Beacon Wireless Solutions, Inc. et al v. Garmin International, Inc. et al
Filing
142
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 5/9/2012. (jat)
W ER : OFFI :, Dlm O ur
OE S. S
AT R- OKE,
VA
'
Fl
'
,
I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FOR THE W ESTERN DI
STRI O F V I N I
CT
RGI A
HA RRI
SON BU RG D I I ON
V SI
z
,
.
f
A
% Jokl
.
j.
2 2 2/
2
'
,
,
BEA CON W I
RELESS SO LU TI S,I C . eta1,
ON N ,
.
Ci lActo N o.5: 1 cvvi
in
1 - 00025
Pl ntf s
ai i f ,
M EM O R AN DU M O PINIO N
GA RM I I
N NTERN A TI A L,l C. etal,
ON
N , .
By: Ho Gln E.
n. e Conr
ad
Chi fU nie St t s Di t i tJ
e
t d a e s rc udge
D ef
endant
s.
Th sc s i p e e tyb f r t ec u t nted fn a t' to f rs mmayj d me t
i a e s r s n l eo e h o r o h ee d n s moin o u r u g n .
Fort r s nss tf t be ow,hec t l g a i pa ta de i par t de e nt '
he ea o e orh l t our wil r nt n r nd ny n the f nda s
m oton.
i
1.
Fact and ProceduralBackaround
ual
Be onW iee sSol i ,nc.iBea on' a Be onW iees Eur ( Li td
ac
r ls utons I (l c ' nd ac
)
r l s ope UK) mie
(Be c nEu o e'(o lci ey C litfs' iiitdt scv l cino M ac 21 2 1
û a o r p ' c le tv l,k an if' ntae hi ii a to n rh , 01
i
)
p
)
a i tGami I enai ,l (t r nItr tona')andGar nUSA,l .ts nni
gans r n ntr tonal nc.ûGami nenai l'
mi
nc ç
Ga n
USA' ( l tvey,S e nt'.Thi c ese fom abusnes rltons pgoneba
' coleci l c nda s'
)
def
) s as tms r
i s eai hi
d
be w e n t o t hnol co pa e t ti ta l co l bor t t desgn and m a ke a
t e w ec ogy m ni s ha nii ly la a ed o i
r tn
a i a i t tw o d i e a e Be con' G l
pplc ton ha ul nt gr t a
s obalPos to ng Sys e ve cl t a ki pr r m
ii ni
t m hi e r c ng og a
it Gami It nai lspes lna gai de c (t '.Ese i l t pl nif
no r n ner tona' rona vi ton vies :
PND' sntaly,he aitfs
)
cl i t tt de e
a m ha he f ndant ,ba e on i talr pr s nt tons ofcom pe a i t pe i o t
s sd
nii e e e a i
ns ton, ap d nt he
pl n if 's i i d know l
ai tf s pec alze
edge oft t e tm a ge e i t y a t i e e i fe t
he l e na m nt ndus r nd he r xt nsve l e
m anagem ents em pl f t devel an a i ton t w oul alow t def
yst
at onn o
op
pplca i hat
d l he endant t
so
i egrat t rPN D S w ih t pl ntf s'vehi e t
nt
e hei
t he ai i f
cl racki pr
ng ogram and t
hen,unbeknownstt t
o he
pl i if , a t a i aton s cii to publc s t tt def nda scoul boos PN D
a ntf s m de he pplc i pe fca i ns
i o ha he e nt
d
t
E
s l by a l ngt pli tfs c
aes lowi he a n if ' ompe io st i e r t t i ve c etac ngpr a si t t
tt r o nt g ae her hil r ki
ogr m n o he
de e
f ndan s PN D Sasw e l M o e s ii a l t pl i t fs c ai t tt de e nt
t'
l. r pec f c ly, he a n if l m ha he f nda s
mia opra e t pl ntfs ta s c e sa br c d anondicl ur ag e me
s ppr it d he ai if ' r de e r t nd ea he
s os e r e nt
(s ondicos eAg e me )e c e bybohpa te t tpr bie eihe pa t fom
d
N s l ur r e nf' xe utd
t ris ha ohi td t r ry r
di c os ng t ot rpa t spr pr e ar i or a i orf om utlz ng s h i or a i f a
s l i he he r y' o i t y nf m ton r
ii i uc nf m ton or ny
pur eunr a e t t pa tes busne sr ai ns p.Fu t nnor t pl i if a s r t t by
pos
elt d o he ri ' i s elto hi
rhe
e, he antfs s e t ha ,
m a ng publct pli if 'pr it r i onua i r ga di t a i ton, hede e
ki
i he antf s opre a y nf
ton e r ng he pplcai t
f ndan s
t
t i r t c l ps oft a i a i sm a ke va ue t t pl ntf s The pl i if alo cl i
rgge ed he ola e he pplc ton' r t l o he ai i f .
a ntf s s a m
t tt de e nt utlz t pl i if 'pr i t r tee m a
ha he f nda s ii ed he a ntf s opr e a y l t nage e s t m pl t o m a
m nt ys e
a f r nd
o he ta s r t i a m a rno c e pl t d by t nondi c os e a e e . Fur he m or ,
t r r de ec e s n
nne t ont m a e
he
s l ur gr em nt
t r e
a c r i t t epan if,h d fn a t we eu j sl e rc dtr ug t ep an if'
c o dng o h litfs t e e e d n s r nu ty n ihe h o h h litfs
unco pe a e pr s on ofva uabl s r c s a r s ce f om w hi t de e nt
m ns t d ovi i
l e e vi e nd e our s r
ch he f nda s
be ft by s li PN D Si or r tng t a i ton. The pl ntf si ta ed t sl w s t
ne ied
e lng
nc po a i he pplca i
ai i f nii t hi a ui,
br ngi c a m s a i tt de e nt f m i a opra i oftade s c e s br a h ofco r c ,
i ng l i ga ns he f nda s or s ppr i ton r
e rt, e c
nt a t
brac ofa i i i fc c r c, un us e ihme t ( cke No.1.
e h n mpled-n-a t onta tand j t nrc n. Do t
)
The def nda spr vi l m ove t c tt ta f rve a t dim i st i pled
e nt e ous y
d he our o r ns e nue nd o s s he m i
ober
he
s ue
andum
c n rc a du j te rc me tcams On Oct 5,2011,t courti s d a mem or
o ta t n nus n ih n li .
opi o on t de e nt'motons ( ke No. ) Thec t nidt mot t ta fr
ni n
he f nda s
i . Doc t 38.
our de e he i o rnse
on
ve
nue, g a e i pa t nd de e i pa tt m o i t di m i s The c tg a t d t m oto
but r nt d n r a
ni d n r he ton o s s .
our r n e he i n
t di m i sw ih r pe tt Bea on' i ple i f c c r tc a m ,de er i ng t tt
o s s t es c o
c s m i d-n- a t ontac l i
t m ni ha he
pli if 'i id c r c cai e a t d fom t s me f c sa cic sa st tga rs
antfs mple onta t l m m na e r he a a t nd r um t nce ha ve ie
t t rexpr cont actcl m . M or s fcaly,t courtconcl
o hei
ess
r
ai
e pecii l he
uded t t conductwhi
hat he
ch,
accor ng t t pl ntf s,exceeded t s
di o he ai i f
he cope oft N ondi os e A gr entand f m ed t
he
scl ur
eem
or
he
ba i frt i i c r tcli (hepr s ofc
ss o he mpled ontac am t omies ompe ai andt pr sonofsr ce
nston
he ovii
evi s
a rs c )fowe fo t Nondicos eAgre ntsune o c a eta e me t a e '
nd e oures l d r m he
sl ur
e me ' nfr e bl tgre nt o gre'
pr vi i How e r a t
o s on.
ve , lhoug t c tdim i s Be on' i ple c r c c a m , he c t
h he our s s ed ac s m i d ont a t l i t our
t unde a s ntt m oto t dimisa t Be on Eur pe' i i c r tc am ,
ook
r dvieme he i n o s s s o ac
o s mpled ontac l i
de e mi ng t tt Nondicos eAgr e e twa n guouswih r s c t wheherBe c
t r ni ha he
s l ur
e m n s mbi
t e pe t o
t
a on
Eur w as a part t t contact
ope
y o he
r .
