Weinerth v. Talley et al

Filing 126

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/20/2019. (mlh)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI (0URT
S
CE S. ST.7
AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UN I
N
TED STAT ES D I
STRICT COU RT
MAt 2 0 2 1
29
FO R TH E W E STERN D I RICT O F W RGI I
ST
N A
D AN W LLE D I SION
W
JUm C.
DODLR C ERK
BY;

.

'

AN GEM L.G .W EI E RT H ,
N

L

Pl ntfy
ai if

Ci lAc i N o.4: CVvi t on
17- 00067
By:H on.M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

M ARTI SW LLE CI
N
W
BO ARD ,

SCH O O L

ChifUnie SatsDit t udge
e
td t e sdc J

D ef
endant
.

M EM O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O

I t se o me a do pli fAn l L. W ene' r en rl )cnmst t
n hi mply nt c n, andf gea G. i th v i e tf' li ha
t
s w a r m ove f om he poston a prncpq ofM a éns leH i Schoola r s i d a
he s e
d r
r ii s i i l
r vil gh
nd ea sgne s
as it ntprncpa atM ari vil M i eSc
ss a
i i l
tns le ddl hoolbe us ofhe r c s x,a a ,i yi a
ca e
r a e, e nd ge n ol don

of teVI oft eCiiRiht Ac of1 6 rTil V1 ' , 2U. C. 20 0 x s g, nd t Age
Til I h v l g s t 9 4 te I' 4 S. j 0 e 1 e .a he
)

Dici na ni Empo me tAc of1 6 (I
srmi do n
ly n t 9 7 T
ADEA' 2 U.. j6 r .--Curnt
), 9 SC. 21 .tq. te l
tç
y
pe digbeo etec u tst Ma d vl CiySc ol ad' rs hool ad'modo f
n n fr h o r i he r nsie t ho Bo t s fc Bo t7
l
)
n or
sl r j g nt l t tmoto t eS ho l a d p e e ss tnta e i nc t t
lmma y ud me . n ha in, h c o Bo t r s nt ubsa il vde e ha
W e ne t wasr asi d fom t li s
i rh
e sgne r
he agh choolt t mi e s
o he ddl choolf l g tm at ,
or e ii e
nondic i i t y r s .
s rm na or ea ons Them a t rha be n 6ll bre ed,a t cour he r or
te s e ly i f nd he
t a d al
a gum e on M a c 11 201 Afe r vi w oft e ier cor t cour c ude t t i t
r
nt
t h , 9. t r e e
he ntr e d, he
t oncl s ha ,n he

f ceoft e denc ofnondic i i t ym odve adduc by t SchoolBoa d, ene t has
a
he vi
e
s rnlna or
s
ed he
r W i rh
whol f ie t pz s nte dences ûce t esa ih a ge nei s ofm ae lf cta t
l ald o e e vi
y
uf int o t bls
nui s ue
tda a s o
w het rt Sc
he he hoolBoa d' a s red r as f r s i ' g W ene t w e e apr extf
r s s e t e ons or ea spun
i rh r
et or

una u dici na n. s h,heSc ol r ' s
lwfl srmi do As uc t ho Boads ummayj g n moto i
r ud me t in s
G RAN TED a t sca e dinns e
nd hi s s is d.
1.

Thef lwi fcstk nfo t sl t j g n tc t aeet tu ip e ot
ol ng a t a e t m he l
o
mmay ud me t e o d t ihe nds utd
pt e e i t lghtm os f voz bl t W ei t t nonm ovi pa t .SeeAnde s v.
es nt d n he i
ta a e o
neth, he
ng t y
t on

Li ryLo y l . 7 U.. 4 2 5(9 6.
bet bb , nc 4 7 S 2 2, 5 1 8 )
t

.

W ene t l awhiefmaeo rt a of6 . en rhDe l!3 ECF No. 0 1 S e
i rh s
t e l ve he ge 0 W i e t c. ( ,
1 2- . h
ha ove 40 y r ofe re e a a t c za a i s r t i t Com m onwe lh of
s t
ea s xpe i nc s ea he nd dm nita or n he
at

Vigni. d a !6 W enet ha wo k dfrt MadnsieCiyPu i S hoosrf ho l
ti a I . t . i th s t e o he r vl t bl c l sc o
l
c
S se ' snc 2 5 whe s wa h t d t t a h i t es ho as p o r m a M atns il
y tm' i e 00 , n he s ie o e c n h c lr' r g a t ti vle
)

Mi l S hoo. d. t 7.
dde c lI a !
I 201 W e ne t wasa nt t t poston ofa ssa ptncpa atM q tns le
n 2, i r h
ppoi ed o he ii
s it nt i i l
ti vil

Hih S ho l I a ! 8 Att ttme Pn l He t rHe t ' wa t s pei e ç oft
g c o . d. t . ha i , mea ah f ah7 s he u lntnd nt he
)

S hoo S se a AjmuDio rf xo 'wa t prncpa Mft lihshoo.d a ! 8 9
c l ytm nd a
x n DL n' s he i i l heag c lL a t ! , .
l
Dio aba kmaeun rt a eof4 , d s r e a p i i l i e2 11 I a ! 4 9
x n, lc l de he g
0 ha e v d s rncpa snc 0 . d. t ! , .
A c di t W ene t sal tons a t Hm e s sare a t li s hool t
cor ng o i r h' lega i , t he
he t t d t he lgh c
, he

s ude st t w e e f li be nd a demi al a s i poory on t sa e' St nda dsof
t nt he e r alng hi ca
c ly nd corng
l
he tt s a t

Lerl r< )tssI a !1 Onmo et no o c so W ene' v c dc nc r t
arng SOL' et.d.t 0.
i
r ha ne c ain, i th oie o ens o
t
Dionr g rl t s nt' e l i a a mi pe f ma c .-aa ! 1 . x n di not
x e a cng he mde s d ci ng c de c ror n e J t ( 1 Di o d
i
n
d

r s nd fvo a y t W ene t ' s g s nsa i tl td he t f c of. l ( ena
e po a t bl o i rhs ug e éo nd nsrl e r o f k f' d.i r l
c
ba
' nt
qu a n makso nitd . hih s ho utmaeyl t t G l a c e t d r én fo t
otdo t z te )The g c ol li tl os is al c r di on a g r m he
a
s at
t e.

2

A tt c l i of201
he oncuson
2-2013 s hoolye r H ea h com pl ed a f rnc palSlm m a
c
a,
t
et
T i i
l éve
Pe f a Repor' f Di
r o= nce
t' or xon,i w hi s r t D i spe f m anceasf nac e a e'
n ch he a ed xon' r ot
r
u c pt bl '
i t f l ng sx c t gotes i tuc
n he olowi i a e i : nst dona l de slp,s
l ea t li choolci at , h:m an tesom ces
lm e x
m a ge ent ot niadoga m a m e ,pt esi ls ,a s denta ade i pr es .
na m , ga z
l nage nt of sonaim nd m
c nac ogt s
Pl' Ex. ,ECF N o.102- a 3 0.Hea h not d, q ong ot tdef encis t tD i
.
s
D
4, t -1
t
e m
he
ki e , ha xon

d mo tae tgq te i c nsse ce i mod l gmut a r s c,c c r a e t y
e nsrt d çex r me n o itn is n
ei
n
u l e pe t on en, nd mpah
f s de s pa e s a s a f' t hedi fnoti piean e r
or m nt, t nt, nd t f'; hat
d d ns r
nvionm e oft s ';t thewas
nt ru t' ha

fgn o it n i a d e sn st e a sa fc si ln ' a t thedd no a e aey
fl c nsse t n d t si g tz nt nd tf l cpi e' nd ha
i
d
i
;
i t d qu t l
T a f ri c e s d s e ta a e cp og e s' J a 4 9 He t r c
f nq o n r a e md n c d mi r r s . d, t , . ah e omme d t a t
pl
:
nde h t he
Sc
hoolBoa d nott w D i sc r c f t posdon ofprnc pal I a 10.
r
ene
xon' onta t or he i
i i . d. t 1
Ther c d i ca e t tt Sc
e ot ndi t s ha he hoolBoa d f l
r olowed H ea h' z com m e ton.By
t je
nda i

lte dae u 1 , 01 , ah a v s dDi o t tl sc ta tf rt ep i i l i n
e tr tdl ne 1 2 3 He t d ie x n ha n on t c o h rncpa posdo
i
woul notber ne d byt Sc
d
e we
he hoolBoa df t 2013-201 s
r or he
4 choolyea .A a 2. was
r J t He
s e nty r as i d t an a ni s r dve posdon wihi t Sc
ubs que l e sgne o
dr nita
i
t n he hoolSysem ' c nta
t s e tl

of e W ene t De l! 1 .
hc . i rh c. 5
W ih t a ovaloft Sc
t he ppr
he hool:oa d,H e h pt ot W e ne t t t posdon of
r
at om ed i r h o he i

prn i lf rt 2 3 1 s ho y a . ah De l5 8 ECF N o. 0 - . ene t fc d
i cpa o he 01 -20 4 c ol e r He t c. ,
1 2 2 W i rh a e
s ve a c le supon a s i he ne posdon, ncudi m ot rgor SO L be hm a ks
e r l halnge
s um ng t w
i i l ng
e i ous
nc r

i s d b t sae sve ebu e c s a dicpi ay pr blm s W ene' D e l! 1 ;
mpo e y he tt, e r dg t ut, nd s iln t o e . i th c. ( 7
t
He t De l! 1 . enet manti t ts ema i he Tn si ' o a r s e c oft e e
ah c.( 1 W i rh i ans ha h de t r ' ison't dd e s a h h s
r

c l ng s W ene t De lj 1 .
hal e . i rh c. 8'
e

1Dr Ze d eTaly l.t p e e S rntn ntoft Ma d vteCiyPubi S h l tke is wih
. be e le yr,he r snt upei e de
he r ns ' t lc c oos a s sue f
l
l
.
t i f ctn rve 'q s igiso e d iya ce iit TalyAf.ECFNo. 0 - , t6
ls ç alng e im ' uedonn t bjc vt nd r dblp l f
a s i
i
e ,
1 08 a .
3

