Nasser v. WhitePages, Inc.

Filing 54

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/7/2014. (jat)

O Fpes OFFI U. DI rcoul'
CE s. S .
4r
AT M
SONBURQ VA
Flçn
I

I THE UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W ESTERN DI
STRI O F VI NI
CT
RGI A
H A RR I NBU R G DI I O N
SO
V SI

J

1 21
24
*

N
:E

Fok'

*

n GQK
'

M I A EL J. A SSER ,SR .
CH
N
,

Pl ntf ,
ai if

Ci lA c i N o. :5: 2c
vi ton
1 v00097

V.

W HI
TEPAGES,I
NC,

By:H on. M i
chaelF.Urbanski
U nie St e D i t i tJudge
t d at s s r c

D ef
endant
.

M EM OR ANDUM OPI ON
NI
Thi mat ri bef r t c ton t moton oft pr s pl i ifM ihae J. N a s r Sr
s te s o e he our
he
i
he o e antf c l
se , .

(t se' .Na srsy e hsmoi na aS to f rrc n i eaino s
ç s r' se t ls i to s t in o e o sd rto f ummayj g n .
Na )
mo
r ud me t'
'
Thec t l c tu t moto a amotont atrora ndaj
our wil onsr e he in s
i o le me
udgme purua tt Fe r l
nt s n o de a
Rul ofCi lPr ed e59()1Fort r a onssaedhe en,hemotonwilbede e
e
vi oc ur e .
he e s tt r i t
i l
nid.
1
.

Thedee ntW hiepage ,I .(d hie es' i orecl lsedNase ' a e sa
fnda
t
s nc, t tpag ') nc r ty it
W
s rs ddrs nd
t l phone ast tofC
ee
ha
t c s Phone ofV igi a 'a S
com a t
r ni ' nd s ca tPhon ofV igi a ' A sa r s t
com s
t
r ni .'
e ul,

Nas e r cevedt a ofu
s r e i hous nds nwan e phone c lsi e
td
al ntnded f rComc t Nas e br
o
as.
s r oughts t
ui
1M oto f r onsde ain, whienotunc m o i f de a prctce ar notr c ze u rt Fe a Ruls
ins or ec i r to
l
om n n e r l a i , e
e ogni d nde he derl e

o CiiP o e u e Se Ambi Ma . . . i. e Pates LLC, .
f vl r c d r . e l
ng mtCo v Unv Viw rn r.
No WDQ-72 7l 2 0WL 4 7 0 ,
0 -0 , 01
558
a * n. ( Md. b. , 01 ) Ab v teBetl c v Me Bo a na Ro t u lc. 9F. D. 9, 0 ( D. .
t l 3 D. Fe 3 2 0 , o e h l n . . l h n n o- .n .9 R. 9 1 0 E. Va
*
.
m
1 3.Th Fo rhCic t shedta c u t s ul c n tu ap s-u g n moinfrrc n ieaintld
98 ) e u t ruiha l h t o rs ho d o sr e otj d me t to o eo sd rto ie
wi i 28d y o tee tyo j d me t samoint atro a n aj d me t u s a toRul 5 () Be a e
t n a s fh nl f u g n a
h
'
to o l r me d u g n p ru n t e 9 e. cus
e
N a s rfld hi m o i f r onsde ain wihi 28da oft c tsor ra i t r ta
s e ie s ton or ec i r to t n
ys he our' de doptng he epor nd

rc mme d to a dds si tec s,t lb c nsr e a amoint atr u g n p ru n t Rul 5 ()
e o n ain n imisng h a e iwil e o tu d s t o l j d me t us a to e 9e .
o
e
Se Do ev.
e v CODES 5 9F.d8 7, 0 (t Ci. 9 8 (() ap s-u g n moini tldwihn ( 1d ys
CO, 6 2 0 8 9 4h r 1 7 ) çlf o t d me t to s ie ti 28 a
t
j
ofh e tyo j d me ta c lsit q eto tec re t s o ta j g n is o l b te tda amoin
te nl f u g n nd al no u sin h o rcnes fh tud me tt h ud e rae s to
'
u d rRue5 ()h we e ima b fr l syld'; e as MLC Auo t . v. wno S uh r Pie ,
n e l 9 e, o v r t y e omal t e .) se lo
y
'
tmoi LLC To f o ten n s
ve
5 2F.d2 9 27 -7 (t Ci. 0 )(oigCODES c niu st a pyn t tsa dn tea n n t
3 3 6 , 7 8 4h r20 8 n tn
CO o tn e o p l owihtn ig h me dme t o
Fe r l l o Ap e lt Pr c dze4)
dea Rue f p l e o e l .
a
r
1

ont bassofnuia ,emoto ldite s a (venual pr sor eso l Ul maey,
he i
s nce
i na sr s , nd e t l omis y tppe. t tl
y)
i

t c u t r ne s mmayj dg n i fv ro W htpa e b c u eNa s rstr camswee
he o r g a td u r u me tn a o f ie g s e a s s e' o t li
r
ba r by t i muniy pr ded byt Com muni tonsDe nc Ac , 47U. C. 230, ndhi
red he m
t ovi
he
cai
ce y t
S. j
a s
pr m is y e t lcai wasnotr ogni d by Vigi a lw .2 Na s rnow ur est c t o
o s or soppe l m
ec ze
r ni a
se
g he our t

r onsde t thol ngf t ras ( )bec us t c tf l t c i rwha Nase '
ec i r ha di or wo e ons: 1 a e he our aied o onsde
t srs
sylsa hi t quia ee t
t e s s d tbl soppelcam'a ( be us t r aediputsoffc t tma
e
li ' nd 2) ca e he e r s e a t ha ke

s mmayj d me tn p r p it .Be a s Na s rsa g me t mia p e e t elw, i
u r u g n ia p o rae c u e se ' r u n s s p rh nd h a h s
moton mus be de e
i
t
ni d.
1
l.

Na s ra s rst tt c tonl ad e s d hi cl m ofpr is y e t
s e s e t ha he our y dr s e s ai
om s or soppela f ie t
nd a ld o

a es hi C li 'ore tbl e t .çg r sor et li a e tbl docrnewhih
ddr s s t am'f quia e soppel splomis y soppe s n quia e ti
c
c
ge r ly i us d t i pl a co r c whe e none e s s ' Tuom a a v. e ntU ni , 2 V a.
ne a l s e o m y
nt a t r
xi t .
'
l R ge
v. 25
368,

376, S. 2 501 506( 996 ( ttonomitd) Thetr nol ya is heei s wha
477 E.d ,
1 ) ciai
te .
emi og t sue r s ome t
c usng be us t equia edoc rne ofpr is yesoppe i ditnc fom t docrne of
onf i
ca e he
t bl
ti
om s or t l s si t r he ti
l hough bot ar docrne ofe t 3 N a s ri , how e ,c r c t t
h e ti s quiy. s e s
e ia e e t
qu t bl soppe t
ver or e t ha
e t bl e t
quia e s oppe i a di tnc docti u rV igi a l w .
l s si t
rne nde r ni a
N as e i lke i e co r c t tne t rt c tnorW hie gesadd e s d hi ç l m ' f
s r s i w s r c t ha ihe he our
t pa
r s e s s ai ' or
c

e tbl e t l Butt si bec us igj Vigi a t r i norc z d c us ofa tonf
quia e soppe.
hi s a e din r ni,he e s e ognie a e ci or
e t bl e t l a t docrnei us ly a s re a a s el r t rt n as d. Vici a
quia e soppe , nd he ti s ual s e td s hi d ahe ha wor ' r ni
'

Po rEnecvMkt .I v.EQT Ene c LLC,3: 1
we
r
c. nc.
r v.
1 CV630,201 W L 29 1 at*1 ( D.
2
051 0, 0 E.

2A m or f s e r ia i oft l ngt f c uala pr dur lbac ound oft sm a t c n be f
e ulom ec t ton he e hy a t nd oce a kgr
hi ter a
ound i t
n he

c u tss mmayj g n o iin.( tNo 51.Thec u t lrfanfo rh s n t t itr hee a i i
o r' u r ud me t pno Dk. . )
o rwi eri rm e ahig ha hsoy r, s ts
l
onl tnge i l r eva t t is c rntybeor t cour.Butonepoi i worh r ieai N a s ralo
y a ntaly el nt o he sue ure l f e he
t
nt s t et rtng: s e s
br
oughts ta i tVerz whopr dedt f t lsi t W hiepage ,a ha s tldt tcai
ui gans ion,
ovi he auly itng o t
s nd s ete ha l m.
3Buts OrtGan, Pr is yEsoppelA Calf rA M or I l i Conta Law,1 J. e rRa & J t 47,
ee i
om sor t
:
l o
e ncusve
rct
6 G nde ce us.

