Mya Saray, LLC v. Dabes

Filing 36

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Senior Judge Glen E. Conrad on 3/5/18. (hnw)

ct arsoy l ts DlTcousr
E
FcE$ s .
A R A dx ,A
T o N iv
FI ED
L

I THE UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTEM DI
STRI O F V I GI I
CT
R NA
CH AM OTTESV I
LLE D I I ON
V SI

MAq 25 2 1
22
J L c. DL M CL
u .é DU E
1
ERK

B :H E C E K
Y D. LSm
P
R

M Y A SA M Y ,LLC ,
Pl i if
a ntf ,

Ci lA c i N o.3: 7CV 0001
vi ton
1
6
M EM O M N D UM O PIN IO N

DM ES,I
BM H I dba
M

DABESEGYPTI I PORTS,
AN M

By: on.Gl n E.Corr d
H
e
la
Se o Unie Stt sDititJ
ni r t d a e src udge

Dee n .
f nda t

M y Saa ,LLC (ç y Saa ' fld ti a to a an tI rhm Da s ar sd n o
a ry
ç a ry' ie h s cin g is b a i be , ei e t f
M
)
Ge ny,as e t f de a c a m sunde t Ln m A c , he Pa e A c ,a t CopyrghtA c ,
nna
s ri e r l l i
ng
r he nha
tt
t nt t nd he
i
t

al ar lt d cli unde Vigi a lw. Thedef nda ha move t dim ist c e f rl k of
fd ea e am
r r ni a
e nt s
d o s s he as o ac

pes na jzidci na i r pe v n eo ,i teatr aie t ta frtec s t t eCe ta
ro ll s ito nd mp o r e u r n h len tv ,o rnse h ae o h nr l
r
Di t i t of Ca iom i . The m o i n has bee f l bre e a i rpe f de ii n. por tw
s rc
lf a
to
n uly if d nd s i or c so 1 , j

f l wigra o , h d fn a tsmoin wilb d ne i pata dd nid wih u prj d c i
ol n e s ns t e ee d n ' to l e e id n r n e e to t eu ie n
o
part
.

Backcround

M ya Sa ay i a lm ie la lt c m pa ba e i St r i V i gi a t tm a ac ur s
r s i t d i biiy o ny s d n e lng, r ni ha
nuf t e

a d srbuts t ba c pr t,i l i hooka a hooka a e s re . M ya Sa a s l
nd iti e o c o oduc s ncudng
hs nd
h cc s o is
r y els
t hoo h pr t nai nal u rs ve a r gitr d ta m a ks i udi t G YA'm a k.
he ka oduc s to ly nde e r l e se e r de r , ncl ng he I
M
' r

Compl! 5 DktNo.1 Thec ny as o anlmbe ofhooka r ltdpae s a welas
. , .
.
ompa lo wns z r
h-eae tnt, s l
a f de a l r i t r d co i tf c r a n pr
e r ly eg s e e pyr gh or e t i oduc pa ka ng.
t c gi

:Thecour hasde e ne t tor la gumentwoul no ai t decii pr sa t stme.
t
t nui d ha a r
d t d he
sonal oces t hi i

I t i t n a i M ya Sa ay cai t tI n m Da sma ,s ls ofe sf rs l ,
n he nsa t cton,
r l ms ha br hi
be kes e l, f r o a e
a e r s pr
nd xpo t oduc s t ti rnge is tade a ks pa e s a coppi . Da i a r sde tof
t' ha nf i
t r m r , t nt , nd
ght
bes s e i n

Gema y He i t e mao iy o ro Da e Eg pin I o t,a fmi b sn s b s d i
r n.
s h j rt wne f b s y ta mp rs a l u ie s a e n
y
Augs g Gen
bur , lnany t t ma s a s l hooka pr t . M ya Sa a a lge t t s m e of
ha
ke nd els
h oduc s
r y le s ha o
D a s pr
be ' oduc s i l ng t e br nded w ih t na e G M Y ,' Ci rnge M ya Sa a s
t , nc udi hos a
t he m W
' &nf i
r y'

i tle t a p o ry'a d ç r k o n l ce td (n o d rd t b ce t d by (lfnd n
nelcu l rpet' n i e n wig y rae a d r e e o e r ae ) d e e a t
we
frt p r o eo k wi l i n igM y Saa sitle t a p o e t rg t. Co l! 1 .
o he u p s f no ngy ngi gn
a ry' n elcu l r p ry ih s' mp . 8
'
M ya Sa a f rhe al ge t tDa s has e
r y u t r le s ha be
xpore t pr t a is t t Unie St t s
td he oduc s t s ue o he
td ae
t oug t na i l di t i or , w ho ha di ti e t m t r t l s or s t oughou t
hr h wo tona sr but s
ve s rbut d he o e ai t e hr
t he

Untd S ae ,çn ld n t e Co n at o Vigna' I ! 1 . Ac o dn t t e
ie tts ç cu i g h mmo we l f r ii. d. 7
i
h
'
c r ig o h
c ai ,çg uli erti sor ,a ot retbls nt,i t Commonwe lh ofVigni
ompl nt çmj tpl eal t es nd he sa ihme s n he
at
ri a
s l,o frt s l,a us ... be Tobac o Pr t ,i udi AM Y Toba co Pr t . I
e l fe o el nd e Da s
c oduc s ncl ng
c
oduc s' d.
'

!2 .
0
OnDe e e 4 2 7 Da e mo dt d s s t ec s f rlc o pes na ju s ito
c mb r , 01 , b s ve o imis h a e o a k f ro l tidcin
a i o rve or i t at m a i ,t ta f r ve
nd mpr pe nue , n he le tve o r nse nue. Da s itd a de a a i i
bes ubm te
clr ton n
s
uppor oft m oton. Acc di t t de l r ton,Da ha ne rta ld t Vigi a N o
t he i
or ng o he c a a i
bes s ve r vee o r ni . r
ha he e ro
s
ve wned,l a ed,orope a e a pr ry i Vig ni The de a a i i c t st t
es
r t d ny ope t n r i a.
clr ton ndi a e ha
D a sEgy i n I pors i notlc ns d t do busnes i V i gi a,a hasno em pl yee ,a nt ,
be
pta m
t s
ie e o
i s n r ni nd
o s ge s

orr pr s n a i i Vigi a. Alho Da s a knowldg t tAM Y pr uc sa e a ia e
e e e t tves n r ni
t ugh be c
e es ha
od t r val bl
f r s l i t U nie St t s he m a nt i t t hi bus nes ha not die ty s d pr
o a e n he
td ae,
i a ns ha s i s s
r c l ol oduc s i
t n
Vi g ni or t r e a of is pr
r i a a get d ny
t oduc s f s l i t s pa tc a s a e. Da s i c t t thi
t or a e n hi r i ul r t t
be ndi a es ha s
busne s ls l is pr
i s sels t oduc s t o h t r pm y w hol s e s r t i dit i or , a t lke.
t hr ug hi de al r , e a l s rbut s nd he i '
'

