Carter v. America Note Servicing et al
Filing
22
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 5/14/2014. (jat)
I T H E U N I ED STAT ES D IST RICT C O U RT
N
T
FO R T H E W E ST ERN D ISTR IG O F V IRG I IA
N
H ARR I N BU RG D I SI N
SO
W O
CLERKS OFFI O.s.DI EO URT
CE
S'
AT ROANOKE.
VA
FIED
L
MAt 15 2 1
21
aUL
BY:
. D
D
,
CLERK
CLERK
I EN E CARTE R ,
R
Pl ntf,
ai if
Ci lA ct on N o. 5:
vi
i
: 14cv00003
AM E RI N O T E SERVICI G , tAk,
CA
N g
By:H on. i
M chaelF. banski
Ur
.
Unied St esDititJ
t at src udge
D ef
endant
s.
M E M O R AN D U M O PI I N
N O
Tli m ateri bef t cout on t m odonst dim isofdef
ls t s ore he
t he
o s s
endant ALG Tm see,LLC
s
t
(ALG' a At n cLa Gt u LLC rAt n cLa '.Dk . s 3& 4 rs c v l.Th s
<
< ' nd l d w o p,
)
a
f l d w'
a
) tNo .
,epe d ey e e
m odons a wihoutm ertand wlla
re t
i
' ccordi y be de ed.
l
ngl
ni
1.
I t sa t n pant fle eCatr(Catt'se sad caao yjd me i h rfvo a
n hi ci , li i rn re ç te' e k e lrtr u g ntn e a t nd
o
f
<
)
as alge avoldon oft FarDe Cole donPrc esAc,1 U. C. j1 2, t...l he
lo le s i a
he i bt lc
a dc t 5 S. j 69 q ùq n r
e
com pl nts alegestae f l ng f steevantt t pendi m otons on Febtz y 6,2003,
ai he l
l olowi act l
o he
ng
i :
aar
Cattt outace tl De dofTr s wihBankofAmeia( non- ty.The20 De dof
re ook
r di i
ne e
ut t
.
rc a pat)
03 e
Tr tgaveBank ofA m erca a se iy i et ti Caret' hom e. Cat e ref anced t 2003 D eed
us
i
curt nt es n
t s
tr m
he
ofTr tw ih a second D eed ofTm s bet
us t
t ween hetand Ba ofAm ercaon Sept ber 14,2004.
nk
i
em
Cat e hasatached copi ofbot D eedsofTrustas e bis t hetcom pl nt asw elas t
tt
t
es
h
xhi t o
ai ,
l he
s tem ents a em entm em otalzi t t m ancng agr e .
etl
tt
i i ng he ef
i
eem nt
A fett 2004 ref ancng,Bank ofAm e i f l t cl t accountas oci ed wih t
t he
m i
rca aied o ose he
s at
t he
2 D e d ofTrzt de pie t f c i ha be n pa d of a t s cuiyi e e ti c e t d
003 e
t , s t he a t t d e i f nd he e t t nt r s t t a e
s
e
xdnglihed. O n D ecem ber23,2005,Bank ofAm e i assgned t 2003 D eed ofTr tt Ulied
zs
tca i
he
us o lt
Gu tnt Reie t l ns nc Co n o No t CaoiarUGRI' (nohe no pat) UGRI
aa y sd n i I ma e mpa y f rh r l <
a
n
' a t t n- ty.
)
s equenty as i d t D eed ofTr tt def
ubs
l sgne he
us o endantA m erca N ot Se ci
i
e rvi ng.
O n M ay 1,2013,A m erca N ot Se cng exec ed a Subs aton ofTrus ee f t 2003
i
e rvii
ut
dtzi
t or he
D eed ofTrustwhi appoi ed def
ch
nt
endantALG ,as Subs m eTtzt Put ua t t aut iy
dt
as ee. s nt o he hort
s
upposedl conf re by t Subsdt i ofTrus ee,def
y
er d
he
uton
t
endant ALG and A tandc La sc dul a
s
l
w he ed
f el t sl ofCatrshomef Tueda yune1 ,2 3.Catrc a tdAta La
ot cosue ae
te'
or s yl
1 01
re ontce lndc w
t r u hhe c u sl n fl dfee t c so si lt Ma a de t J n o 2 1 t ifr t m
h o g r o n e o oz iftn oc ain n ae y n al u e f 0 3 o n o m he
r
y
t s iy i e ti Catershom e had been extnguihed vi t 2004 r m a i butr ved
hat ecutt nt res n t '
i s
a he
ef ncng,
ecei
no i lca t t f os e s ew oul be canceled. The s l wascanceled when Carerfl
nci don hat he orecl ur al
d
l
ae
l
t led
t pr e acdon i sat cout .
he es nt
n te
t
A st pt e z a hit y Ca t tsc pl i w a r m ove by t de e nt t f de a c ur
o oc dlr l sor , t e ' om a nt s e
d
he f nda s o e t l o t
on Fc u r 11 201 D kt N o.1.Thepe ng m otonst dim i sw e e fl d on Fe u r 1 ,
br a y , 4.
.
ndi
i o s s r le
br a y 7
2014. D kt N os.3 & 4. Pl ndf r ponded t t m odons on M ar h 10,2014. D kt N o.13.
.
ai f es
o he
c
.
D e e nt di notfl r pl bre sw ihi t Hm e a l t d a t pa de ha wave or l
f nda s d
te e y i f t n he
lote nd he t s ve i d a
agume .Ass h,hematri now rpef a udia n.
r nt
uc t
te s
i ot dj cdo
I
I.
F d êl l ofC vl z c d r 1 @ 4) r t apat t mo efrds sa b s du o a
e e a Rue iiP o e u e 2 6 pemi
s zy o v o i sl a e p n
mi
fal et saeaclm uponwhihrle cnbegtntd. Fe R. v. 1 $() Thesa r on
f i o tt li
f ur
c eif a
a e ' d. Ci P. 29 6.
'
tndad
s h a m odon i now w ele t bls d. < s v ve a m odon t d s is a c pbi m us c nt i
uc
s
l- sa ihe t ut i
To
o i m s , om nt t o a n
s sce f c u lm a t r a c pt d a t ue t çt t a c m t z le t ti pl usbl on isf c . '
uf i nt a t a te , c e e s r , o s a e bi o e i f l s a i e t a e '
u
'
As t tv.qba,55 U. 6 ,67 ( 9 (uotngBelAt. p. Two y, U. 5 57
hcof I l 6 S. 62 8 200 ) q i l lCor v. mbl 550 S. 44, 0
( 07) A pli fswelpld fcua alg donswhieas dt betue l tav. tdSae ,
20 ). qndf l- e a t l le a , l sume o r ,bar Unie tts
1 F. 47 474( hCi.1 7,f tbee ught riearg t rl a t s c a ve
20 3d 2, 4t z 99 ) '
mus no o as iht o ei bove he pe uld
ef
lve. Twombl,55 U. a 5 tg donallt tne t tac tmus ace a tuealof
e l'
'
0 S. t 70. f
Addi l ,he e tha our t c pt s r l
y
t al
he legadonscont ned i a com pl nti i
ni n
ai s napplcabl t l lconcl i . Thr
i e o ega
usons
eadba tec t sof
te ial
t elm ent ofa caus ofacton,s
he e
s
e
i uppored by m e concl or s at e s,do nots âce.' l l
t
re
us y t em nt
uf ' qba,
556 U . a 678 A te t c pl i m us c nn s fc e f c s fom w hi h t co ut c li
S. t .
nd, he om a nt t ont i ufi i nt s t t
c he t , al
ng
upon
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?