White v. Astrue
Filing
18
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/1/2013. (jat)
I ' > vx
N ru :
l s o sl Ts s m svm c' c o c u '
r
w
r
r
N p-Ayuaoot .Dl = =
o- lo
ceua r
xj k
l a
o
ml p
p
Fol rl w ssr t m s c' oFvlt xl
trls
rslx Tm r
lcl A
I m ts
u l oxst c ol s ox
m
vl l
12 1
23
qc u
.
c
BY;
LA RR Y W .W H ITE,
Pl nt f ,
ai if
Ci lA c i N o. 5: v11
vi t on
: 12c 7
V.
CA R O LYN W .CO LV I
N,
ACTI COM M I ONER OF,
NG
SSI
SO CI L SEC U RI ,
A
TY
By:H on.M i
chaelF.U rbans
ki
Uni ed St es D i ri Judge
t
at
st ct
De endant
f
.
M EM O R AND U M O PI I N
N O
Thi matri bef et c to dee ntsM otont Se AsdeDef t( . 11
s te s or he our n fnda '
i o t i
aul DktNo. )
fld on Aprl26,201 On Oc obe 26,201 pl ntf fl ac
ie
i
3.
t r
2, ai if ied ompli s e ngr vi oft
ant e ki e ew he
Aci Commiso rs(heScommisone ' de ii t de hi s pplme als c iy
tng
sine' t t
si r' cson o ny m u e nt e urt
)
i om e The s
nc .
umm onswass r edon t Comm isone on Nove
ev
he
si r
mber1 201 wih a a we
9, 2, t n ns r
d e pu s n t Lo a Rue4( )2 , nM a c 1 , 01 .OnAp i 2 , 01 ,h ma itaej g
u , rua to c l l b () o r h 9 2 3
rl 5 2 3 t e gsrt ud e
e ee a or rdieci t Clr oft Cour (heE ek' t e e dea ta i tt
ntrd n de r tng he ek he
tt $ r ' o ntr ful gans he
Cl )
Commisone frhe fiur t ans ro ot r s dee a i tpli ifsc an.( .
si r o r al e o we r hewie fnd gans antf omplit Dkt
No.9. Dea twa enerdbyt Clr ont s meday.( . 1 ) Pli iftlda
) ful s t e
he ek he n
DktNo. 0. antf ie
r pons i oppostont dee ntsmotont s tai dea tonAprl29,201 ( .
es e n
ii o fnda ' i o e sde ful
i
3. DktNo.
çl eds o iino mo in ma eu d rRue5 (). i amatrwh c le lz l
s- ip sto f to s d n e l 5 c . s te ih is agey
h
.
wihi t dicei oft tilj ' Cons .M aorr & Fie ootnc.l v.W ag n
t n he s rton he ra udge.
'
ol s lv r pr i nc.
ma
Consr Cor ,38 F. 249,251(t Ci.1 .l consdei whehe t
t. p. 3 2d
4h r 967) n i rng t r i ca e' xit t
good us 'e ss o
1Theco tdeci st he ror lagum e a i wil ai i isde sonalpr s .
ur lne o a a r
nt s t lnot d n t cii
oce s
sta i ed fut ud me t nd rRue5 () ac ur s u dc nsd rk te t mo i gpat
e sd ea lj g n u e l 5 c, o t ho l o ie f h r he v n ry
whe
ha ame ioro de e e whehe i a t wih r a ona epr
s
rt i us f ns , t r t c s t e s bl ompt s t pe s lr ponsbiiy
nes , he r ona es i lt
o ted fuln p ry,h peu iet t p ry, eh rt r i ahsoyo dltr a o
f h ea t g at te rjdc o he at wh te hee s itr f iaoy din,
i
a t a ia lt ofs tonsls dr si ' Pay e r . tt ofCal dav.Br ke,439F.
nd he val biiy anc i e s a tc.
' ne x el Esa e
za
a
3d
1 20
98, 4-05( h Ci.2006) TheFo t Cic thase ese altongprf e et t a a
4t r
.
urh rui
xpr sd s r
s
eernc ha, s
ge a m at r def ulsbe a ded a t tcli sa def ns sbedipos d ofon t i me is'
ner l te , a t
voi
nd ha am nd e e
s e
her rt.'
Coleo Prpaaov Ac d.l v.
ltn e rtr a .nc. Hoove Uni r a.nc.61 F. 41 41 ( hCi.201 )
r ves ll , 6 3d 3, 7 4t r 0 .
Dea lj d me ti e p cal dsa o e i stainswhee a h r ,h dee d n i t e
f ut u g n s s e ily ifv r d n i to
u
r, s ee t e fn a t s h
g v nz n .Se Fe R. v P. 5d ( r v dn ta ta d fut u g n ma b e trd
o e me t e d. Ci. 5 () p o i ig h t t l ea lj d me t y e n ee
l
agans t Unied St t s isofi r ,orisa ncesonl i t cai tesa ihesacli o
i t he t
a e , t fce s t ge i
y f he l man tbls
am r
rgh t r i bye denc t tstsi t c fl;seas Eli tv.Comm'ofSoc.Sec,6:0i t o elef vi e ha aifes he oul e lo lot
r
. 1
CV00032,2011W L 2836283,a *1( . Va.J y 1 2011 (ole tngc es.
