Harrison et al v. Carrington Mortgage Services, LLC et al

Filing 57

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/28/17. (hnw)

cLERK' OF CE U. DI COURT
s FI S. SQ
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI OF VI GI I
CT
R NA
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON

AFR 2 8 2 1
27
J
BY:

UDL

CLERK
.
L
ERK

R OG ER G . AR RI
H
SON ,e a .
t l,
Ci lA c i N o.3: 6- vi ton
1 CV 0001
4
Pl ntf s
ai i f ,
M EM O M N D UM O PI I N
N O

Ho Gl n E.
n. e Com'd
a
Chi fU nie St t D i ti tJ
e
t d a es s r c udge

CARRI
NGTON M ORTGAGE,
SERVI
CES,LLC,e a .
t l,
D e e nt .
f nda s

Pli tfs Roge a Ka l Ha rs fl d t i t nt a ton unde t Far Cr t
a n if
r nd ra rion ie he nsa c i
r he i edi

Re ri Ac,15U. C.j1 x s q.a i tdee nt Ca ngt M o t geSe vc s LLC
po tng t
S.
681 ! e gans fnda s ni on rga
r ie ,
a Equia I onnai Se v c s LLC.The ca e i pr s nty be or t c to t pli tfs
nd
f x nf
ton r i e ,
s s e e l f e he our n he a n if '

moin fratr y sfe p ru n t Ru e3 ()5 o t eFe ea Ru e o Ci lP o e l e F r
to o tone ' e s u s a t o l 7 a( ) f h d rl ls f vi r c dz . o
r
t r a onssaed, hem o i wilbe de e
he e s
tt t
ton l
nid.
B ackzround

Pli tfs fl d ce ti dic r r que t on de enda Ca rngt M o t e Se vies
a n if ie ra n s ove y e ss
f nt ri on rgag r c ,

td n n o ' icu i sv ne n itro ao is Carn o o j ce t e c
G i gtn), n ldng e e t e n er g tre . rigtn b e td o a h
ca
i e r t r as e tng t tt i e r t i s we e va a n bi ous ove br d,t y
nt roga o y, s ri ha he ntr ogaore
r gue nd m gu , r oa mdul
bur ns e, i r l va , s ug doc e s ea iy a c sbl t pl i if , no r a ona y
de om
r e e nt o ht
um nt sl c es i e o antfs t e s bl
7

cac a e t l ad t t dic r ofa isbl doc
lult d o e o he s ove y
dm s i e ument,a s htprvie d orot r s
s nd oug
i l ge
he wie
e mpt i o m ai n. Cani on t pr e d t a we m a of t 'nt l ga ores by
xe
nf r to
ngt hen oc ede o ns r ny
he i ew t i
r f r i t doc l e s pr uc d i di co r The e a w e s i l d r f r nc t doc e s
e e r ng o
lm nt od e n s ve y. s ns r nc ude e e e es o um nt
t t c i t d of be w e n t o a t e hl d e page . I r pondi t one of pl i if '
ha ons s e
t e w nd hr e m r d
s n es
ng o
a ntf s

i e r t re s ki t i ntfc to of c rai i vi l lkey t have dic r bl
nt roga o i s ee ng he de iia i n
e t n ndi dua s i l o
s ove a e

i or ai n, Ca rngt sa e t t t s cfc i vi l we e ço be dee mi d. See
nf m to
r i on t t d ha he pe ii ndi dua s r ç
t
t r ne '
'
Ca rngtn' Re p.t P1. I er . Doc tNo.39- Ca ngtn a s f ie t r s
ri o s s o s ' ntr ogs, ke
1. ni o lo al d o e pond t
o
c ran i e r t re at t r Pli if bei ve t e r s es t be i deq t a
e ti nt roga o is logehe . antfs le d hes e pons o
na ua e nd

