Premo Autobody, Inc. et al v. Parker et al

Filing 56

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 4/28/17. (hnw)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI CoUU
S
CE S. SI e
AT RLANOKE,
VA
FI
LED

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN D I
STRI OF VI GN A
CT
R
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON

AF2 28 2 1
27
J

E% CLERK

BY2

;
.
:
.
e
D

ERK

PREM O AU TOBOD Y ,I C. e a1,
N ,t .
Ci lA c i N o.3: 7CV 00001
vi ton
1
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
M EM O M N D U M O PI IO N
N

C.W AV ER LY PARK ER,e a .
t l,

Ho Gl n E.Conr d
n. e
a
Chi fUnie Stt Diti tJ
e
td aes src udge

De e nt
f nda s.
Pl i if Ge ge A. M a M a i L.M a a Pr m o Aut y, I br
antfs or
yo, re
yo, nd e
obod nc. ought t
he
i t nta to agans de enda s C.W a ry Pa ke ,M i ha lPa ke ,t She iff rt Ciy of
nsa ci n i t f nt
ve l r r c e r r he rf o he t

Cha l ts le a t Unie St t s of Ame i a.The c e wa orgi ly fl i t Cic t
rote vil, nd he t d a e
rc
as
s i na l ied n he r ui
Cou tf rt Ciy ofCha l te vil Vigni a t Unie Stt stm ey r m ove t m a tr
r o he t
ro ts le, r i a, nd he t d a e i l e
d he te
t t s co t The pl i if s e de l r t y r le i r a i t a s l of c ran pr ry a
o hi ur.
antfs e k c a aor e if n elton o ae
e ti ope t nd

a sr ac us ofa tonf tes si a i tcel nde e nt.Thematri c rntybeo e
se t a e ci or r pasng gans rai fnda s
te s ure l fr

tec uto t P r r'moin frs mmayj g n a t Co ns1a d1,sv rn ea d
h o r n v akes to s o u r ud met s o u t n l e ea c n
r ma of Co 11 a t va a e t c lts or r gr ntng pl i if lave t a e t i
e nd
unt 1, nd o c t he otr' de a i
antfs e
o m nd her
c
ompli .The She ifha alo m o d t dim is t c m pl i agans hi .Fort r as ns
ant
rf s s
ve o s s he o ant i t m
he e o

sae ,h moinsfrs
ttd te to o ummayj g n a dt d s s wil g a td. 1oh rmoinswil
r ud me t n o imis lbe rn e Al t e tô l
be de e
ni d.
B ackzround

PrmoAu o d I . : e ' i aVignaCopo ain whihf r iryman an dis
e
tbo y,ne (Trmo' s r ii r r to
)
c o n el itie t
o f si Chalte vle Vig na Am.Co l ! 2 Cu rn l,i i n ta tv l e g g d i
fke n ro ts il, r i i.
mp . . re ty t s o ciey n a e n
bus ne s but is prnc pa ofi e a r gi t r d a nt i G e ge M a
i s,
t i i l f c r nd e se e ge s
or
yo, a r i nt of
esde

Chal ts le 1 M areM a i Ge geM a ss e(ole tvey,he$ a '.
roté vil. d. i yo s or
yo' pous c lci l t G yos'
M
)

The Unie Stt hol a s ur d c am a i tPr mo i t n omtofa oxi ael
t d aes ds ec e l i ga ns e
n he m t
ppr m t y

$ 1 ,7 31b vrueo tnNoie o Fe e a TM Lin (C FTU' lldp i rt No mb r1 ,
1 93 7. y it f e tc s f d r l
e S
N
) ie ro o ve e 5
20 1 JJ ! 9 On De e e 1 , 01 ,d fn a t C. a e l a M iha lPak r(olciey,
1 .-S .
1
.
.
c mb r 5 2 5 ee d n s W v ry nd c e r e c le tv l

t t r e s' o ti d a j d me t a an tPrmo i t e a u t o $ 93 ( t r e
he t k r' b ane u g n g is e n h mo n f 4 ,01 t l k r
pa
)
he pa
J d me f S e Fia Or e,Pake v.P e ,No.5 0 .5 0 3 9 ( .Ci.Ct De .1 ,
u g n ). e n l d r r r r mo
4 C11 0 0 7 Va r . c 8
20 5,Do k t . - .On Fe r éy 1 , 01 t Cic i Co r f rt eCiy o Ch rots il
1 ) c e No 412
b u r 1 2 6,he r ut u t o h t f alte v l
e
is d awrtoffe if ci i e c i oft Pa ke J gm e t Se W rtofFir Fa i s Do ke
s ue
i
r a as n xe uton he r r ud n . e i
e i ca , c t
N o.413.

On Fe r ay 1 , 01 ,t S eifo t eCiy o Ch ro ts le J me Br wn C<heif
b u r 7 2 6 he h rf f h t f a ltevi , n s o
l
s rf
Br wn', g n t lv t efeifca o t p ro a p o e t o Prmo Se S eifsReun
o ' be a o e y h ir a is n he es n l r p ry f e . e h rf
)
tr
on W rtof Fir Fa i s Doc tNo.41 4.The She if s e nty s r d t pl i if wih
i
e i c a , ke
rf ubs que l e ve he antfs t
notc oft pe ng s e of t pr ry.Notc of She ifs Sa e Doc tN o.41 8.She if
i e he ndi al
he ope t
ie
rf
l , ke
rf
Br
own s dt pr pe t a publc a tonso N ove r30,201 J nua y 4,201 and J nua'
ol he o ry t
i uc i
n
mbe
6, a r
7,
a z
y
11 201 See Bil o Sae Doc tNo.41- 0.The Pa ke s ptr ha ed t pr ry,a t
, 7.
l f l,
ke
1
r r lc s he ope t nd he
She ifditi e t pr e dst t Pa ke si pa ta s ts a ton oft Pa ke J
rf srbut d he oc e o he r r n ri l a if c i
he r r udgme .Se
nt e