t W D. ul 4, ) c lci as )
H e e, he Co m i sone ha s n good c us t s tas de t e t y ofdef ul. W hie
r t
m s i r s how
a e o e i he n r
a t
l
t Com m i s one i ce t nl per onaly r pons bl f t f iur t r pond tm el t
he
s i r s rai y s l es
i e or he a l e o es
i yo
pl i if s c pl i ,t tve ot rPa f ct s c
a ntf om a nt he i
he vne a or ouns li f vorofs ti a i t Cl r s
e n a
e tng s de he e k'
e r ofde a t Si fca l t Com m i s one ac e w ih r as bl pr pt s by flng he
nty
f ul. gni i nty, he
s i r t d t e ona e om ne s ii
r
a s r( tNo. 3 ,hea miitaieta cit( tNo 1 ) a dh rmoint s t sd
n we Dk . 1 ) t d n sr t rnsrp Dk . . 4 , n e to o e a ie
v
d a t( . 11 oneda atrt Clr ' e r ofdea tz Theei nohitr ofdiao y
eful DktNo. )
y fe he ek s nty
ful. r s
so y ltr
a ton i t sc s a t flng oft a we a admi sr tveta c i i c t t t
c i n hi a e, nd he ii
he ns r nd
nitai r ns rpt ndia e hat he
Comm isone hasme iorousde e e a pl t plad a ot wie de e agans t s t
si r
rt i
f ns s nd ans o e nd her s f nd i t he ui.
Fi ly, heCom misone i c t t tt e r wa duet m itke ori dve tnce a noti
na l t
s i r ndia es ha he ror s
o sa
na re , nd
n
ba f ih. Se e. .Eli t 6: 0- d at
e, g. lot, 1 CV 00032,
2011 W L 2836283,a *1.
t
2Pl ntf' r s ewaspr iedon t m itke beleft tt adm i srtvetans rpta a we hadnotbee
ai ifs e pons
em s
he sa n i ha he
nita i r c i nd ns r
n
fl
ied.
2
Plitf a g st a h i p eudc dp i rl d et ted lyc u e b t
an if r ue h t e s rj ie rma i u o h ea a s d y he
y
Co sin rsd f ut ( tNo. 6 a !7. Slj lyi a o is l d e n t o ttt
mmiso e ' ea l. Dk . 1 , t ) ç lea n nd f tef o s o c nsiue
l
p eu ie ColtnPrp.61 F.da 41 Tob s r , litf h sfie t alg a y a t l
rj dc . leo e , 6 3 t 7. e u e p an if a ald o le e n cua
p eu iei h sr s o e a atit-ih d yd lyi r s ndn t tec mpan i n t
rj de n i e p ns , nd hry eg t a ea n epo ig o h o lit s o
s t e t l n t s g e t h t an ifwa p eu ie a amatro lw.S eBu tnv. e
uf nl o g o u g s t a plitf s rj d c d s te f a e ro Th
ki y
TJ Cos.nc.No. 07
X .l , 3: -CV-76 2008W L 1
0,
944033,a * ( D. Ma 1 2008) $
t 4 E. Va. y ,
.ç
To
d tr n i t en n d futn p ry wa p eu ie , o rse miewheh rt ed ly (a s d
eemi e f h o - ea lig a t s rj dc d c u t xn n
te h ea c u e
byt deful) ( )ma i i sbl f t non- fuli pa t t pr ents ofis
he a t: 1 de t mposi e or he dea tng ry o es ome t
e denc ( ma imor difc tf t no dea tngpa t t pr e wihti ;(
vi e; 2) de t e fiul or he n- fuli ry o oce d t ral 3)
hn rdt non- fuli pa t sa lt t complt dico r a ( wasus dbyt
mpee he dea tng ry' biiy o
ee s vey; nd 4)
e
he
de a tng pa ' t c l orc m i a f a ' 1 N one oft s f c or a y he e
f uli
l y o olude om t r ud. d.
t
'
he e a t s ppl r .
Fi ly,al s dr tcs nc i i aval bl Specfc ly, heCo misone s s st t
na l e s asi a ton s ia e.
ii a l t
m s i r ugge t ha
panif alwe a a i o a sx yd y t fl hsmo inf rs mma yj d me t Plitf
li tf be lo d n ddt n l it a s o i i to o u r u g n . an if
i
e
s e t beiv t a s c a e tn i nwo l p eu iehm e e frh r saigdh Ag n y
e ms o le e h t u h n x e so u d rj d c i v n u te, ttn s e e c
t
h stetmeiyt o frt ep an ifa a dto a 3 d yso p eudc . ( t No 1 , 7)
a h e rt o fe h litf n d iin l 0 a f rj ie' Dk . . 6 ! .
'
Thus i lghtoft Fo t Ci e t sS i e w o n com m im e t t r ol ton of
,n i
he urh r ui' t m - r
t
t nt o he es u i
diput on t i m e is't cou tfndst (
s es her rt , he r i hat ç
'
good ca e' sst va t t e r ofde a t
us 'exit o cae he nty
f ul
unde Rul 55() ColeonPr p.61 F.d a 420( hCi.201 .Purua t Loca Rul 4()
r e c . lt e , 6 3 t
4t r 0) s nt o
l e c,
pl ntf i diecedt fl hi brefwihi t ry( )da oft daeofe r oft
ai if s r t o ie s i t n hit 30 ys he t nty he
a ompa ngor r TheCommisone ' rs ei duet ry( da afe pl ntf sbre
cc
nyi de .
si rs epons s hit 30) ys tr ai if if
i f l d. An a opra e or roft cour s l be e e e t sda
s ie
ppr i t de
he
t ha l nt r d hi y.
The Cl r oft Cour i he e diec ed t s nd a ce tfe co Oft s M e or ndtm
e k he
t s r by r t o e
ri i d py hi
m a l
O pi o a t a com pa ng Or rt a lc
ni n nd he c
nyi
de o l ouns lofr or
e
ec d.
3
Ent r d: M a 1 201
ee
y , 3
4/* 3 4f
4M
M i ha F.Ur ki
c el
bans
Unie St t D i ti tJ
t d a es s r c udge
4
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?