D. N. et al v. Louisa County Public Schools et al

Filing 25

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/13/16. (hnw)

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI CT COURTW R A FCEUS DITCOUR
STRJ
KSOF I
yq
olN6xiv . T
,S
A
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRJ OF VI
CT
RGW I
A
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON
.

D. . by a t o hi ne f inds
N,
nd hr ugh s xt re
CHRI
STW A NOLEN a
nd
ROBERT NOLEN,e a ,
tl

FL D
IE

J l3 2 1
AN
26
a
u
B
K

. DL
D

L
ERK

U h Ct f
.
ERî

Pli if ,
antfs
Ci lAci N o.3: 5- 000
vi ton
1 CV- 45
M EM O M N DU M O PI I N
N O

LOUI COUNTY PUBLI SCHOOLS,
SA
C
e a.
t l,
D e e nt .
f nda s

By:H on.G l n E.Co 'd
e
ma
Chi Unie Stt DititJ
ef t d a es src udge

PlitfsChitn Noe a dRo et ln(h $ ln',n i d al a da n x
anif rsia ln n b rNoe te ( e s' ibviu ly n s e t
No )
findsf t rmi c l e D. .a N . .brngt sa ton agans def nda sLoui a
re
or hei nor hidr n, N nd N , i hi c i
i t e nt
s

Comt Pu lcSc o l (C ? a dLo iaCo n ySc o Bo r (ç
t y bi h o s C
LCPS' n us u t ho l ad $
)
LCSB' . anif a pe l
' Plitfs p a
)
t ou c eoft rduepr e shea i und t I vi l wih Diabiii sEduc ton Ac
he t om
hei
oc s
rng er he ndi dua s t s lte
ai
t

((
$DEA' , U. C. j 1 0 , ts c, swel sa s r camsu d rS cin 5 4o t
I
' 20 S. j 4 0 e el a l a se t li n e e to 0 f he
)
.

Re bl ainAc o 1 73(s cin 5 41, 9U. C. 79 Th c s i prs nl beo et
ha ii to t f 9 C e to 0 ' 2 S. j 4. e a e s e e ty f r he
t
ç
)
c u t nd fn a t'mo int ds s 't s a t oRue 1 b ( )a 1 b ()o t eFe e a
o r o ee d n s to o imisp l u n t ls 2()1 nd 2()6 f h d r l
r
Rul so Ci lPr edtr Fort f l ng r as ,t motonwilbeg a ed i pm'a
e f vi oc le.
he olowi e ons he i
l
r nt n t nd
de e i par.
ni d n t
B ac ound
kzr

Thef l ng f ct, ale fom pl i if c
olowi a s t c n r
antfs' ompl i ,a eac e e astuef pu pos of
ant r c pt d r or r es

temoi nt d s s .Se Erc s nv Pad s 5 U. 8 , 4( 0 7 .
h to l imis e ik o . r u , 51 S. 9 9 2 0 )
)
D . . nd N . .a e m i c l e w ho r i i Loui a Vi gila w ih t i pa e s t
N a
N r nor hidr n
es de n
s , r ri t he r r nt , he

Nolns D. . bee as
e . N has n mden wihi t LCPS s t m,whih i o r e n by LCSB,snce
t t n he
yse
c s ve s e
i

2009. i t 201 201 s hoolye r D. . ndN . . te d M os - kol El me a y
Durng he 3- 4 c
a, N a
N a tnde
sNuc s e nt r
.

S ho l $ NES', ihi o e ae b LCPS
c o (M
(
' wh c s p rtd y
)
.
D . . sdignos d asa itca wa ei bl f ,a r ceved,s i e to a
N wa a
e
utsi nd s lgi e or nd e i
pecal ducai n nd
r lt d s r i e a ac l wih a im .Dtrngt 201 201 s hoolye r i wa dee mi d t t
ea e e v c s s hid t uts
li he 3- 4 c
a , t s t r ne ha

D. ' tle s Ejsrcie(q vr n n 'wa t g n r l d c to ca so m. mp . 1 .
N. t q at re tit en io me t s he e e a e u ai n lsr o Co l! 9
Sl
v
'
Howe r LCPS s ntD . home S tlas 1 tm e be a eofnon- s plna y is sc us d by
ve ,
e
N.
G e t 0 i s c us
a
dici i r s ue a e

hi (q ts '1 !20 I a dto , l igt smesh o ye r LCPSrg lryrpo e D.
s auim. d. .n d i n dz n he n c o l a,
'
i
r
e u al e v d N,
f o t g ne a 8 a i n cas r a s nthi t t prncpalsofi e f rnon- s i i r
r m he e r l duc to l s oom nd e m o he i i ' fc o
dicplna y
is ca edbyhi a im .W hiei t prncpalso fc D . . e ei d no e a i l
s ues us
s uts
l n he i i ' fi e, N r c ve
duc tona

isnlto , u i se dS d s o lke a dpa e o t e(jicpa' c mp tr'I !2 .
n t cin b t n ta ç e n wfa s n ly d n h p rn i ls o u e . d. 3
ma
'
Fi ly, i t s m es hoolyea ,LCPS r gul l pr ve e D. . r m a tndi cas i t
nal durng he n
c
r
e ary e nt d N f o te ng l s n he
ge r e a i n cl s oom a ke hi i t s c a e ai n r
ne al duc to as r
nd pt m n he pe i l duc to oom f non- s i i r
or
dic plna y
is ca e byhi a im .
s ues us d
s uts LCPS de edt ealegai nsi s e nti vi lz
ni hes l to n ubs que ndi dua ied

e u ainp o rm ($ 'me tn swi M s No e , e es eas e p e s dc n ensa u
d c to r g n &EP' eig t . ln wh r h lo x rs e o c r bo t
1 )
h
t n mto cls r m i tuci n t tD . .wasm isng.
he mot f a s oo nsr to ha N
si

Th c mpan f rhe sae ta D. ' is sa s h o % olwe hm h me'1 . 3
e o lit u t r tts h t N. sue t c o lû l d i o . d ! 0.
S
f o
'
Specfc ly,D. .
ii a l N woul ofe I toutunc ntola y,' a i sr sa a e y f N . a
d tn t
ac
o r lbl 'c usng tes nd nxit or N. nd
t Nolns Bec us ofD . .t f m iy wasuna et atnd c c vi i fi
he e . a e
N , he a l
bl o te hur h, st rendsand f miy,or
n l

tkeD. t a yp bl plc s Th s is e as c u e M sNoe t q ihe j b.
a N.o n u i a e . e e su s lo a s d . ln o ut r o
c
l Dec mbe of201 D. . shos tlz be aus ofhi a im .l J nua y of201
n
e r
3, N wa
pia ied c e
s uts n a r
4,
M s N ol n as def nda st pl e D . . n a prva e s hool ha c d ha e hi non. e ked e nt o ac N i
i t c
t t oul ndl s

dicplna y is sc us d by hi a im .LCPS de e t sr que t I Aprlof201 LCPS l t
s i i r s ue a e
s uts
nid hi e s . n
i
4,
os
ta k ofD . durng t s hoold M s N oln a i r quese t tLCPS pl eD. .n a
rc
N. i he c
ay. . e gan e t d ha
ac N i

2

prva es hool LCPS de e he s ond r ques.On M a 5,201 D. .e t d t s hoo
i t c .
nid r ec
e t
y
4, N xie he c l
buidi on hi own,b wa lt rca htby a LCPS sa fm e
l ng
s
ut s a e ug
n
tf mber Tha s me da LCPS cal d
. ta
y,
le
t polcea s
he i nd oughtt ha D . .i unt rl c
o ve N nvol a iy omm itd f amen alhe t exn nai n
te or
t alh mi to
be us ofnon- s i i r is c us d by hi a im . N . f cbl r m ove fom t
ca e
di' plna y s ues a e
c
s uts D. was or i y e
d r he
s hooli ha ufsby t s rY sde is Be us t ha ufswe et lr e onD . .t
c
n ndc f
wo he i
pute . ca e he ndc f r oo a g
N , he

de isputD. .i l s kl a pl ce hi i t ba ks a oft po i c . . sa t t
pute
N n eg hac es nd a d m n he c e t he lce ar D N. t red o
ba hi hea ont c rsdoora c
ng s d he a '
nd age, c pr m p edt de i t r movehi fom t
whih o t he putes o e
m r he
ve ce. hN . . nd M r Noln wine s dt e tr i i nt De ist nta pore D.
hi l Bot N a
. e t s e he n ie nc de . pute he r ns t d N.

