ME2 Productions, Inc. v. Does 1-11
Filing
46
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 1/29/18. (jcj)
CLERK' OFFI U. DI COURT
S
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE.
VA
FI
LED
J 28 2 1
AN
28
I THE UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI NI
CT
RGI A
CHAM OTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON
JUm C. UDL ,CL
E
a:
v
DEPU
tt
l
LERK
M E2 PROD U CTI S,l C.
ON N ,
Pl ntf,
ai if
Ci lAci n No.3: 7CVO0002
vi to
1
,
M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NI
M OHAM/D AHMED,lg
g k,
.
By:Hon.Gln E.Co a
e
nr d
Se orUnie St t sDititJ
ni
t d a e src udge
Dee ns
f nda t .
l t i c p rg tifi g me ta to plitf M E2 P o ucins I c ($ E2' mo e f r
n hs o y ih n rn e n cin, anif
r d to ,n . d ' v s o
M )
d futj d me ta an td fn a t M o me Ah d M aio Ama a Da d J n a Ro i
e a l u g n g i s e e d n s ha d me , rs l y , u a , nd bn
S t, u s a toRu e5 ()o teFe ea Rue o Cii Pr c d r . Fo t era o sae ,h
ml p ru n t l 5b f h d r l ls f v l o e u e r h e s ns ttd t e
z
m o i wilbegr nt
tons l
a ed.
B ackzround
l rv e n mo in f rd fut u g n ,hec u t c e t teplitf wel e d d
n e iwig to s o ea lj d me t t o r a c ps h anifs l- a e
pl
alg to a t la iiya t e Ry nv. me o ng Fi Newo k, 3F.d7 , 8 ( t
l ains s o ib l s nz. a Ho c mi s n. t r 25 3 78 7 0 4h
e
t
Ci. 0 )
r 2 01 .
M E2,aN e daco o ai t thol t co i tt t El dM e ha c: s r ton,'
va
p r ton ha ds he pyrgh o he m t c ni Re urec i '
alege t tt de e nt vi a e isc i htbyusng BiTore t c a diti et
l s ha he f nda s ol t d t opyrg
i
t r nt o opy nd srbut he
fl Am. mp . ! 1 - 3 2 2 Do k t 1 Biror n alwsa iiil iep o ie So
im.
Co l! 2 1 , 2-4, c e No. 2. t-re t lo n ùta fl r vd r d
l
t
s aeatl wihat re t ewok. I !1 . Th u eswh j i t n t r c nt ndsrb t
h r se t o rn n t r ' d. 8 e s r o o n he ewo k a he itiu e
'
a e iefl by e c downl di adif r ntbi ofda a. I Pl i ifi e ii d t de e nt
n ntr ie
ah
oa ng fe e t
t d. antf d ntfe he f nda s
t o ht I a e s susdwhe i rngi aci t occ rd. Ja!2
hr ug he P ddrs e e
n nfi ng tviy ure l 2.
-
On J 30, 7, ai iffld a a nde c
une 201 pl ntf ie n me d ompl i agans t def nda sf wiluly
ant i t he e nt or lf l
v oai gt Co y ih Ac,1 U. . j 1 . s q AAe p o ry sr igt ed fn nsa d
i ltn he p rg t t 7 SC. 01ç e .
1
r rpel e vn h ee da t n
not.e evi a r pons pli ifm ove f e r ofde a ta i tAhmed,Am a J n,a
r c i ng es e, a ntf
d or nty
f ul ga ns
ya, a nd
S ut . Pu s a t oRue5 ()o t eFe e a Ru e o Cii Pr c dze t Clr e trd d fut
t lz ru n t l 5 a f h d r l ls f v l o e l ,he ek n ee ea l
r
a ans e c o to ed fn a t. Plitf h s w mo e f rd fut u g n a ans te a d
g i t a h f h s ee d ns anif a no v d o ea lj d me t g i th m, n
t m a tri rpef rdiposton.
he te s i o s ii
St
andar ofR e e
d
vi w
Rul 55 of t Fe r l Rul of Ci l Pr e e e t bls s a t s e pr es f r
e
he de a
es
vi oc dur sa ihe
wo-tp oc s o
o ti n ad fulj d me t J fes nv. iee n .461F. u p. d4 0 4 3( D. . 0 )
banig ea tu g n . efro Brn r I c,
S p 2 3 , 3 E. Va 20 6 .
y
Frt Sh g lr mu te trt ja t sd fut' Fe R.Ci. 5 a . Second,a part m ay
is,% e cjek s ne he ry' ea l- d.
t
'
v P. 5()
mo et c u t o d fut u g n u d rRu e5 ()
v he o r f r e a lj d me t n e l 5 b .
