Harrington v. African American Matchmaking

Filing 10

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/8/17. (hnw)

Download PDF
I THE UN I N TED STA TES D I I COU RT STR CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI CT RGN A CHA M O TTESV I LLE DI I ON V SI CL ERKS OFFI U.. ST. CE S DI COURT ATROANOKE, VA FI LED MA 28 2 1 ï 27 , BY; D L CL EY ERK r/CL ERK BLAI HAI NE UUNGTON , Pli tf, a n if Ci lAc i No.3:6CV00084 vi ton 1 M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON NI AFRI CAN AM EI UCAN M A TCH M A K I G , N By:Hon. e E. Gln Conr d a ChifUnie St t sDititJ e t d a e src udge D e e nt f nda . Plitf Bli Harn o tdlrigtn'fldti c p rg tifig me t cin a an t anif ane rigtn s arn o ' ie h s o y ih n rn e n a to g is l l d fn a tAfia Ameia M ac madn ($ ' o De e e 1 , 5 algngvo ains ee d n rc n rc n th l g ç AAM ' n c mb r 4 201 , le i ilto ) o t e Co y ih Ac,1 U. C.j 1 e s q Th p an ifh sn w fld amoin frd fut f h p rg t t 7 S. 01 t e . e litf a o ie to o ea l j d me tu e Rul 5 ()o t Fe ea Rue o Cii P o e t e Fo t r a o s'ae t u g n nd r e 5b f he d rl ls f vl r c dl . r he e s n s td,he r t m oto wilbegr nt d. in l a e Fact Backeround ual I rv e n amoinf rd fulj g n ,h c u t c e t a t et welpe d d n e iwig to o ea tud me tt e o r a c p s s nz he l- la e f c a a lga i i t c a m l le tons n he ompl i a t la lt Se Rya v. ant s o i biiy. e n Homec ncsFi Newor 253 omi n. t k, F.d7 : 8 - (t Ci. 0 ) 3 78 7 0 81 4h r 2 01 . Thepl i ifi a ex re e c antf s n pe inc d, omm e c a ta la l a i phot a r Defnda i r i l r ve nd oc ton ogr phe . e nt s ama c ki a dai we ief Afi n- e i n i vi l . t hma ng nd tng bst or rca Am rca ndi dua s AAM c r nty has22, ure l 060 me e s On S p e e 1 2 01 tepanifc pl e t p ooga h û mb r . e tmb r , 0 ,h litf a tr d he h t rp ç 01 1 -2. g't z BER- - 9 0 j '(he p ç t r ph' a publs t Phot rph on Aprl 1 2011.Pli if rgitr d t i og a ), nd pho ihed he og a i 7, antf e see he Phot r ph wih t Unie Stt CopyrghtOfi e on Aprl26,2011.Be nni on ora ut og a t he t d a es i fc i gi ng bo Jme 1 201 t de e ntcopid a posed t Pho ogr ph t ac ompa a a tce o t t , 5, he f nda e nd t he t a o c ny n ri l n he e e t he we st f rAfia Ame ia M ac mn n (AM M ' .The def ndant copi d and posed t b i o rc n e rc n th kig 1 & ' ) Phot a on no l st n s ve ditnc URTs ogr ph es ha e n si t ,. Pli iffld t s c antf e hi oppi hti rnge e a ton agans AAM on De mbe 1 2015, g nfi m nt c i i t ce r 4, algi viltonsoft CopyrghtAc,1 U. C.j1 e sq. rcod s le ng oai he i t 7 S. 01 t e The e r howst tt owne ha he r ofAfi a Am e i a M a c l wass r ed on J nua y 3,201 To da e Afi a Ame i a rc n rc n t hmadng ev a r 7. t , rc n rc n M atbm a ng ha no fl a r po i pl a ng.An e r ofde a twa fld agans Afi a c ki s t ied es nsve e di nty f ul s e i t rc n Ameia M ac mn i go F b ay1 , 01 , u s a t oRue5 ()o t Fe e a Rulso Cii rc n th k n n e nlr 0 2 7 p ru n t l 5 a fhe d r l e f vl P o e u e Plitf h sn w mo e f rd f utud me tThema tri rp f rrv e r c d r . an if a o v b o ea lj g n . te s ie o e iw. St andard ofR evi w e Un e Rul 5 o ' e Fe ea Ru e o Cii Pr c d r ,d fulj d me ti at -tp d r e 5 ft d rl ls f v l o e u e ea t u g n s wo se h p o e s Se J fes n v Brn r l .4 F. u p. d4 0 4 3 ( D. . 