t t hos t ,whe ehe wa e l t d a r l s d wih no ne di gnos so m e c tons
o he pial
r
s vaua e nd eea e t
w a
e r di a i .
The c
ompl i al ge t t a trwines i t M a 5,201 i de , . t ufe e
ant le s ha , fe t sng he y
4 nci nt N N. ç f r d
s

fo e te a x ey (n qwa ari t ak ata h rf ra ti frfa t a t ywo l c l
r m x rme n it a d s fad o s e c e o nyhng o e r h the u d al
t poiea dtk hm a y. I !4 . na dto , N ' g a e d o p d a dh sa td
he l n a e i wa ' d. 3 I d iin N. s rd s r p e , n e tre
c
'
s f rng s i le be or a dtrngt s hoolda be a e ofhi a xit The c
ufe i eétr s f e nd li he c
y c us
s n e y.
ompl i al ge
ant le s
t tM r N o e a s s f r C xte esr s and a et ' fe wine snpt M a 5 201
ha . l n l o ufe ed t r m te s
e
nxi y'a tr t s i he y , 4

icd n .d. 81
n ie tI ! .
D. . d notr t nt M NES afe t M a 5,201 i de .I t a LCPS pr de
N di
e ur o
tr he y
4 nci nt nse d,
ovi d

D: . t s ci e ton a s r i sa hi hom ef t r toft 2013- 4 s hoolye r
N wih pe al ducai nd e vce t s
or he es he
201 e
a.
LCPS as pr ded D. . t co pe a or e a i ove t s
lo ovi
N wih m ns t y duc ton r he umm e of201 I M a of
r
4. n y
201 LCPS a e t pl eD. .i aprva es hoolt ts i i d i t a ng c l e wih
4,
gr ed o ac N n i t c
ha pecalze n e chi hidr n t
a im .Dtrngt 201 201 s hoolye r D . ' no di cplna y is sc s d,a hewa no
uts
li he 4- 5 c
a , N.S n- s i i r s ue ea e nd
s
l re l
onge xcuded fo t ge r e
r m he ne al ducai n cas r . c
to l soom The ompli talege t t be a eD. .
a n l s ha , c us N
w a no l
s onge e re i i s s a s hool hi f m iy w a onc a i a e t a t nd c c
r xpe i nc ng s ue t c
, s a l s e ga n bl o te hur h,

vi i f m iy a finds a g outi publc.
st a l nd re , nd o
n
i

On M a 4, 5,heN olnsfld a s ile ato d pr es r ques unde Se to
y 201 t
e ie peca duc i n ue oc s e t
r ci n

5 4 s e i mo ea yd ma e frb t tera D. ' no I
0 , e kng n tr n g s o oh h i nd N.S n-DEA iju e .nt i r q e tt e
n ti s I her e u s,h
N olnsdi nots e r m e esunde t I
e
d
e k e di
r he DEA be a e LCPS ha pr vi d D. wih
c us
d o de N. t
c
ompe aor e a i a a e d t plcehi i aprvae s hoolf c l e wih a ts ;
ns t y duc ton nd gr e o a
m n i t c
or hidr n t u im

te eo e tes e il d ainis e wihLCPSh db e r s l d LCPS o j ce t t e
h r fr ,h p ca e uc to su s t
a e n e ove .
b e td o h
Noln' duepr es r ue t a g ngt tt He ng Ofi e co d nota r mone a y
e s
oc s eq s, r ui ha he mi
fc r ul
wa d
tr

d ma e . M a 28 201 ,h He n Ofie s sane LCPS' o j cina d ds s e t e
a g s On y , 5 t e mi g fc r u ti d
S b e to n imis d h
N oln' duepr es r ue t
e s
oc s eq s.

On Augus 25,201 pl ntfsi ta e t saci n asbot a a
t
5, ai if nii t d hi to
h n ppea o t He rng
l f he a i
Oo c r sde son a af - ot compl ntunde Se to 50 Ast t a a oft He rng
e ' cii nd ourc mt
ai
r ci n 4. o he ppe l he a i
Ofi e ' de son,pl i if a guet tt He rng Ofi e e r a am a troflw i d s isng
fc r s cii
antfs r ha he a i
fc r red s
te
a n im s i
t Nol n' duepr e sr ques. antfsa k t c t o r m a t rc eba k t t He rng
he e s
oc s e t Pl i if s he our t e nd hei as c o he a i
Ofi e ,s t t Hea i Ofi e m a d t l de l t evi nta y r or 'whi h i tm l
fc r o hat he rng fc r y s l y ve op he de ir ec d,' c n t
fl

wo dG r moej iilefce c 'I . 58 Ast t eS cin 5 4cams Comt o te
ul t o t udca fiin y. d ! , o h e to 0 li , t I f h
p
'
c
ompli ta l est tdef nda sdic i naed a i tD . ba e s el on li dia lt I
a n leg ha e nt s rmi t gans N. s d ol y ls s biiy. n
CountI,pl i if ca m t tde e nt c us N . . xte n e y whe t y dic i i t d
I antfs li ha f nda s a ed N e r me nxit
n he s rm na e

a an tD. I Co n 11plitfscam t a d fn a t c u e M s No e t q th r o a d
g is N.n u t 1, an if li h t ee d n s a s d . ln o ui.e j b n

sfe e te srs a/ atit wh nte dsrmiae a ansD. I Comt1 panif
u fr xrme tes r r ey e h y ici n td g i t N.n t V, litfs
x
c am t tde e nt ca e M r N o e e r me sr s a a e y whe t y dic i i t d
l i ha f nda s us d . l n xte te s nd nxit
n he s rm na e

a ns D. . aitf ss e da
gai t N Pl n if e k mage i t a mtof$ 000. a we laseq tbl r le .
s n he mot
445, 00 s l
uia e e if

On Se e r 1 201 de e n sm ove t dimist c
pt mbe 8, 5, f nda t
d ù s s he ompl i pur uan t Rul j
ant s t o e

1 ( )1 'n 1 ( )6 o t F d rlRulsf yCii Pr c d r . ec u t edah mi go te
2 b ( )a d 2 b ( ) f he e ea e o v l o e u e Th o r h l e n n h
moton on De e r11 201 Them oto ha be n f ly bref d a i rpef diposto
i
c mbe , 5.
i n s e u l i e nd s i or s ii n.

