Dennison v. Astrue

Filing 23

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 11/27/13. (kld)

t tM s De s n ha no e
ha . nni o d t ngag i s tntalganf aci t snceJ nua y 31 201 t
ed n ubsa i i ul tviy i
a r , 0, he

daeofhe al eddia lt ons t ( .21.
t
r leg s biiy e. Tr )
M s De s fl d ea le a i a i nsf di a lt i ur nce be is a f
. nni on ie ri r pplc to or s biiy ns a
neft nd or

s e nt s c iyi
upplme al e urt ncomebe isonFe nl y25,
neft
b ar 2008.( . ) Thos cai wer
Tr 201.
e l ms e

de e uponi talc ie ai andr c i rton.( .201.Shet nr uetdaX novo
nid
nii onsd r ton
e onsdeai Tr )
he eq se
he i a rviw beor a Admi srtveLa J e.( .201.I a opi ondaed
arng nd e e f e n
nitai w udg Tr ) n n ni t
De mbe 18,2009,heLaw J as de e plitf scai .( .201 .M s Demion
ce r
t
udge lo nid anif l ms Tr ) . l s
a
ppea ed t d ni lofhe c a m sf di a lt i ur nc be ft a f s e e a s ct iy
l he e a
r l i or s biiy ns a e ne is nd or uppl m nt l e z t
r
i om e be ft t t Soc a Se urt Adm i sr ton' Appe l Counci, hi h a ed t
nc
ne is o he i l c iy
ni ta i s
as
l w c dopt he

Law J
udge' de a ast fnalde ii oft Commisone .( . .Ha nge usedhe
s nil he i
cson he
si r Tr 202) vi xha t r
a nitai r me e ,s t na l t de alofhe camst t sc t ( .203)
dmi sr tve e dis he he ppeaed he ni
r li o hi our. Tr
.
H oweve ,i a o ni da e J y 1 20l1 t s c ta fr e On t toc ason, s De s n
r n n pi on t d ul ,
, hi our f im d.
ha c i M . nni o
ha aleg a di a lt ons tda e ofJ nua y 1 2008. The c tf
d l ed
s biiy e t
a r ,
our ound t tt m e c lr t
ha he di a epors
c pl t d durng t r l va pe i oftm e s
om e e
i he e e nt r od i uppored t de e m i t o t tM s Den s n w as
t he t r na i n ha
. ni o

notdia edf alf msofs tnta ganf e o nt ( .
s bl or l or
ubsa il i ul mplyme . Tr 200-1 .
3)
O n M a 1 201 t pl i iff l d ne a i a i f r ape i ofdi a lt a
y 8, 0, he a ntf ie w pplc tons o
rod
s biiy nd

dia lt i ur nc beneis andf s plme a s urt i
sbiiy ns a e
ft, or up e ntl ec iy ncomebe ft.( .281.l he
neis Tr ) n r
s c s tofa i tons M s De s a l ge t ts be m e diabl d f al f m sof
e ond e
pplca i , . nni on le d ha he ca
s e or 1 or
s t nta ga nf e pl e ton J
ubs a i l i ul m oym n
anua y 31 201 due t de ne a i di c di e e,hi
r , 0
o ge r tve s s as p
dys a i fbr yal a,o iy,di be e m e lt ,bor ri pe s lt di or r af e tve
pl s a, i om gi best a t s lius de lne r ona iy s de , f c i
di or r a anxi t d s de . Pl i ifnow m a nt i t ts ha r m a ned di a ed t t
s de , nd
e y i or r a ntf
i a ns ha he s e i
s bl o he
presenttm e. Ast hercl m f di lt i ur
i
o
ai or sabiiy ns ance beneft t r
is, he ecord reveal t pl ntf
s hat ai if
m ett i
he nsured s at r r ent oft Actt ough Decem ber31,2012. See generalv 42
t us equi em s he
hr
l

U. C.jj41 i a 423()
S.
6() nd
a.

M s D e s s c ai sw e e de e u n i ta co i a i n and r co i r to She
. nni on' l m
r ni d po nii l nsder to
e nsde a i n.

t nr quet andrc ve aétno he rnga rviw beor a Admi srtveLa J
he e sed
e ei d
vo ai nd e e f e n
nitai w udge.
l a opi on da e Se em be 22,2011 t La J
n n ni
t d pt
r
, he w udge a s de er i t tpl ntf i not
l o t m ned ha ai if s
di a e The La J
s bl d.
w udge f
ound t tM s D e m i on s f r f om de ne atve di c di e e;
ha
. l s uf e s r
ge r i
s s as

fbr yagi ;obest ,di t m elt 'a f c i dio de ;a a ey dior r Bec us of
i om l a
iy' abees lius fe tve s r r nd nxi t s de . a e
,
t e c tons t La J
hes ondii , he w udge r e t tM s De s i di a e f he pas r l va w or
ul d ha
. nni on s s bl d or r t e e nt k
a tviy. How e r t La J
ci t
ve , he w udge f
ound t tpl i ifr t i s fc e f tona c pa t f a
ha a ntf e a ns uf i i nt unc i l a ciy or
lm ied r nge ofs de a y e ri The La J
i t a
e nt r xe ton.
w udge a s s ed M s D e s sr s dua f tonal
se s
. nni on' e i l unc i
capaciy as f l s:
t
olow

