Taylor v. Hennig

Filing 9

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/19/12. (kld)

el
>**:OFFI u. D1 * Qr
:: :, R
AT M :QNBURG VA

RuP
I THE UNITED STA TES DISTRICT CO U RT
N
FO R TH E W ESTERN DISTRICT O F VI G I I
R N A
H AR RISO NBURG DIVISIO N

AF2 l! 1
2
J
BY;

cD

Yc R

DEPU

W AR REN SC OTT TAY LOR ,
Pl ntf ,
ai if
Ci lAd i N o.5: v00010
vi
on
12c
GR EG H ENN I ,
G
Ext ton and C l ency D i or,
radii
em
rect
Of i oft Secret oft Com m onw ealh,
fce he
ary he
t

By: M i
chaelF.U rbanski
Unied St es Di ri Judge
t
at
st ct

Def
endant
.

M EM ORANDUM OPI ON
NJ

Pli ifW arnScotTa or(û y1 ',pr e di pr K a t f mapa rs Glda
antf re
t yl : or' oc e ng o nd q or
Ta )
upei, e
co antpurua t 42U. C.j1 3o J n r 31, 2.Ta oralgest tdee n Gr
mpli
s nto
S.
98 n a uay 201
yl le ha fnda t eg
Henni Extadii a Cl ency D i or Ofi oft Secr t y oft Com m onw ealh,
g, r ton nd em
rect , fce he
e ar
he
t
vi a ed hi cons iutonalr ght by f lng t pr sa petton f abs ut par and f war
olt
s
tt i
i s aii o oces
ii or ol e don
or d
i t t V i ni Par e Boar .1 By Or dat Febr y l 201 t s case was r ered t B.
t o he rgi a ol
d
der ed
uar 4, 2, hi
ef r o

W a hCrglr UniedStt MagitaeJ ge pus a t 28U. C. 6 b)1.Th
ug i e, t aes
srt ud , ru nto
S. j 36( () e

ma srt j is daRe t ndRe omme tononFe u r 1 2 2,r o ndi
gitae udge sue
por a
c
ndai
bray 6, 01 ec mme ng

t tt c tdimist scaewihprj c p s ntt 28U. C.j1 5e( ( (i.
ha he our s s hi s t eudie urua o
S. 91 ()2)B)i)
Ta orflda o j ci t t Re ta Re omme tononM ac 1 201 l t s
yl ie n b e ton o he por nd c
ndai
rh , 2. n hi
obe to Ta ora srst tt t con cinsf whihhese padonlc dmeia i
jcin, yl set ha he wo vito or c
e ks r a ke rt nd f
H enni had pr sed hi petton f cl ency and f war i t t V igi a Par e Boa d,
g
oces
s ii or em
or ded t o he r ni ol
r

par wo dha be ngrne Fe rlRul o Ci lPr e e72( ( r uiesapat t
don ul ve e a td. dea e f vi oc dur b)2) eq r
ry o
Se'ea Gl s cii wrte obe to t t prpos fndi a rc
' l nd e pe fc itn j cins o he o ed i ngs nd e omme tons' t
sv
ndai 'of he
1 Thi i oneo t e c
ss
f hr e ompli sfl rce l byTa orc e i peii f ce e y f vai c vitons
ant ied e nty
yl onc m ng ttons or lm nc or rous on ci .
Se Ci lAc i Nos 5; 1 v00097 a 5:2c 0006.
e vi ton . 1 c
nd 1 v0

ma srt j e.Theditit udgetenc ies/qnovoShos po to oft rpor o
gitae udg
src j
h onsd r .
t e rins he e t r
t
secfe pr e fndi orrc
p iid oposd i ngs e omme tonst whiho jci i ma ' 28U. C.j
ndai o c be ton s de.
'
S.

636( () Ta ordoe no obe ts cfc l t a fndi i t magitaej e' Re t
b)l. yl
s t j c pe iial o ny i ngs n he
y
srt udg s por
and Recomm endaton. H e m er y r t at t alegatonss f h i hi com pl nt Thus,he
i
el eier es he l i et ort n s
ai .

hasn s tsidt s ciiiyrquie ntoulne i Rul 72( .
ot aife he pe fct e rme ti d n e b)
Ne t ls,e na s ngTa o ha fldprpe obe tonst teRe ta
verhee s ve sumi ylr d ie o r jci o h por nd
Recom m endaton,t cour fndst Repor a Recom m endaton s d be adopt i is
i he
t i he
t nd
i houl
ed n t

e trt d-hesa r b whiht (lur deemi swh t rt dimisa a to und r28
niey. d' tndad y c he co t tr ne ehe o s s n cin e
f

