Jones v. Colvin

Filing 16

ORDER ADOPTING REPORT AND RECOMMENDATIONS ; denying 9 Motion for Summary Judgment; granting 11 Motion for Summary Judgment; adopting 15 Report and Recommendations. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 8/21/14. (kld)

I T H E U N I D STAT E S D I T RI CO U RT
N
TE
S
CT
FOR TH E W ES
TERN D I
STRI OF VI N I
CT
RGI A
H ARR I N BU R G D I
SO
VISI
ON

N O *8 OFFI U. ;l fGItR'
CE $..5 . Dl l
7
'
AT i RI
M SONBURG VA
Fl ln
1

AL 2 2 1
C
4
u

M THLEEN V.
JONES,

.U

LERK

@

Pl ntf,
ai if

Ci lA c i N o. 5: c
vi t on
: B

6

V.

CAR O LY N W .CO LW N ,
Actng Com m i s onerofSoc alSecur t
i
si
i
iy,

By:H on.M i
chaelF.U t
bansl
d

Unie St esDiti Judge
td at srct

D ef
endant
.

O RD E R

Tl s ilscuiydia ût a a wa rfte t t Hono a l a sG. es
ùs oca e t t sbi y ppe l s eerd o he
t bel me W lh,

UntdSae Ma itaeJ d e pus a tt 2 U.. j6 6b () ,o p o sdfn i sof a t
ie tts gsrt u g , t u n o 8 SC. 3 ()1m)f t t po e i dng fc
a ar c mme e ds o iin.Th Ma itaeJ d eSe arpo t n rc mme d d no J l
nd e o nd d ip st
o
e gsrt u g ld e z a d e o n a o n uy
31 2 4 tc
, 01 , e omme ngt tt Commisone'moton f s
ndi ha he
si rs i or ummayj gme beg a e a
r ud nt rntd nd
t t Commisone' f lde ii beafime Noobjc
hathe
si rs ma cson
ft d.
e donst t rpor a
o he e t nd
r
ecom m endaton have been fl and t cour i oft opi on t t r ta
i
ted,
he
t s he ni hat he epor nd
r
ecom m endadon shoul be adopt i isentt y. I i accotlngl O RD ER ED and
d
ed n t iet t s
ci y

ADJ
UDGED t tt pli fsmodonf s
ha he andf
or ummayj
r udgme , tNo.9 i DEN I t tt
ntDk.
,s
ED,ha he
Commisone' moton frs
si ts i o umma yj me ,DktNo. ,sGRANTED,t tt rpota
r udg nt . 11 i
ha he e r nd
r
ecom m endaùon,D kt N o.15,i A D O PTE D i is entret t t Com m i i ' f a
.
s
n t
i y, hat he
ssoners m l

de ii i AFFI E D ,a t tt sm a t ti S R I EN f om t a tve doc toft c t
c son s
RM
nd ha hi te s T CK
r he c i
ke
he our.
The Cl k i di ect t s a cer i copy ôft sO r t al couns ofrecor
er s r ed o end
dfed
hi der o l
el
d.
Ent ed: Augus 21,2014
er
t
*

@

*

Mi
chaelF.U r l
bansd

#

UniedSttsDitit udge
t ae src l