Luther v. Wells Fargo Bank

Filing 45

ORDER ADOPTING 43 Report and Recommendations; GRANTING 32 Motion to Dismiss Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint; DENYING AS MOOT 16 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim; DENYING AS MOOT 23 Motion for Summary Judgment; DENYING A S MOOT 39 Motion for Leave to File Second Amended Complaint; DENYING AS MOOT 40 Motion for Extension of Time to Answer Defendant's Discovery Requests. Case is dismissed with prejudice and stricken from active docket of the Court. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 9/25/2012. (mlh)

eLERK: oFF) u. Dl = ur
ce :. am

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF VI
CT
RGI A
NI
DANVI
LLE DI SI N
VI O

AT-

sEF 5 2 1
22
.
A
A i ll c.

JAM E S T . TH ER ,
LU

'

Pl ntif
ai f ,

I
SONBURG VA

FIED
L

,

D

C i lA cton N o.4:
vi
i
11cv00057

V.

W ELL S FA R G O B AN K ,

By: M i hae F.Urbans
c l
ki
Uni e St esD i t c Judge
t d at
s ri t

D efendant.
ORDER

Thi c e w asr e r t t H onor bl Robe tS. l U nie St t M ag sr t
s as
ef r ed o he
a e
r Balou, t d a es
itae

J g , u s a tt 2 U. C. 6 6 b ( )B) f r r po e tn i so f c a dar c mme d d
ud e p ru n o 8 S. j 3 ( )1( , o p o s d i dng f a t n e o n e
diposton. A num be ofm otons a e c r l pe ng be or t c t Def nda fl a
s ii
r
i
r ur enty ndi
f e he our .
e nt ied

m oto t dimi st c pl nto Febr r 27,201 a pl i ifr ponde by flng amoton
i n o s s he om ai n
ua y
2 nd antf es
d
ii
i

frs mmayj dg n o M ac 1 , 01 .Byo i o a do d rd tdM a 1 , 01 ,h
o u r u me t n r h 4 2 2
pnin n r e ae y 0 2 2 te
M agita eJ
sr t udgegr nt d pli iflavet tl a a nde c
a e a ntf e
o ie n me d ompli , i ngLu he ha f ie
a nt fndi
t r d al d
t a l ge s f c e f t t s
o le uf i i nt ac s o uppo ta ca e ofa ton aga ns W e l Fa go,a s a e t f itr t
r
us
ci
i t ls r
nd t t d he a lle o
fl a a e d com pl i w ihi t tm e alote w oul r ul i a r c m enda i t tt
ie n m nde
a nt t n he i
l td
d es t n e om
ton ha he

c
ompli bedim is d.Lut rfl hi frta
ant
s se
he ied s is mende c pl nton M ay 24,201 De e nt
d om ai
2. f nda
r s nde by flng am oton t dimi st a nded c
e po d
ii
i o s s he me
ompl i on J 7, 2. Lut rfld a
ant une 201
he ie
rs
e pons de e ntf l a r pl bref a t M agit a e J
e, f nda ied e y i , nd he
s r t udge gr nt Lut rl ve t f l a
a ed he ea o ie
f rhe r pons t de e nt s r pl bre . l t tr pons ,Lut rm ove f r l a t f l a
' t r es
u
e o f nda ' e y i f n ha es
e
he
d o e ve o ie
s c n e d c pl i ,w hi h w a c t ue asa s par t m oton. The ea t r Lut rf l d
e ond m nde om a nt
c
s ons r d
e ae
i
r fe , he ie
a m o i f e e i oftm e t a w e de e nts di c r r ques s D i cove y w a s a d
ton or xt ns on i o ns r f nda ' s ove y e
t. s
r
s t ye
by or rda e J y 25,201
de t d ul
2.
On A ugus 6,201 t M a s r t J
t
2, he gi ta e udge i s d a r por and r com m e ton,
s ue
e t
e
nda i
r c m e ng t def nda ' m oton t di m i st fr ta e
e om ndi hat e nt s
i o s s he is m nded c pl ntbe gr nt a
om ai
a ed nd

RK -

ta Luhe ' mo inf rs mmayj d me t mo infrla t fl as c n a n e
h t t rs to o u r u g n , to o e ve o i e o d me d d
e
c
ompli ,a m oton f e e i oftm et ans rdefnda ' di c r r que t a lbe
ant nd
i or xt nson i o we e nts s ove y e ss 1

d n e a mo t Plitf ha fldo j cin t t erp r a dr c mme ai n i whc h
e id s o . an if s ie be to s o h e o t n e o nd to ,n ih e
a r t rieaet ale tonsrie i hi frta ndedc antrt rt nob e t
ppeas o etrt he lgai as d n s is me
ompli ahe ha j c

s e i l t a yp rinof h rpo t u s a t oF d rlRul o Cii Pr c d r 7 ( )2 .
p ct l o n o t
ka y
o t e e r p ru n t e ea e f v l o e u e 2 b ( )

Ne e tee s t c u t a c n i ee t o jcinsr ie b Luh ra dc rf l
v rh ls,he o r h s o sd rd he be to as d y te n aeu l
y
r vi wed t M agi ta e J
e e
he
s r t udge sr
' epor a w e last r l va por i oft doc a
t s l he e e nt tons he ket nd
co l s t tt M a s r t J
nc ude ha he gi t a e udge' r por i s t ntaly c r c . The c t he ef r a
s e t s ubs a i l or e t
our t r o e dopt
s
t r por a r c m enda i
he e t nd e om
ton.
I i ac or ngl O R D ERED and A D JUD G ED t tde enda ' m oton t dim i s
t s c di y
ha f
nt s
i o s s

Lut rsfrta ndedc ai ( .#32)i GRANTED,a t tdefndan ' motont
he ' is me
ompl nt Dkt
s
nd ha e ts i o

d s s t o iia c mplit( t# 1 ) Lu h rsmo inf rsl r j dg n ( c t#
imis he rgn l o an Dk . 6 , t e ' to o tmmay u me t Do ke
23,Lut rsmotonf la t fl as c n nde compl nt( .#39) a Luhe '
) he ' i or e ve o ie e ond me d
ai Dkt
, nd t rs
m o i f e e i oftm et a we de e ntsdic r r ques a ea1 DENI asm oot
ton or xtnson i o ns r f nda ' s ove y e t r 1
ED
.

( t#4 ) Thi mal ri h r b DI M I ED wih pr j c a di S CKEN fo t e
Dk . 0. s te s e e y S SS
t eudie n s TRI
rm h
a tve doc oft c t
ci
ket he our .
The C l r i di e t d t s nd a ce tfe c oft sOr rt pl ntf a t c
ek s rce o e
rii d opy hi de o ai i f nd o ouns of
el
r c d.
e or

En ee s p e r; , 01
trd: e tmbe
2 2

5 /* - 4/.
'
4mr
M i ha F.Ur ns
c el
ba ki
U nied St esD i ti J
t
at
sr ct udge