Simon et al v. Regal Investment Advisors LLC et al
Filing
36
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 04/28/2017. (ssm)
CLERK' OFFI
S
C
EU.
S. ST
ATROANOKEDI . O URT
FIED ,VA
L
I THE UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STY CT COURT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGW I
A
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON
AF2 23 2 7
2
J
BY:
RO LAN D H . SI ON ,e a .
M
t 1,
Pl i if,
antfs
3 t
cLEfK
.
W CL
ERK
Ci lAc i N o.3:6CV00090
vi ton
1
M EM O M N D U M O PI I N
N O
REGA L I VESTM EN T A DV I
N
SORS
LLC,e a .
t 1,
Hon.Gln E.Conr d
e
a
Chi fUnied St t s Di t i tJ e
e
t
a e s rc udg
D e e nt
f nda s.
Pli if Rolnd H.Si
antfs a
mon,Ca l R.Aye s Ea lRiha d Br
ros
r , r c r ownl ,I ,a J n M ai
ee I nd a
n
Th ma fld t i a to a an tRe a Ive t n Ad io sLLC ($ A' a d fl i i iu l
o s ie hs cin g i s g l n sme t v s r
G ' n oz ndvd a
RI )
r
de e nt i t Cic tCour f r t Cot y of Al m a l s ki m one ar dn a s f
f nda s n he r ui
t o he mt
be re, ee ng
t y m ge or
al ge vi ai ns of sa e a f de a lw . RI a t e of t i vi l de e nt
le d ol to
t t nd e r l a
A nd hr e
he ndi dua f nda s
(olciey, h ç g lDee a t' rmo e t c s t ti c u to te g o n so f d r l
c le tv l t e l a fnd n s' e v d he a e o h s o r n h r u d f e ea
Re
)
q eto a ddv ri u idcin. T plitfsh v mo e t r ma t c s t saec u t n
u sin n iest rs ito he an if a e v d o e nd he a e o tt o r o
yj
t bass t tt f t i vi lde e n ,J s M a tn Ba nes di nottmel co entt
he i ha he ourh ndi dua f nda t ame
ri r , d
i y ns o
r m ova . Thecour hel a he zng on t pl i if moton t r m a on M a c 22,201 For
e
l
t d
ai
he antfs' i o e nd
rh
7.
t f l ng r as ,t c twilgr ntt moton a r ma t c s t sat c t
he olowi e ons he our l a he i nd e nd he a e o t e our.
Backzro
und
The pl ntfsa e r tr d e o s oft Uni r iy ofVigi a. I t 1 0s Ba ne
ai if r e ie mpl yee
he ve st
r ni n he 98 , r s
i r uc d hi e ft t pli if as a Uni r ip a oved fna i a s . Ea h of t
ntod e ms l o he antfs
ve st ppr
i ncal dvior
c
he
pl i if bec me a ci ntofBa nes a alowe hi t m a ge t rr tr me ac ount . I
antfs a
le
r
nd l d m o na hei eie nt c s n
201 whie w or ng f r RI ,Ba nes ale dl de r uded t pl ntf s by c nc ng t m t
4, l
ki o A
r
l ge y f a
he ai if
onvi i he o
i s i aNorh Ca olnast de l e ta c t u ton co pa known a Trt n Sie k
nve t n
t r i ie veopm n nd onsr c i
m ny
s io t wor
De l
veopmen (1 io '. Unbe wns t t pl ntfs Bane wasapa towne ofTrt a
t $Trtn'
)
kno t o he ai if, r s
r
r
ion, nd
t c
he ompa wasG r adyunde goi ba kr cy'a t tm eBn ne c nc d t m t i s i
ny
t e
al
r ng n upt ' t he i
r s onvi e he o nve t n
i. Co . 5 Do ke No 1 1 Asar s l o Ba n s a to s t eplitfsGos tee trt o
t mpl! 4, c t . - .
eut f r e ' cin ,h anif ç th n iey f
l
t r prndpa i t e t alng $1808, 2, a wel a $ tnc e sr n ' pr ie by
hei i l nvesm nt ot i
, 80 5 s l s he s om te m ' om s d
'
i
Ba n s I . t 7
r e . d a ! 2.
l Nove
n
mberof201 t pli if fld s tagans t Re lDe e nt a Bn ne i
6, he antf s ie ui i t he ga f nda s nd r s n
t Cic tCo tf rt Coun y ofAl
he r ui ur o he
t
bema l ,a s ri cli f br c ofc r c , glge e
re s e tng a ms or ea h onta t ne i nc ,
br c offd ir dut f a a vi a i o sa ea f de a s c ii l ws Att tm et
ea h i uca y y, r ud, nd oltons f tt nd e r l e urtes a .
he i he
aci wa fl no oft de e n s r sde i Vigi a. Ac or ngl on N o mbe 30,
ton s ied, ne
he f nda t e i d n r ni
c di y,
ve r
201 t pli tfss r dt de e nt t oug t Se r t r oft Comm onweat pur ua t
6, he a n if e ve he f nda s hr h he c e a y he
1h, s nt o
Vign a Co e j 801 3 ( . On De e e 1 2 6 t e S ceay o t e Co n at
r ii d
. - 29 C)
c mb r , 01 , h e rtr f h mmo we l
h
f wa de t compl nt a s
or r d he
ai nd umm o by c riid m a l t t de enda s The Re l
ns
e tfe
i o he f nt .
ga
De e n s ea h o whom r sdesi M i hi n, ec i t ce tfedm alon ora o De embe
f nda t , c f
e i n c ga r eved he rii
i
r und c
r
201 On De e be 1 201 t Se r t r of t Co monwe t fld Ce tt a e o
6.
c m r 6, 6, he c e a y
he m
a1h ie
ri t s f
k
Co planc i t Cic tCo twhi hti r t de e n s tm et fl r s nsvepl di
m i e n he r ui ur, c rgge ed he f nda t ' i o ie e po i ea ngs
u d rj8013 ( .
n e . - 29 C)
On De mbe 23,201 t Rega De e nt r moved t c e t t sco t I t i
ce r
6, he
l f nda s e
he as o hi ur. n he r
no i ofr m ova ,t Re lDef nda sal d,tupon i o m a i a belef' t tBa ne had
tce e
l he ga
e nt lege '
nf r ton nd i y ha r s
'
t o y tb e p o el sr e wih pr c s . No ie o Re va ! 27 Do ke No.1 Th y
f t e e n r p ry e v d t o e s' tc f mo l , c t
n
'
. e
f rhe alege G
u t r l d, l
upon i or ton a bei f't te n i Ba nesha be pr ry s r e wih
nf ma i nd le ,'ha ve f r
d en ope l e v d t
pr c s ,çewo dc n e t oter mo a o t eSaeCo r Acint t sCo r. I a !2 .
o esç
h ul o s n t h e v l f h tt u t to o hi u t' d. t 8
'
OnJ nuar 23, 7,hepl i if tm ey movedt r m u a s ri t tBa ne hadbe n
a y 201 t antfs i l
o e nd, s e tng ha r s
e
pr pe l s r e wihpr e s a t t r movalwa pr e al de eci f l c ofco e
o ry e v d t oc s , nd hat he e
s oc dur ly f tve or a k
ns nt
byaldee nt. Se 28U. C. 1 (W motont rma t ca eont bassofa defc
l fnda s e
S. j 447 1
i o e nd he s he i ny e t
2
oh rt a lc o s b e tmatrjzid cin mus b ma ewihn 3 d y a trt efln o t e
t e h n a k f u j c te l s ito
r
t e d t i 0 a s fe h iig f h
noieo r mo a un e s cin 1 46a .)
tc f e v l d r e to 4 ()'.
