Sunderland v. Astrue

Filing 23

ORDER denying 14 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 18 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 22 Report and Recommendations. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 8/22/2013. (jat)

r
ap-

I THE UM TED STATES DI
N
STRI COURT
CT
FOR TH E W ESTERN DI
STR I OF W R GI A
CT
NI
H ARR I
SONBU RG D I SI N
W O

E WA DL ESN RL N
D N E U DE A D,
Pl tl,
e i
CARO LYN W .CO LW N ,
Comm i one ofSoealSe urt
ui r
i c ip

o- a ua nzxco-

A - W V
TY
A
Rkn 4v
e

e 11 D
OJt 1k h%.kR
ol u IeK

D *, ' 1
f1YL U
- Y
-

CM I to No.5: c
Aci n
12 v0* 2
0
By1 M ihae F.Ur
t l
bans
ki
Unie St e Dbt i tJudge
t d at : r c

Def
endlnt.
O RD ER

Thi matrwa r fre t t Hon a eRo r S, lou, ie Stt sM a srt
s te s e er d o he or bl be t Bal Unt d ae gitae

J d e p rl n t 2 U.. j6 6 ( )B) frpo o e f i g o fc a darc mme d d
u g , u sl to 8 SC. 3 @)1( ,o rp sd md n s f a t n e o n e
n
diposton.n eM a s t J
s ii
gikae udgesld ar por a r c
e e t nd e omme ai n on Aug t2, 3
nd to
us 201 ,

rc mme dn t a teCo sin rsmoinfrs mmo j d mt t epa td t a t t
e o n ig h th mmiso e ' to o u
u g n b ne ,h t h
pan irsmoinfrsmmayj d e t ed nid a dta t eCo sin rsfn l e iin
litf
to o n r u m n b e e , n h t h mmiso e' l a d cso

b a r d Noo j cin t tcrp r a drc mme d to h v b e fld a dtec u tsi
e o me . be t s o h e o t n e o n ain a e e n i , n h o r i f
o
e
t opi o t tt r po ta r c m me ai n s ul bea pt di ise tr t I i
ht ni n ha he t r nd e o
nd to ho d do e n t n ity. t s

a c ri gyOADERFD a dADJUDGED t a tepani smoinfrs mmayj d e t
c o dn l
. n
h th lit
T
to o u r u m n
( k t#1 i DENI t tteCommisone' moto frs
Doc e 4) s
ED,ha h
si rs in o

j e ( ke
ude nt Doc t

# 1 )i GRM TED,hatt Commiso rsf ld cli i AFFI ED,a t tt smatr
8 s
t he
sine ' ma e son s
RM
nd ha hi te
i STRI
s
CKEN fo t a tved ke oft e c ur.
r m he c i oc t h o t
TheClr i dr c e t s ndac ri c oft sOr rt alc ms lofr c d.
e k s ie t d o e
et
ied opy hi de o l ot e e or

Entr d:Aug t AW , 2013
ee
us
M i ha lF. r ns
c e U ba ki
Unie Stt DititJ dge
td aes src u

.

: