Carnell Construction Corporation v. Danville Redevelopment & Housing Authority, et al

Filing 262

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/27/2011. (mlh)

'JFRK:OFFI U, . s7 JLUFI
CE S Dl ' I 4'
.
AT ROANOKE,
VA
'
*
j ?
.

F,D XZZ/
YE g Z -Z
z

SX

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI I I
CT
RG N A
D AN VI
LLE D I I ON
V SI

J 27 22 1
UN
1
BJ I c. %'cuf
YULA pu
i
ax

; D P Cj x.
E .E yt
L
z

CA RN ELL CON STRU CTI
ON
CO RPOM TI ,
ON

Pli tf /Co e c am De e
a n if unt r l i
f ndan ,
t
V.

Ci lA c i N o. 1
vi ton
4: 0CV 00007
DA NV I
LLE REDEVELOPM EN T &
HOUSI AUTHOI
NG
UTY,

Def nda /Countr a m Pl i if
e nt
e cli antf,

M EM O M N DU M O PI I N
N O

By: n.Gl E.
Ho
en Conr d
a
Chi Unie St t sDititJ
ef t d a e src udge

BLAI SQUARE,LLC,
NE
Def nda /Coun e cl i Pl i if
e nt
t r a m a ntf ,
V.

I
NTERN A TI A L FI ELI
ON
D
TY
m SUM NCE COM PANY,

Coun e cli De e nt
t r a m f nda .

F lwigaj r v r iti fv ro Cnn l Co sr cinCo p rto (Ca'el)o is
ol n u y edc n a o f r el n tu to r o ain I 1 1' n t
o
< n '
cam o rc ds rmiainu d rTil V1o teCii RihsAc,h til u g g a tdte
li f a e ici n to n e t
e f h v l g t tte ra j d e rne h
d fn a t' t nf rn w til n ta se t ematrt t u d rin dd src j d e Th
ee d n s moi o e ra a d rn fnrd h te o he n esg e itit u g . e
o
c s i p e e tyb f r t c u t nCan l' moinf re tyo j d me t Itr ain l
a e s rs n l eo e he o r o r els to o n. f u g n ;n en to a
r
F d l yls rn eCo a y' moinf re tyo j d me t a dCan l' moin frla et
i ei n u a c mp n s t o nr f u g n ; n r els to o e v o
t
o
fl a t r a e ed c pl nt Fort r as t tf l , he c t ilde t m o i nsf
ie hid m nd om ai .
he e ons ha olow t our w l ny he t o or

e tyo j d me ta dg a t h mo infrla et fl at ida n e c mplit
nr f u g n n rn t e to o e v o ie hr me d d o an .

B ac ound
kgr

l M ac o 2 0 ,h Da vleRe e lp n & Ho sn Au h rt (t I ' s lctd
n rh f 0 8 te n il d veo me t
u ig t o i t A' oiie
y DRl )
bi f t st pr pa ai wor r quie t deveop Pha e 4oft Bl neSqua eHo VI
ds or he ie e r ton k e r d o
l
s
he ai
r pe

P oe ti Da v l , r i a Can l ami o i wn d st p e aaina dc nsr cinfr
rj c n n il Vigni. r el n rt
e
s
po e i r p rto n o tu to im,
e
s
ubmit t l s bi DI I a e e Canel' bi a on M a 27,20 DRHA a
ted he owe t d. U'A cc ptd r ls d, nd
y
08,
nd
Ca nel e e e it aco r c f rt st pr pa ai n wo k.
r l nt r d n o
nta t o he ie e r to
r
Sho ty a tre c i t c ta t DRHA as i d isi e e ti t co r c t Bli
rl fe xe utng he on r c ,
sgne t nt r s n he nta t o a ne

Sq ae LLC (Bli S u r', u DRHA c niu dt ma a et ep oe t I en to a
u r,
t ane q a e) b t
t
o t e o n g h rj c. ntr ain l
n
F d lt I u a c Co a yCi 1 'is e ap ro ma c bmdt Can l, n t rb a tda
i eiy ns rn e mp n I C' su d ef r n e c o r ela d hee y ce s
F )
Ca nel' s e y.
r ls ur t