'
On J nua y 26,2017 t Re lDe e nt fl a ç i e ofBar s c e t r m o l
a r
, he ga f nda s ied c c
not
ne ' ons nt o e va
a s e nt lno i e ofr m o l' Supp' Notc Doc tNo.17. The s e nt lnotc
nd uppl me a tc
e va .
'
l ie, ke
uppl me a i e
was a co pa e by a J ua y 26, 201 e a l f om a a t r y i N orh Ca olna e es i
c m ni d
an r
7 m i r
n to ne n
t r i xpr s ng
Ban s c n e t1 Se Sup ' Notce Ex A, c e No 1 - ($ NC Co n e f rDee d n
re' o sn. e p1 i
Do k t . 7 1 ç
As
u s l o fn a t
.
J mesM a tn Ba ne ,pl a e a c t s e la hi c e tt t r m o oft sma t t US
n
ri r s e s c ept hi mai s s ons n o he e val hi ter o
DititCo r f rteW e tr Ditito Vigna Chalte vleDi so ' .
src u t o h
sen src f r ii, ro ts il viin.)
'
Thepl n if s eq n l m o t srket s e e t no i eont ba i t ti wa
aitf s ubs ue ty ved o ti he upplm n al tc
he ss ha t s
fl d m o et n 30 da a t rB a ne w a s r d w ih pr e s I r s
ie
r ha
ys f e r s s e ve t oc s . n e pons t t pl ntf s flng,
e o he ai i f ' ii
t Re lDe e n s s
he ga f nda t ubmit d a a fda tfom Bn ne ,i whih he e aned t thewasno
te n fi vi r
r s n c
xpl i ha
t
c r nty r sdi a t a e si Dur m ,Nolh Car i whe e t s mons a c
ure l e i ng t he ddr s n
hn
'
t
olna
r he um
nd ompl i
ant
ha be n m a l d. Bar s a s r e t the c m e i o pos e s on oft s m onson D e m be 24,
d e
ie
ne s e t d ha
a nt
ss i
he um
ce r
201 b di notr c ve a co o t c pl i untlD e em be 28,201 Bnn sAfi ! 57,
6, ut d
e ei
py f he om a nt i c
r
6. r e fd. ! -
Doc tNo. - .
ke
28 1
The pl ntfss e nty r se a obt ne l a t de e Ba ne r ga di t
ai if ubs que l eque t d nd ai d e ve o pos r s e r ng he
sa e nt c aned i hi afi vi. On M a c 1 2017 t ee da be or t s hed e
tt me s ont i
n s fda t
r h 7,
, hr
ys f e he c ul d
de ii t Reg De e nt fld a c r c e a fda t f o Ba nes I t c r c e
poston, he
al f nda s ie
ore t d fi vi ' m
r
r . n he ore t d
a f da t Ba nes e a ne t t hi s s e w a r s d ng a t a es i D ur m w he e t
f i vi, r
xpl i d ha s it r s e i i t he ddr s n
ha
r he
s
umm o a co pl n had be n m al
ns nd m ait
e
ied. On De m be 24,201 whie viii hi sse ,
ce r
6, l stng s it r
Ba nes was gi n a s a k ofm a lt thad be n s ntt he r s de e. H ow e r Ba nes di no
r
ve
tc
i ha
e e o r e i nc
ve , r
d t
ope t ma la t ttm e Ove t ne f w days Bn n r ceveda to lie t tha be n
n he i t ha i .
r he xt e
, r es e i
ddii na t ms ha d e
lAlhough Ba nesr ve as it nce fom an ator y i Norh Car i , he i curenty pr
t
r ecei d ss a
r
t ne n
t
olna
s r l oceedi
ng
pr s
o e.
ma ld t hi sse ' a e s On De mbe 28 201 Ba ne ope d apa kage t tco a ne
ie o s itrs ddr s .
ce r , 6, r s ne
c
ha nt i d
t c
he ompl i fl d i t Cic t Cour f t Cot y ofAl m a l . Ba nesi c t d i t
ant ie n he r ui
t or he mt
be re
r
ndia e n he
c re td afd v t h thed e G o k o wh n t s mmo so c mplitsrtc mei t ( iq
o rce fia i t a
o s t t n w e he u n r o an s a no hs
n
p se so ' Bnn sCo rce Afi . 1 , c e No 3 - . At h c n lso o tec re td
o ss in. r e re td fd ! 4 Do k t . 2 1 t e o cu in f h o rce
'
a fda tBn ne not dt theha s f r as re o de lt tngl s si r e ye r , c ha
fi vi, r s e ha
d ufe ed e is f biiai os e n ec nt a s whi h d
ld hi t s e te t e tfom physca a m e t lhe lh c r pr vi r Ba nesalo sa e t t
e m o e k ram n r
i l nd n a at a e o de s. r
s tt d ha
h ' i a dd gs c n e t otermo a'o tea to t f d rlc u t I a !20
e i d n o e q o s n t h e v l f h cin o e ea o r. d. t ( .
d
'
Ba ne wa de e on M a c 20,201 Durngt de ii Bn ne i taly t si d
r s s pos d
rh
7.
i he poston, r s nii l e tfe
t tt e o c ani t su ùons a c
ha he nvelpe ont i ng he t nr
nd ompli was t
ant
t i ly ha
physca l nded' t hi on
'o m
De mbe 24,201 BanesDe 45 Doc tNo.34;s e as j. a 45- (ç rceved bot
ce r
6. r
p.
ke
e lo . t 46 ç e i
#
1
h
d c me t o te s me d y o e e a d r a boh d c me t f u d y ltr o te 28h.)
o u n s n h a a , p n d n e d t o u n s o r a s ae, n h t '.
'
Howe r Ba nes lt r t sii d t the wa no a ol el c ran as t whe he r ceved t
ve , r
ae e tfe ha
s t bs ut y e ti
o
n
e i
he
s mmo sa c mpli t S eL.a 7 75(W he I sa k db myatr e . .mj a we t
u n nd o an . e d t 4- t n wa s e y
a
s
to n y, . ( y ns r o
he wasno,1c n' s rde i tvel t tIha r c ved t tpa kage ...on De mbe 24t
r
a t wea fnii y ha
d e ei ha c
ce r h.
c t' . Hema cea,ho ve,t tt s
an'.)
