Johnson v. Colvin

Filing 22

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/8/17. (hnw)

Download PDF
CL :ATR c; u,:' em cotr ERK' oFFl Dl l QANQKE, VA FIED L I TH E U N I N TED STA TES DI STRI COU RT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI NI CT RGI A CH AM OTTESV I LLE DF SI W ON AI 22 2 7 J C 2 J GY: . D , CLERK . CLERK J YJ OD OHN SON , Ci lAci n No. 3: 6CV00071 vi to 1 Pli tf, a n if M EM ORANDUM O PI NION NANCY A . BERRYHI Ac i LL, tng Comm ispne ofSocalSe urt si r i c iy, By: Hon. e E.Conr d Gln a Unie Stt sDititJ t d a e src udge De e nt f nda . Pli tf hmslld t saci c l ng t fna de ii oft Comm isone ofSocil a n if ie hi ton halengi he i l c son he si r a Se udt de ngpl i ifscli sf s biiyi ur nc neisa s e e t s urt i m e c y nyi antf am ordia lt ns a ebe ft nd uppl m n al ec iy nco b neist e teSo ilS c dt Ac, sn n e , 2U.. j 41 ()a 4 , n 4 U. C. e ft md r h ca e u y ta me d d 4 SC. j 6 i nd 23 a d 2 S. j 1 8 q s q.r s e t l.J ds ito o ti c u tsp ru n t 4 U. . j40 ()a d4 U. C. 3 1 t e , ep ci y u d cin fh s o r i u s a to 2 SC. 5 g n 2 S. ve j 1 8 ()3 . Tlsc u tsrv e i l tdt ad tr nai n a t wheh rte ei s bsa ta 3 3 c( ) l o r' e iw s i e o ee mi to s o te h r s u tn il i mi evi nc t s ppo tt Co mi sonersc l i t tpl i iff iedt e tbls e ilm e tt de e o u r he m s i ' oncuson ha antf a l o sa ih ntte n o be st unde t Ac .I s h s t ntale de ee ss t fnalde son oft Co misone ne s r he t f uc ubsa i vi nc xit , he i cii he m s i r mu tb afr d.La v. lb e z , 8F. 6 0 (t Ci.1 6 ) ttd b ify,s b tn il s e f me ws Cee r z e 36 2d 4 4h r 9 6 .Sae rel u sa ta e de ehasbee d i d a s hr l va e de e, onsde i t r co da awhol,a m ihtbe vi nc n efne s uc e e nt vi nc c i rng he e r s e s g f t a qua et s ppor aco l i byar as bl m i Riha ds n v. r es 40 U. 389, omd de t o u t ncuson e ona e nd. c r o Pe al , 2 S. 4 1(9 ) 0 1 71 . Thepl i if J Lesi J antf, ody le ohns n, sbom o J 9,197 a e nt lyc o wa n une 2, nd ve ua l omplt dhe ee r M g s hoole a i M r . ohns a s r ceveda tona voc tonalr ni i da apr e sng. h c duc ton. s J on lo e i ddii l a i tai ng n t oc s i ( 6 ) As omdb t ev c to l x e t otsiida t a miitai ehe rng plitfha TR 2 . f t y h o aina e p r wh e tfe the d n srtv ai , anif s wok da ac s e , o he lhad , a y itr s n ne o eao , n lbdc to s r ie .( r e s ahir h me at ie b b ste, c n r p rt r a d u ain evc r TR l 7 ) M r. oms nwa ls e o di 2 0,h u hs eh ds bsa ta s l-mpo me t n o 4 . s J l o s a t mplye n 01 t o g h a u tnil efe ly n i c me i 2 1 ( 5 ) OnAug t9 201 plitf f r l flda piainf rd sbit isla c n 01 . TR 3 . us , 2, an if omal ie p lc to o ia l y n t n e y i r be f a s e e t s u iy i o ebe f . She al ge t ts be n e dia e f ra1 neks nd upplm n al ec zt nc m neks le d ha he c m s bld o 1 f r ofs tntalganf le oy e on M a 1 2011duet c r omyopahy,bac pr e , o ms uhsa i i ' mpl m nt u y , o a di t k obl ms pos-r lm ai sr s dior r de es i li h bl pr s lr hea tpr e s c tpai hi ttal tc te s s de , pr son, lg ood e sze, r oblm , hes n, gh c oe tr l c nc nrto dfkul e ,se p a