L. Af. fC. a el Pak r! 1 Do k t 411 J a p e eo t ep o rys l wa ap it
( ; f o W v ry r e 7, c e No. - .. A ic f h r pet od s an
l
b00t whi h t M a a s r wa a fxt e a tc d t r le tt owne by t M a a
h, c he yos s e t s i ur , ta he o ea sa e
d
he yos nd

rn e t P e .J= Am.Co l ! 3 .Th rf r , h M a o c ne d t t a afxtr t t i
e td o rmo # .
;
mp . 2 eeo e t e y s o tn ha, s i u e o her
ra pr p ry t yo dtepan b 0 ha dta iwa n ts b e t olvy
e l o e t,he wne h it 0 t n h t t s o u j c t e .
Pl i if fl d t i t t a to i t Ci c t Cour f t Ciy of Cha l tes le,
a ntf s ie he ns an c i n n he r ui
t or he t
r o t vil

Vigi a, a t Unie St t s tmel r moved. I Co I of t i a e d a orgi
r ni nd he
td ae i y e
n unt
he r m nde nd i nal
.

c pl i s pl i i f s e a de l r to t t t Unie St t s i e il t t pr o iy i
om a nt , a ntf s e k
c a a i n ha he
t d a e s ntted o he i r t n

pa ntofalpr ee fo t s e of a Pr m o pr ry.CountI,lbe e S n e pl a r'
yme
l oc ds r m he al
ny e
ope t
l a l d û t r e de ,
i
'

s e a de l r ton t tt Unie Stt s i e il t a pr ee oft Nove be Sae a
e ks
c a a i ha he t d a e s ntted o ny oc ds he
m r l nd

a ypr c e sfo s bs q e ts lso Prmop o ry Plitfsas s e t ej i teSh rf
n o e d ' m u e u n ae f e r pet. an if lo e k o n on h eif
r
fom a diG buton o s h pr ee whie t i t nt a ton i pe ng.Cot II o t
r
ny s
i f uc oc ds
l he nsa c i s ndi
mt I f he
odgi l c
na ompl i i l d a a ton f tes s agans t Pa ke s a She if Br
ant ncude n c i or r pas
i t he r r nd
rf own.
Ho ve ,o Fe a y 24,201 t pl ntf smove f l ve t n e t i compl ntt add
we r n bnlr
7, he ai if
d or ea o m nd he r
ai o
t Unie St t asa de e ntt Cot 11 a t i l ar que tf a de a a i t tt
he t d aes
f nda o mt 1, nd o ncude e s or
clr ton ha he
pant100t bel d t t M a a t tm e oft l vy a s e.The Unie St t di no
i 7 h onge o he yos t he i
he e nd al
t d aes d t

o j c t a n i t c mpan .Th c u tg a td t e panif la t n n a d t e
be t o me dng he o lit e o r rn e h litfs e ve o me d, n h
a nde c
me d ompli wa de m e fl o M a c 2,201
ant s e d ied n r h
7.
The Unied Stt ha a s tl d a c os c am a i tt Pa ke s s ki a or r of
t
aes s lo s e
r s l i gans he r r , ee ng n de
f e osle on t f de alt x le .She ifBr
or cl tr
he e r a ins
rf own a s fl a c os c am a ns t Pa ke s
l o ied r s l i gai t he r r ,

a sri ta t ePak r aela l t S eifBr wn p s a tt Vign aCo ej8013 7 f r
set h t h r es r ibe o h rf o , uru n o r ii d . - 6 , o
ng
a1 cai as e td agans hi .On Aprl1 201 t c the d a hea i on va i m o i ns
l l ms s re
i t m
i 2, 7, he our l
rng
rous to .
Them a tr ha bee f l bre ed a a erpef r vi w.
te s ve n uly i f nd r i or e e
D i cussi
s
on

Sher f Bro n' M oton t D i m i s
if w s
i o s s
I hi n e d ans e ,Sherf Br n a s rs a ç e i Ba . S e s i ba ha be n
n s m nde
w r
if ow s e t ç a n r ' ç a n r ve e
pl
' pl

a ihe by t Fe r lRul s o Ci i Pr e e....Ne rhe e s i i pr pe t te t
bols d
he de a
e f v l oc dur
ve t l s , t s o r o r at he

dee nt'jpla ngsasamoi t dimisf filr t saeacam . Gi nsv.O' nn,
fnda ls e di
ton o s s or alze o tt li ' ve
'
Oui

No 20 CV0 2 4, 0 6W L 3 9 3 , t* ( . Va Fe 2 , 0 6 . r ii Co ej801 3 7
. :2 0 1 2 0
9 6 8 a 1 W D. . b. 0 2 0 ) Vigna d . - 6
pr des t t a ofk e ,w he l vyi a ter f c a ,m ay r uie t t t c e t s eli t
ovi
ha n t r
n e ng s i a i s
eq r ha he r dior e cng he

lvypr vi a i mniyi bond.Thi bond s r st i mniyt ofi e agans ial
e
o de n nde f ng
s
e ve o nde f he fc r i t ll

da ge whi h hem a s t i i c e nce o t s i r ors e ofs h pr ry a t pay
ma
c
y usan n ons que
f he e zu e al
uc ope t nd o

t a ca ma of s h pr pe t al da a wlih he m a s t i i c e nc o s h
o ny li nt
uc o ry l m ge lc
y usan n ons que e f uc

s iu e o sl. Va Co e j8013 7 Att he rng panif c nc d d t a S rf Br wn
ez r r ae' . d . - 6 . he ai , litfs o e e h t heif o
'
r eve s h a i
ec i d uc n ndemniyi bond fom t Pa ke s Pli tf st n si a e t t dimi s l
f ng
r he r r . a n if he tpult d o he s s a

o S rf Br wn,t wh c n p ry o j ce .Ac o dngy S e ifBr wn wilb ds s e
f heif o o ih o a t b e td c r i l , h rf o
l e imis d
f om t s a ton.
r hi c i
I.
I

