Li et al v. Shuman et al

Filing 59

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 7/14/15. (kld)

f FRK' OFFI t. D4 .COURT
N
9
CE Js. sT
ATN OKE,
VA
FI
LED

IN T H E U N I ED STA TE S D ISTR ICT CO U R T
T
FO R T H E W E ST ERN D IST RICT O F VIR GI I
N A
H A RR I
SON BU R G D I
VISIO N

J 1j 2 1
UL
25
Jt l 0.
i

H U I KIJ L1,etal,
N
.

. LERK

DE W L
ER

Pl ntf s,
ai if

Ci lA cton N o.5:4- 00030
vi
i
1 cv-

By:

JOHN E.SHUM AN ,eta.
1y

Mi
chaelF.U r
bansl
d

Unied SatsDiti J
t t e stct udge

D ef
endant
s.

M EM O RAN D U M O PIN IO N

Thi matri beoz t c tonpli if'
s te s f e he our
antfs moùonf rl fom j me fldpurua
ot ei r udg nt le s nt
ef
t Fe tlRul ofCi l oc dut 609$.ECFNo. 2.Thec tptvi l is daMe rnd
o dea e viPt e e
5
our e ousy sue
moa um
Opilona Ot rdimisngwihprj c Co s5 6, nd8(ndi dua cam)a dimisng
ri nd de s si t eudie unt , a
i vi l li nd s si
wihoutptj c Count 3, 7,8( rvai cam) 9 1 ,11 1 1 a 1 ofpli if' .
t
eudie
s 4, dei tve li , , 0 , 2, 3, nd 4 antfs
com pl nt ECF N os 50 & 51.Pl ntf sas t cour t reconsderis di m isa oft e cli s
ai .
.
ni if k he
to
i t s s l hes am .

For t r
he easonsst ed bel ,pl ntf s m odon w ilbe D EN IED .
at
ow ai if '
l
1.

Pli if fldt i motonf rle fom j
antfs le het i or eif r udgme purua t Rul 609 6,whih
nt s nt o e $()1 c
pr i s Konmotona j ttr ,t c tma r le apatr islga rpz sntt fom a
ovde : ç
i nd us ems he ouz y eive rjor t e l e ee ai r
ve

fna j gme ,or rorpz e dig f . . nyot tr aont tj tfe rle '
' lud nt de, oc e n or . a he e s ha usiis eif'
i
1Be us i wasfld wihi t nt - ihtda ofe r oft c utsor r t i m oéon ma ha mor a opra ey
ca e t
le t n we y eg
ys nty he ot ' de ,l s
l
y ve e ppr i tl

be n sye a aRu e5 ()mo o t atro a ndajd nt S eDo ev CODES 5 9F.d8 7 8 9 (t Ci.
e tld s l 9 e d n o le r me u pne . e v .
CO, 6 2 0 , O 4 h r
1 7 )t7fapotu pne tmo o i fe wi i tnd y ofh e tyo jd me ta dc l it q eé nt
9 8 f l sjd n é n s t d t n e a s te nr fu g n n al no u s o he
f
l h
s
c re t s o ta jd me tis udb te tda amoinu e Rue5 ()h we e ima b fr l sye .) se
orcnes fh tu g n t ho l e rae s t nd r l 9e, o vr t y e omal t1d';e
o
y
'
as ML Auo t e I ' v. wno S uh m Pie, 3 F.d2 9 2 7 7 (t Ci. 0 8 (oigCODES
lo C tmo i .JC To f o te n s5 2 3 6 , 7 - 8 4h r2 0 ) n t
v
n
CO
c nt u st a pyn t t sa dn t ea n me tt Fe ea Ru eof p l t Pr c d r 4 .Pli t f' to wo l
o i e o p l o wi tn ig h me d n o d rl l Ap el e o e u e ) an i s moi n ud
n
h
a
f
fr n bet r md raRu e5 ()a ay i, o v r A Rue5 ()mo o Ksc n i ee t be< e ta r i ayrme y
ae o t t e
e
l 9 e n lss h we e .
l 9 e é n f o sd r d o a x ro dn r e d
i
n
ta s ldbeu e saigp' Le v Zo Clrn o . P.6 5F. u p. d6 3 6 51 ( . . . 0 9 (u ù gPa.
h t hoz
l sd p rn l ' e . m ae d n L. , 6 S p 2 0 , 1 -6 . D Va2 0) q o n c
'
E
l s Co v Am . t Fr I s Cos 4 F.d3 6 4 3 (t Ci. 9 8) af s b n m. u Yu Le v Clr n o , 5 F.
n . . , Na. ie n . .1 8 3 9 , 0 4 h r 1 9 ), f' u o S n n e . a e d n 4 3
d
Ap x2 0(t Ci. 0 1.Ided ii welet dta fk l 5 ()f yn t usdt rliaeol matr' rt fas
p' 7 4h r2 1) n e ,ts lste h tfue 9e ma o be e o eig t d teso o rie
l
l
t
a g me t whc c u dh v b e rie p i rt t eis a c o t ej d me t' O' n r Co u i Ga
r u n s ih o l a e e n asd ro o h su n e f h u g n .' Co no v. lmba s
Trn miso Co .6 3F. u p 2 7 9 8 O( . Va 2 0 )( u t gPa . ns Co, 48F3 a 4 4 . fn o h r
a s sin r , 4 S p . d 9 , 1 W D. . 0 9 q o i c l . .1 .d t 0 ) f t e
n
l