n a a d ty o dpr be . ( 2 ) S en w h lseo, o e tain il t s le p e , n h r i o lms TR 61. h o i mai a nst ts hasr mai d dia ed t t pr s nttm e. Ast he a i a i f dia lt nti ha he e ne s bl o he e e i o r pplc ton or s biiy i tr nc be ft,t r c dr ve st tM r . ol on m e t i tr d sausr quie nt o t nsla e ne s he e or e al ha s J ms t he nsle t t e r me s f he Ac tr u ht frtq re o 2 5 b t tte e fe .S eg m,4 U. C. j41 ()a d4 3 a . tl o g he is ua tr f 01 , u no h r a tr e e 2 S. j 6 i n 2 () z Cons que l pli ifi e il t dia lt i ur ebene iso yi s ha esa ihedt ts e nty, antf s ntted o s biiy ns anc ft nl f he s t bls ha he be nmedia edf a1f msofs t nta ganf le pl c s bl or 1 or ubsa i l i u m oyme o orbef eM a c 31 201 See nt n or r h , 5. g n,4 U.. j4 3 a . e - 2 SC. 2 () M r J hns sa i ai we edeniduponi tal onsde ai nr dr c i r to She s. o on' pplc tons r e nii c i r to e onsde ai n. t nrqueseda rceve a7:novohe dnga rviw beo ea Admi srtveLa J he e t nd e i d . . a nd e e fr n nitai w udge.I n a opi o da e M ar h 9,2015,heLa J n ni n t d c t w udgealodee m i d t tM r . o on i notdi a e s t r ne ha s J hns s s bld. TheLa J w udgef oundt t antf s f r fom s ve a s ve ei ime s i l ng de ne a i ha pl i if ufe s r e r l e r mpa r nt ,ncudi ge r tve dicd s a e s t i he r f it e; bsr tvese p a a; iy; ndm e a dio de sG ro l s i e s ; ysolc a t all o tuci le pne obest a r nt l s r r t iusy va da n e oi ld d prsi eds r e, n it d s r e ,ndpo tta mai srs ds r e '( ig osdt ncu e e e sv io d ra x ey io d ra s-ru tc te s io d n' TR 24) Be us oft s i ime s t La J deemi dt tM r. ohns i now lmiedt . ca e he e mpar nt,he w udge tr ne ha s J on s i t o t pe f r a o s de a y e ri la tviis The La J he ro m nce f e nt r xe tona c i te . w udge we on t as e spli ifs nt o s s antf r i ualf to lca ciy a f l esd unci na pa t s olows: 2 Afe c r f c i r to oft e ier c d,1fnd t tt c am a hast tr a e ul onsde ai n he ntr e or i ha he l i nt he r sdua fmctonalc pa iyt pe f m s ntr wor a de i d i 20CFR ei l t i a ct o ror ede a y k s fne n 4 4 1 6 ()a d41 .6 ()e e t n ulto r q rst eus o ac n ; 0 .5 7 a n 69 7 a xc p : mb ain e uie h e f a e oc aso lsaisa r mps no l dde s r mpsors afo ds fe ntba a i c i na t r nd n ; a r , n c f l ; r que l ncng; oc aso lsoo ng, kne lng,c ouc ng,a c a i Shec n pe f m t kild c ' na t pi i e i r hi nd r wlng. a ror ms le wo k a a SVP 1or2 t ti vessmpl r i t s whe et pac of r tn ha nvol i e outne a ks r he e pr tviy i notdit td by a ex e na s zc overwhi h s hasno c r , oduc i t s c ae n t r l olr e c he ontol s ha c uc s onve bet . yor ls ( 27 . Gie s c arsd a G n to l a ct, n a trc nsd rn p an ifsa e TR ) v n u h e iu l z cina c pa i a d fe o i eig litf g , y ed ai n,a prorwor e re e, we last tm o fom avoc tonale r,t La uc to nd i k xpe i nc as l esi ny r ai xpe t he w J udgef md t tpl ntf r i ca bl ofpe f nghe pa tr e ntwo k a as ame ot ha ai if ema ns pa e ronni r s elva r s cl r o e ao , sti j b i g n rlypef r di tenaina e o o l( 3 - 8 .Gie p rt r a l s o s e eal ro me n h to l c n my. TR 7 3 ) v