Par s M oton f Sum m ar Judgm e
ker '
i or
y
nt

S mma y j d me ti a p o dae wh n çhe p e dng ,te d so r a d d s ls r
u r u g n s p r p t e i la i s h ic vey n ico u e
t
ma e i l on fl ,a a a fda t s w t tt r i no ge ne is ast a ma e i lf t
t ras
ie nd ny fi vis ho ha he e s
nui s ue o ny t ra ac

a ta t e mo a ti e tte t j d me ta amatro lm ' Fe .R.Ci.P.5 () F ra
nd h t h v n s n ild o u g n s
te f a ' d
v
6a. o
p ry se i nc t rieag n ieis eo maeilfc,tmu tbeç u h t tar a o a l j r
a t' vde e o as e un su f tra a t i s l c ha e s n be u y
s
.

co d r t n ave ditf t nonul em'
r c or he
movi pa t ' Anderon v.Li ry Lobby.l . 477 U. 242,
ng ry.
'
s
be t
nc,
S.

2 ( 9 6 .W h n d cdn wheh rt g a tamoi n f rs mmmy j d me t t e c u tmus
48 1 8 ) e e iig t e o rn
to o u
u g n, h o r
t
viw t r c d i t lghtm os f vor bl t t non- o ng pa t a dr w a1r s na e
e he e or n he i
t a a e o he
m vi
ry nd a l ea o bl

i ernc i hi fvor J a 255;seas Te r sFl Fa hi .l v. llngtn I us.I ,
nf e es n s a .Z t
e lo ry' oor s ons nc. Btri o nd . nc.

7 3 F.d 6 4 61 (t Ci.1 8 ) He e t ePak r ha emo d frs mmayj dg n a t
6 2 0 , 0 4h r 9 5 . r , h r es v ve o u r u me t s o
Cot sIa I.
mt nd I
A . C ountl

Cot 1s e a d l r ton t ta 1pr e 9om t s l ofPr m o pr pe t bel t
mt e ks ec a a i ha 1 oc eds
he a e
e
o ry ong o

t Unie Stts Vigi alw prvi t twhe api eofpr ry s j c t awrto fei
he td ae . r ni a o des ha
n ec
ope t ub e t o
i f ir
f c a i s d,t pr edsa eus t s tsy t fe if c a a t s l ,i a i r pa d t
a i s s ol he oce
r ed o aif he r a i s nd he up us f ny, s e i o

t d b o . .Co e j80 - 9 Ho v r i te p o e t a is i s b e tt ap ir s n o
he e tr Va d .14 5. we e , f h r p ry t sue s u j c o ro , e ir
s cliy itr s,i ma n v rhee sb lv e u o f rt s tsa to o aj no feifca .
e t t n eet t y e e t ls e e id p n o he aifcin f u ir ir a is
r

S eVa Co e j8014 0 W h np o e t s b e tt asniritr s i lvidt stsyaj n o
e . d . . - 8 . e r p ry u j c o e o n ee t s e e o aif u ir
le ,o e o t o to swilr s l;()t ep o e t wi b s l fe a d ce ro t s n o
in n f wo uc me l eu t 1 h r p ry l e o d r e n la f he e ir
l
itrs; r()t s no itr s wil e i atc e t t ep o e' d s iet s l.
n eet o 2 he e ir nee t lrman 'a h d o h r p ly e pt he ae
t
t
I t s ni s cliy i e es i d a pa bl prort t s e t ofi e exe utng t
f he e or e trt nt r t s ue nd ya e i o he al, he fc r c i he

feif ca ç y s l t ep o ry fe o s c (el r s ctiy itr s .... I (mp ss
ir a is ç
ma el h r pe t re f u h s ro ! e t t n ee t
i
r
' d. e hai
'
a d d . h t e t ep o e t i s l s be tt t esnirl no fe a d ce ro i r man te
d e ) W eh r h r p ry s od u j c o h e o i r re n la f t e i s h
e
dicei oft lvyi ox c r J l t e ntt tt ofieritndst s l t pr pet fe
srton he e ng
e .. n he ve ha he fc ne o el he o ry r e
Z
a c e r oft s hi i e e t t ofi e mus fr tpr de t s ni le hol r s fcint
nd l a
he e or nt r s, he fc r
t is ovi he e or i n de uf e

no i e.Afe t s l t ofi e a i t pr ee f r tt t pa
tc
tr he ae, he fc r pples he oc ds f s o he ymen of s h s c iy
t
uc e urt
i e e t a t r sdue, s f r a ne es a y, t t s ts a ton of t fe i f is' 1
nt r s, nd he e i
o a s c s r o he aif c i
he i r aca .' d.
Ale nai l i t She ifdoesnotnotf t s ri s c ed pa t a t She ifa mc
tr tvey, f he rf
iy he e lor e ur
ry, nd he rf nnot es

ta te sl wi be ma e s b e tt te snirs c dt itr ss te sniritrs rmans
h t h ae l
l
d u j c o h e o e u y n ee t, h e o n ee t e i
a tc d t t pr ry de piet s l Thepr e dsa eus t s tsy t fe if i s a e not
ta he o he ope t s t he a e.
oc e r ed o aif he i r ac a , r

rpadt t de t a e as pl ,a a eno us dt s tsyt s nirs urt i e et 1L
e i o he bor bsnt ur us nd r t e o aif he e o ec iy ntr s. l
.
He e be us t Unied Stt fl t NFTL i 2011 s ver lyea sbe o et Pa ke
r , ca e he t
aes ied he
n
,e a
r f r he r r
J
udgme a os ,t Unie St t hol a s ir i e e ti t lvi d pr pe t Pro t t
nt r e he t d aes ds upero nt r s n he e e o ry. i r o he

s l,h S eife piil sae ta ça 1ie a es l s be tt a ya da1le s'S eTems
ae te h rf x lcty ttd h t ç )l tms r od u jc o n n l in . e r
E
'
oft She i sSae,J n.4,201 Doc tNo.41 1 M or ove ,t Unie Stt save s t ti
he rY
l a
6, ke
- 0. e r he y d a e
r ha t
di no r c venotc oft s e.Se M ot t l e ve 5, ketNo.41 1 Be us t Unied
d t e ei
ie he al e
. o nt r ne Doc
- 2. ca e he t

