Harris et al v. McDonnell et al

Filing 137

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 3/31/2014. (jat)

- - ' o- l u s. sT = ur
oE
DI

AT

I TH E UN I
N
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
G
FO R TH E W ESTERN D I TRI OF W RGI G
S CT
N
H ARR I N BU R G D I SI N
SO
W O

K ; u qW
BR

FlFn
I

2ù
1
JULA .

,

R

JOAN NE H ARRI #1gk,
S,. o be l fé e se v s azl
n ha fo
m le J
al ot s .zrz z.rs t e
l her çi b ' iuat A
i
Ci lA cton N o. 5:3cv00077
vi
i
: 1
Pl ntfs,
ai if
V.

By:H on.M i
chaelF.U r
banski

J
ANET M .RAI
NEY,.pky
#1 -

UniedSt e DititJ
t ats src udge

D ef
endant
s.
M E M O RAN D U M O PI ION
N

O n M a c 1 201 t Folth Cic i Co tofA ppe l g a e t m odon ofpl i f i
t h 0, 4, he z t t u t ur
a s t nt d he
a ndf s n

ti c s,o n HarsJ siaDu fCl syBeg of, ndVitraI d ,oi tr e eo t sd
hs a eJ a ne ri, esc f, uit rh fa co i iid t nev n n he ie
o tepan fsa p l e a dfesp tt b if i Bosiv. c a fr e a, . 4 1 6 () Th t
f h lid f-p el s n t e aae res n t S h ee. t 1No 1 - 1 7 L . a
e
l
c
c s i c ur nty pz e d ng on a e pe t d ba i a i s tt be he t on t M a 1 15 2 4,
a e s t e l oc e i
n x die ss nd s e o
ad
he y 2- , 01
at entcal
gum
endat
.

Att sat conf ence hel i t s c on Febrmry 19,2014,pl ndfsi cat t t t
he t us
er
d n hi ase
t
ai f ndi ed hat hei
m ai goalwast ha tl rda i cout and t be heat on tae i potantis t i i t scas
n
o ve lei y n
t
o
d
l m
t s ues ased n hi e

on t s e s
he am chedul ast Bos ca A sares toft Fouth Ci c tsO t ofM at 10,
e he dc se.
ul he
t t ui' der
ch

201 a l w i pli f t i e v ne i t Bos a a, andfs ha t toppo t niy Be a e
4, lo ng a néf s o nt r e n he dc ppe l pl i f ve ha
t u t . c us
oft ss im i pr e a de l e ,t c dt do li s i t sc s i no i t ha of
hi e s c oc dur l ve opm nt he ons u na s ue n hi a e s w t he nds
z
t Fot h Cicui Cout ofAppe s. As t Fouth Cic tsi pendi dec son i bi ng,t
he ut r t
t
al
he
t r ui' m
ng ii s ndi he
com tw ilst tlscas pendi t dec son.
l ay li e
ng hat ii

I a don t pl i if ' nt r e i i t Bos a a , anot as
n ddi
o a ntf s i e v nton n he dc ppe l
het pectoft
he
a
nom a o pt e a posur oft sc s c m s l t c tt e t ie r sr i i i sln a m' ng
l us oc dur l t e hi a e ot e s he out o xe c s e ta nt n s 'i g l
i
att stm e. Thati beca e t e i no l
hi i
s
us her s
ongerany pat yizt scaseadvocatng t Vipm'' sa et t hi
i hat r ' a s m

sex m a rageand cvl uni ban i c dt
ri
i ' on
l
s ons udonal 1 In ot words t debat i t scot i
.
her
e n hi ut s
, he
deddedl one- i
y
sded.

Att e Fe ua y 1 201 sa' c e e e t pa de a i s e tl c tspt nta
l bt t 9, 4 t t onf t nc , he r s dd e s d le om ' ude i l
a
us
conce n ofdecdi a i pot a cvi ti scas i a pos utew her no par yw asadvocadng t
r
i ng n m t nt i l ght e n
t
e
t
hat