5 (01 )(oigt t r mis r etp e h sbcnc tg rz da ac nrc,o to e utbl d crn )
6 2 3 n t ha p o so y so p l a e ae o ie s o tattr, r q i e o tie .
n
a

Va. ul 1 201 (nena atrto omit )( i Pake v. e tt l ., 301F.
J y 6, 2) itr l leains ted quotng r r W sa.nc
supp.
zd
53 5 ( D. 2004)( l tngc s l.Thus t r i nos ht ngasa' li ' s don
7, 44 E. Va.
coleci a es)
,hee s uc hi
' am'ba e
c
t docrneofe t bl eso .
he ti
quia e t ppel

I iss
n t ummayj me o ni t c tc nsr dNa s ' pla ngsf e tbl o
r udg nt pi on,he our o tue sers e di or quia e r
pr s or e t la mali ac am ba e on t e t bl d ti ofpr s or e t ppe .
omis y soppe s tng l i s d he quia e oc rne
omis y so l

I d igs ,h c u t sk e i gist biago )t c n tu gr s pe dng )l rl t
n on o te o r wa e p n t i l tin o o sr e p o e la i s i al o
o g
be y
a s r a a a 1l ga c a m st tis f c ua a l to c f il be t
s e t ny nd 1 e l l i ha t a t l lega i ns an a r y houghtt s ppo t''
o u r.

M atnv,Ge ie,849F. 863,868( hCi.1 )(iai omitd) s eas Unie Sttsv.
ri
ntl
2d
4t r 988 ctton te ; e lo td ae

W is n, 9 F.d78 7 7( t Ci. 01 )(iai no te )(fcl u t mu tl rlyc n tu
lo 6 9 3 9, 9 4h r 2 2 etto mi d k o rs s i al o sr e
t
g
be
t cli ofpr s ltga s.'.Thec tdi notco tuet pladi a a sri e tbl
he ams o e ii ntgl'
)
our d
nsr he e ngs s se tng quia e
et
soppela ac eofa ton, no pl a ng ca betf il t htt s
s aus
c i as
e di
n dary houg o uppor'lgalc am st t
t e
'
l i ha

donote s.Se 4W ilsononConta sj8: ( hed. ( tngErc onv.Br 81 N. .
xit e
lit
rct 3 4t ) cii iks
own, 3 W 2d
531( D.201 (t uia eesoppeli nota afnnai c us ofa tona c nno beus dt
N.
2) d tbl t
Eq
s n fi tve a e ci nd a t
e o

ce t a e f re bea re n bewe npate .l 28Am . u . dEso p la dW av rj 1
rae n n o c a l g e me t t e ris';
'
J r 2 tp e n
ie
(ii Longv. P M o ga Cha eBa Na.As ' 848F.Supp. 11 ( Ha 201
ctng
J r n s nk, t sn,
2d 66 D. w. 2)
(t uia eeso lma berie unde fde a andsae1w et rasa afr tvedee eor
t tbl tppe y as d
Eq
r e rl
tt a ihe n fimai fns
t prventa t rpa t fom rii a afi tvede e e' .
o e
nohe ry r asng n fnnai f ns .'
)
The c esa yi t docrneofe t bl e t
as ppl ng he ti
quia e soppelct d byN a s rdo notdit t a
ie
se
c ae

difr ntr ul.l Gitrv. r a & Thorci Sur ca Asocit . d.41 F. x 3 ( h
fe e es t n te Cadic
a c gi l s aes Lt , 9 App' 65 4t
Ci. 1 , Alba doco washie byaVigi ahos t asisnew c e ofc r a
r 201 ) an a ma tr
rd
r ni pial t
hif a dic
s ge y. Ther w a ,how e r no w rte c r c a t hos t lw ihdr w t o f r of
ur r
e s
ve ,
it n ont a t nd he pia t e he f e
em pl ent A lhough t Fourh Cicui r er ed t t doct s çcl m ofequiabl es oppel'
oym . t
he
t r t ef r o he
or' t ai
t e t
,'

t dod o di nots on a t or ofequia e r i nce.l t ad, he doe ors d on t
he
r d
ue
ny he y
t bl ela
ns e t
t ue
he

c r c ,a a ke t tt hos t lç e uia y es o
ont a t nd s d ha he pia d q t bl t pped f o a s ri a St t e ofFr uds
be
r m s e tng
a ut
a
'
4
n t e , quia e soppe i
dee e. l .at367. Thus,i Git r e tbl et lddnots r ea t c eofa tons(
fns ' d
e v s he aus ci a

s d) bu i ta wa a s td a aba t a afr tvedee e( s ed) Si yputGitr
wor , t nse d s sere s r o n fimai fns a hil . mpl , fe
i ve ac r tcli îkat369(ç dititco ti recl a idt lw oft ca et
nvol d ontac am,.
l
$
The src ur ncor ty pple he a
he s o
.

