Lai v. Dept. of Justice et al

Filing 33

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS for 31 Report and Recommendations, 27 Motion to Dismiss filed by Dept. of Justice, ATF, Thomas Fisher, Eric, U.S. Marshal, Chris Baker ; granting 27 Motion to Dismiss; adopting Report and Recommendations re 31 Report and Recommendations.. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 10/16/2013. (mab)

t- b'
C
'

. 2 EU s DI O UR
*
R

è, .v
i

x kL v
sm A

.

I TH E U NI
N
TED STA TES DI RI CO UR T
ST CT
FO R TH E W E STER N D I
STR I O F V I G I I
CT
R N A
HARRI
SONBURG DI SI
VI ON
H O N G A N LA I
,
Pl ntf ,
ai if

DEPT.OF JUSTI e aI,
CE, t .
D e endant .
f
s

Fl Fn
I

l 21
23
L

. D

,

D

)
)
C i lA c i N o.5: 3c
vi t on
1 v000
33
)
)
)
) By: M i
chaelF.Ur ki
bans
)
Unied St e Dit itJudge
t ats src
)
)

Thi m a t rw asr e r d t t H onor bl B.W a h Cr gl r U nie St t s M a s r t
s te
ef r e o he
a e
ug i e , t d a e
git a e

J d e p zu n t 2 U. C. 6 6b ()B) frp o o e fndn so fc a dar c mme e
u g , u s a t o 8 S. j 3 () 1( ,0 r p s d i ig f a t n e o nd d
d s osto Thema itaej d efldarpo t n r c mme d to o S p e e 20 2 3
ip iin.
g sr t u g ie e r a d e o n ain n e tmb r , 01 ,
r omm e ng t tt pe ng c am sagans de enda st De rm e tofJ tce t Bur u
ec
ndi ha he ndi l i
i t f nt he pa t n
usi , he ea

ofAlho Tobac o, r ams a Expl i (ç ',ATF Age çErc,' Age Chrs
c hol
c Fie r , nd
osves û
ATF'
)
ntç i 'ATF nt i
Ba r t U nie St t s M a s lSe wi e,a Thom a Fi c , be di m i s f r l c o
ke , he t d a e
s s ed o a k f
r ha l c nd
s s her 1

pr e tonpurua t Fe R. v.P41b)a t tnotc bes ntt t pli ifaf di hi
os cui
s nt o d. Ci
( nd ha ie e o he antf for ng m
a dae bywhi h t s
t
c o how good c us why t c e s dno bedim is d f lc ofs r i e
a e
he as houl t
s s e or a k e v c
upo ç m , t s e r m ai ng def nda .
n1
Sa ' he ol e ni
'
e nt

Noo j cin t t rp r a drc mme d to h v b e tlda dtec u tso t
b e to s o he e o t n e o n ain a e e n ie n h o r i f he
o ni n t tt r por a r omm e ton s d bea e i ise iey.l i a co di y
pi o ha he e t nd ec
ndai houl
dopt d n t ntr t t s c r ngl

ORDERED a ADJUDGED t tt r r a r omme ton( . 22)i ADOPTED
nd
ha he epo t nd ec
ndai DktNo. s
i is e i et a t tpl ntf ' cl i s a i tde e nt D e rm entofJ tc ,t A TF,
n t ntr y, nd ha ai if s a m ga ns f nda s pa t
us i e he
A TF A ge $ i ' A TF A ge Chr sBake ,t Unie St e M a s lSe v c ,a Tho a
nt $ c,'
Er
nt i
r he
t d at s r ha r i e nd
m s

1Asnotd i t r ta r co ndain,t pl ntf mis l t na ofdefnda Fic ra tFihe v
e n he epor nd e mme to he ai if spelcd he me
e nt s he s ç s r'
'

RK

RK

Fic raeDI M I SED wi o t rj d c pzs n t F d R. v. 41b , n te ecams
she r S S
t u p eu ie l ua t o e . Ci P ( ) a d h s li
h
r
a e STRI EN fom t a tvedoc toft c t
r
CK
r he ci
ke he our.
TheClr i s no i et t pl i ifofi ufi i nts r i eofpr s upon defnda t
e k s ued tc o he antf ns fc e e v c
oce s
e n

s a ' n S p e r2 , 01 ( tNo 3 ) t es med yter p r a rc mme d to wa
ç m'o e tmbe 0 2 3 Dk . . 2 ,h a a h e o t nd e o n ain s
s
is d.Pl ntf wasgi ntfe n( 5)da t noiyt Clr t tsr ieha be n
sue ai if
ve ite 1 ys o tf he ek ha e vc d e
a ompls d a i tuc e t tot wie de e
cc
ihe nd nsr t d ha her s f ndan çsa 'woul bedim is fo t s t
ts m '
d
s s ed r m he ui

wi u p eudc p ru n t Fe R. v P. m) Plitf h sfie t r s ndwihnte
t t rj ie u s a t o d Ci. 4( . an if a ald o epo
ho
ti h
a l t d tmeperod.Ass h, ls ntt t a e r por and r c me a i oft
lote i
i
uc ptr ua o he dopt d e t
e om nd ton he

ma itaej d ea dt n tc is e b t Clr ,t shee yORDERED ta ter manig
gsrt u g n he oie su d y he e k ii rb
h th e i n
p ndn cam a an td fn a tS mZ'i DI M I
e ig li g i s ee d n C I s S SSED wi u p eu iepu s a t oFe R.
S '
t t rj dc ru n t d
ho
Ci P. m) Th smatri a c r igy S CKEN fo t a tv d c e o tec u t
v. 4( . i te s c o dn l TRI
r m he cie o k t f h o r.
The Cl k i die e t s nd a ee tf e c oft s Or rt pl ntf a t co elof
er s r ct d o e
rii d opy hi de o ai if nd o uns
r or
ec d.

4/

Etr /
nze 'j

- (3
-

c rc . ? -V *
r # *
.
'

M ihae F.Ur ns
c l
ba ki
U nie St t s Di t i tJ
t d a e sr c udge