F rh r r,hec u t e idt emo int ds s wi r s e t ob t pan if' nu t
u temo e t o r d ne h to o imis t ep c t oh litfs u j s
h
e c me t li , eemii t a t eu j s e rc n cam a g a l e n td fo a
mi h n cams d tr nng h t h nu t n ihme t li r u b y ma ae r m
b oa rs toff c st n t cic s a e t tg rs t t e e s c r tcl i . M o e
r de e
a t ha he r um t nc s ha ave i e o he xpr s ontac a m
r
s e iial tec u t eemie t a t eu j s e rc me t li c ude c mpa smo e
p cfc l h o r d tr n d h t h nu t n ih n cam o l n o s r
y,
c uc t nt meeus anddicos eofc i nta i omai (heconduc embrce by
ond tha he r e
s l ur onfde ilnfr ton t
t
a d
t ee p e sc nrc cam)i t a teu j s e rc me tcam a g byc ne ltdte
h x r s o ta t li n h th nu t n ih n li r ua l o tmpae h
al ton t tt de e nt a opra e t a plcai a i t gr t d i i o ac me cil
legai ha he f nda s ppr it d he p i ton nd n e a e t nt om r a
pr twhi ht def nda st n s d.
oduc
c he e nt he ol
The ea t ,on Apr l1 201 t de e nt fl a s l m oton f s m a y
r fer
i 2, 2, he f nda s ied ea ed
i or um r
j d me tag i gt a n g n i is eo maeil a te it a t a y o t ep an if' o r
u g n , r u n h t o e une su f tra fc x ss s o n f h litfs f u
cams (
li . Docke No. ) Thepl ntfsfldt i s aldbrefi opposto onAprl25,201
t 86.
ai if ie her e e i n
iin
i
2,
c e ng t tt exi t e ofge ne i s ofm a e i lf c pr c ude e r of s m a y
ont ndi ha he senc
nui s ues
t ra a t e l s nty
um r
j
udgme i fvoroft de e nt (
nt n a
he f nda s. Docke No.111) Thedee nt fl t i rpl bre on
t
.
fnda s ied her e y if
M a 2,201 ( ke No.1 ) Theco the r agume o t moi onM a 4, 2.
y
2. Doc t
25.
ur ad r nt n he ton
y 201
II.
D i si
scus on
A.
Standard ofre ew
vi
I c n ie igamoinf rs mmayj d me tu e F d r l l o Cii P o e u e5 ,
n o sd rn
to o u r u g n nd r e ea Rue f vl r c d r 6
çt co ti r quied t vi t f c sand dr r as bl i e e e i a lghtm os f vor bl
she ur s e r o ew he a t
aw e ona e nf r nc s n i
ta a e
t t nonmovi pa t ' Sha v. r 1 F. 791 798( h Ci.1 .Thec r ma
o he
ng ry. w Stoud, 3 3d , 4t r 994)
'
ou t y
g a ts mmayj d me t nl wh n viwigterc r a awh l a di t elg tmo t
rn u r u g n o y e , e n h e od s oe n n h ih s
f vor bl t t nonm ovi pa t t r i no ge ui i s ofm a e i f c a t nonm ovi
a a e o he
ng ry, he e s
n ne s ue
t ral a t nd he
ng
p ry i e tte t j d me a amatro lw.Ceoe Co p v. tet 4 7U.. 1 , 2 - 4
a t s n ild o u g nt s t f a
e
ltx r . Cart, 7 S 3 7 3 2 2
( 986) Ter sFl Fa hi .I .v.Buri tnl .l ,763F. 6 61 ( h Ci.1 )
1 , ry' oor s ons nc
.
lngo ndus.nc.
2d 04, 0 4t r 985 .
Fo ap ry' e ie c t rieag n ieis eo maeilfc t a a iss mma yj d me t
r at s vd n e o as e un su f tra a t h t vod u r u g n ,
t e ie c mu t el uc ta ara o a l j r c udrt n av r itf rt en n vng
he vd n e s b i h h t e s n b e u y o l eur ed c o h o mo i
s
pa t ' Andes v.Li rvLo l .477U. 2 248( 986)
ry.
'
ron
be t bby.nc,
S. 42, 1 .
B.
A nal s
ysi
1.
Trade secret cl m
s ai
A ss a e a
t t d bove, he pl i if as e t c ai a i tt de e nt unde t Kans
t
a ntf s s r a l m ga ns he f nda s
r he
as
Unior TrdeSecesAc (C
fm a
rt t 4
KUTSA' agui t tt defnda smia o itdt rta
), r ng ha he e nt s pprprae hei rde
s r t . To es a i h t i o m a i qu ii sasa t a s c e unde K a a l a pl i if
ec e s
t bls hat nf r ton alf e
r de e r t
r ns s aw, a ntf
mus s t tt i or ton( )ha i pe te onomi vaue;( dervesisval fom
t how ha he nf mai 1 s nde nden c
c l 2) i t ue r
no bengge r l lnownorradiyaserana e;a ()hasiss rcymant ne by
t i nealy c
e l c ti bl nd 3
t ece
i ai d
r a o bl efo t.Dods I 'Pa t.l v. t r,3 F.Supp. 997,1 0( Ka
e s na e frs
on ntl rs nc. Alendo f 47
2d
01 D. n.
20 ;sealoKUTSA,Kan.SttAnn.j60- 204)( 1.
04) e s
a.
33 4 201 )
The def nda sas e t ha t pl i if 'pur t d tade s c e s ditl i o t o s pa a e
e nt s r t t he a ntf s
pore r
e r t s il nt w e r t
c tgores ( )va i faursofBe co sfee ma me s tm t t t oug t
ae i : 1 rous e t e
a n' l t nage nt yse ha,hr h he
4
itg ain a piai n aeds ly do t es re o aGami P a d( )tsigs p o t
n e rto p lc to , r ipa e n h c e n f r n ND, n 2 e tn u p r
pr ded t t defendant t ough t pl ntff 'feetm anagem ents t pl f m . The
ovi
o he
s hr
he ai i s l
ysem ator l
def ndan s c e t tt e de e i t r or i c e t tt e alege tade s c e sdo
e
t ont nd ha he vi nc n he ec d ndi at s ha hes l d r
e rt
not i r a iy,qua iy ass h unde Ka a lw. Fis,a or ng t t def nda s t de in
, n e lt
lf
uc
r ns s a
r t cc di o he e nt, he sg
f a ur s f i t qua i y a ta s c e sbec us t y a e no ke s c e , i t d,a e di pl ed
e t e a l o lf s r de e r t
a e he r t pt e r t but ns ea r s ay
t t pl ntfs'c t e s A c y Sol i . sLLC v. i e t Gr up,I ,81 F.Supp.
o he ai i f usom r . enc
utonscom
Tr z to o
nc. 9
2d 1 ,1 28( D. . 1.Furhemo e t dee nt cone t fat esdei no
001 0 E. Cal201 ) t r r ,he fnda s tnd,he e ur rve
i d pe d n v lefo b i k p s ce, u o l fo p bi us , n te aen t h s b e t
n e n e t au r m eng e t e rt b t ny r m u l e a d h y r o t e u j c
c
ofras bl me ur sofs rc byt pli if.KUTSA j60e ona e as e ece y he antfs
33204 ;Pr esi Pr .
4) ocr sve ods,
I v.Swat 258P. 969,978( n.2011.Thedee nt aloa guet tKUTSA' t e nc.
rz,
3d
Ka
)
fnda s s r ha
S hre
ye rsaut oflmia i ba sa aci by t pli if wih r pec t e g oft t ve
a t t e i ttons r n ton he antfs t es t o i ht he wel
fau e .KUTSA j6 - 25
e t rs
0 33 .