Astec n tu to p oe tp o r se , r elsc t e c e e e pe tto a dt
h o sr cin rj c r ge s d Cnn l' oss x e d d x cains n he
pa te e ot e e nlme ousde a .Ca nela DRHA ac us d e ch o he ofbr a hi t
ri s nc mt r d z r
l ys r l nd
c e a t r
e c ng he
c r c a Ca ne la c edDRHA ofr c d s rmi ton.Alhough Ca ne la DRHA a ee
onta t nd r l c us
a e ic i na i
t
r l nd
gr d
t en e i o mediton, he we euna et r s vet i d fe e es
o t r nt
ai t y r
bl o e ol her if r nc .

OnM a 1 , 0 9 DRHA d rce Can lt so wo kn o tep o e t DRHA
y 420,
ie td r el o tp r ig n h rj c.
rj ce s b e u n iv ie fo Can l a dulmaeyd cae ac nrco d fu t n e t
ee td u s q e t n oc s r m r el n t t l e lr d o ta t r ea l u d r he
i
pe f ma bond.
ror nce

Ca ne lc
r l omm e edt i tnta ton a i tDRI A onFe u r 1 201 as e tnga
nc he nsa c i gans
I
br a y 7, 0, s ri

cai o r edici nai t r42U. C.j1 a as e ntlcam ofbra h of
l m f ac srmi ton mde
S. 983 nd upplme a li
ec
c r t The f l i da Ca ne lfl d a a e ed com pl i ,i w hi h i s bs iut d a c a m
ontac .
olow ng y, r l e n m nd
a nt n
c t u tt e
li

ofr c dsrmi tonl rTil VIo t Ci lRiht Ac of1 42U. C.j2000d,i plc
a e ic i nai mde te f he vi g s t 964,
S.
n ae
oft j1 cam a sre i t orgi lco ant
he 983 li se td n he i na mpli .
2

On Se e r1 201 Ca ne ls ughtl a t a nd isco pl nta s ondtm e The
pt mbe 6, 0, r l o
e ve o me t m ai
ec
i .

til u g g a tdt emoin, n Ca lfldissc n a n e c mplito Oco e 1 ,
ra j d e rne h t a d mel ie t e o d me d d o an n t b r 8
o
2010.Thes c a e d c
e ond m nde ompli a d Bli Squa e a ade e nta a s td a
ant dde ane
r s f nda nd s ere n
a ii lcli ofqua um m e ut
dd tona am
nt
r i.
Thede e nt ans r d ea h oft a e d c
f nda s we e c
he m nde ompl i sa fl d c e c am sa ns
ant nd ie ount r l i gai t
Ca nel f br c ofc r c .Addii ly,t de e n sa d I C a ac e c am
r l or ea h onta t
tonal he f nda t dde FI s ount r l i
de e nta as e td ac am u rt pe f ma bo
f nda nd s re l i nde he ror nce nd.

DRHA a dBlieS u r s b e u nl mo e f rs mmayj d me ta ans Can l,
n an q ae u s q e t v d o u r u g n g i t r el
y
a dDRHA a I C fldc o smoi n f rs
n
nd FI ie r s- to s o ummayj d me t OnJ n ay2 , 01 ,h til
r u g n . a u r 7 2 1 te ra

j g g a tdt d fn a t' t nwi r s e tt Can l' q nu meutcam, u d ne
ud e r ne he ee d ns moi t e p c o r els ua t m r i li b t e id
o h
t m oton wih r s c t Ca n lscai sofr edic i i ton a br a h ofco r c .
he i
t e pe t o r el' l m
ac s rm na i nd e c
nta t