A fe c r f consde a i oft e ie r co d, he u r i d fndst tt
t r a e ul
i r ton he ntr e r t nde s gne i ha he
c ai a ha t r i lf to lca c t t pe f m a r nge ofs de a y wor
l m nt s he es dua unc i na pa iy o r or
a
e nt r
k

a dei d i 20C. R.jj404.567()a 41 967()i vi lfi or
s tne n
F.
1 a nd 6. a nvol ng itng
c r yi 1 poundsoc s ona l a l s t n 1 poundsf e nty,
a r ng 0
ca i ly nd e s ha 0
r que l
s a ng/ a ki f a m os 2 ho sdurng a 8t ndi w l ng or t t
ur
i n hourw o kda st i a
r y, itng bout6
ho sdurng a 8- urw or y,a onl occ s ona o r ton off tc r s
ur
i n ho
kda nd y a i l pe a i
oo ont ol .
She c n f e nty clm b r ps s a r butc o y o as o l clm b
a r que l i am / t i s
an nl cc i naly i
l dde s r / ca f ds ba a e s oop,kne l c ouc orc a l She i
a r /opes s f ol , l nc , t
e , r h, r w ,
s
m ode a ey lmie i he a lte t unde sa r m e r c ry outdeaied
r t l i td n r biii s o
rt nd/ e mbe / a r
t l
i t c i , a nt i a t nton/ nce r ton f e ende pe i ,w or i
ns nl tons m i a n te i co nta i or xt d rods
kn
c r na i w ih/pr xi iy t o he sw ihoutbei dit a t d by t m ,i e a t
oo di ton t o m t o t r t
ng s r c e
he nt r c
a o i t l w ih t ge r lpublc a e ti tuc i /r s
ppr pra e y t he ne a
i , cc p nsr tons e pond a opr a el
ppr i t y
t c ii i m f o s r s s ge a ong w ih co or r orpe r w ihout
o rtc s r m upe vi or , t l
t w ke s
es t
di t a tng t m /e bii beha or e r m e ,r s nd appr pra e y t
s r c i he
xhi tng
vi al xte s e po
o it l o
cha
ngesi t w o k s ti a t a li unf ii rpl c /us publc
n he r e tng, nd r ve n am la a es e
i
t a po t ton. She ha ditc t e w ih r m e be i de aied a c pl x
r ns r a i
s fi uli s t e m r ng t l nd om e
i t i ori or aton,butcan be expect t com pl e a nor alwor week
nsructons nf m i
ed o
et
m
k
pe f r i sm pl r i t ks o a c it ntbas sw ihouta unus lnum ber
r o m ng i e outne as n ons s e
i t
n
ua
ofa enc s orr qui i a tona br ksout i oft et ca l a ce t bl i
bs e
e r ng ddii l ea
sde hos ypi ly c p a e n
t w o k pl c The cl i a ca a s be ex t t i er c w ih ot r
he r a e.
a m nt n l o
pec ed o nt a t t he s
oc s ona l Any c nge i t wor ac s d be i r ce s ow l a
ca i ly.
ha s n he
kpl e houl
ntodu d l y nd
r nf ced w ih s alcues. She shoul w or i an envionm entw ih ltl orno
ei or
t ever
d
kn
r
t ite
cont w ih ot .
act t hers

( .
Tr 23-24) Gi ns harsdua f tona c pa t a afe c i rngpl ntf' ag
. ve uc e i l unci l a ciy, nd tr onsde i ai ifs e,
e a i and pr orw o k e re e a w e la t s i o f om avoc tona e r , he Law
duc ton,
i
r xpe i nc , s l s e tm ny r
a i l xpe t t
J e de e m i d t tM s. ni o r t i s tc e f tona ca iy t pe f m s ve al
udg t r ne ha
Den s n e a ns ufi i nt unc i l pac t o r or e r

s ii w or r ese s i i s gnii ntnum b i t na i
pec fc
k ol xi tng n i fca
er n he tonale onom y,i l ng t r e of
c
nc udi he ol s

a s mblr t sufe ,a br a s paaor ( .31.Ac r ngl t La J
s e e,oy t fr nd e d e rt . Tr ) co di y,he w udgeuli tl
tmaey
c l d t tM s D e s i notdi a e a t ts i no e il t be isunde e t r
onc ude ha
. nni on s
s bl d, nd ha he s t ntted o neft
r ihe

fde a pr a Se 20C. R.jj40 1 g)a 41 920( .TheLaw J
e r l ogrm. e
F.
4.520( nd 6. g)
udge' opi onwas
s ni
a
dopt d a t tna dec s on oft Co m i s one by t Soc a Se urt A dm i sr ton'
e s he i l i i
he m s i r he i l c iy
ni t a i s
A p a sCot ci. H a ng e us e a 1a i s r tve r m edi s M s D e s ha a n
pe l
m l vi xha t d l dm nit a i e
e , . nni on s gai
appeal t t s court
ed o hi
.

W hiepl ntf ma bedia e f c ran f m sofe o e , hec calf cua
l ai if y
s bld or e ti or
mpl ym nt t nl i a t l
de er i ton i w he herpl i t f w a di a e f a 1f ' s ofs t talga nf le pl e .
t m na i s
t
a n if s s bl d or 1 ol
m
ubsan i i u m oym nt