0 6 . irt e tyo r c s . e efro . ie .nc, 61 S p 2 3 , 3 E. Va 2 0 ) Pro o nr f d futj d me t t r mu tb a e ty o d fut S eFe R.Ci P. 5 a . trd ful i ea l u g n, hee s e n nr f ea l. e d. v. 5 () Afe ea t s e trdb t eClr , p ryma mo etec ur f rd fulj d me t nd rRue5 () n ee y h ek a a t y v h o t o ea t u g n u e l 5b . Upon de a t al oft welplade f t a l ed i t c f ul, 1 he l- e d acs leg n he ompli m a bet ke a tu ant y a n s r e. Se Rm n,25 F.d a 7 0 (ç h d fn a t b li d fu t a misp an ifs welp e d d e 3 3 t 8 çTj e ee d n , y zs ea l, d t litf' l la e l - alg to so f cl ' (nen l iaino te ) s eas Fe . Ci P. ( )6 . c r igy,n le ain f a t.' itr a ctto mitd ; e lo d R. v. 8 b () Ac o dn l i j) ted fut u g n c ne t t t p r p it iq iyi wh te o n ttefc o t epla i g h ea lj d me t o tx ,he t p o rae n ur s eh r r o h a e f h e d n s a s p rs te d ful j d me t a d t e c us s o a to te en. An e s n v Fo n .f r u po t h ea t u g n n h a e f cin h r i ' d ro . u d o ' Adva e nt Educ.& Emp' ofAm .l a , 99- 508,1 U. App. nc me . t ndi ns No. 1 999 S. LEXI 1 S 8633,a * t2 ( hCi. 4t r Aug.1 1 ) 0, 999 . Alhoug t w e lpl a d f c ua a l ga i ns i a c pl i a e ac e e as t ue f t h he l- e de a t l le to n om a nt r c pt d r or p r o e o d fut u g n , pa t wh d f ut d e n ta mit ealg to sa t t a u t u p s s f ea lj d me t a ry o ea l o s o d t h le ain s o he mo n s o d ma e . e Fe . Ci. 8 b ( ) p o ii gt tçanalg to - oh r h no er ltn t f a g s S e d R. v P. ( )6 ( r v dn ha ç q l ain t e t a n eaig o g e 2 t n omtofdn a s- i a itd i ar s he m t m ge s dm te f e ponsvepl a ng i r quie a t ale ton i no i e di s e r d nd he lgai s t d nid'. n e ue ty it ec u t ee mie ta la lt i etb ih d imu tte d tr ne e e ' Co s q nl ,f h o r d tr n s h t ibi y s sa ls e ,t s h n ee mi ) i t a o it nmot ofda a s Rya 253F. a 78 81. n s doi t c u'm a c he ppr pra e mt m ge . n, 3d t 0- l o ng, he ot t y onduc t a e d nir he rn u e Rul 5 ( )2 . ec u t yas ma ead tr n to o d ma e n vie tay a ig nd r e 5 b () Th o r ma lo k eemiain f a g s wihoutahe rng asl ast ei a a qua ee de i r ba i i t r or f t a r Se t ai ong her s n de t vi nta y ss n he ec d or he wa d. e An e s n,1 5F.d a 5 7( o igta Gns mecrl tn e ad src c u t n ei ad fut d ro 5 3 t 0 n tn h t t o icz a c s itit o r e trng e a l i ms j d me tma a r d ma e a c ran b efo t pla ig wih u hodn ahe rn ) u g n y wad a g s s e tia l r m he e dn s to t l ig aif'. D i si scus on To e tb ih c p rg tifi e n ,Gwo ee n smu tb p o e :( )o es i o a sa ls o y ih n rng me t l lme t s e r v n 1 wn rhp f t v ld c py ih,a () c p i g o c n tme tee n s o t wok t ta e o iia. Fes ai o rg t nd 2 o y n f o si n lme t f he r ha r rgn l' it ' Pu lm Ic v Rt a Te. r .l c, 9 U. 3 0 3 1( 9 )Thec u t le e