Alvarado v. Co of Tulare et al

Filing 13

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/20/17. (hnw)

CLERK' OFFI U. . OI COURS
CE S ST.
I
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UN I
N
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STRI O F V I F I
CT
RG N A
CHAM OTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON

J 2 12 1
UL
27
JU
BY;

c,

cuuaà
l

DAN I D . LV A M D O ,
EL A
Ci lA c i N o.3: 7CV 00040
vi ton
1

Pl i if
antf,
M EM OM NDUM OPI ON
NI
COUN TY OF TULAR E,e a i
t l,

Ho Gln E.Conr d
n. e
a
Unie St t sD i ti tJ ge
t d a e sr c ud

De e nt .
f nda s

Da e D.Al r c me ed t saci n by flng apr x c
hi l
va ado om nc hi to
ii
o
ompl i on J ne 5,201
ant
u
7.

Al rdo ddnotpa t flngfebutwa grntd la t pr ee L f mapa rs Fort
vaa i
y he ii e
s a e e ve o oc d q or
upei.
he

f l wigr a o , h c u t o cu e t a t a to i s b e tt d s sa f rlc o pes na
ol n e s ns t e o r c n ld s h t he cin s u j c o imis l o a k f ro l
o
jtid cin.
t s it
r
o
Backzround

Al r do' c
va a s ompl i , whih i syld as a a fda t s aes t t he was pr vi usy
ant
c s t e
n fi vi, tt ha
e o l
i a c r t d a t Bob W ie De e to Ce e i Tulr Co t Ca ior a Al r do wa
nc r e a e t he
ly t n i n nt r n
a e un y, lf ni . va a
s
r l s d fom t c r c i f iiy o Aug t2,201 Pro t hi r e s ,ade y wih t
eea e r he ore tonal aclt n
us
5. i r o s ela e
put t he
Tul r Cot y She if sDe t e tbe n eups twhe Al r do r f e t sgn hi na on a
a e mt
rf
parm n c m
e
n va a e us d o i
s me
doc nta i t a r e e d a pr vii oft Unio m Comm e cilCode. Ac or ng t
ume nd nse d ef r nce
o son he
fr
r a
c di o
Al r do,t de y t e hi he d frt i o a wa l ca i hi t be m e t ons ous
va a
he put hr w m a is nt
l, usng m o co
mc ci .

Al aa o as rst a hes sane ahe dij r t tt o tr emo t st he l He( e n gl'
v rd se t h t u ti d a nu y ha o k h e n h o a.
ç ma d s'
d
t tt de yt hedac ou a ef ghede y')aci . Compl2,Doc tNo.2.
ha he put i l c ntbl or t put s tons'
be
'
.
ke
On t cvi c r s e a c pa ng hi c
he i l ove he t c om nyi
s ompl n ,Al r do doe no nn any
ait va a
s t me
pa tc a i vi l o e ii s a de e nt Howe r Al r i c t s t he i now a
ri ulr ndi duas r ntte s f nda s.
ve , va ado ndi a e hat s
r sde of Al ma l Co y,Vigi a,t t t de e nt a e r sde s of Tulr Count
e i nt
be re unt
r ni ha he f nda s r e i nt
ae
y,

Caio a a dt t ei ivo n tec u tsdvest jlidcin. Al aa ot e sae t th
lfmi, n ha h s n kig h o r' i ri t s ito
y r
v r d h n tts ha e
i ase t cli f cvi rght vi ainsunde 42 U. C.j 1 c ihti rnge nt
s s ri ams or i l i s olto
ng
r
S.
983, opyrg nfi me ,
ki ppi e oli blc al a sa y.
dna ng, xt on, a km i, nd lver
St
andard ofR evi
ew

Un e 28U. C. 1 5 e , ihg v r sL f r p u rsp o e dng , h c u t a a
dr
S. j 91 () wh c o en q oma a pei r c e i s t e o r h s
ma d tr d t t sr e i ta fln s Erl e Co. J h o 4 0F.d 6 8 6 6 5 ( t Ci.
n aoy uy o e e n ni l i g . in
i i
i
v. o ns n, 4 3 4 , 5 - 7 4h r
2006) Thec u'i rquie t dimisac s t ta tme'it co tdeer ne t tt a ton
.
ot t s e rd o s s a e t ny i 'f he ur t mi s ha he ci
a
i fi ouso t tt c
s rvol
r ha he ompli tf ist sa eac am o whi h r le m a begr nt d. 28 U. C.
an al o tt li n
c e if y
a e
S.

j 1 5 e( )B) Ad iinql,i e au t ac mplitfld. f nn r a pei, h c u t y
91 ()2 ( . d t ly n v l ai
o
ng o an ie t o ap u rs t e o r ma
q
r ie a wai bl def ns s s e whe t c
as
va e e e ua pont
n he ompl i pl i y r ve l t e se e ofs h
ant anl e a s he xitnc
uc

d e e ErlneCo.440F; a 656(ii Na i v. a de M d. eofCo .64F. 951
efns . ii
,
3d t ctng sm W r m
Hous
n'
, 3d ,

9 3 5 ( t Ci.1 9 )* s eas An es n v.XYZ Co r He 1 S r s-I c,4 7 F.d 6 4,
5 - 4 4h r 9 5) ; e lo d ro
r. at e v . n . 0 3 7
h
6 2 8 (t Ci. 0 5 (e o n zngt a s s n ed s s a ma b a p o raei t e se c
8 - 3 4h r 2 0 ) rc g ii h t ua po t imis l y e p r p it f he xitn e
ofa afr tvedefns i ç ppae fom t f c o ac anf'.
n fimai
e e s t r nt r he a e f ompli )
a
D i cussi
s
on

I t sca e i i a r ntfo t f c oft c
n hi s , t s ppa e r m he a e he ompli t tt s c tdoe notha
ant ha hi our
s
ve

p ro a j rs ito o e t d fnd n s Th c mpan ma e ce rt a Alaa o scamsae
e s n lu idci n v r he ee a t. e o lit k s la h t v r d ' li r
bas d o acso o isonst tocc e i t St t ofCalf ni N o oft acsoro isons
e n t r m s i ha
un'd n he a e
ior a. ne he t
m si
i a lge t ha occ r d i t Com monwe 1h of Vig ni I a ton, t r a e no
s le d o ve
ure n he
at
r i a. n ddii
he e r

* l Erlne,t Unied St es Coul ofAppeal f t Fourt Cic texpli t t s eeni
n ii he t
at
'
t
s or he
h r ui
aned hat he cr ng

a t rt afr e t c u t i a to sfldL f r pa ei dfe e tae s ha to fo odi r cvl uis
uho i fo d d o o rs n cin ie q o ma up rs ifrn its uc cins r m r nay iis t
y

a j siisa e c pint teg nea r l ta a afr tv d fn es ud n tb c n iee s as o t .
nd u tfe n x e to o h e rl ue h t n fimaie ee s ho l o e o sd rd u p n e
44 F. a 6 6(iigNai 6 F.da 95 - 4 .
0 3d t 5 ctn sm, 4 3 t 3 5 )
2

alg to ss g sigt a t eCaio nar sd n salg d yr s nsbl f rteplitf' ijlis
le ai n u getn h t h l r i e i e t le e l epo i e o h an ifs nt e
f
r
have a co m ec i n t V igi a
ny r t o o r ni .

G lwf l a srin o p ro a j rs ito o e a d fnd n r q ie s tsyng t e
G a ' se t f e s n l u idcin v r ee a t e urs aif i h
A
u
o
sa r oft f m sae' l a sa t a r peci t s f gua ds e lrne i t
t nda ds he onl t t s ong- nn tm e nd es tng he a e r nsli d n he
Fouree h Am e e ' Due Pr es Clus ' Tie Enc' & Diti .LLC v. Sha
t nt
ndm nts
oc s a e.
' r
g
srb.
ndong

Li go cRu b rCo.6 2F.d29 3 (t Ci. 01 ) ( c us Vign aslng am sa e
n ln b e , 8 3 2, 01 4 h r 2 2 . t a e r ii ' o -r tmt
Be
e tn spes n lt idcint t eo tr u so d ep o e s t et -r ngts c la e it a
xe d r o a jl s ito o h u e bo nd f u r c s,h wop o et olps s n o
r
sng ei r whe Vigi ai t f um sa e' 1 Ac r ngl aVigi ac t n e r ie
i l nquiy
n r ni s he or t t .' d. co di y, r ni our ca xe c s

p ro a J rs ito o ra n n e i e t d fn a to l i t e e ecs o s c j rs ito
e s n l ' id cin ve
u
o r sd n ee d n ny f h x r ie f u h u idcin
co rswiht r quie nt o duepr e s Se j a 3010
mpo t t he e rme s f
oc s . e . t -2.
i
TheDuePr es Cl us r quiest tade e ntha a qua eC i m tm c ac s' t
oc s a e e r ha
f nda
ve de t t ni l ont t'wih
m

t fnl sae. SeeALSSc n.nc v. gialSev. ula t.nc.293F. 707,711( hCi.
he o m tt
a I . Di t r Cons tns l ,
3d
4t r

2 0 )( ingI tlS o Co. W ahimo , 2 U. 31 , 6( 9 5 ) De n i o tetp o
0 2 ct n ' h e v. s n n 3 6 S. 0 31 1 4 ). pe dng n h y e f
i
mii m c n a t i a c s ,pes n lj rs ito c n et e be g n r lo s ct Ge rl
n mu o tcs n a e ro a u id cin a i r
h
e e a r pe i
k. nea

pes n lmi dcinçe u rsGo tn o sa s se tc c n a t wi t f r m sae s ht a
ro a j s ito d q ie c n iu u nd y tmai' o tcs t he o u tt ,uc h t
r
h
a de e
f ndantm a be s d i t tsae f r a r a o r ga dls ofwhe e t r l ntc
y
ue n ha t t o ny e s n, e r e s
r he eeva onduc
t

