Carnell Construction Corporation v. Danville Redevelopment & Housing Authority, et al

Filing 262

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 6/27/2011. (mlh)

Download PDF
'JFRK:OFFI U, . s7 JLUFI CE S Dl ' I 4' . AT ROANOKE, VA ' * j ? . F,D XZZ/ YE g Z -Z z SX I THE UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT CT FOR THE W ESTERN DI STRI OF VI I I CT RG N A D AN VI LLE D I I ON V SI J 27 22 1 UN 1 BJ I c. %'cuf YULA pu i ax ; D P Cj x. E .E yt L z CA RN ELL CON STRU CTI ON CO RPOM TI , ON Pli tf /Co e c am De e a n if unt r l i f ndan , t V. Ci lA c i N o. 1 vi ton 4: 0CV 00007 DA NV I LLE REDEVELOPM EN T & HOUSI AUTHOI NG UTY, Def nda /Countr a m Pl i if e nt e cli antf, M EM O M N DU M O PI I N N O By: n.Gl E. Ho en Conr d a Chi Unie St t sDititJ ef t d a e src udge BLAI SQUARE,LLC, NE Def nda /Coun e cl i Pl i if e nt t r a m a ntf , V. I NTERN A TI A L FI ELI ON D TY m SUM NCE COM PANY, Coun e cli De e nt t r a m f nda . F lwigaj r v r iti fv ro Cnn l Co sr cinCo p rto (Ca'el)o is ol n u y edc n a o f r el n tu to r o ain I 1 1' n t o < n ' cam o rc ds rmiainu d rTil V1o teCii RihsAc,h til u g g a tdte li f a e ici n to n e t e f h v l g t tte ra j d e rne h d fn a t' t nf rn w til n ta se t ematrt t u d rin dd src j d e Th ee d n s moi o e ra a d rn fnrd h te o he n esg e itit u g . e o c s i p e e tyb f r t c u t nCan l' moinf re tyo j d me t Itr ain l a e s rs n l eo e he o r o r els to o n. f u g n ;n en to a r F d l yls rn eCo a y' moinf re tyo j d me t a dCan l' moin frla et i ei n u a c mp n s t o nr f u g n ; n r els to o e v o t o fl a t r a e ed c pl nt Fort r as t tf l , he c t ilde t m o i nsf ie hid m nd om ai . he e ons ha olow t our w l ny he t o or e tyo j d me ta dg a t h mo infrla et fl at ida n e c mplit nr f u g n n rn t e to o e v o ie hr me d d o an . B ac ound kgr l M ac o 2 0 ,h Da vleRe e lp n & Ho sn Au h rt (t I ' s lctd n rh f 0 8 te n il d veo me t u ig t o i t A' oiie y DRl ) bi f t st pr pa ai wor r quie t deveop Pha e 4oft Bl neSqua eHo VI ds or he ie e r ton k e r d o l s he ai r pe P oe ti Da v l , r i a Can l ami o i wn d st p e aaina dc nsr cinfr rj c n n il Vigni. r el n rt e s po e i r p rto n o tu to im, e s ubmit t l s bi DI I a e e Canel' bi a on M a 27,20 DRHA a ted he owe t d. U'A cc ptd r ls d, nd y 08, nd Ca nel e e e it aco r c f rt st pr pa ai n wo k. r l nt r d n o nta t o he ie e r to r Sho ty a tre c i t c ta t DRHA as i d isi e e ti t co r c t Bli rl fe xe utng he on r c , sgne t nt r s n he nta t o a ne Sq ae LLC (Bli S u r', u DRHA c niu dt ma a et ep oe t I en to a u r, t ane q a e) b t t o t e o n g h rj c. ntr ain l n F d lt I u a c Co a yCi 1 'is e ap ro ma c bmdt Can l, n t rb a tda i eiy ns rn e mp n I C' su d ef r n e c o r ela d hee y ce s F ) Ca nel' s e y. r ls ur t Astec n tu to p oe tp o r se , r elsc t e c e e e pe tto a dt h o sr cin rj c r ge s d Cnn l' oss x e d d x cains n he pa te e ot e e nlme ousde a .Ca nela DRHA ac us d e ch o he ofbr a hi t ri s nc mt r d z r l ys r l nd c e a t r e c ng he c r c a Ca ne la c edDRHA ofr c d s rmi