Breighner v. Colvin

Filing 28

ORDER ADOPTING 27 REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ; denying 13 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 20 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 4/22/14. (kld)

I TH E UNI
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STRI O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
H AR R ISO NBU R G DIV ISIO N

R O BERT W . REI H N ER ,
B
G

r FRKS oFFI u,s, sT.
a
Ce
Dl COURI
AT ROANOKE, V
A
FIED
L

AP2 2 22 1
24
JULI C, UD EY CL
A
k ERK
BY;
CLERK

C i lA c i N o. 5: 3c
vi ton
: 1 v00016

Pl ntff
ai i ,
V.

C A R O LYN W .C O LV I
N,
A c i Com m i s one ofSoc alSec iy,
t ng
si r
i
ur t

By:H on.M i
chaelF.U rbanski
U nie St t sD i t c Judge
t d a e s ri t

D ef
endant
.

O R D ER

Thi ma trwasr ere t t Honor bl J mesG.W elh, t d Stt sM a sr t
s te
ef r d o he
a e a
s Unie a e
gita e

J d e p ru n t 28U. C.j6 6 b ( )B) f rp o o e tn i so fc a d ar c mme d d
u g , u sa to
S.
3 ( )1( , o r p s d i dng f a t n e o n e
diposton. TheM a sr t J
s ii
gitae udge fld ar por a r c me ton o Aprl1 201
ie e t nd e om nda i n
i , 4

r c mme dngt a t eCo sine' moinf rs mma yj d me tb ga tda dta te
e o n i h t h mmiso rs to o u r u g n e r ne n h t h
Co sine' tn l e iinb afr d.Noo j cinst t erp r a drc mme ain
mmiso rs i a d cso e fime
be to o h e o t n e o nd t
o
ha bee fl d,a t c ti oft o ni t tt r por and r co mendai s dbe
ve n ie nd he our s he pi on ha he e t
e m
ton houl
a ed i ise iey.I i a co di y O RDERED a ADJUDGED t tt pl ntf s
dopt n t ntr t t s c r ngl
nd
ha he ai if

mo inf rs mmayj g n ( tNo 1 )i DENI t t h Co s ine ' moin fr
to o u r ud me t Dk . . 3 s
ED,ha t e mmiso rs to o
s mmayj d me t( t No 2 )i GRANTED,h t h rpo t n r c mme d to ( tNo
u r u g n Dk . . 0 s
ta t e e r a d e o n ain Dk . .
27)i ADOPTED i ise i t t tt Commisone ' fnalde soni AFFI ED, nd
s
n t ntrey,ha he
si rs i
cii s
RM
a
t tt sm at ri STRI
ha hi te s
CKEN fo t a tvedocke oft c t
r
' m he c i
t he our.
The Clr i die t d t s nd a c rii c oft sOr rt a1c elofr or
ek s r ce o e
e tfed opy hi de o l ouns
ec d.

Enee :Api , 01
trd rl 2 4
A

/
+/

- 2r- .? 4 r .
' 7 + -- ir
M i ha lF. ba ki
c e Ur ns
U nie St t s Di t i tJ
t d a e sr c udge