Se 42U. C.j 1 2c( j423( ( .Ther aef elme sofpr whihmus be
e
S. 38 a)
d)2)
e r our e nt
oof c
t
c i rd i ma ngs ha a yss Theeee nt aes
onsdee n ki uc n nal i. s lme s r ummarz a f l :( )obeci
ied s olows 1 j tve
me ca f t a clnia fndi ;( t opi o a co usonsofte tngphysca ;(
di l acs nd i c l i ngs 2) he nins nd ncl i
rai
iins 3)
s j ci e de eofph ia ma f ttonsofi r nt, desrbe t oug acai nts
ub e tve vi nc
ysc l niesai
mpaime s as ci d hr h l ma '
t tmony;a ( t cli ntse ai vocai lhit ', e i ls ls a a Vie v.
esi
nd 4) he ama ' duc ton, tona sol r sdua kil, nd ge. tk
y
Fi h,438F. 1l 11 -60( h Ci.1 ) Unde woodv.Ri co f298F. 850,851(t
nc
2d 57, 59 4t r 971;
r
bi f,
2d
4h
Ci.1 .
r 962)
A f e r vi ng t r or i t sea e, he c t sco tai d t c l t tt
t r e ewi he ec d n hi s t our i nsr ne o onc ude ha he

Co misone ' de a ofpl i ifsa ia i f rdiabiiy i u a ebene isa
m s i r s ni l
antf pplc tons o s lt ns r nc
ft nd
s pl m e a s c iy i om e i nots
up e nt l e ur t nc
s
uppored by s t ntale de e. The La J
t
ubs a i vi nc
w udge'
s
de e m i ton t tM s D e s sphvs c i paim e sa e no s s ve e ast r
t r na i ha
. nni on'
i al m r nt r t o e r
o ende he
r r
di a ed f a lf r s ofw or a tviy i c ea l s po t d by s t n i le de e. H ow e r
s bl or 1 o m
k c i t s l ry up r e
ubs a t a vi nc
ve ,
whet t Law Judge' eval i ofM s.Denni snon- i i paim ent i al
her he
s
uaton
son'
phys cal m r
s s so
s
upport by s t i evi
ed
ubsantal dence pr ent a cl erqueston. Si t tm e t herearler
es s os
i
nce he i hat
i
cl m sw er deni M s.Denni hassoughtand r ved addii
ai
e
ed,
son
ecei
tonalteat entf her
r m
or

e o i c ton.Thene r po t doc ntwor e ng s m pt
m tonal ondii
w e rs ume
s ni y oms.Uli t l bas d on t
tma ey, e
he
m e c r co dsa es i M s D e s s c r ntps hi t i lm ia i , he co tfndst t
di al e r ddr s ng . nni on' ur e
yc a rc i t tons t
ur i ha
t Com m i s one ' fnalde i i i nots
he
si rs i
c s on s
uppored b s t nta evi nc
t y ubs a i l de e.

M s De s c r i di nos si l i bi a dior r afe tvedior r an ey/
. nnion a res ag e ncud ng polr s de , f c i s de , xit
pa c di or r a a t nton de i i d s de . Tw o tea i ps hi ti t ,Dr Li ht ra D r
ni s de , nd te i
t c t i or r
r tng yc a r s s . g ne nd .
Al f r have pr
de e ,
oduc d m e als a usfndi a opi onsw hi h i c t t t pl i if
e
nt t t i ngs nd ni
c ndi a e hat he a ntf
s f r f om t a ke '
ufe s r i r d' nonm
phys c lm ia i i m a n a ni bo h û oc alf toni 'a
i al i t tons n i t i ng t t i unc i ng' nd
s

û once rton,pe sse e, pa .'( . ,1 .A t r te tngps hitit Dr W i a
k
c ntai
ritnc or ce' Tr 941 228) hid rai yc ars, . dr,
de crbe he a ha ng i hr c di tc te w ih c enta i a t nto a s tt r
s i d r s vi ç oni fi uli s t onc r ton, te i n, nd hor -e m
c

me y. ( .1 .TheAdmi srtveLaw J
mor ' Tr 205)
'
nitai
udgedic edt s te tngps hitit'
s ount he e r ai yc arss
r pors a r le ex i ty o r porsf om no exa i ng sa e age y ps hol i t ,i
e t , nd e i d plcil n e t r
n- m ni t t
nc yc og s s n
fndi t t pl i ifpos e s s t r i alf tona c pac t t pe f m a lm ie r nge of
i ng hat he a ntf
s s e he esdu unc i l a iy o r or
i td a

s de t r wor
e nay
k.
Thec tc l st tt La J e' opi on i i onsse wih t go r ng
our oncude ha he w udg s ni s nc itnt t he veni
a i s r tve r gul to , nd t tt Com m i s one ' t e t e ofpl i if s m e a hea t
dm ni ta i e a i ns a ha he
s i r s r a m nt
a ntf ' nt l lh
c ton i nots
ondii s
uppore by s bs a i le de e.l e t c ' be i ve t tt La
td
u t nta vi nc nde d, he oul le s ha he w
t
J
udge' r la on t s a e a nc ps hol c r por si es c a l s pe t gi t tt
s e i nce he t t ge y yc ogi al e t s pe i ly us c , ven ha he
r or r vi e spr
ec d e ew r oduce t rr pors a opi onsprort r ce vi a 1e de a iabl
d hei e t nd ni
i o e i ng 1 vi nce va l e
f om M s D e s st e tng ps hi t it ,a r i he viy upon a c ula i r vi w
r
. nni on' r a i
yc a r s s nd eled a l
ons t tve e e
co pl t d m o e t n one yea prort M s D e s s ne a c r nta l ge di a lt o e
m ee
r ha
r i o . nni on' w nd ur e le d s biiy ns t
da e.
t
Furhe ,t La J
t r he w udge e i il r le on t tm ony f o a voca i le r i tndi
xplc ty e i d
esi
rm
tona xpe t n i ng

t ihecai nti c pa eofma ngas c sula j t ntt ot rwor t te ssi
hat' l ma s a bl
t
ki uc esf d usme o he k ha xit n
sgniia numbesi t nainale onomy.'( .31.Howe r t hy heialque to
i fc nt
r n he to c
' Tr )
ve,he pot tc
sins
5

