Premo Autobody, Inc. et al v. Parker et al

Filing 107

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 09/26/2018. (ssm)

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR Tl W ESTERN D I
v
STRI OF VI
CT
RGN A
CHA RLOW ESVI
LLE DI
VISION
CLERK' OFFI U . DI COURT
S
CE S. SX
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

PREM O AUTOBOD Y ,l C.
N ,
GEORGE A .M AY O,m . and
,
M ARI L.M AY O,
E

sc 2 s 2 1
r
?
98
Pl ntf s
ai if ,
,

J
BYUL
;

'
-..

.
-.

'
VM %
:
L
ERK ..
Q
,

.-

. .

Ci lA c i N o.3:
vi ton
17CV0001

c . A VBRLY PARK ER,
W
MI
CHAEL A.
PARKER,a d
n
UN I
TED STATES OF AM ERI
CA,
D ef nt
enda s.

M EM öRANDIM om xl
J
ox
By: o G l n E.Conr d
H n. e
a
Seni Unied St esDi ti Judge
or t
at
srct

U NI
TED STA TES OF A M ERI ,
CA
Cr - ai ant
oss cl m ,

C.W A VERLY PA RK ER,
MI
CHA EL A .PARKER ,
GEORGE A .M AY O,J .
R,
M A I E L .M AY 0 ,
LI
PREM O A UTOBOD Y ,I .
NC ,
COM M ON W EALTH OF V I N I , EPT.
RGI A D
OF TAXA TI ,and
ON
V I NI N ATI
RGI A
ONA L BAN K ,

Cr sD e e n s
os - f nda t .

TheUnied Sttso Ameia (c td Stt ' ha move frs
t ae f rc s e aes' s
uni
)
d o ummayj
r udgme ton is
n
t
a e d c o s c a m s ki g t f e l e on ce t i f de a t x le e um be i g pe s l
m nde r s - l i ee n o or c os
ra n e r l a i ns nc
rn
r ona
pr t i t poss si ofC.W a l Par and M i
opery n he
es on
very ker
chaelA .Par . Fort f l i r ons
ker
he olow ng eas ,
t courtfndst t e i ro genui di put ofm at alf and t t Unied St es i entted
he
hat her s i
ne s e
eri act
hat he t
at s il

t j gme ta amatroflw.Ac r ngl t c ur wilgrn t motonf s
o ud n s te a
codi y,he o t l a t he i or ummayj gme t
r ud n
and per i t s eoft per onalpropery a i ue.
m t he al he s
t t ss

Backeround
1.

The PersonalPropeo atIs
sue

On De e r 1 201 ,C.Wa ry Pake a M iha lA.Pake ( lci y,Ghe
c mbe 8, 5
vel r r nd c e
r r cole tvel ç
t

Pakes' o ai daj
r r' bt ne udgme ta ai tPr Autbody,nc. e 'a ohesi t a tof
)
n g ns emo o
I CTrmo' nd t r n he moun
l
$49,010 i t Cic tCour f rt Ciy o Cha l ts le On Fe r a y 1 ,201 t Cic t
3 .0 n he r ui
t o he t f rote vil.
bur 1
6, he r ui

Co r is e a wrto teifca i e e uin o t ej d me t Th S eif o te Ci o
u t su d
i f sr a is n x c t f h u g n . e h rf f h t f
o
y
Cha lte vil be ant lvy t e m i ofGe ifciso t pe s na pr ry ofPrm o o Fe ua y
ro ts le g o e h
t
r a a n he r o l ope t
e
n br r
17,201
6.

The pe s al pr pe t s i e fom Pr m o w a s d a pu i a c i c uc ed on
r on
o ry e z d r
e
s ol t blc u tons ond t
Nove be 30, 201 , J nua y 4, 201 a J nua y 11 201 The Pa ke s pur has d Ga l o
m r
6 a r
7, nd a r
, 7.
r r
c e <l r
s t n i ly al o t pr ry' s d a t a to , a t y r m a n i pos es i n of s h
ubs a ta l l f he ope t ' ol t he uc i ns nd he e i n
s so
uc

pr ry.Am.Cr sc. !40 DktNo.8 seas Pakes Ans rt Am.Cr scl! 40
opet
os-l! -42, .
3; e lo r r' we o
os- . ! -

4 , . . 0 (d tigt ealg to si p rj a s4 - 2 o teco scam) Th p ro a
2 DktNo 9 a mit h l ain n aa rph 0 4 f h r s-li . e es n l
n
e
pr rys dt tePakesa tea tonsi t pr rya ij i t sc e( ri fe rfred
opet ol o h r r t h uci s he opet t sue n hi as heenatr eer

t a ihePe snal o r/).
o s G ro Prpe t
t
H.

