Harrington v. African American Matchmaking

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/8/17. (hnw)

I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES D I I COU RT
STR CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGN A
CHA M O TTESV I
LLE DI I ON
V SI

CL
ERKS OFFI U.. ST.
CE S DI COURT
ATROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

MA 28 2 1
ï
27
,

BY;

D L CL
EY ERK
r/CL
ERK

BLAI HAI
NE
UUNGTON ,
Pli tf,
a n if

Ci lAc i No.3:6CV00084
vi ton
1
M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI

AFRI
CAN AM EI
UCAN
M A TCH M A K I G ,
N

By:Hon. e E.
Gln Conr d
a
ChifUnie St t sDititJ
e
t d a e src udge

D e e nt
f nda .

Plitf Bli Harn o tdlrigtn'fldti c p rg tifig me t cin a an t
anif ane rigtn s arn o ' ie h s o y ih n rn e n a to g is
l
l
d fn a tAfia Ameia M ac madn ($ ' o De e e 1 , 5 algngvo ains
ee d n rc n
rc n th l g ç
AAM ' n c mb r 4 201 , le i ilto
)
o t e Co y ih Ac,1 U. C.j 1 e s q Th p an ifh sn w fld amoin frd fut
f h p rg t t 7 S.
01 t e . e litf a o ie
to o ea l

j d me tu e Rul 5 ()o t Fe ea Rue o Cii P o e t e Fo t r a o s'ae t
u g n nd r e 5b f he d rl ls f vl r c dl . r he e s n s td,he
r
t
m oto wilbegr nt d.
in l
a e
Fact Backeround
ual

I rv e n amoinf rd fulj g n ,h c u t c e t a t et welpe d d
n e iwig to o ea tud me tt e o r a c p s s nz he l- la e
f c a a lga i i t c
a m l le tons n he ompl i a t la lt Se Rya v.
ant s o i biiy. e n Homec ncsFi Newor 253
omi
n. t k,

F.d7 : 8 - (t Ci. 0 )
3 78 7 0 81 4h r 2 01 .
Thepl i ifi a ex re e c
antf s n pe inc d, omm e c a ta la l a i phot a r Defnda i
r i l r ve nd oc ton
ogr phe . e nt s
ama c ki a dai we ief Afi n- e i n i vi l .
t hma ng nd tng bst or rca Am rca ndi dua s AAM c r nty has22,
ure l
060

me e s On S p e e 1 2 01 tepanifc pl e t p ooga h û
mb r . e tmb r , 0 ,h litf a tr d he h t rp ç 01 1 -2. g't
z
BER- - 9 0 j '(he
p
ç t r ph' a publs t Phot rph on Aprl 1 2011.Pli if rgitr d t
i og a ), nd
pho
ihed he
og a
i 7,
antf e see he
Phot r ph wih t Unie Stt CopyrghtOfi e on Aprl26,2011.Be nni on ora ut
og a
t he t d a es
i
fc
i
gi ng
bo
Jme 1 201 t de e ntcopid a posed t Pho ogr ph t ac ompa a a tce o t
t
, 5, he f nda
e nd t he
t a o c
ny n ri l n he

e
e
t he
we st f rAfia Ame ia M ac mn n (AM M ' .The def ndant copi d and posed t
b i o rc n
e
rc n th kig 1
&
'
)
Phot a on no l st n s ve ditnc URTs
ogr ph
es ha e n si t
,.
Pli iffld t s c
antf e hi oppi hti rnge e a ton agans AAM on De mbe 1 2015,
g nfi m nt c i
i t
ce r 4,

algi viltonsoft CopyrghtAc,1 U. C.j1 e sq. rcod s
le ng oai
he
i
t 7 S.
01 t e The e r howst tt owne
ha he
r
ofAfi a Am e i a M a c l wass r ed on J nua y 3,201 To da e Afi a Ame i a
rc n
rc n t hmadng
ev
a r
7.
t , rc n
rc n
M atbm a ng ha no fl a r po i pl a ng.An e r ofde a twa fld agans Afi a
c ki
s t ied es nsve e di
nty
f ul s e
i t rc n

Ameia M ac mn i go F b ay1 , 01 , u s a t oRue5 ()o t Fe e a Rulso Cii
rc n th k n n e nlr 0 2 7 p ru n t l 5 a fhe d r l e f vl
P o e u e Plitf h sn w mo e f rd f utud me tThema tri rp f rrv e
r c d r . an if a o
v b o ea lj g n .
te s ie o e iw.
St
andard ofR evi w
e