pos t t voc tona expe ta t or he rngdi no a qua e yco i rM s De s s
ed o he ai l
r t he al a i
d t de t l nsde
. nnion'

non-xe tonallmiato .( . -74) l deemi ngt ts fce j e s frt
e ri i t ins Tr 73 . n tr ni ha ufiint obs xit o he
cai nt t voc tona e pe t i e onl hy he ialst tonsi whih M s De s
l ma , he a i l x r consder d y pot tc iua i n c
. nnion
ha k lm i i a lt t m ai ai a t nton and c e r ton f e e d pe i ' a S
d c i t n biiy o
no
nt n te i
onc nt a i or xt nde r ods ' nd t
no

lmi i a lt t wor i coo di tonwih(t rl' ( .74) M s De s clal s fr
i t n biiy o k n r nai t ohes. Tr . . nnion e ry ufes
'
fom m e a i pa r e st tafec he conc nta i a s i lf toni Fort sa tonal
r
nt l m i m nt ha f t r
e r ton nd oc a unc i ng.
hi ddii
r a on,t c tc udest tt Com m i s o r sde e m i ton i nots
e s he our oncl
ha he
s i ne ' t r na i s
uppored by
t
s t ntale de e. M or ove ,t c tfndst tt r cor i l ng a lr por sf om t
ubs a i vi nc
e r he our i ha he e d, nc udi l e t r he
t e tng ps hi t i t ,c e ry es a i he t ta a r s tofhe ps hi t i c ton,t pl i if
rai
yc a rs s l a l t bls s ha s e ul
r yc a rc ondii he a ntf
cmm otpe f r e n t lgh s de a y w or whi h s i o he w i e phys c ly ca bl of
r o m ve he i t e nt r
k
c he s t r s
i a l pa e
pe f r i A c or ngl t cour c l st tM s D e s m ha m e t bu den ofpr i
r o m ng. c di y, he
t onc ude ha
. nni c s t he r
oof n
es a i hi t aldi a lt f al f m sofs t nta gai ule pl e t
t bls ng ot s biiy or 1 or
ubs a i l nf m oym n .
The r co d s st tDr J f r y Li ne , ps a r s wih RM H Be or lHea t
e r how ha . e f e ght r a ychi t it t
havi a
lh,

te tdM s De s f s vealye r a me wihhe ona las eghtspaaeoc asons ( .
rae . nnion or e r a s nd t t r t e t i e rt c i . Tr
937 .Shorl bef et rl n peid, Nove r25,2009,Dr Li ne i c t i a
)
ty or he eeva t ro on
mbe
. ght r ndiaed n
M e a I nnen Quesinnaiet tM s Dennio s fr fom ' r df tona
ntl mpai t
to r ha .
s n ufeed r ç ke unci l
ma
lm ia i ' i m ai ai ng bot is i lf toni ' nd C onc nt a i pe s s e e,orpa e.'
i t tons' n
nt ni
h loc a unc i ng' a c e r ton, r it nc
c
c '

( . 1 .Dr Liht rnot t ti
Tr 94 ) . g ne ed ha s
moodsa lt hag be difc tt at ndes t hi
tbiiy dl en fiul o tai pie gh
dos s ofm e ca i ns' a he alo i c t t tM s De s w a una e t m ee co pe ii
e
di to ,' nd
s ndi a ed ha
. nnion s bl o
t m ttve

sa r i û i anlngjatnto f (jt hours me s ( nt nlngjr a
tndads n l nti i te in or a woma
eg nt' k ai i egulr
' mai
at
tendmwe, û kgng)i c r nai wihorpr xi t t ohes'a ûmdesa i qa
' t i n oo di ton t
' wor
o miy o t r,' nd t rtndtng nd
t
r mbe gng ve ys ta smpl i tucins' ( . 7, .Dr Liht rf t rrpore
eme ri ) r hor nd i e nsr to . Tr 93 939) . g ne urhe e td
'
t tM s Dennio ha û fiuly ( t me r a co ntai '( .940)
ha .
s n d i fc t wihq moy nd nce rton. Tr
di
'
.

6

Be nni on M ar h 11 201 a t rD r Li ht erl f t pr tc ,M s D e s
gi ng
c , 0, fe . g n e t he ac i e
. nni on
c i d he t e t e atRM H Be vi a H e t w ih D r Ra ond A l f r a her
ontnue r r a m nt
ha or l alh t . ym
de e , not

ps hitit ( .1 4) Pli ifconi t seDr Al f o argul ba i,me tngwih
yc ars. Tr 22 . antf tnued o e . deer n e ar ss ei t
hi e r oneand-- l t t eemont .( .1 ) Dr Al frsnot fom J 1 201
m vey - ahaf o hr
hs Tr 224 . . dee ' es r une 9, 0
de c i M s Demion ase iy a tt d,a t y i caet ts r pore s f rng fom pa c
s rbe . r s
asl giae nd he ndi t ha he e td ufe i r
ni

atc t t t eetmespe we k.( .9 )
ta ks wo o hr i
r e Tr 49 .Howe r t notsalor lctt tM s
ve ,he e s efe ha .
Dc s c ri aSai'afec a iogi l'i ohee 't
nnion ared i r' f t nd ' ca, ' rnt'houghtpr ses ( .9 ) Shorl
f
l
'c
oce s . Tr 49 . ty
t r fe , J 30,2010, r Al f rr por e t tM s Den s C e r t ts m e i
he ea t r on une
D . de e e t d ha
. nion ' a s ha o one s
f
wa c ng herc put re n w he i i of , f a ed ( he hous w ilc t h on fr ' a f l t t
t hi
om e ve
n t s f' e r C
'
t
e l ac
ie, nd e t ha
'

