a e e i t t a i a i of
den ii d ny xt a di r i c t nc ha g
ve ie o n xc pton o he pplc ton
t Younge doc rne,t c tc ude t ti m us a t i f om hea i a ofhe c ai s
he
r ti he our oncl s ha t t bs a n r
rng ny
rlm
concer ng t pendi st e pr
ni he
ng at oceedi
ngs.

Addii l a c ai sa i tt D e rm e ofSoc a Se vi esa e ba r by t El ve h
tonaly, ny l m ga ns he pa t nt
i l r c r r ed he e nt
Am e e t t Unied St t Cons iuton. Pur ua t t El ve h A m e en ,t n
ndm nt o he t
a es
tt i
s nt o he e nt
ndm t t
a
u ons ntng St t i i m une f o s t br
nc e i
ae s m
r m uis oughti f de alc t b he ow n c tz . Edel a v.
n e r ours y r
ii ens'
'
m n

J da 415U. 651 662- ( 974 . Thi pr e to as c endst saea nce , ge sof
or n,
S. , 63 1 )
s otcin lo xt
o tt ge is Re nt
Uni ofCalv. e,51 U. 425 429( 997) whihaec i r dd m lloft Stt,' t
v.
. Do 9 S. ,
1 , c r onsde e ' s he ae'M ,
ar
He lhyCivSc Dit Bd. Educ v. e 429U. 274,280( 977) l Vigi a de t t of
at t h. s. of
. Dovl,
S.
1 . n r ni, parmens

s a s r ce ar c i r d la m soft Com m onwea t . . a l a tw he i c e t t rr e i
oci l e vi s e ons de e i r
he
1h . , t e s
n t om s o hei ol n
pr t c i c l e ' N e s n v. e r c N o.3: 1 c 0001 2011U . Di t LEX I 1
o e tng hidr n.
' l o H r i k,
1 - v4,
S. s .
S 23618 a *35
,t

( . Va. t26, 1;s eas Doev. lnsNo. 1
W D. Oc. 201 ) e lo
Muli , 2:0CV0001 201 U. DitLEXI 74080,
7, 0 S. s.
S
a *( . Va. 0)( di t tt W ieCo yDe rmen ofSocalSevies i isr ei
t W D. 201 hol ng ha he s unt pa t t
i r c ,n t ol n
pr e tngc l e ii prpel c rcei da a am oft sae'. I t absnceofc e t
otci hidrn,ks o ry haa trze s n r
he tt') n he e
onsnt o
s tora e es w a ve ofi m uniy, he Cha l t s leD e rm e ofSoc a Se v ce a isChid
ui
n xpr s i r m
t t
rote vil pa t nt
i l r i s nd t
l
Pr ec i Se vi s Di s on a e i m une f o labiiy unde t El vent Am e
ot tve r ce vi i r m
r m i lt
r he e h
ndm e t
n.

Thec tlkewie c l st tJ
our i s onc ude ha udgeBe r a St p ni Ca n,t gua di a lt m
ry nd e ha e ngi he r an d ie
a
ppoi ed f he c l e a e i m une fom la lt Se St p v.Spa km a 435 U . 349,
nt or r hidr n, r m
r i biiy. e um
r n,
S.

3 5 5 ( 9 8 ( ic so udca i ntl s eas Flmigv As il4 F.d8 6 8 9(t Ci.
5 - 6 1 7 ) d susinj iilmmu iy ; e lo e n . b l 2 3 8 , 8 4h r
,
1 ( di t tt dee nt whiea tngast g din,wa i
994) hol ng ha he fnda , l ci
he uar a s mmunefom la lt e ni
r ibiiy, ve f

s ele t tej d ei o e c u t.
h id o h u g n p n o r)
Fi ly, l Belhasatmptdt i
nal whie l te e o nvoket co tsf rlq si j iditon,he
he ur' edea ueton urs ci
r
com pl i , n unde t m os lbe a c tud i f ist a l ge s fci ntf t t s a e a pl us bl
a nt eve
r he
t i r l onsr on, a l o le uf i e ac s o t t
a i e

cli unde any f de alc tt i lorsa ut ypr son a i ta oft na e def nt .
am
r
e r onsiutona
tt or ovii gans ny he m d enda s

Ac o dn l t c mpliti s b e t ods sa u d rTwo l a dI b l
c r igy,he o an s u jc t imisl n e
mb y n q a.
C oncl i
us on

Fort r a ons sat d, he c t ilgr ntt de e nt 'm o i nst dim i s The Cl r i
he e s
t e t our w l a he f nda s t o o s s .
ek s
diec e t s nd c e oft sm e or nd o ni a t a c pa ng or rt t pl i ifa
r t d o e opi s hi m a um pi on nd he c om nyi
de o he a ntf nd
a lc
l ouns lofr c d.
e
e or

ENTER : Thi l(Q day ofSe ember 2015.
s
pt
,
Chi U nied St esD i r ctJudge
ef t
at
sti