Ad iinal t etilud ed ne l l smoinf rs mmayj d me ta dg a tdDRHA'
dto l h ra j g e id F C' to o u r u g n n rne
y,
S
cos- to f r a t l u r u g n o tep ro ma c b n cam.
r smoi n o p ri s mmayj d me t n h ef r n e o d li
a
Les t n amont be o etil Ca nelm o dt a ndisc
s ha
h f r ra , r l ve o me t ompli t a acli
ant o dd am

u d r4 U. C. 1 81 etilu g d nidtemo ino J n ay2 , 1 fn igta i
n e 2 S. j 9 .Th ra j d e e e h to n a u r 8 201 ,i dn h t t
c m e te iel t l t '
a t ntr y oo a e.
'

Thej ytilc
ur ra omme e onFe uay 7 2011
nc d
br l , .DurngtilCar l fld amotont
i ra, nel ie
i o
a e t compl ntt c o m t t e de p e e e a ti . Specfc ly, r ls
m nd he
ai o onf r o he vi nce r s nt d t ral
ii al Ca nel ought
t a acai ofr t la in unde Til V1ag ns DRF A, e on tilt si onypr de by a
o dd l m
e a ito
r te
ai t I bas d ra e tm
ovi d

me e o DRHA' Bo r o Co s in r.Thetilu g utmaeyd nidtemoin,
mb r f
S a d f mmiso es
ra j d e li tl e e h to
tndi t ti woul bedna o it 'gi nt l t eof(he c e,'oa acai of
i ng ha t d l pprprae,' ve he t ur t j as 't dd l m
i
pos
r alaton on t basi oft boar m em ber' t i ony.
et i i
he
s he
d
s estm

OnFe r ay1 , 0 1 t ej r rtr e av r it g i t U' i t ea u to
b u r 7 2 1 ,h u y eu n d ed c a ans DI I n h mo n f
A
$ 1 ,411 o terc dici n t ncam.Th j r as ft t a Ca n l,
3,683 .4 n h a e s rmiai li
o
e u y lo omd h t r elDRHA, n
ad
BlieS u r b e c e t ec n c, u t ej r ddn t wada yd ma e f rt s cams I
an q a e r a h d h o ka tb t h u y i o a r n a g s o ho e li . n
a di o ,h j r f u di fvo o I I o DRIA' c u trli a an t h b n
d t n t e u y o n n a r f F C n I S o necam g i s t e o d.
i

Afe tilDHA a dBlieS u r fldamoinf r u g n a amatrof1w o ,n
tr ra,
n an q ae ie
to o j d me t s te a r i
t at m a i m o i f ne ti l To s ppor t m o i t de e nt r i e t f l ng
he le tve, ton or w ra .
u
t he ton, he f nda s a s d he olowi

a g nt: 1 t tM ihae Sc e ,Canelsprsde a s es r hol r a Vi ntSc e ,
r ume s ( ) ha c l als r l' e i nt nd ol ha e de , nd nce als

Ca l' p oe t n g r p o ie fletsi n a til( )ta ted ma e a r e b te
mels rjc ma a e, r vd d as e t y t ra; 2 h t h a g s wad d y h
mo
j r ween t e o ea eu d rTieVl a dta e e i teda g sweerc vea l,h
u y r o r c v rbl n e t , n h t v n f h ma e r e o rbe t e
l

e i e c o s c d ma e wa i a misbea do ddn ts p r tev r it ( ) h t h j r
v d n e f u h a g s s n d sil n /r i o u po th e dc; 3 t a t e u y
wa i r p rys lce , i ti d a disr ce , ndt a t j r wa p io e b i r p r
s mp o el ee td manane , n n tu td a h the u y s os n d y mp o e
c mme t o p an ifsc u e; 4 ta t ej r ' v r it nteb e c o c n rc camswa
o n s f litf' o nsl ( ) h t h u y s ed c o h r a h f o ta t li
s
i o sse t a d( )ta e ie c rltdt M c rW o d Co s ligs o l h v b e
nc n itn ; n 5 h t vd n e eae o Guie o s n u t h ud a e e n
n
a it d.
dm te