C o t ngba i goi t ha n. ( .1 .Heas rpore t tt cli ntsmoo
i mehi d s ng o ppe ' Tr 235)
s
'
lo e td ha he ama '
ds

weeu tbl ( .1 .M s De s n sw Dr Al e a i o Augus 27,201 Att t
r nsa e. Tr 235) . nnio a . defr gan n
t
0. ha
tm e he i c t d t ts w a co u ed a utwhe t t ke he m e c tons a t ts d d not
i , ndi a e ha he s nf s bo
n oa
r di a i , nd ha he i

kno t c rc dos ( .11 .Heas rpore t the moodwa C
w he ore t age.Tr 96)
lo e td ha r
s'
down, noi t t
' tng ha
'
s ha û
he d l da a notg ddays' ( .1 96 .Agan,her tdadar'afcta
good ys nd
oo
. Tr 1 )
'
i
epore t i' fe nd
f
ûogi l'i oheent'hough pr ese .( ,11 )
t ca, d r 't
l
'c
t oc s s Tr 96 .
O n Se e be 9,201 Dr Sa a Fr nc s a sat age y ps hol s , pl e a
pt m r
0, . ndr a i , t e nc yc ogi t com et d
D i a lt De e m i ton Expl na i n f r i whi h s c nc ude t tM s Denni o s f r d
s biiy t r na i
a to o m n c he o l d ha
.
s n uf e e
f om ' ode a e 'f to llm ia i i m a nt i ng bot ts a f toni ' nd
r k
m r t ' unc i na i t tons n i a ni
h soci l unc i ng' a

û nc ntai pesse e, pa ev ( .1 ) I f mi he opi on, . a i rviwe
t e r ton, ritnc or c ' Tr 42 . n or ng r ni Dr Frncs e e d
co
'
t r or i M s Denni on' c e bu di notphys c l e m i t c a m a . The m os r ce
he ec d n .
s s as , t d
i aly xa ne he l i nt
t e nt

pi eofe de er e wa daedAugus 1 201 ( .1 3) Not y,t e de
ec vi nc eviwed s t
t 7, 0. Tr 3 . abl he vi nce
r vi e di noti l l t rr pors fom M s Denni on' tea i physci ns Dr A l e a
e ew d d
nc ude a e e t r
.
s s r tng
ia
. def r nd
Dr W i a f ndi t tt cl i a s f r d f om tm a ke 'f t o llm ia i i
. dr i ng ha he a m nt uf e e r l r d' unc i na i t tons n
m a nt i ng bo h ds i lf toni ' i onc t a i n, s s e e, pa ey a t tt
i a ni
t soc a unc i ng' and s en r to per i t nc or c ' nd ha he
c
'
7

c a m a s f r d f om t hr c difc tesw ih c e r ton, te i a s t e m
l i nt uf e e r d oni f i uli
c
t onc nta i a t nton nd hor t r

memor ' ( .1 1 )
y.' Tr 205, 228 .
A fe r vi w i t a ia e r c d,Dr Fr nc sde e ne t tM s D e s w a no
t r e e ng he va l bl e or
. a i t nui d ha
. nni on s t

dia e ( .1 .Spe iialy, hef ndt twhieMs De s sd ntlc to ( )
s bld. Tr 50) cfc l s ou ha l . nnion' d a ondiins had
me
afctd ( ja lt t pef m s mea i tes'i udi wor s ha donei t pa ts
fe e her biiy o ror o ctvii ,'ncl ng k he d
n he s, he
s ul ne r he es be abl t û olow s m pl die to , nd pe f r s m pl ,r utne wor '
ho d ve t l s
e o û l i e r c i ns a
f
rom i e o i
k,
'

( ,1 ) I maki t sdeemi ton, .Fr i ga 'g e tweg 't ame a saus
Tr 51 . n
ng hi tr nai Dr ancs ve tr a iht'o
ntl tt
e l ton pe f m ed by Dr Lee who had c nd t d a o tm e i pe s ps hi t i
va ua i
r or
. n,
o uc e
ne-i , n- r on yc a rc
i er e on J nua y 1 2009- m or t n o ye rprort t a l ged di a lt ons tda e.
nt vi w
a r 4,
e ha ne a i o he le
s biiy e t

( .1 .
Tr 43)
On J nuar 24, 1, t rs a e a nc ps hol s ,Dr N a y H e s ,s m ia l
a y
201 ano he t t ge y yc ogit . nc
i er i l ry
f und t tM s Denni o s f r fom t ode at ' fm c i llm ia i i m a nt i ng bot
o
ha
.
s n uf e ed r l
m r e ' t tona i t tons n i a ni
h

ioci f to ng'andS once rton, ritnc o pac ' ( .1 .Dr Hesr t ga
s al uncini ' l ntai pesse e, r e. Tr 65) . ie ,oo, ve
s
c
'
Dr Le n' opi o w hi pr da e t a l ge di a lt ons td t by m o e t n a ye r
. e s ni n
ch e t s he le d s biiy e a e
r ha
a