'
de l r we r ha he ummo a c antwe eco ane i t sme
ns nd ompli r nti d n he a
e v lp ,a ta h r c i e t m o t e s me d y Se i .a 4 (ç dd tr c ie (h
n eo e nd h t e e ev d he n h a a . e d t 5 $ in' e ev t e
I
s mmo sa dc mpan)o t s p rt d y . Ir c ie b t d c me t o tes med y.)
u n n o lit n wo e aae a s e ev d oh o u n s n h a a ';
'
1 a 5 (n iai gt a thee v lp 'c nann t sl nsa d c mp an wa gv nt hi
d. t 0 idc tn h t t n eo e' o ti ig he l
t
mmo n o lit s ie o m
o t e2 t o De e e, u t a h ddn ttp ng i' n it 28h' (mp ssa d d ;d. t
n h 4 h f c mb r b th t e i o S e ) f u tlhe t ' e hai d e )I a 78
o
)
( susi whe hebe a a r of(hee se eoft pa ka 'a Gt c e sc ai d
dic sng n
c me wa e G xitnc he c ge' nd the ontnt ont ne
t
wihi t tpa ge' (mphassadde . Att c uson ofhi de ii Banesrieae
t n ha cka ') e
i
d)
he oncl i
s poston, r etrtd
ta h S n gqgh c s )t b i fd r l o r. I . t8
h t e û ts t e a e o e n e e a c u t' d a 4.
wa
'
4
St
andard ofRevi
ew
S dea c u t ae c u t o l td j rs ito , wh c G o s s o l ta p we
i r l o rs r o rs f i e u id ci n' ih s se s n y h t o r
Fe
mi
'
p
a horze b Consiu i a sa u e.' Kokkone v.Guar a Lie l .Co.ofAm . 511U .
ut i d y
tt ton nd tt t '
n
din f ns
,
S.
3 5 3 7 ( 9 4 . Ac o dn l,te c u tmus d r sz ta a c u e le o ti et i l td
7 , 7 1 9 ) c r i gy h o r
t G el h t a s is u sd h s i e
p me
mi
j rs ito ,...a d te b r e o e tbl hng te c nrr r ss u o t pa t a s ri
u idcin
n h u d n f sa i i h o tay e t p n he ry se t
s
ng
j rs ito ' Bab t v.n ' Un o , 4 F.d 5 9 6 5( t Ci. 01 )(nba c (b o ae i
u idcin. r ol Itl i n 6 0 3 9 , 0 4h r 2 1 e n ) a r g td n
'
r
pa to ot rgr
r n he oundsby t Fe r lCo t Jliditon a Ve Clrfcai n Ac of2011 Pu
he de a urs trs c i nd nue a ii to
t
, b.
L. 1 2-3 1 5S a . 5 ( c 7 2 1
No. 1 6 , 2 tt 7 8 De . , 01 $.
fRe
d movalsaut s i pa tc a ,mus be srcl consnz d,i s uc a t r m ova o
t t e , n riulr
t tity
t e na m h s he e
l f
c s s f om s a e t f de a co tr i es s gnii a f de als co e ns ' I ;s e a s Di v.
ae r
t t o e r l ur a s i f c nt e r i m nc r .' d. e l o xon
Co u :Dar I .3 9 F.d 8 1 8 6(t Ci. 0 4 ( oi gta f d r lc u t C r o lg dt
b r iy.nc, 6 3 1 , 1 4h r 2 0 ) n tn h t e ea o rs G e bi e o
a
c n tu rmo l u id cin srcl b c us o t sg iia tf d rls c n ensi iae '
o sr e e va j rs ito tity e a e f he in fc n e eaim o c r mpl td'
c )
(nen lq oain makso t d . Th s a y d u t a o tt ep o it o r mo ls o l be
itr a u tto r mit ) u , n o b s b u h r prey f e va h u d
e
r s ve a i tt f de alf u a i f vorofr ma i t c et sa ec t Ba bour 640
e ol d gans he e r or m nd n a
e nd ng he as o t t our. r ,
F.d a 6 5 s e as Paia e Colcin LLC v.S rs 5 2 F.d 3 7 3 6 ( t Ci.2 0 )
3 t 0 ; e lo l d s le to s
s
ho t, 5 3 2 , 3 4h r 0 8
(mp szng ta c u t ha e a S uy t c n t e rmo lj rs ito slcl a d r s le a1
e ha ii h t o rs v ç t o o snl e va u idcin t ty n e ov l
d
i
d u t i fvo o rma d); a s alv. n leSae Co p,6F.d 2 , 3 (t Ci.1 9 )
o bs n a r f e n ' M rh l Ma vi ls r . 3 29 2 2 4h r 9 3
l
(e o nzn G n rs 'ce ritnin t r src rmo la d t r s le a1d u t a o tt e
rc g iig ç g e s la n e to o e tit e va n o e ov 1 o b s b u h
co
p o ryo rmo a i fv ro rti dsaec u tu idcin'.
rpet f e v l n a o f eane tt o rj rs ito '
)
D i cussi
s
on
I t s c e,t pa tes diput r r ng t pr it ofr movalbois do t t
n hi as he ri ' s e ega di he oprey
e
l wn o wo
is s ( )whehe Ba pr ryco e e t rmo l a ( i not whehe t spr e al
s ue : 1
t r nws ope l nsntd o e va; nd 2) f , t r hi oc dur
de e t s d be de m e c e i lghtofB a ne exp e s d des r t ltga e t c s i f de a
f c houl
e d ur d n i
r s' r s e
i e o ii t he a e n e r l
c t Theco ta es e e h oft eis i t n a c l
our.
ur ddr s s ac
hes s ues n ur nd oncudest tr m a i war nt
ha e nd s r a ed.
1.
A denuacv ofB arnes'Consent
Se ton 1 a ofTil 28oft Unie SttsCodepr vi st tShedee ntort
ci 441()
te
he td ae
o de ha ç
t fnda
he
def n s' a r m ove i ny cvi a ton br
enda t 'm y e
f
a i l ci
oughti a Stt c tofwhih t diti tc t of
n
a e our
c he src ours
t Untd S ae h veo ii a j rs ito ' 2 U. C.j 1 41a . t e to 1 46 o Til 28
he i tts a rgn l u idcin. 8 S.
e
'
4 () t cin 4 f te
s
d srb st a prp it r mo a p o e u et iv k fd rlu id ci n. Babo r 6 0F.da
e ci e he p o rae e v l r c d r o n o e e e a j rs ito ' r u , 4 3 t
'
605. Thi sa t , c wa nme
s tm e whih s ndedbyt Fe r Co t J iditon a Ve Clrfc ton
he de al urs urs c i nd nue a iia i
Ac o 201 (J
t f 1 t CVA', r v d s i pe t e t a ta f lo :
$
' p o ie ,n ri n p r, s olws
)
n
( Re rme s ge r ly.- () The notc ofr
b) quie nt; neal
1
ie emova of a cvi a ton o
l
i l ci r
pr e ngs l befld wihi 30 da a trt r eptby t de e
oce di ha l ie t n
ys fe he ec i
he f ndan ,t oug
t hr h
s r i oro he wie, ac oft i tal ea ng ...;
e vce t r s of opy he nii pl di
( )A)W h n acvia to i r mo e s eyu d rs cin 1 41a , 1d fn a t
2(
e i l cin s e v d oll n e e to 4 () a1 e e d n s
whoha bee pr ry i i d a s ve m us i n i orc e t t r m ova of
ve n ope l o ne - nd er d t oi n ons nt o he e
l
t a ton.
he c i
'
( Ea hd fnd n s alh v 30d y a trr c itb o s r ieo t a d fnd n
B) c ee a t h l a e a s fe e ep y r evc n h t ee a t
o t eiiilp e dngo s mmo sd srb d i paa rp ( )t fl t noieo
f h nta la i r u n e c ie n rg a h 1 o ie he tc f
rm o l
e va .