Byme r n u o ii na od re trdM a 2 2 1 t tilu ed ne t
mo a d m pn o nd r e nee y , 01 ,he ra j dg e id he
d fnd ns moi nf r u g n a amatro lw a dg a tdt ermo inf rn w til Afe
ee a t' to o j d me t s te f a n rne h i to o e ra . tr
rv e n ter lv n e ie c ,h til u g f t t a M ih e a dVic n S ae p o i e
e iwig h ee a t vd n e te ra j d e omd h t c a l n n e t c ls r v d d
f let si
a s e tmony a ti l t tt de e a swe et ke b s prs when t f l et tm onywas
t ra ; ha he f nd nt r a n y ur ie
he a s esi

gv n; n ta, b e t h fletsi n ,h j r ' v r c mih h v b e d fee t
ie a d h ta s n t e as etmo y te u ys edit g t a e e n if rn .
S cfc ly t etil u g e haie ta éo n o tej r ' manl e o i uiywiht e
pe iial,h ra j d e mp sz d h t i l e f h u ys i i s f nq r t h
l
n
Cou tdurng t i de i r tons c e ne Ca nel' f t e a lt t obt i a bo ' a t t
r
i he r lbe a i
onc r d r ls u ur biiy o a n
nd,' nd ha

tll t j yha knownt tmuc i notalofCanel' prvi ( r ni De rme of
çif he ur d
ha
h,f l, r ls e ous Vigi a pa t nt
4

Trn p rain wok wa t o d d,ti l eyt j r wo l n t vea r e d ma e i te
a s o tto ) r s mb n e i s i l he u y ud o ha wad d n g s n h
k
a u tid d' ( re tdMe Op. t 2 Do k t . 9 .Ha igc n ld dt t n w til
mo n t i . Co rce m. a 2 ; c e No 21 ) vn o cu e ha a e ra
'

wa warn e o tebai o t fletsi n ,h tilu g d cie t a d e st eohe
s ra td n h ss f he as e tmo y t e ra j d e e l d o d r s h t r
n
a g nt r s dby t de e nt i s
r ume s aie
he f nda s n uppor oft rmoton f ne ti l
t hei
i or w ra .

Th c s wa s bs q e t ta serdt t t e sg e j d e a dan w s h d ln
e a e s u e u nl rn fre o he md rin d u g , n e c e u ig
y
or rwase e e o M a 1 2011 Purua t t tor r t ca ei s heduld t ber ti d on
de
nt r d n y 9,
. s nt o ha de , he s s c
e o ere
De mbe 5, 1,a t pa te ha un i Ocobe 21 2011t c
ce r 201 nd he ris ve tl t r ,
o ompl t a tona dic y.
ee ddii l s over
Asi caedabove t m a tri pr s nty be or t c ur o t m o i f e r of
ndi t
, he te s e e l f e he o t n he tons or nty

j d me tfldb Can la I a dCan l' mo infrla et fl atidn n e
u g n i y r el nd FC, n r els to o e v o i h r me d d
e
e
c pl nt Thec t d ahe i o t motonson J ne 20,2011
om ai .
our hel
arng n he i
u
.
D i si
scus on

M ot ons f Ent ofJudgm e
i
or
a
nt

Can l a dI C h v fldmoinsf re tyo j d me t ru n t Rue 5 ( )a d
r el n FI a e ie to o nr f u g n pu s a t o ls 4 b n
5 ( )o t F d rl e o CiiPr c d r .Ca ls e e tyo j d me ti isfvo o t e
8 d f he e ea Ruls f vl o e u e mel e ks nr f u g n n t a r n h
c e c am f rbr a h ofco r c tld byDRHA a Bli Sq r ,a I C s e e r of
ount r l i o e c
nta t ie
nd a ne ua e nd FI e ks nty

j d me t nisfv ro tepef r n eb n c u trli fldb DRHA.To s p o t t
u g n i t a o n h ro ma c o d o n ecam ie y
u p r is
moins tec u tr li d fn a t ag et a tetil u g g a td ane tils ll o te
to ,h o necam ee d n s r u h th ra j d e r ne
w ra oey n h
b ssta tejr wa p e e tdfletsi n t s p o t r elscam f rd ma e u d r
a i h t h u y s r sn e as e tmo y o u p r Can l' li o a g s n e
Til V1 a t a t etilud e so iin Cnn wa g a t . . n w tilo g ec u trli
te , nd h t h ra j g ' pn o t o y rns . a e ra n t o necam)
i
h
a ns I C'ort c mtr li a i tCa l (FI sBr a 5;Doc tNo. .
gai t FI ' he ot e cam gans mel. I C' . t
ke
225)

