Brown v. Pompeo et al

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 8/16/2017. (jat)

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN D I
STW CT O F V I I A
RG NI
CHARLOTTESVI
LLE DI SI
VI ON

CL
ERZS OFFI U..DI O URT
CE S ST.
ATRG NOKE,
VA
FIED
L

AI 16 2 1
J
C
27
UD

BK

EP
.

,
CLERK
LERK

HAM I
LTON BROW N,AS E EXT
W
FRI
END'FOR THE ESTATE OF
'
ALLI
SON PARKER,
Ci lAci n No. 1
vi to
3: 70V00057
Pl i i f
a ntf ,
M EM O R AN DU M O PI I N
N O

M I E PoM pE0 , lt roR oF
K
D l scr
CEN TRAL I
NTELLI
GAN CE AGENCY,
e a.
t l,

H o Gl n E.
n. e
Com'
ad
Unied St t sDititJ
t
a e src udge

D e e nt
f nda s.

Fr de k Ba , a f der l pr til dea ne c r nty i a c r t d a N o t a t Ohi
e dc
nks
e a e ra ti e ur e l nc r e a e t rhe s
o
Co r c i lCe e i Yot t
r e tona nt r n mgsown,Ohi c
o, omm e ed t saci by flng as l- t e K oto
nc hi ton
ii
ef syl d i i n
m
ton o oc d n o ma upe i.
t dic os FI elc r c s v ilnc ,' al wih a m o i t pr ee i f r pa rs
o s l e SA e toni ur e la e'1 ong t
Bn
nks sgned t m o i ns o be l of G-n it Br
i
he to n haf
sl m lon own. Bn i i a e t t Br wn i
l
'
' nks nd c t s ha o
s

p o e dn a t G e tâin ' o t e t tt o Al s n Pak r' t ç lc e s d Ro n key
r c e i g s he t x e d' f h s ae f l o r e, he t e q a e a o gj
n
Es
i
'
d
'
ee n de r tng ke m o he r c or f
Vigi aTeevii N e Re tr' H e s ks a or rdiec i M i Po pe , t Die t o
r ni l son ws pore .2

t Cè r ll e lge e Age y,a o he f de alage i s a of i s t pr e c e of
he nta nt li nc
nc nd t r e r
nc e nd fcal o oduc opi s
FI ma e i l r l td t pur re s v il nc o Pake a Ve t r Fl nag n,t i vi l
SA t ras e ae o po td ur e la e f r r nd se a a he ndi dua
r s nsbl f rPa ke ' de t Fort f l ng r as ,t c tc l
e po i e o r rs a h.
he olowi e ons he our oncudest tt a ton i
ha he c i s

s b e t ods sa t e 2 U. C. 1 5 g .
u j c t imis lmd r 8 S. j 91 ( )
'CFI ' ef st t For gt l eli nceSur eilnc Act 5 U. C.â1 01 . s g
S SA'r er o he ei l nt lge
v la e , 0 S.
8 ,1 e .
t

2Thec u ttk s udca n tc ta t c re t peln o Pake ' frtn mei ç ls no r a e j iil oie h the or c s l g f r rs is a s s io '
i
A
'

Se to l 5 g i c mmo yrfn'dt a t Sh e -tie nle' Ther l p o i t a
ci n 91 () s o nl e e e o s he d re srk s l.
t
'
u e r hbi
s
prs r fom pr e di i f ma pa rs r wihoutpr pa e t o t slng f e K f t
ione r
oc e ng n or
upe i ,o t
e ym n f he i e , t he
i
prs rhas on 3 o m or proroc sons whiei a ce a e orde ane i a f iiy,br
ione
,
r e i
ca i , l nc r r t d
t i d n ny aclt ought
mla ton o a ali a c toft Uzied St t st twasdim is d on t gr
c i r ppe n our
he lt
a e ha
s se
he oundst ti i
ha t s
fi o ,malc o , f ist saeac am upo wiih r le m a begr nt d,lnl s t pds r
rvol us
ii us or a l o tt l i
n lc ei f y
a e l e s he one