Da e De l ! 1 ,Dk .No 29 Da e rpo t t a (two o te e e tte ae lc t d i
b s c. J 2 t . . b s e rs h t i q f h s niis r o ae n
l

Calf i' a none a e l a e i Vigi a. 1
iom a' nd
r oc t d n r ni d.Fort s r as ,Da s a gue t the l ks
he e e ons be r s ha
ac
s fc e c a t wih t Co monwe lh ofVigi a t alo t s c tt e r ie pe s l
uf int ont cs t hè m
at
r ni o l w hi our o xe cs r ona

j s ito o e hi
mi dcin v r m.
I rs
n e pons t t pe ng moton,M ya Sa a s m itd a dec a ai n fom M n
e o he ndi
i
r y ub te
l r to r
hmoud

Bad ,t pr sde ofM y Sa ay. The de l r ton i c t st tBa
awi he e i nt
a r
c a a i ndia e ha dawiwa fr ti r ed
s is ntoduc
t Da s i J nua y of 2009, whe Da s c t t d hi i V igi a a i uie a t
o be n a r
n be on ace m n r ni nd nq r d bou
diti i M ya Sa a shooka i Eur pe Afe r cevi ne tve f dba k fom s ve alof
srbutng
r y'
hs n o . tr e i ng ga i ee c r
e r
is Eur a diti o s r a di Da s' busne s pr tc s M ya Sa a ç clned Da '
t
ope n srbut r eg r ng be
i s ac ie ,
ry ç i
de
bes
r que tt diti e M ya Sa a pr t .' Ba a De l ! 1 Dk . .31 1 Ats mep it
e s o srbut
r y oducs' d wi c. 2, t No - .
o on
t r afe ,M ya Sa a r c i d r po t f om is di t i or r a di a ne br nd of A M Y
he e t r
r y e e ve e r s r
t s rbut s eg r ng
w a

ho ka ta wee sy e smia t p an ifsM YA h o a . JJ ! 1 . Ac o dngt Ba a ,
o hs h t r tld i lr o litf
o k hs -. 3 c r i o d wi
1S
.
AM Y hooka pr t a eofe e f s l i t Com monwe lh ofVigi a a ha be n s d
h oduc s r f r d or ae n he
at
r ni , nd ve e ol

a rti so e i Fal Chl c , ifx, n Rih n .S ei j 1 .
t eal tr s n l z h Fara a d c mo d e d.g 1
s r
D i cus i
s s on

Da e h smo dt ds s t ec s f rlc o peg na j rs ito a di r p rve u
b s a ve o imis h a e o a k f ro l u idcin n mp o e n e
u e Rue 1 b ( )a d ()o t eFe ea Rue o Ci lPr c d r . I t eatmaie Da s
nd r l 2()2 n 3 f h d r l ls f vi o e u e n h le tv , be
ha r quesed t tt c tta f r t ca e t t Ce r lD i ti tof Ca i o ni ,pur uml t 28
se
t ha he our r ns e he s o he nt a s r c
lf r a
s to

U. C. 1 0 a .Th c u t la d e se c ag me tnt r .
S. j 4 4() e o r wi d rs a h r u n i u n
l
1
.

Pe s lJur s c i
r ona
i di ton

Rul 1 b)2)oft Fe rlRuls o Ci lPr dtr a hoiesdimis f rl k o
e 2( (
he dea e f vi oce le ut rz s sal o ac f

pes n l l id cin. W hl n ih rp ry a d e s si i isb ifngo t emoin, h lw o
ro a jz s ito
r
ie et e a t d r se t n t rei n h to t e a f
t U nie St t s Co t of Appe l f r t Fe r l Cic t gove ns t due p oc s ml l i
he
td ae
ur
a s o he de a r ui
r he
r e s a ys s

a ia e t t pli ifs c am s of pae i rnge e . Se Aut nomi s I v.Oxf d
pplc bl o he a ntf' l i
tnt nfi m nt
e
oce
c nc.
or

Ge eTe h. d, 6 F.d 1 2,1 6( e . r 2 0 ) Ho v r f ra yno pae tcamsta
n c Lt .5 6 3 01 01 F d Ci. 0 9 . we e , o n n- tn li h t

ae n titmaey l k dt p tn lw, h c u tmu trviw teis e o pes n l u idci n
r o n i tl i e o ae t a t e o r s e e h su f ro a j rs ito
n
t rt 1w oft r ona cr ui,i t s c e t Fourh Cic t Se Sie DrvesI v.
mde he a
he egi l ic t n hi as he
t r ui. e lnt i nc.

S r n I us.nc, 2 F.d 1 9 1 01( d. r 2 0 ) Elc . o I gn . nc v. y e 3
to g nd .l .3 6 3 1 4, 2 Fe Ci. 0 3 , e s fr ma ig l . Co l, 40
.
F.d1 4 ,1 4 ( d Ci. 0 3 .
3 3 4 3 8 Fe . r 2 0 )
Unde Fede a Cic ta l Fou t Cic tpr e ,af de aldititc tmay e cs
r
r l r ui rd rh r ui ec dent e r src our
xer ie

pes n l u idcin o e an n e ie d fn a O l i ()tef z saesln -r saue
ro a j rs ito v r o zsd nt ee d nt n y : 1 h oum tt' o g nm ttt