Se
cond, he de e nt ca ego i e t pl i if 'pur t t s i t a s r t asnot ng
t
f nda s t r z he a ntf s
pored e tng r de ec e s
hi
mor t npr blm -ol ng s ppor a t ha d r c tt i t pli if 'c
e ha o e s vi u
t nd he r wa e onsiutng he antf s omm unia i
c ton
box. A sG a m i w a de l ng bot t i e f c s c fc tons f t i eg a i n ap i a i
r n s ve opi
h he nt r a e pe i i a i
or he nt r t o plc ton
a t s a et r s de on isPN D S i utlze t pl i if 'c m uni tonsbox a
nd he ohw r o e i
t
, t ii d he a ntf s om
ca i
nd
c l bor t wih t pli if t de glt hesi t a i to a s t r Ac r ng t
ola aed t he antfs o bug ic n he pplcai n nd ofwa e. co di o
t def nt ,t st tng s
he enda s hi es i uppor f l t qua iy a a t a s c etbec us t s
t ais o lf s r de e r
a e he uppor ha no
t s
i pe nte onom i val a i no ke s c e by t pl n if .M or s cii aly, he
nde nde c
c ue nd s t pt e r t he ai t f s
e pe fc l t
dee nt aguet tt yutlz dt pl ntfs'had r (hec
fnda s r ha he iie he ai if rwae t ommuniai box)i t sme
c ton
n he a
ma
mwrasdo t pl i if c t e s Furhe r whiet def nda sdo notc es t tt
he antfs' usom r . t nuo e, l he e nt
ont t ha he
1
I taly,t defndan salo a s redt tt plitfs pum ore ta s c esc e plt at r
nii l he e t s s e t ha he an if'
td r de e r t ontm aed hid
cae y i vi v i f ei lngua tansatonst t smia t t fat es aediplyedont s r e ofa
tgol nvol ng arous or gn a ge r l i ha , i lr o he e ur , r s a
he c e n
G a m i PN D. H owe r i t rr ponsve bref t pl ntfs do notc e i t f ei I
r n
ve , n hei es i i , he ai if
at gorze he or gn angua ta l tons
ge r nsa i
a ta escesb tise d rfrt te meeya i n iaysr ie. ( c e No 1 1a 21)
s rd e rt, u n ta ,ee o h m rl st cl r evc s' Do k t . 1 t .
a l
'
5
tc nc l eal o teplitfs te t na e n s se (..teu deli s u c c d ,
e h ia d tis f h anif 'l e ma g me t y tm e:,h n ryng o re o e
alort ,pr oc s orfr t)quaiya ta sces i i undiput t tt defnda s
g ihms ot ol, omas lf s rde e rt,t s s ed ha he e nt
we e no a f ded a c st t e t c ca de a l . Siva D a a Sys v.l e Cor ,1 Ca .
r t f or
c es o hes e hni l t is l co t
. nt l p. 09 l
Rpr 3d27,34( l Ct App. 0 ,o ruldonohe grundsbyKwi e DaaSys v.ne
t,
Ca. .
201 ) ver e
t r o
ks t t . ltl
Co , 46P.d8 7( l 2 1 (on d e n tb e e uigma hnera a l s fwae S e
m.2 3 7 Ca. 01 ) C e o s o , y x c t
l
n c i -e d be o t r ,us '
t unde l ng s ce c e;nordoesone ac r t r ui ie know l dge ofa t a s c e s
he
r yi our od
quie he eq st
e
ny r de e r t
e
mbodi i t tc ')
ed n ha ode. .
'
I r pons ,t pl i if c e t tt i tade s r t di tl i o t r e s pa a e
n es
e he a ntf s ont nd ha he r r
ec e s sil nt h e e r t
c tg re :( )tec mbnain o tet led sg fau e ;2 t s u c c d a doh r
ae ois 1 h o i to f h wev ei n e tr s () he o re o e n te
tc c lde a l oft s
e hni a t is he ohwa e r sde i t pli tfs fe tma
r e i nt n he a n if ' l e nage nts t m pl tor a
me yse af m nd
i t tlmaisbo a ()vey s ii tc c li onnai pr de byt pli if t t
n he ee tc x; nd 3 r pectc e hnia nf ton ovi d he antfs o he
d e nt f t pur e ofa s s i t de e nt t e ne rt PN D s t a e and t
ef nda s or he pos
s i tng he f nda s o ngi e he
ofw r
he
i e f es ct a i .W ih r pe tt t co bi to o desgnf t es t pli if
ntrac pe ik tons
t es c o he m na in f i eaur , he antfs
c nt nd e s ntaly t tt vii lt t c t r ofi vi ualf a ur sdoe notviit t ta
o e s e i l ha he sbiiy o usome s ndi d e t e
s
ta e he r de
s c e s a usoft c bi ton oft e f a ur sbec us a t e de e s
e rt tt
he om na i
hos e t e
a e, s he vi nc ugge t , he
ss t
c bi ton w asnott e diy as e t i bl ' i ot rw o ds t c bi ton wasnotea iy
om na i
d a l c r a na e' n he r , he om na i
r
sl
duplc t o a PN D by ot si t s al t m edi - i e c m e ci lte tm a ke untlt
i a ed n
her n he m l o
um s z d om r a l e
r t i he
def ndan spubls d t i e f c s ii a i ns m ade a ia e t i PN D s t a e a s d
e
t
i he he nt r a e pec t c to ,
va l bl he r
of w r , nd ol
c bl st te bl a fee m a em e s t m t c m uni a e w ih a G a m i PN D .
a e ha na e l t nag nt ys e o om
ct t
r n
W ih r s c t t und l ngs c cod and o he t hni lde a l oft pl i if '
t e pe t o he eryi our e e
t r ec ca t is he antfs
s
ohwa e, hepl i if ar t tt de e nt mia opra e t etades c e sb t si
r t
antfs gue ha he f nda s s ppr it d hes r
e r t y e tng
t pr
he oductw ih t uli at purpos ofm aki i avaiabl t a1 oft pl ntf s'com pett s.
t he tm e
e
ng t l e o l he ai if
ior
W ih r pe tt t t chni li o m a i n pr de b t pl i if t t de enda s durng t
t es c o he e ca nf r to ovi d y he a ntf s o he f
nt
i he
6
e ne rng sa t pl i if c e t tt sta f roft hni li or ton c tt e
ngi e i t ge, he antfs ontnd ha hi r nse
ec ca nf ma i onsiutd
m uc m o e t n m e e com m o a e pr e - ol ng s ppor .The s cii i or a i
h r ha
r
npl c obl m s vi u
t
pe fc nf m ton
f nihe s e y t t def nda sw a no ge r l kno n i t i ty and de i is
ur s d ol l o he e nt s t ne aly w n he ndusr
rved t
i pende te
nde
n conom i va ue f om notbei ge r ly know n.
c l r
ng ne a l
Ahe r viwi t pari 'bre s hea i a gume on t is a as es i t
r e e ng he tes i f, rng r
nt he s ue, nd s sng he
e de i t r c d, he co tc ude t tt e s e ofge ne i s sofm a e i lf t
vi nce n he e or t
ur oncl s ha he xit nce
nui s ue
t r a ac
p e l d t ec u t r m g a tn t moinf rs mmayj dg n wi r s e t ot
rcu e h o r fo r nig he to o u r u me t t e p c t he
h
m i a opra i oftade s c e s c ai . M o e s ii ly, he c tde e m i t ta gen ne
s ppr i ton r
e rt l m
r pec fca l t our t r nes ha
ui
is ofmatra f cte ssa t whehe t pli if ha ta s r t und Kans s1w i
s ue
e i l a xit s o
t r he antfs ve r de ec e s er
a a n
t co bi ton oft t ve des g f a ur a i t t c c li or a i pr vi d t t
he m na i
he wel
i n e t es nd n he e hni a nf m ton o de o he
de e nt i t de opm e oft i e f ees cfc to .Ho ve ,bec us t c t
f nda s n he vel
nt he ntra pe ii ai ns we r a e he our
beive t tt de e nt di notm ia opra et tades r t c prs d i t s c co
le s ha he f nda s d
s ppr it he r
ec e s om ie n he our e de
a o he t hni lde a l oft pl i if 's t a e t co twilg an t de e
nd t r ec ca t is he a ntf s ofw r , he ur l r t he f ndan s m o i
t ' ton
frs mmayj d me t st t i a p c o t epanif'KUTSA cam .
o u r u g n a o hs s e t f h li t s
f
li
Ka a lw r cog z t t e nt
ns s a e nies ha , ve hough i vi f alr sofa br de f aur
ndi dual e tze
oa r e t e
c
ombi ton m ihte s i t ma ke ,t c bi ton oft e f t esnonehels m a
nai
g xit n he r t he om na i
hos eaur
t es y
q lf asa t a s c e pr de t tt c bi to is l s ts i s t r r m e soft
ua iy
r de e r t ovi d ha he om na i n t e f a i fe he equie nt
he
tades c e saut . Se Koc Hvdr a bon Co.Di ofKoc l . l v.
r
e rt tt e e
h
oc r
. v.