at mpt d t r s ve t is wih Ca ngt De pie t s e f t t pa tes c d not
te e o e ol he s ue t
ni on. s t hi foz he ri oul
i or ly r s vet dicove y diput a pl ntfss e nty fl d am oto t co l
nf ma l e ol he s r s e, nd ai if ubs que l ie
i n o mpe .
The co utc
t ' onduced a he rng o t m oton t co lon M a c 1 201 Ea le t t
t
a i n he
i o mpe
r h , 7. ri r ha
da Ca rngtn pr ded n e d i e r t y a we s whih t c t ed ast ba i ofis
y, ri o ovi
m nde ntr ogaor ns r , c he our us
he s s t

r l g .Rui g o t e o j cins i l u o a i d p h e au to o t e s sce c o t
ui s ln n h be to n i f n n-e t v lain f h af in y f he
n
e
e it g r s nss t c u t o er ld d fnd n ' o j cins a t eg t o plitfs
xsi e po e , he o r v rue ee a ts be to s o i h f an if'
n

itro ao is s san d i pa t ndo e r ldi pa t e e d n ' o j cin i r g r st fu
ner g t re ; u ti e n r a v rue n r d f n a ts b e to s n e ad o o r
o te itro ao is a s sane d fn a ts o j ci n a t f u o plitfs
f h n er g t re ; nd u ti d ee d n ' b e to s s o o r f an if'
i e r t re .Thec tdi notadd e spl i if 'i e oga o y num be s ve ee l s r,t
nt roga o is
our d
r s antfs nt n- t r
r e nt n. n ho t he
c ur gr nt d i pa ta de ed i pa pli if 'm o i t c pe .The e fe ,Ca rngt fl d
o t a e n r nd ni n rt antfs ton o om l
r a tr r i on ie
s eme a r s ns .The pl i if ha now fl t i t ntmoton s ki at ne sf s
uppl nt l e po es
antfs ve
ied he nsa
i ee ng tor y' ee

p ru n t F d rlRul o Cii P o e u e3 ()5 . ematrh sb e f l b ifd a d t
u s a t o e ea e f v l r c d r 7 a( ) Th te a e n ul ree n he
y
pa tesha a s t tt y do notr quie ahe rng.I i rpef r vi w.
ri ve dvied ha he
e r
a i t s i or e e
Di
scuss on
i

Fe ea Rue o Cii P o e u e 3 ()5 g v r t e pa me to atr y s fe a
d r l l f vl r c d r 7 a( ) o ens h y n f tone ' e s nd
e pe e i dic r dipu es W he t co t gr nt t moton t c
x ns s n s ove y s t .
n he ur ' s he
a
i o ompe, a a r i
l n wa d s

ma d tr t e so o t r ee l r td e c p insa p is ()t emo n fld amoin t
n ao y mls ne f h e nl ae x e to p le : 1 h va t ie
me
to o
co lprort a tmptngi good fih t o an t dico r wihoutc ti e ve in,(
mpe i o te i n
at o bti he s vey t
our ntr nto 2)

t n n ico l e o o j cin wa s b tn ilyj siid,o ()ohe cr l tnc sma e a
he o ds lsz r b e to s u sa tal u tfe r 3 t r icz a e k n
r
ms

a r o e p n e u j t S e Fe .R.Ci P.3 ()5 ( .I o o t t r e e c pinsi
wa d f x e s s nus. e d
v. 7 a ()A) f ne f he h e x e to s

pr s nt t co ' ( tno ' a r e ns a f s I I t moton i gr nt d i pa ta
e e , he ut G
t mus t' wa d xpe es nd ee . d. f he
i s a e n r nd

d n e i p l Ru e 3 ()5 ( al ws t e c u tt a po t n ra o a l e pe e a is
e id n at l 7 a( )C) lo h o r o p ri e s n be x ns s t t
o
dicei I ;Ba l v. r n,No.2:
s rton. d. row He ma
13CV00033,2015U. DitLEXI 25707,a *8- (
S. s.
S
t
, 9 D.