4

St
andards ofR e e
vi w

Ru e1 ( )1 o t eFe e a Rulso Cii P o e u ep r t apa t t mo ef r
l 2 b ( ) f h d rl e f vl r c d r emis ry o v o

d s sa o a a to f rlc o s be t te j rs ito Th p an ifb ast b r e o
imis l f n cin o a k f u j c matr u id cin. e litf e r he u d n f
p o i t a s be t te ju s ito e it, n v. F. r i Co.1 6F.d6 2 6 7(t
r vng h t u j c matr ti dci n x ss Eva s B. Pekns , 6 3 4 , 4 4 h
Ci.1 9 ) a dmu t sa ls sa i gt b i t camsa s re i t c mplitb f r t
r 9 9 , n s e tbih tndn o rng he li se td n he o an eo e he

c u t yd cd teme iso s c cams Ale v. rc t4 8U. 7 7 7 0( 9 4 .
o r ma e ie h rt f u h li , ln W i h, 6 S. 3 , 5 1 8 )
Ru e1 ( )6 o t eFe e a Rulso Cii P o e u ep r t apat t mo ef r
l 2 b ( ) f h d rl e f vl r c d r emis ry o v o
dimi s lofa a ton f f iur t sa eacli upon whih r le ca be gr nt d.To s vi
s sa
n c i or al e o t t
am
c e if n
a e
ur ve
s h am o i n,apli tf m us e tbls ç aca plusbiiy'by pladi Sf c ua c t ntt t
uc
to
a n if t sa ih ç il a i lt '
f
e ng ça t l on e ha
a l t c t o dr w t r a ona ei e e et tt de e nti la ef t mic
lows he our t a he e s bl nf r nc ha he f nda s ibl or he s onduc
t

alg d'As r f v.q a, 5 U. 6 2 6 8( 0 9 . 1 l- e d dalg to i t e
l e . hco t I b l 5 6 S. 6 , 7 2 0 ) A1welpla e l ains n h
e '
e
c pli a et ke a tueand alr a ona e f c ua i e e sa edr wn i t pli itsf vor
om a nt r a n s r
l e s bl a t l nf r nce r a n he antf' a .

Ed r sv Ciyo God bo o 1 8F.d2 , 4 ( t Ci.1 9 ) Ho v r (at to a
wa d . t f ls r , 7 3 31 2 4 4h r 9 9 . we e ,ç j bo tm,
l
p an ifmu tçu g g r camsa r s t l fo c n ev bl t plusbl' or ss
litf s n d e he) li co s he i rm o c ia e o a i e t eit
ne

d s sa. W a M oeDo s LLC v Co a t6 0F.d3 9 3 4 6 ( t Ci. 01 )( u t Bel
imis l' g r g m
'
. z r, 8 3 5 , 6 - 5 4h r 2 2 q oi l
ng
At. p . Two l 5 0U. 5 4, 7 ( 0 7 M o e v r t ec mp an mu tc nan
l Co v. mbv, 5 S. 4 5 0 2 0 :. ro e ,h o lit s o ti
s fc e f t d or iearghtt r le a
ufi i nt acs i a s i o ei f bovet s c ai l ve' a tsae ac am t r le
t
he pe ultve e l' nd tt t l i o ei f

t ti pl usbl o isfke'Twombl 550 U. a 555,570.Alhough acompl i nee no
ha s a i e n t a .'
y,
S. t
t
ant d t
c an dea ld f mala lga i ,i m us c an m o et n Glbesa co l i 'a ça
ont i t ie ac
le tons t t ont i r ha ta l nd ncusons' nd &
f mul i r c t ton oft e e e sofa c us ofa i n w ilnotdo. I a 555.
or a c e ia i
he l m nt
a e cto l
' d. t
'
Di si
scus on

Congr s ha e c e t sat e t e tr t tsude swih dia ltesha ac es t
e s s na t d wo t ut s o nste ha t nt t s biii ve c s o
afeepublce
r
i ducai e lt t tofnon- s bl d sude s Thefr ti t I
ton qua o ha
dia e t nt .
is s he DEA,whih
c

5

r uie ,i e a i,t ts ae a e i f de a fmdspr vi afe a o it publce
eq r s nt r la ha tt s cc ptng e r l t
o de r e ppr pra e
i ducai n
to

t s e t wi d s bl is 2 U. C. 1 2 a( ) Th sc n sam ei S cin 5 4, ih
o md n s t ia ite . 0 S. j 41 ()1. e e o d tt s e to 0 whc
h
i
pr bisr ci e soff de alf , ncudi s hool,fom dic i natng a i ta i vi ua
ohi t e pint
e r unds i l ng c s r
s rmi i gans n ndi d l

be a eo ads blt 29U.. j7 4 a .ç hee st I a fr t l r q ie
c us f ia ii
y.
SC. 9 () t ra he DEA fimai y e u rs
W
ve
pm iiaigsae t a s r d sb e c id e afe a p o raepu i e uc to ,.. S cin
cp tn tts o s u e ia ld h lrn re p r p it blc d ai n . ( e to
5 4 i se dp o i t ds rmiaina an t ia e id vd as'Selr b S le sv Sc . .
0 ) n ta r hbi ici n to g is d sbld n i iu l. les y elr . h Bd
s
'
o Ciyo M a a s s Va,1 F.d5 4 5 ( t Ci.1 98.
f t f n s a , . 41 3 2 , 28 4h r 9 )
1
.

St
andi
nz

I Cot s1,11 a I oft c
n mt I 1, nd V
he ompl i , . . nd t Nolnsa s r cli sf rt i o
ant N N a he e s e t am o her wn
e oto andm onear ha m sr uli fom de e nt 'alege dic i i to agans D. .i
m i nal
t y r es tng '
r
f nda s l d s rm na i n i t N , n

vi ai ofSe ton504.ni i motont dimis de e nt frtaguet tN. andt
olton
ci
I her i o s s , f nda s is r ha K. he
Nolnsl c sa ng t brngt s c am s Spe fcal t y a guet tSe ton 5 doesnot
e a k t ndi o i he e l i . ci ly, he r
ha c i 04
co e sa ngon pa e st a s r i vi lca msf da a sba e on dic i nai
nf r t ndi
r nt o s e t ndi dua li or m ge s d
s rmi ton
a i tt i dia e chidr n.Theco ti c tai d t a ee
gans her s bld l e
ur s onsr ne o gr .

Toha esa ig ap an ifmu t e n tae ( )t th o s eha s fe e a tnt y
v tndn , litf s d mo srt : 1 ha e r h s u fr d n ' jl
i r
i fc'ta i c n r t, a tc lrz d a da t a o i ne t ( ) h tteei ac u a
n a t h t s o c ee p riuaie , n cu l r mmi n ; 2 t a h r s a sl
'
c n cinb t e teij r a dt ec nd tc mpan do ; n ( ) h ti i l eyt a t e
o ne to ewe n h nu y n h o uc o lie f a d 3 t a t s i l h t h
k
ij r wil rd e s db afvo a l d cso Lua v. fnd r o W idie 5 4U. 5 5
n u y lbe e r se y a r be e iin. in De e es f llf, 0 S. 5 ,
5 0 61( 9 2 . na d t nt tec nsiuin lsa dn rq ie ns tef d rl u iir h s
6 - 1 9 ) l d ii o h o ttto a tn ig e u rme t,h e ea j d cay a
o
de l
ve oped a pr nta lm ia i ol s a i w her t pl i ifGge r ly m us a s r hi own
ude i l i t ton l t nd ng
e he a ntf ç ne a l
t se t s

l lrg sa i e e t,a ca tr s hi cai t r le on t lgalrght ori t r t oft r
ega i ht nd nt r ss nd nno e t s l m o ei f he e i s n e ess hid

p ris'W at v. l i, 2 U. 49 , 9( 9 5 . we e, cin50 c e tsarg t f
a t . rh Sedn 4 2 S. 0 49 1 7 ) Ho v r Se to 4 r ae ih o
e '
a ton f pe s ore ii swhos cli sm i o he iebeba r d by t s pnz nta
c i or r ons ntte
e am
ght t m s
re
he e de il