( I d fn a t a es r e a d fee ttme , n altrs r e d fn a tflsa
C) f ee d ns r ev d t ifrn i s a d ae-ev d ee d n ie
no i e of r m ova ,a ea le - e ve de e ntm a c e t t r m ova e n
tc
e
l ny ri r j r d f nda
y ons nt o he e
l ve
t h t t e rir s l d de e
houg ha a le -ewe
f ndan di no pr vi usy i ta e or cons nt t
t d t e o l niit
e o
rem oval
.
28U.. j 1 4 ( )
SC. 4 6 b .
The 2011 a e
m ndme s c fe t wel- t bls û ue of una m iy' a ia e t
nt odii d he
lesa ihed s l
r
ni t ' pplc bl o
c s s iv li g mutpl d f n a t,whc rq ie t a a1d fn a t j i i o c nsn t
a e n ov n li e e e d n s ih e ur s h t l e e d n s on n r o e t o
r mova. Se L seas Ha todFiel .Co. Hare vil M ut I .Co.736F. 255,259
e
l e 4; e lo rf r r ns v. lys le .ns ,
3d
( h Ci.201 (ç SuprmeCour ha consr d ( 1 a 1 ofTil 28 t r quiea1
4t r 3) $
The e
t s tue jj 441 nd 446
te ) o e r 1
d fn a t i ac s t j i i o c nsn t r mo a, r ai tes -ald çteo u nmi ')
e e d n s n a e o on n r o e t o e v lce tng h o c le rl f na i t '
l
y.'
Then nd e t alor ol d acic ts i a t whe t 30- y r m o lpe i begnst rm i
me m n s s es ve
r ui plt s o
n he da e va rod i o t n
m ulide e nt c es i whi h t def nda s a e no s r e a t s me tm e. Prort t
t- f nda as n
c he e nt r t e v d t he a
i
i o he
6
e cm e oft JCVA,t Unied St t sCour ofAppea sf t Fo t Cic ta e ar e
na t nt he
he t
ae
t
l or he urh r ui dopt d ul
t tç e uied a n tc o r mo a t be fld wi i te frts r e d fn a ts tit a
ha s q r g) oie f e v l o
r
ie t n h is-e v d ee d n ' hrpd y
h
wid w. Bab u , 6 F.d a 6 7 (e fimig is a h r n e t t e r l m iuae i
n o ' r o r 40 3 t 0 ra fr n t d e e c o h ue c ltd n
'
M c n e v. ado Tnzte o Ma ya d Co nt Colc , 5 F.d 9 ( t Ci.1 9 ).
Kin v Bo r f se s f r ln mmu i le e 9 5 2 24 4h r 9 2 )
v
Howeve ,t 2011 a e
r he
m ndme sGo r l Ba bo a M c l e on t spoi 'a a pt d
nt tve nled r ur nd Kim y hi nt' nd do e
t ls-e v d d fn a tr l,l e wh c ' ea h d fnd n ha tit d y fo t e d t o
he atsr e e e d n ue md r ih d jc ee a t s hry a s r m h ae f
g
s r i et fl anotc ofr moval' M oor v. hlk, E11 - 2e v c o ie
ie e
.'
e Sve a No. .- 1 2727,201 U . Dit LEXI
1
3 S. s .
S
9 3 9, t* 7( M d.ul 1 , 01 )
7 2 a 3 D. J y 1 2 3 .
As o he co t ha r c l no e (he n nde sa t doe not a es t f m
t r urs ve e enty t d, I
t me d tm e
s
ddr s he or
co e mus t ke Neihe doesi e e sy a es whe c e mus betl d i s pa aefom
ns nt t a .
t r
t xpr s l ddr s
n ons nt t ie f e r t r
t no ie of r moval' Ga e a W iln - ie Condo.As ' v.Oua iv Buit LLC,No.
he tc
e
.
' t s t li ms Brc
sn
lt
ls
3:6 c - 2 2 - C,201 U. Dit LEXI 1 38 ,a #1 ( S. S p .7 2 6 ;s e as
1 -v 0 0 2 CM
6 S. s.
S 2 0 t 1 D. C. e t , 01 ) e lo
Grfi e v Ce rRa i s& I waCiyRv Co, 8 F.d 1 8 ,1 8 ( t Ci. 1 )(Th 20 1
ito n . da p d o
t . .7 5 3 1 2 1 7 8h r 20 5 $ e 1
ç
a nd nt t j 1 t tc te t r eofunani t di no de ci t f m ofortme
me me s o 446 ha odii d he ul
miy d t s rbe he or
i
fn f rc n e twhe mutpl d fnd nsaeiv le ' .
r me o o s n
n li e ee a t r n ov d.)
'
A.
Or e nalNo i e o Re oval
ii
tc f m
Agans t sba kdr t c t us frtc i rwhehe t orgi lnotc ofr m ova
i t hi c op,he our m t is onsde
t r he i na ie e
l
fldb t eRe a Dee d n sc mpidwiht enzeo u a miy c d fe i j 1 4 ( )2 ( .
e y h g l fn a t o le t h l f n ni t o iid n 4 6 b ( )A)
As sl a i d a
lmm rze bove,t orgi lnotc alege G
he i na
ie l d, s
upon i or ai n a bei f't ti Bar s
nf m to nd le ,' ha f ne
ha bee pr ry s r edwih pr es ,E woul cons ntt t r movaloft St t Cour Aci n
d n ope l e v
t oc s t
he
d
e o he e
he ae
t to
t ti Co r. Noieo Re v la !28
o h s u t' tc f mo a t .
'
I M a v.Boad ofEducai o Prnc Geor s o t 71 F. 735,7 ( h Ci.
n vo
r
ton f i e
ge'f unv, 3 3d
42 4t r
201 ) t Fourh Cic thed t tt nle ofuna miy doe no r r t tG c o t
3 , he
t rui l ha he l
ni t
s t equie ha d h f he
ea
defnda ssgn t noi ofrmo lortl a spaae notc ofr mova c yi wih j
e nt i he tce e va ie e rt ie e l ompl ng t
7
1 b)' l tad,:a noi of rmova sgne a fld by a atr y f r one dee nt
446( .' nse I tce e
l i d nd ie
n tone o
fnda
r pr en i una g
e es tng
mbi uousy t t t ot r de e nt c e t t r mova s ts i t
l ha he he f nda s ons nt o he e
l a ifes he
r qui e e of u ni ous c e f pur es o r m o l, I (mp ssa d d . Snc t e
e r m nt na m
ons nt or pos f e va . 4 d. e ha i d e ) i e h
2
r m ovi de e n s i M a e es l sa e i t no i e ofr m ova t tt y had co ule
e
ng f nda t n yo xpr sy t t d n he tc
e
l ha he
ns t d
wih t non e
t he
r movi de e nt a t t t norr m o ng de enda had c e ed t t
ng f nda nd ha he le vi
f nt
ons nt o he
r
emova ,heFo t Cicui co l
lt
urh r t ncudedt t(her m ova wasefe tvey a t t td hediti t
ha G e
t
l
f c i ' nd hus ha t
'
t
src
co tdi note ri de i ngt r m a t ca et saecou t' I a 740,742.
