Taylor v. McDonnell

Filing 3

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 10/14/2011. (jat)

CLERK. oFFs u. ' s' rouv
:
ce s os c
ATaoAyoc ,
vA

47zp
F, j.
iz
j
0CT 1? 22 1
1

FNT HEWEEE TDISRCTOFVI NI
I T U TT S A ETDS RITCOURA
ORHE NISDRN TS IT C RGIT

J
ULI C.
B:AEDuD (,RE .
Y DP LcL
U (/

H A RR I N BUR G D I I O N
SO
V SI
W A R REN SCO TT TA YL O R ,
Pl nt f,
ai if

Ci lA c i N o.5: c
vi t on
11 v00097

R O BER T F.M CD O N N ELL,
A s G ove nor oft Com m onw e t ofV i gi a
r
he
al h
r ni
D ef
endant.
M EM O R AN DU M O PI IO N
N

Pr s panifW ar nSc t Ta lr se ngt p o e dif r
o e litf re ot yo , e ki o r c e n o mapau rs ha flda
pe i, s ie
c
ompli a i tde e ntRobe tF.M cDonnel a Gove noroft Comm onweat of
ant ga ns f nda
r
l, s
r
he
1h

Vigi a Pli ifalgest tdee ntha vi ae hi c tt i rght unde 42U. C.j
r ni. antf le ha fnda s oltd s onsiutonal i s r
S.
1 b de ng hi pe ii f e c i c e e on Se e be 1 2011 f rt prorD U 1
983 y nyi
s tton or xe utve l m ncy
pt m r 4,
, o wo i
c
onvi t o i 1 a 2001. The c tgr nt pl i if sa i a i t pr e w ihou
c i ns n 995 nd
our a s a ntf pplc ton o oce d t t

prpa
e ymentoffesbu dimis hi co ai pu s ntt 28U. C.j1915e ( ( (i
e t s ses s mpl nt rua o
S.
()2)B)i)
be a e pl i ifdoesnots a e a cl i u n w hi h r i ca be gr nt d.
c us a ntf
tt
a m po
c elef n
a e
l

S cin 1 5e pr vd st a ac u t hal imisa i o mapa pe i c mpan t t
e t 91 () o ie h t o r s ld s s n nf r
o
u rs o lit i
a
anytme'fiçaist saeacam onwhi r ifma begrntd . .. 28U. C.j
i 'i tt l o tt li
f
ch ele y
a e . '
'
S.
1 ()2)B)i) Unde t Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e e aco aitmus c ti ças t
915e( ( (i.
r he deal es vi oc dur , mpl n
t onan t hor
a pl i sa e e oft cli s wi t tt plad ri en ild t r le . FED. Cl P.
nd an t t m nt he am ho ng ha he e e s tte o ei f'
'
R. v.

8()2) A c antmus pla e
a( . ompli
t e d noughfcst tsaeacli t rleft ti plusbl onis
a t o ltt am o ei ha s a i e t
fc ' As r tv.I l U. ,1 S.Ct 1 1 (
a e. hcof qba, S. 29
'
. 937, 949 2009)( i BelAta i Cor v.
quotng l lntc p.
Twombl 550U. 5 570(
v,
S. 44,
2007).A cli i f i l plusbl whe t pl ntf pla
)
am s acaly a i e n he ai if e ds

.

f c st talow t c t o ' a t r as bl i e e t tt de e nti la ef t
a t ha l he our t ï w he e ona e nf r nce ha he f nda s i bl or he
dr
m ic
s onduc a l ged. qbal 1 S.Ct a 1 49.
t le '
'l , 29
.t 9
l t s c e, a ntf cl m st tde e nt asG ove noroft Com m onw e lh of
n hi as pl i i f ai ha f nda ,
r
he
at

Vigi a, olt d hi co tt i rght by de ng hi peii f e c i ce e y o
r ni vi a e s nsiutonal i s
nyi s tton or xe utve lm nc n
Se e r 1 2011 f rt prorDU1c nvito i 1 95 a 2001 Unde Vigi al t
pt mbe 4,
, o wo i
o c ins n 9 nd
.
r r ni aw,he
G ove norhast s e di c e i t gr ntr que t f rpa don and r preve. The Cons iuton of
r
he ol s r ton o a e s s o r
e i
tt i