Sttsdi no r c venotc a SheifBr s cfc l s l t prpe t s j c t an a
ae d t e ei
ie nd rf own pe iialy od he o ry ube t o y nd

alle s u d rVigna lw,t e Prmo p o e t s l t te Pak r r man s b e tt t e
l in , n e r ii a h e
r p ry od o h r e s e i s u j c o h
f de a t x le . pr ee f om t s l a e t be us d t s ts y t te if c a , ih a
e r l a i ns The oc ds r he a e r o
e o a i f he i r a i s w t ny

s pl r pa d t t de or The e or unde Vig ni l w,t Unie St t s ha no i e e ti
ur us e i o he bt . r f e,
r r i a a he t d a e s
ntr s n
t pr ee fom t s l a t f de a tx le r m an i ac.
he oc ds r he a e s he e r l a ins e i nt t
The s m e r s tocczswhe t c tl kst f de a l w.The I t m a Re nue Code
a
e ul lr
n he our oo o e r l a
n e l ve
pr de t twhe t Unie St t ha acli o le on a pi c ofpr ry a t pr ry
ovi s ha
n he t d aes s a m r in
ee
ope t nd he ope t

i s b e t t a n nudca s l,t e fd r l le rmans atc d t t p o ry a e t
s u jc o o j iil ae h e e a in e i ta he o he r pet bsn
sa uorl pr s rbedno i et t Unie Sae . e IR. j7 2 4 A. a dR. Co l p.
tt t iy- e c i
tc o he td tts S e . C. 4 5 1 H. n S. a Co
$;
,

v. td S ae ,4 F.S p 75 ,75 ( . Pa 1 7 )(und rs7 2 4 )an nj d ca s l
Uni tts 61 u p. 2 5 W D. . 9 8 ç e 4 5 b o -u iil ae
e
ç
dvet p o ryo af d rltx le o l i: 1 Th Uni dS ae fie t fl t erc r noie
i ss rpet f e ea a in ny f ( ) e t tts ald o ie h e o d tc
e
o t ele 3 d y b f r t sl ; r( )t eUntd S ae c nsnt t a te sl ds h r e t
f h in 0 a s eo e he ae o 2 h ie tts o e s h t h ae ic ag s he
le o ( )t e ce io c mple wih n tc p o iinsp e cie b s cin 7 2 ()a t
in; r 3 h rdtr o is t oie r v so r s rb d y e to 4 5 c nd he
r g ai n pr mugae t rt e . Eve i' eUrtd S ae i o n tc o tes l,tmus
e ulto s o l td heemd r'
). n ft l e tts s n o ie f h ae i t
h i
c nsn t a t ep o e t wi bes l fe a dce ro isl ns S eIR. j7 2 ()2 ; o te
o e t h t h r p ry l od re n la f t i . e . C. 4 5 c( ) S uh m
l
e
Ba k o La d r aeCt . I 7 0F.d 1 01 1 0 n. ( 1hCi.1 8 )( oi gt a t esau e
n f u ed l y v.RS, 7 2 0 , 0 2 3 1 t r 9 5 n tn h t h tt t
r uie t Unie St t st c e tt dic r o t t x le whe t pr ry i s d a a
eq r s he t d a e o ons n o s ha ge f he a i ns
n he ope t s ol t

no j iil ae.I teisa tc s, h UntdS ae d dn t e even tc o t eS eifss l
nudca s l) n h n tn a e t e ie tts i o r c i oie f h h rf ae
a di no c e .Se M o i t I ewe 5,Doc tNo.41 1 Co eque l t
nd d t ons nt e ton o ntl ne
ke
- 2. ns nty, mderf de a
e rl

l w, hetx le r m an o t pr ry.
a t a i ns e i n he ope t
Fi ly,i a
na l t ppea s t t c tt ta 1pa te a ee t t t pr ry atis r mai
r o he our ha l ri s gr ha he ope t
s ue e ns

s be tt tetx le sa d ta teUntdS ae d e n th v a itr s i t p o e d . n i
u jc o h a in n h t h i tts o s o a e n ne et n he r c e s I t
e
s
br e ,t U nie St t c nc des t ti no l r as e t a c a m t t pr e .D e .s Br i
i f he
t d a es o e
ha t
onge s r s l i o he oce ds f' . n

Res 1 Doc tNo.46.I t ad,t Urie St t sr afimsisco e i t ti hol a s ni r
p. , ke
nse he lt d a e e fr t nt nton ha t ds e o
s czed i e e ti t Pr mo pr pe y.I Si ia l t pl i if as e tt tt y ç r e wih
e lr nt r s n he e
o rt d. m l ry, he antfs s r ha he ç e t
ag

(heUnie Stt ' a yssa saet ts h rs ti f t rma t by t f iur oft
t
td aes) nal i nd tt ha uc e ul s urhe ndaed ' he al e he

She ift pr ry c
rf o ope l onduc a s l ofpr ry fe a c e ro le asm a t d by t Vigi a
t ae
ope t r e nd l a f i ns
nda e
he r ni

Co e 5 . - 0' Pl. Br i Op n 4 Do ke No.4 .The c u tt ee o e fnd t a b t
d 80148 . s' . n p' , c t
'
7
o r h rf r i s h t oh
Vigi a a f de a lw m a t t s me c l i nsbe r a d:t tt pr e fom t
r ni nd e r l a
nda e he a
oncuso
e che ha he oc eds r he
s l we e pr pe l diti e t t Pa ke s t t t Unied St t s has no i t r t i t
ae r o ry srbutd o he r r ; ha he
t
ae
n e es n he
pr e f o t s e;a t tt f r lt x le r m an on t Pr mo pr ry.The c t
oc eds r m he al nd ha he ede a a ins e i
he e
ope t
our
wilt r f e dim is Cot 1 asi s e a de a a i t tt Unie Stt s ha a i e e ti
l he e or s s
mt , t e ks
clr ton ha he t d a e s n nt r s n
s h pr e ds
uc oc e .
B. C o 1
unt 1