n l pl i ifsr sd lf nc i c pact and a trc i rnghe a ,e a i a prorwor antf e i ua u tonal a iy, fe onsde i r ge duc ton, nd i k e re e a welast voc tonale r ' t tmony, heLaw J e a s de e mi d t tM r . xpe inc , s l he a i xpe ts esi t udg lo t r ne ha s J ohns n r t nst c pa iyt pe f m s ve a ot rs de a ywor r e whi h e s i o eai he a ct o ror e r l he e nt r k ol s c xit n sgnii a nlm be i t na i le onomy.Ac r ngl t La J i fc nt l r n he tona c co di y, he w udge uli t l co l tma ey ncuded t tM r . ol on i notdia e a t ts i no e il d t be l unde et rf de a ha s J ms s s bld, nd ha he s t ntte o neks r ihe e r l pr a . TheLa J ogr m w udge' o ni wasa e a t fna de ii n oft Com mi so rby s pi on dopt d s he i l c so he s i ne 1Thee de de l vi nce veopeddurngt e le ad nitai pr ee ngs a M r . l s stsi onyatt i he arir mi sr tve oc di , nd s Jom on' e tm he e de i y he i e tbls t tpl ntf' pro wo kasas nne o r t r quie pe f ma eoflghte rto vi ntar arng, sa ih ha ai ifs ir r ca r pe aor e r d ror nc i xe in. ( 5 -8 2 7 .Gie teLa J d estn igta Mr. omsni n w l tdt sd nay e et n,h c u t TR 75 , 7 ) v n h w u g ' idn h t s J l o s o i e o e e tl x ri te o r mi o c n ld sh theCo sin rsd tr n to ta zlitf a rt t t sp riua patee a t r r l in t o cu e ta t mmiso e' eemiain h t anifcn et o hi atc lr s rlv n wok oe s o ml sp o tdb sbsa ta e ie e Ho v rtevo aln lx ra tea miitaieh aigrc gnz dtat j b u p re y u tnil vd nc . we e,h cto a e petth d nsrtv e rn e o ie h the o o sa ne o eao i n tlse i t Dito ayo Ocu ain l te , n ta tecoe to whihi lse i ta f c n r p rtrs o itd n he cin r f c p to a Tils a d h th lssj b c s itd s h t o d cl n pe ae:whc i g n rly d e d a u s l d s d nay wok r l. ( 7 ) S c tsi n f o l t rp rr ih s e eal eme n nkie , e e tr r oe TR 4 . u h etmo y me l e our gedt Admi tai La J nc a he l r tve w udget f t tM r Joms i ca eofr u ni t wor asas r ro r t us o md ha s. l on s pabl etr ng o k came pe aor a tij big n rl p rome .( 3 -8 . we e,hec m'd e n t eivet theLa J g ' c n ieain s hs o s e eal efr d TR 73 )Ho v rt o t o s o b l ha t w ud es o sd rto y e o pani p s woka asn ne o eao, r frta matr tevo ain l x etsc n ieaino ti p sj b, f litcs a t r s c n r p rtro ,o h t te,h cto a e p r' o sd rto fhs at o c ompo t wiht r quie nt ofSoca Se iy Rulng96- P o Soci Se urt Rulng96- s h ast s ppor a rs t he e r me s il curt i 8 r al c iy i 9P, uc ou t t dn ta plitf a no yefr te 6 o s a n ro eao a ii g n rl p rome i ten to a e o o . - ig h t anifcn w rom h j b f c n e p rtr sts e eal efr d n h ain l c n my m y Sttd difr nty,her or m t sca ei l noevi nc t s r t noto t tM r . l o maynow wor ae fe e l t ec d hi s ncudes de e o uppo t he ln ha s Joms n k a adoc ntprpa e,DOT No. 587- 1 Ne rhee s a r fe e beow,heAdmi srtveLa J ewe s ume e r r 249. 