Baird et al v. The Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation

Filing 17

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/29/16. (jcj)

I THE U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI OF V I F I
CT
RG N A
CH ARLOTTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

CL S OFFI U. DI COUFF
ERK'
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

h:2 2S 2 1
1
26
z' '
e

Ju
BY I c.

:

TODD A. RD,e a1,
BAI
t .

jt , -M y
z cl
u

w- u
./)
'd

Pl i i f ,
a ntf s

Ci lAci No.3: 5- 00041
vi ton
1 CVM EM O M N DU M O PI I N
N O

THE FEDEM L HOM E M ORTGAGE
CORPOM TI ,
ON
By:
Hon. e E.Co a
Gln
nr d
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

D e e nt
f nda .

Pl ntfsToddA . id a Da G.Ba r fld t sa ton a ns de e ntThe
ai if
Ba r nd na
id ie hi c i gai t f nda

Fe e a Ho M o ta eCo oain(Trd i M a ' . ec s f c s so tef r co u es l
d r l me rg g p rto G e d e c' Th a e o u e n h o e l s r ae
)
oft Bar 'hom ea t i s bs nte c i The c s i pr s nty be or t cour on
he ids
nd her u eque viton.
a e s e e l f e he
t

Frd i M a ' mo int ds s t ec mplitpls a tt Ru e1 ( )6 o teF d rl lso
e d e cs to o imis h o an t u n o l 2 b ( ) f h e ea Rue f
r
Ci lPr dlr .Fo t r s nss tf rh be o t moton t dim iswilbegr nt d. t
vi ote ze r he ea o e o t l w, he i o s s l
a e wih
r pec t Count 1 1 1 a I ofpli if 'c
es t o
s , 1 , nd V
antfs ompl i a wilbede ed wih r pe t Count
ant nd l
ni
t es ct o
1 . antfs r ue tf l vet fl a n nde c
1 Pl i if ' eq s or ea o ie n me d ompli wilbegr nt
ant l
a ed.
B ac ound
kzr

Thef l wi f t,t ke fom pli if 'c
olo ng ac s a n '
r
antfs ompl i ,a ea e e a tuef pu pos of
ant r cc pt d s r or r es

temo in t ds s.S eErc s n v P z us 5 U. 8 , 4( 0 7 .
h to s o imis e ik o . a d , 51 S. 9 9 2 0 )
O n J m e 9,2004,pl i if e e e i o a m or ga l n w ih GM A C B n f pr pe t
t
a ntf s nt r d pt
t ge oa t
nk or o ry

l t a 3934 Ca pbe lRoadi Tr Vigi a Thel n wa e de e by ano ea s lr d
ocaed t
m l
n oy, r ni .
oa
s vi nc d
t nd ecze
by ade d oft s . de oft u ta nt d Br ndo Bes c a t se
e
nzt The ed r s ppoi e a n wik s nzt e.
A ts e poi t e f e ,GM A C Ba a s gne t not t G M A C M o t ge,LLC
om
nt her a t r
nk s i d he e o
r ga

(C
G
GMAC M o ta e' wh came alrg t a h le o t en t . AC M o ta ete
rg g ', o li d 1 ih s s od r f h o e GM
)
rg g h n
a sg e t en t t F e d eM a a dC ce a (n a e tf rFrd i M a , ih wa t a ma
sin d h oe o r d i c n ç td s a ) g n o e d e c whc s he c l
a
o ro te1 m1'Z ! 1 On Au s 1 , 0 ,
wne f h 0 . J 6.
'
gu t 9 20 9 GMAC M o ta ea p itdPr fs in l
rg g p on e o e so a
Fo e l s r Co r to o Vign a(PFC' a s b t uetutei plc o Be wik. e
rco u e mo ain f r ii < ' s u si t r se n a e f s c Th
1 )
t
a i me doc e wasr co de i t Clr sOfi e f rLouiaCo y.
ppont nt um nt
e r d n he e k' lc o
s unt
Pli if e nm al de a t on t i m orgag 1 . a r s t GM AC M orga
a ntfs ve ly f uled her t e 0= As e ul,
t ge

i tu t d PFC t f e l eon t Pt ry.PFC publs dt a rie e t f t
nsr c e
o or c os
he ope t
ihe wo dve ts m n s or he
f e l tr s l i t Ri hmond- mesDipa c on Se e r28 2009 and Oc obe 5 2009.
or c osle ae n he c
Ti
s th
pt mbe ,
t r ,
On Oc obe 7,2009 a a oxi t l 5: p. i PFC c
t r
t ppr ma ey 30 m ,
onduc e a f r c os es ei fon oft
t d o e l m al n r t he

Louia Co y Cic tCot Fr ddi M a m a t hi tbi of$11 01 00 a bec m e
s unt r ui ut e e c de he ghes d
2, 7. nd n
r co downe oft pr rytlough a e c e tu t sd d. AC M orgaget n r pored
e r
r he ope t lr
n xe ut d r see' ee GM
t
he e t
t c e tblr a t tpli if 'hom eha be n f r c os d. o di t t c pli , antfs
o r di ze us ha a ntf s
d e o e l e Acc r ng o he om a nt pl i if
di no be om ea r oft f r l ur untlNove rof2009.
d t c
wa e he o ecos e i
mbe

On M a c 1 201 Fr ddi M a fl d a unl wf de ane a ton a ns pl n if i
r h 9, 2, e e c ie n a ul t i r c i gai t aitfs n
t Louia Count Ge r lDititCour. a ntfswer s r e notc oft aci n bym al On
he
s
y ne a src
t Pli if
e e v d ie he to
i.

Aprl10, 2, hege r ldititc thel ahe i i whih i a r d pos es i o t
i 201 t
ne a src our d arng n c t wa de
s son f he
pr ryt Fr ddi M ac Pli if we enotpr e a t hea i ast y a lgedl hadno
ope t o e e
. antfs r
es nt t he rng he le y
notc oft a ton. J y 5,201 Fr ddi M a fl as c unl wf de ane a ton
i e he c i On ul
2, e e c ied e ond a ul t i r c i
a i tpli if ;
ga ns a ntfs howe r Fr ddi M a ob ane anon- ui i t sca eon Se e r4, 2.
ve , e e c t i d
s t n hi s
pt mbe 201
On M a 1 201 pl i if fl a c pl i a i tFr e M ac GM AC M o t ge,a
y , 2, a ntf s ied om a nt ga ns eddi
,
r ga
nd

PFC i t Cic tCour ofLouia Count s ki da a a r s s i n oft f r l m e
n he r ui
t
s
y, ee ng m ges nd e ciso
he o ec os

a t se sde d.
nd nzt e' e Two we ksl t ,GM Ac' orga fld aba pt y peii whih sa d
e arr
M t ge ie
nknz c tton, c t ye
a1ltga i ag ns i. antfsob ane anon-ui i t saci o Fe ua y 21 201
1 ii ton ai t t Pl i if t i d
s t n hi ton n br r , 3.

I M a c of201 Fr eM acl ke pli if outoft i hom ea pr ve e t m
n rh
3, eddi
oc d antf s
her
nd e nt d he
f o e e i Asar s t pl i if l tpe s lpr pe t t twa l a e i i t hous .
r m ntrng.
e ul, antfs os r ona o ry ha s oc t d nsde he
e
Pl i if fld t i t n a ton a i tFr ddi M a i t Cicui Co tofLouia
antfs ie he nsa t c i gans e e c n he r t ur
s
Coun y on J y 1 201 a s ri va i c am sr l t t t f r cos e oft i home a
t
ul 3, 5, s e tng rous l i e aed o he o e l ur
he r
nd

s b e u n e ito Th s c u t i cu e b e c o e p ii c v n n s( u t1; r a h o
u s q e t vcin. e e o n s n ld : ra h f x lct o e a t Co n ) b e c f
c nrc ( u t 1; o f le ito ( u t11; n b e c o i idc v na t fg o fih
o ta t Co n 1) wr ng' v cin Co n 1) a d ra h f mpl o e n o o d at
u
e
a dfi d ai ( un I . nt ec mpan , litfsc ne t a t e fldag iv nc lte
n ar e l Co t V) I h o litp an if o tnd h t h y ie re a e etr
hg
t Fr eM a ptr ua t t de oft s.The s e c m pe a or da a si t a ot of
o eddi c ls nt o he ed nlt
y e k o ns t y m ge n he m mt

$500, 00.On Augus 11 201 Fr eM a r
000.
t , 5, eddi c emovedt c et t scour.
he as o hi
t

Up nrmo a, e d eM a mo dt d s s t c mplit zs a t oRue 1 b ()o
o e v lFrd i c ve o imis he o an pl u n t l 2()6 f
r
t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr ed e Theco thel ahe rng ont m oton o M a c 24,201
he de al es
vi oc ur .
ur d
ai
he i n r h
6.

