Silvious v. RR Donnelley & Sons
Filing
44
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Magistrate Judge B. Waugh Crigler on 7/1/11. (kld)
:k
:**4e' I t.. 5 . /UR
FTC J8 QI ' C T
k ' ATGFARIQTIN@VIi,
'<
t . ' LTVA
Fy
ken .- .
)
j
I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES D I
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI OF V I N I
CT
RGI A
HARRI
SON BURG DI I ON
V SI
OW EN F.SI I
LV OUS,l,
l
J 21 21
UL
1
q
: L , LR
D C K
?
!
:.. .
' :.
u
CASE NO.5: 0CV00l16
l
Pl ntf ,
ai if
M EM ORAN DUM OPI ON
NI
RR DONNELLEY & SON S,eta1,
.
De endant .
f
s
By:B.W AUGH CRI
GLER
U . M AGI
S.
STRATE JUDGE
OnJ ne2 20l ,hedee a , Do ely& S (k nely' , c ns lflda
u 6, 1 t fnd ntRR nn le
ons û
Don le ' by ou e, ie
)
moton t compelt pl ntf sa t
i o
he ai if tendance a hi deposii sc
t s
ton hedul accor ng t a notce f Jul 6,
ed
di o
i or y
201 a teofie o Ha t e orig i Ha rs nb r Vigni5 us s orl al rt J y45f d r l
1 t h fc s f r r p tn n rio u g, r i a j t h t fe he ul ' e e a
y
holday. Bei a e t ,on t da et moton w asfl t onl m ea t c ha a isdipos
i
ng war hat
he t he i
ied, he y
ns he ourt d t t s al
f comm uni tng w ih t pl ntf wasby t ephone ort ough t Unied St t PosalSer c t
or
ca i
t he ai if
el
hr
he t
a es t
vie, he
cour endeavor t s
t
ed o chedul a s a usconf enc ont def ntsmoton fr by t ephone and t
e tt
er e he enda '
i ist el
hen
vi an emai addr sf t pl ntf s i by def ns c el l s yi t emai addr s couns
a
l es or he ai if uppled
e e ouns . n uppl ng he
l es ,
el
i or ed t cour t al t rproreforst us em ai had f l becaus ofa a ents bl
nf m he
t hat 1 hei i f t o e
l
aied
e n ppar pam ocker
.
On June 30,2011,t cour com muni ed a notceoft pendi t eplone sat conf ence t
he
t
cat
i
he
ng el z
t us
er
o
pl ntf t ceby t e
ai if wi
elphoneand once by e ai.The t ephonecalsf om t cour wer metw ih an
m l
el
l r he
t e
t
answe i devi a t e ai çbounced.'Neve hel s t courtpr ded wih t conf encecal as
rng
ce nd he m l ç
'
rt es , he
ocee
t he
er
l
s
chedul a 10: a. .on J y 1,201l. Att tme,and consit ntwih t r t i i Donnele s
ed t 00 m
ul
he i
se
t he eciatons n
ly'
m oton,couns i or e t cour t pl ntf de ton orgi l wass dul by agr
i
el nf m d he
t hat ai ips posii
i naly
che ed
eementf
or
June 23,2011 butbe e ofa f iy em e gency def e c
,
caus
am l
r
ens ouns s
el oughta contnuance. How e ,
i
ver
c elwasnota e t comm uni e wih pl ntf .Thecour r t wasr
ouns
bl o
cat t ai if
t eporer
equesed t cont def e
t o
act ens
h d ai if ppearon J 23:,buthe di nota
une d
d
ppearon t tdat . Al eforsby Donnele s
ha e 1 f t
counsels oul pl ntf a
ly'
counselt c
o omm uni e wih pl ntf havef l t ge a eany r
cat t ai if
aied o ner t
esponse. Couns i onned t cour
el nf
he
t
t r s e ed orceriid maii havebeen r reved and si
hat egit r
tfe
lngs
eti
gned f by pl ntf ' wie,t
or
ai ifs f hough emais
l
contnuet bounce.
i o
A chi r ponsbiiy ofapro s ltga i t m ai ai com m uni ton w ih opposng couns
ef es i lt
e ii nt s o nt n
ca i
t
i
el
and t c t Faii t r pond t eforst com muni e by couns ort cour,orm aki onesel
he our . lng o es
o f t o
cat
el he
t
ng
f
una l e f s comm uni i ,deprves bot c eland t cour ofany opporuniy t addr
vaiabl or uch
catons
i
h ouns
he
t
t t o
ess
mater t ar neces ar f an or rl diposton oft cas W hen s f l eornegl contnues,a
t s hat e
s y or
de y s ii
he e.
uch aiur
ect i
pr s ltgantriksha ng adver e ac i t ken on a
o e ii
s
vi
s ton a
ccountofwha es entaly becom esa f l et
t s il
aiur o
Pr ut
osec e.
Tha i whathashappene her asa r ul ofwhi t cour fndst tDonneley' June 29,
ts
d e,
es t
ch, he
t i ha
l s
201lmoton t com peli wel t
i o
s l aken. By s at Or ,t moton wilbe GRANTED a pl ntf wil
epar e der he
i
l
nd ai if l
bediect t appearf hi deposton on Jul 6,20llat9: a. .a t oficesofHa Repori 84
r ed o
or s
ii
y
30 m t he t
rt
tng,
W es W at Steet Harionbur V igi a and contnui t da untlcom pl e
t er r , rs
g, r ni
i ng hat y i
et d.
Pl ntf her by i W A R NED t f l e t com pl w ih t r qui em e soft
ai if e s
hat aiur o
y t he e r nt
he
O rde m a I ad t t i pos t on ofs t ons i l ng t aw ar t t def ndantofc t
r y k o he m
ii
anc i
nc udi he
d o he e
os s
and at or y' f es a di m i s oft ca e
t ne s e nd s s al he s .
The Cl k oft Cour i diec edt tans i acopy oft sRepor a Recom mendaton t al
er
he
ts r t o r m t
hi
t nd
i o i
couns ofr d and t bot m a la em ai a copy he eoft t pl ntf .
el ecor
o h i nd
l
r o he ai if
EN TERED :
U . M aglta eJudge
S.
sr t
J
Dat :
2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?