ton.Alhough Ca ne la DRHA a ee onta t nd r l c us a e ic i na i t r l nd gr d t en e i o mediton, he we euna et r s vet i d fe e es o t r nt ai t y r bl o e ol her if r nc . OnM a 1 , 0 9 DRHA d rce Can lt so wo kn o tep o e t DRHA y 420, ie td r el o tp r ig n h rj c. rj ce s b e u n iv ie fo Can l a dulmaeyd cae ac nrco d fu t n e t ee td u s q e t n oc s r m r el n t t l e lr d o ta t r ea l u d r he i pe f ma bond. ror nce Ca ne lc r l omm e edt i tnta ton a i tDRI A onFe u r 1 201 as e tnga nc he nsa c i gans I br a y 7, 0, s ri cai o r edici nai t r42U. C.j1 a as e ntlcam ofbra h of l m f ac srmi ton mde S. 983 nd upplme a li ec c r t The f l i da Ca ne lfl d a a e ed com pl i ,i w hi h i s bs iut d a c a m ontac . olow ng y, r l e n m nd a nt n c t u tt e li ofr c dsrmi tonl rTil VIo t Ci lRiht Ac of1 42U. C.j2000d,i plc a e ic i nai mde te f he vi g s t 964, S. n ae oft j1 cam a sre i t orgi lco ant he 983 li se td n he i na mpli . 2 On Se e r1 201 Ca ne ls ughtl a t a nd isco pl nta s ondtm e The pt mbe 6, 0, r l o e ve o me t m ai ec i . til u g g a tdt emoin, n Ca lfldissc n a n e c mplito Oco e 1 , ra j d e rne h t a d mel ie t e o d me d d o an n t b r 8 o 2010.Thes c a e d c e ond m nde ompli a d Bli Squa e a ade e nta a s td a ant dde ane r s f nda nd s ere n a ii lcli ofqua um m e ut dd tona am nt r i. Thede e nt ans r d ea h oft a e d c f nda s we e c he m nde ompl i sa fl d c e c am sa ns ant nd ie ount r l i gai t Ca nel f br c ofc r c .Addii ly,t de e n sa d I C a ac e c am r l or ea h onta t tonal he f nda t dde FI s ount r l i de e nta as e td ac am u rt pe f ma bo f nda nd s re l i nde he ror nce nd. DRHA a dBlieS u r s b e u nl mo e f rs mmayj d me ta ans Can l, n an q ae u s q e t v d o u r u g n g i t r el y a dDRHA a I C fldc o smoi n f rs n nd FI ie r s- to s o ummayj d me t OnJ n ay2 , 01 ,h til r u g n . a u r 7 2 1 te ra j g g a tdt d fn a t' t nwi r s e tt Can l' q nu meutcam, u d ne ud e r ne he ee d ns moi t e p c o r els ua t m r i li b t e id o h t m oton wih r s c t Ca n lscai sofr edic i i ton a br a h ofco r c . he i t e pe t o r el' l m ac s rm na i nd e c nta t Ad iinal t etilud ed ne l l smoinf rs mmayj d me ta dg a tdDRHA' dto l h ra j g e id F C' to o u r u g n n rne y, S cos- to f r a t l u r u g n o tep ro ma c b n cam. r smoi n o p ri s mmayj d me t n h ef r n e o d li a Les t n amont be o etil Ca nelm o dt a ndisc s ha h f r ra , r l ve o me t ompli t a acli ant o dd am u d r4 U. C. 1 81 etilu g d nidtemo ino J n ay2 , 1 fn igta i n e 2 S. j 9 .Th ra j d e e e h to n a u r 8 201 ,i dn h t t c m e te iel t l t ' a t ntr y oo a e. ' Thej ytilc ur ra omme e onFe uay 7 2011 nc d br l , .DurngtilCar l fld amotont i ra, nel ie i o a e t compl ntt c o m t t e de p e e e a ti . Specfc ly, r ls m nd he ai o onf r o he vi nce r s nt d t ral ii al Ca nel ought t a acai ofr t la in unde Til V1ag ns DRF A, e on tilt si onypr de by a o dd l m e a ito r te ai t I bas d ra e tm ovi d me e o DRHA' Bo r o Co s in r.Thetilu g utmaeyd nidtemoin, mb r f S a d f mmiso es ra j d e li tl e e h to tndi t ti woul bedna o