c n es j rs ito o e t d fnd n ;a d () t e e ecs o j rs ito c mp rs wi
o fr u id cin v r he ee a t n 2 h x rie f u idcin o o t t
h
c n tmto a d e p o e s r q ie ns Se Auo e o c I c,5 6 F.d a 1 1 (ii
o si in l u r c s e urme t. e t a n mis n . 6 3 t 0 6 ctng
Bu g rKi gCo . Rud e c , 71U. 4 2 4 - 6( 9 5 ' e as Caeis o Md.I c v.
r e n m v. z wiz 4
S. 6 , 717 1 8 $, e lo rfrt f .n .
s
Caeis Pr c n y Cts.l . 3 4 F.d 3 0 3 6 (t Ci.20 3 . W i r g r t t e frt
rfrt e na c r . nc, 3 3 9 , 9 4h r 0 )
t e ad o h is
h
r quie e ,bot cr uis ha r c ze t t ç r ri s l a m sa ut e e pe s l
e r m nt h ic t ve e ogni d ha t gila' ong- r t t e xtnds r ona
vi

jlidcint t e tn p r te b teDu Pr c s Clu e' Yo ncv Ne Ha e Ad o ae
t s it o he x e t e mitd y h e o e s a s . u . w v n v c t,
r
o
'
31 F.d 2 6 2 (t Ci. 0 2 ;s eas To c c m. n . . r s & Pa' 5 4F.d 1 3
5 3 5 , 61 4h r 2 0 ) e lo u h o I c v Bee l
dn
t, 7 3 40 ,
r
1 1( d Ci. 0 9 .Co s q e ty t sauo y a dc nsi to a i uiisc ae c it t e
41 Fe . r 2 0 ) n e u n l,he tt tr n o tt in lnq re o ls e n o h
u
sn l q e to o whehe d p o e si s tsidb t c u tse ecs o p ro a j rs ito
ige u sin f t r ue r c s s aife y he o r' x rie f e s n lu id cin
ove t no esde t de e nt Touc om ,57 F. a 1 1 s e as St r v.O' nnel
r he m i n f nda .
hc
4 3d t 41 ; e lo ove
Co l

Aso s.I c, 8 F.d 1 2 1 5 3 (t Ci. 1 9 ) (x lii ta Gh sam o y iq iy
s c . n . 4 3 3 , 3 - 6 4h r 9 6 e p anng h t t e tt r n ur
t
ne s a iy m e ge w ih t co tt tona i r a t t i r e es e i ly bec m e
ce s rl
r s t he ns iu i l nqui y, nd he wo nquii s s nta l
o

one'
'
)

Th d p o e sp o g o tepes na j rs ito a ayssne e sttsa i ur it
e ue r c s r n f h ro l u idcin n l i c siae n nq iy n o
whe he t de e nt m a nt i s fc e ( i m lm c a t ' w ih t f u s a e. I t
t r he f nda
i a ns uf i i nt t ni l ont c s' t he or m t t n he
m

G a o ia' c s o I tr ain lS e Co v W a hi t n 3 U. 31 ( 9 ) te Su r me
t n nc l a e f n en to a ho . . s nRo , 26 S. 0 1 45 , h p e
c
'
4

Co r hed t a a c u tma e rie j s ito o e a n n e i e td fnd n o l (ft e
u t l h t o r y xecs mi dcin v r o r sd n ee a t ny ç h
i
d fn a th sGe ti mii m c n a t wih Eh f r m sae s c t a temane n eo t
ee d n a c ran nmu o tcs t t e o u tt) u h h t h itna c f he
'

s i d e i to fn ta i o ln to o fi p a a d s bsa ta j tc .' Go d e rDt o
ut o s l fe d r dt na oins f ar ly n u tnil usie' o y a ml p
o
i
'
Tie Opeains S. v. o ,5 4U. 91 ,9 (01 )(uoi I tlS o Co.3 6U. a
r s rto s A. Br wn 6 S. 5 23 2 1 q tng n ' h e , 2 S. t
31 .Thi rquie nt' ve adeg e ofprdi a lt t t lga s tm t alowspotnta
6) s e rme t s
gi
re
e ctbiiy o he e l yse hat l
e il
def nda t t sr t e t i prm a y c
e n s o t uc ur he r i r onduc w ih s m e m i m lm a szanc as t w he e t
t t o
ni l s lr e
o
r he

co uc wil a wil not r nde t m la e t s t' W o l W i Vol wace Com . v.
nd t l nd l
e r he ibl o ui.
'
rd- de
ks
n

W o d o , 4 U. 28 , 9 ( 9 0 .
o s n 4 4 S. 6 2 7 1 8 )
Si e l e nai na Shoewa decde c u' ha ditnguihe be wee t ne a o a 1
nc ntr to l
s i d, ot t ve si s d t n t r l r 1s
ge

p po ej s ito ' a d Gpe ii o c s -ik d jlid cin. Go d e r 5 4 U. a 91
u s M dcin' n l cfc r a e l e t s ito ' o v a, 6 S. t 9
s
n
r
'
( ingHeio tr sNa in lsd Co o i.S. v. l, 6U. 40 ,41 ( 9 4 ) Ast e
ct
i
lc pe o co ae e lmba A. Hal 46 S. 8 4 1 8 ). h
S p e Co r e p an d i Go d e r G a o r ma a s r g n r l u idcin o e fr in
u rme u t x lie n o y a, d jc u t y s et e e a j rs ito v r o eg
g
(itrsaeo fr in c t r )( ee d n s t he ra y a d alcamsa an tt e wh n t i
sse -tt r o eg - omty d fn a t) o a n n l li g i s h m e her
a slainswi ro m)Saeaes ûo tn o sa d s se tc a t rnd rt m e sn il a
f ito t f nt tt r o c n iu u n y tmai ' s o e e he s e tal t
h
y

h mei t fr m S ae' I S cfcjl s ito , nt eo h rh n de n so a G ci t o
o n he o u tt. d. pe ii t idcin o h t e a d, pe d n n l t y r
'
r
a vi
a o c re c t a tk sp a e i t e fr m S ae'a d i G o i e t a j d c to o is e
n c u rn e h t a e lc n h o u tt' n s t ntn d o du iain f su s
c .
d rvn fo o c n e tdwih t evey c nr v ryt a etbls e j idcin. 1 . l ti
e iig r m, r o n ce t , h r o to es h t sa ih s urs ito ' d n h s
'
ca e t ei no s si t tt de e ntsc a t wih Vigi ars t t lve ne es a y
s , her s ugge ton ha he f nda ' ont c s t r ni ie o he e l c s r

t s p r te e ecs o g n r lj rs ito . I se d te pa t s d s u e wheh r t e
o u po t h x rie f e e a u idcin n ta , h ri ip t
e
te h
d fn a tsc n a t wi Vigni a es fce tt c n e s cfcj idcin.
e e d n ' o tcs t r i a r ufiin o o fr pe ii urs ito
h
The Fe r Cic t a t Fourh Cic t e pl y a t ee pa ' t s t de e m i whe he
de al r ui nd he
t r ui m o
hr - z e t o t r ne
t
t r

t ee rieo s e ii ju s ito o e ano e ie td fnd n c mp lswihterq ie n s
h xecs f p cfc ti dcin v r m sd n ee a t o o' t h e urme t
t
ofduepr es. Se 31 SvssI .v.Aaot hLa .l ,1 F. 1 1 ( d. r 1 ;
oc s e 7 . nc
r ec bs. nc. 60 3d 373, 378 Fe Ci. 998)

