Collins v. Commissioner Of Social Security

Filing 22

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/26/17. (hnw)

I TH E UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI O F V I GI I
CT
R NA
CHA RLO TTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

CLERK OFFI U. DI COUU
Y
CE 3. ST.
AT M M NOKE,
VA
FI ED
L

J 2s 21
A8
27
8 '

L

.
D

ROBI COLLI S,
N
N

Ex cL
ue

TY CLERK

Ci lA c i N o. 3: 6CV 000
vi ton
1
40

Pli if
antf,
M EM O R AN D UM O PI O N
NI

CAROLYN W .COLVI Aci
N, tng
Co mi sone ofSoc a Se iy,
m si r
i l curt

By:

Hon.Gl n E.Conr d
e
a
Chi U nie St t s Di t i tJ e
ef t d a e s rc udg

D ef nt
enda .
Pl i ifha fl t s a ton c l ng ng t fna de i i n oft Com m i s one ofSoc al
a ntf s ied hi c i hale i he i l c s o
he
si r
i

Se iy de ng pl ntf c am f rs e e als c iy i omebe isunde t Soc a
curt nyi ai ifs l i o upplm nt e urt nc
neft
r he i l

Se iyAc,asa nde 42U. C.j1 1t s l urs ci oft scour i purua t 42
curt t me d,
S. 38 t ec.J iditon hi
t s s nt o
U. C.j 1 c)3) whihi or ae j205g)oft SocilSe urt Ac,42U. C.j405()
S.
383( ( , c nc ports
(
he a c iy t
S.
g.
A s r l c e by t m e o a a a gum e s it d by t pa te ,t i s be or t s
efe t d
he m r nda nd r
nt ubm te
he r i s he s ues f e hi

cour a ewhe he t Co misone ' fna de ii n i s
tr
t r he m s i rs i l c so s uppore by s t nta e de e,a i
td
ubsa i l vi nc nd f
i i not whehe pli ifhasm e t bu de ofpr faspr s rbe b a ptr ua t t Ac .
t s , t r a ntf
t he r n
oo
e c i d y nd ts nt o he t
St t d brel s t n i le de eha be n d i d a s r lva te de e,c i rngt
a e i ty, ubsa ta vi nc s e efne s uch ee n vi nc onsde i he
r co d a a w hol ,a m i htbe f
e r s
e s g
ound a qua e t s po ta c us on by a r as bl m i
de t o up r oncl i
e ona e nd.

Rihads nv.Per es 402U. 38 401( 971.
c r o
al ,
S. 9,
1 )
The pl i if Robi Coli ,w a bor on M a c 28,1
a ntf ,
n
lns s n
rh
992,a e nt ly com pl t he
nd ve ua l
e ed r

hi s hoole a i M s Coli a s c
gh c
duc ton. . lns lo omplt d a tona tani asa n s sas itnt She
e e ddii l r i ng
ure' ssa .
hasbeen em pl
oyed asa nurs s ass s ant r t
e' i t , esaurantw or and busgi . She l tw or on a
ker,
rl
as
ked

r a and s t i d ba i i 201
egul r
us a ne s s n
2.O n J y 1 201 pl ntf fl d an a i a i f
ul 6, 2, ai i f ie
pplc ton or
s e e a s urt i om e be i s M s Coli a l ge t ts be a e di a e f a l
uppl m nt l ec iy nc
nett . . lns le d ha he c m
s bl d or l

f r o s bsa t l an ul mp o me to Ap i 1 2 2 d et j e ier e mao datrts
o ms f u tni g if e ly n n rl , 01 , u o uv n l h u ti rh ii.
a
( 21l .Shenow manti t ts ha rmane dia edt t pr e tme.
TR )
i ans ha he s e i d s bl o he esnt i
M s Coli 'c ai w a de ed upon i ta c i e a i n a r c i r ton. She t n
. lns l m s ni
nii l ons d r to nd e onsde a i
he

rqueseda rc ve a7:novoheai a rviw beor a Admi sr tveLa J .I a
e t nd e ei d .
rng nd e e f e n
nitai w udge n n
o ni d t d J nua y 1 201 t La J
pi on a e a r 6, 5, he w udgea s de e m i d t tpl ntf i no dia e The
lo t r ne ha ai if s t s bl d.

Law J f t tM s Coli s fr fom oseoa t oss ( 25) Be aus oft s
udge ound ha . lns ufes r
t rhr i, TR . c e hi
c ton,t La J ger e t tpli ifi dia e f he pa tr e ntwor aci t (
ondii he w ud uld ha antf s sbld or r s elva
k tviy. TR
Howe r t La J e dee m i d t tM s Coli r t i s fce f tona c pa t
ve ,he w udg tr ne ha . lns e ans ufi int unc i l a ciy

fralmiedrngeoflgh wor aci t ( 27)
o i t a
i t k tviy. TR .TheLa J a s se Ms Coli '
w udge s e sd . lns
r s dua f tonalc pa iy asf l
e i l unc i
a ct
olows:

Afe c r f c i r ton oft e ier or t unde sgne fndst tt
tr a e ul onsde a i
he ntr ec d, he
r i d i ha he
cl i a hast r s dualf nctonalca c t t pe f nn lg wor asdefne i
a m nt
he e i
u i
pa iy o r o i ht k
i d n

20 CFR 41 967( e ep s c nsa a / wal f furholr i aneght
6. b) xc t he a tnd ndor k or o
zs n i hourw or y;c n stf f rhour i a e gh kda a i or ou
s n n i t hourwor y;c n oc s ona l
kda a ca i ly
pus pul wih he lf a a l g;c n occ sona l clm br mpsa sais c n
h/ l t r e t nn nd e a
a i ly i a
nd t r ; a
ne rc i l r ,r , s afol ; n oc asonal ba a e,
ve lmb adde s opes or c f ds ca c i ly l nc knee , r uch,
lc o
a c a l ca f e nty soop;s d avoi c enta e e
nd r w ; n r que l t
houl
d onc r t d xpos e t e r m e
ur o xte
c d a he t vi a i ,f s odor , t,ga e , nd poorve ia i a
ol nd a , br tons ume ,
s duss s s a
ntlton; nd
s d a d ha r ,i l ngm a hi r a hei s
houl voi za ds ncudi
c ney nd ght.

( 27) Gi s h arsdua f tonalc pact a afe c i rngpli ifsa
TR . ven uc e i l unci
a iy, nd tr onsdei antf ge,
e
duca i a prorw o k expe i nce asw e la t s i o f om a voca i le r , he La
ton, nd i
r
re ,
l s e tm ny r
tona xpe t t
w
J
udge f
ound t tM s Coli r t ns s fci ntf tona c pa iy t pe f nu s ve als ii
ha
. lns e ai uf i e unc i l a c t o r o
e r pec fc

lg wokr e e si i sgnii ntnumbe i t nai e onomy.TR 3 33 .
iht r ols xitng n i fca
r n he tonal c
( 2- )
A cc di y,t La J ge uli a el c l ed t tM s Coli i notdi a ed, t ts i
or ngl he w ud
tm t y onc ud ha
. lns s
s bl and ha he s

no e ildt apei ofdia lt ors plme als c iyi
t ntte o rod
sbiiy up e nt e urt ncomebeneks ( 33 .See
t . TR )
ce ,20C. R.jj41 9 ( .TheLa J
n.
F.
6.20g)
w udge' o ni wa a edast tnalde sonof
s pi on s dopt
he i
cii

t Commisone byt SocalSe urt Admi srton'Appe l Counci.( 14) Ha ng
he
s i r he i c iy
nitai s
as
l TR - . vi
e us e a lava l bl a i s r tve r m edi s M s Coli ha no a
xha t d 1 ia e dm nit a i e
e , . lns s w ppea ed t t sc t
l o hi our .

W hiepli ifmaybe diabld f c ran f
l antf
s e or e ti onnsofe oy e ,t c ucilf c ua
mpl m nt he r a a t l
dee m i ton i whehe pli ifwa diabld f a lf msofs t ntalganf e o e .
tr na i s t r antf s s e or 1 or
ubsa i i ul mpl ym nt

Se 42U. C.j1 () Theeaef ree nt ofpr fwhihmus bec i r di ma ng
e
S.
382ca . r r ou lme s oo c
t onsdee n ki

s c a a ay i.Th s ee nt aes mma ie a f lo :( )o j cieme ia fcsa d
u h n n lss e e lme s r u rz d s o lws 1 b e tv dc l a t n

ciia fn ig ; 2 teo iin a dc n lso so te tn p y iin ' 3 s b e tv e ie c
l c l i dn s ( ) h pno s n o cu in f r ai g h sca s ( ) u j cie vd n e
n
,
ofphysc manie ttonsofi nne s asdesrbedt oug acli n ' t tmony' nd (
ial fsai
mpai nt,
ci hr h ama ts esi
, 4)
a
t c a m a ' e a i voc i
he l i nt s duc ton, atonalhi t y,r s dua s ls a a V ie v.Fi h, F.
sor e i l kil , nd ge. t k
nc 438 2d

11 11 60( hCi.1 ) Undewoodv.Ri c f 298F. 850,851( hCi.1 2)
57, 59- 4t r 971; r
biof,
2d
4t r 96 .
Afe ar viw oft r c d i t sca e t cou ti una et c l t t
tr e e
he e or n hi s , he r s bl o onc ude hat he
Com m i s one ' fnalde i i n i s
s i rs i
c s o s uppored by s bs a i le de e.W hie t La J
t
u t nta vi nc
l he w udge
c a t rze pl i t f ss ve e i pa r e a os e r hr i , he e i no quesi bu t tM s
har c e i d a n if e r m im nt s t oa t os s t r s
ton t ha
.

Co l ss fr fo j v n l o s t h u t i atrtswihhd a ntss p u aia S eas
li ufes r m u e ie n e r e maod rh ii t irde ii u p rtv . h lo
n
e ince d e son a a ey. n c udi t tpli ifr t i s fc e physc
xpere s epr s i nd nxi t lI oncl ng ha antf e ans ufi i nt
ial
c c t f ra lm ied r nge oflg wor a tviy, he La J
apa iy o i t a
i ht k c i t t
w udge r le prm a iy on r por s fom
e i d i rl
e t r
none i ng s a e age y ph i a ,a a di a lt e ua i f om a phys c t a s a
xam ni t t
nc ys ci ns nd
s biiy val ton r
i al her pi t nd
oc pa i lt a s . H oweve ,t m e ca r o d i l
cu tona her pi t
r he di l ec r nc udesr por s fom t e m e c l
e t r hr e di a
s c als sw ho a t l e m i M s Coli ,i l ng D r Om Sa a r y,Dr W ila C.
pe i i t
c ualy xa ned . lns nc udi
.
m nt a
. li m

1W hiet La J
l he w udger ed t tpl ntf semotonalpr emsar notse e, M s Coli ar
ul ha ai if'
i
obl
e
ver
. lns gues
on appealt tt r cor cl l esabls t herdepr s on and anxi y afecthercapaciy f wor
ha he e d eary t ihes hat
es i
et f
t or k
ac i t l
tviy. nasmuch ast cour belevest pl ntf hasesabls t he physialpr em sr
he
t i
hat ai if
t i hed hat r
c obl
enderher
di abl f al susai wor aç i t t courtfnds i unnecess r t consdert i er a of M s
s ed or l t ned
k tviy, he
i t
ay o
i he nt ply
.
Coli 'em otonaldifculi
lns
i
fi tes.

Andr ws a Dr Gr gor Pudhor ky.Al t r s i it de em i t tpli ifi
e , nd . e y
ods
1 h ee pecalss t r ned ha antf s
s ve e y i pa r d,a una e t e ge i r gul rw or a tviy on a s t ne bas s G i n t
e r l m i e nd bl o nga n e a
k ci t
us ai d i . ve he
a i sr tve r gul tons asw e la t gove i c s l w ,t c ti una e t co l t t
dm ni ta i e a i ,
l s he
m ng a e a he our s bl o nc ude ha

t La J
he w udge' r la onno xn i ng medials c , t nons e ince
ne m ni
c our es and he
medials ur e ,i
c o cs s
s
uppore by s tntale de e.Bas d on t r t fo t t e m e c s c ait who
td
ubsa i vi nc
e
he epors r m he hr e dial pe i lss
a t lyexa ne M s Coli ,t cou'i c taned t c l t tpl ntf ha m e t
c ual
mi d . lns he l s onsr i o onc ude ha ai if s t he
t
bur n ofpr i esa ihi t ts i t al dia e f ralf nnsofs tnta ganf
de
oof n t bls ng ha he s ot ly s bl d o l o
ubsa il i ul
e pl ym e .
m o nt

Dr Om Sa nta e m i d M s Coli on J ne29,201 a t be toft sa e
.
ma r y xa ne
. lns u
3, t he hes he tt

ds blt a e y.Dr S ma ta rpo tdt t li tf c n e ah soyo j v ni r e maod
ia ii g nc
y
. a nr y e re ha panif a i s itr f u e l h u t i
e
a t ii a s a ed wih l thi pa n f rm a y a s a t ts hasbe t ki s e oi f
r hrts s oci t
t ef p i o
ny e r , nd ha he
en a ng t r ds or

te t ntofhe c ton.( 41 .Dr Sa nta lse hi i esi a f to
r ame
r ondii TR 6) . ma ry itd s mpr son nd uncinal
as e s e a f l s
s s m nt s olow :
I PRESSI :
M
ON
J nie r um at d a t ii r ol ng a hi deg ne a i n,l f - i d
uve l he
oi rhrts es vi nd p e r to e ts de
wih pai a s iton i t l
t n s oca i n he umba r gi a a s rg wrs pan.
r e on, nd lo i ht it i
Pa i nts pr
te ' ognos slke y w e knes s c
i i l a
s e onda y t pa n o t l ts de.
r o i n he ef i
Cr di lt i good.
e biiy s
FUN CTI AL ASSESSM EN T:
ON
The num be ofho st c ai a c n sa i a e ghthourw or y i l s t
r
ur he l m nt a t nd n n i kda s es han
t ho s Thenu be ofhour t c amantc n wa k i a e ghthourwo kda
wo ur .
m r
s he l i
a
l n n i r y
ia
s boutt o hour .The num berofhour t c a m a ca s ti a ut2 hour .The
w
s
s he l i nt n i s bo
s
am ot tofw e g t cl i a c n c r y i 20 pounds
m
i ht he a m nt a a r s
.

( 41 .
TR 8)

4

Dr Gr gor Pudhor kyi aboa d c riid i e itandboa d c rii r uma ol s
. e y
ods s
r e tfe nt m s
r e tfed he t ogit
a t U ni r iy ofV igi a M edi alCe er r Pud ods s w M s Coli on s ve al
t he ve s t
r ni
c
nt .D . hor ky a
. lns
e r
oc as o beg nni i 201 a t r ques ofa t rr um a ol gi t On J y 21 201 Dr
c i ns i ng n
4, t he e
t no he he t o s .
ul , 4, .
Pudhor ky s m a i e pl ntf shi t r asf l w s
ods um r z d ai i f s o y olo :

Shec tnuest ha anumberofmus ul keea s oms Thehi i amaor
oni
o ve
c os ltl ympt .
ps j
pr bl m asi w a t l ttm e t
o e
t s he as i hough i wasnotbr
t
oughtup s t ous y by he .
pon ane l
r
The rghtw r s as s i r ghthand dom i
i
i t he s i
nanti di i She i w earng a br
s sablng.
s
i
ace
f il c t nty butha ng pr e s w ih f tona iy pa tc a l i pa e i
a ry onsa l
vi
obl m
t unc i lt ri ul ry n r ntng
he t e da t r Shealo f el t ts ha l tf le e i a lf ebow
r oddlr ugh e .
s e s ha he s os ul xt nson e t l
pa tcul ry i t m or ng buti w or 0uts e
r i a l n he
ni
t ks
om whata t d goeson a s
s he ay
nd he
al o ha pai on t m e a a pe toft kne She hasnotno i d a s e lng
s s n
he di l s c
he e.
tce ny w li
a t pai i w ih w a ki H e s if s l tng g por i oft m o ni
nd he n s t
l ng. r tf nes asi ood ton he r ng.

Shehasnotha a t pe i o he c tcose oi whi h r mai d a 1
d ny a rng f r ori t r ds c e ne t 0

mil rmst c ad y. etk st i i c nu cinwi Cee r x2 0
li a wie a Sh a e hs n o j n to t lb e 0
g
h
m ilgr m s t ce a da Ge a l t e atng t dr s t
li a wi
y. ner ly ol r i he ug hough s i s
he s howi
ng
s e c hi oi f a ur st a e N o hype gl e i s m p om a ol by hi t y.
om us ng d e t e he r a.
r yc m c y t t ogy
s or
She di notfnd t g ba ntn he pf c d a i addii a 200 m ilgr m s
d
i he a pe i l ul ol nd n
ton t
li a
m ade he f eli ta 't f l i da
r e t r nge' he olow ng y
s
Be n a fve w ih a e i ve e a s e nts e ha a y m e rc,
ga t i
t nkl nvol m nt nd ubs que om w t s m t i
pr dom i t l l ts de i vem e ofkne s hi a w rs s Folowed by D r
e
na e y ef i nvol
nt
e , p nd it . l
.
Fr nk Saul bur ofpedi ti r um a ol a U VA a hasbee o a ga utof
a
s y
a r c he t ogy t
nd
n n
m
a nt i l i M TX,a t o i ,e ela mos r e l Humia whi h wa
ge s ncud ng
zahi prne nbr nd
t ec nty
r
c
s
dic i d afe e s o s ptc s k i Aprli M J Hasbee f l we i
s ontnue tr piode f e i hoc n
i n H.
n olo d n
a tr um a ol y b Dr J ne Le i f a
dul he t og y . a t w s or boutt e ye s
hr e ar .

La a notd bel wih nonna APR,t m ont of Hum iaa tre s of
bs s e
ow t
l
wo
hs f
r fe piode
s ps s
e i.

( 8 .Folowi aviiwihpli ifonSe e r8, 4, .Pud r ds rfredMs.
TR 33) l ng st t antf
ptmbe 201 Dr ho o ky eer
C oli t t or ho e c s ge y uni a t U ni st ofV igi a M e ca Ce e , or
lns o he t pa di ur r
t t he ver iy
r ni
di l nt r f

consdeai ofalf hi rplce nt ( 840)
i rton
et p e a me . TR
.

Dr Pudhor kycomplt d a a t ii m e c s c sa e nton Se e be 9,201
.
ods
e e n rhrts dial our e tt me
ptm r
4.
Dr Pudhor ky c imedt tpli ifsphysc c ton c us a le i lc
.
ods onfr
ha antf
ial ondii a es n smotona ompone .'
nt'

( 68 .Hedesrbe t pai i M s Coli 'l thi asû i fc nt' ( 688) The
TR 8)
ci d he n n . lns ef p i gniia . TR
s
'
.
r um a ol i topi d t tpl i ifw oul be una e t stf m or t n a houra a tm e,a
he t og s ne ha a ntf
d
bl o i or e ha n
t i
nd

t ts woul beuna et sa f mor t na
ha he
d
bl o tnd or e ha bout1 mi es ( 689) Henotdt ts
5 nut . TR
.
e ha he
wo d bet ft s 'f a t20% ofa a r g wo k da a t ts wa c pa eofno mor
ul
l a k' or bou
of
n ve a e r y, nd ha he s a bl
e

t nl sr swor ( 691.
ha ow tes k. TR )
Dr W ila C.Andr w s J . a or hopa di s ge c pl t d a i epe ntm e c l
. li m
e , r , n t e c ur on, om e e n nd nde
di a
eva ua i on N ove be 5,201 Dr A nd ew sls e hi phy i lfndi asf l s
l ton
m r
4. . r
i t d s s ca i ngs olow :

On physc le m i ton,s ha s ver lm iai ofm o i i he lf hi a i
ia xa na i he s e e i t ton
ton n r e t p nd s
e e naly r a e a ut20 d e s Sheha a poora c ofm oton a s gnii a
xt r l ot t d bo
egr e .
s
r
i nd i f c nt
pa n wih m oto He rghthi i e nal r a e t 0 a haspa n a t e
i t
i n. r i
p ntr ly ott s o nd
i t he nd
poi
nt.
She hasa no m a e m i ton o herc r ca a t r i s ne
r l xa na i f
e vi l nd ho ac c pi .

Sheabducsa f wa d fe t 11 deg ee wih t rg s ul ra 13
t nd or r l xes o 0 r s t he i ht ho de nd 0
deg e s wih t l f . She haspai wih e r m e ofm oton.
r e t he e t
n t xt e s
i
She haspa n i he 1 ba wih lm ie fe on a e e i N e tve
i n r ow ck t i t d l xi nd xt ns on. ga i
s r i l r i e.
ta ght eg a s
l he l h kne s hasr t o t l r c e t nc butno sgnii a de onniy.
n re
e, he
e r pa ela r pia e,
i f c nt f t
She hasa nor a ne ol i a vas ul re m i ton.
m l ur og c nd c a xa na i

He rghtwrs s pal rte st 1 de e a dor ilxe t 0 de e . She
ri
it he ma l xe o 0 gr es nd sfe s o
gr es
ha poor s na i a pr ton a ve y w e g i s r ngt H e l l e bo ,
s
upi ton nd ona i nd r ak rp t e h. r ef l w
asnot a
ed bove hasm ode a e lm ia i ofm oto a s has s g fc nt
,
r t i t ton
i n nd he
i ni i a
wea s .She hasdifc t g ti he l f ha o rhe d bec us ofa
kne s
f i uly e tng r e t nd ve a
a e
com bi i ofs derel
naton houl
bow lm iaton ofm oton.
i ti
i
H ergai i awkw ar w ih l ofr aton ofherhi and t s w al i a ver
ts
d t ack ot i
ps
hen he ks n
y
hali sl gai pater
tng, ow t t n.

( 711.Dr Andrwss te t f l ngoveala s s nt
TR ) . e ubmitd he olowi
rl sesme :
M s Coli ha s ve e m uli a tc a r um a oi a t ii . She i t a l
. lns s e r
t- ri ul r he t d r hrts
s ot ly
i a bl ofdoi wor e n i a s de a y l ve .The r as f r t sa e t
nc pa e
ng
k ve n e nt r e l
e ons o hi r he
f l i
olow ng:
She c nnotstf m or t n 30 t 40 m i e a a tm e w ihoutpai She
a
i or e ha
o
nut s t i
t
n.
doe ha de
s ve gene a i di c di e e i he l ba s ne s c
r tve s s as n r um r pi e onda y t he
r o r
r um a oi a t ii a sgni i a sr i on he ba be a e ofhe ve y
he t d r hrts nd i fc nt t a n
r ck c us
r r
poormoton i bot hi . Shec nnotwa k f mor t 30 mi e a a
i n h ps
a
l or e han
nut s t
tm e ors a f m or t n 30 m i e a a tm e be a e ofhers ve e
i
t nd or e ha
nut s t i
c us
e r
lm iato ofm o i ofhe hi , i f c ntpai w ih he hi and
i t in
ton
r ps s gnii a
n t r ps
lm ia i ofm oton i t r s ofhe kne on t l f .
i t ton
i n em
r e he e t

g 1 S eha po ra it t g t e lf h n wh r s en e si i as a e
2 . h s o bl y o e h r e t a d ee h e d t n p c
i
be a eofpoormoton oft lf s de a el
c us
i
he e4 houl r nd bow. Sheha e n
s ve
poor lm iaton on t rghtw ih he s ve e lm iaton ofm oton i t
er i t i
he i
t re r i ti
i n he
w r s c us ng he lm iatonsw ih s na i a pr ton a
it a i
ri t i
t upi ton nd ona i nd
dor il xi n a pa m arfe o
sf e o nd l
l xi n.

Th c mbn to wo l ma ehe ic pa l o wo kn i a ys d na yj b
e o iain ud k r n a be f r ig n n e e tr o
w he e s had t s tf l nge t n 45 m i e a a tm e,bu alo w he e s had
r he
o i or o r ha
nut s t i
t s
r he
t us he ha f r r ttve m oton.
o e r nds o epe ii
i

He hp a dk e a dba kp o lmsp e ld h rfo wo kn i a yj bt a
r i n n e n c r be rcu e e r m r ig n n o h t
r r s s a ng, a ki ca ng,lfi s oopi orbe ng.
equie t ndi w l ng, nyi i tng, t ng
ndi

l es e et r i no ca ct t tlc denvii he bei c pa eofwor ng
n s nc he e s
pa iy ha oul
son r ng a bl
ki
w ih t s ve e lm ia i nst ts ha a ba e on t e he s t ton w ilonl
t he e r i t t o ha he s nd s d
hes r iua i
l y
w or en he c pac t f w o k a i pen nc i ac i te ofdaiy lvi w il
s
r a iy or r nd nde de e n tvii s
l i ng l
de e s Shehasar a be n t Charo t vil t t k a
cr a e.
le dy e o
ltes le o al boutt a hi
otl p
r plc m e a t r i ce t nl t pos i lt t ts wilne at a hi a a
e a e nt nd he e s rai y he sbiiy ha he l ed ot l p t
ver young age.
y

( 711- 2)
TR
71 .
The c tr adst r pors ofDr Sa a r y,Dr Pudhor ky,a D r Andr w st
our e
he e t
. m nta
.
ods
nd .
e o
i ca e t tM s Coli i s m pl una e t pe f m a w o k r e on a r gul ra s t i d
ndi t ha
. lns s i y bl o r or ny r ol
e a nd us a ne
basi Al t
s. l hree m edi s alst per
cal peci i s sonaly exam i M s.Coli i conductng t r
l
ned
lns n
i hei

e l ato . Eac phys c a not d phy i lm a f t i s ppor i ofa fndi ofdi a i
va u i ns
h
i in e
s ca niesatons u
tve
i ng
s blng

physc lmiai Bo h Dr Pudhor ky a Dr Andr wsr pore t tM s Coli wasbe ng
ial i t ton. t .
ods nd .
e e td ha . lns
i
e ua e f a t t ll f hi r pl e e . I s t i t co tsvi w , he ove w he m i w e g
val t d or o a e t p e ac m nt n hor , n he ur ' e t
r l ng i ht
oft m edi a e denc s ppo t t noton t tpl i if sr
he
c l vi e u r s he i ha a ntf ' heum a oi a t ii hasnow
t d rhrt s
pr gr s d t a di a i l ve ofs ve iy.
o es e o
s blng e l e r t

Asno e a
t d bove, n tndi r sdualf nci nalc pa iy f c ti lghtwor r e ,he
i i ng e i
u to
a ct or era n i
k ol s t
A dm i s r tve La J
nit a i
w udge r le on r pors f om t o none m i ng s a e a nc phys c a ,a
e id
e t r w
xa ni t t ge y
i i ns s

wela af n to a c p cte e au to c mpltdj ityb ap y ia te a it n a
l s u cin l a a i s v lain o ee on l y h sc lh r ps a d n
i
oc upa i na t r pi t D r J e D uc a la Dr W ila A m osc
c t o l he a s . . os ph
kw l nd . li m
onduc e r co d r vi w s
td e r e e
on be foft s a e di a lt ag y.Bot ph i i ns o ne t tpl ntf r t ns s fci nt
hal he t t s biiy enc
h ys c a pi d ha ai i f e ai uf i e

f tona ca ciy f lg e ri Howe r t c tnot t tbot physcinsc
unci l pa t or i ht xe ton.
ve , he our es ha h
i a onduc e
td
t i r c d r vi w sbe or r c i toft m e ca s r s a em e f om Dr Pudhor ky, he
he r e or e e
f e e ep
he di l ou ce t t nt r
.
ods t

bo d c rii r uma ol s, nd t media e l ton ofDr Andr ws t orho e c
ar e tfed he t ogit a he
c l vauai
.
e , he t pa di
s ge Asf rt f tona c pa t e uai n, hec ta i not t tt sudywasnot
ur on.
o he unc i l a ciy val to t our gan es ha he t
per or e by a m e c s r e, w e e t r s t va i t d by t t e tng r um a ol i t
f m d
di al ou c nor r he e uls lda e
he r a i he t og s ,
w ho co m i sone t e ua i
m s i d he val ton.
W hie t A dm i s r tve Law J
l he
ni ta i
udge de e m i t gi t ea w e ght't t f tona
t r ned o ve l t i ' o he unc i l
gr

ca ctesevauai ( 29)t c tssmpl una et c l et ts h a e l tonb
pa ii
l ton TR ,he our i i y bl o oncud ha uc n vauai y
non- e ca s tc i e il d t c r lngwe g . l i wel s tld t t whienotcon r lng
m di l otr es s ntte o ontoli
i ht t s l ete ha , l
toli
orbi ng upon t Co misone ,her porsa opi onsfom teai a e
ndi
he m s i r t e t nd ni r r tng nd xami ng
ni
phys c ans s d be ac or d g e t rw e ghti a di a lt e l ton t n t e ofnonii
houl
c de r a e i n
s biiy va ua i ha hos
e m i ng ph i a ,unl st t e tng phys c a 'r po t a e be e tofa addii l
xa ni
ysci ns es he r a i
i i ns e r s r r f
ny
tona

s
uppori evi nc J onv.Banha t43 F. 650,65 ( hCi. ) Huntrv.Suli
tng de e. ohns
r r, 4 3d
4 4t r 2005 ' e
,
lvan,
8

993F. 31 35( hCi.1 2) Ca
2d , 4t r 99 4 mpbelv.
l Bowen,800F. 1 1 ( hCi.1 ) The
2d 247, 250 4t r 986 .
smeprncpa i e
a
i i l s mbodi i t go r nga nitai rgultons Und 20C. R.j
ed n he ve ni dmi srtve e ai . er
F.

416. ()1 ,ti e iil pr de t tge r l mor weg wilbegi nt t opi on
927 d () i s xplcty ovi d ha, nealy, e iht l
ve o he ni
ofame c ls cewhohasa lye mi dt cli nt M orove , C. R.j
dia our
dual xa ne he ama . e r 20 F.
41 9 * 4 die t t ,ge r l mor weghts dbegve t opi onsfom ateai
6.274 2) r cs hat nealy, e i houl
i n o ni r
r tng
s c snc s h apr es i i m or lkey t pr de adeaie l t na pi t e oft
our e, i e uc
of sonal s e i l o ovi
t ld, ongiudi l cur
he

cama ' me ca i ime t a lmiains Fi ly, er20C. R.j41 927( ( ,i i
li nts di lmpar n s nd i tto . nal und
F.
6. d)5) t s
not d t tm or w e g i pr ry a cor d t t o ni ofa s c a i ta
e ha
e i ht s ope l c de o he pi on
pe i ls boutm e ca i s s
di l s ue
r a e t t a e ofs i lt
el t d o he r a pec a iy.
I t i t ntc s ,ofa 1t phys c a who ha r nde e o ni ns i w o d s e t t
n he ns a a e
1 he
i i ns
ve e r d pi o , t ul e m ha

onl Dr Pudhor ky ha te t d M s Coli on mor t n oneoc aso Dr Pudhor ky i a
y .
ods
s rae
. lns
e ha
c i n. .
ods s
boa d ce tfe r uma ol it Hi as e s e stnd s
r rii d he t og s. s s s m nt i uppor i t e e l tonsofDr Sama r y
t n h vaua i
.
nta
a Dr And ews Dr Sa a r y e
nd . r . . m nta xami M s Coli a t be s oft sat diabiiy
ned . lns t he he t he t e s lt
a nc A l t e phys c a s it d ph i las e s e s whi h i c t t tM s. lns i
ge y. l hr e
i i ns ubm t e ysca s s m nt
c ndi a e ha
Coli s

c r nty una et wo k on a r gulra s ti d ba i, t
ure l
bl o r
e a nd usa ne ss wihoutt ng uns dul br a .
aki
che ed e ks
Thevoc tona ex r t siid t t e f c t tt ne t t keextabr kswoul pr cude
a i l pe t e tfe o he fe t ha he ed o a
r ea
d el

rgul.emplyme .( 7172) Thus t c tc l st tM s Coli hasme t bur n
e ar o nt TR - .
,he our oncude ha . lns
the de
i esabls ngdia lt f ralf
n t ihi
s biiy o l onnsofs t nta ga nf e o
ubsa i l i ul mpl yment asa l e i he
, leg d n r
a ia i f s pplm e a s urt i m ebe ks
pplc ton or u e ntl ec iy nco
net .
Fort r s sae t c ti c tai d t co l t tt Comm isone ' fna
he ea ons t td, he our s onsr ne o ncude ha he
si rs i l

d cso i n t u po tdb s bsa ta e i e c .Dee d n ' mo inf r u r j d me t s
e iin s o s p re y u tnil v d n e fn a ts to o s mmay u g n mu t
t r or bede e U pon t fndi t tpl ntf ha m e t bur n ofpr aspr c i d by a
he ef e
ni d.
he i ng ha ai if s t he de
oof
es r be
nd
9

puruantt t Ac i e t bls ng dia lt f a lf ms ofs t nta ga nf e oyme ,
s
o he t n sa ihi
s biiy or l or
ubsa il i ul mpl
nt

j d me twilb e trd i fv ro t epanif Th Co sin rsfn ld cso d n i
u g n l e nee n a o f h litf. e mmiso e ' ia e iin e yng
s e en al e urt i om e be ft w il r ve s d t t e en t tt de a w asbas d ont
uppl m t s c iy nc
ne is l be e r e o he xt t ha he ni l
e
he
fndi t t pl i if i not di a ed. How e r snc t C o m i s one ha a r nty not
i ng ha a ntf s
s bl
ve , i e he m s i x s ppa e l

c i r whehe pl i ifm e t t fna i ei i lt r quie nt unde t SSlBe ft
onsde ed
t r antf e s he i ncal lgbiiy e r me s
r he
nei
Pr gr t c ur mus r ma t c s t t Co mi sone f a a opra ede e mi to A
o am, he o t t e nd he a e o he m s i r or n ppr it t r nai n.
J m e a Or ri c onniy wilbeen e e t sday.
udg nt nd de n onf t l
t r d hi
The Cl r i diec e t s nd c r ii d c esoft sM e o a
e k s r t d o e e tfe opi
hi m r ndum Opi on t a l uns lof
ni o 1 co e

r c d.
e or
Da -so : s
r
Thi

44

d yo-a u r, 2017.
a fln ay

Chi fU t d St t D it i J
e
e a es s rct udge

10