W hie syl d a a <nt p l de y Count1 s ks a s e a deca ai n t tt Unie
l t e s n t e ea r'
i
'
1 ee
e ks
lr to ha he t d
St t si e il t a pr e dsoft No mbe 30,201 She if ss l a a pr e fom
a e s ntted o ny oc e
he ve r
6 rf a e nd ny oce ds r

s bsq e t s ls o P e p o e t. Plitfs as s e t e j i t S rf fo a y
u e u n ae f r mo r p ry an if lo e k o no n he heif r m n
diti i of s h pr e whie t i t nt a ton i pe ng.A s a i ta ma tr t t
srbuton
uc oc eds
l he nsa c i s ndi
n niil te , o he
e e tCo 1 s kst s m e de l r ton s
xt n unt 1 ee he a
c a a i oughti Coun 1 a noti e pl a r t c thas
n
t , nd
nt r e de , he our
ar a a es e t m e isoft tcai .
le dy ddr s d he rt
ha l m
û he tue bil of i e pl a r hit rc l i a a ton i whih t pli if i a
T
f
l
nt r e de so ialy s n c i n
c he antf s
dii e e t d sa hol r who r que t t c tt dee m i whih of t o mor a r e
sntr se tke de
e ss he our o tr ne
c
wo r
e dve s
cai nt i rghtuly e il t t f o pr pe t pos e s by t pl i if' SeeM FA M ut
l ma s s i f l ntted o he und r o ry s s ed he antf .
'
.

I . . . s y 29 F. p 6 0 6 3( . Va 1 6 ) l e Rue2 o t Fe rl ls
ns Co v Lu b , 5 Su p. 6 , 6 W D. . 9 9 .i r l 2 f he dea Rue
und
of Ci lPr ed e a wel as t a l ous i e pl de pr so i t Code of Vigi a
vi oc ur , s l he na og
nt r ea r ovii ns n he
r ni ,

j8. - s h apes who ma be e e t muli ecamsby ohest t s mef nd
01364, uc
ron
y
xpos d o tpl li
t r o he n u

hed b i, y r q iet o e ohe p rist b j i d i a itr la e a to 'Nain Ba k
l y t ma e ur h s t r a t o e one n n n ep e d r cin. to s n .
e
'
N. v Ra e , .9 - 01 ,1 9 W L 71 8 3 a * ( . Va Oc.1 9 8 .F o t epan
A. . n y No 8 0 8 9 8
3 0 , t 4 W D. . t ,1 9 ) r m h li
ln u g o t Vigna sau e itr la e i a p o it whe ap ry h lsfnd s b e tt
a g a e f he r ii tt t, nep e d r s p rprae n a t od u s u j c o

c mpei cams Se Va Co e j8013 4 (t he e e a y p ro i o ma b e po e t
o tng li . e . d . - 6 l n v r n e s n s r y e x s d ù
W
muli ela lt t ough t e se e ofc am sby o he st t s mepr ry orfmd hed by
tpl ibiiy hr
he xitnc
li
t r o he n
ope t
t
l

hm o o h sbe af ....)(mp a i a d d .Fu te no e ç cama tn ti p se so o
i r n i hl
' e h ss d e ) ri n r , & li n o n o s sin r
'
a
co r ofpr ry c
ntol
ope t nnnotbrngt a ton a t f c t sa hol rt i e pl d.' nke s
i he c i nd hus or e he t ke de o nt r ea 'Bn r

TrltCo v. r.Na.Bn k,1 9 F. D.3 2 3 7 ( D. Y.1 91 ( u tng 3 J me Wm.
t . Mfs t n 3 R. 0 , 0 j. N. 9 ) q oi A a s
s
M o r e a.M o r ' Fe ea P a tc !2 .7( 9 ).
o e t l o es d rl r cie 20 1 91)
,
I t i t n c s ,t pli if hol no s h f ndsa t She ifha ar ady diti e
n he nsa t a e he antf s d
uc '
u
s he rf s le
srbut d
t m t t Pa ke s As s h,t pl ntf s c nnotf ce ot r t i t p l ad,es cily whe
he o he r r .
uc he ai if a
or
he s o n e e
pe a l
n
t r i no diput a t who ha arg t t pr ee . st c 'ha ar a dic s d,t r
he e s
s e so
s i ht o he oc ds A he oul s le dy s us e he e
t
i no diput ast t pr ee fom t s l ;t r i smpl a s ni f de a t x le a tc d t
s
s e o he oc ds r he a e he e s i y e or e r l a i n ta he o

t pr pe t Thus t c t i st tit r e ri i ppr
he o ry.
, he our beleve ha n e pl ade s na opdae i t i t ta ton.
t n he nsan c i

Plitfsas ak t c u to e j i S rf Br wn fo d srb t t ep o e d fo
an if lo s he o r t n on heif o r m itiui h r c e s r m
ng
t s l The Pa ke s ha pr s nt e denc t tt pr e ha ar a bee diti e
he ae.
r r ve e e ed vi e ha he oc eds ve le dy n srbutd.