Ne Fe . 6 2 5 (Th p r dfe e c b t e Rul 3 ()5 ( a Ru e3 ()5( i
v. b 2 , 01 ) l e dma y ifr n e ewe n e 7 a( )A) nd l 7 a ()C) s
t a a a r i ds rto a yt e Rul 3 ()5( .) l tei tn matr tec u tg a t d
h t n wa d s icein r md r e 7 a( )C)' . n h nsa t te, h o r r ne
'
i pm' a de e i pa tpl i if 'm oto t c
n t nd ni d n r antfs
i n o ompe .The pl i if pr va ld o s e oft
l
antfs e ie n om
he

itro ao is t c u t usan ds meo t d fnd n ' o j cin , n t ec u t v r ldi
n er g t re ,he o r s tie o f he ee a ts be to s a d h o r o enze n
pa' a d s sane i patoh r o j ci n .Ac o dngy Rue 3 ()5 ( a p is a d i i
t n u ti d n r t e be to s c r i l , l 7 a( )C) p le , n t s
t
wihi t co tsdic e i whehe t a
t n he ur ' s r ton
t r o ppori e ns s I de e mi ng whehe a a r of
ton xpe e . n t r ni
t r n wa d
a t ne sf si a opra e t c tc i r t pur e ofRul 37:ç o a l t ditit
tor y' ee s ppr it , he our onsde s he pos
e
ç low he src
t

co t t punih de i r t nonc
urs o
s lbe a e
ompla e wih t f de a r l s ofd s ove y a t de e s h
inc t he e r l u e
i c r nd o t r uc
co uc i t f t e'Zor sv.Spe i lv I . 1 F. 1 2,1 U. App.
nd t n he u ur .' ne
c at ndus, 66 3d 21 998 S.
LEXI 31
S 686,

a * 9( t Ci.1 9 )(mp bls e )
t 2 4h r 9 8 t u ih d .

Th a lss t e Ru e 3 ()5 ( c ne ae t e e to s e u rtd i
e nay i md r l 7 a( )C) o tmplts he xc p ih n meae n
3 ()5 ( . tp e o v. fz rI c,2 4U. Dit LEXI 9 8 9 a * - ( . N. J l 9
7 a( )A) S e h ns n P ie n . 01 S. s.
S 2 5 , t 5 6 M D. C. uy ,
201 ) (Ru e 3 ( )5 ( e fciey i o rts t s b tn ie sa d r s o Rue
4 & 1 7 a()C) fe tv l nc po ae he u sa tv tn ad f l
t
3 ()5 ( .) Th r fr ,te e p ns so a ds o ey moin ma b i s d u n a p ry
7 a( )A)' . ee o e h x e e f ic v r to
'
y e mpo e po
at
o de e t pr
r r d o oduce dicove y whe e t tpa t s c
s r
r ha ry' onduc ne es iaed t moton unls o of
t c st t he
i
e s ne

t etr ee c pinsa ple . e Fe R. v. 3 ()5 ( . r ,hep risd no d s u eta
h l e x e to p is S e d. Ci P. 7 a( )A) He e t a t o t ip t h t
l
e
pl i if a t m pt t obt i t di c ve y w ihout t i e ve i o t c t l t ad,
a ntf s te ed o
a n he s o r
t
he nt r nton f he our . ns e

Ca n o ag e t tt erfiu et prvieterq se ds o ey wa s b tn ilyj tte
ni gtn r u s ha h i alr o o d h e uetd ic v r s u sa tal usi d
i
o a a r o e p ns swo l b t u t
r n wad f x e e ud e mj s.

ç p ry stsist eGu tnil j siid'sa d r ift r i ag n i d s u ea t
G a t aife h s bsa tal u tfe tn ad i hee s e une ip t s o
A
y
pr pe r s uto ori a r a o bl pe s c d t nk t tt f iur t pr
o r e ol i n
f e s na e r on oul hi ha he al e o oduce dic r i
s ove y s
c r e t t ti ,i i has a r as bl bass i lw a f t' Skv Ca e LLC v.Coly,No.
o r c , ha s f t
e ona e i n a nd ac .
'
bl .
e