0 8. ve t ls , s e lctd l t nita i w udg nt ont c i rpl ntf' ca eunde Stp 5oft s quen i dia lt a l i, twhihheconcude t tM r J on o onsde ai ifs s r e he e tal s biiy nayss a c l d ha s.ohns rt ns s t e f to lca iy t pef r ale nae wor r esexitng i sgnii an numbe i t nai l eai ufkint uncina pact o ro m tr t k ol si n i tc t r n he tona e o my l s c a t c utb le e ta ti d tr n to i sy o td b s b tnile ie c ,te c u t c no . namu h s he o r eiv s h t hs eemiain s u p re y u sa t vd n e h o r a c udest tt de i e isi t La J ge' a yssa Stp 4 a ewlhoutcons nce. oncl ha he fcince n he w ud s nal i t e r t eque t SocilSe udt Ad i sr to sAppe sCot i.Ha ng e use a 1a ia e he a c y m nitai n' al mcl vi xha t d 1 val bl ad i sr tver m e e , r .J on hasnow a m nita i e di s M s ohns ppeaedt t sc r . l o hi ou t W hie pl ntf m a be dia e f c ran f r s of e pl ym e ,t c c a f c ua l ai if y s bl d or e ti o m m o nt he nz i l a t l de e mi to i whehe pl i ifi dia ed f ralf msofs t nta ga nf e oy e .Se t r nai n s t r antf s s bl o l or ubsa i l i ul mpl m nt e 4 U. C. j4 3 d ( )a d 1 8 ca .Th r aef t ee n so pr o wh c mu t ec n iee 2 S. j 2 ( )2 n 3 2 () e e r o l lme t f o f ih s b o sd r d r i mn i gs ha a ay i.The eee nsaesl rz da f lo :( ) b e tv me ia fcs n k n uc n n lss s lme t r l mma ie s o lws 1 o j cie d c l a t a dciia sn i g ;2 teo no sa dc n l so s fr ai h sca s ( ) u j ci e ie e n lnc l d n s( )h piin n o cu i n o te t y iin ;3 s b e tve vd nc ngp o p y ia ma fsainso i ime t, sd s rb dtr u hacama ts e tmo y a d() h f h sc l nie tto f mpar ns a e cie h o g li n ' tsi n ; n 4 t e cli a tse to voc tonalhit r r sdua s ls a age Vie v.Fi h,438 F. 115 am n ' ducai n, a i so y, e i l kil , nd . t k nc 2d 7, 1 5 - 0( t Ci. 9 ) Un e wo dv. bc f, 8F.d8 0 8 ( t Ci.1 6 ) 1 9 6 4h r 1 71 ; d r o Ri io f 29 2 5 , 51 4h r 9 2 . Afe a r vi w of t r or i t s c s ,t c ' i co taned t co l t tt tr e e he ec d n hi a e he out s nsr i t o ncude ha he Comm isone ' fna de son i s s i rs i l cii s uppored by s t n i le de e. M r .J t ubsa ta vi nc s ohns s f sfom on ufer ' r s ve e de ne a i di cdie e,he r f iur ,see a e r ge r tve s s as a t al e l p pnea a obest Shealo ha ahit r of , nd iy. s s so y de e sve dior r wih n e y a pos-r pr s i s de t nxit nd ttauma i sr s s dr m e. As f her emotona tc tes m o or i l pr ems whiet La J obl , l he w udgede e mi d t tM r . o o e re e m ode a edi c tesi t r ne ha s J hns n xpe inc s r t x uli n he c e rto pe sse e, ndpac , . yeRom a ac ula i ps hol s, tr i r onc ntai n, r it nc a e Dr Fa no, ons ttve yc ogit dee m ned t tpl ntc se o i na s ha ai i m to l ympt sa e no s s ve e a t pr ve r gt a wor ac i t M r . om r t o e r s o e nt e z r k tviy. s l J ohns n' c r ol s f md t t s e re e e ry he r f im e d t non-s he i o s a di ogit ot ha he xpe inc s a l a t al ue o ic m c ca di r omyo t Howe r anec a di r m onOc o r4,2011r ve l onl midl dec e ed pahy. ve , hoc r og a t be e aed y l y r as s g na lAve tiua s soi f cinwiha ee to fa to o 45 t 5 %.W hi panif e me tle nrc lr y t lc un to t n j cin r cin f % o 0 l litf e hasc i dt r c ver gul rc r f rhe r pr e s he c r ol s ha no ontnue o e ei e a a e orhe a t obl m , r a di ogit s tdoc e e a um nt d ny wor e ng of he c ton, des t pl ntf oc asonal pr s ntton wih c r ova c a s ni r ondii pie ai ifs c i e e ai t a di s ulr 4 s ympt . I tr sofhe ea l he r f l e t m e ca r or doe no s oms n e m r ry a t aiur , he di l ec d s t uppo ta fndi of r i ng dia lt f rl s sr nuousf r sofa i t Asf rhe se p a a M r . o o hasunde gone s biiy o e s te om ctviy. o r le pne , s J hns n r di nosi wo k- ,a i ha bee de e mi d t ts r quiesus ofaCPAP m a hi ,t ug ag tc r ups nd t s n t r ne ha he e r e c ne ho h he c m pla ewih t spr t olha be n une n. The ei no i c to t the see dior r r o i nc t hi o oc s e ve r s ndia i n ha r l p s de afecshe c pa iyf s de a y wor aci t f whih s i o he wiephysc ly c pabl f t r a ct or e nt r k tviy or c he s t r s ia l a e. Bas on t m e c lr po t,a we la pli tf st tmony,i woul a a t M r . ed he di a e rs s l s a n if esi t d ppe r hat s J ms n' bac pr e spr e he m os sgnii a wor r lt d physca lm iai ns M r . ol o s k oblm oduc r t i fc nt k-ea e i l i tto . s J ms n hass f r d fo 1 ba k pr blm sf ma ye r . Shea t e t ons ofhe ba k ol o ufe e ' m ow c o e or ny a s r tdbut s he et r c dfiute t awo k rlt dij r .S n w us sac n f rn uain.nDe e e o 2 1 a ifc lis o r -eae nu y he o e a e o mb lto I c mb r f 01 , ntr e pr c ii r r pore t t pl ntf was s f rng f o i r a i bac pan. The ntr e ts a ttone e td ha ai if ufe i r m nc e sng k i ls p a tto e o i dta M r. o n o i t b et wok.( 5 4 . I 2 2 panifu d r n rciin r pne h t s J h s n s ma l o r TR 7 ) n 01 , litf n e we t all a s ieM ll lc s o ds v r b-aea f rmia se ossa teL5 S1lv l ( 5 3 . l r pn l wlih h we e ee iltr lo n n ltn i th - e e. TR 6 ) mb M or r c nty, heha c e ee l s s ompli d o r di toni ohe l we e r mii .A ph i a e mi to ane f a ai nt r o r xte tes ysc l xa nai n i Jmeof201 r a e lmiedll ba r ngeofm o i n, ii sr i ht1 gr ie, nd t r s n t 3 eve l d i t lm r a to postve ta g e as a ende nes t papai I Se e be of201 s wa as e s wih cloni l ba k pan, ge r tvedic o l ton. n pt m r 3, he s s s ed t lr c ow c i de ne a i s diea e s s s , pondyl yss se i,a rght15 r c o t Ne rhe e s he docor ha not ol i, t noss nd i . adiul pahy. ve t l s , r t s ve r ommende i i mea ur s optngi t df cons r tvete t e .N om e c doc o s ec d nvasve s e , i nsea or e vai r am nt di al t rha s uggese t t M r .J t d ha s ohns n' m us ul ke ealpr ems a e dia i i ove al i c . l o s c os l t obl r s blng n r l mpa t n as e sng pl i i sm us ul ke eala c r ovas ulrpr blm s t Admi sr tveLa J s s i nntœ c os l t nd a di c a o e , he nita i w udge r id on r po t fom sa e a nc physcans who c i r d M r .Jo on t be c pa e of ele e rs r t t ge y ii onsde e s hns o a bl pe f r i lg e f m sofwo k,de piehe doc e edphysca pr e s r o m ng i ht r or r s t r um nt i l obl m . 5 I s r,gi n t m e c r or i tls c e t c tm us co l t t t r i n ho t ve he dial ec d n li as , he our t ncude ha he e s s t nta e de t s ppor t La J ubsa i l vi nce o u t he w udge' fndi t t M r .J ms r t ns s ûc e s i ng ha s ol on eai uf i nt f nc i l c pa t f s de a y l l of physc l e ri u tona a ciy or e ntr eve s i a xe ton. M o eove ,gi n Dr Rom a s r r ve . no' ps hol ca sudy,heco t le st tt r co d s yc ogi l t t ur be ive ha he e r upporst fndi t t antT sde es i t he i ng ha pli i pr sve dior r a as oca e n ey a sr s dior r a eno s s ve ea t pr ve pe f r a e o s de , nd s it d nxi t nd te s s de , r t o e r s o e nt r o m nc f t s de a y wor r esf whi s i ot r s physc l c pa e. I f lowst tt fna he e nt r k ol or ch he s he wie ialy a bl t o l ha he i l de ii oft Commi so i t sc s mus bea fnne c son he s i ner n hi a e t f d. Ona alotlsc ut pl i ifm a t a g l e si s r ofhe ppe t li ot antf kes wo r lm nt n uppo t rmotonf sl a y i or lmm r j g n , rrma df ra dto a c n ie ain.Plitf c ne st tt Co si n rer d ud me to e n o d iin l o sd r to anif o tnd ha he mmiso e re i nfndi e i lfmci na c pa iyf rpa tr l va wor Thec t r s i f ngr sdua t to l a ct o s e e nt k. our ag ee ,f ornoo he ea on t rr s t n t La J ha he w udge ssndi o r i ua f nc i c pact f no mor t n s de a y e ri l ' ng f esd l u tonal a iy or e ha e nt r xe tona aci t Ass tf t a tviy. e orh bove t c t le st tt r i no e de et s ppo t La J , he our bei ve ha he e s vi nc o u rthe w udge' s fn igt a Mr . o n o i n w c p bl o pefr ngh rp ir o a s ame o rtr ete a i dn h t s J h s n s o a a e f ro mi e ro j b s c x r peao , i r s h a t aly pe f r c u l r o med ora ge r ly pe f me i t nai lec s ne al ror d n he tona onomy. Howe r t c u'mus ve , he ot t t c l t t her c ds oncude ha t e or upporst notont tpl i ifr mai c pa eofpe l mi s de a y t he i ha antf e ns a bl rbr ng e nt r wor r e , i ntse by t voc i na e r whih e s i sg fca ntmberi t na i k ols as de i d he ato l xpe q c xit n i nii nt l n he tonal econom y. Pl i i ss ond a gt e on a a pr s nt ac os rquesi antY ec r tm nt ppe l e e s l e ton.Asr l c ed a efe t bove t , he Adm i sr tveLa l nita i w udges ikalyf pect l oundt t antY se o i difc te r s tnm ode a e ha pli i m tonal fiuli s e uli rt l tto i c n e tain, e sse c , n p c .( 2 ) ti fr ltn h sfn i g a t i ains n o c n rto p ritn e a d a e TR 6 .Ye,n o mu aig i id n s s o mi pli i s r sdua fmci na ca iy,t La J antY e i l t to l pact he w udge di not i l s h det i nc e i d ncude uc k e is n c e r ton,Pe s se e a pa . Net r di t La J onc ntai r itnc , nd ce ihe d he w udge i ude s lmiai i ncl uch i t tons n c nrton, ritnce o c i hehy t tc queto opounde ot vocaina e r once tai pesse , rpa e nt poheial sinspr bt he to l xpe t a t a nitai he dng. Cii ava i t ofde sons mos not bl t oft Unied St t t he dmi sr tve a tng rey cii , t a y hat he t aes Co rbf pe l frteFo rhCic ii M a cov. li , 0F.d6 2( t Ci. 01 ) plitf u t Ap as o h u t rutn s i Cov n 78 3 3 4h r 2 5 , an if a gu t t La J r es hat he w udge' fndi ofa lm ia i t sm pl t l l d wor doe notnec s dl s i ng i t ton o i e, msdle k s es a y i pl o t kei o ac ot ,m ode a elm iai i c en r ton,pe sse e, pac m y, r a nt c mt r t i t tons n onc ta i r it nc or e. Thi c ur ha c itntym l ha aLa l s o t s onsse l edt t w udge' fndi oflmia i osmpl t s led s i ng i t tont i e,m kil wo k smpl doe no t ke i o ac ount a cam a ' m ode a e lm iai ns i he a lt t r i y s t a nt c li nts r t i t to n r biiy o co n r t , kr gulry, nd sa ont s Se , 2.Se onv. vi 21F. pp. 639, 43 nce ta e wor e a l a t y a k. e e. , xt Col n, su 3d 642- ( . Va 20 4 . Sae dfee ty t e c u t b le e ta, i s c crl tn e , t e W D. . 1 ) ttd ifrn l, h o r eiv s h t n u h icl a c s h ms Comm isone f ist c ny t btr n i g ng f wa d wih t e de e ast t e se eof s i r a l o a he lde n oi or r t he vi nc o he xitnc ohe j b acama t g t ee p ce t p rom, ie ac mp e e i ec n ieain o gl f t r o s li n mih b x e td o e fr gv n o rh nsv o sd r to f l o t cama tsi ar n s S eW ak rv. we , 8 F. 47 5 (t Ci. 9 9 .Ho v r i he li n ' mp ime t. e l e Bo n 8 9 2d , 0 4 h r 1 8 ) we e,n t i t ntc s , hec t le st tt La J epr ryr ledont ps hol c ls u of he nsa a e t our be ive ha he w udg ope l e i he yc ogi a t dy Dr Rom a a we la t eoft sae a nc ps hol ss i fndi t tM r .J . no, s l s hos he t t ge y yc ogit , n i ng ha s ohns n c n o a pe f t s le s de a y wor de pie he difc te i c entato pe sse ,orpa e. ronn m kild, e ntr k s t r fiuli s n onc r i n, r it nce c Cii Dr Rom a sco ula i e ua i t sa ea ncyps hol git f t ha M r . o on tng . no' ns t tve val ton,he tt ge yc o ss omdt t s J hns co d sildo s m e f m sofwor des t t e se e ofm ode a e lm iatons c us d by he ul tl o or k, pie he xit nc rt i t i a e r e to a p o lms ( 9 - 0 ,1 - 4 ) l a s sig te v c t n li c o plitf' mo in l r b e . TR 3 1 6 28 1 4 . n se sn h o ai a mpa t f anifs o e oto l d f ton, t La J m i na ys nnc i he w udge a s e i il r led i s t nta mea tr o t lo xplcty e i n ubsa i l sle n he ps hol ca r por ofDr Romano. ( 3 ) Folwi c nd c o aci c le au to ,Dr yc ogi l e t . TR 7 . lo ng o u t f l a v lain . ni Rom a obs r d a f l ws no e ve s olo : Bas d upon t r s t oft se l to i a a st tt Cli a i c pa eof e he e uls hi vaua i n, t ppe r ha he am nt s a bl pe f m i smpl a r pe ii t s and woul notha difc t c ror ng i e nd e ttve a ks d ve fiuly ompl tng ei s m ede al d a c plx t s t rs r son. Cli ntdoe nota a o t ie nd om e a ks mde upe vii The a ma s ppe r t be c o ompr s a afmc i ofhe c r ntps ho- motona fmc i ng. r omied s t ton r ure yc e i l L toni He a lt t m ant i r gulra tnda e i t wo kplce pe l m wo k a tvii on biiy o i an e a te nc n he r a , rbr r c i tes ac it nt i , ndco plt anonnal r yo onsse bass a m ee wo kda rwor kwee t i e z i kwihout ntm pton a a sr ltvey lni ppe r ea i l l mpaie i r ga dst he ps ho- m otona f to ng. r r d n e r o r yc e i l unci ni He a lt oa c pti t c i fom s pe v s s i e a twihc biiyt c e nsnlton r u r ior ,nt r c t owor r a t publc ke s nd he i, a we las co ng wih r tne sr s or e ot e e i co pe ii wo k do no s l ; pi t ou i te s s nc mt r d n m ttve r t a a t bei par d. Shei notc r nty r cevi ps ho r c media i l ppe r o m ie s ure l e i ng yc topi c ton. t doe not ppe rt t heCl i a woul r quiea s sa et a quael m a s a a ha t am nt d e r s it nc o de t y nagehe r ownf nds.Gi nt efndi ,heCl i a tsc u ve hes i ngs t am n ' ompl i o f to lmpanne ant f unc i na i i nt a a si onsse a t stm e. ppe r nc it