W ene t tli atl s r d a prncpa oft hi s hoolf t e ye r . Att
i rh zfm ey e ve s i i l he gh c
or hr e a s
he
concuson oft 2015
l i
he
-201 s
6 choolyea ,H ea h c m e
r
t om nded W ene t sT f t a
i r h' f or s nd
ef

a nc m e si i pr ng t s hool' a f
dva e nt n m ovi he c ,? nd f r t at d he on a e ng c i xng
cong a ul e r
ch vi ontnli

c ta tsa a aptncpa a of un 1 , 01 .2He t De l! 2 .
on r c tms s i i l s J e 5 2 6: ah c. ( 7
'
I i undiput t tsa di d t s s or i pt
ts
s ed ha t ndat ze e t c es m oved dutng W e neth' t nut as
i
i t se e
prnc pal Howe r t pa desdia ee a t whe herW e nerh efecdvel addr s d t
i i .
ve , he r
s gr s o
t
i t f
y
es e he

s hoolsdicpl ypt e s Alhough H e t sdeca a i i c t st tTsadentbe vi
c ' si i
nat oblm . t
a h' lt ton ndi a e ha ftz
ha oz

i o gl' ui W enet stn ea prncpa, ahDe . 2 ,heafda t pzsntd
mpzved'dv ng i rh' e ut s i i lHe t c ! 4 t fi vis ee e
by t Sc
he hoolBoa d pantaver dif z htpit r Se e .A f.ofK a e Sa r ECF N o.
t i
y f e e c u e. e . , f
r n wye ,

1 0 9 a ' (e cii g s e sa T o y a s wh to ofc ntol d igW ene t '
0 - , t1 d s rb n md nt s f wd nd ome a ut o t ' urn i rhs
r
;
tnu ea prncpa) Af. fGeadI dd ECF No 1 -2, t1(mp szn t tTthe e
e r s i i l; f o r l ti ,
. 00 1 a e ha ii g ha fj r
g
w e e a l j 46 r
r t ea t epor e fght be we n sade sdutng M r . epe t sf tyea as
t d i s t e tz nt i
s W i r h' us
r
.

p i i l' ndt ttstz nt we efe u p l n i ça s s i e t i ca s sc mpe ey
rncpa, a ha ' q de s r r q e ty ot n ls, kpp d het ls e o ltl,
'
la
orlf s hoo e ty).
e t c l al'
He t s de l r ee fo t Sc ol y tm o ul 1 , 0 6 W enet De l! 2 .
ah ud ny e d t m he ho S se nl y 4 2 1 . i rh c. 5

Twod y ltr onJ l 1 , 01 , . be eTalyl . Taly', ba kmae wa na d
a s ae, uy 6 2 6 DrZe de l ,r rt l ' a lc l, s me
e
e)
i e i s rnt nde .Taly had s r d a prncpa ofPa tck H e y El m e a ySc
nt zm upe i e nt le
e ve s i i l
ti
nr e nt r hool

r t kHe f)i teCiyof r sil sn el l 1 2 2.- Attet of l ys
Tadc nr n h t Mae vl ic uy , 01 J. h i
e
1
L
me Tal '
e

2Unde Vigilalm a publc s hoolplncpa ac r sfc i lng contac 't us'afe se vi a
r r ri a
i c
i i l quie fontnpi
r tsat ' t r r ng

pr bai aytt o t e y asi t t i n. . ej2 .- 4 Upo o nni c dnln c nta t
o t r e' f hr e e r n ha posdo Va Cod 2129 . n bti ng on l g o rc
on
m
i
sttz,at a rora nita orfc n onl bet m i e f good c us ' Echtnb m p v.Loudon Ct Pub.
a ts e che
dmi sr t fa
y er natd or
a e.'
e
p

Sc .26 F. u 2 1 4 ,1 4( D. . 0) seas Hi itv. h n nC . h. .4 3F. x
hs, 3 S pp. d 0 3 05 E. Va20 3; e lo bbts Buc a a
Sc Bd, 3 App'
2 , 06( hCi. 11 CA Vig''p lcsho lal nsmtrha apotce prpet rg ti he
03 2 4t r20 )
rml ubi c o cmiit o s r etd o ry ih t r
a
z
e o me o es o nnscntrl c rc sau.)(in Wooe v. itnFog Sc Bd, 5 F.
mply nt nc he bti o isi ontat tts' ct g tn Cl o re h. .6 5 2d
ng
' i
f
5 2 5 4- ( hCi. 9 1)
5 , 4 55 4t r1 8).
4

p o dont S pei t nd ntnl l 20 6 n oft shoo s nt S hoo S se we ef l
r mo o u rn e e i uy 1 , one he c l i he c l y t m r ul
y
ac r die by t sa e.I
c e td
he t t d.

Onl y2 2 6,hel a ne pa t bl he a adcedte T c oo boadwa sa
ul 3, 01 t oc l ws pe pu i d n t l ld,f h l t nt
s
s
m ot di t e saf.'P1' Ex. ,
e ve s t f' .
s
C.ECF N o.102- a 2.Afe nodng t tm oz t 70 pe ce
3, t
tr
ha
e han
r nt
oft Sc
he hoolSyseh' saf m e be swe ewhie t at l t por e t tf les tnt nde
tt s t f m r t
t , he dce e t d ha fa upe i e nt
t
.

'

a t s hoolboar ...beiveam or di r e s a f'c d fm pr t diti ts
nd he c
d
le
e ve s t f' oul ' ove he stc '
i

pe f r nc . J a 4. l ywa q t da s yngt a fg i tt s n sdobeyra do
ro ma e' d. t Tal s uo e s a i h t fmqno iy mde t
'
e
f
te nd
wel n t yha pe ei a hozt whol lket m l?a t tTttsgoodt ha a
lwhe he ve opl n ut iy
ook i he
nd ha fi'
o ve

casoo a asho t trp ee st d mo rp iso o gta.' d (lea ni
lsr m nd c olha e rsnt he e g a bc f ur aej' l a atrdo n
'
o im a) Theat eat t d smi rc
rg l.
'
rkl tdbu e i l omme st S hoo Boa dme rVit rCore
a
nt o c l r mbe co r a
tf re ' :
f r a>
co l
< t nkt sc mmun t ha aveylr Afian Ame ia
' bi hi o
I
iy s r age rc gq rc n
com m uniy a t r ha be n alt r s f om pa e sf
t , nd he e s e a ge eque t r
r nt ot
m or A fi n Am e i n t ac r .I or rf t s dent t
e rca
rca e he s n de or he m
so
ha am or com f t bl la ni ene onm ent It nk i'
ve
e
ora e e z ng
, hi ts
i por a t t s ude st ha a t a rt tl
m
t nt o he t nt o ve e che ha ookslket m ,
i he

Co z as i l' no j taM adns iet i ,tsana wi
re ad. ts t us
r vl hng i' don de
l
is '
s ue.'

Specfcal,Cor e s i he' lle t s em ot bl k m a et a s
ii ly
r a ad d i o e
t
e ac
l e chet
i t diti t hopi t y ca s r asposdver em ode sf
n he szc ,
ng he n e ve.
i
ol
l or
s u nt i t i c a s .
t de s n he r l s es

L=a 5 Attetmet sae nt weema ,fh maort ofteMad vt HihSc ol
d t . h i he ttme s z de T e j iy h r nsil g ho
t
e
.

st e po uléo wa b a k a mae'W ene t De l!2 3
tz nt p a n s lc nd l. i th c.J 9.
d
'
3 Ast Sc
he hoolBoa d notson bref s a e
r
e
i , t t ment s a t sea e c it wih publs s dis I ed,
s uch s he r onssent t
ihed m e . nde
t Vigi aBoa d ofEduca s2018Annua Re ton t Condii andN e ofPublcSc siz
he r ni
r
don'
l por
he
ton
eds
i hool t

Vignasae t tKg tzish vef un t te c r o c o boo tt a a mi pe f a eo al md n s
rii tts ha fs t e a o d ha ta hes f olr s he c de c ro- nc f ls e t
fj d
ge rl , ndt pef r n eo s e sof oo s csc l 'De. BrS p. . umm. , No. 0 ,
neal a he roma c f md nt c lr pe i al ' fs . up MotS
y
p' '
J.ECF 1 0

a 1 n. (uot 2 8An a Re t t1 ,valbeav
t 1 1 q i 01 nu l pora 2 a ial t
ng
5

.oev
d .l/iago /bo /e t/ x.ht )
. v e rporszde s ml.