Themoton ha be n f ly bre e a i rpef diposton.
i s e u l i f d nd s i or s ii
Standard ofR e ew
vi

Rul 1 ( )6 o t Fe ea Rue o Cii P o e u epemisapa t t mo ef r
e 2 b ( ) f he d r l ls f v l r c d r r t ry o v o
dim is lofa a ton f rf iur t s aea cai upon whi r i c n begr nt d. su ve
s sa
n ci o al e o tt l m
ch elef a
a e To twi
s h amoton,apl i ifmus esa ih tf c a pl usbiiy'by pl a ngif c t lc e t t
uc
i
antf
t t bls ça i l a i lt '
e di Ga tz ontnt ha
a
al wst co tt dr w t r as
lo he ur o a he e onabl i e e t tt de e nti labl f t miconduc
e nf r nce ha he f nda s i e or he s
t

alg d. As r f v.c a, 5 U, 6 2, 78(0 9 . l lr la e alg to si te
le e ' hco t I b l5 6 S. 6 6 2 0 ) A1welp e d d l ai n n h
'
e
c
ompl i a et n astuea a1 r as na ef t ile e esa e d a i t pli ifsf vo .
ant r ake
r nd l e o bl acual rf r nc r r wn n he a ntf a r

Ed r sv. t o God b r ,1 8F.d2 , 4 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Ho v r çatb to a
wa d Ciy f ls o o 7 3 31 2 4 4h r 9 9 . we e ,i l o tm,
g
pli ifmus G
antf t nudgeg r camsaéos t lnefom c i bl t plusbl t r ss
he) li r s he i r onceva e o a i e' o e it

ds s a. W a M o eDo ' LLC v Co at6 0F.d3 9 3 4 6 (t Ci. 1 )( u tn Bel
imis l' a r c .
'
à
. z r, 8 3 5 , 6 - 5 4 h r 20 2 q o ig l
At. p. . mby 5 0U.. 4 , 7 ( 0 7 M oe ve,h c mp an mus c n an
lCo v Two l, 5 S 5 4 5 0 2 0 :. r o r te o lit t o ti
3

s fcintf c sç o r ie arghtt r le a vet s ultvel ve 'a t t t ac am t r i
ufi e a t t a s i o e if bo he pec a i e l' nd t a e l i o elef
t
s
t ti plusbl o isf ce. Twom bl 550 U. at555,570.Alhough a c m pl i ne d not
ha s a i e n t a '
'
y,
S.
t
o ant e
c t i deaied f c ua alegai ns i mus co an m o et nçlbesa concusons' nd ç
on a n t l a t l l to ,t t nt i r ha ça l nd
l i 'a &
a
f r ai r ciai n oft e e e t ofac us o a ton wilnotdo.' d. t555. n c i rng a
o mul c e tto
he l m n s
a e f ci
l
'I a
l onsde i

Rul 1 b ( )mo in tec u t yc n ie e iisatc e t o r fre t i t c mpli t
e 2()6 to ,h o r ma o sd r xhbt ta h d o r e er d o n he o an .
S eP ilp v. It .nc,1 0F.d60 , 8(t Ci. 9 9 .
e h lis LC1 n ' I . 9 3 9 61 4 h r 1 9 )
l
Di
scuss on
i

1
.

N otce Pri t Judi i A c i
i
or o
c al ton

Fr ddi M a fr ta g st tt compl nts d be dim is d be us pl ntf sf ie
e e c is r ue ha he
ai houl
s s e ca e ai if a ld
t a f d i ar as bl opporuniy t t ke c r c i a i ptr ua t pa a a 20 oft
o for t e ona e
t t o a ore tve cton zs nt o r gr ph
he

d e o tu tPaa rph2 pr vd st tSn çt rBo r we o Le d rma c mme c , opzr
e d f r s. r g a 0 o ie ha ç q i
l he ro r r n e y o n e j i o
b j ie t a yj diil cin'h taie o to t la d cl n so ab e c o a yo te
e on d o n u ca a to 't a rs s u f he o n o l t r ra h f n f h
me
l n docl e t t i l uc Borowe orLe rha notfe t o he pa t ..ofs h alege
oa
lm n s mtl t h r r
s
nde s ii d he t r ry .
uc l d
br c a a f de t ot rpm' he eo ar a o bl pe i a trt gi ng o s h no i et
ea h nd for d he he
t r t e s na e rod fe he vi f uc tc o
y

tk c re tv a to 'Co lEx. !2 , c e No. - . rg a h 1 o t ed e o t s
a e o rcie cin. mp . A 0 Do k t 1 1 Paa rp 5 f h e d f nlt
'
f rhe prvie t tt aln tc sgv nb Bo r we o Le d ri c n e to wi t sS c t
u t r o d s ha ç ql o ie i e y ro r r n e n o n ci n t hi e miy
g
h
l sr me t t i wrtn . I !1 . h rdsrc c u t h vef u dt a amo tie tc l
n tu n mus be n iig' d. 5 Ote itit o rs a o n h t l s d nia
'
l gua pr cuded ltga i whe t pa t aleg ng avi ai n oft agr e e f l t
mz ge e l
ii ton
n he ry l i
ol to
he e m nt aied o
pr deno i a a o
ovi
tce nd n ppor t t c et t br a hi pa t pro t flng s t See e. ,
hmiy o ur o he e c ng ry i r o ii ui. e g.
Es e v.Fed. om e Loan M o t ge Cor , o. 1 CV - 28,201 W L 1
tp
H
r ga
p. N 5: 3- 021
4
276495,a *
t4

( D. . . r 27 201 ) Hota flv W el Fa c Bn ks A.No CI A. 1 - 0 3
S. W Va Ma . , 4 ; l p e . ls r o n N. , . V. 2:2 0 9 7,
z
201 W L 1
3
337283,a * ( D. . M a . 201 ;Ke' v.Unie Stt s No.3:2CV490t 3 S. W Va. r 29, 3) l
ns
td ae ,
1
J 201 W L 5877479,a *4( D. Nov. 201 .
RS, 2
t E. Va.
20, 2)
4

I t i t ntc s ,asa i ta m a tr t c t ive t tt f cli i pl ntfs
n he nsa a e
n niil te , he our bele s ha he our a ms n ai if '
c
ompli a epr diatd o t de oft s,a a al ge s bs que m odii a i t t de d
ant r e c e n he ed nlt nd n le d u e nt
fc ton o he e
oft s,ast c us ofa ton de nd on t e se eofa c r t lr lto hi bewe n t
nzt he a es c i
pe
he xitnc
ontacua e ai ns p t e he
pa te .Se G e be v.Fi s Hor z H o e Loa Co p. N o. 1
ris e r r
r t i on m
ns r , 05- 554P,
2006 W L 581 2, t*3
08 a