it 'gi nt l t eof(he c e,'oa acai of i ng ha t d l pprprae,' ve he t ur t j as 't dd l m i pos r alaton on t basi oft boar m em ber' t i ony. et i i he s he d s estm OnFe r ay1 , 0 1 t ej r rtr e av r it g i t U' i t ea u to b u r 7 2 1 ,h u y eu n d ed c a ans DI I n h mo n f A $ 1 ,411 o terc dici n t ncam.Th j r as ft t a Ca n l, 3,683 .4 n h a e s rmiai li o e u y lo omd h t r elDRHA, n ad BlieS u r b e c e t ec n c, u t ej r ddn t wada yd ma e f rt s cams I an q a e r a h d h o ka tb t h u y i o a r n a g s o ho e li . n a di o ,h j r f u di fvo o I I o DRIA' c u trli a an t h b n d t n t e u y o n n a r f F C n I S o necam g i s t e o d. i Afe tilDHA a dBlieS u r fldamoinf r u g n a amatrof1w o ,n tr ra, n an q ae ie to o j d me t s te a r i t at m a i m o i f ne ti l To s ppor t m o i t de e nt r i e t f l ng he le tve, ton or w ra . u t he ton, he f nda s a s d he olowi a g nt: 1 t tM ihae Sc e ,Canelsprsde a s es r hol r a Vi ntSc e , r ume s ( ) ha c l als r l' e i nt nd ol ha e de , nd nce als Ca l' p oe t n g r p o ie fletsi n a til( )ta ted ma e a r e b te mels rjc ma a e, r vd d as e t y t ra; 2 h t h a g s wad d y h mo j r ween t e o ea eu d rTieVl a dta e e i teda g sweerc vea l,h u y r o r c v rbl n e t , n h t v n f h ma e r e o rbe t e l e i e c o s c d ma e wa i a misbea do ddn ts p r tev r it ( ) h t h j r v d n e f u h a g s s n d sil n /r i o u po th e dc; 3 t a t e u y wa i r p rys lce , i ti d a disr ce , ndt a t j r wa p io e b i r p r s mp o el ee td manane , n n tu td a h the u y s os n d y mp o e c mme t o p an ifsc u e; 4 ta t ej r ' v r it nteb e c o c n rc camswa o n s f litf' o nsl ( ) h t h u y s ed c o h r a h f o ta t li s i o sse t a d( )ta e ie c rltdt M c rW o d Co s ligs o l h v b e nc n itn ; n 5 h t vd n e eae o Guie o s n u t h ud a e e n n a it d. dm te Byme r n u o ii na od re trdM a 2 2 1 t tilu ed ne t mo a d m pn o nd r e nee y , 01 ,he ra j dg e id he d fnd ns moi nf r u g n a amatro lw a dg a tdt ermo inf rn w til Afe ee a t' to o j d me t s te f a n rne h i to o e ra . tr rv e n ter lv n e ie c ,h til u g f t t a M ih e a dVic n S ae p o i e e iwig h ee a t vd n e te ra j d e omd h t c a l n n e t c ls r v d d f let si a s e tmony a ti l t tt de e a swe et ke b s prs when t f l et tm onywas t ra ; ha he f nd nt r a n y ur ie he a s esi gv n; n ta, b e t h fletsi n ,h j r ' v r c mih h v b e d fee t ie a d h ta s n t e as etmo y te u ys edit g t a e e n if rn . S cfc ly t etil u g e haie ta éo n o tej r ' manl e o i uiywiht e pe iial,h ra j d e mp sz d h t i l e f h u ys i i s f nq r t h l n Cou tdurng t i de i r tons c e ne Ca nel' f t e a lt t obt i a bo ' a t t r i he r lbe a i onc r d r ls u ur biiy o a n nd,' nd ha tll t j yha knownt tmuc i notalofCanel' prvi ( r ni De rme of çif he ur d ha h,f l, r ls e ous Vigi a pa t nt 4 Trn p rain wok wa t o d d,ti l eyt j r wo l n t vea r e d ma e i te a s o tto ) r s mb n e i s i l he u y ud o ha wad d n g s n h k a u tid d' ( re tdMe Op. t 2 Do k t . 