6

c i r tons Specfc l Se ton 504 pe misça pe s a de d'by unlwf l
onsde a i .
ii aly, c i
r t lny r on gg ve '
a u

dici n to t b i a a to 2 U. C. 79 a a( ) Co rsh v itr ee t i ln u g
s rmi ai n o rng n cin. 9 S. j 4 ()2 . u t a e neprtd h s a g a e
t pr bi dic i i ton agans a i vi ua bas d o hi o hera s iton wih adia e
o ohi t s rm na i
i t n ndi d l e n s r
s oca i
t
s bl d

pes n. e Po vihv. y ho aCt . . fCo nPla ,1 0F. p' 4 4 4 7 28( t
ro S e po c Cu a c y Ct o mmo e s 5 Ap x 2 , 2 - 6h
Ci. 0 5 ( ( h dsrc c u tn or cl c n l e t a teRe a iiai nAc d e n t a
r 2 0 ) çT) e itit o r ic re ty o cud d h t h h bltto t o s o h ve
ç
a a s cain lds rmiainc mpo e t'; e as , A. xr lK. v. e s n vleS h
n so ito a ici n to o n n -l s e lo D. e e . A. Pla a t i c .
'
l
Dit, 0 - 3 , 0 W L 2 8 2 9 a * ( N.. t 3 , 0 )($ r , sidviuaswi a
s.No. 7 4 41 2 08
6 4 3 , t 6 D. J Jm. 0 2 08 C e a n i d l t
He
h
r lto s pt apes n wihak o d sb l y ( an ifjc u dha eac us o a to t e
eain hi o ro t n wn ia ii ,plitfs o l v a e f cin md r
t
.. .

t eRe a l ainAc()) v rh ls ,sana s caina d srmi to cam çe u rsa
h h bitto t.' Ne e tee s ç l so ito l ici nain li rq ie
i
'
g

s pa ae a ditnc de alofabe i ors r i et anon- s bl d pe s a d a notbe
e r t nd si t ni
neft e v c o
dia e r on' nd m y
pr s d on aderva i be ftorha ba e on te mentt wa dsadia edpe s n.'Hoo
emie
i tve ne i
nu s d r at
o r
s bl
r o '' ker

v. l sI d p. c Dit, 3:9c - 6 6 G- 2 0W L 40 77 , t* ( D. x. e t
Dal n e S h. s.No. 0 -v 0 7 - BH, 01
a
25 6 a 5 N. Te S p .
1 , 1 )(u tn Uni dS ae v. b lLe r i gCmt se n .No. 9 1 1 , 01 W L
3 20 0 q o ig t tts No e n nn
e
y .I c, 0 - 8 8 2 0
1 47 3 , t* ( D. . a . 9 2 0 )
0 7 0 a 4 E. Pa M r 1 , 01 ).
I t sc e, antfs c
n hi as pl i if ' ompl i ,e n lbe al consr d,doesnotaleget N. .
ant ve i r ly
tue
l hat N or

t Nolnswe e dia ed,o t tt y we ede e be st ors r i e ba edon D . '
he e
r s bl r ha he
r nid ne s e v c s s
N.S
di a lt I t ad,Coun s1,11 a I oft co pl ntaleget tN . .a t Nolns
s biiy. nse
t 1 1, nd V
he m ai l ha N nd he e

s fee e to a a dfna ca h r s ll G e (
u fr d mo in l n
n il a ms oey ç n LCPS d srmi t da an t N .
wh
J ic i nae g is D. '
'
Co l! 7 , 7 81 I p iulr panif alg i Co n s1 a I t t N. n Mr Noe
mp . ! 3 7 , .n m c a, li t s l e n u t 1 nd V ha N. a d . ln
f e
ex re e e r m esr s a a ey a trwine sngt de isf ce ul r moveD . .i
pe inc d xte te s nd nxi t fe t s i he pute or f ly e
N n
ha ufsa l s kl . ai if alegei Cot 11t tM s N o e e re e e r me
ndc f nd eg hac es Pl ntfs l n mt l ha . l n xpe inc d xte

sr sa a eyandwa f c dt q the obbe us D. br
tes nd nxit
s ore o ui rj ca e N. oughthi be vi a is s
s ha orl sue
ho e.
m Thes c a m s r s e i e y on t d s r m i ton pl ntf salege t tD . . xpe i nce
e l i e t ntr l
he i c i na i
ai if l ha N e re d,

7

a She do no c am t y t m s ve f ce a dic i nai n. D. . x r l K. ,
nd d y
t
t l i he he el s a d ny s rmi to ' A e e . A.2008W L
'
268
4239,a * l ap a st tpl i if ha f ie t s
t 6. t pe r ha antfs ve a ld o how t tt ha s ts d t s
ha hey ve a ife he e
pr nta lmia i a t ,do notha sa ngt b i t e cai s
ude i l i t tons nd, hus
ve t ndi o rng hes l m .
N e rhels , antfsa guet tt y ha sa ngt brng t i own c am sunde
ve t e s pli if r
ha he ve t ndi o i her
li
r

Se to 504ba e on t Uit d Stt sSupr me Cour' dec son i W i l a v.Pa maCiy
c in
s d he
e ae
e
ts ii n nkem n
r
t

Sc o l src, 5 U. 5 6 (00 ) I t t ae teCo r h l t a p r n sh vein e n e t
h o Ditit5 0 S. 1 2 7 .n ha c s ,h u t ed h t a e t a û d pe d n ,
i
e or ea erght c er ng t e
nf c bl i s onc ni he ducai n oft i c l e 'unde t I
to
her hidr n'
r he DEA.W i l a 550
nkem n,

U . a 5 I s hol ng,t Cour r le on t t xtoft I
S. t 29. n o di he
t ei d he e
he DEA,whih pr vi st tis
c o de ha t
pur ei t S ns et tt rg sofc l r wih dia ltesa par nt ofs h c l e a e
pos s o s ur ha he i ht
e
hid en t s biii nd e s uc hidr n r

prtce 'I . t5 3( ing20U. C. 1 0 () 1( ) I a dto ,heCo r f u dta te
oe td. d a 2 ct
'
i
S. j 4 0 d ( )B).n d iin t
uto n h th
ex e s t r oft I
pr s ed e ms he DEA ç ont mpl t pa e swilbet pa te brngi t
ç e aes r nt l he ri s i ng he
c
a nita i c pli s' nd Stwoul bei onsse wih t sa u or s he et ba t m
dmi sr tve om a nt'a s
i
d nc itnt t he t t t y c m o r he

fo c ni un t a sr te e(n o c a e rg t i fd r l o r. J a 5 6. ic
r m o tn ig o se th s e f re bl) i hs n e e a c u t'Z t 2 Sn e
'
W i l a c t ha dia e a t whehe ishol ng a i sbe
nkem n, ours ve s gr ed s o
t r t di pple yondt I
he DEA t i l
o ncude
Se to 504 c am s Someco t extnde t hol ng i W i ma wihoutmuc e anai n.
ci n
li .
urs e d he di n nkel n t
h xpl to

Se D. e r lK. , 0 W L 2 4 3 , t* (itn c ss . h rc u t,n ldn ti
e A. x. e. A.20 8
68 2 9 a 6 lsig a e ) Ot e o rs icu ig h s
c t ha lm ie t hol ng ofW i l a t cli sb o hts e yt rt I
our, ve i t d he di
nkem n o am r ug oll mde he DEA be us
ca é
t Supr m eCour' de i i wa g o
he
e
ts c son s r unde i t s i sa u or l
d n he pecsc t t t y angua a pu pos oft
ge nd r e he
I
DEA .Se Augusi v.W i he trPub. h. s .No.5: 3c
e
tne
nc se
Sc Dit,
1 v000 201 W L 5347465,a *6
25, 3
t

n. ( . Va.Se .1 201 (itngc s s.
6 W D.
pt 7, 3) lsi a e )
Thec ti m or peruade byt a hortest tha lmie t s peofW i l a
our s e s d he ut ii ha ve i t d he co
nkem n
t t D EA . rt theSu e eCo tm a no r f r nc i isdecson t a ot rcvi rght
o he
Fis, d
t
pr m
ur de e e e e n t
ii o ny he i l i s
s a ut ot rt n t I EA . A umz tne 201 W L 53 465 a *6.Ot r c t ha sm ia l
t t e he ha he D
'
'
si , 3
47 , t
he our s ve i l r y

8

f md t tW i l a ç snotta lt i o abr d rg t pur uea saut y o c
ot ha nkem n l
doe
r nsa e nt
oa i ht o s ny t t or r omm o
n