TieEng g& Diti s
r
'
srb.LLC v S n o cLic o Ru b rCo. 6 2F.d 2 2 3 - 2 (t Ci.
. ha d n n lnc b e , 8 3 9 , 010 4h r

20 2 .Un e t i ts,h c u tc n ies ; 1 wheh rte d fn a tp r sf ly drce is
1 ) d r h s e t te o r o sd r :ç ) t e h ee d n u po e ul ie td t
(
a t iisa r sd n so te f r m sae ( )wheh rt cam a ie o to o r ltst t e
ci te t e ie t f h o u tt, 2
v
t e he li rs s u f r eae o h

d fn a tsa tvte wiht ef r m sae a d ( )wheh ra s rin o p ro a j s ito i
ee d n ' ciiis t h o u tt , n 3
t e se t f e s n l mid cin s
o
r a o bea dfi. la d LLC v. K Ino to Co, 9 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 ( d Ci. 01 )
e s na l n ar' g r s
'Ce
S n vain .7 2 3 3 3 3 7 Fe . r 2 5 ;
s a s Tie Eng' & Di t i , 682 F. a 30 Gfhe fr t t f t s c r s nd w ih t
ee l o r
c
sr b.
3d t 2. t ' i s wo ac or or e po
t he

E i mtm c a t 'pr 'o l e a i lSho s nd t t r f c o c r pondswih t tar
m ni l ont c s ong' f nt m tona
e,ç he hid a t r ores
a
t he f i

ply a d s b tn il u tc ' o . l me Co p. Ku ma 2 F.d 1 5 ,1 6 ( d. r
a n u sa ta j sie prng' nn d r v. z k, 49 3 3 6 3 0 Fe Ci.
'
20 )
01.
I t s c e,t pl i if r les a l s i pa' on t Gs r a of co m er e 't or of
n hi as he a ntf e i , t ea t n l,
t
he it e m
m
c ' he y

se ii Jrsito Se P1' Br i Op n 1 ,1 - ,Dt.No.31(mp szngt tDa s
p cfc ' idcin. e . .n p' 1 920 t
u
s
e haii ha be
s pshi pr t t na i diti or i t Unie S a e a t tt pr t ar uli t l
hi s oduc s o tonal srbut s n he t d t t s nd ha he oduc s e tma ey

s l a rti soe i Vign a. Urbru aey çth p e ie r q rme t o t sr n o o d t eal tr s n r ii) t tn tl, s l e r cs e uie n s f he te m-f
t
l
c mme c t e r rman t et d. Poa Elcr Oyv. umt Oy 8 F.d 1 4 ,1 48( e .
o r e h o y e i ms tl ' lr e to
e '
S t o , 29 3 3 3 3 F d
Ci. 1 ) s eas Cec r a
r 20 6 ; e lo lad LLC v S I v to Co,7 2F.d 1 7 ,1 8 ( d Ci. 0 5 .
. K r ain . 9 3 3 3 3 1 Fe . r 2 1 )
mo
Ast Fe r lCic te ane i Ce ca d:
he de a r ui xpl i d n l z
W het rme e pl c m e ti o t sr n ofc
he r a e n nt he te m
omme c i s fc e
r e s ufii nt

t etb ih j s ito o wh t e itn t a tepr d csr a h
o sa ls mid cin, r eh r n e t h t h o u t e c
t f u i r quie c be ta d t As hiM e a I ty Co.v.
he or m s e r d, an r ce o a
t l ndusr

Sunei Cou tofCalf ni,Solno Co v,480U. 1 ( )
ror r
ior a a
unt
S. 02 1987 .
J sie Brn n j ie b tr e oh rj tc s o i d t a mee
u tc e na , on d y h e te usie , pne h t r
f e e biiy t tt de e n ' pr uc woul wi u i t
or s ea lt ha he f nda ts od t
d nd p n he

f r m sae wa s fi in t e tbih jl s ito . To J sie
o u tt s u tce t o sa l t id ci n
s r
u tc
Br nnan, d pr s i s ts id whe t de e nt pl c s a
e
ue oce s s a ife
n he f nda
ae
pr
oduc i o t sr a of c m e c w hie be ng Ga a e t tt
t nt he t e m
om r e
l i t w r ha he
fnal pr
i
oduc i be ng m a ke e i t f um St t ' I a 117
ts i
r t d n he or
a e. d. t
'

t e a J.c uri i pa t. Duepr e si stsi be a e
BrmAn , onc rng n rl
oc s s aifed c us
t de e nt d r c l be ft fom G he r t i s l of t fna
he f nda ie ty ne is r
t e al ae
t
he i l
pr
oduc i t f u St t ' a i r c l be is f o t Gl w s
t n he or m a e ' nd ndi e ty neft r m he ia
t t r gul t a f ciia e c m e c a a tviy. I J tc
ha e a e nd a lt t om r i l c i t ' d. us i e
'

O' n o wr t spaaey a wa j ie b t e j sie .
Co n r oe e rtl nd s on d y hre u tc s
J tc O '
us i e
Connor co e d t t s m e hi m o e t n t
nt nde ha o t ng
r ha he
f r s a lt ofe r oft de e ntspr uc s i o t f m
o e ee biiy
nty
he f nda ' od t nt he onl
sae wa r quie be a e t t1 w t e hol doe notgua a ee
t t s e r d c us ha o hr s d s
r nt
t t due pr s ' ptr e ula im e t r ui e e t i m e .
ha
oce s
lpos f - va l n eq r m n s
t
Acc r ng t J tc O'
o di o usi e Connor a çs t tal c
Eubsan i onne ton . . .
ci
bewe n t def nda and t f l m St t ' mus a ie outoft
t e he e nt
he o'
u
a e' t rs
he
a tviis oft de e ntt ta e ç z e uly die t d t r
c i te
he f nda ha r d pos f l r c e owa d
pu

t e f nl S ae' J. a 1 2 (iain a d q o ain maks
h o m tt. #a t 1 ctto s n u tto
'
r
o te ) M eeypa i t p o uc it t esra p c mmec ,
mitd . rl lcng ( r d t no h te m f o r e
a
wihoutm o e,i no a ac oft de e ntpur ef l die t d
t
r s t n t he f nda
pos uly r c e

t wadt ef r m S ae' J.(mp a i a de )
o r h ou tt . .. e h ss d d .
'1
J
The Supr m e Co t r c nty r c i r t r quie nt f
e
ur e e l e onsde ed he e r me s or

etb ihig j s ito u d r a srn o -o re t e r i
sa ls n mi dcin n e te m- fc mmec h o y n
Mcn v e M a hn r ,Lt .v.Nia to,1 S.Ct 27 0 ( 01 )
ltr
c ie y d
c sr 31
. 8 2 1.
Agai t Coul di notr c co e us o whehe s m ehi
n, he
' d
t
ea h ns ns p
t r o t ng
m or t n f e ee biiy i r quie W rtng f ra pltaiy oft
e ha or s a lt s e r d. ii o
tr lt
he

Co t J sie Ke ne y h l t a jlidcin o e t e d fn a t
ur, u tc n d ed h t t s ito v r h ee d n
r
was i ope t r a sr a ofco me c t or be aus t
mpr r mde
te m- - m r e he y c e he
de e ntha notpur e u l a ied hi s l oft f r sa e'
f nda
d
pos f ly val m e f he o um tt s

lws S ' iial, h j rs ito a f csd dn tGe e la itn
a . p cfc l t e u idcin l a t i o t v a n ne t
e
y
r
t i
o nvoke orbe ftfom t pr e ton of't l wsoft f nz
ne i r he ot c i
he a
he o m
s a e. I a 2791
t t d. t
.
Ce g d,79 F. a 1 .
l ar 2 3d t 381
Si e As hiwa decde t Fe r lCic tha G clned t t ke a poston on t
nc
a
s i d, he de a r ui s ç i
de
o a
ii
he

rq ie n so a sra o -o rejlidcin lt s' be a e t e r s lto o te c s s
e ur me t f te m- fc mmec t s ito a e t c us h e ou in f h a e
r
'
be o e i di notr q r t Cour t do s Cel r 792 F. a 1 2;s a s Pol rEl to Oy,
fr t d
e uie he
to
o. ga d,
3d t 38 ee l o a ecr

8 9 F.d a 1 4 - 0 (I Be el Hil F n Co v. y lSo r in Co n, F.d 1 5 ,1 6
2 3 t 3 9 5 & n v ry ls a . Ro a veeg r .21 3 5 8 5 6
t
( d Ci. 1 9 ) t i c u t d cie t d cd wh c o J tc O' r rs a d J sie
Fe . r 9 4 , hs o r e ln d o e ie ih f usie Co mo ' n u tc
Br nna st sss d be a ed bec us t out
e n' e t houl
dopt
a e he come oft ta a woul be t s me t r
ha ppe l
d
he a mde
e t rt s . Subs que pa l ha f l w ed t ta oa h,a t r ol i oft c est f r
ihe e t
e nt ne s ve olo
ha ppr c s he es uton he as hus a
ha no r qui e us t t ke a s de on t A s hidi de H e e w e lkewi e de lne t de i w hi h
s t e rd o a
i
he a
vi . r ,
i
s c i o c de c
ve s on of t s r a - f c m e c t r s d a y be us , .. .t r s t w oul be t
ri
he t e m o - om r e heo y houl ppl ca e
he e ul
d
he

smeu d rala t uain o t e sra o -o r ets.) I c nr s,t Fo rh Cic i
n n e l ri lto s f h te m-fc mmec e t'. n o tat he u t r ut
c
'
7

has hed t tme ey plc ng pr t i o t sr m ofcomm e c G t t e c ai n t t
l ha r l a i
oduc s nt he tea
r e i h he xpe t to ha
wi

t e wo l bep r h s di gh f r m sae'i no s fiin t c n ttt ç ciiyp r sf ly
h y ud u c a e n t e o u ttq's t u fce t o o siue l tvt u po e ul
a
d rce 'a t a sae I r Ceoe Co p,1 4 F.d 61 ,6 ( t Ci.1 9 )(ii Le nc v.
ie td' t h t tt. n e ltx r . 2 3 9 29 4h r 9 7 ct
ng s ik
Holn s rh & Vo e Co. 3 F.d 9 9 9 5 (t Ci.1 9 $. Ac o dngy ç s p slig wo t
s
, 5 3 3 , 4 4h r 9 4
c r i l, s t o t
mo
M c nt e de i i ns f om l
l yr c s o r
ower c rt i t Four h Cic t ha c l d ...t t t Fourh
ou s n he
t r ui ve onc ude
ha he
t
Cic t e s ntaly f l w s t tor s e biiy pl ' o G t e m - - om m e ce pl ' t t a s t
r ui s e i l olo
he f e e a lt us r s r n of c
r
us es, s e

f rh i As hi' Colir v.La & Se Re t Co. LLC,N o.7: 3- v- 04,201 U . Dit
ot n a .
'
le
nd
a s. .
1 c 001
4 S. s.