S eAf. fC. a e l Pak r! 1 , c e No. - . plitfsha efie t p o u ea y
e f o W v ry r e 7 Do k t 41 1 The an if v ald o r d c n
e de e i r buta .Cons que l t coztac e sast et tt pr e ha ale be n
vi nc n e tl
e nty, he lr c pt
nl ha he oce ds ve r ady e

d srb td. e Fe . Ci . 5 ()2 . rf r ,ot e tn t a panif s e t e j i te
iti ue S e d R. v P. 6 e( ) Theeo e t he x e t h t litfs e k o no n h
occ r nc o pas e nt,t c tfnds t cli moot See e. ,Bur s v.But ,423 F.
ur e e f t ve s he our i
he am
. , g.
ce s
z

S p 2 , 9( D. . .1 7 )( tn t t h Co r c u dno f s in a ij n t n t c mpe
u p. 7 2 S. W Va 9 6 noig ha t e u t o l t ah o n nu ci o o l
o
c mpl nc wi c n u twhih ha ar a y o c re ) Ry La rExe s As ' v.Ch spe k
o i e t o d c c d le d c u rd ; . bo
a
h
c . sn
ea a e
W etr Ry. 91 F.d 1 6 1 9 ( t Ci.1 9 )(An a p a o t d nilo a ijmcin t
sen , 5 2 1 , 1 4h r 9 0 ç p e l f he e a f n nt to o
ç
l he
t l
pr bi a a ti rndee mootby t ha ni oft a t' .Consequenty,t cour w il
ohi t n c s e rd
he ppe ng he c.'
)
di m i sCount1 .
s s
1

11
1.

M o i t Se and R e and CountI I
t on o ver
m
I

ThePake sa k t c t o s ve a r m a Col 11 I t Q i na c
r r s he our t e r nd e nd mt 1. n he rgi l ompl i ,Co
ant unt

11s u h j d me ta ans t Plk r a d S eifBr wn f rte p s ig.Th Pakesa s r
1 o g t u g n g i t he e s n h rf o o rs a sn
e r r se t
t tt ec u t u dno h v j rs ito o e t i cam be a ei a e whpl u d rVigna
ha h o r wo l t a e u idcin v r hs li c us t ds s l n e r iiy
1w be we Vigi a ctze f ra n o tls t n $75, a ha no f c ua c
a t en r ni ii ns o n m un e s ha
000 nd s a t l onneci n t
to o

Co n s Ia d I.S e 28 U. C.j 1 3 (itn t e rq ie n s f r dv riy o ctz n hp
ut n 1 e
S.
3 2 lsig h e ur me t o ie st f iie s i

j ds ito 2 U. C.j1 41c ( )B) (ttng t a u n rmo lo a a to aiig u d r
u d cin; 8 S.
4 () 1( sai h t po e va f n cin rsn n e
f de a lw,t diti tco ts l s r9o t a ton a1 cai no wihi t orgi lor
e r l a he src ur ha l eve m he c i 1 l ms t t n he i na

s p e na j ds ito o t e d src c u t.Fu te mo e t Pak r a sr t a te c u t
u plme tl u dcin f h itit o r) rh r r, he r e s se t h t h o r
mus e au t wh t ri p se s s t e a ii t a j d c t Comt IIfo t tme o te
t v lae ehe t o s se h blt o du iae t 1 ' m he i f h
y
r
r m ova pe ii notafe t s e ntn e
e
l tton,
tr he ubs que m ndedco pl ntt tadde a f de alde e n .Se
m ai ha
d e r f nda t e

Caepla l .v.Le s 5 9 U. 61 7 ( 9 6 (ttn t a rmo a p ru n t 28 U. C.
tr i r nc
l
wi, 1 S. , 3 1 9 ) sai g h t e v l u s a t o
S.

j1 41a r q r sac s t t e ftf rf d rla j iain a te t t er mo a peiin i
4 () e uie a e o & i o e ea dudc to t h i h e v l tto s
b
me
f1d'.
ie '
)
Ha t eUntd Sae n t e ap ryt t i tn a to j1 41 g ve ngrmo a of
d h ie tts o be n a t o he nsa t cin, 4 , o mi e v l

acvi a to b s d o dvest o ctz n hp o fd r lq e t nj rs ito ,wo dha eb e
i l cin a e n i ri f iie s i r e ea u si u idcin ul v e n
y
o
t onl ba i upo whih a de e ntc d r m o t c e t f de a c t I t ti t nc i
he y ss n
c
f nda oul e ve he as o e r l our. n ha nsa e, t

i n tce rta t e c u' wo l h veha o iia j rs it n o ral o t e cams l l
s o la h t h o l u d a
t
d rgn l u idci ve r f h li , i y
o
y
ke
rn e ig t c s t i f rrmo a.Se 2 U. C.j1 41a ( r vdng f rr mo a o G n
e d rn he a e mft o e v l e 8 S.
4 () p o ii o e v l f ç y
a
c vi a ton br
i l ci
oughti a St t cou tofw hi h t dit i tc t oft Unie St t ha or gi l
n
ae r
c he s rc our s he
t d a es ve i na

j rs ito ).I t s c s ,h we r he Untd Sae ,a a p ry t te l iain r mo e
u id cin' n hi a e o ve,t
ie tts s a t o h i g to , e v d
t
ptrua tt j 1 a as ase tdt tr mova waspr rt rj1 Se ton 1
ls n o 444, nd lo s re ha e l
ope mde 442. ci 444

pr de t t a a ton a f tng pr pe t upo whih t Unie Stt has a le may be
ovi s ha ny c i feci
o ry
n
c he
t d a es
in
r m ovedt f r lc t s c i n 1 a l r m o whe a cvi aci n i br htagans t
e
o ede a our; e to 442 lows e val n i l to s oug
i t he

Untd Sae . 8U.. j1 4 ($ cvia to . .ha i c mme c di aSaec u'a dta
ie tts 2 SC. 4 2 ç i l cin . t t s o n e n tt o l n h t
A
t
i a ans o dr ce t Eh Untd Sae f ro r ltn t te c le to o rv n jma b
s g i t r ie td o t e ie tts o r eaig o h olcin f e e ue y e
rmo e b t e t t e Ee eaq d src c u t....) Th rf r ,t e c u tma e ecs
e v d y h m o h f d rl itit o r
' . e eo e h o r y x r ie
'

j rs ito pzs a t oj 1 4 a d 1 4 rt r h n j1 41
u id cin l u n t j 4 4 n 4 2 ahe t a 4 .
r
Thepur eofj1 i t pr deafde a f um frt Unie Stt a ofie sof
pos
442 s o ovi e r l or o he td aes nd fc r

t eUni dS ae . rf r ,h g a to fd r ll id cinu e j1 4 ,nc n rs t r mo a
h t tts Theeo e t e rn f e ea jz s ito nd r 4 2 i o ta t o e v l
e
r
ju s ito u d rj1 41 s ul b ra b o dy S eToly v M o a t Co.5 F. u p. d
ti dcin n e 4 , ho d e e d r a l . e l . nsn o , 91 S p 2
e
8 7 8 9 ( D. . . 0 8 (l e to )1 4 s o l b c n tu db o dy e o ht p o i ea
3 , 4 S. W Va 2 0 ) ç s cin 4 2 h u d e o sr e r a l n ug o r v d
ç
fd rlf r m f rf d rlosc r ml t l iain o f d rld fnss' ;Dt h m v Lo k e d
e ea o u o e ea f e s d he i g to f e ea ee e .) l n . c h e
t
' r