Ha igc r f l rve dt eo d rg a t gan w til n tetil u e s
vn a eul e iwe h r e rni
y
n e ra a d h ra j dg '
m e or ndum o ni t c ti una e t a e w ih t c t r a m de e nt . The or r
m a
pi on, he our s bl o gr e t he oun e cl i
f nda s
de

e e e on M a 2, 1wholy gr nt t de e nt 'moton f ane ti ,a t r i
ntr d
y 201
l a ed he f nda s
i or w ral nd he e s
not ng i t opi c oror rt tc n bei t r eed a lmii t cai soris t b
hi n he nim
de ha a
n e pr t s i tng he l m
s ues o e

rtid.W hi t etilud eso i o fc e e l ieyo ted fn a t' r u n t t
ere
l h ra j g ' pnin o us d xcusv l n h ee d n s ag me t ha
e
Ca e lsprma ywine s pr de f let si o t s
m l' i r t s es ovi d a s e tm ny o uppor Ca e lscai f da a s
t m l' l m or m ge

u e Til VI tetil u g s e iial a k o e g dt a t ed fn a t a v n e a dto a
nd r te ,h ra j d e p cfc ly c n wld e h t h ee d n s d a c d d i n l
i
g oundsf ane ti l s
r
or w ra , omeofwhih i ude ale d e r st tpe me t d al as c soft
c ncl d lge ror ha r a e 1 pe t
he

til n t e u y sv r it n al o rcams Ha n c n ld dt t ne til swarnt
ra a d h j r ' e dc o 1f u li . vig o cu e ha a w ra wa ra td
o t eb sso teflee i e c ,h til u g f t iu n c sayt a d e st atm ai
n h a i f h as v d n e te ra j d e omd t n e e sr o d r s he l t
e ve
a g e sas e t b t de e nt .
r um nt s red y he f nda s
Fort er s ,t c ti c nce t tt M ay2,2011or rgr nt ane ti l
hes ea ons he our s onvi d ha he
de a ed
w ra
on a1cli s Co eq nty,t c s wilber ti i ise iey.
1 am . ns ue l he a e l e red n t ntr t l
Il.

M n i For Le t Fie a Thi d Am e d Com pl nt
t on
ave o l
r
nde
ai

Ca e lha as fl amoton f rla t fl at r a
m l s lo ied
i o e ve o ie hid mende c
d ompli . Specfcal
ant
ii ly,

Ca l s e st a d: 1 acam o rc d srmiainu d r4 U. C. 1 81a an tDRFA
mel e k o d () li f a e ic i n to n e 2 S. j 9 g i s
I
a Bli eSq r ;2 acam o rc dsrmiainu d rTil VIa ans BlieS u r ; n
nd an uae () li f a e ic i n to n e te g i t an q ae a d
( )acam o rtlaina an tDRHA a dBlieS u r t e j 1 8 a dTil V1
3 li f eait g is
o
n an q ae md r 9 1 n te .
A snot d a
e bove,Ca ne lpr vi l r quesed l a t a e is c pl i t a t
r l e ousy e
t e ve o m nd t om a nt o dd he
pr
opos d c a m sofr t la i n a dicrm i i a ns D RF A . W he Ca ne lm ove t
e li
e a i to nd s i naton gai t
I
n r l
d o

1A le na i y, t c not t t r i aEgener pr umpton agai tpari new ti s'
t r tvel he ourt es hat he e s l
al es
i
ns tal
ral '