i u d ri n n d n e o s ro sp ysc lij r ' 2 U. C.j 1 5 g . P era d tie s
s n e mmie t a g r f eiu h ia nu y. 8 S.
'
91 ( ) r til ean e
aec n i ee ç rs nes'o p r s so t etr esrk sr l. S e2 U. C. 1 5 h .
r o sd rd ' io r'f r u po e f h h e -tie ue e 8 S. j 91 ( )
p
A r viw ofc tr co dsr ve l t tBa ,eihe o hi own be l o on be l o hi
e e
our e r e a s ha nks t r n s
haf r
haf f s
alas S-n lon Br w'ha tld ml r usa tonsora
i , çl mit
l
om ' s se me o c i
ppeas whie i a c a e orde aned,
l, l nc r er t d
ti
whih ha be n dim is a fi ous ormalci o f rf ii t sa e a c am upon whih
c ve e s s ed s rvol
i ous r o alng o tt
li
c
r le ma begr nt
e if y
a ed. Se Ba v. na No.1 6981 2017U . App.LEXI 11 6,a *1
e nks Hor k,
6,
S.
S 41 t 9

& n. (t Ci. a 9 2 7 (iigp irc s sfldb Ba ksa c n l dngt t wa b re
3 4h r M y , 01 ) ctn ro a e ie y n nd o cu i ha he s ar d
9o p o e dn i fr p u ei o a pe l yo rto o t etr esdke r ll seas Bn ks
m r c e ig n oma a p rs n p a b peain f h h e -t s ue; e lo n

v.Co a ,No 1 - - 7 ,2 1 U. Dit LEXI 1 0 1 a * ( . Pa Au 4 2 7
c s . 7 mc6 3 0 7 S. s.
S 23 8 , t 4 W D. . g. , 01 )
(etrtngt tr o at x to sLiia t d r' ie tn t eClr sOfi ef rteW etr
rie ai he e ms f d ai u tg n Or e'dr cig h ek' tc o h sen
ve
Ditito Pe yl ni Gno t ac e a / doc t...a a ia i f l a t pr e i
src f nns va a G t o c pt nd or ke
ny pplc ton or e ve o oc ed n

f r pa pei, o litpeiin o oh rfln b Plitf Fr d rc Bn k jo h sb h l (r
o ma u rs c mp an , t o , r t e iig y anif e eik n s n i e af o
t
o be afo Plitf aist mi o Br wn l u ls c ran c n iin a eme) Br wn v
n h l f anifs l Hn l n o '' n e s e ti o dto s r t; o .
a
t
'
Vas k ,No.1 - 4 9,2 6 U. Dit LEXI 47 5 a * & n 1 ( . Pa Jn.1 ,2 6
lu a
5 1 3 01 S. s.
S 3, t 2
. W D. . a 4 01 )
( imisn al cinsldb ç- mi o Br wn' u s a t ot etr e srk sr l a n tn t a
d s sig ra to e y tl l n o 'p ru n t h h e -ti e ue nd o ig h t
ln t
tç mitnBr
çHa lo own'i a ai f Frderc Bn '
s n las or e ik nks).

2

Be a e Ba ha i ure muli e t ti s'a t r i no i c to t the f ce
c us nks s nc r d
tpl s rke ' nd he e s
s
ndi ai n ha
a s
i i ntdange ofs rousphysca ha hei notelgi et pr e wiho pr pa e oft
mm ne
r ei
i l nn, s
i bl o oce d t ut e ym nt he

fl fe Se 28U. C. 1 5 g . Ac od n l, n s moin t pr c e i f r pa p rs
ii e . e
ng
S. j 91 () c r i gy Ba k ' to o o e d n o ma u ei

wil d ne a dt i a to wil eds s e wih u p eu iept s n t j1 5 g .
lbe e id n hs cin l b imis d t o t rj dc l ua t o 91 ()
r
TheClr i die t d t s nd c e oft sm e o a
e k s r c e o e opi s hi m r ndum opi on a a co pa ngor r
ni nd c m nyi
de
t t pli if
o he antf .

DATED : s t N d yo Au ut201 .
Thi Y a f g s, 7

U nied St t D i t i tJ
t
a es sr c udge