1w camso ac id sbe l b apae t.'L, v. u tnI d p Sc Dit No H- 82 5
a li n hl ' haf y rn rj' F. Ho so n e . h. s. . 0 - 41 ,
,
2 0 W L 3 7 26 a # 2( . Te S p . , 0 ) s eas W o d ufv. mi o - wn hi
09
0 39 , t 2 SD. x. e t21 20 9 ; e lo o r f Hn l n To s p
t
Pu . h.3 5F. p' 8 3 8 6( dCi. 0 9 . c n , h S p e Co r e plct sae
b Sc , 0 Ap x 3 , 3 3 r 2 0 ) Se o d t e u r me u t x iil ttd
y
t a çh tx o I r s l e teq e to p e e tdl 'a t a : p o e itpr tto o t e
h t d e e t f DEA e o v s h u sin rs n e , ' nd h t( r p r ne eain f h
t
l
a
(DEAj e uie ac nsd rto o tee tr sauo ys h me' ik l n, 5 U. a 5 3.
I
r q r s o i eain f h nie ttt r c e 'W n ema 5 0 S. t 2
W hiet c ta e i t t tbot t I
l he our ppr c aes ha h he DEA a Se ton 504 co an t s m eS ny pa t
nd c i
nt i he n i
a
ry
a i ve ' a
ggre d'l ngua t Supr m eCour' de son i W i l a Er le on t t quesr cur
ge, he
e
ts cii n nkem n 'ei d he mi
tu t e
a c e toft I
nd ont n
he DEA,e pe i ly c e ni t c e m i
s c al onc r ng he otr nousrght ofpa en sa t i
i s
r t nd her
c l e a t i r di s'Augusi 201 W L 5347465,a #6;s ealo Hoo r 201 W L
hidr n nd her eme e .'
tne, 3
t
e s
ke , 0

4 2 7 6 a * (( h W ik e nc u t e s n dt a t etx a dsr cu eo t eI
0 5 7 , t 6 $Tj e n lma o r ra o e h t h e t n tu tr f h DEA d e
$
os
no difr ntaebe we n t rg sa co de t c l e a t eac or t pa e s a i
t fe e i t t e he iht c r d o hidr n nd hos c ded o r nt , nd t
pr vi f txpansver viw a e e i pa e ali ve nt a a1lvel i l ng t
o des or e
i e e nd xt nsve r nt nvol me ' t 1 e s nc udi hè

fd r l o rs' Uz iet eI
e e a c u t. l k h DEA, e to 5 4d e n tc n anasauo yshe t a
l. l
S cin 0 o s o o ti ttt r c me h t
c e aesc e mi
ont mpl t ont r nousrgh shed by par nt a t i c l e I t c tsviw,t e
i t l
e s nd her hidr n. n he our' e hes

ditnci nsa e sg fca whe de i ngwée he t e e t hol ng i W i l n.
si to r i nii nt n cdi
t r o xtnd he di n nke ma
M o e r t c t i t tt decson i W i l n wa s cos l tedt t t xta
r ove , he our fnds ha he ii n nke ma
s o l ey i o he e nd
snlt r oft I
t c u e he DEA t i woul bei o t e e isho di t Seci n 504 cai .
hat t
d mpr per o xt nd t l ng o to
l ms
The e or ,t c tco l
r f e he our ncudest tt N olnsdo notha sa ngt puruec am st r
ha he e
ve t ndi o s l i mde
Se ton 504 ba e s el on t al ge dic i na i s f r by D . . n i t c tco d
ci
s d ol y he le d s rmi ton ufe ed
N Eve f he our ul
fnd t tt Nol nsha sa ngt brngt s Se ton 504 c am son t i own be f t co t
i ha he e
d tndi o i he e c i
li
her
hal, he ur
i nota a e ofa a ho iy t tN . . a D . .S ol rbr he ,w o d a s ha s a ng bas
s
w r
ny ut r t ha N , s N ' de ot r ul l o ve t ndi
ed
o t f t a l ged i t com pl i . cc di y,Co m t 1 , 1 , I w ilbe dim i s d f r
n he ac s le
n he
a nt A or ngl
t s 1 1 1 and V l
s se o

9

lc o s b e tmatr u id cin.
a k f u j c- te j rs ito 1
I.
I

Faiur t St e a C l m
l e o at
ai

l t i moton,de e
n he r i
f ndant a s a gu t tpli tfsha f ie t sa ecli supon
s lo r e ha a n if ve al d o tt am

whih r ifm a begr nt i bot t a
c ele y
a ed n h he ppea oft He rng Ofkilsde ii n a we las
l he a i
f a ' c so s l
Cot loft c
mt
he ompli .The c twila es e c a gtme i t r
ant
our l ddr s a h r l nt n u n.
a. Appe oft H e ng O f i r sD ec s on
al he ari
fce '
ii

I a ton t t f - mtc
n ddii o he ourcot ompl i , antfsa s a a t He ng Of e '
ant pli if l o ppe l he mi
fc rs
de sont tD. .Sd pr es r ques w a i uf intduet t na ur oft pr e
cii ha N ' ue oc s e t s ns sce
o he t e he opos d
r med s ik al monea yda a . I
e y, pect ly
t r m ges The DEA i ac
s ompr he i saut t tS ovi sa
e nsve t t e ha d
pr de
.

pa y ofpr dur lrght t pa e st e ur t i i ve ç i de i i a
nopl
oce a i s o r nt o ns e her nvol m nt n c sons boutt i
her

dia ed c l se a i ' Sele s 1 F. a 5 Co e sa c pli sa t dia e
s bl hîd' duc ton. lr , 41 3d t 27. nc m nd om a nt bout he s bl d
'
c l sed a i mus behe r C t Stt e
hid' uc ton
t
a d i he a e ducai na age y orby t l a ed a i
by
to l nc
he oc l uc ton

a e c , sd tr n db S aelw. 2 U. C. 1 59 ()A) s eas M . . xrlD. .
g n y a ee mie y tt a ' 0 S. j 41 ( 1 ( ; e lo M e e. M v.
'
Sc Dit o Gr e vleCny, 0 F.d5 3, 35(t Ci. 0 2 (; i ce rta, n e t
h. s. f e n il t .3 3 3 2 5 4 h r 2 0 ) $t s la h t u d r he
l
I
DEA, e sa s ri avi ai oft I
parnt s e tng olton he DEA mus frtrque tad pr es he rng.).
t s e s ué oc s a i '
Howe r Gheprnci lf m ofr le t rt I
ve , s
t
i pa or
ei f mde he DEA i p os ctve be s i t f m of
s r pe i
neft, n he or
e a i a omm oda i .' i v. i Ge ge' Cnt Bd. Ed ,60 F.
duc tonal cc
tons'Re d Prnce or s y. of uc.
Supp.3d 601,

6 6( M d 2 4 . s c t eCDEA d e n tp o i ef rc mp ns tr o pmiie
0 D. . 01 ) As u h,h S
I
o s o r v d o o e ao y r t tv
da
mage . Sele s 1 F. at525.TheI
s' lr , 41 3d
'
DEA a s expr s l r quie exha to ofcai
lo
e sy e r s
usi n
l ms
unde ç herFe r lw spr eci t rg so c l r n wih dia ltes..s e ng r le t t
rd
ot
de al a
ot tng he i ht f hid e t s biii . e ki ei f ha

j
l
Att De mbe 11 2015heai pli if c e p ovi d a ii lf cst tma s rtaf ng
he ce r ,
. rng, antfs' ouns l r de ddtona a t ha y uppo mdi
t tt NolnsandN. s fr d dic i nai ba edont ra s itonwihD. ,s paat 9om t
ha he e
N. ufe e s rmi ton s
hei s ocai
t N. e r e
he
dic i na i t tD. .pe s ly e re ed.
srmi ton ha N r onal xpe inc Howe ,t c
ver he ompli doe notc ant ealgai ,a t
ant s
onti hes le tons nd he
c ti c tai byt f t pr de i t c ai ,o fndt tt Nolnsa N. do notha sa ngt
our s onsr ned, he acs ovi d n he ompl nt t s ha he e nd N.
ve tndi o

pls et i camsNe etees tec u t lds s Co nsI,1, n I wih u p eu iet alw panif
t u her li . v rh ls,h o r wil imis u t 111a d V to t rj dc o l litfs
r
o
t opporu t t s k la t fl a a ndedcompl nt
he
tniy o ee e ve o ie n me
ai .