( ra weg ta ii c n itn wi teme ia fn igsa dtemao i o cama tsc re t
l e t ih s t s o sse t t h d c l idn n h j rt f li n ' u rn
g
h
y
( ntlr iua f tona c pa t , ( .1 )
me a esd l unci l a ciyj' Tr 67 .Howe ,s ga t mor r c nto ni of
'
ver he ve he e e e pi on
Dr Li t r pl i if st e tng phys c an f r s ve a ye r , ii erwei bec us i i f om
. gh ne , a ntf r a i
i i o e r l a s S ght
l
ght a e t s r

ove aye ra ' ( .1 ) Li t frtsaea nc ps hol s,Dr Hesrdi no ha t
r a go.' Tr 67 . ke he is tt ge y yc ogit . ie d t ve he
oppor uniy t r vi w a lr por sby M s D e s sot rte tng ps hi t i t ,D r Al f ra
t t o e e l e t
. nni on' he r a i
yc a r s s . de e nd
D r W i r ,w hi h des r be t c a m a ' s ve e co e r ton a s i lf toni lm ia i .
. da
c
c i he l i nt s e r nc nta i nd oc a unc i ng i t tons
The m os r ce pi e of e de r vi w e by D r Heierw asda e J nua y 1 2011.
t e nt ec
vi nce e e d
. s
t d a r 0,
O n A pr l22,20l1,M s.D ennion com pl ed an i ake as m entatt Hanis
i
s
et
nt
sess
he
onRocki
ngham Com m uniy Ser ces Boar RM H Behavi H ealh r er ed M s.D el i on t t
t
vi
d.
oral
t ef r
m s o he
Com m uniy Servi Boar becaus s w as unabl t af or contnued teat entatRM H
t
ces
d
e he
eo f d
i
r m
8

Be vir lHe t wihoutfna a a ssa e.( .1 .Sher poredi ghlvesof
ha o a alh t
i ncil sitnc Tr 208)
e t s
hi e l
a ey,'kria lt a paa a, a Srque a s veemoods ngs' ( .1 ) She
nxit 'iirtbiiy nd rnoi ' nd û e nt nd e r
'
f
wi .' Tr 208 .
a s r pored t i f c ntdifc t w ih he a lt t c e r t ' nd hers tt r m e or
l o e t i gnii a
s
f i uly t r biiy o onc nt a e' a
hor -e m
m y.

( .1 .Fo e mpl,s dor g t ngslkehow t s lhernamewhiesgni ac c '
Tr 208) r xa e he ç gotl hi i
f
o pel
l i ng he k,
'
iba i m a h w he co i m oney, ort t' he wasdrvi w hie i t m i tofdoi s '
û sc t
n untng
' ha d
'
s
i ng
l n he ds
ng o.
'

( .1 .Thecouns ornot t tM s De s l s aye ma rpeii get e a
Tr 208)
el
ed ha . nnion û pl d ny e ttve surs nd
di
move nt du i t c s oft i a ' ( .1 ) ' wa una et manti e
me s rng he oure he ntke. Tr 209 .kShe s bl o i an ye
'
c t tf m or t n a f w s co a a tm e a s nta s g fc ntpori n oft s s i
on ac or e ha
e e nds t i nd pe
i nii a
to
he e s on

la ngove wihherhe ddownfcngt toor' ( .1 .
e ni
r t
a
a i he l . Tr 209)
'
O n M a 27,2011 pl i tf m etw ih D r K e t W i r a ps a r s w ih t H a rs
y
, a n if
t . nne h d a, ychi t it t he r i on-

Roc ngha Co
ki m mmuniySeviesBoad.( .1
t rc
r Tr 205-07) Dr W i anot t tM s De s
. . dr ed ha . nnion

S i dlt e s anxit nea pa c,irtbiiy,paa a a a ttdde esi 'i
û nueg o ndore ey, r ni ria lt rnoi, nd giae pr son,'n
cont
addiint t hr cdifc teswihc enrton,atntona s ttr me y .... ( .
to o s oni fiuli t onc tai te i nd hor em mor
c
' Tr
'
1 ) Uponi eviwi t cama ,hef
205 .
ntr e ng he li nt ound:
She i fdg y,r ksa bi,a ps chom ot ag t ton i p e e . She i ir t bl ,
s i et oc
t nd y
or ia i s r s nt
s r ia e
gua dedsa m idl pa a d t ough t i t l e w ih l fusr ton t e anc
r
nd l y r noi hr
he n ewi w t ow r t a i ol r e.
. . . M ood i de e s d a
s pr s e nd i t bl ....Cog ton i gr s y i a t but
ni a e
nii s os l nt c ,
concentaton and atenton ar poor.
r i
t i
e

( .1 .
Tr 206)
M s D e s r t r d t te w ih D r A l ef ri J a J y, 1. D urng t tm e,
. nni on e u ne o r at t . d e n une nd ul 201
i hat i
he r por e t the ûs r s l ve sa e r a i l hi ' a t ts c n be ( r ia e'orG a '
e t d ha r st e s e l r el tve y gh, nd ha he a
'
t rt bl ' û d '
i
s

butt tiohe tme ,k
ha kt r i s nobodyc nsop g r felngha ''( .1 ) noe t ts ha
a t hel e i ppy.' Tr 234 .He td ha he d
r c nty s f r a m a c e s l s i s ve alwee , i w hi h tm e s be i ve her el
e e l uf e ed
ni pi ode a tng e r
ks durng c i he le d s f

t ha s r
o ve upehuma powes ( .1 ) Sheas expli dt DrAl frt ts ha l the
n
r. Tr 231.
lo ane o . dee ha he d os r

ca hirj b ove oneyea prorbe aus s Co g how t ma c
se o
r
r i c e he t r ot
f
o ke hange l tco ntai had
,os nce rton,
pa catcks a t
ni ta , nd houghtghe c t r weetl nga he.'( .1 l.
t l usome s r aki bout r' Tr 23 )
9