Elo kv. l Cor .233F. 73 75 ( dCi. 0 , n t tapa ta ne ti l ho dbegrntd
c c Kma' p,
t
3d 4, 8 3 r 20 0) a d ha
ril w ra s ul
ae

o l i to ec sst h r iiganta teerrwhc h sce tnoo eee n o tev rit i n t
ny n h s ae ç ee ts li h th ro ih a rp it n lme t fh edc dd o
w
i any wa afectt de e m i l ofany ot is ' 1 ,ordwher t i uest ber red ar s at
n
y f he t r naton
her s ue,' d. E e he ss o eti e epar e

fom t r s oft c s , Yo v. n ' Pa rCo.32 F. 8 ,8 ( t Ci.1 63 .Ap yi t s
r he e t he a e' unz l tl pe , 2 2d 20 22 4h r 9 ) pl ng he e
'
sandar ,t c i convi
t
ds he ourt s
nced t tapari new ti woul be i opera t tt cas m us be
ha
tal
ral
d mpr
nd ha he e t
r t ed i isentr t
eri n t ie y.

6

a n t c mp an i J n ayt a dacam o dsrmiainu d rj1 81 tetilu g
me d he o lit n a u r o d li f ic i n to n e 9 ,h ra j d e
de e t moto fndi t i c meentr yt lt Li wie when Ca nelmove dtrng
ni d he i n, i ng hat t a
iel oo ae. ke s ,
r l
d li

til oa dacam o rtlaina ar s l o c rantil e t n ,hetilu g fu dt ti
ra t d li f eaito s e ut f eti ra t si y t ra j d e o n ha t
mo
woul bei ppr it t pe mi t a ndm e a t tsa e oft ltg ton.Be us Ca ne l
d na opra e o r t he me
nt t ha t g
he ii a i
ca e r l
wa p e ousy de ed la t a e isc
s r vi l ni e ve o m nd t ompl i , her s uton oft i tntmoto r q r s
ant t e ol i
he nsa
i n e uie
c i r to ofRul 1 oft Fe r Rul ofCi lPr edu e a t i a oft ca e'
onsde ai n
e 5 he de al es
vi oc r nd he û w
l
he s '
doc rne.
ti

Rue 1 p o d st a la et a n ape dngs o l b çr el)gv ll. . e
l 5 r vie h t e v o me d la i h ud e t e ly ien . wh n
f
j tc s rq ie . Fe . Ci P. 5 a( ) AsteUntdS ae Co r o Ap e l f rte
usie o e ur s' d R. v. 1 ()2 . h i tt s u t f p as o h
'
e
F u t Cic i e plie i La e v. r e , 38F.d40 ( t Ci. 0 6 ,Eth slb rl ue
o rh ru t x an d n b r Ha v v 4 3 4 4h r 2 0 ) ç l i iea r l
l
gi e f tt t f de a polc i f vorofr ol ng c s son t i me isi t d ofdiposng
ves fec o he e r l i y n a
es vi a e
her rt nsea
s i
oft m ont c c ii s' La r 438F. a 426. Co e nty, heFou t Cic tha
he
e hnialte .' be ,
3d t
ns que l t
rh r ui s

In ep ee Rue 1 () op o ieta i a t a n ape dn s o l bed ne o ywh n
E tr rtd l 5a t r vd h t l ve o me d la ig h ud e id nl e
i
e

t ea n me t udb p eu iilot eo p sngp ry te eh sb e b df i o tepa t f
h me d n wo l e rj dca t h p o i a t,h r a e n a at n h r o
h
t emo igp ry o t a n me t udh v b e f tl. L.( u tn J h o v Or we t
h vn a t, r he me d n wo l a e e n ui ' d q o ig o ns n , o a
e' a
Fo d Co.7 5F.d 5 3 5 9( t Ci.1 8 :.Dea ao e wi u a c mp n igp eudc ,
o s , 8 2 0 , 0 4h r 9 6
ly ln , t t c o a yn rj ie
ho
ba f ih,o f iiy,i nota s f intb i t de amoton t a e J hns 785F. a
d at r ' lt s
ut
ufk e ass o ny
i o m nd. o on,
2d t
509 51
- 0.