M a t Co . 4 5 F.d 1 4 ,1 5 (t Ci.2 0 )(Be a s i' s i ra tt t fd rl
ri p , 4 3 2 7 2 3 9h r 0 6 ç c u e ts o mpo tn o he e ea
n
ç
g v rme tt p o e tgt itr ss,r mo a rg t u e s ci n 1 4 a emuc b o d rta
o e n n o r tc is nee t) e v l ih s nd r e to 4 2 r
h ra e h n
t o e u d rs cin 1 41' . n e d E e to 1 4 ()1 a to ie r mo a o t e e tr c s
h s n e e to 4 .) I d e , ç cin 4 2 a( ) uh rz s e v l f h nie a e
'
s
e n i o y oneoft co r r i i r iesi ve a f r lofk e orage y. 1 C.W rg ,
ve f nl
he ntove ses t a s nvol s ede a f r
nc ' 4
'
i ht

A. ilr& E. o e , d r l a tc a dPr c d r : mo lfo S aeCo rsj3 2 (t
Ml
e
Co p r Fe e a Pr cie n o e u e Re va rm tt u t 7 6 4 h
Ed 2 7 .ç lf o cam c g ia l t e j1 4 i pr sn ,t e e tr a to i rmo d
. 01 ) G l ne li o nz b e md r 4 2 s e e t h nie cin s e ve ,
g
r r es oft r ltons p bewe n t Seci n 1 c am and t non-e ova e c am s'
ega dl s he ea i hi t e he to 442 l i
he
r m bl l i .
'

Na. d b n S . . p' o W ae & Po r 4 6F.S p . 9 ,5 9( D. l 1 0 .n sl
t Au u o oc v De t f tr
we, 9
u p 4 9 0 E. Ca . 98 ) I t
m,
j1 4 ce ts a ç p ce o sau o i ma d td s p lme tl s b e tmatr j rs ito '
4 2 rae l e is f ttt rl n ae u pe n a u j c- te u idcin.
s
y'
t he src
l
cs t
W rght& M ilr Fedea Pr tce a Pr ed e j3726.G-- ditit courtcan exer ie is
i
le , rl aci nd oc ur

ds rto t d ciej rs ito o e t s p e na cams. .'I .
ic ein o e ln u idcin v r he u plme tl li . . d
'

W h n fc d wi a mo in t rma d a c s rmo d pls a tt j1 4 te c u t
e ae t
h
to o e n
a e e ve t u n o 4 2, h o r
r
c n ie sp i ilso c miy f d rls j dca e o my a d f in s t lt a t.Se i=;
o sd r rncp e f o t , e eaim, u iil c no , n ar e s o ii ns e p.
g
s ealo Ba k o Ne Yor M el n TnltCo.v.Phi , 10- 271 2011W L 13
e s n f w
k lo
s
pns L- 1 ,
22393,a *
t3

( M d. r 1 2 1 (e n i gt ec s , l h wa p e iu l rmo d pls n t j 1 4
D. Ap . , 01 ) r ma d n h a e wli
c s r vo sy e ve t ua t o 4 4,
r
whe onl saelw camsa sae dee nsrmaned ou oft tntrssofc t ) I
n y tt-a li nd tt fnda t e i
t he ç ee t
i
omif'. n
t i t nt m a t r t U nied St t s c a m s an i e e ti a1 of Pr m o' pr r y a s e t
he ns a
te , he
t
ae li
nt r s n 1
e s ope t nd e ks o

f r c os on t ti e es.Cons que l i mus bede e ne wha pr ry be onge t Pr mo
o e l e ha nt r t
e nty, t t
t nni d
t ope t l d o e

a d rman s b e tt t fd r ltx le s Ths iq iy wila d e swh t e Prmo o t e
n e is u j c o he e e a a in . i n ur l d r s eh r e r h
M a owned t pantb00 h.The te pa sc am as i i t owne s p oft pai b00t
yos
he i
t
r s s l i lo mplcaes
rhi
he nt
h.

Se ,ec,S nc tr v Co n at 5 Va 1 4 1 9 3 ( 8 6 (t s e ifwh tke t e
e .. a se . mmo we l 8 . 2 , 2 - 0 1 6 ) $ h rf o a s h
h,
A
prpet ofA t ra atc n a ns t pr pet ofB,t r by...c
o ry
mde n ta hme t gai t he o ry
he e
ommisates s'
t r pas.).
At tls sage o t ltga i he c tbele s i woul be t ar t t ltga s
li t
f he ii ton,t our
ive t
d
mf i o he ii nt,

c rr t j1 spur e ofpr vi ng a f r lf m t t f rlgo nme ,a a
ontay o 442' pos
o di
edea onz o he edea ver nt nd n

ie ce tus o j iilrs u c st rma Comt11 l t e c t'wee t d s panif
n o in e f udca e o re o e nd t 1. f h out r o o o, litfs
woul be f c t smula ousy ltgae t s
d
or ed o i t ne l ii t he ame is i bot ve s:i sa eco twih t
sue n h nue n t t ur t he
te pa sng cai and i f de a co tbe us of t Unie St t s c os cai s e ng t
rs si l m
n e r l ur ca e
he
t d a e ' r s l m e ki o