51 CV0 0 8 2 5 U. Dit LEXI 1 6 9 ,a * ( . Va Aug 2 2 5 .l u t ha e
:1 0 4 , 01 S. s.
S 0 3 3 t 8 W D. . .1 , 01 ) ç rs v
co

c n ld d ta tu sa ta j siiain' c ud i cu e ma i g me i ro s o j cin t
o cu e h t s b tn il u tfc to o l n ld
kn
rt i u b e to s o
o
r que t d dic r o e n e gi i a lgii t diput overt s que ofdic r '
e s e s ove y, r ve nga ng n e tma e s e
he e nce
s ove y.
'

Ke v. ri, 6 F. D. 9 , 9 - 7( M d 2 0 ) S mial wh n d tr i n wheh ra
mp Hars 2 3 R. 2 3 2 6 9 D. . 0 9 . i lry, e ee m nig t e n
'

a r o atr y' fe wo l b u j s, h c u tlo st f t fco s ç 1 wheh rt en n
wad f tone s e s ud e n u t t e o r o k o èl a t r: 1 ) te h o r
(
c mpyig p ry a td i b d fih ( )t a u to p eudc t a n n o in ec u e t
o l n a t ce n a at , 2 he mo n f rj ie h t o c mpla c a s d he
a v ray, 3 tene d f rd tre eo t ep riulrs r o n n c mpl nc ,a ( )wh te
d es r ( ) h e o eernc f h a t a o t f o -o i e nd 4 eh r
c
a
l sd a tc s nc i woul be m o e efe tve. Ande s v.Fo
es r si a tons
d
r f ci '
'
r on
und.f Adva me .Ed &
or
nce nt uc.

Emplyto Am. n in ,1 5F.d5 0 5 4( t Ci.1 9 )
o ' f I da s 5 3 0 , 0 4h r 9 8 .
Fe ea Rul o Cii P o e l e3 ()p o i e ta apat ma p o u eb sn s rc r s
d rl e f vl r c dz 3 d r v d s h t ry y r d c u ie s e o d
r
i le ofr s nd ng t i e
n iu
e po i o nt noga o is whe t a we m a be a c rane fom s h r c ds
t re
n he ns r y
s e ti d r
uc e or .

S e Fe .R.Ci P.3 ( ) No eh ls,Rue 3 r q ie t a G a s ct to s l b i
e d
v. 3 d . n t ee s l 3 e ur s h t f q pe i in hal e n
l
ka
s fc e tde alt pe mi t i e r tng pa' t l a e a t i ntf a r a l a c n t
ufi i n t i o r t he ntroga i
ly o oc t nd o de iy, s e diy s a he
t
pa t s r e t r c dsf rwhih t a we ma be a c rane ' Se Hil d Ent r . l v.
ry e v d, he e or o
c he ns r y
s e ti d.' e lyar
e s. nc.

W arn 0i Co, . 0
re l .No 5:2CV3 9 20 3 U. Dit LEXI 2 9 2 a * ( D. C. a 31 2 0 )
2 , 0 S. s.
S 7 2 , t 4 E. N. J n. , 0 3 .
The s cfct r q rme t i 3 () 1 i d sg e t lmi t e p a tc o ç ie tn t e
pe iiiy e uie n n 3 d () s e in d o i t h rcie f ç r ci g h
d
i e r tng pa t t a m as ofbus ne s r c ds .... Fe R .Ci P.33 A d s y Com m it e'
nt r oga i
ry o
s
i s e or
' d.
'
v.
vi or
te s

N o e.Ac r ngl t r s
t
co di y, he e pondi pa t K st dut t s iy,by caego y and l aton,t
ng ry G he y o pecf
ha
t r
oc i he
r co dsf om w hi h a w e st i e r t i s c n be de i ' H il r Ent r sl ,2003 U .
e r r
c ns r o nt r oga or e a
rved.' lya d e s. nc.
S.