I r ve ng a moi n f r d futj d me t t c u tv e alwelp e d d fc l
n e iwi
to o ea l u g n , he o r iws l l- la e a ma
alg to si t ec mp an a tu f rp r s so la iiy S e Fe .R. v.P.8b ()(An
l ai n n h o lit s r e o u po e f ib l . e d Ci
e
t
()6 ç
ç
al gai --ot r t n one r l tng t t amount of dn ges i admit i a r ponsve
le ton he ha
e ai o he
ma - s
ted f es i
pla i g i r q ie a d te alg to i n td n e . s e as Ry n 25 F.d a 78 ( e
e d n s e urd n h le ain s o e id' e lo a , 3 3 t 0 ç
);
Th
d fn a tb hi d ful, d t t eplitf s l- la e alg to o f c.)(n en l i to
ee d n , y s ea ta mis h anif welp e d d le ains f a t' itr a ct in
'
a
o te l. Co e ue ty i t d fulj d me tc n e tûh a pr p it iq iyi wh t e o
mitd ) ns q nl, n he ea t u g n o tx,i e p o rae n ur s eh r r
t
n tt f c o t epla ig s p o t te d f ut u g nta d te c u e o a to teen'
o he a e f h e dn s u p rs h ea lj d me n h a s s f cin h r i.
'
An es nv. u .o Ad a e n . uc & Emp'o Am.n ins 1 7F.d6 ( t Ci. .
d ro Fo nd f r v nc me tEd .
t f I da , 8 3 28 4h r Aug
1 1 )(mpubls dtbl opi on)
0, 999 t
ihe a e ni .
I t f c salege i t c
f he a t l d n he ompli e tbls la lt t n t co tmus de e net
ant sa ih ibiiy, he he ur
t t nni he
a opra e n oun of dn ag . Ryan, 253 F. a 78 81. The c t may m a a
ppr it m t
m es
3d t 0our
ke
de e mi to a t t n
t r nai n s o he mountof dn
mage wiho a hea i i t r co d c ans s ce
s t ut
rng f he e r ont i uo int
e de t s
vi nce o uppor t awa d. Ande s n v. und.f rAdva e e .Educ.& Empl m e of
t he r
r o Fo
o
nc m nt
oy nt
Am.n in , 5 F.d5 0 5 7( t Ci. 9 8 ( o igt tt s mecru tn e adsrc c u t
Id a s 1 5 3 0 , 0 4h r 1 9 ) n tn ha çn o ic msa c s itit o r
i
e trn ad fulj d me t ya r d ma e a c ran befo t ep e dng wi o t o dù
n eig ea tu g n ma wa d n g s se ti a l r m h la i s t u h l ig
h
ah aif'; itr & Al e Tr d sl d s Pe inFt v Ca tl so ain & Pan icCo.
e rn l Pan es
l d a e n u . nso md . pi Re tr to
i
a
itn
,
91 F. u p. d 6 0 68 ( M d 2 3 (i dngta t ec u t e dn tc nd c a e i e t r
9 S p 2 8 , 4 D. . 01 ) fn i h t h o r n e o o u t n v d ni y
a
hea i t de e m i da a sa E a r l i t a on a fda t ordoc e a y e denc i t
rng o t r ne m ge nd G y ey nse d
m
fi vis
um ntr vi e n he
r c r t d tr n tea p o raesmf
e o d o eemie h p r p it t l.