h ndus, nc. Ande s No.
r on, 90-
1 K,1992W L 79046,a *2-3( Ka 1 (oncudi t talhoug ac ranc t r
292t
D. n. 992) c l ng ha, t h e ti usome
ls wasc piedusngpublc i or ton,age ne is ofma e i lf tno t l s e se
it
om l
i
i nf ma i
nui s ue
t ra ac nehe e s xit d
ast whehe t ls qua ii asata s crtde ndi on Chea ountoftme a e ns i
o
t r he it lfed
r de e e pe ng t m
t
i nd xpe e t
wo dtkefrot r t duplc t t i o mai ';Andew Com . Va DornI .l .
ul a o hes o
iae he nfr ton'
) r
v. n e ndus. nc,
CI A. 88241 0,1 W L 1
V. No. - 4- 990
36779,a * n. ( Ka J y5,1 ( tr ni t t
t 4 3 D. n. ul 990) deemi ng ha,
e n i C ndi d f t es'ofa desgn w e e ûg e a l know n,' he pl ntf c or ton'
ve f t vi ual ea ur '
i
i
r t en r ly
't
ai i f om a i s
t xa tc bi ton off a ur s c d be c r c e i d a a uni s uton t t ne ofis
t c om na i
e
e t e oul
ha a t rze s
que ol i o he eds t
c t rbas a t quaiya a(r s ce'';Ma v.Taz Che Co.440P. 640,
usome e nd hus lf s tade e rt'l nn
te m. ,
2d
647( n.1 )(i ta sc e ca e s i ac nai ofc
Ka 968 E r de e r t n xit n ombi ton ompone s e hofwhih,by
A
nt, ac
c
is f m i be i t publc dom a n.A know l dge oft bes com bi t o ofpr e s sor
t el, ght n he
i
i
e
he t
na i n
oc s e
s tmsofco nai ofelme t ma a untt atades rt'.
yse
mbi ton e ns y mo o r ece.'
)
The pl ntf si t i t ntca e poi tt e de e i t r co d s
ai if n he ns a
s
n o vi nc n he e r ugges i t tt
tng ha he
pr c s com bi ton off t esof e ed by t i pr
e ie
na i
ea ur
fr
he r oduc w a no ,i t w o dsoft s a ut ,
t s t n he r
he t t e
C e diy a c r a na e, ore s l r plc bl i a G a n PN D i t s c o oft f e t
t a l s e t i bl ' a iy e i a e, n
r
'
nni
n he e t r he l e
m a ge e i usr s r d by t pli if be o et de e nt publs d t ei e f ce
na m nt nd ty e ve
he antfs f r he f nda s
ihe l nt ra
z
s ii atons m a a l e t i PN D s
pec fc i , de vaiabl he r
ohwa e a s d c
r , nd ol onne tng c es K oc
c i abl .
h
Hvdr a bon Co. D i ofK oc I
oc r
, v.
h ndus .l . 1 W L 790 a *
. nc , 992
46, t 2-3. Evi nc i t r c d
de e n he e or
as s sst tt sco bi to off a ur sde i d i pende ec
lo ugge t ha hi m nai n e t e rve nde
nt onomi val fom not
c ue r
ben ra iya c rana l a dwa t es b e to r ao a eef rso sc e y.S eA1 W . t
ig e d l s e ti be n s h u j c f e s n bl fo t f e r c e 1 Pe
Suppl Co.v.HilsPe Pr .Di ,Col t- molveCo.8 F.
v
l' t ods v. caepal i
, 40 Supp.1 1 ( Ka
433, 438 D. n.
1 )(tW l t rt pos e s ofs hi or tonha tke r s na ese t pr e tis
993 tg hehe he s sor uc nf mai s a n ea o bl tps o otc t
scec i as aquesi offc . . ( nl ra ona ee f t ar rquie t pr tc t
e r y s lo
ton a t . . Ol y e s bl fors e e r d o oe t he
scec ofpuai ta s rt,nota1c eva eef t ....) Theef e,hec t
er y
ttve rde eces
l onc i bl fors '. r or t our
'
conc ude t ta ge ne i s ofm a e i lf c e s sa t whe he t pl ntf s co bi ton of
l s ha
nui s ue
t r a a t xi t s o
t r he ai if ' m na i
t e ve de i f a ur s c tt esa t a s c e u rKa a l w . Se U ni r a Eng a ngw l
s gn e t e ons iut
r de e r t nde ns s a
e ve s l r vi
l v.Duat 51 F.Supp.2d 11 11 ( Ka 20 CThee se eofatades rti a
nc.
re, 9
40, 51 D. n. 07)
xitnc
r ece s n
is f t tiroffc.'' 1W . tSuppl Co.840F. pp.a 1 7(; e se o a
sue or he re a t' ,
) Al Pe
v ,
Su t 43 $The xitnce f
8
tades r tund t Unior Tr de Sec e sAc i aque ton off tf de e na i byt
r
ec e
er he f m a
rt t s
si
ac or t nni ton he
tiroffc.)
re a t'.
'
Furhe m or a t r g ne i s ofm a e i lf c exi t a t w he he t s cii
t r e, no he enui s ue
t ra a t s s s o
t r he pe fc
tc c li onnatont tt pli if ta mitdt t defnda s(o alw t dee nt t
e hnia nf
i ha he antfs rns te o he e nt t lo he fnda s o
ac r t t vedesgnfaursont i PNDs flswihi t a tofata s rtunde
quie he wel
i et e
her
) al t n he mbi
rde ece
r
KU TSA . U ni s Eng avi l ,51 F.Supp. a 1 ; 1 W . tSuppl Co. 8 F.
ver al r nc. nc. 9
2d t 15l A l Pe
v
, 40
Supp. 1
at 437. Evi nc i t r or s esst tt si or ton wa notge r lykn
de e n he ec d ugg t ha hi nf ma i
s
ne al own,
wa t s b e to ra o a eme s rso sce yb t epanif, n d rv di d p n e t
s he u j c f e s n bl a u e f e r c y h li t s a d e ie n e e d n
f
ec no i va ue bas d on is e usve s i t m a ke . Fort e r a ons t co tw ilde t
o m c l
e
t l i ne s n he r t
hes e s , he ur l ny he
moinf rs mmayj d me ta t t eKUTS cam rltn t t epan if ' o i aino
to o u r u g n s o h
A li eaig o h litfs c mb n to f
desgn f aur sa t hni a i or a i pr de t t deenda s2
i e t e nd ec c l nf m ton ovi d o he f nt .
On t o he ha a e ai d a
he t r nd, s xpl ne bove, hec r wilg an t moton a t t KUTSA
t ou t l r t he i s o he
c a m a i r l t s t t s r e code a ot rt c m i lde aisoft pl i i f 's t a e. A s
l i s t e a e o he ou c
nd he e l ca t l
he a ntf s ofw r
sa e a
t t d bove, her i no di put t tt pl i if di notafor t de e nt a e st t s
t es
s e ha he a ntf s d
f d he f nda s cc s o he e
t l i alde ais. Fo t sr as t c t le t tt de enda sdi notus o o he wi e
ec m c
tl
r hi e on, he our be i ves ha he f
nt d
e r t r s
2
I s r i , tec u tee t ted fn a t' rume tta KUTS Strey a saueo lmi to sb r
n o ulng h o r rjcs h ee d ns ag n h t
A' h e -e r ttt fi t in as
a
a a tonbyt pl ntfswih r pe t eihtoft t l de in fatr s Ac di t t deenda s t
n ci
he ai if t es ct o g
he weve sg e u e . cor ng o he f nt,he
pl ntfskne orr as bl s d ha knownt tt defnda s'fr tac ofalege m ia oprai ofei t
ai if
w
e ona y houl ve
ha he e nt is t
l d s ppr iton
gh
o t ef au e o c r dmo et a t r ey a sb f r t e isa t utwa tld o M a c 21 2 1 S eKUTS j
f h e tr s c ure r h n h e e r e o e h n tn s i s ie n r h , 01 . e
A
6 -3 5(ç a to frmia p o rainmu t ebo g t t ntrey asa trtemia p o raini
03 2 ç cin o sp r pito s b ru h wi h e er fe h s p rp ito s
An
hi
ds o ee o b tee ecs o rao a edig n es o l h v b e dso ee '.l tal,h c ut oe ta,
ic v rd r y h x r ie f e s n bl l e c h ud a e en ic v rd.) ni ly te o r n ts h t
i
' i
t t exentt tt defndant ase tt tt saut oflm iai be n t r n whent pa tesm a va ius
o he t ha he e
s sr ha he tt e i ttons ga o u
he ri
de ro
pu i de onsr to ordicos esoft fa r st m s l sfom 2006t 2008,t sagum en f l bec us ,a
blc m tains
s l ur
he e m e he eve r
o
hi r
t ais a e s
dic s d a
s us e bove,mer publcdicl ur oft f t est s vesdi notnec s iy desr tades r tsausi
e
i s os e he eaur hem el
d
esarl toy r ec e tt f
du ia i silr ne difc t Thedee a sas bas t i saut oflm iai a gum e on t i a s ri
plc ton tl emai d fiul.