9 .Ha igc n ld dt t n w til mo n t i . Co rce m. a 2 ; c e No 21 ) vn o cu e ha a e ra ' wa warn e o tebai o t fletsi n ,h tilu g d cie t a d e st eohe s ra td n h ss f he as e tmo y t e ra j d e e l d o d r s h t r n a g nt r s dby t de e nt i s r ume s aie he f nda s n uppor oft rmoton f ne ti l t hei i or w ra . Th c s wa s bs q e t ta serdt t t e sg e j d e a dan w s h d ln e a e s u e u nl rn fre o he md rin d u g , n e c e u ig y or rwase e e o M a 1 2011 Purua t t tor r t ca ei s heduld t ber ti d on de nt r d n y 9, . s nt o ha de , he s s c e o ere De mbe 5, 1,a t pa te ha un i Ocobe 21 2011t c ce r 201 nd he ris ve tl t r , o ompl t a tona dic y. ee ddii l s over Asi caedabove t m a tri pr s nty be or t c ur o t m o i f e r of ndi t , he te s e e l f e he o t n he tons or nty j d me tfldb Can la I a dCan l' mo infrla et fl atidn n e u g n i y r el nd FC, n r els to o e v o i h r me d d e e c pl nt Thec t d ahe i o t motonson J ne 20,2011 om ai . our hel arng n he i u . D i si scus on M ot ons f Ent ofJudgm e i or a nt Can l a dI C h v fldmoinsf re tyo j d me t ru n t Rue 5 ( )a d r el n FI a e ie to o nr f u g n pu s a t o ls 4 b n 5 ( )o t F d rl e o CiiPr c d r .Ca ls e e tyo j d me ti isfvo o t e 8 d f he e ea Ruls f vl o e u e mel e ks nr f u g n n t a r n h c e c am f rbr a h ofco r c tld byDRHA a Bli Sq r ,a I C s e e r of ount r l i o e c nta t ie nd a ne ua e nd FI e ks nty j d me t nisfv ro tepef r n eb n c u trli fldb DRHA.To s p o t t u g n i t a o n h ro ma c o d o n ecam ie y u p r is moins tec u tr li d fn a t ag et a tetil u g g a td ane tils ll o te to ,h o necam ee d n s r u h th ra j d e r ne w ra oey n h b ssta tejr wa p e e tdfletsi n t s p o t r elscam f rd ma e u d r a i h t h u y s r sn e as e tmo y o u p r Can l' li o a g s n e Til V1 a t a t etilud e so iin Cnn wa g a t . . n w tilo g ec u trli te , nd h t h ra j g ' pn o t o y rns . a e ra n t o necam) i h a ns I C'ort c mtr li a i tCa l (FI sBr a 5;Doc tNo. . gai t FI ' he ot e cam gans mel. I C' . t ke 225) Ha igc r f l rve dt eo d rg a t gan w til n tetil u e s vn a eul e iwe h r e rni y n e ra a d h ra j dg ' m e or ndum o ni t c ti una e t a e w ih t c t r a m de e nt . The or r m a pi on, he our s bl o gr e t he oun e cl i f nda s de e e e on M a 2, 1wholy gr nt t de e nt 'moton f ane ti ,a t r i ntr d y 201 l a ed he f nda s i or w ral nd he e s not ng i t opi c oror rt tc n bei t r eed a lmii t cai soris t b hi n he nim de ha a n e pr t s i tng he l m s ues o e rtid.W hi t etilud eso i o fc e e l ieyo ted fn a t' r u n t t ere l h ra j g ' pnin o us d xcusv l n h ee d n s ag me t ha e Ca e lsprma ywine s pr de f let si o t s m l' i r t s es ovi d a s e tm ny o uppor Ca e lscai f da a s t m l' l m or m ge u e Til VI tetil u g s e iial a k o e g dt a t ed fn a t a v n e a dto a nd r te ,h ra j d e p cfc ly c n wld e h t h ee d n s d a c d d i n l i g oundsf ane ti l s r or w ra , omeofwhih i ude ale d e r st tpe me t d al as c soft c ncl d lge ror ha r a e 1 pe t he til n t e u y sv r it n al o rcams Ha n c n ld dt t ne til swarnt ra a d h j r ' e dc o 1f u li . vig o cu e ha a w ra wa ra td o t eb sso teflee i e c ,h til u g f t iu n c