4

Dit LEXI 279 a *4.I m ay notsm pl die tt opposng pa t ç o a und fe e it d
s.
S
22, t
t
i y r c he
i
ry l n
t
if r nta e

ma so r c r s'Se i .(u tn Fe . Ci .P. 3 a v s r c mmitesnoe ) Th rf r ,a
s f e o d . e d q o ig d R. v 3 d ioy o te ' ts. ee o e
'
dump o t a ofdoc nt i a t ga z d m n ri nots fce .Se M i e v.W els
f hous nds
ume s n n mor nie
nne s
ufi int e nt r
l

Fa Ba k N. , 6F. D. 7 , 7 - 9( M d. 01 )
mo n e A.28 R. 2 3 2 8 7 D. 2 2 .

I t isa tmatr rigtn a g s t a i wa s b tn il j siid b c u e i
n he n tn te,Carn o r ue h t t s u sa tal u tfe e a s t
y
ra o a l b le e t a i sts dter q ie n so Rul 3 () Carngo as ag e ta i
e s n b y eiv d h t t aise h e urme t f e 3 d . ri tn lo r u s h t t
ra o a l b le e t t i p o e l ivo d Rul 3 () i rs n ig t p an if'
e s n by eiv d ha t r p ry n ke
e 3 d n epo dn o litfs
i e r t i s be a e t i e r a oresG ade br d i uie ' r uii m a doc nt t
nt rogaore c us he ntrog t i t
m
oa nq r s' eq rng ny
ume s o
( c uled t a c ran f c s s h a i nttes q n ii ,daa,aci n,t ss r s t .'SEC v.
t ons t o s e ti a t , uc s de ii , ua ttes t to e t , e uls'
be

El n e a , 0 F. D. 7 , 7 ( . N. 20 2 .Smial, e Ca rn o d dn trfr n e
t d p n 2 6 R. 5 4 5 7 M D. C. 0 ) i lry wh n rigtn i o ee e c
i
r s i doc nt ordi no r s nd t t i t roga or Ca ng on as e t t tr a ona e
e ponsve ume s
d t e po o he n e r t y, ni l
s rs ha e s bl

pes nsc u ddfe a t temeiso i o j cins
ro o l ifr s o h rt f t b e to .
s
I t i m oto t c pe ,pli if di not a s tt t Ca rngt s r la e on Rul
n her
i n o om l antfs d
s er ha r i on' e inc
e

3 ( ) wa i r p r I ta , panif ag e () ta Carngo s o j cin we e
3d
s mp o e . nse d li tfs r u d 1 h t ri tn' b e to s r
ia p o raey b iep ae ()t a Carn o si lme tto o Rue 3 ()wa i u fce t
n p r p itl olr lt , 2 h t rigtn' mpe n ain f l 3 d s ns fiin
i t tCa rngt d pe hund e ofpag ofdoc e t i t d o s iyi whe e i t
n ha r i on um d
r ds
es
um n s nsea f pecf ng
r n he

d c me t t a s r c ud b fu d, n ( )t tf rs meitrog t re , ni go ddno
o u ns he n we s o l e o n a d 3 ha o o n er ao is Ca n tn i t
pr de r e e st r s
ovi ef r nce o e pons ve doc e sordi nota w e a t t r
i
um nt
d
ns r loge he .

Upon r vi w of Ca ngt s i tal r s es i a ar t t Ca rngt pr de
e e
ni on' nii e pons , t ppe s ha
r i on ovi d
ai i f t t gores
lm nt nd he oca i ns
hos ' lm nt .
Pl ntf s wih ca e i of doc l e s a t l to of t e doc l e s For exam pl
e,
Ca ngt n die t d pl i if t r
ni o r c e a ntf s o oughl s ve y- i pa s of t r i i N ot , t t oy e nt fve ge
û v c ng
se
es' he w page
'

ç a aci Hit l 'a ove o hund e pag oft çorgi ton Fie. The c t e v
ç ns ton soy ' nd r ne
Tr
r d es he ç i na i
l'
'
our obs r es

t ti s
ha , n ome r s ns s t md ro page r f e e i sgni a i compa on t t t t l
e po e , he mbe f
s e er nc d s i t nt n
k
ds o he o a

nu eso d cl n sp o u e I s me c s s h we e ,Ca ngo r fre t b t e j s
mb r f o tme t r d c d. n o a e , o v r ni tn eerd o ewe n u t
t a a doz n page .The c tdoesno bele t e r s
wo nd
e
s
our
t ive hes e pons st be t e eg ous s tof
e o
he gr i
or