Gitrsb e c o o ta tcai '(mp a i a d d ) a dte eo ed e no s p o th
te ' r a h fc nr c l m. e h ss d e l, n h rf r o s t u p r te
'
poston t tN a s rs dbea e t pm s acli ofe t bl e t
ii ha s e houl
bl o
ue a m
quia e soppelhe e.
r

Si ldy,i M c l v. c l,43Va Ci. 1 W L 3361 9( ki ha Ct
mia n Ca1 M cal
. r 296, 997
651 Roc ng m y.
Ci.Ct Se . 1 ,adi v ea e awies e sulyase t e tbl et la a
r . pt4, 997) vore s , f uco s f l s red quia e soppe s n
a fr ai def ns a ns he hus nd' e or eme ofane ry de ade ol s par ton
fim tve e e gai t r ba s nf c nt
a l c - d e ai

a ee ,whe et c eha r onc ld s ty a trm a ng t ag ee t J,s at*5.
gr ment r he oupl d ec ie horl fe ki he r men . d
..

Agan, t eesoppeldi no s r asa c us ofa ton.Fi l i Ba r v.Donnelv, 1
i equiabl t
d t e ve
a e ci
naly, n ry
l 78

F.d 1 40(t Ci. 98 ) t epanifs ug tad caao yj dg n t r s leac nr v ry
2 0 4h r 1 6 ,h litf o h e lrt r u me t o e ov o to es
ove t ow ne s p ofa pa ntng i t pl i if spos es i The dit i tco ta a de t
r he
r hi
i i n he a ntf
s s on.
s r c ur w r d he

p an ifs mma yj d me t tn n t a t esau eo lmi to sh dnm o d fnd n '
litf u r u g n ,i dig h t h ttt f i t in a
a
n ee a ts
ase tonofownes p.TheFourh Cic trve sd, i t tSg nde Vigni lw,onema
sri
rhi
t rui e re notng ha tuj r ri a a
y
be e t
s oppe t pl a t ba ofa s a ut oflm ia i by co uc s toff a unde t
d o e d he r
t t e i t tons
nd t hor
r ud,
r he

ge rldocrneofe tbl et s' I a 1 ( tngCiyofBedfr v.JmesLef &
nea ti
quia e soppel. d. t 042 cii t
'
od a
fel

Co,5 8F.d21 , 7 1 ( t Ci.9 7) Th Fo rh Cic i rma d dtec s t d tr n i
. 5 2 6 21 - 8 4h r1 7 ). e u t rut e n e h a e o eemie f
e tbl eso lbar dt i ai oft saut oflmiai .J a 1
quia e tppe re he nvoc ton he tt e i ttons #= t 043.Agan,
i
eq t bl es o lw a nota c ai orca e ofa ton, a pot nta ba t t a s ri n o an
uia e t ppe s
lm
us
c i but
e i l r o he s e to f
afi tve de e e. Bec us e t bl es o li nota va i c us ofa i n, as e ' a s r i
fnna i
f ns
a e quia e t ppe s
ld a e cto N s r s s e ton

4v igi a' St tt o Fr udsr quiest ce t n c r t bewrte i or rt beenf ce bl. Se ge r l
r ni s aue f a
e r hat rai ontacs
itn n de o
or a e e nealy,

C. re Va c n l . . Loe z , 79Va 4 , 65 , 8 SE.d65 , 6 (01 )
Po tr u ha .nc v Di rn o 2
. 49 45 -7 6 9 . 2 6 6 0 2 0 .

ofa e t bl esoppe ç a m ' do notpr vi a r s n t a t rora e d t c ts
n quia e t l t i ' es
cl
o de ny ea o o le
m nde he our '

j dg n .
u me t
111
.

N a s ra s a
s e lo ppea st a guet tbec us t r a e ge ne f cua diput , t court
r o r ha
a e he e r nui a t l s es he

erdi g a tn s mmayj d me to hsp o soye tp l li .Bu s mmayj d mc t
re n r ni g u r u g n n i r mis r so pe cam
tu r u g n
woul onl bei ppr i t i t f t i diput we ema e i l See Cros vvCiv of
d y na oprae f he acs n s e r t ra .
bv
t

Ga tn a 6 F.d6 4 6 4n.2(t Ci. 0 1 (uoigFe R. v. 5 () (ç io r s al
so i , 35 3 3 , 4 l 4h ' 2 1 ) q tn d. Ci P. 6 a) C c u t h l
r
A
ga ts mmayj d me t f h mo n s o ta teei n g n ieds u ea t a yma e il
r n u r u g n i t e va t h ws h t h r s o e un ip t s o n tra

f c a dt emo a t se t ldt j dg n a amatro lw.' e h ssa d d ) Th
a t n h v n i ni e o u me t s te f a ' (mp a i d e l. e
t
'
dipu e f t a e no m a e i lhe e
s t d ac s r t t r a r .

Nas e bas hi docrneofpr s or e t lcai on a c
s r ed s ti
omis y soppe l m
onve s ton heha wih a
rai
d t
W hie ge c t e s r c r pr s nt tve o Oct r28,
t pa s us om r e vi e e e e a i n
obe
2009. N a s ras e t t tdurng
s e s red ha
i
t sc
hi onve s ton,t r pr s nt tve t d hi s had r ove t of e i lsi f om t
r a i he e e e a i ol m he
em d he f ns ve i tngs r he

W hie ge webst a t tNa srt nof t ra tont mii t hi ijtyi rla eo
tpa s
ie, nd ha se ook urhe ci o tgae s n t n einc n
r
t s pr i e. One o t a g u ntW hie ge r i e i r s ns t N as e ' pr i s y
hi om s
f he r t ne
t pa s a s d n e po e o
s r s om s or
et
s oppe c ai w a t tN a s rw asnoti e ona e ' n hi r la e o t c t e s r i e r p'
l l m s ha s e
t as bl ' i s e i nc n he usom r e v c e s
r
s a e e s N as e quie c r ty not t tt r s bl nes ofhi r i nc on t s a e e s
t t m nt .
s r t or ec l
es ha he ea ona e s
s ela e he t t m nt

i g n rlyaq sin o f c f rajzyt d cd .S eGitrv Cada & Tho a i S r ia
s e eal ueto f a t o l o e ie e te . r ic
r
r cc u gc l
Asocae .Lt , 9F.App' 365,370( hCi.2011 ( tngt trla a r s blnes
s its d.41
x
4t r
) noi ha eince nd eaona e s
aepr mi ntyfcua is f atiroff t.Howe r e n a s ngNa srsrlmwe
r ee ne l a t l sues or re ac)
ve, ve sumi
se ' ei
w a r a ona e t ti ,t ki t f c si t lg m os f vo a e t N as e , he non- ovi
s e s bl - ha s a ng he a t n he i ht
t a r bl o
sr t
m ng
pa t he c nnotpr va lon hi c a m be aus Vi g ni 1 w doe notr cog ze pr m i s z
rya
e i
s li
c e ri a a
s
e ni
o so.
y

5

et
soppel Thi c l i i o oflw,a i i t r f r pr rgr
. s oncuson s ne a nd t s he e o e ope oundson whih t a r
c o wa d

s mmayj d me t
u r u g n.

N a s c nnota s thi e t bl e t
s er a
s er s quia e s oppelc ai be a e alhoug t doc rne i
l m c us , t
h he t i s
r ogni ed i V igi a i i nota ca e ofa ton butr t r a a fr a i def e. A sa m a t r
ec z n r ni , t s
us
ci
a he n f im tve ens
te
ofl w , c nno pr vai on hi pr i s y esoppe c a m be a e,a t ug i i a c us of
a he a t e l
s om s or t
l li
c us lho h t s a e

acin,hedodrnei no rcog z i Vigi a TheRul 59()moi t r i wihoutmei
to t
i s t e nied n r ni.
e e ton hee s t
rt
a s lac or ngl bede e by s pa ae o de e e e t sday.
nd hal c di y
nid
e r t r r nt r d hi
TheCl r i diece t s nd ac tfe c oft sM emor ndum Opi ont c ms lof
e k s r td o e
erii d opy hi
a
ni o ot e
r c d and t pr s pl ntf .
e or
he o e ai if

En e ed:
tr

7 -//
t

/ * - r /.*,-e U
J ' 4
4
N-*
N
.

M i hae F.U r ns
c l
ba ki
Unie St t sDiti tJ
t d a e src udge

6