fnd nt lo e her tt e i ttons r
nt her s e ton
t ,i Fe uay 2007,t deenda spubls d a eal veso oft a i to s ika i f fveoft
hat n br r
he f nt
ihe n ry rin he pplcain pect tons or i
he
t vedesgn fa u e Furher or t defndant poi t e de ei t r or s
wel
i e t r s. t m e,he e
s nt o vi nc n he ec d uggesi t tt pl ntfs
tng ha he ai if
wer a aeoft spublcdicl ur fom Fe uay 2007t M a c 2008.Howe ,t sa gum e lke s m us
ew r
hi
i s os e r
br r
o rh
ver hi r
nt i wie t
fi.Theplitfspoi t e de i t rcor i c tngt tt defndanst m s l swe euns eofwhen,
al
anif nt o vi nce n he e d ndia i ha he e t he eve r
ur
e cl t s cik ai we epubls d.I a eve ,t cou tfndsm os convi ngt pl ntfs'a g e
xa ty, he pe t tons r
ihe n ny nt he r i
t
nci he ai if r um nt
t tt m e epublc ton oft i e fces cii tons by is l,woul notr ndert fatr sr diy a c ti bl
ha he r
iai
he ntra pe fcai , tef
d
e
he e tle ea l s erana e
w ihou t sm ula ousa l lt oft PND s t r a con ci c e . Ahe al,iw a t c bi to
t t he i t ne
vaiabiiy he
ofwa e nd ne tng abls
r l t s he om nain
oft desgn f at r st tcons iut st pl ntf s pur td t a s cr t . I s t t c tde e m i t tt
he i e u e ha
tt e he ai if ' pore r de e e s n hor, he our t r nes ha he
def nda shave f l t ca r t rbur ofpe s s o on t ssa u e oflmia i a gum e .
e nt
aied o r y hei den
r ua i n hi tt t
i t tons r
nt
9
mi a opraet s t hni a dea l whe t yutlz d t pl n if 't e ai sha dwa et
s ppr it he e ec c l tis n he iie he aitfs elm tc r r o
t s mz de l t i e f ce s c fc tons a t s t a e r s de on t PN D S Se K U TSA
e t d ve op he nt r a pe i i a i
nd he ofw r e i nt he
. e
j6 - 3 0 2 (r v dn ta ç s p r p ito 'me nset e t c u sto 'o û icos r o
0 3 2 4) p o i ig h t s a p o rain' a i r t q iiin' r û s l u e r
mi
h a
d
us 'ofata s cel seas Siva o,1 Ca. r 3da 3 ($ doe no , e cutng
e' r de e rt; e lo l c 09 lRpt. t 4 EOne s t by xe i
m ac ne r ada e s t e ç e't unde l ng s ur e c
hi - e bl of war , us he
r yi o c ode; doesone a uie t r s t
nor
cq r he equiie
knowldgeofa ta s c ese
e
ny r de e r t mbodidi t c ' .Theeor t co twilg a tt
e n hat ode.)
'
rf e,he ur l r n he
moi nf rs mmayj d me t t r s e tot eKUTS cam a ir ltst tepan if'
to o u r u g n wi e p c t h
h
A li s t eae o h litfs
s ur c a ot rt c c lde aisr s de i t i s t r .
o ce ode nd he e hni a t l e i nt n he r ofwa e
2.
Bre h ofc r tc ai
ac
ont ac l m
A s s a e a ve t pl n if brng a br ac ofconta ta ton a ns t de e nt ,
t t d bo , he ai t f s i
e h
r c c i gai t he f nda s
c e ng t tt de e nt br ac d t N ondi c os e A g ee e tby di cl i t
ont ndi ha he f nda s e he he
s l ur r m n
s os ng he
pl i if 'c i nta i or a i ast tt r i de i d i t c r c ,t t r pa tes a by
a ntf s ont de i l nf m ton, ha e m s f ne n he ont a t o hi d ri , nd
o he wieusng s h i or ton i ama rnotc t mplt d by t c r c . Thedefnda t
t r s i uc nf ma i n
nne
on e a e
he onta t
e ns
a s r t tno g nui is ofm ae ilf te sswih r pe tt t br a ofc r tcli
s e t ha
e ne s ue
tra ac xit t es c o he e ch ontac am
be a e none oft i or a i t tt y di c os d orus d f lw ihi t a bi oft
c us
he nf m ton ha he s l e
e el t n he m t he
Nondicos eAg e ment
s l ur r e
.
Cl us 1oft N ondi c os e A gr e e tpr de
a e
he
s l ur
e m n ovi s:
d
t i t a i or a i 'a us d i t s A gr e e s l i l
confden i l nf m ton' s e n hi
e m nt ha l nc ude,buti
s
no lm ie t a l tade s c e s non- i i or a i da a, know - ,
t i t d o, l r
e rt,
publc nf m ton, t
how
doc ntton,hadwae,s fwae (ncudi lsi t r ofand doc tton
ume ai
r r o t r i l ng itngs he e
umenai
rltd t r t ,di a ,drwi a s iiai r ai t a pa t is
eae he eo) agrms a ngs nd pecfc tons eltng o
ry, t
busne s or pr
i s
oduc s w hi h i m a ke a i ont de t a ' or k opr e a y' a
t
c s r d s t i n i l'
c
û
pr i t r ' nd
whi h i di cl e by e t rpa t t t ot rpa t I onna i di c os d or ly
c s s os d
ihe r y o he he ry. nf
ton s l e a l
o vi ualy s l be c i r d Contde i l l or a i i s h i or a i i
r s l ha l
ons de e
i nta nf m ton f uc nf m ton s
i ii as tconfdental' or lpropr e ar ' at t tm e of di cl e and i
dentted
t i i'
l
i t y'
he i
s osur
s
r uce t wrt e s m a y f m by t di c os ng pa t a s ntt t r e vi
ed d o it n um r or
he s l i
ry nd e o he ec i ng
pat wihi t ry ( )da a tri taldicosze. Durng t st ry ( da
ry t n hit 30 ys fe nii sl lr
i hi hit 30) y
pe i s h or l or vi ua i or a i s dic os s l be pr de t s e
r od, uc a
s l nf m ton o s l ed ha l
ovi d he am
pr ecton as ConfdentalI orm aton.
ot i
i i nf
i
10
( ke No.1 1a 1)
Doc t
- t.
Ac or ngt t de e
c di o he f ndan s t pl ntfsf ie t ma k a confde i orpr itr
t , he ai if al d o r s
i ntal
oprea y
any oft doc en s orot r i or a i t tt y pr vi d t t de e nt i t c s of
he um t
he nf m ton ha he o de o he f nda s n he our e
t i bus ne sr a i hi A s s h, he de e nt a gue t ti onna i i nots e tw ihi
he r i s el tons p.
uc t
f nda s r , ha nf
ton s
w p tn
t c r tsr a h.Howe r t pl i if a g t tt çs l i l buti notlm ie t '
he ontac ' e c
ve , he antfs r ue ha he thal ncude,
s
i t d o'
ln ua eo tec nr c ij csa iui it t c nrc a drn e si a n bl t t
a g g f h o ta t ne t mb g t n o he o ta t n e d r t me a e o he
y
i t r e a i t tdco i nta l o to 'i no lm ie onl t i or a i n l bel d a s h.
n e pr t ton ha t ntde i l nf nna i n' s t i t d y o nf m t o a e s uc
Addii ly, hepl ntfsc e t tt s e ntc
tona l t ai if ontnd ha he ubs que onduc ofbo h pa te i ha t l
t
t ri s n biualy
e ha ng i or i n wihoutm a ki a c i nta orpr it r n nded t
xc ngi nf mato t
r ng s onfde il
opre a y me
he
N ondi c os e A g ee ent The de e nt as e t ha t pl i if 'û our e ofdea i '
s l ur r m .
f nda s s r t t he a ntf s i s
c
lngs'
a g entm us f lbas d upon t N ondi c os e Agr m e ' r qui e entt ta1 a e e s
r um
t ai e
he
s l ur
ee nt s e r m
ha l m ndm nt
t t c r tm us be i w rtng.
o he ontac
t n ii
t nde K a as l w ,t i s ofw he hera c t a ti a bi
s
u r ns a he s ue
t
on r c s m guousi a que ton of1 w t
s
si
a o
be de e m i d by t co t' I e a e Li ng Cm t . l v. om es e d Co. 1 F.Supp.
t r ne
he ur . nt ar t d vi
'
vs . nc. H
ta
, 06
2d
11 ,11 ( Ka 2000)( tng Clr v.Pr nta I .Co.ofAm.464P. 253, 6( n.