Vi qi a N atonalBank' Sec iv I e e t
r ni
i
s urt nt r s

On J y 20,2005 a pe i i aly t r a t r Pr m o o ai d a s r e of c
ul
nd rod c l he e fe , e
bt ne
e is
omm e c a l ns
r i l oa
.

fo Vigi aNainalBa k (s r ni Nai l l e ha f t c
rm r ni to
n vigi a tona' n xc nge or he ommeca lans Prmo
).
ril o , e
gr n e t ba k a s urt i t r s i Pr m o' as e s i udi ; la co t r c i bl i nt r
a t d he n
ec iy n e e t n e s s t , ncl ng $ c un s e e va e, nve o y,
a1
m a hiar (i) eq pme ,a d fr tr a d ge r i angils' Am. os- . B, No.
c n y sc, ui nt n uniue n nealnt be .
'
Cr sclEx. Dkt
.

83-1. On J y 22, 2005, Vigi a N a i
ul
r ni tonal fl a lnanci sat e agai t Pr o w ih t
ied
ng t em nt
ns em
t he

Vigi aStt Cor rto Commison(( '. Purua tt Vigi aCod j8.A- 5,Vigni
r ni ae poain
si SCC'
)
s n o r ni e 9 51 r i a
N a i alfl d a tna i c ntnua i n s a e e o J 24,201 r ga di t i ta tna i
ton ie
s nc ng o i to t t m nt n une
0 e r ng he nii l i nc ng

2

s a e e . Vigi a N a i naltl d a s c c tnua i St t m e on J y 20,201 r g d ng t
t t m nt r ni to ie
e ond on i ton a e nt
ul
5 e ar i he
i ta Gna i s a e e .
nii l nc ng t t m nt
Pr m o ha n f fle is l n r pa e t o i to . A s ofJ 4,201 t o sa ng
e
s ot ulil d t oa e ym n blga i ns
une
8, he ut t ndi

baa eowe t Vigi aNa inali u ngprnci ,i e e t a lt f es i $1 443.6.
lnc
d o r ni to ,ncldi i pal nt r s, nd ae e , s 58, 5
H I.

The Unied St es'FederalTax Li
t
at
ens

Pr m o f l d t pa c ra n f de a lxe a s s e i 20 201 a 2011 On t da e o
e aie o y e t i e r l s s e s d n 09, 0, nd
.
he t f
t a s s m e t , e r lt x lensi f vo oft U nie St t s a os by ope a i o l p s ntt
he s e s n s f de a a i n a r he t d a e r e
r ton f aw, ur ua o

26U. C.jj63 a 63 TheUnie Sttsfld noie ofe c oft f dealtxle wih
S.
21 nd 22.
td ae ie tc s a h he e r a ins t
t Clr o t SCC,pu s n t Vigi aCodej 55 1 2. XsofSe e r3,201 ,Prmo'
he ek f he
rua t o r ni
- 4 1.
ptmbe
8 e s
o sa ngf de a tx oblgai tt $1 355.5.
uttndi e r l q
i tons o al 99, 8
IV.

O t Def
her endant to t A m ended Cros cl m
s he
s- ai

The Unie S' t s alo na e t Com m on e 1h o V igi a Pr m o G e r e M a a
t d à e s m d he
w a t f r ni , e , o g
yo, nd
M a i M a o as c os - l i de e nt . The r c d r ve l t t t V igi a D e r m e t o
re
y
r s c a m f nda s
e or e a s ha he r ni
pa t n f
Ta to a t e V igi a Em pl ym e Com m i son pr vi usy r c r ed m e o a
xa i n nd h
r ni
o nt
si
e o l eod
m r nda of le
i ns
a i t Pr m p f r un i t xe i t Ofi e of t Cl r o t e Cic t Co t f t Ciy of
ga ns e
o pa d a s n he fc
he e k f h r ui ur or he t
Cha l te vil I i undipu e ho e r t a t Com m onwe lh ha no t k n t se
ro t s le. t s
s t d, w ve , h t he
at
s t a e he t ps

ne e sr t obanapefce lena ai tt Pes nalPrperya is Se Stpulton!3, .
c say o ti re td i g ns he ro
o t t sue. e i ai
Dkt
1 (G'eCo
01 çf
rh mmon alhofVigi a' le , deci da , veno b e pefce a t t
we t
r ni s ins as srbe bove ha t e n re td s o he
Pe sonalPr
r
opert .,)1
y ,.