Vigi apr dest tçll Gover rs l ha po r.. t gr trpre andpa do a tr
r ni ovi ha tthe
no hal ve we .o an e ive
r ns fe
co cin ....'VA.
nvito
'
Coxsr a t5,j 1 TheCodeofVigi adoe notpl ean r srcins
'. r.
2.
r ni s
ac y etito
on t spow e , t tng t tt he pow e ... o g a pa dons a r pre s i ve t d i t
hi
r s a i ha t
t
r t r nt r
nd e i ve s s e n he

Go r .'VA.
venor'
CODEANN.j53.- Thi dic ei t ga orde r quet frparona
1229. s srton o rnt ny e ss o d nd

rp iv i n ts b e t of d rl u iil e iw.
e re e s o u j c t e ea j dca rv e
l Gr ha v. ncel A ndr G r hmn' pe ii n f c e e y c pe a i n wa de ed
n a m A
one,
e a
s tto or l m nc om ns to
s ni

byt Gove norofVigi a a he s
he
r
r ni , nd
oughtr co i e ai oft tdecson i t Unied Stt s
e nsd r ton ha
ii n he t a e

DititCo r f rt Ea tr Ditito Vigna 7 F. u p. 46 9, 0( D. .1 9 ) The
src u t o he sen src f r ii. 3 S p 2 2 63 E. Va 9 9 .

c u t edta C ce n yp tto t t eGo en ro Vignai n ts b e tt j d ca rve '
o r h l h t 1 lme c ei n o h v r o f r ii s o u j c o u iil e iw'
a
i
f rt o r a ons l a 631 Fi s , he co tf und t tt r i no c tt i ly pr e t
o w e s . d. t . r t t
ur o
ha he e s
ons iutona l ot c ed
i t r ti c e e i V igi a,s a i .
n e es n l m ncy n r ni t tng'
A cl m e y pe ii i diec e t t e c i br nc of go r e w hi has
e nc tton s r t d o he xe utve a h
ve nm nt ch
t pow e t g a cl m e y o c m ut a s nt nc A s s h, c e e
he
r o r nt e nc r om
e e e e.
uc l m ncy i a
s n

e e ui r me y n taj dca rme y ...Th s p rto o p we sd crn
x c tve e d o u iil e d .
e e aain f o r o ti e
pr bis t co t f om pl c ng r ti tons on t pow e s del ga e t t
ohi t he ur s r
a i esr c i
he
r
e t d o he
e utve br nc
xec i
a h. A c or n y, dec s ons t gr nt cl m enc or co m ut a
c di gl
ii
o a
e
y
m
e

s ne e ae rr l a p o rae s b e t fr j dca rve I o d r f r a
e tnc r aey p r p it u j cs o u iil e iw. n r e o
ce n ypei o t b s be tt j dca r ve t eemu tb a p o e u a o
lme c tt n o e u j c o u iil e iw, h r s e r c d rl r
i
f
undnm ent cons iutonal rght whi c es a pr ect i er i cl ency.
al
tt i
i
ch reat
ot ed nt est n em

Rihsgv n rs t acam s be tt j d ca rviw mu tb b sd o sau e
g t ii g ie o li u j c o u iil e e
s e a e n ttts
o r l s de i ng t s o oft c e e y pow e a t oblga i nsoft ofi e
r u e fni he c pe he l m nc
r nd he i t o
he fc
c r d w ih e r i i t pow e .
ha ge t xe c sng he
r

1 a 63 3l( iai omitd) s as Ohi Adul Pa l Aut v. oodwad,5 U. 272
d. t 0- cttons te ; ee lo o
t m e h. W
r 23 S.
( 998)( di t tceme yde sonsa ege rlynote il t j ca rviw a t tt
1
hol ng ha l nc cii r neal
ntted o udiil e e nd ha he
ce nc pr e esa is d no vi aet DuePr e sClus ) Co Bd.ofPadonsv.
lme y oc dur t sue o t olt he
oc s a e ; nn.
r