41 43 D. n.
cii ak ude il ns
,
2d
25 Ka
1 7 ).Assae i o e c u t u igtemoinh ai ,h c u t o cud st a ca e1o
9 0)
ttd n p n o r d rn h to e rng t e o r c n l e h t lus f
t Nondicos eAgr eme i no a g
he
s l ur
e nt s t mbiuous buti t d,cea l r uie t ti onna i be
, nsea l ry eq r s ha nf
ton
m a ked a c nfde i lo pr pre ar t qua i y a (co i n i ll or a i 'wihi t
r
s o i nta r o i t y o lf s s nf de t a nf m ton' t n he
m e ni oft c r c . H o e , hi l alc l i doesnote t a l i . Se Scha e
a ng he ont a t
w ver t s eg onc uson
nd he na ys s e
fr
v.Al Thi sExtror l ,1 P.d450,2007W L 258 69,a *2( n.CtApp.
1 ng ei , nc. 66 3
05 t Ka .
2007)
(
unpubls tbl de son)( i t tt i eprttonofawrtenc rc pr e t a
ihed a e cii notng ha he ntr eai
it onta t es ns
spaaequesi fo whehe awrte c r tha be nmodiid) Ast pli if pr ry
e rt
ton rm
t r itn ontac s e
fe . he antfs opel
f e s i t i a gtm e ,c ti we ls tl d i K a ast Che t r sofa w rten c r c m a
or ca t n he r r l nt d s l e te n ns hat t e m
i
it onta t y
11
be va i d,m odii d,wai
re
fe
ved,a l d,o w holy s ta i by a s eque l e u e
nnule r
l e s de
ny ubs
nty xec t d
contact whet s s
r ,
her uch ubsequenty execut contactbe i w rtng ori par .' Car x Serv.
l
ed
r
n ii
n ol'' -
Sys.l .v.Ki leler 927F. 511,518( 0hCi.1 )(uotngCoonr d& W azConsr
. nc, dd-l l ,
2d
1 t r 991 q i
o
l
t.
Co.v. otlEntr.l .535P. 971,979 0( n.1 ) ûf si tu eve whe t
M e es.nc,
2d
-8 Ka 975). çhi s r e n n he
m i t n co r c c ai a pr son pum ori t r ui e t ts e ntm odik a i nsbe
te nt a t ont ns ovi i
tng o eq r ha ubs que
t to
e de edbyawrtng. #-(ii Nihol & She r Co.v.Ma 92P.5 5 ( n.
vi nc
ii ' s ctng c s
'J
pad
xon,
45, 46 Ka
1 )
907).
The Supr m e Cour ofK a a ha e a ne t s S odi i a i 'doc rne:
e
t
ns s s xpl i d hi é
m fc ton' ti
One pa t t a c r c c l otunia e a l c nge t t r st r of M odii a i
ry o ont a t a m
l t r ly ha
he e m he e .
fc ton
r quies t a s nt of a l t pa te t t co r c . The r m ut l as e i as
e r he s e
l he ri s o he nt a t
i
ua s nt s
m uc a r qui ie i efec i a m od tc ton a i i i t i tal c e ton of a
h e s t n f tng
ii a i s t s n he nii r a i
c r t M ut as e m a noto y be s w n by a e es agr e e , a s
ontac .
ual s nt y
nl
ho
n xpr s e m nt but l o
m a be i ple f om t c r um s a esa c
y
m i d r he ic t nc nd onduc oft pa tes l e t rca e
t he r i . n ihe s ,
howe r t r m us be a m e tng of t m i w ih r s c t t pr
ve , he e
t
ei
he nds t e pe t o he opos d
e
m odii a i
f c ton.
Fa t Ka n 4 P.d9 8 9 ( n. 9 )
s v. ha , 81 2 5 , 61 Ka 1 71 .
Furhe mor t Sa e m e t modiy ac r c mus bes
t r e, he tgr e nt o
f onta t t uppo td by i pe nt
re
nde nde
c i rton. M as v. e Co.774F.Supp. 61 ( Ka 1 )(ii Bl kv.
onsdeai ' rh Colman ,
'
608, 6 D. n. 991 ctng oc
Fe k,499P. 1 2,1 4 ( n.1 2).kcourss ul besow t hol t twrte c r t
da
2d 05 05 Ka 97 ) k t ho d l o d ha itn ontacs
h v b e mo iidb a t o t ep ris. .' l . itr a q tto mak )(u tn
a e e n dfe y cs f h a t . . d (nen l uoain r s q o ig
e
'
Alxa rv. ik,11 P. 46 467(941) t ns c t ha ge al r s ve
e nde Flc 9 2d 4,
1 ). l as ours ve nerly eer d
Ka
m odii a i n t t e c r um sanc whe e t pa tes S dopt d a c s ofcond tt t i
t c to o hos i c t es
r he r i a e
our e
uc o he r
mut stsa tondifr ntfom t te pr se i t orgi c r c.' l (ntr l
ual aifci fe e r ha x e sd n he i nal onta t'' d. i ena
q tto maksomitd)( i Fat481P. a 962)
uoain r
te quotng s,
2d t .
Som e K a a c eshol t tt s m odii to doc r ne a i s onl t c t uc i
ns s as
d ha hi
tca i n ti pple
y o ons r ton
co r c s Se ee. ,Bos on Hnnna l t l LLC v.Am . c d. Fa iv Phvs c ans N o.1 251
nt a t . e R.
t
h n ',
A a Qf m l
ii ,
0- 0-
12
CM ,201 W L 1
2
37870,a *4( Ka J n.18 201 ;Fiz ni v.Shafr 1 P.d 1 5,
t D. n. a , 2) tmo s
fe , 92 3 8 2008
W L 4291 42, t*4( n. .App.
6 a
Ka Ct
2008)( publs dtbl de iin) Howe r ohe c es
un ihe a e cso .
ve , t r as
t nd t dia e wiht sc r c e i to oft sae o Ka a lw. Se e. ,Ca - Se v.Svs.
e o s gr e t hi ha a t rza in he t t f ns s a
es c. rx r
.
I ,9 F. a 518( tnni ngt tala ebewe nafa hiors e nta afa hie
nc. 27 2d t dee ni ha e s t e r nc s ubtna nd rnc se
s e ntw asm odii by a s eq n ag e e des t t f tt tt or g na con r c
ubt na
fed
ubs ue t r em nt pie he ac ha he i i l t a t
i l dapr so sai t tico dno bemodiide e byawrtngl Pe r Asocss
ncude
oviin ttng ha t ul t
fe xc pt
ii ; nnc o s .
l ,
nc.2006W L 13 2,a *11( tr ni t tm itnwave andwrte modiiai
2025 t deemi ng ha te i r
itn
fc ton
cl us ofa c l c i s vi sconta woul notpr l a fndi ofw ai rorm odii a i i
a es
ole ton er ce
r ct
d
ec ude i ng
ve
tc ton f
Shepa te r i l w avedt i rght ... mademodii ai t t t r s.. wihout
û
t
ri s outne y i her i s or
fc tons o he e m
. t
rgadt t ca e r quii t twaveso c nge bema i wrtng.l Nihol & She r
e r o he lus s e rng ha i r r ha s
de n ii ' ; c s
'
pad
Co.92P. t546( tr ni t tac r c f t s l ofg c dbemodii bya
,
a
deemi ng ha onta t or he ae oods oul
ted
s e nto a ag e m e de pie t orgi c r c ' r qui e en t ta s e nt
ubs que r l r e nt s t he i nal onta t s e r m t ha ny ubs que
a e me sbei wrtng) Sc fr 2007W L 258
gre nt n ii ; hae,
0569,a * ( tr ni t tacove ntnott
t 3 deemi ng ha
na
o
c pe e w a m odii by t c
om t s
fed
he onduc oft pa te des t a pr son t tt ag ee en c d
t he ri s pie ovi i ha he r m t oul
bea nde onl byam ii ) s as 1 Am. ur 2dConta t j51 ( i t tt l l
me d y
tng ; ee lo 7A
J .
rcs 4 notng ha he ' e
u
f l we by c t ge r ly ( st tunl sac r ti r quiedby lw t bei wrtng, he
olo d
ours ne a l C ha es ontac s e r
i
a o n ii t
c r tc nbemodiidorly,e nt
ontac a
fe al ve houghipr de t tica bemodii onl i wrtng'
t ovi s ha t n
fed y n ii ).