Vig' '' s m e s x m a ra a cvi lni ba i c tt do l N otng t pr e oft l c of
t t as a -e
m
t ige nd i l ' on n s ons iu na . i he obl m
he a k
a r iy i tlsc s ,t pade s e t d t tt c t c i ta ndng a a iusc a t
dve st n li a e he l s ugg s e ha he o ut onsde ppoi
n m c mi e o
ar t t ban i cons i donal ot at m a y,t t c tr y on tae now a
gae hat he
s
tm
, le dvel hat he our el
l
bandoned i da
ni l

bte s fl d by Ra ne a Robe t . N e t tat r tve i s ts a t y. Fi s,a ntng a a i us
i f le
i y nd
t s ihe le na i s a if c or
t t ppoi i n m c
ct ae t def t lw scal otbe accom pls by t tm e t Fot h Ci c thea t scas i
ui o end he a
m
ihed
he i he ut r ui rs hi e n
eaty M a Beca e t Folt h Cicui has decded t t up t Bos cas on an expedied bass
l y.
us he zt r t
i
o ake he dc e
t
i,

i i i pt c a f r t c tt r que tt ta a iusc i e de et fm e a unde t ke t
t s m a dc l o he our o e s ha n m c uta vot he i nd
r a he
expenset wei i on a i ue aleady s
o gh n
n ss t
chedul t be heaz i s
ed o
d n hortor by a hi cour .
det
ghet
t

Se ond, s t t e ri tbre s i i difc tf t t c z tt pa a g e tde lofc e nc t t pror
c
a o he a le i f , t s fi ul o he olt o y r a a
t de e o he i
l ar ent s
egal gum s uppor t c lenged l whe t par w ho fl t have t m s ves
dng he hal
aws n he des
ted hem
he el
aba
ndoned t e ar ne s.
hos gm nt

Ast S e Coztsae ls tt i Unie Sttsv. i ot 1 3S. .26 ( 3,
he uptme lr ttd at e' n td ae W nds , 3 Ct 75 201 )
m
fgj nwhe At l IIpemist e tieoffdea j ididon,pr nda c i rdons
feve
n dce I t t he xecs e tlurs c
ude l onsdea
de a t tt Co ti i tupon fha c t t a r e s wli h s r nst pr s nt don of
m nd ha he ur nss
t t onc e e dve s ne s lc ha pe he e e a

1 hl d fnd n l n t Ran y teSaeRe ita o Via Reo d, r ial ag e ta Vignassmesx
W i ee a t a e M. ie ,h tt gstr f tl c r soi n l tu d h t rii' a -e
e
g y
mazaeb nwa c n dtin lh tp i nc a gdfl wigte auay 2 1 d cso b Vi nasAton y
zig a s o s tt a, e os h n e ol n h J n z, 0 4 eiin y r i' tre
zo
do
o
gi
G e t lnott de e t ban. Thom a E.
ne a
o f nd he
s Robe t,t Cl r oft St t t Cic tCouu, i wieha r te t d f o
rs he e k he am on r ui
lke s s e r a e r m
s ppor l t lw sandnow tkesnoposdonon t i co dt tonaiy.''i s e ro c r t tt rsakl fom t
u drg he a
a
i
her ns u i lt l s c nai ontass ahe tr y r he
b

Bo d cs, eetl No fl Clt of u t o t u st avo aef zheb nsc n t t o aiya l sbenjie
s c aewh l le zok ek Co rc ni e o d ct o t l ' o sid n l nd u e on d
n
t
t
q
ilt tde e ebyt izer ni Ptnc W il m Count Clt ofCour .
l ha f ns
he tt ve ng i e li
a
y ek
t

i s supon wlih t c zts lt l de nds f il i do ofdifc tc ttz l
s ue
ac he olr o a gey pe
ot lum na n
f i ul ons it
dona

q edo s' J a 2 8 (uoigBa e v. t, 6 U.. 8 , 0 (9 2) Mu hl et Ato y
u s n .' . t 6 7 q t
' Z
n k t -Cat 3 9 S 1 6 2 4 1 6 ). c i he t me
k
G e r lofVig' i ha done i t sc s a r ga dst c e d Vig ni lw s i W i
ne a
tm a s
n hi a e s e r he ho nge r i a a , n ndsor t
he

Prsde a e dwilt posdo tke byEdi Wi ora i tuce t De rme of us e
ei nt gre tl he i n a n
f nds nd nsr td he pat nt J dc
h
nott def t se
o end he cdon oft D ef e ofM at igeA ctati s iAt cas The W i otCot
he
ens
ta
s ue t hat e.
nds
ut
not tmt
ed l

FheEx c
j
e udve' a e me wihW i o ' lg lagu nttie t
s gre nt t nds rs e a r me ass he
rs t i t of a t l eat t a vial cont ove y,t Cot
ik hat nsead
ea , nes nd t
t ts he
ut
f a fi y,nonaces rendl
advet ar pr
s y, oceeai i whih a pat y beat n i
ng n
c
t
e n
t lgi l ut s ks t tansf r t t court a i ' as t t
he e sat e ee o t e o he
s n nqut
ry
o he
cons adonaiy oft l saéve act
dtz lt
he egil
.