sayt a d e st atm ai n h a i f h as v d n e te ra j d e omd t n e e sr o d r s he l t e ve a g e sas e t b t de e nt . r um nt s red y he f nda s Fort er s ,t c ti c nce t tt M ay2,2011or rgr nt ane ti l hes ea ons he our s onvi d ha he de a ed w ra on a1cli s Co eq nty,t c s wilber ti i ise iey. 1 am . ns ue l he a e l e red n t ntr t l Il. M n i For Le t Fie a Thi d Am e d Com pl nt t on ave o l r nde ai Ca e lha as fl amoton f rla t fl at r a m l s lo ied i o e ve o ie hid mende c d ompli . Specfcal ant ii ly, Ca l s e st a d: 1 acam o rc d srmiainu d r4 U. C. 1 81a an tDRFA mel e k o d () li f a e ic i n to n e 2 S. j 9 g i s I a Bli eSq r ;2 acam o rc dsrmiainu d rTil VIa ans BlieS u r ; n nd an uae () li f a e ic i n to n e te g i t an q ae a d ( )acam o rtlaina an tDRHA a dBlieS u r t e j 1 8 a dTil V1 3 li f eait g is o n an q ae md r 9 1 n te . A snot d a e bove,Ca ne lpr vi l r quesed l a t a e is c pl i t a t r l e ousy e t e ve o m nd t om a nt o dd he pr opos d c a m sofr t la i n a dicrm i i a ns D RF A . W he Ca ne lm ove t e li e a i to nd s i naton gai t I n r l d o 1A le na i y, t c not t t r i aEgener pr umpton agai tpari new ti s' t r tvel he ourt es hat he e s l al es i ns tal ral ' Elo kv. l Cor .233F. 73 75 ( dCi. 0 , n t tapa ta ne ti l ho dbegrntd c c Kma' p, t 3d 4, 8 3 r 20 0) a d ha ril w ra s ul ae o l i to ec sst h r iiganta teerrwhc h sce tnoo eee n o tev rit i n t ny n h s ae ç ee ts li h th ro ih a rp it n lme t fh edc dd o w i any wa afectt de e m i l ofany ot is ' 1 ,ordwher t i uest ber red ar s at n y f he t r naton her s ue,' d. E e he ss o eti e epar e fom t r s oft c s , Yo v. n ' Pa rCo.32 F. 8 ,8 ( t Ci.1 63 .Ap yi t s r he e t he a e' unz l tl pe , 2 2d 20 22 4h r 9 ) pl ng he e ' sandar ,t c i convi t ds he ourt s nced t tapari new ti woul be i opera t tt cas m us be ha tal ral d mpr nd ha he e t r t ed i isentr t eri n t ie y. 6 a n t c mp an i J n ayt a dacam o dsrmiainu d rj1 81 tetilu g me d he o lit n a u r o d li f ic i n to n e 9 ,h ra j d e de e t moto fndi t i c meentr yt lt Li wie when Ca nelmove dtrng ni d he i n, i ng hat t a iel oo ae. ke s , r l d li til oa dacam o rtlaina ar s l o c rantil e t n ,hetilu g fu dt ti ra t d li f eaito s e ut f eti ra t si y t ra j d e o n ha t mo woul bei ppr it t pe mi t a ndm e a t tsa e oft ltg ton.Be us Ca ne l d na opra e o r t he me nt t ha t g he ii a i ca e r l wa p e ousy de ed la t a e isc s r vi l ni e ve o m nd t ompl i , her s uton oft i tntmoto r q r s ant t e ol i he nsa i n e uie c i r to ofRul 1 oft Fe r Rul ofCi lPr edu e a t i a oft ca e' onsde ai n e 5 he de al es vi oc r nd he û w l he s ' doc rne. ti Rue 1 p o d st a la et a n ape dngs o l b çr el)gv ll. . e l 5 r vie h t e v o me d la i h ud e t e ly ien . wh n f j tc s rq ie . Fe . Ci P. 5 a( ) AsteUntdS ae Co r o Ap e l f rte usie o e ur s' d R. v. 1 ()2 . h i tt s u t f p as o h ' e F u t Cic i e plie i La e v. r e , 38F.d40 ( t Ci. 0 6 ,Eth slb rl ue o rh ru t x an d n b r Ha v v 4 3 4 4h r 2 0 ) ç l i iea r l l gi e f tt t f de a polc i f vorofr ol ng c s son t i me isi t d ofdiposng ves fec o he e r l i y n a es vi a e her rt nsea s i oft m ont c c ii s' La r 438F. a 426. Co e nty, heFou t Cic tha he e hnialte .' be , 3d t ns que l t rh r ui s In ep ee Rue 1 () op o ieta i a t a n ape dn s o l bed ne o ywh n E tr rtd l 5a t r vd h t l ve o me d la ig h ud e id nl e i e t ea n me t udb p eu iilot eo p sngp ry te eh sb e b df i o tepa t f h me d n wo l e rj dca t h p o i a t,h r a e n a at n h r o h t emo igp ry o t a n me t udh v b e f tl. L.( u tn J h o v Or we t h vn a t, r he me d n wo l a e e n ui ' d q o ig o ns n , o a e' a Fo d Co.7 5F.d 5 3 5 9( t Ci.1 8 :.Dea ao e wi u a c mp n igp eudc , o s , 8 2 0 , 0 4h r 9 6 ly ln , t t c o a yn rj ie ho ba f ih,o f iiy,i nota s f intb i t de amoton t a e J hns 785F. a d at r ' lt s ut ufk e ass o ny i o m nd. o on, 2d t 509 51 - 0. Thelw oft c edoc rneii ar eofpr c ie bas d upon s a he as ti ûs ul a tc , e ound polc t twhen a iy ha n i s i o ltg t d a decde t ts ul bet e oft m a tr' Unied St t v. t s ue s nce ii a e nd i d, ha ho d he nd he te .' t aes Unied SttsSmetngRei ng& M i ngCo.339U. 1 1 ( 950) Applcai oft docrne ae li fni ni , S. 86, 98 1 . i ton he ti va isde ndi on whe he t r lng a is wa r nde e by a a laeco tora he re pe ng t r he u i t s ue s e r d n ppelt ur not r d src j d e Ast F u t Cic i h snoe , itit u g . he o rh rut a td wh te r l g b o ed src j d eb c meb n i ga th 1w o t e eh r ui s y n itit u g e o i dn s û e a f h n t c s 'u o s bsq e tdsrc j d e i n tamatro rgd lg l ue b t a e' p n u e u n itit u g s s o te f ii e a r l, u moeamatro p o e j d ca a miitainwhc c nv r wihte r te f r p r u iil d n srto ih a ay t h crl tn e .I ma s mei sb prp rfraditit u g t te t icl a c s t y o t ms me e o e o src j d e o r a e r i rr lngs a bi ng,s m e i e not a le u i s ndi o tm s . Hil BAS W ya d teCo , 6F.d2 7 2 0n. ( t Ci. 98 ) c r igy tedo tie lv. F n o t p.69 2 8 , 9 3 4h r 1 2 .Ac o dn l,h crn i as l o ds rto . S t v Bomd ,8 3F. 1 9 ,1 0 (t Ci. 98 ) Th c u t y s t e f icein' mih . t s 1 2d 2 9 3 4 4h r 1 7 . e o r ma nz ' e e cs isd s rto t d p r fo a oh r ud esn l gwheeo eo tef l wig x r ie t ic ein o e a tr m n t e j g ' zi n r n f h ol n o e c pt n a p is ç 1 t frt e iinwa ce ryer n o s ( )a itr e igc a ei te x e i s p le :t ) he is d cso s lal ro e u ; 2 n n ev nn h ng n h o ( lw h so c re ; 3 t ee d n eo rma di s bsa tal difrn ; 4 oh rc a e a a c u r d ( ) h vie c n e n s u tn ily fee t ( ) t e h ng d crumsa c se it o ()ama ie tn u tc wo l ohewier s l. M e d n al Na' ic tn e xs; r 5 nf s ij sie u d t r s e ut' n e b l v. tl ' Trn p. ft Bd.21 F.d46 4 9( t Ci. 0 0 ; e as Ko rdv K M a t p. 1 9 a s Saey , 3 3 4, 6 9h r 2 0 ) s e lo n a . r Co , 9 6 U. DitLEXI 1 5 8 a * - 0( D. C. p.1 ,1 9 )( i g i lg to c a g d S. s. S 4 8 , t 9 1 E. N. Se t 2 9 6 fndn ,n ih f h n e cru tn e ,h t ta se o d re tr db a o h rdsrc j d es ul n t ete tda ic msa c s t a a rn fr r e ne e y n t e itit u g ho d o b rae s bi ngunde t 1w oft c s docrne. ndi r he a he a e ti ) Appl ngt f e ng prnc pls t co tfndst ti t sc s ,c nged cr um sa es yi he or goi i i e , he ur i ha n