D i si
scus on
To etbih c py ih ifig me t S wo ee n smu tb prve ()o e s i o a
sa ls o rg t n rn e n ,l lme t s e o n: 1 wn rhp f
t
v l c p rg t a d ( )c p ig o c nsi n ee n so t wo k t a a e o iia . Fes
ai o y ih , n 2 o yn f o tme t lme t f he r h t r rgn l' it
d
'
P bln sI c v.Ru a Te.S r .Co,4 9 U. 3 ,3 ( 9 ) Fo p r s s o a d fut
u 's n .
r l l e v . 9 S. 40 61 1 91 . r upo e f ea l
j d me tt ec u t eive ta plitf ha e tbih db t ee n s Plitf h salg dta
u g n,h o r b le s h t an if s sa ls e oh lme t. anif a le e h t
i owne avald co i ,a t tt c i ht d m ae i lwasco ed a diti e fo t
t
d
i pyrght nd ha he opyrg e
t ra
pi nd srbut d r m he
d fnd ns I a d e s su i BiTor n . Am. mp . !1 - 2, 8 2 Ex A,
ee a t' P d rs e sng t re t
Co l! 1 1 1 , 2, . B.
Ac or ngy,t c twilnow t n t t a oprae r i i t s c e Pli if
c di l he our l
ur o he ppr it elef n hi as . anif
rq e t a ijmci n p o btn frh rifi e n o d e h ni:Reu r cin' sauo y
e u ss n n t to r hiiig u te n rng me t f s c a c s re to , ttt r
M
'
dn
mage i t amountof$6, pe de e n ,a cossa a t e sf es
s n he
000 r f nda t nd t nd tom y' e .
1 I j tv Reif
. n uncie le
Th Co rg tAc p o i e ta çan c u t a i j rs ito o acvla to aii g
e py ih t r v d s h t ç l y o r h vng u idcin f ii cin rsn
g
t e ti tte ma . . r n tmp r r a d fn lij n to o s c tr a i ma d e
md r h s i
l y . g a t e o ay n a n u cins n u h e ms s t y e m
r a o a l t p e e to rsr i ifi e n o ac p rg t' 1 U. C.j5 2 a . Ijmcie
e s n b e o r v n r e tan n rng me t f o y ih ' 7 S.
0 () n t tv
r le i a opraewhe t nalr oft i rnge ntpr ve sa a qua er m e a lw,a a
ei f s ppr i t
n he tze he nfi me
e nt n de t e dy t a nd
pe a n ijmcin i e p cal a p o raewhe at ra o c n iuig ifi g me te it.
nn ne t nt to s s e ily p r p it
n h e t f o tn n n rn e n x ss
3
S eM . E.Muscv Ki e Ic,1 9 F.S p 2 4 9 4 3 7 ( D. . . 0 )(vaiu
e L.
i . mbl. n . 0
u p. d 6 , 7 - 4 S. W Va 20 0 ç ro s
l
diti tc t wihi t sc r ui ha he d t twhe a c am ofco i i rnge nthasbe n
src outs t n hi ic t ve l ha
n li
pyrght nfi me
e
p o e ,a pema n ij n to p o i t frh rifig me t i a prprae a r u iey
rv n
r ne t nu cin r hbing u te n rn e ns s p o it nd o tn l
i
e trd.) Hee plitf ha p o e acam o c py ih i fi g me ta t erc r lc sa y
n ee ' . r, anif s r v n li f o rg t nrn e n , nd h e o d a k n
'
i c ton t t de e nt wila t i fom f ur i rnge e s Cons que l t co t
ndi ai hat he f nda s l bsan r ut e nfi m nt .
e nty, he ur
fn st a apema n ij n to i a p o dae
d h t r ne tn u cin s p r p t .
I . St t or D am age
I a ut y
s
Th Co y i h Ac as S u h rz gqsau o yd ma e t c mp nst c p rg th l es
e p rg t t lo s t o ies ttt r a g s o o e ae o y ih o d r
a
f rdifc tt pr do te m l s sa t de e f ur i rnge nt' M E2 Pr . l .v.
o f ul-o- ove wnsr n os e nd o t r m e nfi me .
'
ods. nc
P r s CI L NO.1 - 0 7 SOM/
mnya , VI
70 0 8
RLP,2 7 W L 4 70 5 a 1 ( Ha Oc.1 , 7 .
01
70 1 , t 3 D. w. t 9 201 )
Thea ountofsa u or da a a r d f a onewor m a no be ( e st n $750 o mor
m
t t t y m ges wa de or ny
k y t s s ha
l
r e
t a $ 00 0 a t ec u tc n ie sj t' 1 U. C.55 4() 1. W i i t a rn e te c u t
h n 3 ,0 s h o r o sd r us ' 7 S.
0 c () t n h t a g , h o r
h
ej y wieds rto t s th n u t fd ma e . Se F. . o l rh Co v. n e o a y
no s d ic ei n o e te mo n o n g s e W W owo t . Co tmp rr
ArsI .3 4U. 2 , 1 3 ( 9 2 . I e riigt i ds rto , d src c u t o sd r t e
t.nc, 4 S. 28 23 -2 1 5 ) n xecsn hs ic ei n a itit o r c n ie s h
f lo n t ref cos ç 1 t ee p ns ss v da p o sra e by d fn a t i c r cin
o lwig h e a tr :$ ) h x e e a e nd r st e p d
(
ee d ns n ome to
wiht ifi e nt;( )rve u sl s b tepanif; nd( )wh te teifi e n wa
t he n rng me s 2 e n e o t y h litfs a 3 eh r h n rng me t s
wigju a dk wi o wh t e iwa a cd n a o in c n . J s rlaM u i Co. CA.n .
llf l n no ng r eh r t s c ie tl r n o e t' apeil sc .M
'
Ic
v. ic sLo n eAsoc, 3 F. u p.1 9 1 ( D. . .1 9 ) S g fc nl i ap an if
W n ' u c s .8 7 S p 5 , 61 S. W Va 9 3 . iniia t f litf
y,
pr s t t t i rnge e was wilu ,t cour ma a r up t $1 000. 1 U. C.
ove ha he nfi m nt
lf l he
t y wa d
o .
50,
7 S.
j504()2)
c( .
He e t a e
r , he m nded c
ompli co ans no al ga i t tt de e nt s c s f l
ant nt i
le tons ha he f nda s uc e s uly
downl ded t e ie fl or t t t y r a d a s cfc pr s i c
oa
he ntr m
ha he e pe ny pe ii oft n onne ton wih t i
ci
t her
i rnge nt Nordoe t pl i ifpr dea e de east t a m a l s s t i by t
nf i me .
s he antf ovi ny vi nq
o he c l os es usaned he
4
pli tf . Alhought pl i ifal ge t tt de enda sa t d wilul t c t le st t
a n if
t
he antf le s ha he f nt c e lf ly, he our bei ve ha
a a r of$750pe def nda i s fce t c
n wa d
r e nt s ufi int o ompens t t pli ifand dee f tlec i
a e he antf
t r u t opyrght
r
i rnge e .
nfi m nt
Thi a r i c it ntwih a ç e n te i c t ac os t c mty ...t a r t
s wa d s onsse
t l ce t r nd n ours r s he ot r
r
o wa d he
m i m um sa tor a r of$750. pe vi a i 'i i rnge e ca esbr tby ç py i t
ni
ttz y wa d
t
00 r olton' n nfi m nt s ough
t rgh
co
ho de swhos e co i i rnge e da
l r
e k pyrght nfi m nt mage nott bemadewhol butr t ra aprma yor
s
o
e, ahe s i z
sc n ayrve u sra al g o fl ma slws isa ans a o y u Do d fn a t wih
e o d r e n e te m l wh j ie s a ut g i t n n mo s e ee d n s t
d
t hopesofc r i s tlm e s' M albu M e a LLC v.g da t dl Ca eNo.PW G- 4- ,
he
oe cng e te nt .'
i
di.
Re c e , s
1 261
20 7 W L 6 3 1 , t* ( M d Fe 1 , 01 )( olci gc s sl tn tea r t $ 0pe
1
3 3 5 a 3 D. . b. 5 2 7 c le tn a e i ig h wad o 75 r
mi
v oain (n en lq o ainmak o te l s eas .eg.I P od .
i lto ) itr a u tto r s mitd ; e lo . , . r s LLC v. be, s No
T.
Hu r Ca e .