ur d
r n clni o e nd he s o tt
r . d. t
'
Unlket notc ofr m ova i M a t Reg D e e nt 'orgi lnotc i l d no
i he i e e
l n yo, he al f nda s i na i e ncude
i c ton,muc l s a t a g
ndia i
h e s n m mbi uousr pr s nt ton, ha t i a t ne we eaci o behafof
e e e a i t t her tor ys r tng n
l
orwiht cons to Ba ne . M e ey alegi I n i o m a i a bei f'ha anonr m ovi
t he
en f r s
r l l ng t
upo nf r ton nd le t t
e
ng
de e ntç
f nda s d c e t t r m ova' i no t s m ease e sy s ai t theha i f c ,
woul ons nt o he e
l' s t he n
xpr s l ttng ha
d,n a t
c n e td Noieo Re v l t!28 s eAn eAr n e Comt v. ie Pa .ns Co, 0 F.
o s n e . tc f mo a a
; e n u d l t ' Untd c I . .9 5
y
S p .2 7 2 9 ( M d 1 95 ( o dn ,p irt M a o t a t e rmo n d fn a t f i d t
u p 7 , 7 D. . 9 ) h l ig ro o y , h t h e vig e e d n s al o
e
s ts yt una m iy r quieme by a l i upon i o mai n a bei f t ta he de e nt
a if he ni t e r nt legng,
nf r to nd le , ha not r f nda
d dn to j d t tep tto frr mo l. Be a s al ft d f n a t ddn t a iuo l
i o b e o h eii n o e va) c u e l o he ee d n s i o un mb g usy
j i i t eo iia noieo rmo lt a noie b isl, sn ts fiin t s tsytez l o
on n h rgn l tc f e va, h t tc , y tef i o u tce t o aif h ' e f
u
t
mani iy.
m t
B.
Suppl entalN otce
em
i
OnJ nua y26, 1 t Re De e nt fl a s e nt lnotc e e sngBa ne '
a r
20 7, he gal f nda s ied uppl me a ie xpr s i
r s
cons ntt r mova . Thepl n if a guet tt s e e alno i i i fe tvebec us t
e o e
l
aitf s r
ha he upplm nt tce s ne f c i
a e he
2 I M a , t F rhCic titrrtdtepea n me tv ri o 28U. C.j1 46. Ma o, 3
n vo he ou t rui nep ee h r-me d n eson f
S. 4
y 71
F. a 740. However t Cour no e t tisr soni woul ha bee t s m ee n i i we ea yzi t
3d t
, he
t t d ha t ea ng
d ve n he a ve f t r nal ng he
curentve son oft saut I at741n. .
r
ri
he tt e. d.
1
8
def nda sa euna et pr vet ti wa fl dwihi 30 da fom t da eon whi h Ba n wa
e nt r
bl o o ha t s ie t n
ys ' he t
r
c r es s
s r d wih pr es Fort f l ngr as , heco tag e s
e ve t oc s.
he olowi e ons t
ur r e .
Pro t t e 2 1 n nd n s t j 1 4 ,t Fo rh Cic i h l t a (ndvd a
ir o h 01 me me t o 4 6 he u t r ut ed h t G iiu l
i
d fn a t h vetit d y fo tetmete aes r e wi p o e so wihac mpan t j i
ee d n s a hry a s r m h i h y r ev d t r c s r t o li t o on
h
i a ot r s va i r m o lpe ii ' M cKim e 955 F. a 928;s e a s Ba bour 640 F.
n n he wi e ld e va tton.'
r y,
2d t
e lo r
,
3d
a 61 n4 ( oi t a S n eatmeyp tto E sfldwihnt ei ta t it- a wid w, a h
t 2 . n tng h t t c i l eiin i ie t i h ni l hry d y n o e c
o
l
i
ltrs r e d fn a t h u dh v tit- a sfo t d t o sr iei whc t j i t p tto
ae-e v d ee d n s o l a e hry d y r m he ae f ev c n ih o on he eiin
f rr mo a,b c u e j 1 4 alwse c d f n a tt it d y i whc t a t) Al u h
o e v l ras
4 6 lo a h e e d n hry a s n ih o c' . t g
'
ho
( r ura M c nne we e l giltve y ove r e wih r pec t whehe t da eofs l c
t bo nd Ki y r e sa i l
Ba
ruld t es t o
t r he t
ewie
on t frts r d de e ntti r d t wi w f r flng oft Notce o Re o l' t
he is-e ve f nda rgge e he ndo o ii
he
i f m va , hey
'
S r n t ve z dwi r s e t ot ed a ln fro h rd fn a t t j i a'o ieo Re v l'
ç e o o m l t e p c t h e d ie o t e ee d n s o o n N tc f mo a.
we
e h
'
M oo e 201 U . D it LEX I 97329,a *39. A sJ
r , 3 S. s .
S
t
udge H ola r e a ned i M oo e
l nde xpl i
n
r,
a he lhy r pec f c r ui pr e ntw oul s
a t es t or i c t ec de
d ugge tt tBa bour a M c i y
s ha r
nd K nne
s o db c nsd rd o er ldo l t tee tn t tte aei o tbl wih
h ul e o i ee v rue n y o l x e t ha h y r nc mpai e t
t
t J
he VCA . I t s r r i i not worhy t tt Hous J cir Comm it e
n hi ega d t s e t ha he
e udi a y
te
Re o to t eJ
p r n h VCA i iae t a t en n me t t j 1 46b ( )wee smpy
ndc ts h t h me d ns o 4 ()2 r i l
i e d t r s ve t c r ui s i r ga di Sde e m i ng t da e on w hi h t
nt nde o e ol he i c t plt e r ng t t r ni he t
c he
30- y pe i begnst nm.' Re ta 1 Not ng i t J
da rod i o
'
por t 3.
hi n he VCA s
ugge t t t
ss ha
Congr s w i he t pr vi a ope e d tm e f r m o l To t c r r t
e s s d o o de n n- nde i or e va .
he onta y, he
J
VCA die t t tea h de e nt i e il d t a t ry- y pe i a tr beng
r c s ha c
f nda s ntte o hit da
rod fe i
s r d,a t Hous J i ir Co it Re tsa e t tt J
e ve nd he
e ud ca y mm tee por t t s ha he VCA i not
s
i e d t çal an i fniepe i f r
nt nde o slow
nde i t rod or emova .' Re ' a 1
l'
pol t 4.
t
I a *39d. t
40.
Thi c ur, as ha ot r i t Fourh Cic t fnds J
s o t
ve he s n he
t r ui, i
udge Hola r s r a oni
lnde ' e s ng
pe s i
r uasve. Se Qa e a W ila sBrc Condo. As ' v. Ouaiy Buit LLC, N o.
e t s t lim - i e
sn
lt
l.
3:6c 0 0 2- C,2 6U. Dit LEXI 1 0 8 ,a *1 ( S. S p . ,2 6 ( ni , .
1 -v- 2 2 CM
01 S. s.
S 2 3 0 t 9 D. C. e t 7 01 ) Cu e J)
;
W hiev.Li rv M ut Fiel .No.M J 1 579,201 U. Dit LEXI 57928,at*3( M d.
t
bet
. r ns,
G- 66 S. s.
S
D.
M a 2, 6)( r s J.. Consse wiht s decsons t c t ncude t taltrs r e
y 201 Ga bi, )
itnt t hee ii ,he our co l s ha ae-e v d
9
def nda ha t ryda fom t tmehei s r dw iht i ta pl a ng t et rc e t a
e nt s hit ys r he i
s e ve t he nii l e di o ihe ons nt o n
9
exitngno ie o r movalorfl hi own notc ofr m ova wih t co en oft e rir s r d
si
tc f e
ie s
ie e
l t he ns t he a le -e ve
def nda s3
e nt .