I d rVkgnalw, me rn u o le frc leto o txe ha fh e fc o aj dg n i fv r
Un e
ii a a mo a d m f in o olcin f a s s û e fe t f u me tn a o
t
o t Co n at t be e fre a p o ie i Aril 1 o Cha tr3 o Tie 8. (ft Co e o
f he mmo we l o n oc d s r vd d n t e 9 f pe f t 01 o he d f
h,
c
l
Vigii) e c p t tawrto feifca ma is ea a y t a rt me rnd m i fld. Va Cod j
r na, x e t ha
i f r a is y su t n i ûe he moa u s e ' . e
me
'
5 .- 8 5 Th is a c o awrto fei a isi rq ie t ce t ale o tep ro a p o ryo aj g n
8 11 0 . e su n e f i f ir fca s e urd o rae in n h es n l rpet f ud me t

dbo.Se Va Co ej 80 -7 ,80-01 seas I r ARCEnea Co .l2F.d1 1,19 U.. .
etr e . d j .14 8 .15 9 e lo n e
r m. 2 3 00 9 7 S Ajp
LEXI 2 3 , t*1 (t Ci.1 9 )(n u ls e tbl o iin C'hec ssctdb W alc fi t c n rdc
S 49 3 a 0 4h r 9 7 u p bih d a e pno ) I ae i y la e al o o ta lt
'
e
t f tt t unde Vigi a lw,W alac di not o an a pere t le a ns Coltr' pe s na pr ry
he ac ha,
r r ni a
l e d
bt i
f ced in gai t sa s r o l ope t

b cus iddno fl t rq st wrto fei a is' (mp a i o te )
e a e t i tie he e uiie i f ir fca .) e h ss mitd .
'

Ge r M a s r e as Pr m o' prnci o fc r a r gi t r d a n . M a i M a i
o ge yo e v d
e s i pal f e nd e s e e ge t
r e yo s

Ge geM a o' s e (ole tvey,t t yos'. I i un s td t neihe Prmo no t
or
y s pous c lci l he ;
Ma ' t s dipue hat t r e
)
r he
M a ha a y r m a ni o r hi i t r s i t Pe s l o t .2
yos ve n e i ng wne s p n e e t n he r ona Pr pery
ProceduralH it
s orv

On J n r 3, 7, e o a t M a Gl d t i t n a ton i t Cic tCour f rt
a ua y 201 Pr m nd he yos e he ns a t c i n he r ui
t o he
Ciy of Charott le. The U nied St t r oved t ac i t t s courton Januar 11,2017.
t
l esvil
t
a es em
he ton o hi
y

Upon r o l t Unied St t s fl d a c os - a m a ns t e Pa ke s s e ng t f e l e on t
em va , he t
a e ie
r s cl i gai t h r r e ki o or c os
he
f de al t x le . The c os - l i was l t r a e d t i l
e r a i ns
r s cam
a e m nde o nc ude V igi a N a i na , t
r ni
to l he
Co m on e lh ofV igi a,Pr m o,a d t e M a asc os - l i de e nt . The a e d c os m
w at
r ni e
n h
yos r s c a m f nda s
m nde r s
cl m i t onl cl m t r ai pendi bef e t court
ai s he y ai hat em ns
ng or he
.

OnAu ut2 , 01 ,h Untd Sae fld amo in frs mmayj d me t Th Pak r
g s 4 2 8 te i tts ie
e
t o u r u g n. e r es
o
ûld t s e r s ns t t mo in o Se e r 7, 201 The mo in i no rpe f
e he ol e po e o he to n ptmbe
8.
to s w i or
diposto .3
s ii n
Standard ofRevi
ew

Rul 56 of t Feder Rul of Ci l Pr
e
he
al es
vi ocedur per is a pary t m ove f s m ar
e mt
t o
or um
y

j d me t Cl ec u t h l g a ts mmayj d me ti temo a ts wst a t eei n g n ie
u g n . s- o r s al rn u r u g n f h v n ho h t h r s o e un
-h
diput a t a maei fc a t mo nti e ildt j me a amatroflw. Fe R.
s e s o ny tral a t nd he va s ntte o udg nt s te a ' d.
'