ç o l n dz 't a Rul 3 ()atmp st p e n .S e e:. Gr s e v.Au o om wr l c
ç cz t l
d me mp' h t e 3 d te t o rve t e , . , ak
ts n.
Co. 6 7 F.S p 2 1 05 1 0 ( Ne 20 9 ( r d cin o 70 d c me t wa n t
,4
u p. d 1 , 1 8 D. b. 0 ) p o u to f ,00 o u ns s o
s fiin t e 3 ( );I r Et c m I c, . 2 , 1 U. Dit LEXI 1 8 3 ,a * 3 4
u fce t md r 3 d ) n e hio n .No 23 7 20 3 S. s.
S 825 t 29
( D. .Va J y 2 ,201 )( tn t tp o uci n o o e 9 milo p g sdd n ts tsy t
S. W
. ul 6
3 noig ha r d to f v r
l n a e . i o aif he
i
s cfct rq ie n o Rue3 ().
pe iiiy e urme t f l 3 d)
Nor u
, pon r viw of t s e e alr s ns ,doe t c tfnd t t t r i a
e e
he upplm nt e po es
s he our i ha he e s
sgnii a d fe e e i t pa r nges pr de i Ca rngt s i tal r pons s a is
i fc nt if r nc n he ge a
ovi d n ri on' nii es e nd t
s e e t r pons s I t ad,t ma r i whi h t i o m a i i pr s nt d has be n
upplm n al es e . nse
he nne n
c he nf r ton s e e e
e
s t ntal c ng wih Ca rngt pr d ng ac u l r pons s i t a of r e rng t t
ubsa i ly ha ed, t
ri on ovi i
t a es e nse d
ef ri o he
docl e s pr
tm nt oduce f ma of t i t rog t i .Se Ca rngtn' Supplm e alRe ps,
d or ny
he n e r a ores e r i o s
e nt
s .
Doc t No. 54. The e s e e a r s
ke
s upplm ntl e pons s ar c itnt wih t co ts r i on
e e onsse
t he ur ' ulngs

Carn tn' o j cins Fu temo e t t ee tn tec u t r e e Carn è t rs o dwh n
ri go s b e to . rh r r, o h xe t h o r od r d rigtn o e p n e
i di notr f e e r s i doc e s t c tbele st tr as bl dii nta t ne
t d
e er nc e ponsve um nt, he our ive ha e ona e, lge tor ys

c ul h v c me t dfe e t c n l ins a t t e meis o t o j cin.Fo e n e
o d a e o o ifr n o cuso s o h
rt f he b e to
r x mpl,
Ca rngtn di not pr de a r pons f i or ton t t i bei ve t be a ia e i t
ri o d
ovi
es e or nf ma i ha t le d o
val bl n he

publc r or Se e. ,Stu he s Sci & l ' Cop .v.Gen.Foods Cor ,45 F. D.375,38
i ec d. e, g. r t r
. ntl
p.
R.
0

( D. x 1 6 )( tn ta a itro aoy c n b o j cina l o t ek o n sta i s e
S. Te . 9 8 noig h t n n er g tr a e b e to b e n h r u d h t t e ks
i o maini t publcr c d)
nf r to n he i e or .
Ca rngt a s a s r s t t i ge ne y be i ve t t pl i if ' i e r t i we e
r i on l o s e t ha t nui l
le d ha a ntf s nt r oga ores r
ove l br d.W hie t c tr cog z t t Ca rngt m a ha i pr ry us d t e c
r y oa
l he our e ni es ha r i on y ve m ope l e he xa t