1
0

i as a alb eu d rg eI
s lo v ia l n e t DEAq'2 U. C. 1 5 1. we e , xh u to o camsi no
h
. 0 S. j 41 () Ho v r e a sin f li s t
'
nec s a y i ç hea i sr tvepr es woul bef tl 'M . .e r l D. .30 F. a 536.
e s r f ç dm nitai
t
oc s
d
uie. M x e. M , 3 3d t
'
l t sca e de enda sc e t tr mandi t c e a r quii t Hea i
n hi s , f nt ont nd ha e
ng he as nd e rng he rng
Ofi rt co uc adue pr es he rng wo d bef ie. f nda t a s r t tpl i if a e
fce o nd t
oc s a i
ul
utl De e n s s e t ha antfs r
a tm ptngt fa t i I
te i o r me he r DEA cli s f rwhih mone a y dn a a eno a ia e,
am , o
c
t r m ges r t val bl as
Se ton 504 cli s f rwhi h mone a y dn a sa e a ia e The f t ra g t tt
ci
am , o
c
t r m ge r va lbl . y urhe r ue ha he
He rng Ofi e doesnotha t a ho iy t a r m one da a ,t s er m e t tt
ai
tc r
ve he ut rt o wa d
y m ges he ol e dy ha he

Nolnss e I addii de e nt c e t tpl i if a enotr quie t e us t i
e e k. n
ton, f nda s ontnd ha antfs r
e r d o xha t he r
a i sr tver disbe us s h e usi woul bef tl aspl i if ha ale y
dm nita i eme e ca e uc xha ton
d
uie
antfs ve r ad
r ceved c
e i
ompe aor e to a s r ce asr q r d t rt I
ns t y ducai n nd e vi s e uie mde he DEA.

Ba e o t eij y alg db p an if a dt etpeo rme ys u h t rd e si
s d n h nur le e y litfs n h y f e d o g t o e rs t
p ro a ij re a mo eayd ma e , e p ci l- tec u t o ld st a e h u to o
es n l nu is nd n tr a g s rs e tvey h o r c ncu e h t x a sin f
pl ntfs Se ton 504 cli woul bef tl asm o tr dnmage a enota ia e unde t
ai if ' c i
a ms
d u ie
nea y
s r
val bl
r he
I
DEA a t ,t Hea i Of erw o d no ha a hort t a d s h r le . Pl n if
nd hus he
rng sc
ul t ve ut iy o war uc ei fz aitf s
a i t tt y ha ar dy r ceved e a i a co moda i a r quie by t I
dm t ha he ve lea e i
duc tonal c m
tons s e r d he DEA a
nd

s e o l mo tr d ma e a t ssa e S eCo l! 5 - . F u t Cic t a
e k ny neay a g s thi tg . e mp . ! 0 51 The o rh ruih s
e iil sa e t tt I
xplc ty t t d ha he DEA doe notpr vi f t sf r ofr le . le s 1 F. a 525.
s
o de or hi o m
ei f Se lr , 41 3d t

Th c u t e o nie t a çth icu i no acam f rmo eaydn g sma n t i az o
e o r rc g z s h t çj e n l so f li o n tr ma e y o ,n l f
g
d
is f r nde exha to f tl .' i 60 F.Supp. a 607.
tel, e r
usi n ' ie'Re d,
u
3d t
Howe r t he c t ha f md
ve ,i r ours ve ot
ot

ta e ha to o I
h t x usin f DEA a mi srtv rme iswa ftl i c s salg n ijl e t a
d nitaie e de s uie n a e le i g nt is o
r
2
I a ar t tpli if donotdiput t t He i Ofi rdoe no ha a t rt t awa dmonea y
t ppe s ha antfs
s e hat he arng fce s t ve uho iy o r
tr
da a s M or ver duepr e she rngofk e si ot rca e ha sm iaryf undt tt ydi no ha auhort
m ge . eo ,
oc s a i
t r n he s s ve i l l o
ha he d t ve t iy
t awa dmoneay damage .Se ec.A. e r l M . v.I
o r
tr
s e. . , C. x e . C. ndep.Sc Dit No.1 No. 3099,
h. s.
52, 062006W L

3 2 7 8 a * ( M i No 7, 00 ) N. e rlTr il v Es a l Pu l S hs, Ci 0 -41 , 0 5WL
2 7 6 , t 2 D. l v. 2 6; T, x e. uio . p noa bi c .No. v 40 5 2 0
m.
l
c
61 8 8 , t# 0( N. Jm. , 05, ev. wno Bo r e No. v A. 2 1 3 3DPW, 0 4W L 1 2 7 ,
6 4 3 a 1 D. M.t 2120 ) Do To f u n , Ci. 0 - 1 6 .
20
21 0 5
a * ( MasM a 28 20 4 . s c tec utipesa e ta teHe rn Of rddn t a ea toi t
t 2 D. s. y , 0 ) As u h,h o r s ru d d h th aig t i o h v uh rt o
ke
y
a ad m o tr da a t pli if.
w r neay m ges o antfs

dia ed sude ..whe et pl i ifs ug onl mone a y d gesa c
s bl t nt .
r he antf o ht y
t r nma
s ompe a i f
ns ton or

ij re , tfrh re uc to a a ssa c fo tesho l itit' d ( ic si gc s si t
nu is no u te d ain l s itn e rm h c o dsrc 'I . ds u sn a e n he
S ve t, nh, n Te t Cic t) Al o g p an if'camsaer ltdt c mpi wih
e nh Nit a d n h ruis. t u h litfs li r eae o o lmwe t
h
t I
he DEA i t tD. .Si l i i t ge r le a i c a soom w a pr s a y pa tofhi
n ha N ' ncuson n he ne a duc ton l s r
s e um bl r
s

I t mone a y dnmage t tpli if s k a em e ntt qo ns t f t e i lham
EP, he
tr
s ha antfs ee r a o mpe ae or he motona r

t a D. alg d ys fee a ar s l o d fnd n s ds rmiain. e Co l!6 . c us
h t N. le e l u f rd s eut f ee a t' ici n to S e mp . 9 Be a e
mone a y da
t r mage a eno a lbl unde t I
s r t vaia e
r he DEA,a pl ntf sco e t tt y a eno
nd ai if nc de ha he r t
s ki a addii na educ ton a omm odai ns e usi ofpl i ifsSeci n 50 cam s
ee ng ny
to l
a i cc
to , xha ton
antf
to 4 li
woul be f iea t r f r i no r quie i t sc e. co di y,t c tde lne t
d m l nd, he e o e, s t e r d n hi as Ac r ngl he our ci s o
r ndt c et t He dng Of rf adecson on t me isofCountIi t c
ema he as o he a
sce or
ii
he rt
n he ompli .
ant
b. D i abiiy D i c i i t on aga ns D . .
s lt s r m na i
i t N

Ha ng c l d t tt Nol nsa N . . a k sa ngt pur uet i own c am s
vi oncude ha he e nd N l c tndi o s her
li
ba e on de e nt 'al ge dic i nai a i tD. .t s ec am t tr ma nsi t sc e
sd
f nda s le d s rmi ton gans N , he ol l i ha e i n hi as
i D . .sal to ofdia lt dicrmi to i vi ai ofSe to 504.Pli if a gu t t
s N '' legai n
s biiy s i nai n n ol ton
ci n
antfs r e ha