The da be or t sqcl waspubls d, Ta ly c le W ene t w hie s w a on
y f e he ti e
ihe
le a ld i r h l he s
vac don a i t d a t how m a blck t c r we ee pl
a
nd nquie s o
ny a ea he s r m oyed a t li s hool4 J a
t he lgh c
.
. t
z

!3 W enet i o me Talyt ts K sou oftwn, vaa on, nddi notkaw t
( 2. i th nft d l ha he f
e
wa t o on c d a d
t he
o
a s tt li q s on, ft et ofIe)he d. J. W ene t as a v s dTalyt t
n we o ts ue d of l op t r a ' - i th lo d ie l ha
a
h
'c
k
e
( e f ma ewa ge)t p c nsd tdon: ndt ts ed dno t c mme lii ta hes
f tot nc s h z o o ie a 'a ha h i t e o nd ntng e c t
p
ba e onrc o sx. d a !33 Ta ya k dW ene t t c un t enx ro ta h r b r c
s d a e r e L a t . ze s e i rh o o t h l
mbe f e c e s y a e
a z pot ba k t li wih t i or a i L , W ene t di a s w a i % ct J a
nd e t c o nm t he nf m ton. d i rh d s he s ns ed. o.
-

.

A fw d y ltt o ul 2 2 1 , l yme wihW ene t a a vie he t a hewa
e a s ae , nl y 6, 0 6 Tal t t i th nd d s d t h t
e
s
de i he t t poséo ofa ssa prncpa a M aéns i eMi l S hoo . I a ! 3 .
mot
ng r o he i n sitnt i i l t t vl dde c l d. t 4
l
s
W hen W ene t a ke w hy s w a beng de ot d, le al ge y Tsa ed fhecom m uniy
i th s d
he s i
m e Taly le dl ft t t
t
ha s ke 'a fe us dt ea r t. I !a 36 Att f oft ed cso Talyha n
s po n' nd f f e o lbo ae' d. t . he i
'
r
'
me h e ii n, l d ot
e
.

v std t elg F hoo dlig t y ho da ott ic s d a a pe yoflhelih s h ls
iie h l h c l lrn he q ol y f s use ny s c t lg c oo '
i
d
)

opea nso pe f t nc 'wihW en rh L a !3
r éo r ro- e' t i e t . i t 9.
ma
Talymanti t tVsde ii t r moveW ene t fom t poséon ofplncpa
le i ans ha
cson o e
i rh r he i
i i l
wasm otva e by f s uesofs f t a dicplnea t li s hool' Taly A f.q 3. n hi
i td
fs
i
a e y nd s i i t he lgh c .' le f , I s
t

a fda t Taly ac
fi vi, le knowl
edgest tt hi s
ha he gh choole re ed f om eac de c pr e s'
xpe i nc f
s
a e
ogr s '

unde W ene tfsla z hi J Howe t Talye
r i rl e de s p.da
ve , le mphaiest tK he c r a
sz ha f r oncens boutt
ot
he
4A c ci gt Taly, t il tr waspr ptd by c e nsvoi d byDi t W iim s a bustes
cozln o le he tqtty
'
om e
onc r
ce
anaha l a on,
l
iz s
t chera t ii s hoolwho wa bengtans e r d t anot rs
ea
t he lgh c ,
s i r fre o
he choola enerh' die
tW i t s r cdon. le Af.at4.
Taly f
W ila s r pored t s wast onl blckt ac ra t hi s hoola t tpa e swer unha wih
tim on e t hat he
he y a e he t he gh c
nd ha r nt e
ppy t

t ta f rd cson. .
he r ns e e ii J
i
5 Prort Tal sa ntne asi e i s rnt ndent t SchoolBoar a
i o ley' ppoi nt ntrm upe i e
d dopt d ar ol
e es udon a hozzi
ut i ng
, he
t s rnt ndentt r asi pe sonne wihi t SchoolSyse .D e .sEx.4,ECF N o.100- at59s as
he upe i e
o e sgn r
l t n he
tm
f'
4,
ee lo

Va Co j2212 7(fft shoo b r a op sars ldona ho iigt dvso s pei tnd ntt
. de .- 9 < he c l oad d t e ou ut rzt he iiin u tn e e o
l
l
r asi ...tac s prncpasa asit prncpal,t di son s i e ntmayr s i a s h
e sgn
e her , i i l nd ssant i i s he vii uperntnde
ea sgn ny uc
t che ,pri pa ora ssa prncpalf t ts hoolyea t any s hoolwihi s h di son,pr de no
ea r nci l s itnt i i or ha c
ro
c
t n uc vii
ovi d
change orr s i e duzng a s hoolyea s l afec t s ar ofs h t ac r prncpaloras i a
ea sgnm nt i
c
r hal f t he al y uc e he , i i
sstnt

p icpa f rt a sho y a .)
rn i l o h t c ol e r'.
'
6

e v t nme f rlanig . . ve s do d A ene t )a hive n s'Lk l pa dc a ,
n io nt o e r n . o rha we
i rl c e me t. t n r ulr
fs
'
.

Talyi l ae ta r s teofiesa t hkhsho , swela pae t ofhihsh l
l ncc ts h t eou c fcr t he
e i
c ola l s rns g c oo
sade s f e es e c t a
tz nt,f xpr s d once ns boutalc ofdicplnea contolwihi t s hool
had
ak
s i i nd
t t n he c y'
a r a pat nt f at f t s e y oft z s u nt . I
nd f ny e s e ed or he af t
m
hei t de s' d.
'

Taly' a fda ta s e pha i st f ene t ss t ngt a ei t éon a
le s fi vi lo m
sze hat v i rh' te hs r nsruc
nd

a a e ac 'a d t a T al g é e tr c t e a a e uc t rwa i ami d es hoo s tip'
c d n is' n h t d ry he n ie a e r s n d ao s n d l c l etn '
ne
1 Att tm e ofTaly' decson,M a dns leM i e Schoolha no as it ntprncpa a
d. he i
le s ii
r vil ddl
d
ss a
i i l nd
rf

wa i de pe a e ne d ofan a a m i drve acm i sr orduet dr ng a s s m ent
s n s zt e
c de c- i n l nitat
o oppi s e s

s e . l Tale i caest hgwasf m iitwih W e ne t sa ldesa e re e fom
cor s' d. ly ndi t hat
'
a la t
.
i r h' bii
nd xpe inc r

h> ng pr vi l w or d wih he ,a t the ff l t ts w oul exce a a ssi and
vi
e ousy
ke t r nd ha
fet ha he
d
l t s itng
m otvadng t a r ' a t naddl s hool 1
i
e che s' t he i e c . d.
A fe r as i ng W ene t t t mi e s
t r e sgni
i rh o he ddl choolTaly r i t ed D i t t
, le ensat
xon o he

poséon ofprncpa f t 2016
i
i i l ot he
-2017 s
choolyea .I a 4.Taly as r as i d Re
r d. t
le lo e sgne nee
Br n,t blck f ae a ssa pdncpa a t li s hool t t posdon ofa ssa
ow he a em l s it nt
i l t he lgh c , o he i
s it nt

p i i l t be t ti Elme tr S hoo rf be t ri' . d. le rplc dBr wnwih
rncpa a Al r Hars e n ay c l Al r Hars) I Taly e a e o
t
Cl r nceSi i on,ablc m aewho had <e re e notonl i t s
ae
m ngt
ak l
'xpe i nc
y n he chools t m butas
ys e
lo

i lw enf ce
na
or ment'J aAcc di t Taly' a hda t hedeet ne t tDi a
.' .
d
or ng o le s f vi,
t mi d ha xon nd
Si i on w oul be a et m oz efe dvey ha et dic plna ypr e satt li
m ngt
d
bl o
e f c l ndl he s i i r oblm
he lgh

s h lSe i s(pi n t a Thes h l smo esmat r d ds i i d a s f dli g
c oo . e d o nig h t f c oo wa r t cu e , icpl nd a e l n
t
ne
t
p i o s t n r 'a t tSli t se l y e ba k r u ma hm r l s td'f r
x n') e u e' nd ha i ngon' mp o m nt c g o nd de i f l uie ' o
we
t post ofa ssa p i i l tt hg s hoo)
he ii
on sitnt rncpa a he ih c l.

