Switzer v. Thomas et al

Filing 69

ORDER granting 40 Motion for Permanent Injunction; adopting 62 Report and Recommendations ; granting 9 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim; granting 11 Motion for Permanent Injunction. Termed as moot Motion to Substitute Atty. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/18/13. (kld)

CLERK' OFFI U. DI X URT
S
CE S. ST.
AT ROANOKE,
VA

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI
STRI T C O UR T
C
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI T O F V I I I
C
RG N A
H ARRI
SONBURG DI SI
VI ON
TH O M A S L.SW I
TZER ,
Pl ntf
ai if,
V.

SHERI JO HN THO M AS,e al,
FF
t .
D efendant
s.

nrk'D
FE
1

:A2 12 1
3
J A C.
ULI DUDL ,CL
EY ERK
BY;

DEP CL
UW ERK
)
)
)
Ci lAci No. 1 v00056
vi ton 5:2c
)
)
) By: M ihae F.Ur ns
c l
ba ki
)
Unie St e DititJudge
td ats src
)

FI
NAL ORDER
Thi ma trwasr f r d t t Ho r bl J m e G. e s Unied St t M a sr t
s te
e ere o he no a e a s W lh, t
aes gitat

J ,ptrua t 28U. C.j636( ()B) f pr e fndi off ta arc
udge ls nt o
S.
b) 1( ,or opos d i ngs ac nd e omme d
nde

d s osto Th ma itaej d efldarpo t n r c mme d to o Fe r ay2 2 3
ip iin. e gsrt u g ie e r a d e o n ain n b u r 6, 01 ,
r commendi t tt de e nt'm oton t dim isbegr e t tpl i ifsm oto f
e
ng ha he f nda s
i o s s
antd,ha antf '
i ns or

s mmayj d me t ndf rla et fl a a n dc mp an bed ne ,h tti c s b
u r u g n a o e v o ie n me de o lit e id ta h s ae e
d s s e wi p eu iea dsrc e fo t a tv d c e o t c u ta dta tefcsa d
imis d t rj dc n tik n r m he cie o k t f he o r, n h t h a t n
h
cru tn e j siye tyo ap efl ij n to pls a tt 28U. C.j1 51a.
ic msa c s u tf n r f r-ii nu cin t u n o
ng
r
S.
6 ()1
Aln wi t erpo t n r c mme d to tema itaej d ee trda Or e o
o g t h e r a d e o n ain,h gsr t u g n ee n d r n
h
Fe a y26,201 de ng ea h ofpl i ifsnum e ouspe ngnon- s ii m o i ,n o
bnzr
3 nyi
c
antf
r
ndi
dipostve tons m ng

t m amoin fre r e c ij n to ( t #4 a damoint c riyca sa a p it ls
he
to o me g n y n u ci n Dk . ) n
t o e t ls nd p on ca s
o
f
c e ( .#27) Puruan t 28U. C.j636( () ama sr t j ca onl r o nd
ounsl Dkt
. s to
S.
b)1 , gitae udge n y ec mme

ads sto a t amo inf rij n tv rle a amo int p r t itn n eo aca s
ipo iin s o
to o n u ci e eif nd
to o emiman e a c f ls

'A he rng washel be o et magitaej eon Ocobe 11 201 on dee ntShe ifJ Thoma motont
ai
d f r he
sr t udg
t r , 2
fnda
rf ohn
s' i o

rq iepefl rve a whc panifwa pee , sa pie o t po sblyo ap efigij n to a
e ur r-ing e iw, t ih litf s rsntwa p rs d fhe siii f r-in nu cin nd
i
t
l
t ba i t r f r a wasgi n a o rt t t behe d.SeeD k . 55.Pli ifwasas notfe oft
he ss he e o , nd
ve n ppo uniy o
ar
t#
antf
lo iid he

ma itaej d esrc mme d to t t p efl gij n to b etrdi terp r a drc mme ainisl
gsrt u g ' eo n ain ha a r-in nu cin e nee n h e o t n e o nd to tet
i
l
t whihplitf h da o o tnt t o j c.S eFil v. - AC LLC, . :8 v 9 , 0 9WL 6 6 2 2,t*
o c anif a n pp ru iy o be t e - d GM
e
No 20 c 2 4 2 0
50 2 a 8
( D. . a 3 2 9 .
E. Va Jn. 0, 00 )

a to .Th r f r ,hec u t lc n tu tema itaej d esr ln so t s moinsa
cin e eo e t o r wil o sr e h g srt u g ' uig n hee to s
r om m e d di postons
ec
nde s ii .