Du c t45 U. 458( 981 ( di t tt r i noc tt i l pr e tdi eeti
msha, 2 S.
1 ) hol ng ha hee s onsiutonaly otce ntr s n
ce nc .Be a et CodeofVigi at sno plcea c tonsorlmiai ont
lme y) c us he
r ni û
doe t a ny ondii
i ttons he
powe v t d i t Gove no 'unde t saeconsiuto t gr ntr pre a pa dons t
r ese n he
r r'
r he t t
tt i n o a e ive nd r , he

c u t o n t t ce nc pei o i Vignai n ts be toj iil e e Grha 7 F.
o r f u d ha a lme y tt n n r ii s o u jc t udca rviw. a m, 3
i
Supp. a 631 Se ond, hec thed t tt Te t Am e
2d t . c
t our l ha he n h
ndmen oft Unie Stt
t he td aes

Co ttto prcu e j d ca rv e i tec s .L Thec u t oe a f lo :
nsiui n e l d s u iil e iw n h m e i
o r n td s ol ws
gl e p we t g a tce n yi ap we rs r e t t esae u e teTe t
' h o r o r n lme c s o r e ev d o h tts nd r h nh
l
Ame
ndm e oft Unied St t s Cons iuto ... or ove ,Gr ha ' c e e y
nt he
t
ae
tt i n. M e r a m s l m nc
pe ii woul notbedieced t a f de a ex utve butr t t t Gov no of
tton
d
r t o e r l ec i
aher o he
er r
t Com m onw e 1h of V igi a a t f de a c tm us r m ai s pa a e a
he
at
r ni , nd he e r l our
t e n e r t nd
a r f om Gr ha ' cl m e y pe ii die t d t t e c i br nc of t
pa t r
a m s e nc
tton r c e o he xe utve a h
he
Com m o alh ofV igi a
nwe t
r ni .

I Ba e ont s t rasms t c t l dt tçlle ncyi t sc ei anexe utv
d. s d he e wo e c ,he our concude ha dclme n hi as s
c ie

rme ye cusv l t a o t eCo n at o Vigni a di n ts b e tt j d ca rve
e d x l iey h t f h mmo we 1h f r i a n s o u j c o u iil e iw
by a f de alc t' 1
e r our .' d.
1I.

I t i c s , litf i s e igfd r lu iil e e o t ed na o hi p t inf r
n hs a e p an if s e kn e ea j dca rviw f h e il f s ei o o
t
e c i c e nc by t Gove noroft Comm o alh ofVigi a Howe r a t
xe utve l me y he
r
he
nwe t
r ni.
ve , s he
Cons iuton ofV i g ni t Code ofV i gi a, nd t hol ng i G r ha m a c e r pl i if
tt i
r i a, he
r ni a he di n a m
ke l a , a ntf
ha no c tt i l pr ec e i e es i c e e y,a t Gover ' de alofhi pe ii i
s
ons iutonaly ot t d nt r t n l m nc nd he
nor s ni
s tton s

nots j c t r e byt sc t Ac or ngl I I ORDERED AND ADJUDGED t t
ube t o eviw
hi our. c di y, T S
ha
pli ifsr ques f i or pau rssausi GRANTED,ha pli if c ai i
antf e t or nf ma pe i tt s
t t antf ompl nt s
DI I
SM SSED W I PREJUDI f f l et saeacli puruantt j 1 5()2 ( (i,
TH
CE or aiur o tt am s
o 91 e()B)i)

a t tt sc es l beSTRI
nd ha hi as hal
CKEN fo t aci d ke oft c t TheClr i die t
r m he tve oc t he our.
e k s r ced
t s nd a c oft s M em or
o e
opy hi
andum Opi on a a co pa ng Or rt pl ntf .
ni nd c m nyi
de o ai i f

Ent r d: O c obe 1 2011
ee
t r 4,

4/- , W / ? - V2
*
V
##
M i ha F. r ns
c el U ba ki
Unie St t s Di t i tJ
t d a e sr c udge

4