2:6 c - 1 9 2 7W L 5 7 43 , t! ( D. i No .1 2 7 (wa dn $ 5 p rv oain .
1 -v 1 9 , 01
3 9 7 a 2 S. Oho v 4, 01 ) a r ig 7 0 e i lto )
M E2hass dove aht e Doe ac os t c r f c i hti rnge e ,ncudi f is
ue
r mdr d
s r s he ounty or opyrg nfi m nt i l ng or t
c p rg tt d c a i:Re u r cin. S ePu rs 2 7 WL 41 7 5 a * l t i c s ,
o y ih o s h nc s re to ' e maa , 01
Me
'
0 01 , t 2. n h s a e
M E2 orgi ly s d Doe 1 11 be or nnmi t de e nt a flng t s me f r uli
i nal ue
s f e
ng he f nda s nd ii he n
om ac
d f ut u g n moin a an ttefu d f utn d fnd n sl Ad i o al , E2ha fld a
ea lj d me t to g is h o r e a lig e e a t. dt n ly M
i
s ie
ne ry i ntc l ws t i t s ditit i Cas N o.5:6- 0008 Ac or ngl t c t
a l de i al a ui n hi src n
e
1 CV3. c di y, he our
be ives t t a a r of t saut y mi mum wiho i e es f ea h of t def uli
le
ha n wa d
he t t or ni
t ut nt r t or c
he a tng
de e nt i a uae.
f nda s s deq t
.
I l A t or y' Fe s and Cos s
l . t ne s e
t
Ne t pl ntf r ue t $665 i c t a $2, i a t ne sf esfom e c oft
xt he ai if eq ss
n oss nd 520 n tor y' e r a h he
de e
f ndant. J ns n Af . Doc t Nos 39- 41 1 43- 45- I any a ton f c i ht
s e e
f,
ke
. 1, - , 1, 1. n
ci or opyrg
i rnge nt Q hec t nisdi c ei n ma a l t r co r off 1c t'a ç y a s a r
nfi me ,ç our i t s r to
t
y low he e ve y u1 oss' nd t
ma lo wa d
'Themoto e r f t t wr movi ,S
ins ven eer o he ong
e tondonHa Fale ' Howe r Exhi tB at he t t
s ln.
'
ve, bi tac d o he
a nd dc mplitc nimsta tefl s be toteigign a tvt i ti cs i ç c nc Reur cin.
me e o an o fr h th im u j c t h n n ig cii n hs ae s t ha i: sre t '
y
Me
o '
a r a o a l a tr e ' f e t t e p e al p ry a p r o t e c ss' 1 U. C.j5 5
e s n be to n y s e o h rv ing a t s a t f h o t. 7 S.
i
'
0.
Alhoughaditi tc trti Gbr d le y'i a yi j505,i ç y nota r at ne s
t
slc our eans l oa e wa ' n ppl ng
tç
ma
wad tor y'
f e as a mat r of c s r t r a c ur mus make a mor pa tc a i d, c e- c s
es
te
our e; ahe , o t
t
e ri ul rze as by- a e
a s sme t' Kita ngv. o nW i y & So s I . 1 6S. .1 7 ,1 8 ( 01 )(le ains&
se s n . rs e
'
Jh l
e
n .nc, 3 Ct 9 9 9 5 2 6 atrto
itr a q oainmak o te ) Toa ss dsrc c u t wi e e csn t erds rto u d r
nen l u tto r s mitd .
sit itit o rs t x r iig h i icein n e
h
j505,t Suprme Co toft Unie Stt ha dieced dititc t t co i rç e rl
he
e
ur he td aes s r t src ours o nsde ç vea
s
n n xcu iefco s'i cu i gS rv lu n s , tv to ,o j cieu r a o a lne s a dt e
o e lsv a t r, n ld n t ioo s e s mo iain b e tv n e s n be s , n h
'
f
nee i pa tc arcr m sa e t a nc co i r tonsofc
d n ri ul icu tnc s o dva e nsde ai
ompe u i a de e r nc ' 1
ns ton nd t re e. d.