( . W a h. a . , 0 6 ( e yigmo int d s s acam u d rt Co sl rPr tci n
W D. s M r 8 2 0 ) d n n to o imis li n e he n t
me o e to
Act des t non- omplanc wih t notc a c epr vii be aus s h al ga i of
, pie
c
i e t he ie- nd- uz o son, c e uc le ton

d c p i b sne sp a tc sG lal e ssid p nd n o a yc n rc b t e t epate '
e e tve u i s r cie û e ry xit n e e e t f n o ta t ewe n h ris).
c
Pli if do no co e ot r s buti t d al get tt y s tsi d t no i e a cze
antfs
t nt nd he wie, nsea le ha he aife he tc - nd- lr
pr son.
ovii Thus t c tfndst tpli if we er quie t co y wih t notce a cle
, he our i ha antfs r e r d o mpl t he i - nd- tr
pr vii pro t flngt i c
o son i r o ii her ompl i .
ant
Pli if a guet tt y s ntadr f ve son o t co antt Fr ddi M a o Jme 23,
antfs r
ha he e
a t r i f he mpli o e e c n t
201 ls t n t e we ksbef r slng s t Fr ddi M a c e t tt e wee wasnota
5, e s ha hr e e
o e i ui. e e c ont nds ha hr e
ks
r a ona epe i f i t t ke c r c i a ton,a t r f e pl i if di notc
e s bl rod or t o a ore tve ci nd, he e or , antfs d
ompl wih
y t
t no i - nd- tr pr vii i t dee oft s . n ism o i howe r Fr eM a ct st
he tce a cle o son n he d nzt l t ton,
ve , eddi c ie o
s r lc s si whih t dititc ltf
eve a a e n c he src otr ound t t pli ifpr de no notc t t
hat he antf ovi d
ie o he

d fn a tp irt iiitn j d ca a to a d t u , imis dtea to . ec u t st wae
ee d n ro o rtaig u iil cin n ,h s ds s e h cin Th o r i ma r
l
ofa a ho iy t s
ny ut rt o uppor t pr ii t tt e wee i no aG e s bl pe i 'f a
t he oposton ha hr e
ks s t d a ona e rod' or
r
br a hi pa t t a las ilta ec r tvea ton. onl a ho iy t tFr ddi M a
e c ng ry o t e t riit oreci c i The y ut rt ha e e c

pr vi si t Re lEsa eSe te e Pr edlesAc t tgve lnde st ry da t tkea ton
o de s he a t t tlm nt oc tr
t ha i s e r hit ys o a c i

wihrs c t aboro rsi r 1 U. C.j2605()2) Thec ti no pes dedbyt s
t e pe t o
r we ' nquiy. 2 S.
e( .
our s t rua
hi
a gum e ,a t ts m e s a ut pr de t tt l nde m us s nd r c ptoft co r s nde e
r
nt s ha a
t t e ovi s ha he e r
t e e ei
he r e po nc

wihnfved y d ne st a to rq se i tk nwi i s hpeid. I . 2 0 ()1( .
t i i a s s ls he cin e uetd s a e t n uc ro ' d j 6 5 e( )A)
u
h
'
Ass
uch,t sa ut cea l co e a e ast ton i whih al nde m a t ke c r c i a ton
he tt e l ry nt mplt s iua i n
c e r y a ore tve c i

wihi afve- y pe i The ef r ,t c tfndst tpl i if ha s fcinty pl
tn
da rod. r o e he our i ha antfs ve uf e l ed
c
omplanc wih t notc - nd- tr pr son i t de d oftus.
i e t he ie a cle ovii n he e
r t
I.
I

Faiur t St e C l m s
l e o at ai

Fr ddi M a ne a gue t t e n i t c r doesnotdim ist co pl n f f l e
e e c xt r s ha, ve f he ou t
s s he m ait or aiur
t c m pl wih t notc a c epr vii i t de d oftus,t co a n f ist sa ea
o o y t he ie- nd- ur o son n he e
r t he mpli t a l o tt ny
c am upo whi h r le m a begr nt d.
li
n
c ei f y
a e
a. Count1 Br ac o ExplctCove
: e h f
ii
nant i t De d ofTr t
s n he e
uj
l CountIoft c
n
he ompli ,pl n if cli t tFr i M a br a he t de d oftus,
ant aitf s am ha edd e c e c d he e
r t
whih r uie t tal aci nst ke t wa dsf e os ebei a c dq ewih a i a elw .
c eq r d ha 1 to a n o r or cl ur
n c or nc t pplc bl a
Spe ik aly,pl i if c e t tGM AC M orgage' a nt e o PFC ass tt etuse
c t l antfs ontnd ha
t
s ppoi m nt f
ubsiut r t e
wa i ld, ha Be wi k r m anedt tuse l rt de oft u t a t tPFC wa no
s nvai t t s c e i he r t e mde he ed r s, nd ha
s t
e il d t f e os on t Pr t Thus pl ntfsco e t tt f e l ur ,Fr ddi M ac'
ntte o or cl e he opery.
, ai if nt nd ha he or c os e e e
s
s eq n t a u de ane a to ,andpli if 'e c i n we ei vi a i ofVigi a1w
ubs ue t ml wf l t i r ci ns
antf s vito
r n olton
r ni a

a dt tr o t ed e o tu tI mo i t ds s Co n 1 Frd i M a ag e ta : 1
n he e ms f h e d f r s.n vng o imis u t , e d e c r u s h t ( )

panif lc sa igt c le etea p it n o PFC a s bsiuetu te ()GMAC
litfs a k tndn o halng h p on me t f
s u ttt r se ; 2
M o ta e sa ponme to PFC a s bsi etutewa v ld; n ( ) anif ' a ko n tc
rg g ' p i t n f
s u t r se s ai a d 3 plitfs lc f o ie
mt
a gt nti ba r d by t sa u eoflm iatonsa nots
r une s r e
he t t t
i ti
nd
uppore by t t r soft de of
td he e m
he ed
/

our wil r s c r um nt n ur
t s . Thec t l add e sea h a g e i t n.
nz t1
L St ng
andi

Asa i ta m a tr Fr ddi M acfr ta gue t tpl i if do nothavesa ngt
n nii l te , e e
is r s ha antfs
tndi o
c le e t a
ha l ng he ppoi m e ofPFC a s tt e t u t e. ha sandi a pl i ifm us
nt nt
s ubs iut r s e To ve t ng, a ntf
t

de nsrt .( )t theors hass frda Sn u yi fc't i co rt,pa tc ai d,
mo tae' 1 ha
he ufee n û j r n a t'hat s ncee riulrze
i
1

I tero p st nb ifpanif asr ta, n e Co nt,h yd n tcam ta F e deMa b e c e
n h i p o ii rel litfs seth tu d r u 1te o o li h t rd i c ra h d
o

t de d oftus be us t y di notr cevea t alnotc oft f r l ur s l Ass h,hecoltnee notde de
he e
r t ca e he d
e i cu
ie he o ecos e ae. uc t tr d
ci
whehe pl ntfsha saedaplusbl cam f rbr ac oft dee oft tt rs ht y.
t r ai if ve tt
a i e li o e h he d rus mde uc heor

6

a a t l ri ne t ()t a t eei ac u a c n e to b t e t ij r a dtec n u t
nd cua o mmi n ;2 h t h r s a s l o n cin e we n he nu y n h o d c
c mplie o ; nd()t a ii l eyt a t eij r wi ber d e s db af v r b ed cso
o an d f a 3 h t t s i l h t h n u y l e rs e y a o a l e iin.
k
l
Lu a v Dee deso W idie 5 4U. 5 5 5 0 61( 9 2 . s ef rab e c o ad e o
in . fn r f l l , 0 S. 5 , 6 - 1 9 ) To u o ra h f e d f
f
tt t one mus ha sa ng t G s e t sown l lrght a i t r ss a c nnotr s hi
rl ,
s
t ve t ndi o l s r hi
a
ega i s nd n e e t , nd n
et s

c am t r le on t l lrg sori e essoft r pa te . W a t v. l n,422U . 490,
l i o ei f he ega i ht nt r t hid ri s' rh Sedi
'
S.