7

Ats e poi s e ntt t r s i
om
nt ubs que o he ea sgmne s t hi s hoolr gai f l
nt , he gh c
e ned ul
a r t ton fom t s a e The s
cc edia i r
he t t .
choolr m ansfzl a c edied. W ene t D ep.4,ECF N o.
e i tly c r t
i th
1 1.
00-

The Sc
hoolBoa d hassè it d zs soff ea he s pa adons'f t 2013 t 2018
t
tbm te t
f c te r
t
' ot he
o
hs lye z .D ef' Ex.13,
ca a s
.s
ECF N o.100- a 1 D utng t 2013 fs aly t t Sc
13, t -5. i he
ic ea , he hool

Syse l t> e reghttac r . da a 1 O ft e t n wor d att hi s hool ni
tm os nt i e he s L t . hos , e
ke
he gh c
, ne
.

wor d a Al r H a rs and eghtw ot d a t mi e s hool l D urng t 2016 fs a
ke t be t r i,
i
ke t he ddl c . d. i he
ic l
ye r t Sc
a , he hoolS t m l tûfy-i t c r .I a 2-4.O ft e t nt wor a Al r
ys e os t sx ea he s d. t
hos , we y ked t be t
H a zs sxt n wot att b gh s hool a hfe w or d a t m i e s hool I
r i, i ee
ked he i c
, nd t en
ke t he ddl c
. d.
I.
I

I t i tnta i W ene t a s r scnm sofr cea s x cic i i don unde Til
n he nsa cton, i rh s e t li
a nd e ls rm na
r te
V1 ,and a cnm ofa dic i i i unde t AD EA .
1
li
ge s tm naton
r he
The SchoolBoa d ha m ove f
r s
d or

s
ummayjdg ntonalhtec ' s
r u me
lt e ou .
nt
ff ec ur s al rn s mmayj g ntfhemo nts wsta t r i nog nune
f' o t h lg a t u r ud me it
-h
va ho h thee s e i
d s ut a t a ymaeil a t n t mo a ti e ldt j g nt sama troflm 'Fe
ip e s o n tra fc a d he v n s ndt o ud me a
e
te a ' d.

R.Ci P. 6()T ds t ige ui i T raon bl jl c udrtr aveditfrt
v. 5 a.< ipue s n ne fa e s a e uy o l eun r c o he
A
no vn pat.' betra Pat of . l d, 8F. 30 , 3(t Ci. 01 )(uoi
nmo ig ryn' zain ry Vav.ud 71 3d 8 31 4h t2 3 q tng
Li
Dua v. c ' Co . Am.6 3F.d 3 3 33 (t Ci. 1 ). fc i mae lfi
lne Pa ka n
of , 7 3 2 , 0 4 h r 20 2) A a t s tda i t
Kn i afe t out om eoft sztunde t gove ni lm 'A nde s 477 U. a 248.l
taght f ct he c
he ti
z he
r ng a '
r on,
S. t
n

d ccigwh t rag nunedipu eof tra fc e it,hec t t fiwgt fc sa d
e il
n ehe e i s t mae il a t xss t our mus T e he a t n
v
r a ona ei e encç dr wn t r r i t lghtm os fvor bl t t nonm ovi pary'
e s bl nf r s a
he efom n he i
t a a e o he
ng t .'

W o a dv. la h r 71 F.d 8 , 7 (t Ci. 1 ) Ho ve, ' no vig p ry
oz r Gal e , 2 3 65 8 3 4 h t 20 3 . we r f he nmo n a t
t
m us r l on m or t n c l or alga
t ey
e ha oncus y le dons m e e s culdon, hebuici ofonei e e e
, r pe a
t
llng
nf r nc
8

upon a he ,ort m e ee se e ofas i l ofe de .' a h v. a e t r 731 F.
not z he r xit nc
cndla vi nce'D s M
a he ,
3d

30 , 1 (t Ci. 1 )
3 3 1 4. r20 3.
h
1 1.
1

Til VI m a i unlwf lf a em pl ert tdic i i t a i ta i vi l t
te I kes t a u ot n
oy o ' s rm na e gans ny ndi dua wih

r s c t g r c mpe a ,tt , ondéons o p ii ge ofe oy ntbe a eof
eph t o hej o nsdon e ms c i , r rvl s mpl me , c us
e

s c idvdu l rc . .g qsx. 4 U.. j2 0 -()1. i lry t ADEA ma e '
u h n ii a' a e . or e ' 2 SC. 0 0e2a() Smi l,he
s
'
a
k si
t
u a ul oia e l y zt f ici naea ans a yi i d l t r s e tt gel
nlwf f n mp o e o f s tmi t g i t n ndviua wih e p c o h r
d
com pe a
ns éon,t r s c dons orprvie ofe pl e ,be aus ofs h i vi '
e m , ondi ,
i lges m oym nt c e uc ndi duals

a e'2 U. C. 6 3()1.
g - 9 S. j 2 a()
:
A pli fma a i s mmayj g n a detbl hac m o rc ,sx o a e
andf y vod u r ud me t n sa i bi f a e e , r g
j
dic i i ton i one oft wa .Fis,apl ntf m a ofe die torc r um sa ile de
s rm na i n
wo ys r t ai if y f r r c
ic tnta vi nce
ofa e pl rsdic i i t y a m us H ilv.
n m oye ' s tnnna or ni . l Lockhe d M a én Lo 'dcsM
e
r
s

t l ,354
. nc.

F.d2 7 2 4( h Ci. 0 )(nba ) a o ae i a t Gr s FBL Fi Se v .I .5 7
3 7 , 8 4t t20 4 e nc , br td n r b os v.
n. r s, nc, 5

U..1 7( 0 ) S c nd, plitf ma pr c e u rt bkr n-hitngfa wo kst
S 6 20 9. e o a nnif y o ed nde he lde s fi rme t e
f t i Mc nel
orh n Don lDou lsCo . Gre 4 1U. 7 2(9 3 .- a 2 5 seas Fose v.
a
v. en, 1 S. 9 1 7 )J. t 8 9 e lo tr
I
L
Uni ofMa lnd Ea tr S r , 8 F.d24 , 49( h Ci. 01 )( teVl) M ees v.
v.
a - se n ho e 7 7 3 3 2 4t t 2 5 Til l; rih
W ak r 3 9F.d3 , 3 (t Ci. 0 4 (
le , 5 3 30 3 4 4 h r 2 0 ) ADEA)
.
I t i r s c i bre s t pa de a l eW e ne t scsi sofcic i i
n her e pe tve i f , he r s nayz
i r h' l m
ls tm naéon unde
r
t M c onnel D ou 1s fa e k:Put uantt t sfa e k,t pl ntf be r t i éa
he D
l
a z m wor
s
o hi r m wor he ai if a s he ni l

bur n ofesa ihi a ptm a f ce c e ofdictm i ton.M e e s 359 F. a 334.I s
de . t bls ng
i a i as
s i na i
t ih,
3d t
f he
s ee ,t btr snfst t def nda t a dc at al gii a e nondic i i or
pcc ds he zden lit o he e nt o r ul e e tm - t ,
s rm nat y
b
'
.

'

z as f t a r ee pl enta don.- O nce t de e a pr ft ajs ai f r
e on oz he dve s m oym
c
J.
I
L
he fnd nt ofe s u dhc t o
on
,

t ac
he don a is ,f heblr n safsbac t tz pli ft pz by apr ponde a oftz
t s ue f
t
zde lit
k o le a ndf o ove
e
z nce le
9

e de e t tt empl rss a e t s f e e notist' t as , butwet apt e f
vi nc ha he
oye ' t t d ea ons w t
t t e ons
ue
e etxt ot

ds tmi ton.' l 35 F.d a 28 ( u ngRe ve v. a ton Pl i Pt ds l .
iç i nai ' Hi, 4 3 t 5 q oé
' l
e s S nde s umbn o . nc,
5 0U. 1 3 1 3 ( 0 ).f 'ef lp ee ti uiyT r e wih t utmaebu d n of
3 S. 3 , 4 20 0) ff i r tx nq r meg s t he li t r e
eh na
.
pe s d n t c t t tg pli f ha be n t v c ofi e na ds tmi don'
rua i g he out ha t andfj s e he iém ntnéo l ici na ,
he
wlih a altm esr m inswih t pl i f' M e rt v.O l D onnni Fr i htLi l . 601
ac t l i
e
t he anéf . r it
'
d
i on e
ne nc,

F.d28 , 9 (t Ci. 01 )(uot Te a De tofCmt Afat v. ldnq 45 U.. 4 ,
3 9 2 4 4 h r 2 0 q i x s p'
ng
p fis Bt i , 0 S 2 8
r

25 (9 1)
6 1 8 ).
I mo i f s mmayjd me , h S h l a d agu st a W ene t i u bl .
n vng or u r u g ntt e c oo Bo t r e h t i rh s na et
o
esa ih aptm a f ci c e ofz e s x,ora dic i i
t bls
i a e as
ac , e
ge s tm nadon,ors
how t tt as e t
ha he s red

j tfcéonsf rhe ra sg me weeprtk lAlho ht ec r c lde ta
usi a
i
o r e sin nt r ee ma. t ug h ou t oncu s h t
W ene t ha e t bls aprm a f ce c s ,i a ee wi. t Sc
i r h s s a ihed
i a i a e t gz s t he hoolBoar t tW ene t ha
h
d ha
i zh s
/

n prsntdg fce e i nc fo whc arao bl jr c l c ldeta t S hoo
ot e e e ufiint vde e r m ih e s na e u y oud oncu h t he c l
Boar sa s r e r s f he r s i entwe ea pt t xtf dic i i éon.
d' s e t d ea ons or r ea sgnm
r
e e or s rm na
A.