OnJ y27, 1 Dr Al fri c tdi aM e all ime Quesi iet tM s
ul 201 , . dee ndiae n
nt mpar nt
tonnar ha .
D enni s f ed f om im ar f i
son uf er r t ked unctonallm iatons' i m ai ai ng bot ts alf i ng'
i t i 'n
nt ni
h toci unctoni '

a t e rton, ritnc o pa e. ( .1 ) Heec dDr Li ne' fndi fom
nd û ntai pesse e, r c ' Tr 228 .
conc
'
hoe . ght rs i ngs r
N ove be 2009, i t tM s D e s w asuna e t m ee c pe ii s a r i
m r
notng ha
. nni on
bl o
t om ttve t nda ds n

C i angng at i f g1t hours g nt't nti i rgulratnda ,' nd
t nti i j tenton or a woma
e me , i anlngl e a te nce'a
' mai

û rtndgngla rme lngjveys ta smpl i tucins' ( .1 .Hi
t sa i nd e mberi
unde
r hor nd i e nsr to . Tr 226) s
'
e l ton ofM s Denni on' a lt t C or i c di ton w ih orpr m iy t o he s '
va ua i
.
s s biiy o t k n oor na i
w
t
oxi t o t r '

deei ae s ht ts ha d us f a lt t fncin, ( .1 ,Hef t ri c td
trortd uc ha he d d eul biiy o u to ' Tr 226)
no
'
urhe ndiae
t tM s D e s ha ino us f a lt ' o û om pl e a nor a w or y a w or e k
ha
. nni on d d
e ul biiy' t i
c
et
m l kda nd
kw e

wihouti er i fo ps hol c l ba e s oms' ( .1 .M s De s
t ntruptons r m yc ogialy s d ympt . Tr 226) . nnion
'
c i d t tea w ih Dr A l e f rt r m a nde of2011 a t oughout201 wihou
ontnue o r t t . def r o he e i r
nd hr
2 t t
s g fca ti pr ve en .
i nii n m o m t
A spr vi l not d,t Co m i s one di c e t tea i ps hi ti t 'r po t ,
e ousy e he m s i r s ount d he r tng yc a r s s e r s and
r led e i il on r por sf om t non- xa i ng s a e a nc ps hol s s i fndi t t
e i xplc ty
e t r he
e m ni t t ge y yc ogi t , n i ng ha
t pl i ifpos es e t r s dua f tonalc pa t t peror a lm ie r nge o s de a y
he a ntf
s s d he e i l unc i
a ciy o f m i t d a
f e nt r
w or The La J
k.
w udge de e m i t tt non- xa i ng ps hol s s r por ss d be
t r ned ha he
e m ni
yc ogi t ' e t houl

ta f de co i r bl weght'sncet we e k onsse wih a s
kfor d nsde a e i ' i hey r ç it nt t nd uppore by t o he
c
td he t r

e de ofr c d,ncudi te t ntnots' Tr 29) Theopi o ofDr.Li ne a
vi nce e or i l ng rame
e. . .
'(
nins
s ght r nd
Al e wer gi n û sgniia weght'a diteweght'rs ci l ( .28 .The
defr e ve i i fc nt i ' nd ktl i , epe tvey. Tr -29)
no
l
'
Law J
udge not t tDr W i a pe f m e a ps hi t i e ua i oft c ai a ,bu di not
ed ha . dr r or d
yc a rc val ton he l m nt t d

i c t t wei gi t hi fndi .( . .
ndiae he ght ven o s i ngs Tr 27)
H avi r ew ed t r d,t courti unabl t concl t t Law J
ng evi
he ecor he
s
eo
ude hat he
udge'
s
teat entoft report and opi onsf om t teatng psychi rst ort Law Judge' r i
r m
he
s
ni r he r i
at i s, he
s elance
on t r t ofnonhe epors
exam i ng s at agency ps
ni t e
ychol s s,com por w ih t r r ent of
ogit
t t he equiem s
10

t a i sr tve r gul tons de lng w ih t e l ton ofo ni e de e. Unde 20 C. R.
he dm ni ta i e a i
ai
t he va ua i
pi on vi nc
r
F.

j40 15 c( ) ii e iil pr de t t ge r l mor wei wilbegi n t t
4. 27()1 ,t s xplcty ovi d ha, nealy, e ght l
ve o he
opi onofamedials c whoha acualye mi dt cai nt Mor ove,20C. R.j
ni
c our e
s t l xa ne he l ma . e r
F.
404. 27( ( )die t t tge r ly, ewei i gi nt o ni ofteai s c , i e
15 c)2 rcs ha, ne al mor ght s ve o pi ons r tng oures snc
s h pr es i sar m or lke y t pr de a det ie l ngiudi lpi t e oft cl i a '
uc of s onal e
e i l o ovi
a l d, o t na c ur
he a m nt s

me ca i ime s nal unde 20C. R.j404.527()5) i i notdt tmor weihti
di lmpar nt.Fi ly, r
F.
1 c( ,t s e ha e g s
ac or t t opi on ofa s ci ls aboutm e c lis s r l t d t t a ea ofs c a t
c ded o he ni
pe a i t
di a s ue e a e o he r
pe i ly.
l t i t ntc s i i c ea t tDr Li t r Dr Al f r a D r W i r a t ly s w
n he ns a a e, t s l r ha . gh ne , . de e , nd . d a c ua l a
M s.Denni on s aloccasi wher t st e agency ps
son
ever
ons,
eas he at
ychol s s have nevers or
ogit
een