Jl ( e l uoa o maksa dattd n o te )(u d gAs wa d t TVA, 9 U.. 8 ,
.,i ma q td n r n lea o s mitd q o n h n e v.
t nt
27 S2 8

3 6(9 6 mtn esJ, o v i g)2Th c a ei lg l o iinsb Rqne a Ro et a dt e
4 1 3 ) a d i, .c ncut l. e h ng n e a p sto y i y nd b ts n l
n
a
r uli l k ofany advocat f t chalenged l cons adonalt m akest rs i W i ora
es tng ac
e ot he l
aws'
dtz
iy
he ik n nds
r iy het O n t si s ofcons a tonalsgni ancewhi has engendet s m uch s tt
ealt
e.
hi s ue
dtzi
i fc
ch
ed o
piied

publc de t ,t co tm us K s s on . .t m os c m it d a vi or a ve s r a gu e s
i ba e he ut
t V it
. he
t om t e nd g ous d r a y t m nt

t i o m t nl g o t c uts' Hol s rhv Pe ,1 3SCt2 5 , 6 47 (0 3
o nf r he zn s f he o t. ln wo t . r 3 . . 6 2 2 7 -5 2 1 )
i
' i
( n e yJ,l sni g (o n n o t pupo eo j d iblyp i ilsi t ec n e to
Ke n d , .cse t l c mme d g n he t s fus ca it rncpe n h o tx f
i n
i
Ar l Ilsa lng.S ha riyi pli ylcknghee.
dce I tnci ) uc dvest s qnl a i t
The Supr e Cour has fl t
em
t
'ong ecogmzed t cotrt have i entpow ert say
' hat t s
nhet
o t
ptoceedi a <o cont t diposton oft ca
ngs nd t
rol he s ii
he useson isdocketwih econom y oftm e and
t
t
i

efr f risl,o c u sla dfrl ka t.'S o ev IN..5 4U.. 8 , 1 (9 5 (u t g
fo t o teff r o n e, n o i n s' t n . . S, 1 S 3 6 4 1 1 9 ) q o i
t
'
n
La i v N. Co, 9 U.. 4 , 5 (9 6) I e d t eFo t Cic i h sf u dt tadstc
nds . Am. .2 9 S 2 8 2 4 1 3 ). nd e ,h urh rut a o n ha itit
2Uli a ey,t Cot i W i orf md t s pr de lsa ' c e ss ds d i t tc eby t pa tcpa of
tm t l he ut n nds ot he e u nda t ndmg onc m a fe . ha as
n
he r ii don
t Bi r a Le a Ac G r whih i e v ne a t dit tc ta a i ee tdpa t a pa dcpae
he padsn g l éon oup, c ntr e d t he szc out s n ntr se ry nd r i td
t oughoutt a l pr e s I c z t no one ha i e v ne i t sc e M ot ove , he W i orCout wa
ht
he ppeas oc s . n ontas,
s nt r e d n hi as .
e rt
nds
t s
c me a
once d boutt e e i ltga t tw o de uei i de l t he rt tcaea t pr e sa s itd
he xtnsve ii don ha ul ns f t ci o a ha s nd he oblm s ocae
ned
wih t r s tng lc ofpr c de ta guda e Tha c e n i a e he e a t i ntc l s ue r iedi t sc ei
t he e uli a k
e e n il i nc . t onc r s bs nt r s he de i a i s a s n bi as s
bef et Fourh Cic tonex die r viw.
or he
t rui
pe td e e

c l t y i i dsr d n sa acvl te p n igad cso fo ahkh tc l t h tc ud
oz ma ,n t ice o , ty iimatt e an e iin r m
r
s
e oz t a o l
r
contolt out e. See H ikey v.Ba e 833 F.2d 1 05, 98 W L 390 a * (t Ci. 987
t he com
c
xt r,
0 1 7
20, t 1 4h t 1 )