Thepli ifsi éa bur n unde t M cD onnelD ou 1 fa e or i çnot
antf' ni l de
r he
l
as r m w k s f
one ous' Bur ne 45 U . a 253. e t bls aprm a f i c eofdicrm i ton,t
r .' di , 0 S. t
To s a ih
i ace as
s i na i he

pandf mus s w ()t ts i ame rofap otce cas ()t ts s frda
li f t ho 1 ha he s mbe
r etd ls;2 ha he ufee n
a ves e o me ta ton ()t ts ewa pef mi he jbduisa alve t tme he
d re mply n ci ;3 ha h s ror ng r o te t e lha t r
e ly rslgtmaee pe t do a t etmeoft a ve s e o me ta do a ()t a
mpo e ' e ii t x ca ns t h i
he d re mply n c n; nd 4 h t
t a r eempl e ac i occ r '
he dvç s
oym nt ton ur ed d
unde ct t t nc gi ng zs t a i e e e of
r ic unsa es vi ie o n nf r nc

una ul srmi to 'Ad msv. . Uni o N. - i nlo 6 0F.d 5 0 5 8 (t
lwf dic i nai n. n
'
Tr of v. f c. l
W mi n, 4 3 5 , 5 4 h
Ci. 01 )
r2 1.

1
.

TheSc
hoolBoat a guest tW ene t scqm sf i a t s ond eem e bec ùs het
d t
ha
i th' li al t he ec
l nt a e
r as i entwasnota ad t e e pl entac
e sgnm
n ve s m oym
don.Forput esofa dic i i éon cmm
pos
s tm na
li
unde Til VI ort AD EA , T ve s em pl m enta éon' i one t tfad t ey a f t
t te I he
an f t e
ad
oy
c 's
ha f ve s l fec s

tett , onddo , be û soft epli fse o me t'J me v. zM e &
l ems c i nsor ne t l andf' mply n . a s Boo - n
a
a
;
Ha lo l .36 F. 3 , 7 (t Ci. 0 4 (nen lq tt mak o nte )The
mi n,nc, 8 3d 71 3 5 4h r 2 0 ) itr a uoai
t
on t s nitd.
Unied St t sCour ofA ppe l f t Four h Cic tha hel t tar asi entc n
t
ae
t
a s or he
t t ui s d ha e sgnm
a
cons tt a adve s e pl e a
dtze n
r e m oym nt cdon Ti t pli fc n s
ff he anéf a how t tt r sgnm e ha
ha he easi
nt d

s mesg ika d ti ntl fe t'l .i e n lq otéo maksomitd . a lso s c
o in f nt e rme a e fc . d ( r a u a n r
' nt
te ) Ex mp e f u h
e fc s n ld af c e s i c
fe t i cu e f r a e n ompe a n,obdte lv l r s nsb ly o o ran t f r
de
ns do j l,e e of e po i ii , r ppo tziy o
t
p omo i . I ( ena q tto ma k omitd .
r ton' d.i z l uo ain r s te )
' nt
I s
n uppor ofisa gum e ,t SchoolBoa d f us on t f c t tW ene t s
t t t
nt he
z oc es
he a t ha
i rh'
r asi e ci notha a i m e a e e f ton he s lr orbe is SeeD e . Br Supp.
e sgnm nt ld
ve n m dit fec
r aay
neft .
f' .
s

MotSA J (De sBt?, No. 0 ,a 1 (mp szn t tt pli fsTaaya
.1
mm. .f E' . ECF 1 0 t 6 e haiig ha he andf' f lr nd
<
)
s
be ' swe eunc n d t ty a de pt he n w r l7 Ast f r g i gpr c d n ma e
ne
ft r ha ge ha e r s ie r e o e). he o e o n e e e t k s
ce r howe r a a r e v pl e a
la ,
ve , n dve s m oym nt céon i notlm ie t st éonsi whi h a
s
i t d o iua
n
c n
ç pl e e re esaHi i
m oye xpe i nc
m nudon . s ay orl sofbene is I t ad,ar s i e c
i alt
n
os
ft . ns e
ea sgnm nt an

c dt t a a ves e o me a éo wh ni i a c mpa e byac a g i jb dteo
ons a e n d re mply nt c n e t s c o nid
z
hnen o l r
l ve ofê ponsbiip l m es 368 F! a 375. ca eW ene t wa m oved fom t poséon
e l es
i lt a ,
3d t
Be us
i rh s
z
he i
-

ofp i i l o t tofa ssa p i i lar a ona l j yc ul e sl fn t a h r
rncpa t ha sitnt rncpa, e s b e ut o d a i i d h t e
y
r s i e c dt t an adver e e pl m e a
ea sgnm nt ons u ed
s m oy nt cHon.
Thus W e ne t s dsi s t s cond
, i r h a fe he e
elm e ofaptm af i c e.
e nt
i ace as

2.

TheSc
hoolBoa d a s ar
z lo guest tW ene t i una e t m e t t t elm e .To
ha
i rh s bl o et he hid e nt

sdsyti ee n,apanéf mus p ee ts fce te i n efo wlc araon bl jr
a f hs lme t li f t r sn ufiin vde c rm l h e s a y u y
i
c udin t tfhewa peft n h tjbd isa alve t t t re o e'lgtmae
o l id ha f
s
s tomig e o ute t e lha me he mply rse ii t
e ct
xpe adonsatt tm eoft a z e e pl m e ac ' Hil 354F. a 285. Fourh
he i
he.dve s m oy nt don.' l,
3d t
The
t
Cicui,lke ot ra la ecot s ha Tqualfe t st qliem e by c a iyng t tt
r ti
he ppe lt ut , s f ii d hi e pr nt lr fi ha he

pli fsbur i t sz ga d i nota one ousone' HiIv. .Fr i htLi I ,523 F.
anéf'
den n hi e r s
n
r
.' I Se e
nes nc.

Ap x 21 21 (t Ci. 1 ) s eas De ionv. wa o Ge l a h Co, 41F.d 1 6
p' 3, 6 4 h r 20 3 9 e lo n s S c oo
.9 2 41 ,

1 21(0 Ci.1 1 ( l n t tt pli iff thibur nof o uc byitod ig
4 1 + r 99 ) hodig ha he antf f
me s de pr d éon nt ucn
s e e de ofgood pe f m a e' a a r e ng wih t Sec Cic tt tKpz of
om vi nce
r or nc ' nd g e i
t he ond r ui ha f oof
f
com pe e e s ûc e t m a outaprm a f i c e ofdic i i don wa ne ri e
t nc uf i nt o ke
i ace as
s rm na
s ve nt nded t
o

e c mpa sp o ofs pe irt o fa e spe f r nc n)(uo Po lv. r c eUrv.
n o s r of u ro iy r lwls ro ma e ' q dng wel S a us l ,
i
5 0F.d 1 5 , 5 ( Ci. 9 )9 Mont n v. Con ninc Pr ds I .7 0F.
8 2 1 0 11 5 2d r 1 78) La
a e Am. ve e e o . nc, 5 2d

1 5 1 1 -1 (t Ci. 9 4 (o l igt tt pli if sa ihe ap i fcec s wih
40 , 4 3 4 7h r 1 8 ) c ncudn ha he antf etbl d tma a i ae t
s
e i nc t tlsjbpef ma ewa g neal sésa tr, sieot re de et t
yde e ha n o ror nc s e rl a fco y dept he vi nc o he
i
y
c tay.T tou hons
onrr) T h g
Al
ummayj g nta e o e i fe t ast t tt j
r ud me n mply r s re o set ha he ob
e ctdon pt ha notbee m e ,not ng pz lbist e pl e fom count rng t s
xpe a
ong s
n t hi
oli t he m oye r
e i hi

a s r n wih e i nc t td mo tae (ra la tc e tsaq e don off c)t a t
s edo t vde e ha e nstt s o t e s r ae u s
a t h t he
pr f r d fxpe a i i not i f ct lgii at ata1'W ar h v.O li Ca .I .Co.435F.
ofe e e ctton' s , n a , e tm e l.' c
'o s ns
l
3d

5 0 51 ( . C.. 0 )
1 , 7 4t i 20 6 .
h r
Vi wi t r or i t lghtm os f vor bl t t pl ndf,t cour concudest t
e ng he ec d n he i
t a a e o he ai f he
t
l
ha

ar a o a l j. c ll fndt t a t tmeofhe r a sg ntW en rhwa me é he
e s n b e ut ozd i ha, t he i
y
r e si nme , i e t s e ng r
e o e ' lgtmaej b e pe tto . r c d rve l t tW ene t wa s e vs d b
mply rs e ii t o x c ains The e or e as ha i rh s up r ie y

H e h f al t fna t l da ofhe t ee ye tt easprncpa . e tfsdeca a
at or lbut he i l weve ys
r ht - a enm
i i lH al
lt éon

i iae t a W ene t n o yf tot dup t glah')e pe tdons'bu f xc e e
ndc ts h t i th ot nl ç f me
pe
o l e t s x ca , t f e d d
' e

Ie)e pe t t i t ea e smos ci a t t es c s ofMa t vz H i School'
è t x cai n hos t a
h
ons
t tdc l o h uc e s
ti ie gh
ns
.'
,

He t De lI2 Addton l , tt ee oft 2 15 0 6 shoo y a, ah c mme e
ah c.J 9. ii al a l nd he 0 -2 1 c l e t He t o nd d
y a
W ene t sT f t a a nc m ent ,' ch i l
i rh' f ots nd dva e
ef
s'whi ncuded i z as t ts ot ,a
nc e ed es c es nd

f on r t ltd he o a l e i c tnln c r c sa'sa ap i cpa. I ! 2 . c t
f g auae z n cn vng on i x g onta t tt s rn i l' d. j 7 The out
c
i
i
u
'
beive t ts h e de , hen c ta e i W e ne t sf vor i s f e t s tsy he
le s ha uc vi nce w
onstz d n i r h' a , s ufkint o ai f r

bur n att prm af i sage SeeTil v.Pi ontAllnes I . 713 F.
de
he i ace t .
le
edm
ri
nc,
App' 181,186
x