4 9 ( 9 5 .no d rt ha sa dngt s o ac nr d i Vign a t n mu tb ap tyt o
9 , 1 7 ) I r e o ve tn i o ue n o ta n r ii,t e s e a' o r
o
t
b n fcayo t ec nr c. W ofv. d. tlMo t. s , 1 F. p' 3 6 3 2( t Ci.
e eiir f h o ta t' l Fe Na' rc As ' 5 2 Ap x 3 , 4 4h r
'
n
2 3.
01 )
l t i t ntc s ,t c tc l
n he nsa a e he our oncudest tpl ntfsdo no ha sa ng t c le
ha ai if
t ve tndi o ha lnge
PFC' a n men a s tmt tu t . antfst notale t tt y a eapa t t t
S pppi t t s ubsi e r see Pl i if i
do
lge ha he r
ry o he
doc nta n i PFC,t tt y a et i e
ume ppoi tng
ha he r he ntnded be ûca i soft a nt e ,o t t
ne ire
he ppoi m nt r ha
t y ha a diec i ve e i t m a tr'Le sv. tonsa M o' .
he d ny r t nvol m nt n he te .' wi Nai t r lc.LLC, o.
t
N

3:3 0 2 , 01 W L 3 25 , t* ( . Va J n. 9 2 4 ; e as Bemetv. n o
1 CV0 0 6 2 4
25 9 a 3 W D. . a 2 , 01 ) s e lo i t Bn k f
Am.N. , 1
. A.3:2CV3 , 01 W L 1 5 5 , t* ( D. . r 1 , 1 )(i dngt t litf
42 2
3 4 46 a 7 E. Va Ap . 8 20 2 fn i ha p an if
lc e sa igt c le g t v ldt o t s si t t se a p it n be a s çp litf
a k d tndn o haln e he ai i f he ub tt e nzte p on me t c u e ç jan if
y
u
g

wa no ap ryt ted c me t p o ni PFC, n ta çt ln e qa p itdPFC a
s t a t o h o u n a p itng
a d h t lhe e d r p on e
g
s
s bsi t tu tea dt lnd rsc t e p e a e ted c me t (h bor wejha n dr c
u tt e r se n he e e' oms l rp r d h o u n ; te ro r d o ie t
u
iv l e n .ç ih u a e f r e b ec nr c rg t glitfs lc sa igt a tc te
n o v me f) S to t n n b c a l o ta t ih , panifj a k tndn o ta k h
W
vai t oft a nt t'M orion v.W e l Fa zoBa N . ,30 F.Su 3d 449,454
ldiy he ppoi men .' rs
ls r
nk- A.
pp.

( D. 201 . hemor pli if ha nots fce l e tbls dt tt a nt ntof
E. Va. 4) FM r e, antfs ve ufiinty sa ihe ha he ppoi me
PFC ass tt t tu t a f td t i rg so d i ,ast y G tl hadt oblgai t make
ubsiu e r see fece her i ht r utes he i il
s
he i ton o

pa nt t rt ( oe. I ;s ealoLi aPr Hol ngs L. C.v.1
yme s mde he nl t ' d. e s voni op. di . L.
'
2840- 2976
1
Fami nRd.Hol ncs L. C.71 F.Supp. 7 735( D. ih. a 1 201 )
r ndo
di . L. , 7
2d 24, E. M c M y 3, 0

(s t ug t eçbjro rc ranyha a itr s i a odngf r cos r .. h v ldt o t e
E ho h h ç or we e til s n ne et n v ii o e l u e . t e aiiy f h
Al
g
a sg me td e no af c wh t e gJ( lro ro siso lg to , u o yt who ()
si n n o s t fe t eh r a b or we we t b iains b t nl o m a
El ro ri o lg td.) F n ly tec ur b le e t a t s bsiuea p it n d c me t
b o r we s bi ae '. i al ,h o t eiv s h the u ttt p on me t o u n
'
wa c e rt tGM AC M o t e wihedt a ntPFC t s l pl i if 'pr ry a f e os e.
s l a ha
rgag s
o ppoi
o e l antfs ope t t or cl ur
Pli tfsdo notaleget tGhedocl twa at r d afe delve' t PFC o t ti
a n if
l ha ç
t
lmen s le e tr i z o
y
r ha t
mir pr s n edt i e i ofet rpa t 'Beme t 201 W L 135 46,a * Ass h, he
se e e t he nt ntons ihe ry. r t, 2
'
45
t 7. uc t
c tc ncudest tpli if do no ha sa ng t c le t a nt e ofPFC a
our o l
ha antfs
t ve t ndi o ha lnge he ppoi m nt
s
s tt etusee
ubsiut r t .

i Vaii o h Ap i me to b tt t T u te
i l t ft e pont n fsu siu e r se
dy
Eve i t c tco d fnd t tpl i if ha sa i t c lngePFC' a n me
n f he our ul i ha antfs ve t ndng o hale
S ppoi t nt
a s tmt tu t e Fr ddi M aca guest tGM AC M orga vai y a n edPFC a
s ubsi e r s e , e e
r
ha
t ge ldl ppoit
s
s tt etu t .ç tu t ' powe t f r c os i c e r d by t dee oftus 'M o s 30
ubsiut r see ç r see s
A
r o o e l e s onf re
he d r t' ni on,

F. u p. da 4 3(iigFara Ct Re e eo me t& Ho s Au h v Rik e 7 7S. 2 8 6
S p 3 t 5 ctn ifx v. d v lp n
u . t . . e s , 0 E.d 2 ,
8 9( . 01 ). d e o tu th st p p o e , iha et Cos c r t eln e 2 Va 2 1) A e d f r s a wo u s s whc r o ç e u e h e d r
t
be i i r si e e ti t pa ce i co ysa t pr ec t bo r rfom ac elr ton oft
nefc a y' nt r s n he r l t nve nd o ot t he r owe r
c eai
he
de a f e l tr dnt s c li pr ryprort t f flm e toft c tonspr ce nt
bt nd or c osle he e trng ope t i o he ulil n
he ondii
e de

i i o e . M ahe v. M o ta eCo .7 4S. 2 1 6 20 ( 2 .ç s b t u etu te
t mp s s' t ws PHH rg c p , 2 E.d 9 , 0 201 ) K u si t r se
'
A
t
ma bea nt d unde a s pa a enotrz d doc ntbyr movaloft orgi tuseenn e
y
ppoi e
r e r t a ie
ume
e
he i nal r t
m d

i t d e o tu t'M o rs n, 0F. u p. da 45 s eas Va Co eAn j5 - 9 9 (-h
n he e d f r s. rio 3 S p 3 t 4; e lo . d n. 5 5 () çl e
'
lpa t s u e by t de d o t s . .s lha t r ghta pow e t a nta s tt t t s e
ry ec r d
he e f nz t . hal ve he i nd
r o ppoi
ubs iu e nlt e

o tuse f a r a on a r r es ofwhe he s h rg a powe i e e sy gr nt d i
r r t es or ny e s nd, ega dl s
t r uc i ht nd
r s xpr s l a e n
s h de d oftus, e cu i a a lnowl ng a i t m e desg tng a a n i a
uc e
r t by xe tng nd cc
edgi n nsnt nt i na i nd ppoi tng

s tt e.(.Oncea ntd,hes tt etuseei e we e byVa Codej55 59( t
ubsiut t
)
ppoi e t ubsiut r t s mpo r d
.
- 7) o

f e l ea s lt pr ry..'Bol iv. nk ofAm .N o.1 1 c 225,
or cos nd el he ope t ..
' our Ba
,
: 0- v2010W L 33851
77,

a * ( D. . . 4, 0 .
t 3 E. Va Aug 2 201 )
Thec t le st tpl n if 'co ant e n lbe al consnz d,doesnotc ai
our bei ve ha aitf s mpli , ve i r ly
t e
ont n

s fc e f c a alegai nst unde mi PFC' a nt nta s tt dt see Thedee of
ufii nt a m l l to o
r ne
S ppoi mr s ubsim nlt .
d
tus, ed J 9, 4,a nt d Br ndon Be wik ast orgi t se GM AC Bn t n
r t dat une 200 ppoi e a
s c
he i nal nzt e.
nk he
ta f e t no et GM AC M o t ge, c wase i ty al we unde t t nnsoft
r nsen'd he t o
rga whih
xplcil lo d
r he e
he

n t. eBooli 2 0W L 3 8 7 , t* (i ig u e ie tc l a g a efu i ten t
o e Se lt , 01
r
3 51 7 a 2 fndn , nd r d n ia ln u g o nd n h oe
h r ,h tçth e piitr o t Noea is h r i iaet tt yaege l
ee t a ç l e x lct e ms f he t t sue ee ndc t ha he r ey
g
ta se a l' OnAug s 1 , 0 , AC M o ta ea p itdPF a s b t tetute
r n f rbe).
u t 9 20 9 GM
rg g p on e C s u si z r se
tt
t o h a e c e a nt e o s tmt tuse docl e t twa r or d i t Cl r s
hr ug n xe ut d ppoi m nt f ubsi e r t e lm nt ha s ec de n he e k'
Ofk eofLouiaCot y. c t le st t a t hol roft no e,GM AC M o t ge
f
s
mt The our bei ve ha, s he de
he t
rga
wa t S ry s c e by t de d oftu t'a a horze t a ntPFC ass tmt tuse
s he d t e ur d he e
pa
r s' nd ut i d o ppoi
ubsi e r t e

f a ras npurua t Vigi alw.SeeLa a * ( ( h No ei p se s db g
or ny e o s nt o r ni a
d t 3 $Tq e t s o s se y t
;
he
.

d fnd nj a i t u t eGa t s c r db t ed e o tu t') s eas HinPh m v. n o
ee a t, nd s h s h p ry e u e y h e d f r s.' ; e lo e n Bn k f
'

N. , 5 F. u p. 8 4 81 ( D. . 2 (idn t tpanif h ven talg d
Y.8 6 S p 24 0 , 3 E. Va 201 ) fn ig ha litfs a o le e
s fc e f t t s t tt a nt e ofa s tt etuse wa fa ul ntwhe l he
ufi i nt acs o how ha he ppoi m nt
ubsiut r t e s r ud e
nç
t

rc r d s ls sn fcu l a i f rc ncu i t a a yoh re tt b sd s( d fnd nj
e od ico e o a t a b ss o o ldng h t n te n iy e ie t ee a t
he
posese t Not '.Thec t u t rfndst tt t mbi
s s s he e'
)
our f rhe i ha he ma guouslngua i t de doft s
a ge n he e nzt

ce rya t o ie GM AC M o ta et a p itas bsi et se . eCo . A !2
lal u h rz s
rg g o p on u tmt nlte Se mplEx.
4
(te r a isopto ma fom tmet tmermoveTr teanda ntas c s tuse t
ç nde, t t in, y r i o i e
use
ppoi uc esor r te o
a Tr seea nt d he e
ny u t ppoi e r unde ,'
r'who ts l s c d t a1 t tte, wera dute c e r
tha l uc ee o 1 he il po
nd is onf red

u nTn se heen a db Ap lc beLa ' . an,
po zte ri n y p ia l w.) Ag i GMAC Ba k wa t eo ii l e d r
'
n s h rgna ln e
unde t de d oft s,butt n i ta f re t not t GM AC M o t ge.
r he e
nzt
he t r ns er d he e o
rga Unde Vigi al w,
r r ni a

9

whe anot i ne taed, hedee oftas s cli t tdè ne e s rl nmswih i.Se
n
e s go it t
d llt e trng ha bt c s a iy
t t e

W ila v Gif r ,1 4S. 4 3 4 4( .1 2 ) s eas Si s nv Bih p 8 Va 1 0
lims . fo d 2 E. 0 , 0 Va 9 4 9 e lo tmp o . s o , 2 . 9 ,

1 8 W L 29 7, t* ( . u . ,1 8 )(t i u o b e l t z ta ata se o asc e d b
86
8 a 7 Va J l 1 8 6 çt s nd u tdy n e h t r n fr f e urd e t
1
c riswi i tes c rt wi u f r l s in n o d lv r ' .n s m,h c u t o cu e
are t t h e u i t t o ma a sg me t r eiey.) I u t e o r c n l d s
h
y ho
'
t tpli if ha nb s f e l al ge t tGM AC M orga di notha a hort t
ha a ntf s ve t ufki nty le d ha
t ge d
ve ut iy o
a ntPFC ass tt etuse unde Vigi al w o unde t t r soft de o t u t
ppoi
ubsiut r t e
r r ni a r
r he e m
he ed f r s.
N e rhels , antfsa guet tc ran de i incesast t e c i oft s tt e
ve t e s pli if r
ha e ti fce i
o he xe uton he ubsiut

t u t a nt e docl ntr nde s h docl nti i Spe ii aly, antfsc e t t
r see ppoi m nt tme e r uc
lme nvald. c fc l pli if ont nd ha
t sgnor J fr y St pha ad it d t the sg t a o f e l tr d ume samont
he i , e fe e n, m te ha
i ned hous nds f or cosle oc nt
h
wihoutr di t m andwihoutt not ypublc, kol Shet n, e e i t s m er .
t
ea ng he
t
he ar
i Ni e lo pr s nt n he n oom
A ss h,pl ntf sas e t ha t a
uc ai i f s r t t he ppoi m e ofPFC a s tt e t us e w asi ld,a t t
nt nt
s ubs im r t e
nva i nd ha

PFC di notha a hort t f e os on t Pr ry.Thec ti c tane t dia ee
d
ve ut iy o or cl e he ope t
our s onsr i d o s gr .
Unde Vigi al w,me epr ed a ir gul tesi t e c i ofmorga doc nt wil
r r ni a
r oc ur l r e mii n he xe uton
t ge ume s l

n tmd r n t lg l ldt o to ed c me t. . d An j5 -1 6. (W m iigta
o t e mie he e a vai i f h s o u n s Va Co e n. 5 0 2 $
y
tn h t
i n t r p rynoaie . s al o iv ld t t et el n d c me t'; ofv F d Na '
s o p o el trz d . h l n t n ai ae h md ryig o u n .) W l . e . tl
.
'
Mo t. sn, 3 F. u p. d 1 3 1 6( . Va 2 1, f 51 F. p' 3 6(t Ci.
rg As ' 8 0 S p 2 5 , 6 W D. . 01 ) afd 2 Ap x 3 4 h r
2 3 . wa as t ec s i W ofa Bemet plitfsalg t a S e h n sg e t esc n
01 )As s lo h a e n l nd r t an if le e h t tp a in d h e o d
pa oft s tt t t seea nt ntdocl ntwhe t frtpa wasnota tc t i.
ge he ubs iu e nlt ppoi me
tme
n he is ge
ta hed o t
Howe r t co ti bot c s sf
ve , he ur n h a e oundt tt ts tt et u t e a nt e wass ilvai
ha ha ubsiut r se ppoi m nt
tl ld
be a e t r i no r qui e e t tdocz e sbe s a ed t t rf pr rnot rza i Se
c us he e s
e r m nt ha
lm nt
t pl oge he or ope
a i ton. e

Be t,201 W L 135 46,a * (û t h W ol s sedt tt l l to ..ha t t
nne' 2
t
45 t 7 ç houg
Al
f ugge t ha he alegain .t t he wo
pa sofanotrze doc n weeno e cue i t s mepl ea t s tme ( yqcal
ge
ai d ume t r t xe t4 n he a
ac t he nme i , ma lg
ji oquesi whehe t doc nthadbe ne c e pes nal i fonto t notl 't si
nt
ton t r he ume
e xe utd ro ly n r f he ay hi s

no e o g t s r ieamo int d s s . ( u tn W of 8 0F. u p. d a 1 5 ) M o t
t n u h o u vv
to o imis' q oig l, 3 S p 2 t 6 ). s
'
i
mpora l pli if ha no pld s t intf cua alegai nst s
tnty, antfs ve t e ufk e a t l l to o how t tt s tt e
ha he ubsiut

tuse a nt e doc ntdi notac uz t l sa et i e to oft pa te .Se W ol,803
r t e ppqi m nt ume d
c a ey tt he ht n i ns he ris e
f

F. u p 2 a 1 6(-h d c me ta p itn PFC a s b tmt tu te r g r ls o wheh r
S p . d t 6 çf e o u n p on ig
l'
s u si e r se , e ade s f te
i p g sweea tc e wh ni wa e e u e , a t rdt itn o b t (h ln e ' a sg e j
t a e r ta h d e t s x c td c p u e he n e t f oh t e e d rs s in e
s
a dP t b b u d b i.) Th rf r ,h c u t id ta panif h v fie t alg
n FC o e o n y t'. ee o e te o r fn s h t lit s a e ald o le e
'
f
s fc e f c st s
ufii nt a t o how t tPFC' a nt nta s tt e tu t wasi ld.
ha
S ppoi me s ubsiut r see
nva i
I sl t c ti t tCo Im us f i be aus pli tf sdo notha sa ngt
n lm, he our tnds ha unt
t a l c e' a n if
ve tndi o
l

c le t vai t oft s tmt t se a nt nt a e ni t ydi ha sa i
halnge he ldiy he ubsi e nlte ppoi me , nd, ve f he d ve t/dng,
t c
he ompl i doe no c an s fcintf cua alegai t unde mi t a nt nt
ant s t ont i ufi e a t l l tons o
r ne he ppoi me .