( u l h dtbed cso )(W ef t t dstc c u ta tdwi i isdstdo i sa mg
t bi e a l e iin < md l he itit o r ce t n t ice n n ty
mp s
<
ut
h
'
proceedi whie a ai gui
ngs l w dng dance f om t Supre e Cout i a cas t coll dec dereeva
r he
m
tn
e hat zd i l nt

is s'.W hi ii taet tasa ofacvic s s dbet ta nonl i e tot nay
sue.) l t s tz ha ty
'
e
i l a e houl mdetke y t xta di r
z
czumsa e ,hi c s pts nt j ts hctlmsa e a i e de fom t epli if'
ic tnc s t s ae e e s us uc icl tnc s s s vi nt t l ontfs
a
i e v nûon i t Bos a a a t lc ofa y opposton t pli f ' ii t tt s m e
nt r e
n he dc ppe l nd he a k
n
ii o q néfs poston ha he q -

s xmara a cvilni ba i unc dtz l Nori t r a prj c t t pli f by
e rige nd i ll on n s ons adona.
s hee ny eudie o he andfs
sayi t sm a t r. Bec
t ng hi t e
ause t Four. Cicui hasgra ed pl ndf s m odon t i e
he
t r t
h
nt
ai f '
o nt rvenei t
n he

Bo dca pelt ywi n t fr e t d tndai e' i a te g o p o l ka sfed st
s p a,he l o be o c d o f a sd 'whl noh r t u fi nt f t e he
l
s
e
t
s
r l ofa ta wi d f tet t o boh. La ds 2 9U.. t2 5 Ha igi ev n da tl
ue lw h t l eme h khs f t ' n i, 9 S a 5 . vn ntt e e tle
l
'
Four h Cicti,pl ndf snow have avoi i t de e pendi a t cout ofappeal
t r zt ai f
ce n he bat
ng t he
t
s.

The c t viw st i e v nton ofpl i f i o t Bos i Fout h Cic ta a t be a
ou t e he nt r e i
a ndf s nt he tc
t t ui ppe l o

p o e ua g mec n e/a dtea e c o a yo p sdo t t ep sdo a v ctdb t
t c d rl a -ha g t n h bsn e f n p o i n o h o i n d o ae y he
pl ndfsi tlscas com pel t colr t exer s r t nt I s t t colt doesnotbele i
ai f n li e
s he z t o
cie estai . n hot, he z t
ive t

t bepmde ori t i eet ofj dc t is a opi oni as tngwheeonl onesdes
o
nt n he ntrss us e o sue n ni n et
i
r y
i'
a gum ent at f cefTl pr s TheFot h Cicui,how e wilhave t beneftofpli f
r
s e or lly es ed.
ut t t
ver, l
he
i
andfs'

agu n sa dav r u d fns t i o m teis simu t e iei t pe iga e l Ba e
r me t n ko o s ee e o nfr h sue t s d cd n he ndn pp a. s d
on pl ndf s i et i i t pendi appea i Bos and conce nsove prude
ai f ' nt venton n he
ng
ln
dc
r
r
ndalsandi t
t ng, he
cotr wils a tzsm a t runtlt Fourh Cicli rul . An a optat O rde wilbe ent red t s
tt l t y li t e
i he
t r zt es
ppr i e
r l
e hi
day.

3N o t tt pli f i tlsc eha ei e td t m s l si ot Bos ldga a t c s i pe n ona
w ha he andfs n li as v nsre he eve nt he dc i don nd hat a e s ndig
n
e ie ba i a t Fo Ci c t t c i a i c m pel t c utt de y de e nt ' odo t ta f toz
xped t d ss t he uuh z ui, he onsdet tons o li he ot o n f nda s m n o t ns e
ng

sa ti cs whe iwa rie a teo te ofhsi ainaen ln e a pial.O k. . 7.
ty ls ae n t s asd th ust tilt t r o o gr p l be tNo 6 )
l
t o
k
c
4

The Cl k i di ct t s a copy oft sO t t alcounse ofr
er s re ed o end
hi der o l
l ecord.
Ent red: M ar 31,2014
e
ch

/ /. 4 .J f Aw
+ m a
c
M i ha lF. ba ki
c e Ur ns
U nie St t sD i ti tJ
t d a e sr c udge

5