(t ci. 1 )( digt see ntsdsidwheetepbi fss r o feerdt hi
4hg r20 7 ûn n hi lme a fe
r h ndf' upeds r f fre o m
r
> f sao da dc
s a e s ne p ompee e o e ' sxwe ksprt t t pan fst = i do )
tnt mply e' i e iy o he li df' e na n
'

( ena q tto mak omitd; s v. IDu o d Ne p s& Co.3 F.d7 1 7 6
i r l uoain r s te )Bas E..
nt
nt r mo r
, 24 3 6 , 6
n. ( h Ci. 00 )( i t see nt a fe Fhe e a got e t i g ,hepli fT a
2 4t r 2 3 ûndng hi lme s dsi d r , mon h r h n s t nndf f d
h

be ntl ta h rpef - nc wa sésatr .
e od h t e rot e s a fco f)
ma
M oe ve, enet ha ctde i nc fom whiharaona l jr c l fndt t
ro rW i rh s ie vde e t
c e s be u y oud i ha
c r an pr f r e ct i wer f , n f ct l g tm a e'W ar 435 F. at517.For
e t i ofe ed xpe atons e f i a , e ii t .' ch,
not
3d
i t nc whiet Sc
nsa e, l he hoolBoa d e pha i est ttt hi s hoolr m a ned unac r died' at
r m
sz ha fhe gh c
e i
ce t '
t e ofW ene t st e, e .sBr a 22,t s m ew a t e f aloft ot rs hool i
he nd
i rh' enur D f' . t
he a
s nz ot l he he c
sn

t Ciy ofM a dns le i l ng Pa rc H e y,whe eTaly ha s r d a prncpa snc
he t
r vil, ncudi
ti k nr
r le d e ve s i i l i e

J y 1 20 2 S eTalyAf. t1 rl 2 4, lf rct s h l weea ce ie wihwa rng
ul , 1 . e l
e f a tn 01 al ou iy c oo s r c r dtd t rz ,
i
whi m e nst y we enot6ll a r died.l t s m e of2016,none oft s hool
ch a he
r
ly cc e t n he um r
he c
s

wihn t Ciyss h ls se we ef l a c e ie ' De pieti dekinc , l ywa
t i he t ' c oo y tm r ' l c r dtd.
uy
). s t b s f e y Tal s
e
pr ot t t poston ofi erm s rnt nde .
om ed o he ii
nt i upe i e nt

Al t s m elnes M a dns le Hi Sc
ong he a i , t vil gh hoolwa notta onl s hoolt tçl t
s
le y c
ha fos
t a r atasg f a z t 'dutng t tm ef a ei wli h W ene t w a prncpa.D ef' Bt
e che s
inik nt a e' i he i r m n lc
i rh s i i l
. .
s
a 8.I t a t r or i ca e t tt r ddl s
t ns e d, he ec d ndi t s ha he ni e chooll tm or t c t t n t li
os
e ea he s ha he agh
s hooldutng t 2015 is a yea ,and t tAl t H a rsl tm or t a r t n t li
c
i he
ic l r
ha be t ti os
e e che s ha he ngh

s
choola t naddl s hooldt ng t 201 fs lye r W hiet Sc
nd he i e c
ui he 6 ica a . l he hoolBoa d e pha i
r m
szes

t tt en
ha h umbe ofta he s lf t el g s ho ne ryf ou e 'fo 20 3t 2 6 J
r e c t Who e t h n h c ol al f bld? r m 1 o 01 ,A
i
d
a 5,t nk
t he unbe oft a swho l tAl r H ati i t s d a a e hi tt t
t e chet
ef be t rs nc ea e t n ven ghe a e.
N onet l s t ei no e de e t t prncpa oft mi e s hoolorA l r H a rswas
hees , her s
vi nc hat he i i l he ddl c
be t ti
t s i d i 2016.
ea sgne n
Ba e on t f e ng e de e t c tc l
sd
he or goi vi nc , he our oncudest tage ne is ofm a e i
ha
nui s ue
t ral
f te s sa t Fhe he W enerh w a pe f nnng a a a ce a elve a t dm e ofhe
ac xit s o
t t i t
s ror i t n c pt bl e l t he
r

r a sg ntAc o d n l, heS hoo Boadi n e dte t sl r jd me ont t r
e sinme . c r i gy t c l r s ot n ld o lmma y u g nt he hid
elm e .
e nt
3.

The c utas c l st diput d i s soff c e s wih re pec t t f 'h
ot lo oncude hat s e s ue
a t xit t s t o he out
t
elm entofa prm a f c eca e t tt a r ee pl entac
e
i a i s : ha he dve s m oym
don occ r f
ur ed f
unde
r
cz l s a esgvi rs t a i er eofunl ' dicrm i éon.' da s 640 F. a 559.
iclm t nc i ng i e o n nf enc
awf s i na
ul
'A m ,
3d t
A pli fc n s if t see entby s
anéf a atsy hi lm
howi t the poséon r m ane ope orwa fle by
ng ha r i
e i d
n
s tld
asm ia l qualfe a i a outi t pr ec e ca s Hil 35 F. at285;s a s D uga
i lry
ii d pplc nt sde he ot t d ls . l, 4 3d
ee lo
n

v. be reCou ySc Bd.29 F.d 71 , 21 ( h Ci. 0 2 ( igt tt f urh
Al mal nt h. , 3 3 6 7 4t t 2 0 ) notn ha he o t
e e e i a AD EA ca e f ss ds i wih pr ofr plce e by a s t ndal younge
l m nt n n
s f a fed t oof e a m nt
i
ubs a l
y
r

W o ke7 .
r r'
)

I t sca e,ti undiput d t tW e neth wast pl e by a blc m aewho i m ot
n hi s i s
s e ha
i t
e ac d
ak l
s
e
t 20 y r younge .TheSc
han
ea s
r
hoolBoa d nonet l s a
z
he e s ppea st a gte t tW ene t s
t o r z ha
i r h'
r plce e by D i doesnotgvers t a i e e e ofdic i ton snc Di fha
e a m nt
xon
i i e o n nf r nc
s Hm na i i e xon f d

pt vi ex i
e ous perencea aptncpa' a Tas ha ploza i st
s i i l? nd flo d i dm nitadvee de ei t Sc
xpe nc n he hool
Boa d' Ce z O fi e. D e .sBt a 17, c di t t pli fse dence how e r
t s ntal fc ' f' . t A coz ng o he anéf' vi
'
ve ,
,
D i w a r as i d t t a ni st
xon s e sgne o he dr nitadve posdon afe H e t f
i
t t a h ound hi pe f m a as
s r or nce
prncpa t beuna e a eand t Sc
i i lo
cc pt bl
he hoolBoa d de lned t r w hi c t c f t
r ci
o ene
s ont a t or he
2013-2014 s hoolye t Vi wi t r cot i t lghtm os f vot bl t W ene t t c t
c
a . e ng he e d n he i
t a a e o i th, he our
c ude t t decson t r pl c W ene t wih D i s
oncl s hat he ii o e a e i r h t xon uppor sa i e e of
t n nf r nce

dic i i or a m usatt ss a oft pr è ngs The c tt r or concude t
s rm nat y ni . hi t ge he oc edi .
our he ef e
l s hat
W e ne t hasm e he < e ai l m ode t'but n ofesa ili a prm a f ce ca eof
i rh
t r t l tvey
r
s ' de
t blsnng i a i s
dic i in
s tm taéon unde Til VI a t AD EA . a v. ke Re ' ed.Cts I , F.
r te I nd he
B nt Ai n
lM
r . nc.333 3d

5 6 5 ( t Ci. 0 )( e n lq otdonma ksomitd .
3 , 45 4 h r 2 03 i r a u a
nt
t
te )
B.

Unde t M c onnelD ou l fa e k,t bur n s fst t Sc
r he D
l
as r m wor he de hit o he hoolBoar t
do
pr
oduc e de e oflgii a e,non- s rm i or z s f r m ovi W ene t f om he
e vi nc
e tm t
dic i nat y ea ons or e
ng i rh r
t

poséon ofprnc pa .
i
i i l Thee pl rsbt n a t ssa f sone ofpr
m oye ' ude t hi t ge f
i
oduc
don,not
pe s son,'a i i vesç c e biiy a s s ent' W a ch,435 F. at514.Reym g on
r ua i ' rd nvol t r di lt s es m .
no
' r
3d
l'
af visfom Taly a t ofism e be s t Sc
ûda t r
le nd wo t m r , he hoolBoa d m a nt i t t li
r
i ans hat he ngh
s hoolha Ks dousdicplna yi s s'dudng W ene tfst nur asprncpa a t r f e
c
d fe
s i i r s ue '
i rl e e
i i l nd he e or
nee atsr ' s i i ta a prncpa.' D e . Br at23
ded ftong dicplha i n s i i l ' f' .
s
-24. a ot af nt a t sed
M ny her fa s te t
t di cplne a s tde beha orpr em sa t hi s hooldurng t spe i i l ng
o s i i nd tz nt
vi
obl
t he gh c
i hi rod, ncudi

saf m e bet w ho wot unde W ei t h.Fozpur e oft pe ng m odon, t cout
tf m s
ked
r ne t
pos s he ndi
he
t
c ude t tt Sc
oncl s ha he hoolBoa d hass i he isbut n ofpz
t
ats d t
de
oducdon.