hi a e ha ic t nc exitwhih c eli f vorofnotte tng t orgi lr lngson Car l' motonsa bi ng, s c ouns n a r a i he i na u i nels i s ndi a whi h wa r ntgr ntng Ca ne lla t a nd c ra a i r l e ve o mend isc t ompl i .I i a r ntfom t r co d ant t s ppa e r he e r t tt prorr lngson Ca nel' m otonst am e wer ba e prm arl on t tm i oft ha he i u i r ls i o nd e s d i iy he i ng he m o i ns oneofwhih wasfl d l st n amont be o eti a oneofwhih wa br ug to , c ie es ha h f r ral nd c s o ht durng t i l N ow ,ofc s ,t posur oft c s i c i r bl dif r nt A ne t i lha i ra . our e he t e he a e s ons de a y fe e . w ra s be gr nt t dic r pe i hasbe e t nde by s ver lm o hs a t ca e i no en a ed, he s ove y rod en x e d e a nt , nd he s s t 8 s he e t ber tid untlt e oft ye r c dul d o e re i he nd he a .Thus t prm a y c e st ryi t ti l , he i r onc m mde l ng he ra j d e sp e iusr ln saen ln e prs n, n tec u t st bet c n l d ta t e u g ' rv o ui g r o o g r e e ta d h o r i ma l o o cu e h t h dee d n swils fe u d ep eu iea ar s l o t ep o s da n me t.W hl p eu ie fn a t l u fr n u rj dc s e ut f h rpo e me d n s ie rj d c c n r ul whe eapr e a a es t r opos d mend e r i e a ne l lt r r quii a tona dico r m nt a s s w ega heo y e rng ddii l s ve y, th tb ssf rafn i go p eu iee sn ilya pl swheet ea n me ti o frds o t ç a a i o id n f rj dc se tal p i t e r h me d n s fee h rl y beor ordurngtil' J on,78 F. a 51 s eJ.( di t tt pli ifs dbe fe i ra. ohns ' 5 2d t 0; e .,hol ng ha he antf houl I J g a e la t a anew ca eofa tononrma snc t Ccic tnce wilbequie r ntd e ve o dd us ci e nd, i e he t lr umsa s l l t dfee twi an w til ts i n n ). ifrn t e ra no o mmi e f h I r c ng t sde ii t c tz c ni st tt ne cl msofdic i i ton a n ea hi hi c son,he our e og ze ha he w ai s rm na i nd r t la i a i tBli Sq r mi htc e t ac lc ofi e e tt twoul r quieBl i e a iton ga ns ane ua e g r a e onfit nt r s ha d e r ane Squa et obt i ne c r o an w ouns l a t tt swoul i t n, e st t at r tonst t til e , nd ha hi d,n ur nec s ia e le a i o he ra s he e and di c r de dlnes A s e phasze durng t he r ng o t i t n m otons t c dul s ove y a i . m i d i he a i n he ns a t i , he c t l a e t s hedulng or ri ne s a y t a co moda et nee oft pa tes a our wil m nd he c i de f ce s r o c m t he ds he ri , nd t ec u t sc n i c dt t u ha j sme t wil le it a yp tn il rj d c t Blie h o r i o v n e ha s c du t ns lalv ae n oe ta p eu ie o an Squar Ac or ngl t c t l pe mi Ca nelt fl a t r a e d co pli . e. c di y, he our wil r t r l o ie hid m nde m a nt Co l i nc us on Fo t ra o ssae t emoi n f re tyo j d me tfldb I C a dCan lwil e r he e s n ttd,h to s o nr f u g n ie y FI n r el l b de ed, Ca ne lsm o i n f l a t fl at r a nded c ni and r l' to or e ve o ie hid me ompl i wilbegr nt The ant l a ed. Clr i dieced t s nd c rii copisoft sme a e k s r t o e e tfed e hi mor ndum o ni a t a co pa ng pi on nd he c m nyi or rt a1 c de o 1 ouns ofr c d. el e or ENTER: i 7- A da otl , 2 1 Ths 1 y -une 01 . @ Chi fU nied St t D i ti tJ e t a es sr c udge

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?