LEXI 1 71 8 a *1 ( . Va Oc . 5 2 4 ( n a , . (olcigc s s.
S 4 1 , t 6 W D. . t 1 , 01 ) Co rd J) c le tn ae )
W he p e e tdwih mo in t ds s f rlc o p ro a j rs ito ,d src c u t
n rs ne t to s o imis o a k f es n l u idcin itit o rs
ha tc i r bl pr e a l wa ' a C a pe mi dic r i a d of t m o i '
ve ionsde a e oc dur l ee y' nd s y r t s ove y n i
m
he ton.
'

Ma ieM iln Bn k N. v Milr 6 4 F. 8 9 9 4 ( d Ci.1 81;s eas l tr in
rn da d n . A. . le, 6 2d 9 , 0 2 r 9 ) e lo nb mu o
S lto s I c v.Va t Gp . 1 0 F.S p 3 9 4 9 8 ( SC.2 5 (mp a iig t a
ou in - n .
nus , 3
u p. d 9 , 9 D.. 01 ) e h szn h t
ç ititc u t h veb o dd sr to t alwj s ito a ds o ef' (iigM ya La .I c
ç src o rs a r a ic ein o lo mi dcin l ic v r ) ctn
d
ln bs. n .
v. z s V.2F.d 5 , 4( t Ci. 0 3) lihv. S Caionis n . 1 F. D. 5 , 9
Ak o N. , 3 6 6 4h r 2 0 )* tc KI lfr a I c, 21 R. 2 4 25
,
( . N . 1 8 )( b evn ta ac u t ho d odnai p r t t id ci n lds o eyt e s
M D. C. 9 8 o s r ig h t o r s ul r i rl e mijl s ito a ic v r mls
y
r
t eplitf scam a p a st beG la l fi oo s);2 CP.LLC v.Fise b r M a h.Co,
h an if li p e r o s e ry rv lu ' 5
c
rtn e a c
.
10 -v 0 0 0 20 9U.. s.LEXI 1 5 9 ,a * n.4 ( N. De .8 20 9 (oi gt a
:9 c - 0 8 , 0 S Dit
S 1 1 4 t 36 1 D. H. c , 0 ) n tn h t
c u t S v t ea t o i t o d rj ds ito a d so e ys as o t' .I c s siv l igt e
o rs l e h u h rt o r e u dcin l ic v r u p n e' n a e n o vn h
ha
y
)
t et d sra o -o rete r , l idcin lds o r ha b e f t t bepatc lry
mstl te m-fc mmec h o y jz s ito a ic vey s e n omd o
e
r
riua l
a opra e Se . e c. Com m i s ra a lEne ci At i ue v.Chi M ei Opt l t oni s Co n.
ppr i t . e . ,
s a i t ' r e om g
oe ec r c
r ,

3 5 F.d 1 5 1 2 ( d 2 0 ) (o cudn ta a dee miain a t wh c sra o 9 3 31 , 3 2 Fe . 0 5 c n l ig h t
tr n to s o ih te m- f
c m e c s a r s d be a
om r e t nda d houl
dopt d co d t be r s ved on t pr s ntr co d be a e t
e ul t
not e ol
he e e e r c us he

dititc tde lne t o d j iditona dico r ' a o e vi t ti t pli ifSi
src our ci d o r er urs ci l s veyy' nd bsr ng ha f he antf çs
8

a e t s tsy J tce O' r r s t s, t e wil be no ne d t a es whehe t ls
bl o aif usi
Co mo ' e t her l
e o ddr s
t r he e s
r src i ts pr pos d by J tc Br nna s d be t sa r ...unde t due pr e s
e titve e t o e
usi e e n houl
he t nda d
r he
oc s

ca s ';s eas Cea r , 9 F.da 1 7 (o igta d fn a tso ii l to wa d ne
lu e' e lo la d 7 2 3 t 3 5 n tn h t e e d n ' rgna mo in s e id
)
wi o t rj dc t r fln f lo ngt ec nd c o j ds ito a ds o e y ; lrElcr Oy,
t u p eu ie o ei g olwi h o u t f u dcin l ic v r ) Poa e to
h
i
8 9 F.d a 1 4 ( tn t t d fn a ts moin wa h l i a e a c whl t p ris
2 3 t 3 6 noig ha e e d n ' to
s ed n b y n e ie he a t
e

c n u tdjlid cina d so e y .
o d ce t s ito l ic v r)
r
Ap li gt e ep icp e , h c u tc n ld sta j rs ito ld s o ey i warne
py n h s rn ils t e o r o cu e h t u id cina ic v r s ra td
i t i t ntc e,a t ts h dic r woul a d t c ti dee mi ng whe he s ii
n he nsa as nd ha uc s ove y
d i he our n t r ni
t r pecfc

j rs ito e sswih rs c t e c cam a s re i te c mp an . Se Gae e e I .v
u id cin xit t epe t o a h li se td n h o lit e tke p r nc .
S rtc S ssLt . 71 F.S p 2 6 4,6 7 6 ( D.Va 2 0 (o cu i g t t s e ii
tae h y . d, 8
u p. d 6 6 - 8 E.
. 01 ) c n ld n ha p cfc
J rs ito rq ie a cam-p cfc a ay i) Th plitf h s ofr d mo e t a mee
' idcin e ur s li s e ii n lss. e an if a fee
u
r hn r
s c a i o : a e alegai ns'r ga di t de e n ' co a t wih t f m sat z Ii h,
pe ulton r ç r l to ' e r ng he f nda ts nt c s t he onz t e. tc
b

1 F. D.a 2 9 Be a s te p an ifs a srin o pes na j rs ito i no p an y
21 R. t 5 . c u e h litf' se t f ro l u idci n s t lil
o
fi o ,a snc addii le de woul f iia e amor i or d decson,t c twil
rvol us nd i e
tona vi nce
d acltt
e nf me
ii he our l

pe mi t e p rist c n u tj s ito a d s o r . S c d so r s alb lmie t t
r t h a t o o d c midcin l ic vey u h ic vey h l e i td o he
e

t e re o s e ii j s ito rle u n i t p an ifsb ifi o po i o ( c e No 31,
h ois f p cfc mid cin eid po n he iitf' re n p st n Do k t . )
i
a d mu tb c mpltd wi i sxy ( 0 d y . Th pe dn moi n t d s s f r lc o
n
s e o ee t n it 6 ) a s
h
e n ig to o imis o a k f
p ro a jlidcin wilb d ne wih u p eu ie t rfln wihn f u te ( 4 d y
e s n l t s ito l e e id t o t rj dc o eiig t i o re n 1 ) a s
r
2I hi r y bref t def
n s epl i , he endanta gue t the doe nothave s l entcont t wih t W ese'
r s ha
s
ufki
acs t he
tl
n