t t an if s b ' n . . l l lSevsn .4 9 S. 4 , 6 1 91. o r beiv s ha plitf ha r esa ihe t tbo h elm e sa e me .Pl n ifha s tbls d ha t e nt r t aitf s hown t tde e ntco e t Phot r ph ha f nda pi d he og a a t t pl n if owned a vai c i .Thus t c twil a e s pl i ifs r quese nd ha aitf ld opyrght , he our l ddr s antf e t d rme is Plitf s e st er me isprvie b t eCo rg tAc,1 U. C.j 5 2 5 4() e de . an if e k h e de o d d y h py ih t 7 S. j 0 , 0 c a d 5 5 ()a ij n to p o btn f rhe i rn i us o t eP t g a h a d ()sato y n 0 : 1 n nu cin r hiiig u t r nfigng e f h hoo rp , n 2 ttt r z da a si t nmountof$1 750. m ge n he 5, Th Co y ih Ac p o ie ta ç an c u t vn j s ito o acvla to aiig e p rg t t r v d s h t i q y o r ha ig midcin f ii cin rsn g t e t stte ma . . rn tmp rr a fn lijmcin o s h tr a i ma d e md r hi il y . g a t e o ay nd i a nt to s n uc e ms s t y e m ra o a l t p e e t r e tanifig me t f c p g t'1 U. C. 5 2 a.n u ci er le e s n b e o rv n o r sri n rn e n o a o pi h ' 7 S. j 0 ()lj n tv eif i a o i t w he t na ur of t i rnge e pr ve s a a ua e r m edy a l w ,a a s ppr pr a e n he t e he nf i m nt e nt n deq t e t a nd p r n n ij n to i e p cal a p o rae wh n atr a o c n iut i fig me te ss e ma e t nu cin s s e ily p r p it e h e t f o tn ig n rn e n xit. l S eM . E. u i v Ki l. n . 1 9F. u p. d4 9 4 3( D. . .0 0 Cç ro sdsrc e L. M sc . mb e I c, 0 S p 2 6 , 7 S. W Va2 0 ) vai u itit co t wihi t scr ui ha he dt twhe aca m ofc pyrghti rnge e tha bee pr n, urs t n hi ic t ve l ha n li o i nfi m n s n ove a 3 pema e tij n to p o btn f rhe ifig me t i a prp it a d r ui l e tr d' . r n n nu cin r hiiig u t r n rn e n s s p o rae n o t y nee .) ne ' He e,pli if ha pr n a cli of c i i rnge nt a t r i no i c to t t r antf s ove am opyrght nf i me nd he e s ndi ai n ha A i de e f ndan i e t ntnds t sop t i rng m e .Cons que l t cour fnds t t a pe ne o t he nfi e nt e nty, he t i ha nna nt ijmcini a prm it . n l to s p o ae TheCo rg tAc as al wsf rsauo y d ma e .Se 1 U. C.j5 4() 1 (ç py ih t lo lo o tt tr n g s e 7 S. 0 c () t The c p rg to e ma ee t a a y t beo efn l u g n i rn e e , or c v r i ta o o y ih wn r y lc, t n i me f r i a j d me t s e d r d t e o e ,nse d f acualdn a sa pr is a a r ofsa u o y dn a sf a1i rnge e s...n as ofno t m ge nd ott, n wa d tt t r m ge or 1 nfi m nt i um t ls t a $ 5 o mo çta $ 00 0a tec u t o i es u t' . p an ifma ee tsato y e s h n 7 0 r r h n 3 ,0 s h o r c nsd r j s.) A litf y lc tttr ' z dn a s f co i i rnge e whehe or no t r i a uae e de e of t a t l m ge or pyrght nfi m nt t r t he e s deq t vi nc he c ua d ma e s fee b plitf Se J c o v S uki,2 5 F.S p .2d 1 9 ,1 01 ( D.Ca. a g s u frd y anif e a ks n . tr e 5 up 0 6 1 N. l 2 0 ) Ditit c m' a e af r e wie ds rto i s tig d ma e a t s S e F. . 0 3 . src o t r fo d d d icein n et a g momt. e W s n W o l rh Co v.Co tmpo ay Ars I . 