6

s me ln a et o j c t e ey itro ao y Ca n o sp sto ce ry ha s me mei.
a a gu g o be t o v r n er g t r , ni gtn' o i n la l d o
i
rt
The c ur s t i d i pa ta ove ed i pa tor outi s t i many of def nda '
o t usane n r nd
nul n r
rght usaned
e nts

o j cinsf rn al h l o t itro ao is I a la to i tn e t ec u tmo i d t
b e to o e ry af f he n er g tre . n t e s ne nsa c , h o r dse he
l ngua oft i er t r t na r t s pebef r r quii Ca rngtn t a wer I s
a
ge he nt roga o y o row he co
o e e rng ri o o ns . n um,
t c tfnds t tt r was ç ge ne dipu e a t pr pe r s ut o ori a r a ona e pe s
he our i ha he e
1 nui
a
s t s o o r e ol i n
f e s bl r on

c ud ti t ttefiue . . wa jc re t' k Ca l.
o l hnk ha h al r . ( s o rc . S y b e LLC, 5U. Dit LEXI 1 6 9 ,
'
201 S. s.
S 033

a * ;Pees n v. nma ,2 7 F. D.1 ,1 ( D. 20 5 ( o igt a ap ry' a to sae
t 8 tro Ha t n 2 R. 3 6 D. C. 0 ) n tn h t a t s cin r
s bsa tal j tfe i t is ep e e td i o t a ç o l e e e ars n il dfee c
u tnil usiid f he su r sn e s ne h t ç ud ng nd r epo sbe ifrn e
y
c
o o i o n n c nsin iu ,dlg n l)b tr a o a l a vo ae . Th rf r ,t c u t
f pnin mo g o ce to s iie t, u e s n b e d c ts' eeo e he o r
).

fn st a Carn o wa s b tn ilyj si d.
id h t rigtn s u sa tal u tie
Ev n i Carn tn wa n ts bsa tal j si d t c u tb le e t a cru tnc s
e f rigo s o u tnily u tse , he o r eiv s h t ic msa e

rn e t e a r o atr y s fe nus.P irt te plitfs sln a mo in t c mpe,
e d r h wa d f tone ' e su j t ro o h anif i g
to o o l
Ca rngtn c t ndst ti pr vi d t na e ofa c por t r pr e a i t tpl i if c d
ri o on e
ha t o de he m
or a e e es nt tve ha antfs oul
de e.Thi r pr s nt tve wo d alo s e nt Ca rngt s r s
pos
s e e e ai
ul s uppl me
r i on' e pons s Pl i if do no
e . antfs
t
r butt sas e ton atd ha pr s nt d no evi nc t tCa ngt aced i ba f ih,ort t
e
hi s ri l ve e e e
de e ha ni on t n d at
ha,

gv n t ec u tse tnso o tmeb fr til ta te panif wee s b tnil p eu ie
ie h o r' xe i n f i eo e 'a, h t h li t s r u sa tal rj d c d
r
f
y
byt dico r disc te .
he s ve y f ulis
I s r ,t co ti no c
n ho t he ur s t onvi e t tCa ngt s non- om planc i t s i t e w as
nc d ha ni on'
c
i e n hi ns anc

de i r t Furhe ,pli tf s f l t obt i f l or pa talr le unde a nu be o ma tr
lbe a e. t r a n if aied o an u l
ri e if
r
m r f te s
r ied i t moton t co pe .Ac or ngl t c tdee c ts fi i t i t ntm a tr
a s n he
i o m l c di y, he our
ms os- hitng n he nsa
te

u warn e , n t rf r , l e ecs isd sr to u d rt Ru e3 ()5 ( a drq ieta
n ra td a d heeo e wil x rie t icei n n e o l 7 a ()C) n e ur h t
t pa te bea t i own c t .
he ri s r her
oss

Conc us on
l i

Fo t f r ng r a ons pl n if 'm o i f ra t ne sf swilbede e The Cl r
r he o egoi e s , aitf s ton o tor y' ee l
nid.
ek
i diec e t s nd c e of t s m e a
s r td o e
opi s
hi
mor ndum opi on a t a c
ni nd he c ompa ng or r t al
nyi
de o l
co e ofr c d.
uns l e or

DATED:Thi 48*
s

d yo y, 2017.
a fMa
Chi mt d St t Diti tJ
ef
e aes src udge

8