I t sca e,Ba nesha notfl d hi o no ie ofr
n hi s
r
s
ie s wn tc
emova a t tm e f doi s ha
l nd he i or ng o s
ce rye pie . S e2 U. C. 1 4 ( )2 ( . M o e v r teRe a Dee a t aeu a l t
la l x r d e 8 S. j 4 6 b ( )B)
ro e ,h g l fnd ns r n b e o
esa ih t the c e e t t i notc ofr m ova wihi t ry da ofbeng s r ed wih t
t bls ha
ons nt d o her i e e
l t n hit ys
i ev
t he
i iilp e dn S eW e t o v F o k,1 7 F.S p . 5 6 5 2 ( D. . . 0 )(Th
nta la ig. e
swo d . r n 7
u p 2d 3 ' 4 N. W Va 2 01 I e
,
<
peii ng def nda sbe rt bur n of e t bls ng c
ttoni
e nt a he de
sa ihi ompla e wih t r quie nt oft
inc t he e r me s he
r mo a sau e icu igt rq ie n so t ej id ro tmeyc nsn o a1 ee a t.
e v l ttt,n ldn he e ur me t f h on e r i l o e t f l d fnd ns'
).
Co rsi teW etr Ditit fVignaha eç ge dwiht eo ewh l n mao iyo
u t n h sen src o r ii v t r e t h v r emi g j rt f
a
o he c urst t whe e ade e nti s r d t o h asa ut y a nt t r m o lpe i sa t
t r o t ha , r
f nda s e ve hr ug
tt or ge , he e va rod trs
w he t de e ntac ualy r c ve a c o t c pl i . Pur yr LLC v.
n he f nda
t l e ei s opy f he om a nt'
'
A .
Phoc t x Te hs .
ao
c .
LLC, . :6 c - 0 4 20 6U. Dit LEXI 1 9 0 a * ( . Va De . , 01 )( lo ,
No 5 1 -v 0 0 7, 1 S. s.
S 6 61 , t 6 W D. . c 8 2 6 Di n
l
J)(ii gR i v. vey, 0 F. u p. d 8 9 8 ( . Va 2 4 (o e , .; e as Go d n
. ctn
t Li l 3 4 S p 2 2 , 31 W D. . 00 ) J n s J) s e lo r o
e
v Hato d Fie I s Co,1 5 F.Ap ' 4 6 48 (t Ci.2 0 )(mp bihe )(d'etme f r
. rf r r n . . 0
p x 7 , 0 4 h r 0 4 t u ls d df i o
-h
r mo a b gnswh n S d fn n a tal h src i d ac py o te c mp an .' ( u tn
e v l ei
e t ee da t cu l a e eve o f h o lit') q o ig
he
y
'
Lil v.
l CSX Tr n p.I c,1 6 F. p 2 6 2 6 3 ( D. . . 0 2 ) Th sc t t i d n
y
a s s n . 8 Su p. d 7 , 7 S. W Va 2 0 ). i ol fn s o
r
r as t de a e f o t' s pror de i i ns Ac or ng y,Ba nesha t ry da fom whe he
e on o vi t r m he e i
c so .
c di l
r
d hit ys r
n
3 Asot rcourshavenotd,t sconcl i appear t beconsse wih t Fourh Cicui' deci on
he
t
e hi
uson
so
it nt t he
t r ts si
i Ma
n vo. SeeGaes 201 U. Dit LEXI 120380,a *1 .M oor 201 U. Dit LEXI 97329,a *41.I
t , 6 S. s.
S
t 9,
e, 3 S. s .
S
t
n
t t ca ,t Fourh Cicui was pr se e wih t potnta f ms ofcons nt t r
ha se he
t r t
e nt d t wo e il or
e , he emovi de e
ng f ndant'
s
una guous sa e
mbi
tt ment i t notce of r moval t t r codef nda c entd t r
n he
i
e
hat hei
e nt ons e o emoval and t
he
codef
endantsown wrten i ca i ofc e ,whi wasfl mor t n 30da aferi wa s v wih t
'
it ndi ton ons nt ch
ied e ha
ys t t s er ed t he
compl nt Se M avo, F. at740,742 & n. Thepli if a gue t tt lterc dno ber ledupon
ai . e
713 3d
2.
antfs r d ha he a t oul t ei
t s if t una miy r quiement snce i wasuntmel l a n. f lhough t Fourh Cicui di not
o atsy he ni t e r
,i t
i y. d. t 2. W t
he
t r t d
e p esy rs leteplitfs agu n,i r l d tli l,o teatsain o ter mo ig d fnd n g'
x rs l e ov h an if' r me t t ei , el y n h tetto f h e vn ee a ts)
e
ng
couns i t notceofr
el n he i
emoval r t rt t s eque se r t co ent t hol t tt r eofunani t
, ahe han he ubs nt pa ae ns , o d ha he ul
miy
had been s ifed. M oor 2013 U. Dit LEXI 97329,a * s al M a 71 F. at742. Slhus,
atsi '
'
e,
S. s .
S
t 42; ee so yo, 3 3d
s-
whi o l a if rn e t eFo rhCic ia pe r et e t ha c n iee te(ub e e tc nsn ju tmey
l ny n n ee c ,h u t rut p as ih r o ve o sd rd h s squ n o e t ni l
e
oratl tt havepr e e t cl e quesi ' Gats,2016U . Dit LEXI 1
eas o
es nt d he os r
ton.'
e
S. s.
S 20380,a 1 n. 2.
t 20 1
ac l r ceved a co of t i ta pl a ng t co e t t Rega De e nt 'no i of
maly e i
py
he niil e di o ns nt o he
l f nda s tce
r m ova .
e
l
The Re lDe e n s fl t s e nt lnotc of Ba ne 'co e t r m o lo
ga f nda t ied he upplme a
ie
r s ns nt o e va n
J nua y 26, 201 D urng hi de ii Ba ne i taly t tfed t t he w a (
a r
7.
i
s pos ton, r s nii l es i
ha
s û ial
phys c ly
ha d' t e l pe co ani t s
nde ' he nve o
nt i ng he umm o and c
ns
ompli on De e be 24,201 Ba ne
ant
cm r
6. r s
D e 45. Ba neslt ri c e ashe di i hi c r c e a fda t t the c d nots wih
p.
r
ae ndiatd,
d n s ore t d fi vi, ha
oul
ay t
a ol ec ti t whenher eve t s monsa c
bs ut era n y
ec i d he um
nd ompl i .4 L= a 7 75; r sCo r c e
ant d t 4- Bn ne r e t d
,
Afi . 1 ($ d no kn w wh n t S mmo o Co litfrtc mei t my p s eso '
fd ! 4 : o t o
1
e he u ns r mp an is a no
o s sin.
).
Eihe wa i lghtofBa nes s n sa e nt ,heRe lDe e nt a euna et esa ih t t
t r y,n i
r ' wor t t me s t
ga f nda s r
bl o t bls ha
Ba e tm ey co e e t t rno i eofr mova .
nz s i l ns nt d o hei tc
e
l
I.
I
O ppor univ t Cur
t t o
e
Be a et Re lDef nda sa eunabl t pr t tBa n c e t t t i r moval
c us he ga
e nt r
e o ove ha r es ons n ed o her e
i a tm ey m a r t r mova i pr d al de eci . See Ga e ,201 U. Dit LEXI
n i l
nne , he e
l s oce ur ly f tve
ts
6 S. s .
S
1 0 8 ,a * (i ig t e l e v lp o e u al d fcie
2 3 0 t 9 fndn h s mo a r c d rly e e tv
r
b c u e t e c n e t ya
e a s h o sn vs
t i l '; n y Hodnc 1 Lt . Alr dL. of. n .81F. u p. d 5 3 5 4 ( D. x.
mt y' Ho e li s . d v. fe W lf l c,
me )
S p 3 4 , 5 S. Te
2 5 ( çA)l ee d nswh h v b e p o el j ie a ds r e musj i i o c nsn t t e
01 ) ç ( ld fn a t o a e e n r p ry on d n e v d t on n r o e t o h
1
r m o of t aci n. The r mova i pr ed al de eci i s h c 'e i nottm ey
e val he to '
e
l s oc m ly f tve f uc ons nt s
i l
o tie ' ( u tng28U. C. 1 4 ( )2 ( ) W h nplitfs as ti p o e url ee ti a
ban d.) q oi
'
S. j 4 6 b ( )A). e anif r ie h s r c d a d f c n
tm ey motont r m a c t i t Fourh Cic tr tney c l t tr m a i wa r nt d.
i l
i o e nd, ours n he
t r ui ou i l onc ude ha e nd s ra e
Se G a es 201 U . D it LEX I 1
e t , 6 S. s .
S 2038 a * 25; hie, 6 U . D it LEX I 57928 a *4;
0, t 24- W t 201 S. s .
S
,t
J c med Es iav J c s n No DKC 1 - 0 9 2 5U. DitLEXI 1 0 6 , t# ( M d.
a o e pn . a k o , .
5 2 5 , 01 S. s.
S 4 3 9 a 20 D.
Oc.1 201 ;Stve v.Thor bur No. 1 c 31 9, 4U. DitLEXI 11
t 5, 5) e ns
ns y, 2:3-v- 71 201 S. s.
S 2020, t*
a 7
4 Asi c ed a
ndiat bove, i i be
t s yondquesin t tBar r ei t s
to ha
nes ec ved he ummonsa compli on t
nd
ant he
s day andt tt wer i uded i t s envel
ame
ha hey e ncl
n he ame
ope.
11
( D.W . .Au 1 ,201 ) Bec n v.Fa ne M a ,No : 1CV- 0 1 201 U. Dit
S.
Va g. 3 4 , r mn n
.
n i e .9 1 - 0 41 , 1 S. s.
LEXI 7 8 7 a * ( S. J l 1 ,2 1;Belv. ene En es, .5:1 8 2 1U.
S 5 6 , t 7 D. C. uy 2 01 ) l W r r tr.No 1 CV1 , 01 S.
Dit LEXI 3 9 8 a *1 ( D. . . r 5 2 1, io Sy .I .v Na' Lo i Unv.
s.
S 6 7 , t 3 N. W Va Ap . , 01 ) Unc m ss nc . tl us i ,
2 2 F.S p .2 6 8 6 ( D. . 0 ) F no v. o Li m I .No 30 CV0 01 , 0
6
u p d 3 , 41 E. Va 20 3 ; e t n Fo d o nc, . :2 0 7 20 2
U. DitLEXI 1 7 , t*1 ( . Va Aug 23 20 2 ( ih e, ..
S. s.
S 58 9 a 8 W D. . . , 0 ) M c a lJ)
I t sc s ,t Rega De e nt ur t c tt t keam o efe bl a oa h,a fnd
n hi a e he
l f nda s ge he our o a
r lxi e ppr c nd i
t tt y e e t pr e la de e tby uli t l ob a ni Ba n s'c e t r m o l The
ha he ur d he oc dtr l f c
tma ey t i ng r e ons nt o e va .
y
m ant i t tr ma i notr q r d a l a t de e tr a e t t una m iy r quie nti
i an ha e nd s
e uie s ong s he f c elt d o he ni t e r me s
c r dp ir otee tyo s mmayj g n .
u e ro t h nr f u r ud me t
TheRega De e nt 'ar um e i t sr r i notwiho s
l f nda s g nt n hi ega d s
t ut uppo tfo s m ede i i
r rm o
c sons
fo ohe cruis l Es st v. meDe o U. A.lc, 9 F.d7 7 ( s Ci. 0 9 ,h
r m t r ic t. n po io Ho
p t S. .n .5 0 3 2, 7 1t r 2 0 ) te
Fis Cic tde lne t a yt una miy r quie e i afwoode ' a r The Co tthed
rt r ui c i d o ppl he ni t e r m nt n t
n'm nne .
tr l
t t$at hnialde e ti t r m o lpr s ...was s e nty c e whe Hom e De
ha & ec c
f c n he e va oce s
ubs que l ur d
n
pot
oppos d Es io' r m a moton,t r b cea l c 'mi tng is desr t be i f r l
e
post s e nd
i he e y l ry omm t cai t
ie o
n ede a
nce pos t
ci d he n h r ui s l ha e
co ut' I . Si Es io w as de de , t N i t Ci c tha he d t tr m ovi de e nt
t' ' d
.5
ng f nda s
ma c r ad f c p ranngt teu a i t rq ie n p i r ot e tyo j g n , sha te
y u e e e t e tii o h n nmiy e ur me t ro t he n r f ud me ta s h
Fit Cic t a beti a un ihe opi on. Se De ti v.Re s g,630 F. 952,956 5
fh r ui, l i n n publs d ni
e sfno
iwi
3d
-7
( t Ci. 1 )(A1 d fn a t who h v b e p o el . sr e i t e a o mus j i a
9h r 20 1 ; l ee d n s
K
a e e n r p ry
ev d n h di n t on
pe ii f r m o l I t si no t ewhe t no i ofr m o li tl t dititco tma
tton or e va . f hi s t nl
n he tce e va s sed, he src ur y
alw t ermo i d fn a t t c r ted fc b o ti igj i e o a1 e e d n s ir ote
l h e vng e e d n s o u e h e e t y bann ond r f 1d f n a t pro t h
o
e tyo j d me t' (iaina d itr a q o ainmak o te ) S o ev. n o Ne Yo k
n r f u g n .) ctto n nen l u tto r s mitd ; t n Bn k f w r
'
5The Fis Cicui nonet es notd t by f lng t srcty compl wih t r e ofuna miy, t
rt r t
hel s e hat aii o ti l
y t he ul
ni t he
d fn nsSa ters ta tedititc r mih fndabra ho teu ni t rq rme t n rma d(h )
ee da t t n h ik h th src ou t g t i
r
e c f h na mi e uie n a d e n te
y
a to t saec u tad cso ghea p laec u two dh v be np wels t rve ' Es o io 59 F.d
cin o tt o r, e iin t p elt o r! ul a e e o re s o e iw. p st, 0 3
'
a 77 s eas 28U. C. 1 7 d ( rviig wihl tde e to ,ha 'ano d rrma igac s t t
t , e lo
.