Ac r ngl t c t l gr ntFr eM a sm o i t dimisa t Cot 1oft c
co di y, he our wil a
eddi c' ton o s s s o mt
he ompli .
ant
b. C ountI :B r ac ofC ont t
I e h
rac

I Count1 oft co ait pl i if a g t tFr ddi M a br a he a s pa ae
n
1 he mpl n , antfs r ue ha e e c e c d e r t

co r c wih pl ktfs s cii lyt rwrte a i a i f al n modii a i Fr ddi
nta t t ai if , pe fcal hei itn pplc ton or oa
fc ton. e e
M a co e t tt scli f isbe aus pli if ha nots fce l alege t tt r wa
c nt nds ha hi a m a l c e antfs ve
ufi inty l d ha he e s

a sgned a e m e bewe n t pa test ts r e asa l n m odii to
ny i
gr e nt t e he ri ha e v d
oa
fcai n.
Unde Vigi alw,apa t cli i br ac ofc r c m us e tbls t eee e nt t
r r ni a
ry am ng e h onta t t sa ih hr l me s o

p e al ç 1 alg lye f r e b eo lg t n o ad fn a tt aplitf, 2 t ed f n a ts
rv i:& ) e al n o c a l bi ai f ee d n o anif ( ) h e e d n '
(
o

vo ain o b e c o t a o iain a ()ij r o d ma et t ep an ifc us db t e
ilto r r a h f h t bl to , nd 3 n u y r a g o h litf a e y h
g
brac ofoblgain. St ieContnui Cae. v.W rM 671S. 2d 1 1 ( .2009)
e h
i to ' mrs
'
i ng r LLC
iht
E. 32, 35 Va
.
I a ton,a lc r c sr a e t t pm c e ofr a e t t- i l ng am orgagele mus
n ddii 1 onta t elt d o he
has
e l sa e nc udi
t
i nt

b i wrtn t s tsyt esa eo ga d . . d An j 1 - 6 . t esmet k n, n
e n iig o aif h tmt f u s Va Co e n. 12() By h a ô e a y
m odii a i ofa m o t ge a e m e i no e or ea e t l s i i i wr tng.Se Li a v.
fc ton
r ga gr e nt s t nf c bl m es t s n ii
e nds y

M c a n yAso s, 31S. 2d5 3 5 5 7 ( . 0 )(çW q e . ac nr c i r q ie t b
Ene r e s c .5 E. 7 , 7 - 6 Va 20 0 ç h n . o ta t s e urd o e
g
.
i wrtn pls n t ( r iijCo ej1 - , n mo i to t t a c nr c mu tas b i
n iig t ua t o Vigna d 12 a y dt in o h t o ta t s lo e n
r
ka
m iiga dsg e b t ep ryt b c r e o h sa e t'; e as M dn sv.
tn n in d y h a t o e hag d r i g n .) s e lo
'
ni BAC Ho
me
Lo nSe vcn LP, . : 1 6 , 01 W L 3 3 9 , t* n. ( t e tn Plitf i
a r ii m No 2 1 CV4 8 2 2
8 5 0 a 8 5 t he x e t anif s
To
aleg ng ave balc r c t pe ne l modiy herl n e ss s h ac r c woul beba w d
l i
r onta t o nna nty
f
oa xit , uc
onta t
d
r

i Vignab t sauio fa s' M o e ve,e esa et e n o lg to t p o i eo
n r i i y he tt t f rud .
). r o r lnd r r md r o b iain o r v d r
ac e al modii a i r ue tfo aborowe .Se Pa sv. C M org.N o. 1 c 1
c pt oan
fc ton eq s r m
r r e ni PN
t , 2: 4- v- 42,

2 4W L 3 3 5 , t* ( D. . uy7 2 4 (C h r i noc n rcu lo lg to fra
01
7 5 31 a 6 E. Va J l , 01 ) Er ee s o ta t a bi ain o
s r i e t ofe ahomeowneral n m odii ai howeve ,a t an i vi lc nnotfl
e vc r o fr
oa
fc ton,
r nd hus ndi dua a
ie
s ta i ta l nde f f iur t e t ri t t r vi w ,ort pr es a l n m odi i t on
ui ga ns e r or a l e o n e n o, o e e
o oc s oa
fca i

a ee nt- net rvi br a h ofc r c norvi br ac ofdu y ofgood f ih a f i
gr me
ihe a e c
onta t
a e h
t
at nd ar

d aig'
e ln ).
I t i t ntc s pl i if a l ge t tt y s it d a w rte a i a i f a l n
n he ns a a e, a ntf s le ha he ubm te
it n pplc ton or oa

m odii to a t tFr ddi M aca ove t sa i a i a ç e ilz t af r s i
fcai n, nd ha e e
ppr d hi pplc ton nd ç mora ied he o e ad
m

a p o l' mpl!51 P an if f rh rcam ta t el a mo iiainr s id dt e
p r va. Co . . litfs u te li h t h o n dfc to e cn e h
'
f ecos ea pr de f r t r to ofpl i if 'r or owne s p oft i hom e. n s
or l ur nd ovi d or eso ai n
antfs ec d
r hi
her
l uppo t
r
oft s al ga i ,pli if a tc d t t c
he e le tons a ntf s ta he o he ompl i aha
ant ndwrte l n mod scai n r que t
itn oa
i to e s;
howe r t y di noti udea wrte l n modii a i ag ee e toran wrte r s ns
ve , he d
ncl
ny itn oa
fc ton r m n
y itn e po e
fom Fr eM a a t t pli if 'l n m odi to r que t Thec t le st t i t
r
eddi c s o he antfs oa
fcai n e s .
our bei ve ha , n he
c pl i ' c r ntf r ,pl ntf shave f ie t e t bls t fr tel m e o t i b e c of
om a nts ur e o m ai i f
a l d o s a i h he s e nt f he r r a h

c n rc cam i .Gha avai a de f r e b ec nr c t mo iy gh ijla e se a
o ta t li . ,t t ld n n o c a l o ta t o d f t er o n xitd, nd
e t
t tt pa te m um a l ag e d t m od fc ton w a e f tve ' M c nni v. C H o e Loa
ha he ri s
ly r e he
iia i
s f ec i .' l s BA
m
n

S r iic LP, . : 1 6 , 01 W L 3 3 9 ,a * ( D. . a 1 , 01 ) E he al a
e vcn e No 2 1 CV4 8 2 2
8 5 0 t 6 E. Va J n. 3 2 2 .s n o n
W

m odii ai n i c e plt d,t borowe ofe st a i to t t lnde ,whi h t lnder
fc to s ontm a e he r r f r he pplcai n o he e r
c he e

c net e a c p o rj c atr@d tr n to o t b ro rsei iii 'M cn s 2 2W L
a ih r c e t r ee t fe , ee miain f he or we ' lgblt ' lni, 01
y.
3 3 9 a * (mp ssi o ii l. we r a t eh aig panif ake t ec u t o la e
8 5 0, t 7 e hai n rgna) Ho ve, t h e rn , litfs s d h o r f r e v
t n e t ic
o m nd her ompl i a trt y ha ha a opport t t e gei lm ie dic r i
ant fe he ve d n
tmiy o nga n i t d s ove y n
o dert obt n aco oft l n modii a i a e men fom Fr ddi M a Ase ai d mor
r o ai
py he oa
fc ton gr e t r
e e c. xpl ne
e
f ly be o t c t i ve t tpli if s ul bealowe s h opport iy. c di y,
u l l w, he our bele s ha a ntfs ho d
l d uc
t t Ac or ngl
m
Fr ddi M a smoton t dim iswilbede e ast Co 1.
e e c'
i o s s l
nid o unt 1
c C ount1 1 W rona ulEvi ton
.
1:
f
ci

l Count11 pli if a s r t tFr ddi M ac si ope f r l ur c us d t t be
n
1, antfs s e t ha e e
' mpr r o ec os e a e hem o
wr uly e c e fom t i ho e. e e M aca gu t tt r i no vald ca eofa ton f
ongf l vit d r her m Fr ddi
r es ha he e s
i us
c i or
wr ule ci i Vigilaa e n i s h ca eofa ton e se i i ba r d by t sa ut
ongf viton n r ri nd, ve f uc us
c i xit d, t s re
he tt e
oflm ia i .
i t tons