A lho h t c s cha t d by Ka a 1 w on t s i s a ar l s t n c e r t c t
t ug he our e r e
ns s a
hi s ue ppe s e s ha l a , he our
no t l si oft opi ont tt r i pes svea hort u rKa a lw (ncudi t
nehees s he ni ha hee s rua i ut iy nde ns s a i l ng he
c s lw ctda )s
a e a ie bove uppori t prpostont ta u mbiuouswrte a e me (t r
tng he o ii ha n nn g
itn gr e nt ohe
t nac tuci c rc)ma bemodii byas eq ta ee t des t awrte
ha onsr ton onta t y
fed
ubs uen gr men, pie itn
am e e pr vi i i t or g na co r c . A s sa e a
ndm nt o s on n he i i l nt a t
t t d bove, vi nce i t i t n c e
e de
n he ns a t as
s
ugge t t t durng t pa tes bus ne sr a i hi ea h pa t pr vi d ar ua y c i n i
s s ha , i he r i ' i s el tons p, c r y o de g bl onfde tal
13
i o mai t t o he wiho ma ki i ass h.Thepli if poi t e de e i c tng
nf r ton o he t r t ut r ng t uc
a ntfs nt o vi nc ndia i
t t def
hat he endant corpor e r esent i under ood t t i or aton t recei f om
s'
at epr
atves
st
hat he nf m i hey
ved r
t pl i tf s a t
he a n if , lhoug no l be ed a s hs a i e d t be te e a confde i la
h t a l s uc w s nt nde o r at d s
i nta nd,
f t r or ,t tt de e n s i t u t e pl est t e tt i or a i a c i nta .
urhe m e ha he f nda t ns r c ed m oye o r a he nf m ton s onfde i l
He c ,heeaeag a y fcsfo wh c ara o a l j r c udd tr n t a t eewa a
n e t r r r u bl a t r m ih e s n be u y o l eemie h t h r s
m ee i oft m i by t pa te ,e de d by t i c s ofco uc , o e e i o a
tng he nds he r i s vi nce
he r our e
nd t t nt r nt n
a e m e t m odiy t N o s l ur A g ee e ' cl us r ga di ho i or a i
gr e nt o
f he ndi c os e r m nt s a e e r ng w nf m ton
e ha d by t pa teswoul quaiy asS
xc nge
he ri
d lf
i i nta l or to 'u rt c r t Ca confde il nf ma i n' nde he ontac . rx
Se v. . l ,927 F. a 51 .Pe r As oc . l ,2006 W L 1
r Svss nc.
2d t 8, nnc o s s s nc.
320252,a *11 Fas ,
t ; t 481
P. at961 N i hol & She r Co. 92 P. t546. Furhe m o e t r a gua y w a new
2d
; c s
pa d ,
a
t r r , he e r bl s
c i r ton f t sm odii a i be a e,
onsde a i or hi
f c ton c us unde t o i na c r t t pa teswer no
r he r gi l ontac , he r i
e t
r quie t m a nt i t s c e y oft ot rpa te 'i o m a i n t tw asnotm a ke a
e r d o i a n he e r c
he he r i s nf r to ha
z d s
pr i t r M a s 774 F.Su a 61 s e al o Rie S a e Ba ofRie v.Spil a 75
opre a y. r h,
pp. t 6; e s l v t t nk
ly
lm n, 0
P. 1 1 ( n.1 )(dsq hmodfc tonofawrte conrc mus bes ppo tdb
2d 024, 028 Ka 988 dl uc
iiai
itn ta t t u re y
c i r ton i pende a s pa a e f om t o i i lc i a i s
ons de a i nde
nt nd e r t r he r g na onsder ton uppo tng t
r i he
c rct'
onta -).
He e,t c ur c udest tt r i a ge ne i s ofm a e i lf tast w he hert
nc he o t oncl
ha he e s
nui s ue
t r a ac
o
t he
N ondi c os e A gr em e ' pr vi i de i ng E
s l ur
e nt s o s on fni s i nta l o m a i ' asa ende or
contde i l nf r ton' w
m
d
modii byt s e ntdeai oft pari .Sc fr 2007W L 2580569,a *2(ç'
ted he ubsque
lngs he tes hae,
t ç-he
f
quetonofwhehe ac r thasbe modiid i aq si offc. (ii l r Esaeof
si
t r ontac
en
fe s ueton a t' ctng n e tt
'
Snook,38P. 68 ( n.
3d 4 Ka 2002),seas 1 C. S. rcsj1 Ctol tonsrgar ng
) e lo 7B J. Conta t 042 l uesi e di
.
t m odii i ofa cont actar onesoff ,and ar t be det m i by t t eroff upon
he
fcaton
r
e
act
eo
er ned
he ri
act
14
t e de oft c s ')
he vi nce he a e. .Fort sra on,hec t l de t motonf s
'
hi e s t our wil ny he i or ummay
r
j d me t st t b e c o c n rc cam.
u g n a o he ra h f o ta t li
3.
Unj te ihme cai
us nrc nt l m
A se a ne i gr t rdet i i t c tsm e or ndum o ni a t m oton t
xpl i d n ea e
a l n he our ' m a
pi on t he i o
dimissa ( ke No.38a 22-24) t d e nt aguet tt pli if'unus
s s tge Doc t
t
,he efnda s r ha he antfs j t
en i hm e c ai i pr m pt d by bot KU TSA a t e es c r c cl m . l ta l t
r c nt l m s ee e
h
nd he xpr s ont a t ai nii ly, he
c u t oe t a KUTS d e no o eaet b rt pan if' n u te c me tcam b c u e
o r n ts h t
A o s t p rt o a he litfs u j s mi h n li e a s
t be ftt tt pl i if b t
he ne i ha he a ntf s es owed upon t e de e nt c e pl t m o e t n sm pl ta
h f nda s ont m a es r ha i y r de
s ces(..i onuai t tdoe notrs t t lve ofata s ce a t la ilr
e rt ie,nf ton ha s ie o he e l r de e rt nd he inclay
s r i es' ha t pl ntf spr de t t de e nt durng t r r l tons p,i l ng f ei
e v c ' t t he ai if ovi d o he f nda s i hei e a i hi nc udi or gn
ta l i s r esa mar tngs
rnsaton e dc nd kei uppor) W of Elc.I v.Duc
t. le e .nc.
kworh,266P. 51 532
t
3d 6, -
33( n. ) M e wael o.Svs.l v. c sonI o.Sol i .
Ka 2011 ; di r nf
. nc. M Ke s nf
utons LLC, 06- 91J L,
No. 23 -W
2007W L 9261 a *2 ( Ka M a . 2007 ,s as St Casl Fi snc. Fred n.
42, t -3 D. n. r 26, ) ee lo one te n.I v. i ma
*
Bilngs Ra e & Co.1 F.Su 2d65 658 ( D. 2002)( s ri t tbeor
li . ms v
, 91
pp.