Thelw oft c edoc rneii ar eofpr c ie bas d upon s
a
he as
ti ûs ul
a tc , e
ound polc t twhen a
iy ha
n
i s i o ltg t d a decde t ts ul bet e oft m a tr' Unied St t v. t
s ue s nce ii a e nd i d, ha ho d he nd he te .' t
aes Unied

SttsSmetngRei ng& M i ngCo.339U. 1 1 ( 950) Applcai oft docrne
ae
li
fni
ni
,
S. 86, 98 1 .
i ton he ti

va isde ndi on whe he t r lng a is wa r nde e by a a laeco tora he
re pe ng
t r he u i t s ue s e r d
n ppelt ur
not r

d src j d e Ast F u t Cic i h snoe ,
itit u g . he o rh rut a td
wh te r l g b o ed src j d eb c meb n i ga th 1w o t e
eh r ui s y n itit u g e o i dn s û e a f h
n
t
c s 'u o s bsq e tdsrc j d e i n tamatro rgd lg l ue b t
a e' p n u e u n itit u g s s o
te f ii e a r l, u
moeamatro p o e j d ca a miitainwhc c nv r wihte
r
te f r p r u iil d n srto ih a ay t h
crl tn e .I ma s mei sb prp rfraditit u g t te t
icl a c s t y o t
ms
me e o e o src j d e o r a
e r i rr lngs a bi ng,s m e i e not
a le u i
s ndi o tm s .

Hil BAS W ya d teCo , 6F.d2 7 2 0n. ( t Ci. 98 ) c r igy tedo tie
lv. F
n o t p.69 2 8 , 9 3 4h r 1 2 .Ac o dn l,h crn
i as l o ds rto . S t v Bomd ,8 3F. 1 9 ,1 0 (t Ci. 98 ) Th c u t y
s t e f icein' mih . t s 1 2d 2 9 3 4 4h r 1 7 . e o r ma
nz
'
e e cs isd s rto t d p r fo a oh r ud esn l gwheeo eo tef l wig
x r ie t ic ein o e a tr m n t e j g ' zi
n
r n f h ol n
o
e c pt n a p is ç 1 t frt e iinwa ce ryer n o s ( )a itr e igc a ei te
x e i s p le :t ) he is d cso s lal ro e u ; 2 n n ev nn h ng n h
o
(
lw h so c re ; 3 t ee d n eo rma di s bsa tal difrn ; 4 oh rc a e
a a c u r d ( ) h vie c n e n s u tn ily fee t ( ) t e h ng d
crumsa c se it o ()ama ie tn u tc wo l ohewier s l. M e d n al Na'
ic tn e xs; r 5
nf s ij sie u d t r s e ut' n e b l v. tl
'
Trn p. ft Bd.21 F.d46 4 9( t Ci. 0 0 ; e as Ko rdv K M a t p. 1 9
a s Saey , 3 3 4, 6 9h r 2 0 ) s e lo n a .
r Co , 9 6
U. DitLEXI 1 5 8 a * - 0( D. C. p.1 ,1 9 )( i g i lg to c a g d
S. s.
S 4 8 , t 9 1 E. N. Se t 2 9 6 fndn ,n ih f h n e
cru tn e ,h t ta se o d re tr db a o h rdsrc j d es ul n t ete tda
ic msa c s t a a rn fr r e ne e y n t e itit u g ho d o b rae s
bi ngunde t 1w oft c s docrne.
ndi
r he a
he a e ti )
Appl ngt f e ng prnc pls t co tfndst ti t sc s ,c nged cr um sa es
yi he or goi
i i e , he ur i ha n hi a e ha
ic t nc
exitwhih c eli f vorofnotte tng t orgi lr lngson Car l' motonsa bi ng,
s
c ouns n a
r a i he i na u i
nels i
s ndi
a whi h wa r ntgr ntng Ca ne lla t a
nd c
ra a i
r l e ve o mend isc
t ompl i .I i a r ntfom t r co d
ant t s ppa e r he e r
t tt prorr lngson Ca nel' m otonst am e wer ba e prm arl on t tm i oft
ha he i u i
r ls i o
nd
e s d i iy
he i ng he