Un e Rul 5 o ' e Fe ea Ru e o Cii Pr c d r ,d fulj d me ti at -tp
d r e 5 ft d rl ls f v l o e u e ea t u g n s wo se
h
p o e s Se J fes n v Brn r l .4 F. u p. d4 0 4 3 ( D. . 0 6 . irt e tyo
r c s . e efro . ie .nc, 61 S p 2 3 , 3 E. Va 2 0 ) Pro o nr f
d futj d me t t r mu tb a e ty o d fut S eFe R.Ci P. 5 a . trd ful i
ea l u g n, hee s e n nr f ea l. e d.
v. 5 () Afe ea t s
e trdb t eClr , p ryma mo etec ur f rd fulj d me t nd rRue5 ()
n ee y h ek a a t y v h o t o ea t u g n u e l 5b .
Upon de a t al oft welplade f t a l ed i t c
f ul, 1 he l- e d acs leg n he ompli m a bet ke a tu
ant y
a n s r e.

Se Rm n,25 F.d a 7 0 (ç h d fn a t b li d fu t a misp an ifs welp e d d
e
3 3 t 8 çTj e ee d n , y zs ea l, d t litf' l la e
l
-

alg to so f cl ' (nen l iaino te ) s eas Fe . Ci P. ( )6 . c r igy,n
le ain f a t.' itr a ctto mitd ; e lo d R. v. 8 b () Ac o dn l i
j)
ted fut u g n c ne t t t p r p it iq iyi wh te o n ttefc o t epla i g
h ea lj d me t o tx ,he t p o rae n ur s eh r r o h a e f h e d n s
a
s p rs te d ful j d me t a d t e c us s o a to te en. An e s n v Fo n .f r
u po t h ea t u g n n h a e f cin h r i ' d ro . u d o
'
Adva e nt Educ.& Emp' ofAm .l a , 99- 508,1 U. App.
nc me .
t
ndi ns No. 1
999 S.
LEXI 1
S 8633,a *
t2

( hCi.
4t r Aug.1 1 )
0, 999 .
Alhoug t w e lpl a d f c ua a l ga i ns i a c pl i a e ac e e as t ue f
t
h he l- e de a t l le to n
om a nt r c pt d
r or

p r o e o d fut u g n , pa t wh d f ut d e n ta mit ealg to sa t t a u t
u p s s f ea lj d me t a ry o ea l o s o d t h le ain s o he mo n
s
o d ma e . e Fe . Ci. 8 b ( ) p o ii gt tçanalg to - oh r h no er ltn t
f a g s S e d R. v P. ( )6 ( r v dn ha ç q l ain t e t a n eaig o
g
e
2

t n omtofdn a s- i a itd i ar s
he m t
m ge s dm te f e ponsvepl a ng i r quie a t ale ton i no
i e di s e r d nd he lgai s t

d nid'. n e ue ty it ec u t ee mie ta la lt i etb ih d imu tte d tr ne
e e ' Co s q nl ,f h o r d tr n s h t ibi y s sa ls e ,t s h n ee mi
)
i
t a o it nmot ofda a s Rya 253F. a 78 81. n s doi t c u'm a c
he ppr pra e
mt
m ge . n,
3d t 0- l o ng, he ot t y onduc
t

a e d nir he rn u e Rul 5 ( )2 . ec u t yas ma ead tr n to o d ma e
n vie tay a ig nd r e 5 b () Th o r ma lo k eemiain f a g s
wihoutahe rng asl ast ei a a qua ee de i r ba i i t r or f t a r Se
t
ai
ong her s n de t vi nta y ss n he ec d or he wa d. e

An e s n,1 5F.d a 5 7( o igta Gns mecrl tn e ad src c u t n ei ad fut
d ro 5 3 t 0 n tn h t t o icz a c s itit o r e trng e a l
i
ms

j d me tma a r d ma e a c ran b efo t pla ig wih u hodn ahe rn )
u g n y wad a g s s e tia l r m he e dn s to t l ig aif'.
D i si
scus on