'
(le ain & i tr l u tto makso te ) Uli tl i a r igatr e sf e ,so ls
atr t s nena q oain r mitd . tmaey,n wa dn to n y' e s l u'
o
c t
mus viw alt cr um sa e o a c s o t i o t r ,i lg o t CopyrghtAc '
t e l he ic t nc s f a e n her wn e ms n i ht f he
i
ts
es e ilgoal. 1 a 1989.
s nta
s' d. t
'
Hee te d fn a t d dno a v n ea y d fns sf rte c u tt j g f rfioiy o
r, h ee d n s i t d a c n ee e o h o r o ud e o rv l r
t
r as nablne s Howe r o he c t ha r ognied t t c es lke t s one t e t n t
e o e s.
ve , t r ours ve ec z ha as i hi
hr a e o
S raejrs lsic nsse t t t eg aso te( p dg t Ac 'b e o rg n c mp nis o
t e t g e ut n o itn wi h o l f h Co y h q t' y nc u a i g o a e t
c
h
i i i t de e nt wih l ws t f rl r sa ut y dn ag a a s t nta a t ne s f e
ntm da e f nda s t a uis o a ge tt or m es nd ubsa il tor y' e
a z a t r by c eae a une lba gani pr es Pum a as 2017 W L 470701 a + 5
wa d nd he e r t n
qua r i ng oc s.
' ,
r
5, t
(iig Co blrNe a a LLC v.An n mo Usr o Po o n Ti :Do s 1 1 ,Ca e No
ctn b e v d .
o y us es f pc r me e - 1 s .
3:5 c - 5 0 SB,2 6 W L 4 38 3 ,a * ( Or Au 1 ,2 6 )(n e a q oain maks
1 - v 01 5 - 01
2 6 9 t 4 D. . g. 0 01 ) itnzl u tto r
omitd .
te )
t
o t r ne
st t t e prncpl s i r nd,t c r t ns t t l t r m ehod t dee m i a
vih hes i i e n ni he ou t ur o he odesa
r a ona e at r sf . Unde t sme hod,t c tmuli i t numbe ofhour t tt
e s bl to ney' ee
r hi t
he our
tples he
r
s ha he
a t ne r a ona y expe d on t ltgai n by a r as bl houry r t M c e v.Boc r
tor y e s bl
nde
he ii to
e ona e
l a e.
Af e
za ,
7 8F.d81 8 (t Ci. 01 ) Plitf' c u s lcamsta h s e t84h u so e c o t e
3 3 , 8 4h r 2 3 . anifs o n e li h t e p n . o r n a h f h
, e ks n to ne s
f l de enda s c esa t thi c t m a y r t i $300pe hour Thus he s e a a tr y'
otr f nt' as nd ha s uso r a e s
r
.
f a r o $2, pe de e nt I de e ni t r as blne sofc ms lsr quese f
ee wa d f 520 r f nda . n t nni ng he e ona e s
ot e ' e t d ee,
t Fourh Cic thasdie t d diti tco t t c i rt f l ngt l f c or :
he
t r ui
r c e src urs o onsde he olowi weve a t s
()Th tme a d lb re pe d d;( )teno et a d dfi ut o t eq e to s
1 e i n a o x n e 2 h v ly n itc ly f h u sin
rie ; 3 t es il e ur dt p o rypef r t lg l e vc srn e e ()t
as d ( ) h k lr q ie o r pel ro m he e a sr ie e d rd;4 he
atr e so p r t c ssi p e sn teisa tl iain;5 t c so r fe
ton y' p o t y o t n r sig h n tn i g to () he u t may e
uni
t
f rl ewok;()t eatl y' e pe tto a t eo te o t ltg to ()t e
o i
k r 6 h tome s x cains t h u s t f he i ain; 7 h
i
tme l tto s i o e b t e cin o cr l tn e ;( ) te n u t i
i i ain mp s d y h le t r icl a c s 8 h mo n n
mi
ms
c nr v ry a dt r s t o tie ;()tee p re c , e u ain a da lt o
o to es n he eul b an d 9 h x ein e rp tto , n bii f
s
y
t e atr e ( 0 t e u e ia ii o t c s wihn t e lg lc mmunt i
h to n y; 1 ) h nd srblt f he a e t i h e a o
y
i n
y
wh c t e s i ao e ( 1 te n t r a d ln h o t pr fsina rlto hp
ih h ut r s ; 1 ) h au e n e gt f he o e so l eains i
bewe na tr e a dcin ; n ( 2 atr e ' e sa r si smia c s s
t e to n y n le t a d 1 ) to n ys fe wa d n i lr a e .