U. C.j1 5()2)B)i)i tesmea ta unde Rul l b)6)oft Fe rlRulsofCi l
S. 91 e ( ( (i s h a s h t r e 2( (
he dea e
vi
Pr e r ' Smih v.M c ur , 6: 0 v000 2 0W L 23265 a *2 ( . Va J e 8
oc du e.
' t
cl e No. 1 c 22, 01
36, t W D. . un ,

201 ( tngNe omev.E. O. ,3 F. 227, ( hCi.
0) cii
ws
E. C. 01 3d
231 5t r2002)a dLope v.Smih,20
n
z
t 3
F. l1 ll (t Ci.2000) Tos vi a 1 b( motont dimis ac an mus
3d 22, 27 9h r
). ur ve 2()6) i o s s, omplit t
pl enough f st ûût t a cl m t r i t ti pl bl on isf '' A s of v.l ,
ead
act o ss a e ai o elef ha s ausi e t ace.' hcr t qbal

55 U. 66
6 S. 2,

,l S. .1 7,1 49( 09)( tngBel l tcCoo. Twombl 550
29 Ct 93 9 20 quoi lAtani r v.
v,

U. 5 4, ( ).A cli i fcal plusbl whe tepl nifpla fcst talo te
S. 4 570 2007)
am s a ily a i e n h aitf e ds a t ha lw h
courtt ûdr t r onabl i er
o û aw he eas
e nf ence t t def
hat he endanti labl f t m iconductaleged.'
s i e or he s
l
'

1 ( tngTwo y,550U. a 57 .
d.cii
mbl
S. t 0)
Ta oralegest the m aied hi petton f abs ut par t Henni i l e J or
yl l
ha
l s ii or ol e don o
g n at une
ea y Jul 2008. Tayl cl m sH enni acknow l
rl y
or ai
g
edged r vi t petton. He sat t
ecei ng he ii
t es hat
Henni s hi a confr aton l t dat Jul 14,2008. Tayl f hercl m sH enni t d
g ent m
im i eter ed y
or urt
ai
g ol
hi he woul be f w ar ng t pe ii t t Vigi a Par e Boar f i tgaton.Ta or
m
d
or di he tton o he r ni ol
d or nves i i
yl
alegest the l ercont ed J W ade a t Vigi a Par e Boar w ho sat s had not
l
ha
at
act oan
t he r ni
ol
d,
t ed he

r ved Tayl ' petton. Tayl cl m sH enni çpur
ecei
or s ii
or ai
g s posel f l t pr
y aied o ocesst pe ii and
he tton

s dit t VaPaol Boadgn t dee a ha de e pli ifW arn Sc t Ta orhi
en to he
r e r a d) he fnd nt s nid antf re ot yl s
rghtt t e a petti f abs ut par ' Com pl,Dkt.# 1,at3.
i o 5l
i on or ol e don.'
.
Thes alegatonsdo notsat a cl m f whi r i can be gr ed. Cl ency Si an
e l i
t e ai or ch elef
ant
em
ss

e c tverme ye usvel t toft Commo alhofVigi aa i no s jc t j ca
xe ui e d xcl i y ha he
nwe t
r ni nd s t ube t o udiil
rviw byaf ealc r. a m v. eone, F.
ee
ed r ou t' ha Ang l 73 Supp. 629,631( D. .1 ) s e
'Gr
2d
E. Va 999 ; e

as Ohi AdulPaol Auh. W ood r 523U. 27 (998)( di t tce n
lo o
t r e t v.
wad,
S. 2 1
hol ng ha lme cy

de iinsaege r lyno e ildt j cilrviw a ta t ce c pr e esa is
cso r neal t ntte o udi a e e nd h t he lmen y oc dur tsue
di no vi aet DuePr c sClus) Co Bd. fPadonsv.
d t olt he
o es a e; nn. o r
Dums t 45 U. 45 (981
cha, 2 S. 8 1 )
( digt tt r i noc tttonal pr ece i eeti ce nc ) Be a et r i no
hol n ha hee s onsiui ly ot td ntrs n lme y . c us hee s
cons iutpnaly pr ect i er ti cl
tt i l ot ed nt es n emenc Tayl ' cl m st he wasdeni t rghtt
y, or s ai hat
ed he i o

tl apeii f a oltl pado aeno s j c t r e byt sc t Ass c Ta ors
5e tton or bs uey r n r t ube to eviw hi our. u h, yl '
obe tonwilbeover e t Re ta Re omme tonwil a pt i ise trt a
jci l
ruld,he por nd c
ndai lbe do ed n t niey, nd
t scas w ilbe dim ised fom t actvedocketoft cour .
hi e l
s s r he i
he
t
A n appr at O r w ilbe ent ed.
opri e der l
er
Ent ed: Apr l19,2012
er
i

/ /' 4 J / W c
> m #
Mi
chaelF.U r
banski
Unied St esD it i J
t
at
s rct udge