nt t hi i ( 67. TR 4 ) I s t t cour bei ves t t t r i s t nta e de e t s n hor, he t le ha he e s ubsa i l vi nc o uppo tt uli ae r he tm t co l i t tpl i ifsde r eofi r e i t msofhe c enta i perit nc a pa e ncuson ha antf ge mpaim nt n er r onc r ton, sse e, nd c i nots s ve east pr ve pero ma oft sm pl a r pe ii wor r esf whih s i s o e r o e nt f r nce he i e nd e ttve k ol or c he s ot r s physc ly c pa e. St t dif r nty,t c tdoe notbei ve t tt r i nae of he wie ia l a bl aed fe e l he our s le ha he ato l , M a coa isi hi c e, ve hemedial vi ec i r dbyt s i pple nt s as gi nt c ç denc ons de e heAdmi sr tveLa l nita i w udge. I a tnni t fna de son oft Com misone ,t c tdoesno s ges t tM r . n fs ng he i l cii he s i r he our t ug t ha s J o i fe ofa1pa n, s m f t a e otona s mpt aol y.I ed,hem e c lr co d ohns n s ' e l i dico ol nd m i l y om t og nde t r di a e r c im s t t pl ntf s f r fom de t mus ul kee a pr e s as we l a woriome onfr ha ai if ufe s r fnie c os lt l oblm , l s rs ca di c a s mpt s a e oto l d fl ton. Howe r i m us agan be no e t t r ovas ul r y om nd m i na ys l i nc ve , t t i t d ha p ani sph iinsd e h rp o lmst bes b e tt c n r ltr ug c n e v tv te t n litY ysca e m e r be o u j c o o to h o h o s r aie r ame t m e sle . No m e ca docorha s a tr s di l t s ugge t d t tM r .J l o i t t l dia e I m us be se ha s o ms n s o aly s bl d. t t r c g ie t ttei a ii t d wo kwi u a ys be tv ds o o t o sn to is l rn e e o nz d ha h n blt o o r t t n u j ci e ic mf r d e o f tef e d r y ho acama t oal d sb e Cr i v. tr 76F.d5 5 5 4- 5( t Ci.1 9 ) l a e r t t li n ttl ia ld. ag Chae, 3 8 , 9 9 4h r 9 6 . t pp as o he y c u th th Ad n srtve w l d ec n iee a1 fh s b e t fco s e s n b ys p o td o rt a t e miitai La u g o sd rd lo t e u j ci a tr ra o a l u p re ve 8 b teme ia r c r i a j d c tn plitf camsfrb neis I f lo t a a1 a eso t e y h dc l e o d n du iaig an ifs li o e ft. t olws h t lf c t f h Comm iso rsfna decson a e s s i ne ' l ii r uppore by s t nta e de . td ubsa i l vi nce Asa g ne a r e r ol i ofc lcsi t e de i am a trwihi t pr nc of e r l ul, es uton onfit n he vi nce s te t n he ovi e t Commisone e n i t c t i r ol t c lc sdif r n l Ri ha ds v.Pe aes he s i r ve f he our m ght es ve he onfi t fe e ty. c r on rl , s p a Op e h i v. n h 49 F.d3 6( t Ci. 9 4 .F r h r a o ssae ,hec u ti ste u r; p n em Fic , 5 2 9 4h r 1 7 ) o t e e s n ttd t o r fnd h Comm iso rsr s uton o t pe tne c lc si t r o d i t sc e t be s s i ne ' e ol i f he ri nt onfit n he ec r n hi as o uppo td by re s t nta e de e Ac r ngl t fna de ii n oft Co misone mus bea fr e La ubsa i l vi nc . co di y,he i l c so he m s i r t fim d. ws v. lb e z , u r .Ana p o raej g n a do d rwi bee tr dt i d y. Cee rz e s p a p r p it ud me t n r e l n ee hs a l The ce k i die t d t s nd ce tfe co e oft sopi on t a1c lr s r c e o e rii d pis hi ni o l ouns lofr or e ec d. oA-so:I T A r us d yo g s 2 7 a rau ut 01 . Unie St t Diti tJ ge t d aes src ud 9

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?