Pl ntfsha noti entfe a t c ti no a r of a a hort t tr cognies
ai if ve
d ii d, nd he our s t wa e , ny ut iy ha e
z
a c us ofaci n f rwr u e c i outi o t l ndl d-e n co e .Se M a a v.
a e
to o ongf l viton sde f he a or t na t nt xt e r bda

Ala e e& Aso s, .1 3 4 ,1 9 W L 1 6 6 2 a * ( . r CtDe . ,1 9 )
bn s
s c .No 4 2 3 9 6
0 5 5 , t 6 Va Ci. . c 6 9 6

( eemi n tesau eo l tto sf rwr n f l vito ç to td cdn ta Vign a1w
d tr nig h ttt f i ai n o o g' e cin d h u e i ig h t r ii a
mi
u
wi
r c g ie at r o wr n f l vcin). o e v r i s c c u eo a to e it i Vigna t
e o nz s o t f o g u e ito ' M ro e ,f u h a s f cin x ss n r i i,he
c tbei ve t tt saut oflm iai nswoul bet yea s a no o he sa ut oflm iai ns
our le s ha he t t e i t to
d wo r , s
t r tt e i tto
i pr c i d i t Vigi aCode. d.
s es rbe n he r ni
I
H e e t c pl i te t bls s t ta c us ofa ton f wr f e c i n a c e no
r , he om a n s a i he ha ny a e
c i or ong ul vi to c nz d
l t rt n M a c of201 w he Fr ddi M a l cke pl ntf soutoft i ho e. a e
a e ha
rh
3
n e e c o d ai i f
he r m Bec us

pl i if fld t i co pl nto J y 1 201 t c t i t tt scai i tm e ba r d.
antfs ie her m ai n ul 3, 5, he our fnds ha hi l m s i - re
Eve i t c tc d fnd t tt c a m w astm e y, he co pl nti de d ofa f c t l
n f he our oul i ha he l i
i l t
m ai s voi
ny a tz
a

alegai nst tFr ddi M a ace wr u l by e ci t pl i if .
l to ha e e c t d ongf ly
vi tng he antfs Agai t c t
n, he our
be ivest tpl i if ha n;ts fce l de onsr t d t tt s tm t t u t e a nt e
le ha antfs ve
ufi inty m ta e ha he ubsi e r se ppoi m nt
wa i i ort tFr ddi M a l c d a t iyt f e os ont i home. r f r , hec t
s nvald, ha e e c a ke u hort o or cl e he r
The e o e t our
wildimi st scli asuntm ey a f f iur t sat acai upon wli hr le m a be
l s s hi a m
i l nd or al e o t e l m
lc ei f y
di y r d i cs t s r ne t epe t o u t 1.
ga t d. A ccor ngl , F e deMa 'moini ga tdwiirs c t Co n 11
rne 2
o
l
A
'

d. C ountI :Bre h ofI pled C o nant o G ood Fa t a Fai D e i
V
ac
m i
ve
f
i h nd
r alna

I CountI pl i if cai t tt no ea de d oft s conti d a i i
n
V, antfs l m ha he t nd e
nzt a ne n mpled

c na tofgood f t a f i deai a t tFr eM a br a hedt i id co na
ove n
aih nd ar lng, nd ha eddi c e c he mple ve ntby

frco igo terh me l rs ns, e deMa cne d tâ ismpye rie isrg t
oe lsn n h i o .n epo e Frd i c o tn s h tt i l xecsd t ihs
unde t not a de o t s,a t ts h e r iei nota tona ea abr c ofan
r he e nd ed f nzt nd ha uc xe c s s
ci bl s ea h
i i c na .
mpled ove nt
TheFourh Cic tha he dt tc ta t go nz d by Vigi al w do c ai a
t r ui s l ha on r c s ve e
r ni a
ont n n
i i d c na ofgood f ih a f i de lng. eW ol,51 F.
mple ove nt
at nd ar a i Se
f 2 App' a 345; Ve miult .
x t
Va. r c ie

Lt V. . Gr c & Co,1 6F.d5 5 5 - 2( t Ci,1 2 )Ho v r ç oi idd t
d. W R. a e
. 5 3 3 , 414 4h r 9 8 . we e ,s mple uy
n
a ieswih r s c t a tviy gove nedby e e sc ta t lt r s' Skilt r I v. e
rs
t e pe t o c i t
r
xpr s on r c ua e m . lso ms nc. El c.
'

DaaS s.
t v .LLC, 6 F.u pz 61 , 2 ( D. .0 9 (iigW ad'Eq i .n . Ne
6 6 s p .d 0 6 0 E. Va2 0 ) ctn r s up.l c v. w

HolndN. , 9 SE.d51 ,5 0( .1 9 ). us tec v n n o g o fiha df i
l
a
Am.4 3 . 2 6 2 Va 9 7 ) Th ,h o e a t f o d at n ar
de lng doesnotpr cude apa t fo e r ii vald co r c ua rg s ( l ng a t tpa t
ai
el
ry r m xe csng i nta t l i ht , ç o s ha ry
as
doe note r iet e rght i ba f ih.' ol,51 F. p' a 345.
s
xe c s hos i s n d at 'W f 2 Ap x t
I t i t ntca e pl ntf s a l atons i s
n he ns a
s , ai i f ' leg i n uppor Uft i cl i f br c oft
t he r a m or ea h he
i pled co na ofgood f ih a f i de lng r l s e y on t a l ga i t de l ng t r
m i
ve nt
a t nd a r a i e y ol l
he le tons m ryi hei

b e c ofc tac c am s Be a e apa t do no br ac t i ple dut o good f t a
rah
on r t l i . c us
ry es t e h he m i d y f
aih nd
2
h x e ha ai if e k om
ain or her os opet
es t he cto he ur
Tot ee tntt tpl ntfss e c pens to f t i l tpr ryasar ul oft evi in,t co t
fndst ts cli i d tr eva 'aspli if <s d f wr ule ci no f eihe c r i or
i ha uch am s s el nt' antfs çue or ongf viton t or t r onve son
no
ne i nce'M a a
glge . r bda,1 W L 1
'
996
06565 a * n.
2, t 6 8.

f i de lngwhe i e r s se es rg sunde aco r c ,a sncet c
ar a i
n t xe cie xpr s iht
r nta t nd i he ompli i ude no
ant ncl s
a lga i t tplusbl s es t tGM AC M orga sorFr e M ac' c r m al
le tons ha a i y ugg t ha
t ge'
eddi
s ontac

ds rto C se e cs di ba fih ds o ety, rt a Eh ywee te tdu fil, t c u t
icein t x r ie n d at , ih n sl o h t t e rq r ae n ary' he o r
wa
'
mu tds s t i cam.d.s eas M o i o , 0F. u p. da 4 6(sic tealg to s
s imis hs li I ; e lo n s n 3 S p 3 t 5 s n e h le ai n
t
t ryi pli ifsgood f t a f rde i cli pe ti t d e ntse r s ofis
mde l ng antf
aih nd ai alng am ran o ef nda ' xe cie t
e es c r t alrg t f ecos f ponpa e oft l n a do no aleget t
xpr s ontac u i ht o or l e or
ym nt he oa nd
t l ha
De e ntpr ee d wih isc r cua rghtt f e os i ba f t pl i ifhasnotsaed a
f nda
oc de t t onta t l i o or cl e n d aih, antf
tt

cam f br c oft i i c na ofgoodfiha fi de lng. Vaz anav.
li or ea h he mpled ove nt
at nd ar ai '
); z

