Newton et al v. Beneficial Financial I, Inc. et al

Filing 45

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/6/17. (hnw)

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I N I
CT
RGI A
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON

CL S OFFI U.S. SX COUJF
ERK'
CE
DI
ATRM NOKE,
VA
FI
LD

AFR pC 2 1
27
JUL
BY;

TON I W OO D SON N EW TON , e a .
A
t 1,

Du L

ct
aax
z

CL
ERK

Pl i if ,
antf s

Ci lAci n No. 1
vi to
3: 6CV00058
M EM O RANDUM OPI ON
NI

BENEFI AL FI
CI
NANCI 1 I ,e a .
AL , NC. t 1,

By:Hon.Gl n E.Co a
e
m'd
Chi Unie St t sDititJ
ef t d a e src udge

De e
f ndant.
s
Toni W oods Ne on,M i ha lEa l W oods n,a Do l Le sW oods n,J .fld
a
on wt
c e ry
o nd nad wi
o r ie

t i a to a ans Be eiil Fia il 1 Ic (ç neiil' a Di c Fi n il LLC
hs cin g i t n fca n nca , n . C fca' nd t h na ca,
Be
)
e
(Di c '. Th c s i p e e ty b fr te c ur o t d fnd n s moin t ds s . Th
ç t h'
$ e ) e a e s r s nl e o e h o t n he ee a t' to s o imis e
c thed a hea i o t m o i on M a c 31 201 Fort r as s tf t beow,t
our l
zng n he tons
r h , 7.
he e ons e orh l
he
m otonswilbede e
i
l
ni d.
B ackzround

The f l w i f c s t ke f o t pl i if ' s cond n e d c pl i ,a e ac e e
olo ng a t , a n r m he a ntf s e
m nde om a nt r c pt d
a t'e f pur e oft def nda s'm o i t di m i s. Se Er c on v. r ,551 U . 8
s l or pos s he e nt
u
tons o s s
e i ks
Pa dus
S. 9,

9 (0 7 (g j e n l g o ad fn a tsmoi nt ds s, j d emu ta c p a tu a1 f
4 2 0 ) % W h n zi n ee d n ' to o imis a u g s c e t s l e 1 o
t
n
'
t fcu l le ain c n an di tec mpan .)
he a ta alg to s o tie n h o lit'.
'
On J nua y 26,20 t lt J t F. oods n, hepli tfs m o he ,ob a ne ahome
a r
05, he a e udih W
o t
a n if ' t r t i d

morgagel n (he( rtLoa ' fom Benei a M o t ge Compan ofVigi a f pr pe t
t
oa t ç s n' r
Fi
)
fcil rga
y
r ni or o ry

lc td a 1 6 Re HilRo d i Go d ns il, r ii (heG o e t' Th Fis Lo n wa
o ae t 9 7 d l a n r o v l Vign a t t p ry). e rt a s
e
pr
e de e by a l n r pa e a s urt Ag ee e a s ur d by a de d of t s on t
vi nc d
oa e ym nt nd ec iy r m nt nd ec e
e
nlt
he

Pr p ly ( C rtDe do Tr s'.
o e' t ç s e f u t)
t he Fi
'

On M a c 30,2006,M s W oods o ane ahom eeq t lneofc e tfom Be fc a
rh
.
on bt i d
uiy i
r di r
ne ii l

Dic u t mpa yo Vigna(h ç n o Crdf) Th Li o Crdtwa s c rdb sc nd
s o n Co n f r ii t e ç e f e i . e ne f e i s e u e y e o
Li
d e o tu to t ePr p ry(h G e o dDe do Tr s'.
e d f r s n h o et t e s c n e f u t)
s
'
De e nt Be sca s e ded t t i e e t of Be fc a M orga Com pa of
f nda
ne il ucc e
o he nt r ss
ne i i l
t ge
ny
Vigi a a Be fc a Di c unt Co ny. Se r l yea s lt r a or ng t t pli if ,
r ni nd ne i l s o
mpa
ve a
r ae , cc di o he antfs
Be
nefc a ca e ld ordi c r d t Li ofCr di de .
i l nc le
s ha ge he ne
e t bt

Fo tx y a 201 Be eiilfld wi te I tr a Re e e S r ie (ç ' a F nn
r a e r 2, n fca ie t h ne n l v nu e vc 6RS' o
h
I )
1 9 - ( $ 0 - F r '.The1 9 - Fo t ld Q n elto o De t'lse Be fca
0 9 C t 1 99C o m'
he 1
)
0 9 C nn,i e s c lain f b ' itd neiil
t ca
ast c edt a M s W oods a t de t .2d Am .
he r ior nd .
on s he b or
Compl Ex. Doc tN o.35- a 20.I
. D, ke
1 t
t
alo r f r nce t a ot num be f t Li of Cr ta i ntfe t I ot ofDe
s e e e d he cc mt
r or he ne
edi nd de iid he l
Am mt
bt

Dic r ed'as$30,49. is Be iils n M s W oods aco oft 1 C Fo' The
s ha g '
7 87.l
nefca e t .
on py he 099- l
m.
f m ' pr - i e ç nsr to f De or'pr vi d,n pe tne tpa t a f l '
or s e prnt d ç tuci ns or bt , o de i ri n r, s olows
l
'
.

Yo rc ie t i f r b c u e ...a a p ia l sn n ile t y ( ln e)ha
u e ev d hs o m e a s
n p lc be a ca ni a e d r s
t
d sh r e (a ee o f r i n a d b y u o d o b c us a i e tfa l
ic a g d ç nc ld r o gve ) e t o we , r e a e n d niib e
e ntha occ r e t tet ri ori de m e t be a dic r ofa de of$600
ve
s u r d ha ihe s s e d o
s ha ge
bt
orm o e I ac e t ha dic r ade you owe you a er uie t i ude
r . f r dior s s ha ged
bt
d,
r eq r d o ncl

t dicha ge n
he s r d mounti youri om e e n i i i l st n $600,on t Sot r
n
nc , ve f t s es ha
he s he
I m e' i ofyourFor 1
nco 'lne
m 040.

'

I Th plitfsalg ta t fln o t 1 99C Fo m s b e tdM s W o d o t a dto l
d. e an if le e h t he iig f he 0 - r u j ce . o s n o d iina
i om e t x la lt
nc
a i biiy.

M s W oods di it t t o M a c 20,201 Prort he de t a r pr s nt tve of
.
on ed n esae n r h
5. i o r a h, e e e ai
Be i i la s M s W oods n t ts di notne t ma a a tona pa nt on t
nefc a dvied .
o ha he d
ed o ke ny ddii l yme s he
Li ofCr di.Li wie f l ng M s W oods sde t a lnde r pr s nt tvead s d Toni
ne
e t ke s , olowi
.
on' a h, e r e e e ai
vie
a
N e t t tno pa e sw e e r quie o t Li o Cr di. A r m d t s m e tm e, e fc a
w on ha
ym nt r e r d n he ne f e t ol he a i B ne i l

de ed t pl i if 'r que tf ra o lofa s ts l oft Pr ry,ba e on t a s ri
ni he antfs e s o ppr va
hor a e he ope t s d
he s e ton
t tt r wa s fc e e t i t Pr ry t pa of t ba a e oft Fis Loa i f l
ha he e s ufi i nt quiy n he ope t o y f he l nc
he rt n n ul.

The pl i if ma n a n t tBe tcalsposton on t r quese s r s l wasc it ntwih
antf s i t i ha nei i '
ii
he e t d ho t a e
onsse
t
t i unde sa ngt tt Li ofCr di de ha be dic r by Be fc a . Ac di t
her
r tndi ha he ne
e t bt d en s ha ged
nei i l cor ng o

t p an if,h Pr p ry wo dha eoh m ieb e çmd r tr'i i silC a be n s b e t
he litfs te o et ul v t e s e n i e wae , f t tl G d e u j c
t
'
h

t te le o b t t e Fis De d o Tr s a d t S c nd De d o Tr s ' 2 Am.Co .!
o h in f oh h rt e f u t n he e o
e f u t' d
mpl
1( .
4 E)
D e pie n e ous r que t f om t pl i if ,Be f c a ne rt k a ac i n t r l as
s t um r
e s s r he a ntf s ne i i l ve oo ny to o e e e

t Sec De ofTr tle I t a Be fc a as i d is i e e ti t Li ofCr tt
he ond ed
us i n. nse d, ne i l sgne t ntr s n he ne
edi o
.

Die h, The pl ntfs a lge t t i Be fc a ha c
tc
ai if le ha f ne ii l d ompled wih t r r que t, Dona d
i
t hei e ss
l
W oods woul ha be n a e t obt i a l n t ptr has t Pr pe t f r a a ot t t
on
d ve e bl o an oa o lc e he o ry o n m mt ha

woul ha f l s tsi d t baa e of t Fis M o t e Loa Be a e t Pr pe
d ve uly ai fe he lnc
he rt rgag
n. c us he o o
r i d e umbe e by t Sec De d ofTr s le hew a una et do s
emane nc
r d he ond e
u t in,
s bl o
o.
The pl i if e n ualy f l i o a r a s on t Fis M o t ge Loa Be t il
antfs ve t l e l nt re r
he rt rga
n.
nek a
a ntd Sur t Tr se ,LLC as s tt e tuse f t pu pos of i ta i f e l lr
ppoi e
e y u tes
ubsiut r t e or he r e
niitng or c osze
pr e ngs On M a 11 201 t 1w 511 ofM c
oce di .
y , 6, he a .1
1
cabe, es r & Conwa LLC no ii d t
W ibe g
y,
tfe he
pl i if ,o be l ofBe fcil t tt orgi lde ti tum e c d no be pr
antfs n haf
ne i a , ha he i na b nsl nt oul t
oduce t t
d, ha
Sur t Tr t e ,LLC had be a nt d t c
e y use s
en ppoi e o onduc a f r c os e s e a t t i f t n
t o e l ur al, nd ha, n ouree

da ,Be fc a woul >s t tuse t pr e wih t s l oft Pr ry.
ys ne ii l
d k he r t e o oce d t he ae he ope t
The f e os e s l wa s he ed t be c
or cl ur ae s c dul o
onduc e o J y 1 201 a 2: 5 p. . On
t d n ul 2, 6 t 1 m
J y 1 201 t pl ntfs fl d s ta i tBe fcala Diec i t Cic tCour f t
ul , 6, he ai if ie ui gans ne i i nd t h n he r ui
t or he
Co y o Lo s Folo i a c e t d e e ge y he rng, t Cic t Cour i s d an
unt f ui a.
l w ng
ont s e m r nc
ai
he r ui
t s ue

ijmci a i tt f ecos es l
nt ton gans he or l ur ae.
Thec ewa r m ove t t sc ton Augus 5,2016.On J nua y 6,201 t pl n if
as s e
d o hi our
t
a r
7, he aitf s
f l a s co n e d co pl i c a ni sx c m t . The fr t f l c
ied e nd m nde m a nt ont i ng i ot s
i s otr ount a e pr m i e o
s r e sd n
t as e to t t Be f c alc nc le t Li of Cr di de ,a t t tt pl i i f w e e
he s ri n ha ne i i a e l d he ne
e t bt nd hus ha he a ntf s r

a a e e il d t a r las oft Se ond De d ofTr tlen. I Co tOne t pli if s e
nd r ntte o ee e he c
e
us i
n un
, he antfs e k
t ç e tte'a i tt Se ond De ofTnzt d.a 5, l Cot Tw o, he pli if s ek S n
o l t il' gans he c
qui
ed
s.I t n mt
t
a ntfs e ç
a
or f r m o loft le oft Sec Dee ofTr t a f a t ne s f e ,'pur ua t
der or e va
he in he ond
d
us, nd or tor y' e s' s nt o

Vigni Co e j 5 - 6. l Co n Tl e ,t e plitfs a s r a cam f r d ma e a an t
ri a d
5 6 5. n u t l e h anif se t li o a g s g i s
r
Be fcilf r f sng t r m o t Se ond De ofTr s le fom t publc lnd r or . I
ne i a or e u i o e ve he c
ed
u t in r he
i a ec ds n

ComtFo r tepanif s e ad caao yj d me tta Be fca i no e t ldt f rco e
t
u ,h litfs e k e lrtr u g n h t nei il s t ni e o o e ls
t
on t Pr pe t unl sa untlt Se ond De d ofTr tle i r moved.
he o ry es nd i he c
e
us in s e
The s ond a e d co pl nt alo c t ns t count t t a e no ba e on t
ec
m nde
m ai s on ai wo
s ha r t s d
he
as e ton t tt Li ofCr di de wa c ncel d by Be fc a . I CountFi t pli if
s ri ha he ne
e t bt s a le
ne ii l n
ve, he antfs

s e ad caao yj d me tt a Be fca i n te tte t f rco eo teP o ryt e sa
e k e lrtr u g n h t neiil s o n ild o o e l s n h r pe t mls nd
untli co i wihVigi aCodej 55- 1 whih st f rh t pr e alrquie nt fr
i t mples t r ni
59., c es o t he oc dur e rme s o
f ecos ewhe e t not orohe e de e ofi bt dnes cn
or l ur
r he e t r vi nc
nde e s nnotbepr
oduce I Cot Si
d. n mt x,

t ep an if s e ad caao yj g n rg r i gtea t a sa o teF rtM o ta eLo n
h litfs e k e lrt r ud me t e ad n h cu l tms f h is rg g a .
The pli if c e t tM s W oods n a Be fcilte e e i o a l n m odik ai i
antfs ontnd ha
.
o nd ne i a dnt r d nt
oa
t ton n
201 'whih ha notbe c r id o by Be fcal a t tt lnde ha c am e t rghtt
4,
' c s
en a re ut
ne i i , nd ha he e r s l i d he i o

S o usf r co u ec ss b g sitr s c a g s a dbo usa tr e ' f e . I a !5
l g o e ls r o t, o u ne et h r e , n g to n y s e s' d. t 7.
b
'
St
andard ofR evi w
e

The de e n sha m ove t dim ist s c a e d c
f nda t ve
d o s s he e ond m nde ompl i purua t Rul
ant s nt o
e

1 b ()o teFe ea Rue o Ci i Pr c d r . Gl p r s o aRu e1 b ()moin i t
2()6 f h d r l ls f vl o e u e s- u po e f l 2()6 to s o
-he
ts t s fcincyofac ant' Edwadsv.CiyofGol bor 1 F. 231 243 ( h Ci.
et he uf e
ompli .
'
r
t
ds o, 78 3d , 4t r
1999 . Ac r ngl t c ts ç val ton i tus ge r l lmie t a r viw o t
)
codi y, he our' i uai s h
e
nealy i td o e e f he
A l ga i ns of t c pl i t is l . Goi s v.V a l v Cm t Se vs B d. 822 F. 1 1 66
le to
he om a n t e f'
'
ne
le
y. r . ,
3d 59, 65-

(t Ci.2 1 ) ç h l ac mplitatc e b aRue 1 b ()mo in d e no ne d d tie
4 h r 0 6 . ç ie o an ta k d y
W
l 2()6 to o s t e eald
f m al a l ga i , a pl i if s oblga i n t pr de t gr
ac
le tons
a ntf
i t o o ovi he ounds of hi e il m e t t r le
s ntte n o e i f
4

r quie m or t n l be sa c usons a a f mul i r ct ton o t e e e sofa c us
e rs
e ha a l nd oncl i , nd or a c e ia i f he lm nt
a e

o a to wiln td ' BelAt.Co .v Two l,5 0 U. 5 4,5 5 (0 7 (iain a d
f cin l o o. l l p . mby 5 S. 4 5 2 0 ) ctto n
'
i enalquotto maksomitd) Tos vi dimis lfrfiur t saeacli $aco an
ntr
ain r
te . ur ve s sa o al e o tt am,ç mplit
m us c an s fc e tf t alma tr a ce e a t e t Gtt ac am f rr le t ti plusbl
t ont i ufi i n ac u
te , c ptd s nl, o sa e l i o ei f ha s a i e

o is fc ,' me nig ta i mu tt la )fcu lc n e tt a alwste c u tt d a t
n t a e' a n h t t s t e dl a t a o tn h t lo h o r o r w he
'
p
r a ona e i e e e t tt de e nti la ef rt m ic
e s bl nf r nc ha he f nda s i bl o he s onduc al ge ' As r tv.I ,
t le d.
' hc of qbal

5 6U.. 6 , 7 ( 0 )( u tn Two y 5 0U. a 5 0 .
5 S 6 2 6 8 20 9 q oig mbl, 5 S. t 7 )
D i si
scus on

1
.

Count O ne t uah Four
s
hro

Boh de e n sha m o d t dimist c st ta epr mi e on t as e ton t t
t f nda t ve ve o s s he ount ha r e s d
he s ri ha
Be fca ca eled t Li ofCr tde . The de e
ne i il nc l he ne
edi bt
f ndan s a gue t tt pl i if 'as e ton
t r
ha he antfs s ri
i t sr ga d i ba e prma iy on t 1 C Fo m fl d by Be
n hi e r s s d i rl
he 099- r ie
nesc a,a t tt I f r i
i l nd ha he RS o m s
no prm af c ee de e,i a ofis l,t tt Li ofCr di de wa ca e ld.
t i a i vi nc n nd t ef ha he ne
e t bt s nc le
The def nda s r l he viy on t Unie Stt s Cour of Appe s f t Fourh
e nt ey a l
he
td ae
t
al or he
t

Cic ts d cso i FDI v.Ca h o 7 0 F.d 1 9 (t Ci.201 ) i whc t e Co r
rui' e iin n C
s in, 2 3 6 4 h r
3, n ih h u t
c i r d whehe t i r ton i o e de e o a 1 C Fonn c e t a ge ne i s of
onsde e
t r he ntoduc i nt vi nc f 099r aed
nui s ue
m a e i f cta t whehe a unde l ng not had bee ca eled ora sgne 720 F.d a 1
t ral a s o
t r n
ryi
e
n nc l
s i d.
3 t 77.
The Fourh Cic ts ve d de ii ns fo a va it of sa e a l werf de a co t on t
t r ui ur ye c so r m
re y
t t nd o
e r l urs
he
is ,a obs r e t tt r w a ( t f r iy i how t s c t haver s ve t c nta
s ue nd e v d ha he e s ç mio m t n
no
he e ours
e ol d he e r l

i r ' L- Alhough s me l rc t ha hel t tSii a Fol 1 C wih t I
nquiy. d t
' a
o owe ours d d ha t lng
f
' 099- t he RS
m
c tt e prm a f c e e de e of an i e t di c r a 1 ,'t Fourh Cic t f m d ç
ons iut s i
a i vi nc
nt nt o s ha ge 0m1' he
t r ui ot $
a

dfee ta p oa h tk n b a mao iy o t c u t t c n ie t matrutmaey mo e
ifrn p r c a e y
j rt f he o rs o o sd r he te li tl r
pe s sve. 1 a 1 Ap yi t ta oa h,whih % e i prncpaly o t l ngua o t
r ua i ' d. t 78. pl ng ha ppr c
'
c ç les i i l n he a ge f he
r
l r gultons a t pur e ofa For 1099- ' t Fourh Cic tc ude t tGii a
RS e a i
nd he pos
m
C, he
'
t r ui oncl d ha l lng
f
5

Fonn 1 C i a c e t ' r uie m e ns ofs ts yi a r pori oblgai t t I i i
099- s r diors eq r d a
a if ng e tng i ton o he RS; t s
nota me nsofa ompls ng a a t ld s ha ge ofde ,nori i r quied onl whe ea a t l
a
cc
ihi n cua i c r
bt
st e r
y
r n cua

dic r ha ar ady oc ur e ' l a 1 79. Ac or ng y, G a e a c edior ca be
s ha ge s le
c r d. d. t 78'
c di l l us
bec
r t
n
r quied t fl a Fo m 1 C e n whe e a de ha no be n c e l t m e e f c t ta
e r o ie
r 099- ve
r
bt s t e anc led, he r a t ha
Fonn 1 C i fld doe notco tmt s fcinte de e sa ng aone, ha a de ha be n
099- s ie
s
nsi e ufi e vi nc , t ndi l t t bt s e
c ncel d.' 1 a 1 Si e Cas on' c am ofc e lton wasQ s d s ey on t 1
a le ' d. t 80. nc
hi s l i
anc la i
l e oll
ba
he 099C

F r 't eFo rh Cic i h l,a amatro lw,h taj r c ud n th ver n ee av r it
o m, h u t r ut ed s te f a ta u y o l o a e d r d ed c
'
i Ca h o sfv r J Ac o dn l t Fo rhCic iafn dt eg a to s mmayj d me t
n s in' a o . Z c r igy,he u t r ut fi ue h r n f u r u g n
t t FD I I
o he
C. d.

l r c ng is dec son,howe r t Fourh Cic t was Gc r f t not t s cfc
n ea hi t
ii
ve , he
t r ui
ça e' o e he pe ii
ul
cr umsa s'oft ca ebe or i a t ç rowne s'ofishol ng. l a 1 . The Cour
ic t nce ' he s f e t nd he t r
na
s ' t di
d. t 81
t

o s r e t tt ec s wa ti l a o dt , eet e 1 9 - Fo m ( s teo l e ie c o
b e v d ha h a e s ikey n d iy wh r h 0 9 C r wa ) h ny vd n e f
l
d b ds h r e b f r te Co r. J. Th Co r e h sz d t ttin a o h rc s ,wh r a
e t ic ag eo e h u t' .. e u t mp a ie ha ç j n t e a e ee
' ;s
l
pr ry a he i a e For 1099 C i i toduc i o e de e a o wih ot rcr tmsa i l
ope l ut ntc t d m
- s n r ed nt vi nc l ng t he ic l t nta

e de e ofc ncel ton oft debt t Fo m 1 - co d be pr ry c i r d by t tir
vi nc
a lai
he
, he r 099 C ul
ope l onsde e
he re
of f c unde t t alt of t cr um sa s on t uli t is of whehe t de i
at
r he ot iy
he ic t nce
he tma e s ue
t r he bt n
que to was i f t ca ele ' I
si n
, n ac, nc ld. d.
'

Att s sa oft pr e ngs t c ti una e t co l t tCa hi f e os s
hi t ge he oc edi , he our s bl o ncude ha s on or cl e
t pli if 'cai t ta epr mied on t a s ri t tt Li ofCr di de wasca e ld
he antfs l ms ha r e s
he s e ton ha he ne
e t bt
nc le
by Be fc a . Unlke Ca hi t pr e c e i notbe or t cour o a m o i n f sl m a y
ne i i l
i
s on, he es nt as s
f e he
tn
t o or lm r

j g n .No d t ep an if r l d oeyo te 1 9 - Fo m't s p o th i a srinta a
ud me t r o h litfs ey û ll n h 0 9 C r 'o u p r t er se t h t
s
o
c nc la i oc ure I a 1
a e lton c r d. d. t 80. I t a t pli if 's cond n
nse d, he antfs e
mende c
d ompli i l
ant ncudesa
numbe of ot r f c ua al ga i r lva t t s is i l ng t f c t t bo h M s
r
he a t l le tons ee nt o hi s ue, nc udi he a t ha t
.
W oods a he da e we e t d,a tr t 1 C Fonu was i s d, t t no ad to
on nd r ught r r ol fe he 099s ue ha
dii nal
6

pa e swe er quied on t Li ofCr di.Theaddii na al ga i i t s co n nde
ym nt r e r
he ne
e t
to l le tons n he e nd me d

c mpan, whe c n i rd i c nu cin wi t e 1 9 - Fo m,s p r te plu il
o li t
n o sdee n o j n to t h 0 9 C r u po t h a sb e
h
i e e t tt Li ofCr di de wa c nc le by Be fc a . Acc di l t de e n s'
nf r nce ha he ne
e t bt s a e ld
ne i i l
or ng y, he f nda t
m o i nst dimi sCount Onetzo h Fourwilbede ed.
to o s s
s
lr ug
l
ni
I.
I

C ount Fi and Si
s ve
x

Xl ug Be eiilmo e t ds s te sc n n n e c mpan i ise trt ,is
t h n fca v d o imis h e o d me d d o lit n t n iey t
ho
bre i s
if n uppor oft moton di no s cfc l add e s Co s Fi a Si Thos c s
t he
i
d t pe i aly r s unt ve nd x.
e ount
we e a e s d,f t frttm e i Be fcalsr pl bre ,a trt de e y w a poi ed ou
r ddr s e or he is i , n ne i i ' e y i f fe he scinc
s nt
t
by t pl i if . ç -he o d na y r l i f er lc t i t ta a gu e r ied f t fr ttm e
he antfs çl r i r ue n ed a ours s ha n r m nt a s or he is i
çi a r pl bre orm e of ndum wilno be c i r d,' M oodi v.Ki wah I l nd I Co.
n e y if
m a
l t
onsde e ''
e
a
sa M
,

LLC,1 4 F. u p. d711 7 5n.1( SC. 01 )( u tn Clws n v Fe Ex Gr t Pa ka e
2 Sp l
, 2 1 D.. 2 5 q o ig a o . d
omd c g
S s.I c,4 F.S p 2 7 ,7 4 ( M d. 0 6 ) s eas Ep es n v. m e No 4 1 -v
v . n . 51 u p. d 31 3 D. 2 0 ); e lo p ro Pa , . :6 c 0 0 0 201 U. Dit LEXI 4 7 5 a * 5 ( . Va M a . 0 201 )( sr J)(a ) F r
0 5 , 7 S. s.
S 7 3 , t 2 W D. . r 3 , 7 Kie , . sme . o
t sr as n, heco twilno c i rBe fcilsa g e si f vorofdimisng Count Fi
hi e o t
ur l t onsde ne i a ' r um nt n a
s si
s ve
a Si a wilde ism otonwih r s c t t ec s
nd x, nd l ny t
i
t e pe t o hos ount .
C oncl i
us on

Fort r as sa e t de e rt 'm otons t dim is wilbe de e The Clr i
he e ons t t d, he f ndais
i o s s l
ni d.
ek s
diece t s nd c pi oft sm e o a
r t d o e o es hi m r ndum opi on a t ac ompa ng or rt a lc ms l
ni nd he c
nyi
de o 1 ot e

ofr cor
e d.

DATED: i tN d yo Api 2 7
Ths g a f rl 01 .
,

Chi U nie St t s Di t i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge

7