2, -59 E. Va.
ase tng ha, f e
r a hi t pr m pton quesi c t tr tk s a ih t tt i or a i i i s . .
e c ng he ee i
ton, our s i s t t bls ha he nf m ton n s ue .
e
c ttt ta s ces'.
onsiue r de e rt'
)
The c td e m i t tt e es c t a tcl i lke i e doe notope a e t pr mpt
our et r nes ha he xpr s on r c a m i w s
s
r t o ee
tepanif' nus e rcu n cam (lh u ht ee itn eo tec nr d l t teso eo
h litfs u j t n ilne t li at o g h x se c f h o ta i s h c p f
mi
t unus e ihme cam)be aus t No s os eAgre ntdoesno Seg ael t
he j t nrc nt li c e he ndicl ur e me
t l ult ) he
r
r l tonsoft pa te w ih r pec t ' he a la y s r c st tt pl i if pr vi d t t
ea i
he r i s t es t o't ncil r e vi e ha he a ntf s o de o he
defnda t. I Corp v.
e ns3 ce
Hamit Sundsrndl ,444F.Supp.2d 11 ,11 ( Ka 2006)
lon
ta nc.
65 70 D. n.
.
(ntr lquottonmaksa fot t omit ) Ase ane i t c tsprvius
i ena
ai
r nd o noe ted . xpli d n he our' e o
3
H oweve ,t c tnot t tt N ondicl ur Ag e m en doe r gul t t r a i oft pa te wih
r he our es ha he
s os e r e t s e a e he el tons he ri s t
r s c t t dicl ur ofi o maton e nge byt pa te pur ua tt t c ta t l Cor v. a it
e pe t o he s os e nf r i xcha d he ris s n o he onr c . ce p. H m lon
S n srn lc, 4 F. u p 2 l 6 ,l 7 ( Ka . 0 6.
u d ta d n .4 4 S p . d 1 5 l 0 D. n 2 0 )
15
m e or ndum opi on,t N ondi cl ur Agr e e doe notgove n t pari 'r a i nsw ih
m a
ni he
s os e e m nt s
r he tes el to
t
r
espectt t e servi because t ser cesw er pr ded pur uantt t contacts
o hes
ces
he vi
e ovi
s
o he
r '
ça e m e t ag e ' pr s on, c t c tde e m i d t be une or a e a pa t t
i gr e nt o r e ' ovi i whi h he our t r ne o
nf ce bl s r of he
c r c . Se U. e r . . r ie Co. M oha Consr, nc.No.11 cv- 491J KGG,
onta t e S. x el W Extalt
v.
n
t.l ,
- 2 -AW
201 W L 9 088, t*3( Ka M a .15, 2)( o di t tabrac ofco rc cai wil
2
07 a D. n. r 201 prvi ng ha e h
nta t l m l
n t re t nu j s e c me tcam u ls av l c nrc g v m step ris c n u t t
o p e mp a n u t mi h n li ne s ai o ta t o e h a t ' o d c a
d
e
is ei t u j s e rc me t li .I ohe wo d ,h c u t o l e t a ara o a l j r
su n he n u t n ih n cam) n t r r s t e o r c ncud s h t e s n b e u y
c d fndt tt pl i if 'pr son ofa ilr s r c t t def nt , c f l outi
oul i ha he antfs ovii
nc la y e vies o he enda s whih als sde
t p vi w o t N ondi c os e A gr e e , t e a be h upon t de enda s unde
he ur e f he
s l ur
e m nt besow d
nef
he f
nt
r
c r um s a est tw oul r
i c t nc ha
d ende i uia e t r t nto oft tbe i .4 M edi ar I o.Svs.
r neq t bl he e e i n ha nett
w e nf
,
I ,2007 W L 9261 a *
nc.
42, t 2-3. Fort s r as , he c tw ilde t m o i f s l m a'
he e e ons t our l ny he ton or tm l
y
j d me ta t teu j s e c me tcam.
u g n s o h n u t mi h n li 5
4.
lm pled cont
i
ractcl m
ai
Ase ane i gr trdeaii t c tspr vi me andlm opi on(
xpli d n eae t ln he our' e ous mor z
ni Docke No.
t
38a 1
t 4-22) t defndansaguet tt pli if'i idconrc cli i pre e by
,he e t r ha he antfs mple ta t am s e mptd
t i c a m f rbr a h oft N ondi c os e A gr e e t Be a e t pl i if ha
he r l i o e c
he
s l ur
e m n . c us he a ntf s ve
4
Th ee nso a uj s e rc me tcam u d rKa sslw ae ()tec n erlo ab n ft yte
e lme t f n nut n ih n li n e n a a r : l h o fra f e eib h
plitf u o ted fn a t( )a a p e it no k o e g o teb n ft yt dee d n; n ()te
anif p n h ee d n ;2 n p rcai r n wld e fh e eib he fn a ta d 3 h
o
a ce a by t deenda oft be ftunde cic t nc t woul r nde i
c ptnce he f nt he nei
r r umsa es hat
d e r nequia et defnda '
tbl he e nts
r tntonoft be ftwihoutha ng pad f i.J. .
ee i
he ne i t
vi
i or t W Thomps Co. W ele Pr .
on
v. ls ods Cop .758 P. 738,7
,
2d
45
( n. 98 )
Ka 1 8 .
5
Howeve , i s r l g tec u t oe ta teme sr o d ma e u d rh uj s e rc me tcam i
r n o ui ,h o r n ts h th
n
a ue f a g s n e te nu t nih n li s
lm ie t t da a r ae t t pli if'pr sonofs r ce t t defnda t durng t deveopm e oft
i td o he m ges eltd o he antfs ovii
e vi s o he e n s i he
l
nt he
applcai Ont ot rha t mea ur ofda a i t b e hofco r c cai woul co emplt bot t
i ton.
he he nd, he s e
m ges n he r ac
nta t l m
d nt ae h he
defnda s'pr isfom unaut ieds esa t cons nta da a socc i d by t dicl ur oft
e nt oft r
horz al nd he
eque il m ge
asone
he s os e he
pl ntfs'c i ntali or a i bas d upon t pl ntfs'a is onst tunaut i ed s e oft pr tf ls
ai if onfde i nf m ton, e
he ai if dm s i ha
horz al s he oduc a l
u d rteumb el ofh No icosr Age me t ( c e No. 7a 5. Futemo e tec u t oe, h udte
ne h
rl te ndsl u e re n. Do k t 8 t ) rh r r,h o r n ts so l h
a
panif sc e do t iKUTS cam,h me sr o d ma e t gud icu eb t tea ta ls c u e b
litfs u c e n her
A li te au e f a g st o l)n ld oh h cu lo s a sd y
c
mia po raina dteu j s e rc me tcu e b mia po rainta i n ta e it ac u ti c mp t g
sp rpito n h nu t n ih n a s d y sp rp ito h t s o tk n no c o n n o ui
n
a t a Is . KUTSA j6 - 3 2.l nle o d ma e me s r d b a y oh rme h d ,h d ma e c u e b
cu l o s'
'
0 3 2 ç iu f a g s a u e y n t e t o s t e a g s a s d y
l
m ia opra i m a bem e u e by i postonofla lt f rar s bl r t f am iappr it '
s ppr iton y
as r d m ii
ibiiy o ea ona e oyaly or
s opraors
unauhorze dicl ur orus ofatades rt' L.
t i d s os e
e
r ec e. ds
' u
16
a knowldge t tBea on Eur i c r by t Nondic os eAgr me ' a tlaesc a e
c
e d ha
c
ope s ove ed he
s l ur
ee nts fiit l us
( c t . 7a 3 ,h c u t lg a t h mo infrs mma yj d me ta t t ei l d
Do ke No 8 t ) te o r wil rn t e to o u r u g n s o h mpi
e
c r c c am .
onta t l i
11
1.
Conc us on
l i
Fort r s de aied above t cou twilgr nti pa tand de i pa tt
he ea ons t l
, he r l a n r
ny n r he
d fn a t' to f rs mmayj d me t S e iial tec u t l g a ttemoinwi
ee d n s moin o u r u g n . p cfc l h o r wil rn h to t
y,
h
r s c t t pl ntfs i id c r c cli ,a wilde t m oton wih r pec t t
e pe t o he ai if ' mple onta t am nd l ny he i
t es t o he
r mai ngt e cai s TheClr i die t t s nd ce tfe c esoft smemor ndum
e ni hr e l m .
e k s r ced o e
rii d opi
hi
a
o ni a t a c pa ng or rt a 1c
pi on nd he c om nyi
de o 1 ouns lofr co d.
e
e r
ENTER : Thi
s
O z# d y ofM ay,2012.
a -
Chi U nie S a e Di t i tJ e
ef t d t t s s rc udg
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?