Ditito Vignat s p r t e ecs ofp ro lu idcin.Thi ag me trfç t amiun esa di
src f r ii o up o the x rie es na j rs ito
s r u n elcs s d rtn ng
o t lw. ç-le S prme Co r ha rc nz d ta a ditit c u tma e rie s cfc pes n l
f he a çlh u e
gu t s e og ie h t src o r y xecs pe ii ro a
j rs ito o ra d fnd n ...i t e d fn a th ss fiin d nmu c ntcs wih te fr m sae'
u idcin ve ee a t f h ee d n a u fce t mii m o a t' t h o u tt.
'
CF I t v.Is.o Chatr dFi An lssofl i,5 F.d 28 ,2 3 ( t Ci.2 09 (mp ssa de )
A ns. n t f ree n. av t nda 51 3 5 9 4h r 0 ) e ha i d d
(iig ltlSh e 32 U. a 31 ) Ac o dngy t ej rs iton la lssf c s so C p ry sc na t
ctn n ' o , 6 S. t 6 . c r i l, h u idci a nay i o u e n ç at' o tcs
a
wih t e ie sat 'r t rt n is tc a s wih t pari arf de aldititwihi s sa e. Gl
t he ntr t e' ahe ha t tontct t he tcul e r src t n uch tt ' obal
'

To c Souin .LLC v. s baCop. 1 9F. p 3d8 2,8 ( D. . 01 ) s eas Ta o v. s ia
u h lto s
To hi r , 0 Su p. 8 91 E. Va 2 5 , e lo ylr Ihd ,
.
No 3:2 CV- 4 2,2 0 U. Dit LEXI 9 6 a * 8n. ( D . x.J ne3 2 2 (mp szngt tt
. 0 - 0 0 0 2 S. s.
S 91 , t 1 7 N. Te u , 00 ) e haii ha he
Smlni m c n a t a ay i i c n uce a c r igt c na t wi te fr m sae no tef r ditit
t i mu o tcs n lss s o d td c o dn o o tcs t h o u tt, t h oum src
l
h
c ul )(mph ssi o ii l.
o f' e a i n rgna)

f l ng t c
olowi he omplton o t s lmie dico r l t de e nt c
e i f hi i t d s ve y. f he f nda hoos s t r ne hi
e o e w s

ju s ito a mo in t p riss alfl s p lme tlbif a d e sng wheh rteplitf
tidcin l to , he a t h l ie u p e n a res d r si
e
te h an if
c te tbihs cfcj rs ito fre c cam a s re i t ec mp an .
al sa ls pe ii u idci n o a h li s e td n h o lit
Il.

V enue

I a dto t s e i d s sa f rlc o p ro a jzidcin,te d f n a tag e
n d iin o e kng imisl o a k f es n l l s ito h e e d n r u s
r

t a t c s s ul beds se o t eb sso i rpe v n e S eFe . Ci P.1 ()3
h t he a e ho d imis d n h a i f mp o r e u . e d R. v. 2b ()
(uh rzn ds sa f ri o e v n e .Fo t f lo ngr a o , h c u t ia re .
a to iig imis l o mpr p r e u ) r he olwi e s ns t e o r ds g e s
The d fn a ts v n e a g me t i bae o 2 U. C.j 1 0 ( ) a d t e S p e
e e d n ' e u r u n s s d n 8 S.
4 0 b n h u rme
Co tsr e tdecson i TC He lnd v.I af Food Gr Br ndsLLC,1 S.Ct 1 4
ur' ec n
ii n
m a
lr t
oup a
37
. 51

( 1 ) S cin 1 0 ( )p o i e ta Can cvla to f rp tn ifi e n ma b b o g t
20 7 . e to 4 0 b r v d s h t t j y ii cin o ae t n rng me t y e r u h
l
i t ej iil ititwh r t d f n a t ei e , rwh r ted fnd n ha c mmitd a t o
n h udca d src e e he e e d n r sd s o ee h ee a t s o te cs f
i rnge ta ha ar ulra esa ihedplc ofbusne s' 28U. C.j 1 b) I TC
nfi men nd s eg a nd tbls
ae
i s.
'
S.
400( . n

He rln te S p e Co r h l ta t etr çe i e c ' i j 1 0 ( ) Eas a pl d t
a t d, h u rme u t ed h t h em ç sd n e' n 4 0 b , t j p i o
a
r
g
e
do e tcc nor to ,...r f r onl t t Stt ofi or a i 'a doe noti op or t t
m si or ai ns
e e s y o he ae nc por ton,' nd s
nc
ae he

b o d rd fn to c n an d i t g n r lve u saue 2 U. C.j 1 91c . TC He rlnd
r a e eiii n o tie n he e e a n e ttt , 8 S.
3 ()
at ,
a
1 7 S. . t1 7 1 21(mp a i a d d .
3 Cta 51 , 5 e h ss d e )
Eve t
n hough t de e nt i t s c s i not a dom e tc c por ton,he no t l s
he f nda n hi a e s
si or a i
nehe e s
a gue t tve i i pr r i lghto TC H e r l nd. H oweve ,t TC H e r l nd Cou tm a
r s ha nue s m ope n i
f
a ta
r he
a ta
r de

ce rta iso i o d dno a d e st a p ia l yo j1 0b t f ri nd f n a t. S ei
la h t t pnin i t d r s he p lc bit f 40 () o o eg e e d ns e d.
i
a 1 20n. TheCour aloe iil notdt ti di no le prs a opi on o (he Co ts
t 5 2.
t s xplcty e ha t d t tx e s ny ni n t j ur'

hol ngi Br teM a zneW or .Lt v. klm I tis I ,406U. 706 ( 97 . J.
di n unet cli
ks d. Koc l ndusre . nc.
S.
1 2)' ..
'F
a
A cc r i y, ç t e ' r m a ns good l w . 3G Li ns ng. S. . v.HTC Co ' ,N o. 1 1 c
o d ngl s m te e i
Br t
a '
'
ce i
A
1
p.
: 7- v-

0 0 3 20 7 U. Dit LEXI 2 7 0 ,a * ( De. c 1 ,2 7 (ii Re c ms nc v
0 8 , 1 S. s.
S 0 2 2 t 4 D. l De . 8 01 ) ct
ng d.o I . .
1
0