o c re ' CFA I s. . ns. fCha tr d F n M ay t o I i, 51F.d28 ,2 2n.5( t
c u rd.'
'
nt v l to
re e i . l ss f nda 5
3 5 9 1 4h
Ci. 0 9 (iigPek n v. n u tCo s lM ii Co, 4 U. 4 7 4 8 (95 ). t p cfc
r 2 0 ) ctn r i s Be c e n o . nnc .3 2 S. 3 , 3 1 2 ) d e ii
s
p ro a j rs ito o te oh r h n ,rq ie o l t a te r lv n c n u th ve s h a
e s n l u id cin, n h te a d e u rs ny h t h ee a t o d c a uc
coz e ton w ih t f m s a e t ti i f i f t de e ntt de e is l i t ts a e. I
m ci
t he onl t t ha t s a r or he f nda o f nd t e f n ha t t ' d.
'

(ii Heioptr Na inae deColmbi S. v. l46U. 408,41 1 ( 4:. I ohe
ctng lc e os co ls
o as A. Hal,
S.
4- 5 198
nt r

wo d ,tift ed fn a tsc ntcswi t e go u sae a eas t eb sso te s i,t s
r s sj h e e d n ' o a t t h fr m tt) r lo h a i f h ut ho e
l
h
c na t ma e tbl hs cfcj rs ito ' ALS Sc n 2 3F.da 71 .
o tcs y sa i pe ii u idcin.
s
'
a, 9 3 t 1

I t i t ntc s ,t pl i ifha no al geda f t s
n he nsa a e he antf s t le
ny acs ugge tng t tt Tulr Co y
si ha he a e unt
She ifs de y o t Bo W ie De e to Ce e ha e age i s t ma i a co i
rf
put r he b l y t n i n ntr s ng d n yse tc nd ntnuous
a tviy i Vigi a. Nor has he alege a f c s s
c i t n r ni
l d ny a t uggesi t thi c am s a e ba e upon
tng ha s l i r s d
c a t t tt s Ca ior ar sde sha ha wih t f r m sa e l e Al r do doe no
ont c s ha he e lf ni e i nt ve d t he o u t t . nde d, va a
s t
de c i a hi t ta i vi lo e iy i Ca ior a hasdone i V igi a t ts d ha
s rbe nyt ng ha ny ndi dua r ntt n lf ni
n r ni ha houl ve

c us d t ti vi ua ore tt t a tci t beng s dhe e. Be a ei i a r ntfo t f c
a e ha ndi d l n iy o n i pa e i ue r
c us t s ppa e r m he a e

o t c mp an ta p ro a ju s ito i lc n a d t ee i n r a o t b le et a a y
f he o lit h t es n l tid cin s a kig n h r s o e s n o eiv h t n
de e ntwoul wavet sba i f dim is l t c ttndsi a opra et dim ist ca e
f nda
d i hi ss or s s a, he our i
t ppr i t o s s he s

wih u p eu ie Se Trjl v W iln , 65F.d 1 0,1 6 1 ( 0h Ci.2 0 )( od n
to t rj dc . e uil . lims 4 3 21 21 - 7 1 t r 0 6 h li g
o
t tadititc tma s s edimisa a tonunde 28U. C.j1 5f l kofpe s l
ha src our y ua pont s s n ci
r
V.
91 or ac
rona

jzid cin S e t d fn ei o vo sfo tef c o t ec mpan a no frh rf cu l
l s ito s n he e e s s b iu r m h a e f h o li t nd u te a ta
r
wh
rc r i rq ie t b d veo e ' (iain a d itr lq oain mak o te ) se as
e od s e ur d o e e lp d' ctto n nena u tto r s mitd ; e lo
)
.

M ai v. Pao He lh aeCt.6 6F. p x58 ,5 8( dCi. 6 ( li t a tec s
rn La lma at c r r, 3 Ap ' 6 8 3 r 201 ) hodng h t h a e
wa p o el ds se fr lc o pes na j rs ito t e j 1 5 wh r She lc o a
s r p ry imisd o a k f ro l u idcin md r 91 ee G a k f
t
c r cin b t e t e Dee d n s a d Pems v n a g s a p rn fo t fc o t e
ome to ewe n h
fn a t n r yla i wa j p a e t r m he a e f h
c ai
ompl nf).
C oncl i
us on

Fo t era o sae ,tec s wi b ds se wi u p eudc frlc o p ro a
r h e s ns ttd h a e l e imis d t t rj ie o a k f e s n l
l
ho
j rs ito Al oh rp n i moinswilb d ne a mo t Th Clr i d rce t s n
uidcin. l t e e dng to l e e id s o . e ek s ie td o e d
co e oft sm e a
pis hi mor ndum opi o a t ac ompa ng or rt t pli if
ni n nd he c
nyi
de o he a ntf.

DATED: i J# ë d yo J y 20 7
Ths
a f ul, 1 .
U nie St t s Di t i tJ
t d a e s rc udge