Ci. 5 () I d cdn wh te t g a tas mmayj d me tmoin,h c u t s t iwg te
v P. 6a. n e iig eh r o rn u r u g n to te o r mu t l e ) h
v
f c s a r a ona e i e e es dr wn t e e r i t lght m os f vor bl t t nonm o ng
a t nd e s bl nf r nc
a
h r f om n he i
t a a e o he
vi

pat. W o ladv. l a e, 2F.d8 5 8 3(t Ci. 01 )
ry' olr Gal h r 71 3 6 , 7 4h r 2 3.
'
a

2ThePes na Pr ry i l sa pan b0 h. The M a i tal m ant ne t tt pan b00h wasa
ro l ope t ncude
it 0t
yos nii l i ai d ha he it t
y

fxueatc e t ra po et ta te o e a drne t Pe . Ho v rteMa sh v sn eG d ttd
itr t h d o el rp ry h t h y wn d n e td o rmo we e,h yo a e ic a mi e j
a
l
al tonset ls ng Pr mo' ownes p oft pantbo h' a t tme i wass d b t Sherf t t Pa kes
iegai sabihi
e s
rhi
he i ot ' t he i t
ol y he
i o he r r.
Oco r1 201 Or r1 Dl No.81
tbe 2, 7 de , d.
.
3Thec t d tr ne t torla g e woul notadt decsona pr e sa t stm e
our has ee mi d ha a r um nt
d
i he ii l oc s t hi i .

4

Di cus on
s si
1.

Juri ct on
sdi i

The Unie S a e f l d is ame d c os - a m a t r que t o t Chi f Co elo t
t d t t s ie t
nde r s cl i t he e s f he e uns f he
I t r alRe nue Se vi e a de e t oft Se r a y of t Tr a u y,a a t die to of t
nen
ve
r c,
l ga e he c et r
he e s r nd t he r c i n
he

Ator yGe er ,i a oda ewih26U. C.jj7401a 7 3.Thec tha j iditonu r
t ne n al n cc r nc t
S.
nd 40
our s urs ci nde
26 U. C.j 740 a 28 U. C.jj 1 31 1 a 1
S.
2 nd
S.
3 , 340, nd 345. G l pesnshavi le upon or
W l ro
ng ins

cai ng a itrs i 'te Pes nalPrpe t ha be nj ne a pate purua t 26 U. C.
l mi ny neet n' h ro
o ry ve e oi d s ris s nt o
S.
j7403b)
(.
I
I.

V aldiv oftheFeder Tax Li
it
al
ens

Thel ena Re n Cod prviest tGll a y pes la et pa a txneglcsor
ntr l ve ue e o d ha tif n ron ibl o y ny a
et
r f e t pa t s m e a t r de a t a ou ...s al be a le i f voroft U nie St t s
e us s o y he a
fe m nd, he m nt
h l
in n a
he t d a e
upon a1 pr ry a rgh s t pr ry,whe h r r alo pe s nal be ongi t s h pe s n. 26
l ope t nd i t o ope t
t e e r r o , l ng o uc r o '
'

U. C.j6321 Suc le Shala iea t tmet a s s nti ma a s l c ntnu untlhe
S.
. h in < l rs t he i he sesme s de nd hal o i e it
s
la lt f rt a o s a s s e ...i s ts d o be o e un nf c a e by r s of lps of
i biiy o he m unt o s e s d
s a i ûe r c m s e or e bl
ea on a e

tme. 1 j6
i ' d. 322.G melpsswh n t perodfrc lci oft le rnsunde ( U. C.
'
Ti a e e he i o ole ton he in u
r 26 S. )
j650 a. l r Coe 205B. 668,67 ( n D.M a s 1 97) us t tx le e rs(1
2()' n e l,
'
R.
2 Ba k.
s . 9 .Th ,he a in xpie t0
ye r atrt a ssme oftetx, unl s( tmeyprc e n i c tf t cole tonof(he
as fe he se s nt h a ' es 1 i l o e dig n our or he lci
'
a
t)
txi c mme e 'oe tndtec lcinpeid.26U. C.j650 a.çf eta frofprpet
a s o nc d't xe h ole to ro
S.
2() ç' r nse
-h
o ry
s e n t t a t h e o t le do n a f c t e len f r i ' o t ve y na ur and
ubs que t o he tac m nt f he i n es ot f e t h i , o t i f he r t e
s

e s nc ofa le t tno ma tri o who eha t pr pe t go ,i pasesc m onee. Unied
se e
in, ha
te nt
s nds he o ry es t s u
r '
' t

Stt v. s,3 U. 51 5 ( 9 )(ntr quoai maksomitd)
aes Be s 57 S. , 7 1 58 i enal tton r
te .
I t s c s ,i i u s e t tPr m o f ie t pa f de a t xe a s s e i 2009,201 ,
n hi a e t s ndiput d ha e
ald o y e r l a s s e s d n
0
a 2011 As a r s t f d r t x le i f vor o t Unied St t s a o e a t tm e t
nd
.
e ul, e e al a i ns n a
f he
t
a e r s t he i he

a s s me t we e ma a a tc d t al pr ry t n owne b Pr mo,i l ng t e Pe s l
s e s n s r de nd ta he o l ope t he
d y e
ncudi h r ona

Prpet a is . Se 26U. C.jj6321. 2. l i alo undiputd t tt a sse a
o ry t sue e
S.
-632 t s s
s e ha he se sd mouns
t
h ve notbe n s ts d a t tt le h ve n b c e une o ce bl due t a l ps oftm e. 1
a
e a ife nd ha he i ns a ot e om
nf r a e
o a e i
d.

j 63 Co e nty,t Unie Sttsha vai tx le on t Pes lPrpet a i i
22. ns que l he td ae s ld a ins he rona o ry, nd t s
e tte t e oc t le unde 26U. C.j7
nild o nfre he ins r
S.
403. Se 26U. C.j7403$ (En a y c s whee
e
S.
4 & n ae r
1
t r has be n a r f a orne e t t pa an t x,ort dic r a la l y i r s c t r o ,
he e
e
e us l
gl c o y y a
o s ha ge ny i bii n e pe t he e f
t
whe he o no lvy ha be n m a ,t Ator y Ge r or hi de eg t a t r que t of t
t r r te
s e
de he t ne
ne al
s l a e, t he e s
he
Se r t r m a die ta c vi a to t be fl d i a dit itc to t Unie S a e t e o c t
c e a y, y r c i l c i n o
ie n
sr c our f he t d t t s o nf r e he

le oft Unie Sttsunde t sttewih r pe tt s h tx o la lt o t s j c a
in he td ae
r hi il t es c o uc a r ibiiy r o ube t ny
pr pe t o w ha e rna u e oft de i e ,o i whi h he ha a y r g ,tte ori e e t t t
o ry, f
t ve t r , he lnqu nt r n c
s n i ht il
nt r s , o he

pa ntofs htxorla lt '
yme
uc a ibiiy.
).
H I.

Pri w ofCl m s
ori
ai

Se to 740 rquie t c r t deemi te prort o c tng le o cai
cin 3/) e rs he ou t o tr ne h i iy f ompei ins r l ms
upon t Pe s alPr pe t See $.j7403() d'epro i o afdea tx l n i g r dby
he r on
o ry.
.
c.El irt f e rl a i s ovene
-h
y
e
.

fd r lw. l r RetvoAuoBody.lc.772F. 1 ,1 ( h Ci.201 .Unde fdea lw,
e eala ' n e si
'
t
n,
3d 68 72 4t r 4)
r e rl a
atx le aie a t tmet tx ases nti ma ,26 U. C.j632 a t neal tk
a in rss t he i he a s sme s de
S.
2, nd ' rly a es
ge
pro iy o r a le c ea e afert tda e un rt c m m on-a prnc pl t tEhe fr ti tm e i
i rt ve i n r t d t ha t de he o
l w i i e ha t
s n i s

tefrti rgh,'l r RetvoAuoBod 7 F.da 1 2-73(mphassa d (uotngUnie
h is n i t'' n e si
t
v, 72 3 t 7
e
i dde ) q i
td
Sttsv.CivofNe Brt n,347U. 81 8 ( 95 Ho r atx le i no E lda ag ns
ae
t
w iai
S. , 5 1 4:. weve, a in s t : i s ai t
va

a y p rh sr h le o a sc rt itrs,me h ncsl n r o j d me tl n ce i r'u tla
n u c ae, od r f e u i néet c a i' i o , r u g n i rdt ' ni
y
e
e
o
n ieo fdea txle ha be nfld.26U. C.j6 a .
otc f e r la in s e ie
S. 3234)
A ppl ng t s l ga prnc pl s t c ta e s w ih t pa te t t Vigi a N a i nals
yi he e e l i i e , he our gr e t he r i s ha r ni to '
c a m t t Pe s lPr ry a i s i s rort al o he c ai s i l ng t f de a t x le .
l i o he r ona ope t t s ue s upe i o 1 t r l m , nc udi he e r l a i ns
Vigi a N a i lwast tr tt pe f c iscl i a i tt Pe s lPr pe t by pr ry flng a
r ni tona
he i s o r e t t a m ga ns he r ona o ry
ope l ii

fna i sae n wiht SCC onJ y22,200 Se Va. ej8. 51 Si et ttme t
i ncng ttme t t he
ul
5. e Cod
9A- 5. nc ha i ,he
6

ba ha m a nt n is pe f c ed s urt i e e tby flng ne es a y c tnua i sa e e s 1
nk s i ai ed t r e t ec iy nt r s
i
c s r on i ton t t m nt . d.
Be a e Vigi a N a i na w a t e fr t t pe f c is cl i t t Pe s l Pr ry, t c r
c us r ni to l s h i s o r e t t a m o he r ona ope t he ou t
c l st a t ba ha prort unde t Gr ti tm e nle. l i undipu e t tt a oun of
onc ude h t he nk s i iy
r he s-n-i
l ts
s t d ha he m t

Vigi aNai lscl m, ofJ 4,2018 i $1 443.6.
r ni tona' ai as une
, s 58, 5
Th c ur ag e w ih t pa te t t t Unie St t s cl i t t Pe s lPr pe t a
e o t r es t he ri s ha he t d a e ' a m o he r ona o ry t
is i s co i prort be a e t e Unie St t sw a t ne pa t t pere tis i t r s . I i
s ue s e nd n i iy, c us h
t d a e s he xt ry o f c t n e e t t s
undipu e t tt Unie St t spr ry pe f c e ist x le b f lng no i soff de a t x le
s t d ha he t d a e ope l r e t d t a i ns y ii
tce
e r l a i ns

wih t SCC. Se 26 U. C.j 63 a;Va.Cod j 55-42.. The noieswee tld on o
t he
e
S.
234)
e
1 1
tc
r se
r
bewe M a 4,2009a No mbe 1 2011 Purua t 26 U. C.563 *,t fdea tx
t en y
nd ve r 4, . s nt o
S.
234 he e rl a
le ha prort ove a y le or o he i t r s s t t a o e t r a t r I i undipu e t tt
i ns ve i iy r n i ns
t r n e e t ha r s he e fe . t s
s t d ha he

a
moun o t Unie Sut s cl m, ofSe t mbe 3, 8,s$1 355.
t f he td e ' ai as
p e r 201 i 99, 85.
A s no e a
t d bove t Pa ke s pur ha ed t Pe s nalPr pe t a t pu i a tons he d i
, he r r
c s he r o
o ry t he blc uc i
l n

Nove ro 201 a Jnuayo 201 l i undipue t ttheS rf s dt prpet s j c
mbe f 6 nd a r f 7. ts s td ha t heif ol he o ry ube t
t
t a l i le r a t td ny s h p i r le pa s d t ough a c tnue t en m be wha t
o 1 pror i ns' nd ha s uc r o i ns s e hr
'
a
nd on i d o cu r t he
Pa ke s bo t' Pa k s Re p. o M o .Sum m J 4-5,Dlt No.1 I i a s un s e t tt
r r ugh ' r er ' s t
t
.
c.
05. t s l o diput d ha he
onl p i r le t tpa s d tzou a d c ntnue t e u be t pr pe t w e e t e ofV igi a
y r o i ns ha s e lr gh n o i d o nc m r he o ry r hos
r ni
N a i lBa a t U nie St t s 1 a 5;s e a s U nie St t s Re y Br 2,Dl N o.1
tona nk nd he t d a e . d. t e l o t d a e ' pl .
d.
06

(c wldgig t tte Co
a kno e n ha h mmonweat of Vigi a di no ha a pefce le a i tt
lh
r ni d t ve
re td in gans he
Pes nalPr pe t a t e tme i wa s d by t She if a t tt owne s p i e e t ofPr mo
ro
o ry t h i t s ol
he rf, nd ha he
rhi ntr ss
e

a ort Ma weee tnguihe u t s e .Ac o di y,hePakes cli t t Pe snal
nd/ he yos r xi s d pon he al) c r ngl t r r' am o he ro
Pr ry, c t y c r e l own a pos e s i t r i prort
ope t whi h he u r nty
nd s s , s hid n i iy.
IV.