l a 8 n. ( tr a q o ain makso te ) Un e te trtt e fco s te c u ti n t
d. t 8 5 i en l u tto r mitd . d r h ss hre a t r, h o r s o
n
c nc t t 8. hour ofwor pe def nda i r a o bl Cot elus d s t n i ly t
onvi ed ha 4
s
k r e nt s e s na e.
ms
e ubsa tal he
s m ei ta c
n nii l ompl i i t sca easheha ar a fld i a t rc s pe ng i t sditit
ant n hi s
d le dy ie n no he a e ndi n hi src ,
a dh fldt esmefr li d fut u g n moina ans e c o t f t d f n a t. Th
n e ie h a omuac ea lj d me t to g i t a h fhe ol e e d n s e
r
ei h f t alo c ms l a ns a awa d of$2, pe de e ntbe a e s h a a r i
ght acor s ot e s gai t n r
520 r f nda
c us uc n wa d s
e e svewhe c
xc s i
n ompa edt t saut r da ag awa d of$750pe i rnge e .
r o he t t o y m es r
r nfi m nt
Ot rc rsha r ogni d a e es i ar ques f r$ 100 i a t e sf esbas d on
he ou t ve ec ze s xc sve e t o 2, n tonz y' e
e
a r t of$350 pe ho . Plma a ,201 W L 470701 a 16 7. The Co tnle t ta t a of
ae
r ur l r s
7
5, t ur ld ha ot l
$ 5 i a tr e s fe wa r a o be b c u et ta u tç o e aed M E2 f rte fe
2 0 n t n y' e s s e s na l e a s ha mo n s mp ns tgq
o
c
o h es
r as
e onabl e ndedi acoo e c trc ei whi hm ud ofisa t ne swor c dha be n
y xpe
n
ki- ute as n c
h t tor y'
k oul ve e
ac ompls d by apa algal' I a *6. I a t rc s ,t DititCour r e t t9. ho s
c
ihe
r e .' d. t
n no he a e he src
t uld ha 1 ur
wa r a ona ewhe eapa aega c
s e s bl
r
z l l ompl td 7. hour oft wor atar e o $85pe hour See
ee 2
s he k
at f
r .
M ai M e a.LLC v.Reda t Ci lAcin No.DKC 1 0 201 W L 3668034,a *5(
lbu di
ced, vi to
5- 750, 6
t D.
M d.J y 11 2016 .
ul , )
7
Ba e on t f e ng,t c rtbeleve t tt hour pe de e nti a r as bl
sd
he or goi he ou
i s ha wo
s r f nda s e ona e
numbe ofhou sf ran a t ne t e nd on e c de e nti t sc s a t tt a t ne s
r
r o
tor y o xpe
a h f nda n hi a e nd ha he tor y'
hotry r t of$300 i a r as bl r t f a t ne i t sar a. Ac r ngl t c twil
ll ae
s e ona e ae or tor ys n hi e
co di y, he our l
e r ie isbr d dic e i t a r $600 i à t ne sf spe de e nt
xe c s t oa s r ton o wa d
n tor y' ee r f nda .
As t coss pli ifr quess t f l ng a ount fom e h de a tng de e ant a
o t, antf e t he olowi m
sr
ac f uli
f nd :
c tflng f of$400;s
our ii ee
ubpoe r s ns co t pa d t Com c s t i ntf e c de e ntof
na e po e ss i o
a t o de iy a h f nda
$90;apr es s r i ef f s r ceon Co c to $ apr es s vi f ef s r i ea h of
oc s e v c ee or e vi
m as f 25; oc s er ce e or e vng c
t de e nt of$1 a a f e t verf t m iia y sa usofea h oft de e nt of$50.