Cii o ta e I c, 7:2 0 7 2 3W L 2 2 0 2 a * ( . Va Jme4 2 3
tM rg g . n .No. 1 CV0 49 , 01
4 3 9 , t 4 W D. . t , 01 )
( imisn b e c o i idc v n n cam wh r t ep an ifteiso t es mealg to s
ds sig ra h f mple o e a t li ee h litf G le n h n le ain
r
unde l nghe cai sf br c ofc r c i t pr vi c st s
ryi
r l m or ea h onta t n he e ous ount o uppor he c am f r
t r li o
br a h oft i i d c na tofgood f ih a f i de i ' a t compl i i l sno
ec
he mple ove n
at nd ar alng,' nd he
ant nc ude

algai t tt lnde e rie isc r t dicei i ba fih) M o e r t t
le tons ha he e r xecsd t ontacual srton n d at . r ove ,o he
e e tt tpl i if r y on Bour l i v.J or n Chas Ba N . i t i opposton t t
xt n ha antfs el
de as pM ga
e nk. A. n her
ii o he
m oto t di m i s t c tfndst ts h r i nc i m i pl c I t tc e, he bor ow e
i n o s s , he our i ha uc ela e s s a ed. n ha as t
r r

cai t ts wasi e t de a ta s eque l b e c d he oblgai unde t not
l med ha he
nduc d o f ul nd ubs nty r a he r i ton
r he e
a de d oftus a trt l nde t d he t ts ha t de a ti or rt be ei i ef al n
nd e
r t fe he e r ol r ha he d o f ul n de o
lg bl or oa
m odi ai Bour l sv.J or n Cha eBn N . , 3: 0CV670,201 W L 5 408 a
sc ton.
deai pM ga
s nk. A.No. 1
2
40 4, t

* 5( D. . v. , 01 ) TheCo r f u dt ts c cam wa s t in t wi tn a
4- E. Va No 5 2 2 .
u t o n ha u h li s uf e t o t a d
k
hs
m oton t di m i s be aus t pl i ifs
i o s s c e he a ntf howe t tt l nde a t d unr s bl a i ba
d ha he e r c e
ea ona y nd n d

f t I a *5.I t sc e pli if aleg y s htal n modii a i afe t y ha
aih. d. t
n hi as , a ntfs l edl oug
oa
fc ton tr he d
def ule on t i no e a a trFr ddi M acha f e os d on t pr pe t The e a eno
a t d he r t nd fe e e
d or cl e
he o ry. r r
ale to t tFr ddi M a i uc d pl i if t de a torot wie a t d i ba f ih.Fi ly,
lgai ns ha e e c nd e antfs o f ul
her s c e n d at nal

S ete t en t no t ed e o tu tce t lqad t o t ep r o Fr d i M a )t f cltt a
d ih r h oe r h e d f r s raed u y n h a t f e de c o a ii e
n
a
l m odii ai n.'
oan
fc to 'Cook v.Cii nanca .I .N o.3: 4CV00007, 4 W L 20 070,a *
tFi il nc,
1
201
40
t 6

( . Va M a 1 , 4 . e eo e tec u t o ld st tpanif h v fie t pa i y
W D. . y 6 201 ) Th r fr ,h o r c ncu e ha litfs a e ald o lusbl
e tbls t tFr eM acbr ac d t i id co na o g f t a f i de lng.
sa ih ha eddi
e he he mple ve nt f ood aih nd ar a i
Ac or ng y,Fr eM ac sm o i t dim isi g a e a t Co mt1
c di l eddi
' ton o s s s r ntd s o t V.
11
1.

Pl i if 'R e s f Lea 'o Am e
a ntf s que t or
ve t
nd

It io
n he r pposton br e ,pl ntf ss m a y r que tl ve t n e t com pl i i t
ii
i f ai i f um dl e s ea o m nd he
a nt n he

e ntt tt c ur gr nt t m o i t dim is Att he dng ont m oto t dimi s
ve ha he o t a s he ton o s s . he a
he i n o s s ,
pl n if 'c
aitf s ouns las a ke t c t ora to ltmet c
e lo s d he our f ddii na i o onduc dic r a t t
t s ove y s o he
e se eofawrte l n m odii to docl nti s
xit nc
itn oa
fcai n tme n uppor ofCot I . e eM a oppos
t
mt 1 Fr ddi
c
es

plitfs rq e tf rla et a n , ruigta s hrq e t sf tl a dp eu iil
anif ' e u s o e v o me d a g n h t uc e u s i ' i n rj dca.
u é
UnderRul 1 oft Fe r lRul ofCi lPr ed e,apa t m a a e ispl di
e 5 he de a
es
vi oc ur
ry y m nd t ea ng
t e a am a trofc s 'Wihi ace t n tm efn ea t r a tr wiht ço
t
onc s
te
our e' t n
rai i r m nd,he e fe , t he çpposng
i

p ry' m itnc nsn o t ec u tsla e'Fe R. v P. 5a . ec u tçh udfe l gve
a t s te o e t r h o r' e v . d. Ci . 1 () Th o r < o l r ey i
'
s
la ewh nj tc s r q rs'Fe R. v. 1 ()2 , n Se v t n n s ul b d r e
e v e usie o e uie , d. Ci P. 5a () a d d a e o me d ho d e el d
'
l
i

o l wh nt a nd n wo l b p eudca t t eo p sn p ry t eeh sb e ba fih
ny e he me me t u d e rj iil o h p o ig a t,h r a e n d at
on t pa toft m ovi pa t ora e
he r he
ng ry, m ndme woul bef tl 'M ati Ca t lM gmt Fund.
nt
d
u ie.
' rx pia
.
LP

v Be rng i I c, 7 F.d 1 2 1 3( t Ci. 0 )
. ai pont n .5 6 3 7 , 9 4h r 20 9 .
l t sca e, n r vi o t r co d, hec tc l st tt r ue tmus be
n hi s upo e ew f he e r t our onc ude ha he eq s
t

alwe . eei n ba i f rtec u tob l veta a a n me two l b p eu iil r h t
lo d Th r s o ss o h o r t ei h t n me d n ud e rj d ca o t a
e
t r i a ba f ih on t pa to t pl i if . n addii ' i pl ntfsa e t i co pli
he e s ny d at
he r f he antfs I
ton, f ai if m nd her m a nt
t i udeaddii na aleg tonsast t e se e ofawrte l nm odik a i ag ee e ,
o ncl
to l l a i
o he xit nc
it n oa
t ton r m nt

to ea n me t wo l l eye a l t i cam t wi tn r ve u d rRue 1 b ( )
h s me d n s u d i l n b e her li o t a d e iw n e l 2()6 .
k
hs

The e or t co tbei vest ts h n e e t wo d notbef tl .Fort s r s ns t
r f e, he ur le ha uc m ndm n s ul
u ie
he e ea o , he
c tw ilgr ntt pl i if 'm o i f l a t a e Coun 1 oft c pl i a w il
our l a he a ntf s ton or e ve o m nd
t 1 he om a nt nd l

al w pl ntfst e ge i lmie dico r a t t exit nc ofal n modii to
lo ai if o nga n i t d s ve y s o he se e
oa
fcai n
a e m e wih Fr eM ac
gr e nt t eddi
.
Concl on
usi

Fort f egoi r s ns Fr ddi M a sm oto t dimi swilbegr nt d ast Cou s
he or ng ea o , e e c'
in o s s l
a e
o
nt
1 11 a I a wilbe de ed a t Count1 t al w pl i if a o
, 1, nd V nd l
ni s o
1 o lo antfs n pporuniyt e gei
t t o nga n
lmie dicove y ast t e se eofa l n m odii ai n c ta twih Fr eM a Pl i if '
i td s r
o he xit nc
oa
fc to on r c t eddi c. antfs
r ue tf l vet fl a n e d co a n wilbegr nt d.
eq s or ea o ie n m nde mpli t l
a e
TheClr i die t d t s ndcopisoft sm e a um opi o a t a o pa ng
ek s rce o e
e
hi mor nd
ni n nd he cc m nyi
o de t a 1c
r r o 1 ouns lofr c d.
e
e or

DATED : ls iq A d yo Mac , 01
Tl
i
a f rh 2 6.
Chi Unied Stt DititJ
e
t
a es src udge