P an ifh stldo j cinst t erp r a drc mme d to .
litf a le be to o h e o t n e o n ai n
Th c u t a c r f lyr ve dt ema itaej d e' rpo tt o j cinst t
e o r h s a eul e iwe h gsrt u g s e r,he be to o he
r po t t pe tne pori oft r c d,a t r l va l ala hor t a i s doi
e r , he r i nt tons he e or nd he e e nt eg ut iy nd, n o ng,

ma ead n v d tr n to o tos p rin o t erp r t whiht panifo j ce Th
d e o o eemiain f h e o t s f h e o to c he litf b e td. e
o
c u t idst t h ma itaej d ewa c re ti c n l dn ta panifsmoin f r
o r fn ha t e gsrt u g s o r c n o cu ig h t litf' to s o

s mmayj dg n , o e r e c ij n to ,oc riyca sa da p itc u e, n frla e
u r u me tf r me g n y n u cin t etf ls n p on o nsl a d o e v
t a e s ul bedenid; ha de e nt 'm oto t dimi ss d begr nt d; ha t sc s
o m nd ho d
e t t f nda s
i n o s s houl
a e t t hi a e

s dbedimisdwihprj c a src n fo t a tvedoc oft c tandt ta
houl
s se t eudie nd tike r m he ci
ket he our; ha

p e fln ij n to p ls a tt 28U. C. 1 51a i warne .Ac o dngy t ec u t
r -iig n u ci n t u n o
r
S. j 6 () s ra td c r i l ,h o r
ADOPTSt ema itaej g ' r c mme d to i ise t ey.
h gsrt ud e s e o n ain n t ni t
r
l i t r f e ORDERED a ADJUDGED a f l :
t s he e or
nd
s olows

Defnda s motont dimis( t #9) i GRANTED;
e nt' i o s s Dk .
s

Pli tf smo inf rsl r j d me t( t # 1 )i DENI
anif to o l
mma y u g n Dk . 6 s
ED;
Plitf mo inf re r e c ij n to ( t #4 i DENI
an ips to o meg n y nu cin Dk . ) s
ED;
4. Plitf' motont ce tf cas a a ntc ms ( .#27 i DENI
anifs i o riy l s nd ppoi ot el Dkt ) s
ED;

5. Pli ifsmoi f la t fl ana nde c ant( . 26)i DENI
antf
ton or e ve o ie me d ompli Dkt# s
ED;

Th smatri DI M I ED wih p eud c a d S CKEN fo t ea tv d c e o
i te s S SS
t r j ie n TRI
r m h cie o k t f
t cou t
he r ;

De e d n S rf J l Th ma ' t nst r q iep e fl r ve ( t# 1 & 4 )
fn a t heif om o s moi o e ur r -ing e iw Dk . 1 0
o
i
ar G R AN TED ;
e

A p e fln ijmci ni ENTERED a ans Th ma L. wi e a f lo :
r -iig n t to s
g i t o s S t r s olws
z

a. TheCl k oft Cour i DI
er
he
t s RECTED t r us and notdoc ta ne pr s
o ef e
ke ny w o e
flngss
ii
ubmitd by Swize i t sditita i tVigi a sae a l l
te
t r n hi src ga ns r ni t t nd oca
g r m e e ii , t c a s a e pl es i l ng butno lm ie t Pa
ove n nt nttes ofi i l nd m oye , nc udi
t i t d o ge

Cou y of i l a e pl es be or obt ni l a ofc t
nt fc a s nd m oye , f e ai ng e ve our;
b. Le ve ofc t l be g a e onl upon Swize ' s ison of
a
our wil r nt d y
t rs ubm s i
:

i ah b a c r uspeiinfldp rua t o2 U. C.j 2 41 2 5 o
. a e s op tto ie u s n t 8 S. j 2 , 2 4 r
2255;or

i. apr pe l fld pl a ng i whih Swize de
i
o ry ie e di n c
t r monsr t t thei unde
taes ha
s
r
i i ntda rofs rousphysc lhn m o saescli st tar not
mm ne
nge
ei
ia r r tt am ha e
f i ous.
r vol

TheCl k i die t d t s nd ac rii d c oft sOr rt pli ifa t c ms lof
er s r c e o e
e tfe opy hi de o a ntf nd o ot e
r or
ec d.

ste: r / ,oa
nr Mah t 21
ed c
f
+f

2
.

.

r

M i hae F.Ur ns
c l
ba ki
Unie Stt DititJ e
td a es src udg

*