Chaplin v. Maas et al

Filing 29

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 9 Motion to Dismiss; granting in part and denying in part 11 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 25 Report and Recommendations. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/26/13. (kld)

Download PDF
I TH E UNITED STATES DISTRICT CO URT N FO R TH E W ESTER N DISTRICT O F V I GINIA R H ARR ISON BURG DIW SIO N W A LTER CH APLIN , Pl nt f, ai if V. DA NI M A AS,etaI, EL . D ef endant . s ) ) ) Ci l ton No 5:2c 28 viAc i . 1 v300 ) ) ) By: M ihae F.Ur ki c l bans ) Unie St t sDit itJudge t d a e s rc ) O RD ER Thi m a t rw a r f r e t t H o a e B. a Crgl r Unied S a e M a sr t s te s e e r d o he nor bl W ugh i e , t t t s gita e J , s ntt 28U. C.j636( ()B) f pr posdfndi o fc a arc udge purua o S. b)l( ,or o e i ngs f a t nd e omme e nd d diposton.Thema srt j fldarpo t ndr o s ii gitae udge ie e r a ec mmen to onFe u r 1 2 3, dain bray , 01 r ecomm endi t def ng hat endant m oton t di m i be gr ed w ih r pectt t cl m sagai t s' i o s ss ant t es o he ai ns Ofl e D a el a s a d de e wih r s c t t c a m s a ai tDe y J Tyr e a Sh if tc r ni M a n ni d t e pe t o he l i g ns put oe e nd erf Ra alFihe;rc mmendi t tdee a s moinf s nd l s r e o ng ha fnd nt' to or ummayj dgme bede edas r u nt ni m oo a t t c ai sa i td f nda M a a gr n e i pa ta de e i pa t t t t s o he l m ga ns e e nt as nd a t d n r nd ni d n r as o he cl m sagai tdef ai ns endant Tyr and Fiher and r s ee s ; ecom m endi t tdef ndant M aas a Fi her ng ha e s nd s bedimis dfom t sa to Defnda sa pli iffldobe to t vai po tonso t s se r hi cin. e nt nd antf ie j cins o rous ri f he r tand r epor ecom m endaton. i Thec ur ha c rf l rviwe t ma srt j e' rpor al jcinst te o t s aeuly e e d he gitae udg s e q lobe to o h r t t peri portonsoft r d,and t r evantl aut t a i s doi epor, he tnent i he ecor he el egal horiy nd, n o ng, ma adenovodeemi tonoft eporinsoft rpo towhiho jci weema de tr nai hos to he e r t c be tons r de. Theco tc l st ttema srt j dge' rpor i s tnilyc rc.Acc r ngl t ur oncude ha h gitae u s e ts ubsa tal ore t odi y,he c r ADOPTSt ma srt j ' rc ou t he gitae udges e omme toni ise trt ndai n t niey. I i t r f e O RDERED a ADJUD G ED a f l s t s he e or nd s olow : n n Dee nt'moto t dimis( . 9 i GR ANTED i partand DENIED i part fnda s in o s s Dkt# ) s asf l s: olow a Def n nt moto t dim i si G R AN TED ast pl i if scl i sa i t . e da s' i n o s s s o a ntf ' a m ga ns def ntM aas; enda b. D e e a s m o i n t dim is i DENI a t pl i ifs c a m sa ns f nd nt ' to o s s s ED s o a ntf l i gai t de e n sTyr e & Fihe ; f nda t e s r D ef endantM aas i her D I I s eby SM SSED fom t s a i r hi cton; 3. Dee ns moi frs fnda t' ton o ummayj me ( . l )i GRANTED i par a r udg nt Dkt# 1 s n t nd DENI i par asf l s: ED n t olow a. Dee a s moinf s fnd nt' to or ummayj dgme ti DENI asmoo wihr pett r u n s ED t t es c o t cl m sagai tdef he ai ns endantM aas; b. Defnda s'moto f s e nt in or ummayj r udgme o fiur t e us g o i nt n al e o xha t r unds s D ENIED w ih r pectt t cl m sagai tdef t es o he ai ns endant Tyr and Fi he s ee s r; c. Dee nt'moinf s fnda s to or ummayj r udgme ti GRANTED a t pli ifssae n s s o antf' tt l gr sneglgence cl m r s agai tdef aw os i ai aied ns endant Tyr and Fiher beca s ee s , use t cl m i ba ed by t a i e s a ut oflm iatons; he ai s rr he pplcabl t t e i t i Def endantFiheri her DISM I s s eby SSED f t s acton. rom hi i The Cl r i die t t s n a c r ii d c o t s Or rt c e k s r c ed o e d e tfe opy f hi de o ouns lofr c r e e o d. Ent ed: M ar 26,2013 er ch / /' 4 J f W c + m A Mi chaelF.U r bans ki Unied St t D it i J t a es s rct udge

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?