D . .wasdi c i naed a i twhe hewa e ude fom pa tcpa i i t ge r l
N
s rmi t gans
n
s xcl d r
rii tng n he ne a
e a i c a soom ,i unt rl ta pore f amen a he lh e ua i i ano e r nc
duc ton l s r
nvol a iy r ns td or
t l at val ton n
n- me ge y
st ton,a s nthom ee ry fom s hoolo m uli e oc aso . a r s t pli if c e
iua i nd e
al r c
n
tpl c i ns As e ul, a ntfs ontnd
t tD . s f r d da a i t f ofl sofi tu ton tme,s a si tzai n,
ha N. ufe e m ges n he onn os
nsr c i i
ocil tgma i to
hlm ii ton,f a , pr s i a ne tve s l- see .
l lai e r de e son, nd ga i e fe t m

I or rt sae acli unde Se ton 504,apl i ifmus s
n de o t t
am
r ci
antf
t how t theors wa
ha
he s
di c i naed a i ts ey on t ba i ofadia lt Sele s 1 F. a 528.ç opr
s rmi t gans ol l
he ss
s biiy. lr , 41 3d t
T
ove
di c i nai n i t e a i co e ,s ehi m o et n amer f lzet pr det 9e
s rmi to n he duc ton nt xt om t ng r ha
e ailr o ovi he e

a p o raee u ai nr q ie b (DEAjmus bes wn. I a 5 9(n en l u tto maks
p r p it d c to e ur d y I
t ho ' d. t 2 itr a q oain r
'

o te ) l se d t eFo rh Cic i h shedt tete t dfih' rt r s mi u g n 'mu t
mitd .n ta ,h u t rut a l ha i r û at'o û o s s d me t s
h ba
g
j
'
be s
hown i or rt e t bls acli unde Se ton 5 1 ;s a s K. e r l JD.v.St m
n de o sa ih am
r c i 04. d. ee lo D. x e . .
a

5 F. u p. d7 2 7 2( M d. 01 )(G t F u t Cic t .. litfsmu t h w b df i
5 S p 3 8 , 9 D. 2 4 çn he o rh rui . p an if s s o a at
I
,
h
o go smij dg n b t es h o s se t etbls Se to 5 4d srmiaini t e
r r s . su me t y h c o l y tm o sa ih cin 0 ici n to n h
e uc to c ne t' . i sa d r i dfiutt me t c us o t et r a d frnc t wh c
d ain o tx .) Ths tn a d s ifc l o e be a e f h s e t eee e o ih
'
g

l c lsho lo fcas e uc to a j d me t aee tte 'Do v. l t nCt . c Bd.41F.
o a c o fiil' d ain l u g n s r n i d. e Ari o y S h. ,
l '
nc
S p 2 5 9 6 9( D. .1 9 ) Ass c , r camso n gie ea ei u fce t oma
u p. d 5 , 0 E. Va 9 9 . u h mee li f e l nc r ns fiin t ke
g
outaSeci 504 cai ,Se lr ,1 F. a 529,asa e dia e nt wih s hoolof l '
ton
l m le s 41 3d t
r s gr eme s t c
fda s

e lain , n ha v. tt o Ne , 8 F.d 1 6 ,1 7 (t Ci. 9 2 .n a dto ,
vau to s Mo a n Sae f b.6 7 2 1 4 1 0 8h r 1 8 ) I d i n a
i
s hoolsf itr t G i y a s s a dignos 'a c l sdiabiiy i a s notba f ih orgr s
c ' a lte o t mel s e s nd a
t
e' hid' s lt s lo
d at
os

mij d me t I . tmaey panif mus alg t thes h o ' a to sç e a te q
su g n . d Uli tl, lit s t le e ha t c o ls cin t p rld
f
d
s b tnilyfo ic e tdp o e so a j d me t p a tc o sa d r a t d mo srt t t
u sa tal rm a c p e r f sin l u g n , rcie r tn ads s o e n tae ha

tep ro sr s o sb eddno b s ted cso o s c aj d me t' M . e r lJY. D.
h es n e p n il i t a e h e iin n u h u g n .' Y. x e. . & Y.
'
v. p ca S h. s. 1 5 4F.d8 5 8 0(t Ci. 08 .
S e il c DitNo. , 4 3 8 , 9 8h r 20 )
I t rmoton, f nt a gu t tpli if ha f ie t sa ea cai upon whih
n hei
i de enda s r e ha antfs ve al d o tt l m
c
r le m a be g a e ast Cot 1bec us t y f ie t al ges fc e f c st s t t
e if y
r nt d o mt
a e he a ld o le ufi i nt a t o how ha

d f n a t e g g di ba fiho g o smij d me t S e iial, ee a t ag et a
ee d ns n a e n d at r r s su g n . p cfc ly d fnd ns r u h t
pl ntfsha onl s
ai if ve y hown,a be t ne i nc a oram e ef llet tmel a s s a
t s, glge e nd/
r aitr o i y s e s nd

di
agnos D . ' dia lt
e N.S s biiy.
Ba e on t f ct lal ga i i t co pl nta dr wi a 1r as
s d he a ua le tons n he m ai nd a ng 1 e onabl f t
e, acual
i e e esi t pl i ifsf vo ,t c tfndst tpl i if have pl us bl s
nf r nc n he a ntf a r he our i ha a ntf s
a i y hown t t
ha
de enda s di c i i t d aga ns D . .o t bas sofhi di a lt The c pl i a l ge t t
f
nt s rm na e
i t N n he i
s s biiy.
om a nt le s ha

D. . s nthom efom s hoola l a tt n tm esduet no di cplna y i s sr l t t hi
N was e
r c
tes e i
o n- s i i r s ue e aed o s

a im .I a ton,t c
uts n ddii he ompl i as pr dest tde e nt r m ove D. fo t ge r l
ant lo ovi ha f nda s e
d N. r m he ne a
e
ducai n casr m on muli eocc sonsa s nthi t et rt prncpalsofi eora
to l s oo
tpl
ai
nd e m o ihe he i i ' fc
s ciled a i cas r , r her ceved ltl t' i t cton. soc un'd de piet
pe a uc ton l soom whe e e i ite o no nsm i Thi ' e s t he
c
de e mi to t tD . .Slas r src i e r e twa t gene a e a i cls r m .
t r nai n ha N ' e t e titve nvionm n s he
r l duc ton a s oo

M oe rt c
r ove , he ompl i al ge t tde enda sde e t tt ei i nt oc red i t r1
ant le s ha f nt ni d ha hes ncde s cu r n hei EP
m e tngswiht Nolns Thede e nt a s r i o s h de a swhe t y r f s d t pl ce
ei
t he e .
f nda s lo eled n uc nil
n he e u e o a
D . .i aprva es hoolt twa be t e ppedt ha ehi dia lt Fi ly, heco ant
N n i t c
ha s ter qui
o ndl s s biiy. nal t
mpli

sae ta D. wa ds rmiae a an twh nd fnd nsh dhm iv lmtrl c mmitbf r
tts h t N. s ici n td g is e ee a t a i n ot aiy o te o
m e ale l ton.
nt va ua i

Ote c u t h v f t t a smia a to sn u tdt b df i o g o smij g n .
h r o rs a e omd h t i lr cin mo n e o a at r r s sud me t
h

S e ec, . e r lK. .nd p. h DitNo 7 , 2 F.d9 , 8 (t Ci. 0 3 (i dng
e . ..M P. x e. v I e Sc . s. . 21 3 6 3 75 9 2 8h r 2 0 ) fn i
b dfi o g o smij g n wh nt esu e tsmoh rc le tesho o awe k ybai,
a at r r s sud me t e h t d n ' t e ald h c ol n e l ss
h
and t s hoolf ie t r tun he phonecal , opos d dr tcale ai nst t sude ' s hool
he c
al d o e t' r
ls pr e asi tr to o he t nts c

d y a drs i e a o frt p yf rt su e t obeta p re t a t e s h o dsrc)
a , n e cnd d n fe o a o he t d n t rns o td o noh r c o l itit;
K. e rlJD.5 F. u p. a 7 2( dngba fiho g o smij d me twhe Ge c e s
D. x e . , 5 S p 2d t 9 ûn i d at r r s su g n
n d ah r
t
c nsse tyf i dt h n rt a re -po a c mmo ains'; T. BatmoeCi Bd. f
o itnl al o o o he g e d u n c o d to ' N. v. li r t
e
)
v o

S h. m's No. KB- 135 , 1W L 3 4 7 , t* - ( M d Au 23 20 1 (e iga
c Co r, J 1 - 6 201
7 7 51 a 6 8 D. . g. , 1 ) d nyn
1 b ( )mo inwhe t c mplitc n an dalg to t a t es e t ss s n e
2()6 to
n he o an o tie l ains h t h md n wa u pe d d
e
m uli etmesbas o ç tona e,i no none se ,e de ofwr
tpl i
ed n ç
quesi bl f t
xit nt vi nce
ongdoi 'a
ng' nd

G wlto t vie c ta t s i o tn d cso sweeb sdu o r a o o ec u difrt t
d ih u e d n e h t hee mp ra t e iin r a e p n e s n, n o l n e ha
g
Eh su e t h sbe nd nide uc to a be eiss ll b sdo h sds bl y'. o e v r t e
t e td n ) a e e e d ai n l n ft oey a e n i ia ii ' M ro e ,h
t)
co ttnds t tt e a l ga i o di c i i ton a i tD . . t ke t t r go be nd
ur i
ha hes le tons f s rm na i ga ns N , a n oge he ,
yo

m eeys
r l howi t tde e nt as e s d a di gnos d D. .Sdia lt i a t i l m a r
ng ha f nda s s s e nd a
e N ' s biiy n n mtme y nne ,

t tt Nolnssmpl dia e wih de e nt'a s s m e s ort tde enda sco itd
ha he e i y s gr ed t f nda s s e s nt, ha f nt mm te
neglge e I t ad,pli if ha plusbl al ge t tdef nda se ge i c
i nc . nse
a ntfs ve a i y le d ha e nt nga d n onduc t t
t ha

d patds b tn il fo a c p e p o e so lu g n, r cie o sa d r s Th f c t t
e re u sa tal r m c e t d r f sina j d me tp a tc , r tn ad . e a t ha
y
D . ' be vi is i ove whe hewa pl e i aprva es hoolpr vi sf rhe s
N.S ha or s ues mpr d
n
s ac d n
i t c
o de u t r uppor
t

f rt sc ncu in. e K. e r lJD.5 F. u . da 7 2 ( igas fiin cam u d r
o hi o lso S e D. x e. . , 5 S pp 3 t 9 fndn u fce t li n e
Se ton 504 a no i t tt s de ' çe uc tona pr e sr po tdl i o d whe
ci
nd tng ha he m nts td a i l ogr s e re y mpr ve
n
m ove t aprva es hool whe ehe a ommoda i nswe epr de i am or s t m ai a
do
i t c , r r cc
to
r ovi d n
e yse tc nd

rg r u wa ' . n l t ec u ti d t rua ied f n a t' o tn int tte eween
i oo s y' Fial h o r fn s mpes sv e e d n s c n e to ha h r r o
)
y,
pr vi al gai ofvi e ort eae ng be vi be or t M a 5,201 i i nt
e ous le tons
olnt hr t ni
ha or f e he y
4 ncde .

Evi nc ofpe s la m ost ori1wili no ne es a y f a fndi ofbad f ih orgr s
de e
r ona ni iy 1 l s t c s r or i ng
at
os

mij d me t I . t . ec u t o cud st a t ef cu l le ain i t c mplitsaea
su g n . d a 791 Th o r c n l e h t h a t a alg to s n he o an tt
p a sbecam t t ee d n sa tdi b dfiho wi g o smij d me t e a d e sng
lu il li ha d fn a t ce n a at r t r s su g n wh n d r si
h
D. .Sne ,a t tpl ntfsha plusbl s wn t tD. . dic i naed a i ts el
N ' eds nd ha ai if ve a i y ho ha N was s rmi t gans ol y
o t bassofhi dia lt Acc di y,de e nt 'm o i n t dimi sa t CountIwilbe
n he i
s s biiy. or ngl f nda s to o s s s o
l
de e
nid.
c L oui a Count Publc Sc
.
s
y
i hool as a D e e
s
f ndant

Pl ntfshavenn e LCPS a ade e nti t sc e. n t i m oto t dimis
ai if
m d
s f nda n hi as l her i n o s s ,
d e nt a g t tLCPS i anon- ntt a s dbedimis d fom t sc e.I Vig ni,
ef nda s r ue ha
s
e iy nd houl
s s e r hi as n r i a

g r nc o e c shooldi soni ve tdi t di son' shoolboad. CodeAnn.j
ovena e f a h c
vii s se n he vii s c
r Va.
22.- Vigi al w as pr dest tC ve y s h s hoolbo d i de lz d abody c por t '
128. r ni a lo ovi ha i r uc c
e
ar s c a e
or a e'

a ma s orbes I j2 171 Ot rc t i t sCicui,i l ngt sc tha hed
nd y ue
ued. d. 2.- . he ours n hi r t ncudi hi our, ve l
t tpublc s hool di sonsa enote ttest tm a bes d. g.Auc tne 201 W L
ha
i c s vii
r
n ii ha y
ue E. , usi , 3
53 465 a # Smih v. n e C. me Sc ofVa. ns.ofAuts , 3: v00030,
47 , t 5; t J m s Hor l h.
I t
im No. 08c
2009

15

W L 1 1 7 , t* ( . Va Ap . 2, 0 ) M . v. ifx Ct . c Bd.No
08 0 9 a 4 W D. . r 2 20 9 ; S. Fara y S h. , .
10 CV1 7 (CC) 20 6W L 7 3 2 a * ( D. . a . , 0 ) Th ye v W a h Ct Sc .
;5 4 6J , 0
21 7 , t 3 E. Va M r 20 20 6 9 a r . s . y. h

Bd, 4 F. u p. 4 , 4 n. ( . Va 1 9 ) M o e v r panif d n tc n e dt a LCPS
.9 9 S p 4 5 4 6 1 W D. . 9 6 . r o e, lit s o o o tn h t
f
i aco por t body t tha t powe t s orbe s The e or t c r c l st t
s r ae
ha s he
r o ue
ued. r f e, he ou t oncude ha
pli if c nnotma n a n aci la ton a i tLCPS. o di y,LCPS wilbedim is d asa
antfs n
iti
vi ci ga ns
Acc r ngl
l
s se
de e ntfom t sc s
f nda r hi a e.
Conc us on
l i

Fort f e ngr a ons de e nt 'm o i t dimiswilbegr nt d i pa ta
he or goi e s , f nda s ton o s s l
a e n r nd
de e i pa t Themoton wilbede e wih r pec t Co 1oft compl i a gr nt
nid n r.
i
l
ni d t es t o unt
he
ant nd a ed
wih r s c t Cot sI,11 a I oft c
t e pe t o mt I 1, nd V
he ompl i .Co mt I, 1 ,a I wilbe dim is d
ant t s 1 11 nd V l
s se

wih u p eudc s t a plitfsma se la et fl a n nd dc mplit LCPS wil lo
t o t rj ie o h t anif y e k e v o ie n me e o an .
las
bedimis d a adef nda ,a t c es l pr ee s ey agans LCSB.
s sv s
e nt nd he as ha l oc d oll
i t
TheCl k i die t d t s nd c esoft sm e o a l opi on a t ac ompa ng
er s r c e o e opi
hi m r ndtm ni nd he c
nyi
o de t a 1co e ofr co d.
r r o 1 uns l e r

DATED : s 1
Thi 3

da ofJ nua y, 2016.
y a r

ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge