Sunderland v. Astrue

Filing 23

ORDER denying 14 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 18 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 22 Report and Recommendations. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 8/22/2013. (jat)

Download PDF
r ap- I THE UM TED STATES DI N STRI COURT CT FOR TH E W ESTERN DI STR I OF W R GI A CT NI H ARR I SONBU RG D I SI N W O E WA DL ESN RL N D N E U DE A D, Pl tl, e i CARO LYN W .CO LW N , Comm i one ofSoealSe urt ui r i c ip o- a ua nzxco- A - W V TY A Rkn 4v e e 11 D OJt 1k h%.kR ol u IeK D *, ' 1 f1YL U - Y - CM I to No.5: c Aci n 12 v0* 2 0 By1 M ihae F.Ur t l bans ki Unie St e Dbt i tJudge t d at : r c Def endlnt. O RD ER Thi matrwa r fre t t Hon a eRo r S, lou, ie Stt sM a srt s te s e er d o he or bl be t Bal Unt d ae gitae J d e p rl n t 2 U.. j6 6 ( )B) frpo o e f i g o fc a darc mme d d u g , u sl to 8 SC. 3 @)1( ,o rp sd md n s f a t n e o n e n diposton.n eM a s t J s ii gikae udgesld ar por a r c e e t nd e omme ai n on Aug t2, 3 nd to us 201 , rc mme dn t a teCo sin rsmoinfrs mmo j d mt t epa td t a t t e o n ig h th mmiso e ' to o u u g n b ne ,h t h pan irsmoinfrsmmayj d e t ed nid a dta t eCo sin rsfn l e iin litf to o n r u m n b e e , n h t h mmiso e' l a d cso b a r d Noo j cin t tcrp r a drc mme d to h v b e fld a dtec u tsi e o me . be t s o h e o t n e o n ain a e e n i , n h o r i f o e t opi o t tt r po ta r c m me ai n s ul bea pt di ise tr t I i ht ni n ha he t r nd e o nd to ho d do e n t n ity. t s a c ri gyOADERFD a dADJUDGED t a tepani smoinfrs mmayj d e t c o dn l . n h th lit T to o u r u m n ( k t#1 i DENI t tteCommisone' moto frs Doc e 4) s ED,ha h si rs in o j e ( ke ude nt Doc t # 1 )i GRM TED,hatt Commiso rsf ld cli i AFFI ED,a t tt smatr 8 s t he sine ' ma e son s RM nd ha hi te i STRI s CKEN fo t a tved ke oft e c ur. r m he c i oc t h o t TheClr i dr c e t s ndac ri c oft sOr rt alc ms lofr c d. e k s ie t d o e et ied opy hi de o l ot e e or Entr d:Aug t AW , 2013 ee us M i ha lF. r ns c e U ba ki Unie Stt DititJ dge td aes src u . :

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?