Th bu d n t r f r szfsba k t W ene t t p o t tt a s re j dfc to
e r e hee o e l t c o i rh o r ve ha he s et d us iains
i
f rh rr a sgn n we ef otg jt er a o , t r apr tx f rc s rmi do 'Hi ,
o e e si me t r f t n' e s ns bu we e e e t o l c i na n. l
n he
i
' l
354 F. a 285. pli ifca esa ih pt e by s
3d t
A antf n t bls et xt howi t tt em pl tsTe a don
ng ha he
oye ' fxplna
if
s unworhy ofc ede 'orby ofe i ot r f ' sofct um s a le dence s fcenty
t
r nce
f rng he ot
m
ic t nda vi
ufi i l

p o tv of. . ic i n t 'Me es 3 9F. a 3 ( otn Btr pe 4 0U. a 25 )
r baie . ds rmiai ' r ih, 5 3d t 36 qu ig zdi , 5 S. t 6 .
on.
fA1pli fsprmaf cec s , o i e wih s hce e d nc t indt tt e o e '
< andf' i a i a e c mb n d t uf int vie e o i ha he mply rs
(

a s re j t ain i f le ma pemi t titoffc t c ncudet tt e o e
set d uszc to s as , y r t he re a t o o l ha he mply r
unlwf l dicHm i t d.' e s 530 U . a 1
a uly s
na e 'Re ve ,
S. t 48.

To py pr t ,apli ifm us do m or t n pr entconcus yal ga
ove e ext antf
t
e ha es
l or le donsof
dic i i don;r he ,fc z epa tc a s'a e r pr d. e r v.D a on,759 F. 989,998
s rm na
at t fonc et ziulr ' r eqlie M ii
c
2d

(dCi. 9 5. paqifmu tc fr t wiha r si ee ie et ti mo et n
2 z 1 8 )A litf s ome o wad ,t dnisbl vd nc ha s r ha
sl-evn o ninso s c ai S eCa e v. l , 6 F.d79 , 01(t Ci. 9 8.
efsr ig pi o r peulton. e us Bao 1 2 3 5 8 4h r 1 9 )
Fe r c t do nots r t s cond- sw or ac decsons t ,acli of
de al our s
'e ve o e
gues
kpl e ii ; hus
sm
dic i i ton c nnotbebas on m e edia ee e wih an a r e e pl entde ii
s rm ng i a
ed
r s gz m nt t
dve s m oym
c son.

Se Deanet v. r ig I .1 3F.d29 , 9 (t Ci. 9 8.
e l r te Co nn , nc, 3 3 3 2 9 4h r 1 9 )
Pa tcul l t s Cour doe notsta a ki ofs rper onne
ri aty, hi
t s
i s nd
upe - s
l
de t e weghi t pr nc of e pl m e de ii
parm nt i ng he ude e
m oy nt c sons
m a by fl sc r wih e oym e dic i i ton ... 0 %
de lm ha ged t mpl
'
nt s tm na i
.
s e conce n i w het r t r s f wli h t def ndant
ol
r s
he he ea on ot nc he
e

ge sine ) t pli f wa ds rmi t r Thus wh n a
r a sg d he andf s ici nao p
, e n
e o e a dc lts ar a o f r ge sinig t e pan ifnot
mply r r u ae e s n o r a sg n q l litf
a
f bi n by lw ,i i notou. pr nc t de i whet z t
ox dde
a ts
r ovi e o c de
he he
r s waswi e f i ore n cor ec , tm at l,s l asi t l
ea on
s , ar vq
r t uli ey o ong t ruy
h

wa t er a o f rt eplitf' ge sinme j
s h e s n o h an ifs r a sg nt.
16

J ( ena q td maksa ctdonso te )seas Andes v. tu frChe Co.
. i t l uoa on t nd ia
i nt
mitd; e lo
zon Sa fe m. ,

9 5F.d3 7 4 3Ct Ci. 99 )(Thefc t ta e ly ed ss meti swel e no
6 2 9 , 0 /h t 1 2 t a t ha n mpo e oe o hng ldo s t
<
m e n t any t s gi n f li ftngi a pt t xtf dic i i don .... tl s he a t c
a hat
ea on ve or ts ti s e e or s tm na
U ae s
ta ks

t s cii t as gve f a t = i don,a pli fwho st s e de e ofs ts a t y
he pe fc e ons i n ot e na
anéf
tes es vi nc
a if c or
pe f m a e i sm pl c le i t wi dom oft e pl ' dec son, c we ha
t ot nc s i y hal ngng he s
he m oyets ii wbi h
ve

c sse l r f s dt rvim ' ( e n l uo ai ma ksa ct do o it d .
on itnt e u e o e e ) i r a q tton r nd ia ns nl e )
y
nt
t
A fe consde i t pa des a gum e s e bis a t a ia e lw ,t c t
tr
i rng he r ' r
nt , xhi t , nd he pplc bl a he our

c ude t W e ne t hasf ied t m ee he f tm a ebur ofper uadi t colr t t
oncl s hat i r h
al o
t rf i t
ul
den
s ng he zt ha
s ha bee t vi tm ofi e i ldic i i don.' di 450 U . a 256. n viwi
he s n he c i
nt ntona s tm na
'Bur ne,
S. t
Eve e ng

t rc r i t l mo tfvoa l t t pli faraon bejr c ul nothn t tt
he e o d n he kht s a rbe o he anéf, e s a l u y o d
d ha he
alged cic plne r l t d r s f m m ovi W ene t a pdncpa a r pl i he wih
le
ls i i - e a e ea ons or
ng i zh s
i l nd e acng r t
Di a eunworhy ofc edence W ene t ha notpr e e a e denc be
xon r
t
t
. i rh s
es nt d ny vi
e, yond

s czaina c jct ,ha t dicpiep o e a tehih sho c o ce i t
pet to nd onetue t t he siln r blms t h g c ol hr nild n he
l
af viss
ûda t uppor t Sc
dng he hoolBoa ds m oton w e e apr t xtf dic i i éon.
r ' i
r
e e or s rm na
Att out e , he ei no die e dencet W ene t sr c ,ge r ora plyed a
he s t t r s
z ct vi
hat i rh' a e nde , ge a
ny
r e i herr asi e . ndee t z i no li i t sr oz t W ene t sa orge r
ol n
e sgnm nt l
d, he e s ant n hi ec d hat i r h' ge
nde

ha a hi t do wi. he m ovet t nnddl s hoolRa e e st pi t r byvit oft
d nyt ng o
t r
h
o he i e c . ce ntt he c u e
z ue he
publs c nm ent i f vorofdi r iy e nc m e ,wlih we ea lge y m a by Ta ly
ihed or
sn a
ve st nha e nt lc
r le dl de
le
and Cor e a a Sc
r a t hoolBoa d wor s son s ty afe Taly wa a
r
k es i horl t r le
s ppoi e i e i
nt d nt rm

q rnt nta af w da be or W ene t w a r s i d.The c tdoe notbeive
upe i ende nd e ys f e i th s ea sgne
our
s
le

t tar a o b ejr c l c ncud t a s h a p rdon lsae nt i fvo ofe nc d
ha e s na l u y oud o l e h t uc s ia a ttme s n a r nha e
dv riy i a o t m sl s a ee i e c o ds rm i t ya mus Se oh o v. e r .
ie st,n nd f he eve , r v d n e f ic i naor ni . el ns n M to

Go to Nah l & Da i on C . 5 2 F. ' 5 3 5 ( t Ci. 01 )( e vngt t'
v' f s vie
l
vds
, 0 Appx 2 , 35 6h r 2 2 obsr i ha
17

fsa e e sz l tng adest t i pr ci z iy do notequa et diec e de of
ft t m nt efec i
ie o m ove t st
ve
t o r t vi nce
1

u lwf l ici nain' Be nsenv. tPa l m a i sI .1 4F. u 2d7 0 73 n.2
n a u ds rmi to ); t ti S . u Co n e nc, 3 S pp. 3 , 9 1

( Md. 0 )( tngt a a e o e ' f o t ntt fi t i 'fe r s e i tt of
D. 2 01 no i h t n mply ts f mmime o dve sl i xp e s d n e ms
c
ct adng oppor uni esf empl
e
t t ot
â
oyeesofcif e t es...,i notpr ofdic i i t y
lfet nt ac
s
oof
s rm na or
m odvewih r s ctt a s ii hii decson,'a t tT twoul bedihc tt fnd
t e pe o ny pec fc rng ii ' nd ha f
i
d
f ul o i

t a ac mpa ofa sz t td e no ha çadve st poiy).
od y o ny ny ie ha o s t v i riy l '
c
W ene t cont ndst tt tm i oft s a e e si i ca i ofr cedic i i
i rh
e
ha he i ng he t t m nt s ndi tve a
s tm naéon
snc t ywe em a wihi af w da ofhe r asi ent I ed, e ne t m akesm uc of
i e he r
de t n e
ys
r e sgnm . nde W i r h
h

t i ngo he z a sg nta g igt t c us Talyma t pe s nne c n ej ttn
htt
mi f r e sinme , r un ha be a e l
e de he r o l ha g us e
da afe hi a
ys t r s ppoi m e a i erm s rnt nde a wihoutha - knowldgeoft
nt nt s nt i upe i e nt nd t
ndson
e
he
stz
i aéon a t hi s
a
t he gh chool li de ii m us ha bee ba e on W ene t sr ce a or
,ls c son
t ve n s d
i r h' a , ge
.