exa i d t pl i if M or ove ,t r c n be no quesi t tD r .Li ne ,A l f r a
m ne he a ntf .
e r he e a
ton ha s ght r de e , nd
W i a qualf astea i s c .Pe ha m os i po t nty, he e i a s t ntalc r t
dr
iy r tng our es r ps
t m r a l t r s ubs a i ontas
be wee t qua ii a i ofDr Li ht r Al f r a W i a a t e o t s a e a ncy
t n he lfc tons
s. g ne , de e , nd dr nd hos f he t t ge
ps hol i t . The t e tea i phys c ansea h ha a m e c ls ci t i ps hi ty. The
yc og s s
hr e r tng
ii
c ve
di a pe aly n yc a r
s a e ag ncy ps
tt e
ychol s sa e no physci ns Fi ly, nd s g fc nty, he ps a r s s
ogi t r t
i a . na l a i nii a l t
ychi t it '
opi ons a e c i t ntw ih t i c i ca fndi a i pr s i . I s h c r u s a s t
ni
r ons se
t he r lni l i ngs nd m e sons n uc i c m t nce , he
c tdoe notbe i ve t tt La J
our
s
le ha he w udge' r i nc on t r por soft non- xn i ng
s ela e he e t he
e m ni
ps hol i t c n be de ed t be s
yc og s s a
em
o
uppor e by s t nta evi nc
td
ubs a i l de e.
The c tc i
our ontnuest bele t te ri rr pors f o M s D e m i on' t e tng
o i ve ha a le e t r m
. l s s rai
ps hi t i t ,pa tc ary D r Li ne ,a e i ons sen wih pl ntf sa t ll velofa tviy a
yc a rs s r i ul l . ght r r nc i t t t ai i f c ua e
ci t t

t tmeofe uai ( . .Howe r t c t ncudest tt ltrrporsfom M s
he i
val ton. Tr 206)
ve ,he our co l
ha he ae e t r
.
D e s s te tng ps hi ti t ,s er lofw hi h w e e r e ved a t rt sa e ag y
nni on' r a i
yc a rs s ev a
c
r ec i
f e he t t enc
ps
ychol st r ew ed t r d,cl l esablsh t pl ntf doesnotpossesst abiiy t
ogi s evi
he ecor eary t i hat ai if
he lt o

c enta e orpay a t n i t t w o k t s e s o d by t voc tonale r . Addii na l
onc r t
t e ton o he r a ks nvii ne
he a i
xpe t
to ly,

be aus t vocai lexpetse ngl ha ditc t i ntf ngatr t j e nundert
c e he tona
r e mi y d fi uly de iyi lenae obs ve
he

h p teia p o i d tec t'fn sta t eeaen s e ii j b wh c e iti ten to a
y oh t l r vde ,h out id h t h r r o p cfc o s ih x s n h ain l
c
e
cono y t ta pe s w ih t cl i a t s e ri nala non- xe tona lm ia i c d
m ha
r on t he a m n ' xe to
nd
e r i l i t tons oul
pe f m . A c or ngl t c tc l
r or
c di y, he our onc udest tM s D e s ha m e t bur n ofpr i
ha
. nni on s t he de
oof n
esabls ng t aldi lt f a1 f m s ofs t i gai ulem pl ent
t i hi ot sabiiy or 1 or
ubs antal nf
oym .

The c tr cogni est tM s De m i on' co to hasgr ualy de e i a ed o ra
our e
z ha
. l s s ndii n
ad l t r or t ve
pe i ofye r . Cons
r od
as
eque l e t bls ng t pr c s da e ofdi a lt ons ti dit c t The
nty, s a i hi he e i e t
s biiy e s fi ul.
c t t t tM s D e s a i d f a r ce ve une pl e be ft be w e n
our no es ha
. nni on pple or nd e i d m oym nt ne is t e
N ove be 201 a Aug t2 1 i c tng t td i t ttm e perod, he w a c pa e
m r 0 nd
us 0 1, ndi a i ha ur ng ha i
i s
s a bl ,

wilng,a a et wor ( . .Ac or ngl t c ttndst M s De s be me
li nd bl o k. Tr 43) c di y,he our i hat . nnion ca
di a e a ofSe e be 1 2011
s bl d s
pt m r ,
.
Fo t r as nss a e t c ur i c t a ned t c l t tt Com m i s one ' fna
r he e o t t d, he o t s ons r i
o onc ude ha he
si rs i l
de s on i nots
ci i s
uppore by s t nta e de e. The de e nt sm o i f s m a y
td
ubs a i l vi nc
f nda ' ton or um r

j d me t tt eeo e b d ne .Up ntetn igt a t epanif a me t eb r e o
u g n mus,h rf r , e e id o h i dn h t h litf h s t h u d n f
pr a prs rbedbya purua tt t Ac,udgme wilbee eedfrt pli if The
oof s e ci
nd s n o he tj
nt l ntr o he antf.
fnalde i i oft Com m i s one w ilbe r ve s d a t c s r om m it t t
i
c s on he
si r l
e r e nd he a e ec
ted o he

Co si n rf rc mp tto a da r o a p o raeb neis A j d me t ndo d ri
mmiso e o o u ain n wad f p r p it e ft. u g n a r e n
c or iy t r w ih w ilbe en e e t sday.
onf m t he e t l
t r d hi
The Cl r i diec e t s nd c rii d c esoft sopi on a t a compa ng or r
e k s r t d o e e tte opi
hi
ni nd he c
nyi
de
t al couns ofrecor
o l
el
d.

ENTER:Thi 39 &da ofNove r
s
y
mbe
,

2013.

4.

.

t

,

Chi Unied St es Di t ctJudge
ef t
at
sri