S. j 44 ( ) po dn , t i e xc p ins t tG l r e e ndn a e o he
mi
l
S aec r fo whc iwa rmo e i no rviwa l o a pe l oh r s '.
tt ou tr m ih t s e v d s t e e be n p a or tewie'
)
12
M eln N. , 0 F. p' 9 9 9 1( 1hCi. 01 )(A tc n c l e e t eae t teu a i t
l . A.6 9 Ap x 7 , 8 1 t r2 5 ( e h ia d f c rltd o h n n miy
o
&
r quie e t ma be c ed by op i a m oton t r m a pror t t e r of s
e rm n
y
ur
posng
i o e nd i o he nty
umm a y
r
'
J d me t'.
u g n .)
'
TheRega Def nda sha notct d, ndt c t be nuna et l a e a decsons
l e nt , ve
ie a he our has e
bl o oc t , ny ii
fom wihi t Fourh Cic tt twoul a l r m o ng de e nt t c eade e tr l t dt t
r
t n he
t r ui ha
d low e vi
f nda s o ur
f c e a e o he
t ni t r q rme t n t pro t t ee tyo s mmayj dg n . Tot ec nrr , itit
ma miy e uie n a y i ir o h n r f u r u me t
me
h o ta y d src
c rsi Sout Ca olna,M a ylnd, nd W es Vig ni ha e e sy r f e t alow r m o ng
ou t n
h r i
r a a
t r i a ve xpr s l e us d o l e vi
de e nt t c et spr dur lde e tbyflng t c f ntsc e outi t pr s rbed
f nda s o ur hi oce a f c
ii he ode enda ' ons nt sde he e c i
t ry- ypei Se Gae ,201 U. Dit LEXI 1 0,at* - ( clni t f l t
hit da rod. e ts 6 S. s.
S 2038
2324 de i ng o olow he
r a oni o Es io a c udi t tChe ei nofe biiy i t tm ea l df rc e s
e s ng f post nd oncl ng ha ç r s lxi lt n he i lowe o ons nt o
t
l n a tep ry s e i rma d rie t ed t e c wihn t ry d yso r mo a' ;Se n ,
o g s h a t e kng e n ass h ekin y ti hit a f e v l) tve s
'
2 4 U. Dit LEXI 1 20 a * ( o dn t a çth er ri n to tii ( c d fn a ts
01 S. s.
S 1 2, t 8 h l ig h t K l e ro n o banng a o ee d n '
g
tmey c n e ti icza l be a et et it- a fln rq ie n so j1 4 a ema d tr '
i lq o s n s n l be c us h hry d y iig e ur me t f 4 6 r n ao y'
r
)
(iai n > d itr a q oain mak o te l se- e n v.Ve io M d, LLC, No.
çtto n n en l u tto
r s mitd ;Ea trGr e
rz n .
M J 1 - 0 0 2 4U. Dit LEXI 1 0 2, t'1 - 5& n9( M d. uy23 2 4 ( o dn
G- 4 1 4 , 01 S. s.
S 0 76 a ' 3 1
. D. J l , 01 ) h l ig
t tt r m ovi de e
ha he e
ng f ndan sco d no c e a de ec i r ova pe ii by obt i ng t untm e y
t ul t ur
f tve em l tton
a ni he i l
c n e t fan n e vn d fn a t.
o s n o o r mo ig e e d n)
Afe r viwi e si c s l w, hi c t s fndst o - - ic tde sonsct d by
tr e e ng xitng a e a t s our alo i he utofc r ui cii
ie
t Rega De e nt unpe s sve. AsJ
he
l f nda s
r ua i
udge Cury e a ne i Ga e
r xpli d n t s:
Thi i,i pa t bec us i
s s n r, a e mposng a src t ry- y dea i t r ie pr e al
i
tit hit da
dlne o a s oc dur
de e t a a bass f r m a i i plc ty i ns s e w ih a l i t r m ovi
fcs s
i or e nd s m i il nco i t nt t low ng he e
ng
pa te an o n- nded de dlne f m e tng t pr e al r quie e t
ri s
pe e
a i or
ei
he oc dm
e r m n s.
Exc i de a be aus i i s r i alo i onsse wih t va i t ry- y
usng ly c e t s ho t s s nc itnt t he rous hit da
de dlne i ude i t saut a t Fourh Cic tsl sa i pr c i of
a i s ncl d n he t t e nd he
t r ui' ong-t nd ng a tce
r quii co e wihi t r y da oft r e ntt i re
e rng ns nt t n hi t ys he el va r gge vent
.
Gae , 01 U. Dit LEXI 1 0 0 a * 4(iigM c n e 9 5F.d a 9 )
ts 2 6 S. s.
S 2 38 , t 2 ctn Kin y, 5 2 t 28 .
13
For t r as i ntfe i Gae , t c t lke s c ude t t t r m ovi
he e ons de ii d n t s he our i wi e oncl s ha he e
ng
de e nt 'f itr t obt i tm e yuna mousc e i notac a ede ec i t pl i ifr ie
f nda s a lle o an i l
ni
ons nt s
ur bl f t f he antf a s s
t de i incy wihi t ry da of r moval Thi c l i n c pors wih t a o to
he fce
t n hit ys
e
.
s oncuso om t t he dm nii ns
fom t Supr m e Co ta t Fourh Cic tt tc t (s d consr r m ova sa u es
r he
e
ur nd he
t r ui ha ours thoul
tue e
l tt t
na r y,'i lght of sgni a f r im c
rowl ' n i
i ûc nt ede als once ns Ba bo , 6 F. a 61 s a s
r . r ur 40 3d t 3; ee lo
Ha to dF r I s Co.7 6F,da 25 ($ el l o t nmiyi c nsse t t oz o lg to t
rf r ie n . , 3 3 t 9 ç ' e f ma i t s o itn wih l b iain o
Th u
r
c n t er mo a j rs ito srcl b c us o tesg fc n f d rls c nc msi iae .)
o snz e v l u idcin tity e a e f h iniia t e eaim o e mpl td'
c
'
(iai n a d i tr lq tto mak o te )
ctto n nena uoain r s mitd .
i as s p re by t wele tb ihe
s lo u po td
he l-sa ls d
prnc pl t ta Gdo sa tt pr pre yofr m o ls dber s ve i f vorofr m a ng
i i e ha ny ç ubt bou he o it
e va houl
e ol d n a
e ndi
t c s t sa ecour. Ba bour 6 F. a 61
he a e o tt
t'
' r , 40 3d t 3.
C oncl i
us on
Fort r as saed, hec tc l st tt r m o lfom sa ec ti pr e aly
he e ons t t t our oncude ha he e va r t t our s oc dur l
de e tve snc t Reg De e
f c i i e he
al f ndant a e unabl t pr t tBa ne c e e t t r m o l
s r
e o ove ha r s ons nt d o he e va
wihi t r quiie t rpday pe i
t n he e st hit
rod. Bec us t pli if r s d t s de i inc i a tm ey
a e he antfs aie hi fc e y n i l
m ame ,i c r be c e a t c s mus ber m a
r r t a mot ur d nd he a e
t e ndedt sa e c r . Ac or ngl t c t
o t t ou t
c di y, he our
wilgr ntt pl ntfs m o i n t r m a
l a he ai if ' to o e nd.
TheCl r i diece t s nd co e o t sme or ndum opi on a t a c pa ng
e k s r td o e
pis f hi m a
ni nd he c om nyi
or rt a lc
de o l ouns lofr c d.
e
e or
moA
D A TED : s è n da ofApr l 201
Thi
y
i, 7.
Chi U nie St t s D it i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?