To e tb ih c p rg tifi e n ,Gwo ee n smu tb p o e :( )o es i o a
sa ls o y ih n rng me t l lme t s e r v n 1 wn rhp f
t

v ld c py ih,a () c p i g o c n tme tee n s o t wok t ta e o iia. Fes
ai o rg t nd 2 o y n f o si n lme t f he r ha r rgn l' it
'
Pu lm Ic v Rt a Te. r .l c, 9 U. 3 0 3 1( 9 )Thec u t le e t t an if s
b ' n . . l l lSevsn .4 9 S. 4 , 6 1 91. o r beiv s ha plitf ha
r
esa ihe t tbo h elm e sa e me .Pl n ifha s
tbls d ha t e nt r t aitf s hown t tde e ntco e t Phot r ph
ha f nda
pi d he
og a
a t t pl n if owned a vai c i .Thus t c twil a e s pl i ifs r quese
nd ha aitf
ld opyrght
, he our l ddr s antf e t d

rme is Plitf s e st er me isprvie b t eCo rg tAc,1 U. C.j 5 2 5 4()
e de . an if e k h e de o d d y h py ih t 7 S. j 0 , 0 c
a d 5 5 ()a ij n to p o btn f rhe i rn i us o t eP t g a h a d ()sato y
n 0 : 1 n nu cin r hiiig u t r nfigng e f h hoo rp , n 2 ttt r
z
da a si t nmountof$1 750.
m ge n he
5,

Th Co y ih Ac p o ie ta ç an c u t vn j s ito o acvla to aiig
e p rg t t r v d s h t i q y o r ha ig midcin f ii cin rsn
g
t e t stte ma . . rn tmp rr a fn lijmcin o s h tr a i ma d e
md r hi il y . g a t e o ay nd i a nt to s n uc e ms s t y e m
ra o a l t p e e t r e tanifig me t f c p g t'1 U. C. 5 2 a.n u ci er le
e s n b e o rv n o r sri n rn e n o a o pi h ' 7 S. j 0 ()lj n tv eif
i a o i t w he t na ur of t i rnge e pr ve s a a ua e r m edy a l w ,a a
s ppr pr a e
n he t e
he nf i m nt e nt n deq t e
t a nd

p r n n ij n to i e p cal a p o rae wh n atr a o c n iut i fig me te ss
e ma e t nu cin s s e ily p r p it e h e t f o tn ig n rn e n xit.
l
S eM . E. u i v Ki l. n . 1 9F. u p. d4 9 4 3( D. . .0 0 Cç ro sdsrc
e L. M sc . mb e I c, 0 S p 2 6 , 7 S. W Va2 0 ) vai u itit
co t wihi t scr ui ha he dt twhe aca m ofc pyrghti rnge e tha bee pr n,
urs t n hi ic t ve l ha
n li
o i nfi m n s n ove a

3

pema e tij n to p o btn f rhe ifig me t i a prp it a d r ui l e tr d' .
r n n nu cin r hiiig u t r n rn e n s s p o rae n o t y nee .)
ne
'
He e,pli if ha pr n a cli of c i i rnge nt a t r i no i c to t t
r antf s ove
am
opyrght nf i me nd he e s
ndi ai n ha
A
i

de e
f ndan i e
t ntnds t sop t i rng m e .Cons que l t cour fnds t t a pe ne
o t he nfi e nt
e nty, he
t i
ha
nna nt

ijmcini a prm it .
n l to s p o ae
TheCo rg tAc as al wsf rsauo y d ma e .Se 1 U. C.j5 4() 1 (ç
py ih t lo lo o tt tr n g s e 7 S.
0 c () t
The

c p rg to e ma ee t a a y t beo efn l u g n i rn e e , or c v r i ta o
o y ih wn r y lc, t n i
me f r i a j d me t s e d r d t e o e ,nse d f
acualdn a sa pr is a a r ofsa u o y dn a sf a1i rnge e s...n as ofno
t
m ge nd ott, n wa d tt t r m ge or 1 nfi m nt i um
t

ls t a $ 5 o mo çta $ 00 0a tec u t o i es u t' . p an ifma ee tsato y
e s h n 7 0 r r h n 3 ,0 s h o r c nsd r j s.) A litf y lc tttr
'
z
dn a s f co i i rnge e whehe or no t r i a uae e de e of t a t l
m ge or pyrght nfi m nt
t r
t he e s deq t vi nc
he c ua