Forecl
osure oft FederalTax Li
he
ens

Se ton 7403 oft I e na Re nue Code pe m ist Unied Sht s t f e l e on ist x
ci
he nt r l ve
r t he t
e o or c os
t a

le by s ki as e o t pr pe t whih isle aeatc
ins ee ng al f he o o o c t ins r tahed. 26U. C.j740 a .An
S.
3() y

p o et i whc ad l q e t a p y rh st n rg ttte o itr s'i s be t ot ef rco ue
rp ry n ih ei u n tx a e a E y ih,il, r nee t s u jc t h o e ls r
n
a
'
pr e i ,i l ngprpe t i whih ohescam a itrs,asl a $a1 pes ha ng
oce dngs ncudi o ry n c t r li n neet ong s : )1 rons vi
(

le upono cai nga itrs i t pr ry'aej ne a patest t aci 1 j7 a,
ins
r l mi ny neet n he opet ' r oi d s ri d he ton. d. 403()
() Afe deemi ngt meisofC lcai t a le on'teprpet a is a d fndi
b . tr tr ni he rt t l ms o nd ins ' h o ry t sue n i ng
al
t tE cl m o i eetofteUnie Sttst r n E sbe nqetbls e 't c tE yde rea
ha û ai r ntrs h td ae heei ha e sa ih d,'he our t
a
ma ce
s l of s h pr pe t 'a ç dit i uto o t pr e ds ofs h s e a c di t t Gndi o
a e uc o ry' nd ç s rb i n f he oc e
a
uc al c or ng o he
ngs f

t c r i rs c t t i eesso t pate a oft Unie Stts' 1 j7403c .
he ou tn epe t o he ntr t f he ris nd he td ae . d.
'
()
TheUnie Saesh c mpledwih j7403byna ng a dee da st iscos- am a1
td tt as o i t
mi s fn nt o t r scli l

pate S vi le uponorcai nga i ee ti 'hePes lPr rya is I j7 b)
ris d ng ins
ha
l mi ny ntrs n't rona opet tsue. d. 403( .
The Unie Sàt ha alo e u bls
td
es s s s ihed t t i ha vald t x le o t Pe s l Pr pe t
ha t s i a i ns n he r ona o ry.
A ccor ngl t coultGnds i appr i e t or t f ecl e and sal oft Per onalPr t
di y, he
'
t
oprat o der he or osur
e he s
opery

a pemitdby j7403c. Consse wihohe cae i t scrui,teco twilauh i a
s r te
()
itnt t t r ss n hi ic t h ur l torze nd
diec t ltr Re nueSe vc sPr ryAp aiala Liui to S cait (TALS' t
r t he nenal ve
r ie' opet pr s nd q dain pe ilss
'o
)
c nduc t s l Se .e. ,Unie St t sv.Sa he M a tne N o.5: 1 c 00
o
t he a e. e g. t d a e
nc z- ri z,
1 - v- 657,201 U . Di t
2 S. s .

LEXI 6 42,a *8( D. C. y 18 201 ;Unie Sttsv.Stnils No.3: -v- 3,200
S 95 t E. N. Ma , 2) td ae
a sa ,
07c 0039
9
U. Dit LEXI 527 a * ( D.Va.M a.1 2009 ;Unie Stt v.Wheln,No.5: c
S. s.
S 74, t 2 E.
r 8, ) td aes
a
06-v038 2008U. Dit LEXI 6 4,a * ( D.W .Va Apr 22,2008;Unie Sttsv.Re r,
8,
S. s.
S 233 t 2 S.
. .
td ae
nua t

No. c 460, U. DitLEXI 978 a *1( . N. Ma 1 2006 .
05-v- 2006 S. s.
S 48, t M D. C. y 7, )
D it but on oft Proceeds
s ri i
he

The fn is f de e na i n i t pr pe dit i uto oft pr ce ds f o t s e o
i al s ue or t nni to s he o r s rb i n he o e r m he al f
t Per onalPr t l accor
he s
opery. n
dance w ih t applcabl pr sons of t l er Revenue Code
t he
i e ovi i
he nt nal

a e s i c e a ,t pr e ds f o t s l oft Pe s lPr pe t s l be di ti e as
nd xitng as l w he oc e r m he a e
he r ona o r y ha l
srbut d

f lwsuni e use ()Fis,t stsy a y al dc t a e pe e ofs l,a deemi d
olo
tl xha td: 1 rt o aif n lowe oss nd x ns s ae s tr ne

b s b e u n od ro 1 l c u t () S c nd t Vlgn aNalna u flte c mmeca la
y u s q e t r e f h* o r; 2 e o , o r lî to l n h o ril o n
q
4
o lg io ss c rdb tePes o P o e t aests d ()Thr , oteUntd S e u t te
bla n e u e y h ro rp ry r aise ; 3 ld t h le uts nl h
l

f rltx l bl ss l c t ten dc so fd mltx l n ie M e i p rra h 1 o te
dea a i iie mb e t o h o e f e e a l s d n d n aa p 3 f h
a i
e

a n e co scsm aeotsid a d()F l l,h b ln e l n ,oteP r es
me d d r s-ll r ife ; n 4 ol h te aa c ,fa y t h ak r.
d
Co l i
neuson

Fort r a ons sae t c ur c l est tt Unt d Sat i e fte t s
be e s
tt d, he o t oncud ha he le t es s n l d o umma y
r

j d e to iqco scnm se gt f rco eo t ePes n l r p r a is e Ac o A gy te
u m n n t r s-ll e e o o e ls n h ro a P o et t s u . c r l,h
y
c u twi ga tte Untd S ae 'moim An a p o raeJ d e ta d o d ro sl wl b
o r l rn b i tts to
l
e
p r p if u n n n re f ae l e
l
e e e t sd y.
ntr d hi a
The Clr i die td t s nd c pis o t i me r ndum o nin a t a c
ek s r ce o e o e f b s mo a
pi o nd he c ompa ng
nyi
or e t alc nnq o r c r
d r o l o el f e o d.
-

oaw o: l 4 # da o se t mbe ,2 1 .
n s 4 y f pe r 0 8

Se Unte Stt sDiG c J e
dor td a e s t udg

4I i l s cdt tt pr ee âo tl s l oft Pe s lPr t mus f tbeuR. t c tl
t s mdiput ha he oc
m le ae he r ona opery t %
ed o over lt
e ns s o t s e. Se e. .Unie Sut sv.Sa che u prl a No.5:
xpe c f he al
e. g. td e
n z- fne
11<v00657,201 U. Di LEM S
2 S. s
t
--

6 5 2 a *1 ( D. C.Ma 1 ,2 2 (rei sl poce st b I GIfrtSo t egesso t si,
9 4 : t 2 E. N- y 8 01) odrng ae r ed o e I ls t r he x no f he ae
S
f
h ld ayepn e icr dt s r o manmntepo et pn igsl adcn oou nb t c ut)
mu mg n x e ss nur o xue r it. h ry r e dn ae n o s o y j o r ;
e
y
w
m
Unt S e v.Ss ilq No.3:7 c 0 3 3 2 0 U. D1t LEYI 5 7 4 a # I D.Va Ma.1 ,20 9
id u s tnsa .
0 -v-0 9 , 0 9 S. s. S 2 7 , t E. . r 8 0 )
(= e;seas px 6U. C.û6 4 (rvdn tn mo e rnle fc tesl o yo et t stsyafdrl
s ) e lo . 2 S. 32 poiig bt ny el d rm h ae f rpry o alf e ea
f
y
txle R lbeu e f tt p y t Vex e eo lv a s1' .Howe r leUmtdS ae a dt ePakes
a in bsl s d rs o a he l p ns f e y nd ae'
)
ve,
e tts n h r r
sv lgy dsre a t wheh rsc epegsi l etesoa cssicre b tePakesdl gte
e nl ia e s o te ub x ne ncud h trge ot nurd y h r r l h
nn
.

-

.*

pe nc oft ac n. 'he co twilr eon t spaëculris attw tmo i be
nde y hs fo I
ur l ul
hi
a s ue l i t come ne s o t c m ,
s ce s o onlr
tl s ea died ds s me o t l e pr e . Prort doi s t co t* 1pemi t pa te t fl
lo al nd r
bure nt f ho al oc eds i o ng o, he ur
r t he ris o te
s e n a bref ont Lsu ofwhih ex n a epr l c
upplme t l i s he s e
c pen es r opery on/de e nq so t s e.
md xpe e f he al

9