he f nda s
00; nd e o iy he ltr tt
c
he f nda s
Alho h pl i ifsco els e t di de a
t ug antf
uns e ks o vi mongs t f de a tng de e n st orgna
t he our f uli
f nda t he i i l
$1 f e f r s r c o Comc t he di notr s t di de t one tm e $400 slng f e i a
00 e o e vie n
as,
d
eque t o vi he -i
i e n
sm ia f hi n. Theco tbei ve t tdi di t tflngf bewe n t de a tngdef nda s
i lr as o
ur le s ha vi ng ha ii ee t e he f uli
e nt
i r as bl,a t r o e e h oft f urde a tng def nda swilbe la e f o y $1 of
s e ona e nd he ef r , ac
he o
f uli
e nt l i bl or nl 00
t c ur flng f . The co tde lne t a r t r m >ni c t r ue t d. A c r ngl ,
he o t i ee
ur c i s o wa d he e i ng oss eq se 2
co di y
t c t l a r cossa i tea h de e nti t n
he our wil wa d t gans c f nda n he mountof$1
00.
Fial,h p an ifh sas fldmoin t dimiswihp eudc tea to a ans t e
n ly te litf a lo e t s o s s t rj ie h cin g i t h
o
r m ani de e n s Br de Br nna
e i ng f nda t a n e n,Pa a Chrsi n,a Yas M e na For good c us
ul
ita nd
er di .
a e
s
hown,t c 'wilgr ntt em o i .
he oul l a hos
t
tons
Concuson
l i
Fo t ra o ssae ,h c u t l g a t litY smoi n f rd fut u g n a an t
r he e s n ttd t e o r wil r n p an i
to s o e a lj d me t g is
Alm e Am a J n,a Sm lz. J
z d,
ya, a nd
t udgme wilbe e e e i f vorofpl ntf agans ea h of
nt l
nt r d n a
ai if i t c
2Al u h crui c ut dsg e o e wheh rj5 5 i b o d rta 28 U. C.j1 2 ,te c u twi
t g ic t o rs ia re v r te 0 s r a e h n
ho
S.
9 0 h or l
l
e ecs i dsrto t l tc ssi ti matrt to erc v rbeu de j1 20 Se Hu ry & P rn r
x r ie t icein o i o t n hs te o h s e o ea l n r 9 . e mphe s a tes
s
mi
Arhtcs L. v. sadDeim Ic,1 2F. u p. d5 3, 25( D. . 5 tuigt th c ssrc v rbl
c i t. P. Lesr sa n , 5 S p 3 0 5 E. Va 201 ) l l ha te ot eo ea e
e
-n
u d rj5 5ael tdt tec ssrc v rbeu d r51 2 ) Th c u t o sn t e o nz a rc v rbl sr ie
n e 0 r i e o h ot e o ea l n e 9 0 . e o r d e o r c g ie s e o ea e evc
mi
fe p i t ap iaep o essre. S eMa ev Mah a, 5:9 01 0 2 1 WL 3 8 7 3 a * ( D. .
e s ad o rv t r c s ev r e vs . tv s No. 0 CV0 0 , 0 0
7 3 0 , t 4 W. Va
Se t28 201)
p. , 0.
8
t ef de e t i t a ountof$1450,r pr s ntng$750i sa or d
hos our f ndan s n he m
,
e ee i
n t mt y nmage a $700i
s nd
n
atr y sfe a d c ss Th s d fn a t wilas e c bepema nl e j i e fo a y
tone ' e s n o t. o e ee d n s l lo a h
r ne ty n on d r m n
f rhe i rnge e . Fi l t c t l g a pl ntf smotonst d s ist a tonagans
u t r nfi m nt naly, he our wil r nt ai if
i o im s he ci
i t
Br r n,Cl si n,a M edi
ema ui ta nd
na.
The Clr i dieced t s nd ce tfe c e of t s m e a
ek s r t o e
rii d opi s
hi
mor ndum opi on a t
ni nd he
ac
c ompa ng o de t Ahme Am a J n,St t Br r n, ita M edi ,a t a1 c
nyi r r o
d,
ya, a ulz, ema Chrsi n,
na nd o l ouns l
e
ofr or
ec d.
DATED: i'
Ths
d yo Jn ay 2 8
a f a ur , 01 .
/
Se orUnie Stt sDit tJ
ni
t d a e sdc udge
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?