Jn iTe h L d, 81 -v- 0 8 20 7 U. Dit LEXI 1 7 9 ,a * 0 ( D.Ca. t 1 ,
in c t .No. :7 c 0 3 2, 1 S. s.
S 7 7 9 t 2 C. l Oc. 1
2 79.
01 (
I Bnmet,t e S p e Co r h l t twh n a f ri n d fn a ti t s b e to a
n
te h u r me u t ed ha e o eg e e d n s he u j c f
pa e i rnge e ac i ve
t nt nf i m nt ton, nue i gove d by t g ne a ve
s
nw
he e r l nue pr s o r t r t n b
ovi i n, a he ha y

j 1 0 b . Bnmet, 0 U..a 71 .Th g nea v n ep o iin sae t a C d fn a tn t
40 ( )
te 4 6 S t 4 e e rl e u r vso tt s h t G e e d n o
a

r sd n i t Untd S ae ma be s e i a y j dca dsrc ' 28 U. C.j 1 91c ( )
e ie t n he i tts y
e
u d n n u iil itit'
S.
3 ()3
(mp a i a d d ;s eas I r Prnc tn Diia I c Co n.4 6 F. p' 7 ,7 ( e .Ci.
e h ss d e l e lo n e i eo gtl ma e r , 9 Ap x 3 5 F d r
201 ) ( tng t t t Br ne t Co t Keafnne t l sa ng r e t t a pae
2 noi ha he u te ur s fi d he ong-tndi ul ha
r
tnt
i rnge e s tc d bebr ug a i ta f r i de e nti a dititco t a wa no
nfi m nt ui oul
o ht gans o egn f nda n ny src ur, nd s t
r src e t whe e t de e nt r sde ,c mis acs of i rnge e ,o ha a r gulr a
e tit d o
r he f nda e i s om t t
nfi m nt r s e a nd

etb ih db i s a oh r s r q ie t e t ep tn ve u saue).
sa ls e usne s s te wie e ur d md r h ae t n e tt t'
l t s c s , i i und s e t t Da s i a f r gn de e nt Se De .s M o .t
n hi a e t s
iput d ha be s o ei
f nda . e f'
t o

Dimiso Tr n f r1 (mp a ii t a t d fn a td e no r sd i te Unie Sae )
s s r a se 0 e h szng h t he e e d n o s t e ie n h
td tts.
Ac or ngl ve i no i ope ,a t de e nti note il d t d s is lt rRul
c di y, nue s t mpr r nd he f nda s
ntte o im s a mde
e

1 ( )3 .
2 b ()
1
11.

T rans er
f

Dab a t r tve y s e t t a f r t ca e t t Cen r l D i ti t of Calf i ,
es le na i l e ks o r ns e he s o he
ta
src
iom a

pt s a tt 28U. C.j 1 0 () Th ssam ep o i e t tCfo t ec n e in eo t ep ris
lu n o
r
S.
4 4 a. i tt r v d s ha G j r h o v n e c f h a t
l
e
a dwin se ,i t itr s o j sie adsrc c u t yta se a ycv l cint a yohe
n t e s s n he nee t f u tc , itit o r ma rn fr n ii a to o n t r
dititordi so whee i mihtha be n br
src
viin r t g ve e ought' 28 U. C.j 1 a . As t pa'
.
'
S.
404()
he zy
t
s li ta f r Da s be r t C a bur n' of e t ili t t ta f r i wara ed.
eecng r ns e , be a s he i vy
he
de '
sablslng ha r nse s r nt

Enc
ompa sAd s r.Lt v. pe I ,68 F.Supp.2d607,61 ( . N. 2009)
s vio s d. Una m nc. 6
6 W D. C.
.

Bas d o t c r ntr c d,t co ti notpe s ded t tta f ri t ca e t t
e n he ure e or he ur s
r ua
ha r ns e rng he s o he
Ce r l Ditit o Calf ni woul be m o e co nint f r t pa te a wine s .
nta
src f
ior a
d
r
nve e o he ri s nd t s es

No ehee s u tlhec e to o pes n l t id cini r s le , h c u te d t b le et t
n t ls , ni t t sin f ro a jl s ito s e ov d t e o r tn s o eiv ha
u
r
i woul bepr m atr t nzeon t de e ntsat m a i ta f rr ue t Se e. ,Powe tqs
t
d
e tle o l
he f nda ' le tve r ns e eq s. e. g.
re

LLC v. h a , 3:5c 0 26 2 6U.. s.
As rf No. 1 -v-26 , 01 S Dit LEXI 1 9 ,a * ( D.Ca . a 7 2 6
S 8 6 t 9 N. lJ n. , 01 )
( e lnn t c nsd rt e d fn a tsatr t moin t ta se t e j 1 0 ()u tlt e
d ci ig o o i e h ee d n ' l nai
e ve to o ' n fr md r 4 4 a ni h
r

c t'r s le t eis eo p ro a j rs ito ) De io M e Pr d . Bip yScs.
out e ov d h su f es n l u idcin ; v c r d. o s v. o s i.LLC,
No.
11 -v 01 6 , 201 U.. Dit L S 1 5 7 a * ( De. Fe 7 2 3 (a )
:0 c - 0 0
3 S s. EXI 6 3 , t 21 D. l b. , 01 ) s me .
Ac o dn l,t t e tn t ep n i moin s e t ta se te c s pt s a tt j 1 0 ()
c r igy o he x e t h e dng to e ks o rn fr h a e l u n o 4 4 a,
r
t emoinwi bed n e wih u p eu ie
h to l e id t o t rj dc .
l
C oncl i
us on

Fort r as ns s tf t a
he e o e orh bove t de e n ' m o i n t dim is f lc ofpe s l
, he f nda ts to o s s or a k
r ona

jlidcin a d i r p rv n o , nt atr aie t ta frt c s t t eCe ta Ditit
t s ito n mp o e e ue r i he len tv , o rnse he a e o h nr l src
r
o Caion a wi be d n e i p r a d d n e wi o tprj ie i p r. F lo n te
f l r i, l
f
l
e id n a t n e id t u eudc n a t o lwig h
h

c mp ein o t e lmie j rs ito a ds o ey o tie a o e t d f n a t s alh v
o lto f h i td u idcin l ic v r uln d b v , he ee d n h l a e
fure n ( 4 d y i wh c t rn w t ej s ito a c le g u d rRu e 1 09( )a d te
o te 1 ) a s n ih o e e h midcin l haln e n e l 2 2 n h
atr tverques t ta frt c et rj1 a .
lenai e t o rnse he as mde 404()
TheCl r i die t d t s nd c pisoft sm e or ndlm o ni n a t a cp nyi
ek s r c e o e o e
hi m a l pi o nd he c mpa ng
or rt alc ms lofr c d.
de o 1 ot e
e or

DATED: is
Ths

d yo Mac , 01 .
a f rh 2 8

Se o U nie St t s D it i tJ
ni r t d a e s rc udge