3 4 U. 2 ,2313 ( 9 2 .l e e csn ti owo t . ne rr t. nc, 4 S. 28 -2 1 5 ) n x r iig h s d srto ,ad srd c u tc n ie st e f lo n fco s ç 1 t e e p ns qs v d a d p ois icein iti o r o sd r h olwig a tr : $ ) h x e e a e n r ft ( ra db d fnd n si c n e to wi t ei rn e n ;2 r v n e l s b t panif ; n e pe y e e a t n o n cin t h nfig me t () e e u s o t y he litfs a d h ( )wh t rteifi e n wa wi f l ndkn wi o wheh ri wa a cd n a o ino e t' 3 ehe h n rng me t s l u a l o ng r t e t s c ie tl r n c n . ' J s rla M us c Co. M CA . I a pe il i . nc. v. W i s LounR A s oc. 837 ng' e s , Supp. 1 59, 1 61 ( . W . .9 3 . tt tr d ma e a ep iu al a p o raei c s si whc t ed fn a t SD. Va1 9 ) S auo y a g s r m c lry p r p it n a e n ih h e e d n hasf ie t m ot a de e e orpa tcpae i dic r t r by i r sng t difc t i al d o mt ny f ns rii t n s ove y, he e nc ea i he fiuly n a c r a ni an a t ldam a .J c o 255 F.Su 2d a 1101.H e e t pl i i fur es t s e t i ng y c ua ges a ks n, pp. t r , he a ntf g he c t o a r saut y dn a sof$1 750. our t wa d t t or m ge 5, l lgh o t f c t tt de e n ha de a t t de e nthasno de n i t f he a t ha he f nda t s f uled,he f nda t monsr t dt t ta e ha t i rnge nt we e imoce .I t ad,t pli if ha pld t t t i nge nt we e he nfi me s r l nt nse he antf s e ha he nâi me s r c mmitdwilul . mp . 1 By vru o t ed fut t c u t c e t t s alg to sa o te l ly Co l ! 4. ite f h e a l,he o r a c ps he e l ain s f e 4 tue.Se Rya 253 F. a 780.W he t i rnge e i w ilu ,tc t t pialy a r r e n, 3d t n he nfi m nt s lf l &ours y c l wa d s b tnilymo eta t mi mu o sauo yd ma e'EM IAp i M u i t c v. d u z u sa tal r h n he ni m f tttr a g . ' rl sc n . Ro dg e , 6 1F. u p. d6 2 6 5 ( . N. 2 0 . i ce s da r t e-e t d tre tp r s o 9 S p 2 3 , 3 M D. C. 01 ) An n ra e wad t l s he eern upo e f sv t saue'1 (i n F. . o l rhCo, 4 U. a 2 3 . r, litf h sp e ta AAM he ttt . d.ct g W W owo t .3 4 S. t 3 ) Hee p an if a ld h t ' i c e a pose t Pho ogr pht s ve ditnc URIs Pl i ifs kst e tm e t a ountof opi d nd t d he t a o e n s i t ,. antf ee hr e i s he m t mi mum sa t y a r f r e h vi ai n.Tadng i t co i r ton A AM ' wilul he ni tm or wa d o ac olto l n o nsde a i s lf i rnge nt a t dee f tze vi a i ,t c rtwil g a pli if 'r que t a a r nfi me , nd o tr ' lr oltons he ou u l r nt a ntfs e s nd wa d pl ntf at alof$1 750 i sa ut y da ai if ot 5, n tt or mage . s Concl on usi Fo t e r a o sae ,t e c u twi g a tplitY s mo in f r d futj d me t r h e s ns tt d h o r l rn an i l to o e a l u g n . J udgme wilbe e e e i fvo ofpl i if a i tAfi a Am e i a M a c ki i t nt l nt r d n a r antf gans rc n rc n t hma ng n he a t o $1 ,5 ,a d Afia Ameia M ac madng wi be e j i d fo a y f rhe momt f 57 0 n rc n rc n th l l l n one r m n u t r i rnge e . nf i m nt The Cl r i die t d t s nd c rii co e o t s m e and l opi o a t ek s rce o e e tfed pi s f hi mor lm ni n nd he ac c ompa ng or rt Afi a Am e i a M a c adngand alc nyi de o rc n rc n thm l l ouns lofr c d. e e or DATED : i V M d yo Ma 2 7. Ths a f y, 01 ChifUnied St t DititJ e t aes src udge

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?