m o i ns oneofwhih wasfl d l st n amont be o eti a oneofwhih wa br ug
to ,
c
ie es ha
h f r ral nd
c
s o ht
durng t i l N ow ,ofc s ,t posur oft c s i c i r bl dif r nt A ne t i lha
i ra .
our e he t e he a e s ons de a y fe e .
w ra s

be gr nt t dic r pe i hasbe e t nde by s ver lm o hs a t ca e i no
en a ed, he s ove y rod
en x e d
e a nt , nd he s s t
8

s he e t ber tid untlt e oft ye r
c dul d o e re
i he nd he a .Thus t prm a y c e st ryi t ti l
, he i r onc m mde l ng he ra

j d e sp e iusr ln saen ln e prs n, n tec u t st bet c n l d ta t e
u g ' rv o ui g r o o g r e e ta d h o r i ma l o o cu e h t h
dee d n swils fe u d ep eu iea ar s l o t ep o s da n me t.W hl p eu ie
fn a t l u fr n u rj dc s e ut f h rpo e me d n s ie rj d c
c n r ul whe eapr e a
a es t r
opos d mend e r i e a ne l lt r r quii a tona dico r
m nt a s s w ega heo y e rng ddii l s ve y,

th tb ssf rafn i go p eu iee sn ilya pl swheet ea n me ti o frds o t
ç a a i o id n f rj dc se tal p i
t
e
r h me d n s fee h rl
y
beor ordurngtil' J on,78 F. a 51 s eJ.( di t tt pli ifs dbe
fe
i ra. ohns
'
5 2d t 0; e .,hol ng ha he antf houl
I
J
g a e la t a anew ca eofa tononrma snc t Ccic tnce wilbequie
r ntd e ve o dd
us ci
e nd, i e he t lr umsa s l
l
t

dfee twi an w til ts i n n ).
ifrn t e ra no o mmi e f
h
I r c ng t sde ii t c tz c ni st tt ne cl msofdic i i ton a
n ea hi hi c son,he our e og ze ha he w ai
s rm na i nd
r t la i a i tBli Sq r mi htc e t ac lc ofi e e tt twoul r quieBl i
e a iton ga ns ane ua e g r a e onfit nt r s ha
d e r ane
Squa et obt i ne c
r o an w ouns l a t tt swoul i t n, e st t at r tonst t til
e , nd ha hi
d,n ur nec s ia e le a i o he ra
s he e and di c r de dlnes A s e phasze durng t he r ng o t i t n m otons t
c dul
s ove y a i .
m
i d i he a i n he ns a t i , he

c t l a e t s hedulng or ri ne s a y t a co moda et nee oft pa tes a
our wil m nd he c
i
de f ce s r o c m
t he ds he ri , nd

t ec u t sc n i c dt t u ha j sme t wil le it a yp tn il rj d c t Blie
h o r i o v n e ha s c du t ns lalv ae n oe ta p eu ie o an
Squar Ac or ngl t c t l pe mi Ca nelt fl a t r a e d co pli .
e. c di y, he our wil r t r l o ie hid m nde m a nt
Co l i
nc us on

Fo t ra o ssae t emoi n f re tyo j d me tfldb I C a dCan lwil e
r he e s n ttd,h to s o nr f u g n ie y FI n r el l b
de ed, Ca ne lsm o i n f l a t fl at r a nded c
ni and r l' to or e ve o ie hid me
ompl i wilbegr nt The
ant l
a ed.
Clr i dieced t s nd c rii copisoft sme a
e k s r t o e e tfed
e
hi mor ndum o ni a t a co pa ng
pi on nd he c m nyi
or rt a1 c
de o 1 ouns ofr c d.
el e or

ENTER: i 7- A da otl , 2 1
Ths 1 y -une 01 .

@
Chi fU nied St t D i ti tJ
e
t
a es sr c udge