Chaplin v. Maas et al

Filing 29

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 9 Motion to Dismiss; granting in part and denying in part 11 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 25 Report and Recommendations. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/26/13. (kld)

I TH E UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT
N
FO R TH E W ESTER N DISTRICT O F V I GINIA
R
H ARR ISON BURG DIW SIO N
W A LTER CH APLIN ,
Pl nt f,
ai if
V.

DA NI M A AS,etaI,
EL
.
D ef
endant .
s

)
)
)
Ci l ton No 5:2c 28
viAc i
. 1 v300
)
)
) By: M ihae F.Ur ki
c l
bans
)
Unie St t sDit itJudge
t d a e s rc
)
O RD ER

Thi m a t rw a r f r e t t H o a e B. a Crgl r Unied S a e M a sr t
s te s e e r d o he nor bl W ugh i e , t t t s gita e

J , s ntt 28U. C.j636( ()B) f pr posdfndi o fc a arc
udge purua o
S.
b)l( ,or o e i ngs f a t nd e omme e
nd d
diposton.Thema srt j fldarpo t ndr o
s ii
gitae udge ie e r a ec mmen to onFe u r 1 2 3,
dain
bray , 01
r
ecomm endi t def
ng hat endant m oton t di m i be gr ed w ih r pectt t cl m sagai t
s' i o s ss
ant
t es
o he ai
ns

Ofl e D a el a s a d de e wih r s c t t c a m s a ai tDe y J Tyr e a Sh if
tc r ni M a n ni d t e pe t o he l i g ns put oe e nd erf

Ra alFihe;rc mmendi t tdee a s moinf s
nd l s r e o
ng ha fnd nt' to or ummayj dgme bede edas
r u nt ni
m oo a t t c ai sa i td f nda M a a gr n e i pa ta de e i pa t t t
t s o he l m ga ns e e nt as nd a t d n r nd ni d n r as o he
cl m sagai tdef
ai
ns endant Tyr and Fiher and r
s ee
s ;
ecom m endi t tdef ndant M aas a Fi her
ng ha e
s
nd s

bedimis dfom t sa to Defnda sa pli iffldobe to t vai po tonso t
s se r hi cin. e nt nd antf ie j cins o rous ri f he
r tand r
epor
ecom m endaton.
i

Thec ur ha c rf l rviwe t ma srt j e' rpor al jcinst te
o t s aeuly e e d he gitae udg s e q lobe to o h
r t t peri portonsoft r d,and t r evantl aut t a i s doi
epor, he tnent i
he ecor
he el
egal horiy nd, n o ng,

ma adenovodeemi tonoft eporinsoft rpo towhiho jci weema
de
tr nai
hos to
he e r t c be tons r de.
Theco tc l st ttema srt j dge' rpor i s tnilyc rc.Acc r ngl t
ur oncude ha h gitae u s e ts ubsa tal ore t odi y,he
c r ADOPTSt ma srt j ' rc
ou t
he gitae udges e omme toni ise trt
ndai n t niey.

I i t r f e O RDERED a ADJUD G ED a f l s
t s he e or
nd
s olow :
n
n
Dee nt'moto t dimis( . 9 i GR ANTED i partand DENIED i part
fnda s in o s s Dkt# ) s
asf l s:
olow

a Def n nt moto t dim i si G R AN TED ast pl i if scl i sa i t
.
e da s' i n o s s s
o a ntf ' a m ga ns
def ntM aas;
enda

b. D e e a s m o i n t dim is i DENI a t pl i ifs c a m sa ns
f nd nt ' to o s s s
ED s o a ntf l i gai t
de e n sTyr e & Fihe ;
f nda t
e
s r
D ef
endantM aas i her D I I
s eby SM SSED fom t s a i
r hi cton;

3. Dee ns moi frs
fnda t' ton o ummayj me ( . l )i GRANTED i par a
r udg nt Dkt# 1 s
n t nd
DENI i par asf l s:
ED n t olow

a. Dee a s moinf s
fnd nt' to or ummayj dgme ti DENI asmoo wihr pett
r u n s
ED
t t es c o
t cl m sagai tdef
he ai
ns endantM aas;

b. Defnda s'moto f s
e nt
in or ummayj
r udgme o fiur t e us g o i
nt n al e o xha t r unds s
D ENIED w ih r pectt t cl m sagai tdef
t es
o he ai
ns endant Tyr and Fi he
s ee
s r;

c. Dee nt'moinf s
fnda s to or ummayj
r udgme ti GRANTED a t pli ifssae
n s
s o antf' tt
l gr sneglgence cl m r s agai tdef
aw os
i
ai aied
ns endant Tyr and Fiher beca
s ee
s , use
t cl m i ba ed by t a i e s a ut oflm iatons;
he ai s rr
he pplcabl t t e i t i
Def
endantFiheri her DISM I
s s eby
SSED f t s acton.
rom hi i

The Cl r i die t t s n a c r ii d c o t s Or rt c
e k s r c ed o e d e tfe opy f hi de o ouns lofr c r
e
e o d.
Ent ed: M ar 26,2013
er
ch

/ /' 4 J f W c
+ m A
Mi
chaelF.U r
bans
ki
Unied St t D it i J
t
a es s rct udge