fr co e o t e p o e t s b e tt t tx le s l wo d b t art s b e tt e t t
o e l s n h r p ry u j c o he a in . t ul e mf i o u j c h m o wo

j rs ito sa d t c u s so ds o ey o ti ie tc lis e Theeo e t t ee tn ta
u idcin n wo o re f ic v r n h s d n ia su . r f r, o h xe t h t
Co n lIrq ie ad tr n to o wh t rt ep itb0 t wa e rs b e tt atx le t e
u t 1 e u rs eemiain f ehe h an 0h s ve u j c o a in, h
c u t l rti t id cin.
o r wil eanjl s ito
r
N e rhe e s w he her V igila l w pr c udes t M a f o as e tng a pr s ntc a m
ve t l s ,
t
r ri a
el
he yos r m s r i
e e li

oftte,ate pas cli ,orbot a e is o sa elw .
il r s s am
h r s ues f t t a The c ur bele st tt pr rc zs
o t ive ha he ope olr e
ofa to i t srtr l on whehe t Unie St t hasa i e e ti t pant100 h a t
ci n s o s u e
t r he t d aes
ny ntr s n he i 7 t nd o

s e nty r s ve t f ecosze r g s as e td i t Unie St t s c os c am .Upon
ubs que l e ol he or l lr i ht s re n he
td ae ' r sli
r ol i oft Unie St e cai s t onl r m ani is wilbe t M a 'pr e
es uton
he
t d ats' l m , he y e i ng s ues l
he yos es nt
i e es i t pai b00 h a t M a 'sae-a tes salegai ns Att tpoi i tm e
nt r t n he nt t nd he yos tt l w r pas l to . ha
nt n i ,
upo a moton fom et rpa t t c twilf rhe e e ti t pos i lt of r ma Se
n
i '
r
ihe ry, he our l u t r nt ran he sbiiy
e nd. e
Ca trv.Ce .Re lW e tVigi a Ai or Aut ,No.2:5CV 1 55,201 W L 4005932,a *6
re
nt g' s r ni p t h.
1
31
6
t

( D. . . uy2 , 1 )(ûg h rqrmo a i p o rb t h fd r l fie i d s se , h
S. W Va J l 5 20 6 t ' e e e v l s rpe u t e e e a o fc r s imisd t e
tW

c u ti isd srto ma r ti j rs ito o e camsa an tt rmanigd fn a t. . .
o r,n t icein, y ean u idcin v r li g is he e i n e e d n s' .
Theei n g o r a o t k e (n oh r s no r mo a l cam)i f d rlc u t e a s a
r s o o d e s n o e p a t e wie n-e v b e li n e ea o r b c u e n
k

,
,

ofc roft Unle Stt ha aco tont i a a eale tme.) Howe ,f t ra ons
fie he td aes d nneci o t t n rir i .
ver or he e s
sa e t c t l de t i tntmoton.
tt d, he our wil ny he nsa
i
I .
V

M o i t V ac e
t on o
at

ThePa ke sr ues t tt co 'va t iso de gr ntng pl i if l a t a ndt i
r r eq t ha he ul ca e t r r a i
t
antfs e ve o me he r

c mplit Th Pak r agu t t a s n t a nd n ,h c t two d n th v j rs ito
o an . e r e s r e ha, b e t he me me t te ol ul o a e u idci n
r
o r Count 11 As d s us ed a
ve
1.
i c s bove,t c tdia e a be ive i m a pr pe l e r
he our s gr es nd le s t y o ry xe t

j idcin o rt e e t e c s .Mo e ve,u e Ru e 1 () o t e Fe ea Ruls o Cii
urs ito ve h ni a e r o r nd r l 5 a f h d rl e f v l
r
Pr c d r ,hec ur s o l çr ey gv la ewh nj tc s rq ie . I t Fo rh Cic i,a
o e u e t o t h u d ç e l ie e v e usie o e u rs' n he u t rut
f
'
d src c u t yd n la et a n o l whe s c la ewo l c u eu ueprj d c t t
itit o r ma e y e v o me d n y n u h e v ud a s nd eu ie o he
opposng pa t t r ha be n ba f ih on t pa tof t movi pa t or t a e
i
ry, he e s e d at
he r
he
ng ry, he m ndme
nt

wo l b f tl. wa d v. t o God bo o 1 8F.d 2 ,2 2 (t Ci.1 9 ) Th Pak r
u d e uie Ed r s Ciy f ls r , 7 3 31 4 4 h r 9 9 . e r e s
'
have m a no s h a gum e t tw oul ha pr ve e t c tf om gr ntng l ave t a e
de
uc r
nt ha
d ve e nt d he our r
a i e
o m nd.
A c r ngl t c ur w ilde t Pa ke s m oton t vac t .
co di y, he o t l ny he r r ' i o a e

Co l in
nc us o

Fo t e fr g ig ra o s t Pak r 'moin f rs mmayj d me twilb g a td
r h o e on e s n , he r e s to o u r u g n l e r ne ,
t Pa ke s'moton t s ve a r m a wilbe de e a t Pa ke s m o i t vac t wil
he r r
i o e r nd e nd l
nid, nd he r r ' ton o a e l
be de e The She ifs moton t dim is wil be gr nt d.The r m ani is a e wha
nid.
rf
i o s s l
a e
e i ng s ues r
t
i e e t i a t Unie St t has i t pantb00t a t Unie St es cli s e ng
nt r s, f ny, he t d aes
n he i
h, nd he t d at ' a ms e ki
f e l lr on t f r ltx le .The Clr i die t d t s nd c es oft s memor ndlm
or c osze
he ede a a i ns
e k s r c e o e opi
hi
a l
o ni n a t ac ompa ng or rt a1c
pi o nd he c
nyi
de o l ouns lofr co d.
e
e r

DAT D: i J- dyo Api 2 1 .
E Ths 1 a f r, 0 7
l
Chif nied St t sDiti tJ
e
t
a e src udge

13