d ma e s fee b plitf Se J c o v S uki,2 5 F.S p .2d 1 9 ,1 01 ( D.Ca.
a g s u frd y anif e a ks n . tr e 5
up
0 6 1 N.
l
2 0 ) Ditit c m' a e af r e wie ds rto i s tig d ma e a t s S e F. .
0 3 . src o t r fo d d d icein n et a g momt. e W
s
n
W o l rh Co v.Co tmpo ay Ars I . 3 4 U. 2 ,2313 ( 9 2 .l e e csn ti
owo t .
ne rr t. nc, 4 S. 28
-2 1 5 ) n x r iig h s
d srto ,ad srd c u tc n ie st e f lo n fco s ç 1 t e e p ns qs v d a d p ois
icein iti o r o sd r h olwig a tr : $ ) h x e e a e n r ft
(
ra db d fnd n si c n e to wi t ei rn e n ;2 r v n e l s b t panif ; n
e pe y e e a t n o n cin t h nfig me t () e e u s o t y he litfs a d
h
( )wh t rteifi e n wa wi f l ndkn wi o wheh ri wa a cd n a o ino e t'
3 ehe h n rng me t s l u a
l
o ng r t e t s c ie tl r n c n .
'
J s rla M us c Co. M CA . I
a pe il
i
.
nc. v. W i s LounR A s oc. 837
ng'
e
s ,

Supp. 1
59, 1
61

( . W . .9 3 . tt tr d ma e a ep iu al a p o raei c s si whc t ed fn a t
SD. Va1 9 ) S auo y a g s r m c lry p r p it n a e n ih h e e d n
hasf ie t m ot a de e e orpa tcpae i dic r t r by i r sng t difc t i
al d o
mt ny f ns
rii t n s ove y, he e nc ea i he fiuly n
a c r a ni an a t ldam a .J c o 255 F.Su 2d a 1101.H e e t pl i i fur es t
s e t i ng y c ua
ges a ks n,
pp.
t
r , he a ntf g he

c t o a r saut y dn a sof$1 750.
our t wa d t t or m ge
5,
l lgh o t f c t tt de e n ha de a t t de e nthasno de
n i t f he a t ha he f nda t s f uled,he f nda
t monsr t dt t
ta e ha
t i rnge nt we e imoce .I t ad,t pli if ha pld t t t i nge nt we e
he nfi me s r l
nt nse
he antf s e ha he nâi me s r

c mmitdwilul . mp . 1 By vru o t ed fut t c u t c e t t s alg to sa
o te l ly Co l ! 4. ite f h e a l,he o r a c ps he e l ain s
f
e
4

tue.Se Rya 253 F. a 780.W he t i rnge e i w ilu ,tc t t pialy a r
r
e
n,
3d t
n he nfi m nt s lf l &ours y c l wa d

s b tnilymo eta t mi mu o sauo yd ma e'EM IAp i M u i t c v. d u z
u sa tal r h n he ni m f tttr a g .
'
rl sc n . Ro dg e ,
6 1F. u p. d6 2 6 5 ( . N. 2 0 . i ce s da r t e-e t d tre tp r s o
9 S p 2 3 , 3 M D. C. 01 ) An n ra e wad t l s he eern upo e f
sv
t saue'1 (i n F. . o l rhCo, 4 U. a 2 3 . r, litf h sp e ta AAM
he ttt . d.ct g W W owo t .3 4 S. t 3 ) Hee p an if a ld h t
'
i
c e a pose t Pho ogr pht s ve ditnc URIs Pl i ifs kst e tm e t a ountof
opi d nd t d he t a o e n s i t
,. antf ee hr e i s he m
t mi mum sa t y a r f r e h vi ai n.Tadng i t co i r ton A AM ' wilul
he ni
tm or wa d o ac olto
l
n o nsde a i
s lf
i rnge nt a t dee f tze vi a i ,t c rtwil g a pli if 'r que t a a r
nfi me , nd o tr ' lr oltons he ou
u
l r nt a ntfs e s nd wa d

pl ntf at alof$1 750 i sa ut y da
ai if ot
5, n tt or mage .
s
Concl on
usi

Fo t e r a o sae ,t e c u twi g a tplitY s mo in f r d futj d me t
r h e s ns tt d h o r l rn an i
l
to o e a l u g n .
J
udgme wilbe e e e i fvo ofpl i if a i tAfi a Am e i a M a c ki i t
nt l
nt r d n a r
antf gans rc n
rc n t hma ng n he

a t o $1 ,5 ,a d Afia Ameia M ac madng wi be e j i d fo a y f rhe
momt f 57 0 n rc n
rc n th l
l
l n one r m n u t r
i rnge e .
nf i m nt

The Cl r i die t d t s nd c rii co e o t s m e and l opi o a t
ek s rce o e
e tfed pi s f hi
mor lm
ni n nd he
ac
c ompa ng or rt Afi a Am e i a M a c adngand alc
nyi
de o rc n
rc n thm l
l ouns lofr c d.
e
e or

DATED : i V M d yo Ma 2 7.
Ths
a f y, 01

ChifUnied St t DititJ
e
t
aes src udge