gende ,r t rt n conce nsr l t d t s de dicpM e ors f y a t hi s hool To be
r a he ha
r e a e o m nt s i
a et t he gh c
.

s e Tale a ed f s , t ne s hoolye rw a r pi y a oa hi To s ge tt tt
ur , ly ct a t but he w c
a s a dl ppr c ng. ug s ha he
o

'

tm i ofW ene t sr s i ma nti pr éve ofr c dic i na i e t i pe ng
l ng
i rh' ea sgr e s oba
a e s rmi don gnor s he m ndi
a de i c l ra i wholy s c a a concus y.
ca m c aenda nd s
l pe uldve pd
l or Thus tlsa gu e i i ufki nt
, li r m nt s ns f e
t r butt w els
o e
he l- uppor e r éonaepr e ed by t SchoolBoa d.
td a
l es nt
he
r
N ori t de l r i oft f m e s rnt nde ,Pa el H ea h,t t e f c t t
s he c a aton
he or r upe i e nt m a
t o he f e t ha
W ene t had pe f - ed wela prncpa oft hi s
i rh
r ot
m
l s i i l he gh choola t ts de be vi
nd ha m nt ha or
i pr d durng he t e,s f e t c e ea ge neis off tast whe he he
m ove
i
t enur ufki nt o r at
nui s ue ac
o
t r r
z s i e w a r ily m otva e Tli e dencem e ey r fec sH e t spos hoc
ea sgnm nt s acal
i t d. as vi
r l e l t a h'
t
dia e r nt t pe s
s gr e he wih r onne c nge m adebyhe s es or a ac tc nnotbas isrzi
l ha s
r ucc s , nd our a
e t tlng
on s h adia t em e .
uc
s g e nt Agai t c tsr ei nott det = i whe he t r s f
n, he out' ol s
o e ne
t r he ea ons or
whi h Talyr s i d W ene t t t r ddl s
c
le ea sgne
i zh o he ni e choola t outetofli t e a i etm
t he s
ls enur s nt i
18

s rnt ntwe e f s ,f i,ore n c r t' butr t rw het rt y Ttul ' e e t
upe i ende
t f e ar
wi
ve ot ec ,'
a he
he he fr y'w r he
'ea onsf t t a sgnm ent D t a ne t ,133F. a 299. bes e H e t safi vi pz ies
r s
or he e s i
. l z te
3d t
To
ur , a h' fda t as

W ene t a he 2013pe f m a et viw ofD i t t hi a una e a e l a ngt li
i th, nd z
t or nc e e
xon a ed m s cc pt bl , e di o zs

r plc me a Vg s ho p i i l ort 2 1 - 01 s ho y a . viusy f me
e a e nt s h c ol rncpa f he 0 3 2 4 c ol e r Ob o l, or r
s rnt
upe i ende H e t a cur s rnt
nt a h nd t ent upe i ende Taly ha dif r ntopi onsast t
nt le ve fe e
ni
o he
r l i quaik a i ofW ene t a Di
eatve lf tons
i th nd xon.H owe r a t pr e sa oft anal i,
ve , t he etxt t ge he
yss

Titi t pe c pto o t d cso ma e whih i r lva t'S t v. a ,6 8F.d 1 6 ,
fj s he z e in f he e ii n k r c s ee n . mih Flx 1 2 0 2
g
'

1 6 (t Ci.1 0. usHe t sdifrnc ofopni i i uf e tt ce t age uie
0 7 4h z 98 )Th , ah' fee e
i on sns i n o tae n n
ki
is ofm at ra f c ast whe he W ene t sr ce a ,otge
s ue
e il a t o
t r i rh' a , ge
nderwasade er i ng f ct i
t m ni a or n

h rr a sg nt S eCo e nv. h i rElc US I .7 5F. p' 2 7 2 (t Ci.
e e sinme . e lma Sc nedç e . A, nc, 5 Ap x 4 , 49 4 h t
20 9 (on l l t tt fc t taf t rs r io beive t a t epli fpe f r d
1 ) c cucng ha he a t ha o me upe vs r l d h t h andf ro me
i
e
hettn ni t s a qua eyw a i ufii ntt esa ih pr t xtand em phasz ng t tft
t i ng a ks de t l s ns fc e o t bls e e
ii ha fhe

hrn ma a e wa e éte t f r ad fe e o nin? Ande s v. e d ho e
ii g n g r s n ld o o m ifz nt pi o ); ron W s n us
S va a mve Co.40 F.d2 , 6 ( h Ci. 0 5 (e og ii t t o t T a ot e uie
a nn h r , 6 3 48 2 9 4t r 2 0 ) r c n zng ha c urs f nn r q r
c
t dif r nts r i or wihi t s m e or ni don m us r c t s m ec l i on a
hat f e e upe v s s t n he a
ga za
t ea h he a
oncuson
n

e o e ' q lka nsa a ide '
mply es uai do nd bl s).
f
i
w enet sa gumentt tt r a t as f he r asi e wast f tt ts di
i th' t
ha He e l e on or r e sgnm nt
he ac ha he d

notl lkem os oft hi s hoolsudent i undenane byt fctt t s mer ca
ook i
t he gh c
t
ss
r i d he a hat he a a il
de og a cse s a t r ddl s hoolt whi h s w a ta f t e and as i
m r phi xit t he ni e c
o
c he s t ns e r d
sgned a
l de s i poséon.Furhe unde m i ng he ar une t tr em otva edTaly' pe s
ea r b p
i
t r
r ni
r gt nt ha ac
i t
le s r onne
l

changesi t f c t Re eBr
s he a t hat ne own,t younger bl k as it ntprncpa att li s hool
he
, ac ss a
i i l he l c ,
gh
wasz s i d t a ee e ar s
ea sgne o n lm nt y choolatt s m etm e. hieBr n r m ane i t r eof
he a i W l ow e i d n he ol

a ssa prncpa ,t f ctt ts wasr m oved f om t li s hools t a ong wih
s it nt i i l he a ha he
e
r
he tgh c
e dng l
t
.
19

W ene t sr l s
i rh tongy uppor st Sc
t he hoolBoa d' a g entt tr c wa nota de e r ni
r s r um
ha a e s
t tni ng

fco i tema g me c n sTalyma a tehghsh l
atr n h na e nt àa ge l
e de t h i c oo.
Fi ly, e ne t hi she c e on t f c t tTal yr pl ed he asli s
nal W i r. nge r as
h
he a t ha le e ac
r 'gh chool
t

prncpa wih D i a f m e prnçpa w hos pe f m ancew a f
i i l t xon, or r i i l
e r or
s ound t beuns ts a t yi
o
a if c or n
m a a ea , ncudi s udenta saf dicplne,i t 2013 e l ton com pl e by t
ny r s i l ng t
nd t f s i i n he
vaua i
et d
he
prors dnt nde . ene t c enott de eTaly, i i notene ey c e rfom t
i upe e nt W i rh hos
o pos le and t s
l la r
he

e idngr c r whehe Talywa a r oft spef r n erviw i ul of2 1 , n he
xs e o d t r l
e s wae hi ro ma c e e nl y 0 6 whe
m a t pe s
de he t onne c nge a is N one hees ,e n as ur ng t the had knowl
l ha s t s ue.
t l s ve s ni ha
edge of
t prore l ton,Tal y wa e l d t f
he i vaua i
le
s néte o onn dif r ntopi onsr ga di D i s
fe e
ni
e r ng xon'

c pa lte a t i vi ls
a biiis nd he ndi dua chool 'saf nee .Se Col m a 755 F.App' a 2499
s t fng ds e e n,
x t
Ande s 406 F. at272.
r on,
3d
Thus t f c t tTa y' a s s m e ofD i squaik a
, he a t ha Ee s s e s nt
xon'
li dons

and a l dif r d fom t oft pr vi s rnt nde i i ufk intt t ie a
bii
ées fe e r hat he e ous upe i e nt s ns l e o a s n
i e e ofpr extordicrm i t yi e .
nf r nce
et
s i na or nt nt
I
V.

Fo t raonssae ,heSc ol r smod frsl r jdg nt( No.
r he e s ttd t ho Boad' on o l
mmay u me ECF
*

.

9 )i GRAN TED a t c s DI M I SED. q z pdaeOr rwi bee e e
9 s
nd he a e S S
An.pp o t de l ntr d.
l

Enee:
td
r

4/
,

*

-2 - Z o?
*- - %
-

2 .
#

-, m
r

.n
- ZC

.
1

M i I IF.
CUC

,
.

anst
li

CY C Yn td SMC DiSVt t é' ' *m
C ic t S S Jl ' * '
dj X

20