W hie t s cat halreas i udes f w t uallm iadons,is cont
l hi c l
on ncl
e ext i t
t
ext
r r t ti m ay be iw oked i onl fe r
equies ha t
t
n y fxt aotdi y cicum sances'
nar r
t
'

whe t ras f tleffom j gme doe notflwihi t ls
n he e on or ei r ud nt s
al t n he it
ofe rtd ra onsgi n ilRue 609 1-5.Se Li'be v.
numeae e s
ve r l $()() e le r
H eat Servs A c uii
lh
'.
sdon Co . 486 U. 847, 863 n. 864, 108
,
S.
11,

S. .21 ,10 L. 2d 85 (988. As Cl fJ tc Re
Ct 94 0 Ed. 5 1 )
ùe usie hnquit
s
notdi hi spaaeo nini Lie r
e n s e rt pi o n l beg:
j
Rul 60$)a horz sadititco t on modon a
e
ut ie src ur,
nd
u n s c tz a aejs,t z l v apat fo a
po u h ems s r u t o ei e zy ê m
e
f lj me ,or t orpr e di f a Te s
ma udg nt de,
oc e ng or ny f aon
r
j dfi rle fom t opeai oft j gme .
us yng eif t he rton he ud nt'
'
H ow e r w e ha t
ve ,
ve epeat dl i tuct t onl
e y ns t ed hat y
% 1'<extaor nar c r um s a es'wilper ta par y
J f r di y i c t nc ' l mi
t
s
ucces uly t i
sf l o nvoke t <any ot r
he f
her eason' cluse
' a

ofj 609 Thi vey src i e rtdon ofRue
$. s r tit ntm ea
l
60$)i esnta i t fnaiy ofj me si t be
s se il f he i lt udg nt s o
pt eve 486U. a 8 1 S. . 9 ( hnquit
est d.
S. t 73, 08 Ct21 4 Re
s,
C.. disntng (ia
J, se i l ctdons omitd. To gi Rul
te )
ve e
609$() br d a iai wotl undemi
6
oa pplc ton
zd
r ne
num e
tous ot
her r es t
ul hat f vor t Snaiy of
a
he
lt

j me s s h a Rul 59 (e l i t tmodo
udg nt, uc s e rqltng ha
i
ns
f ne tilort atrora ndaj g ntbefld
or w ra o le
me
ud me
le
no ltrt n 28 da atr t e t ofj gme )
ae ha
ys fe he nty ud nt;
'
Ru e6 $()(rvdn t a a c u tma no e tn
l 9 2 p o iig h t o r y t xe d
t tme t fl modons unde Ruls 5
he i o l
e
t e 09$,5 d)
0( ,
529 5 5 d) 5 e,a 609 ;a Fe rlRul
$, 9q$, 9( , 9() nd $) nd dea e
ofAppelt Pr e ue 4()(e ii ge tl t t
lae oc dt a rqutng neal ha
y
a asbefldwihi 30da afe j
ppel te t n
ys trudgme )
nt.

Aie sv.n rm, 5 F.d4 6 5 0 0 (t Ci. 01 ) Th ,h rao f rwlc ac u t a
k n l a 6 2 3 9 , 0 - 1 4 h r2 1. ust e e s ns o t h o r c n
i
ga rl unde Rul 6 $()aelmie Se Dowel Stt Fam Fie& Ca . o.ns Co.
rnt ei
ef t e 09 6 t i td. e
lv. ae r t
s Aut l . ,
9 F. 4 4 ( 1Ci. 993.TheFo t Cic tha ma ce rt taRul 6 6 moton
93 2d 6, 8 4t4 r 1 )
urh tui s de la ha
e 09$() i
ca
nnots t asa s ttze f a tm el appeal I ;s a s Ai ,652 F. a 501.
eve
ubs iat or i y
. d. ee l o kens
3d t

wo ds amo o frr c n ie a o u e Rue5 ()i i pp o raei i a k t ec u t o f e au t t eb ssu o
r , ù n o e o sd r ù n nd r l 9e s na r p it f t s s h o r t r v l ae h ai p n
e
whih i m a aprortzi or( e ey s e t r a gu apr v ousca m .' Pr e t M
c t de i al
ng' m r l e ks o e r e e i li ' o'c s
'

t Co.v. nCo l ' LLC
.
D
ntl

No 11 - 3 1 2 1 WL 1 1 2 7 a * ( . Va Ap. 5 2 1)(u é gUntdSae v S t il Fo dsIc,
. :3CV-3 , 0 4
5 3 6 ,t 1 . D. . r1 , 0 4 q o n i tts . mi ed o .n .
E
e
hf
9 9F. u p 9 5 9 7( D. . 9 7)
6 S p . 7 , 7 E. Va 1 9 ).

Il.

I t i Rul 60$)l odon,pli if objc t t Ju 1 2 Or rdsnisngCount 3,
n her e
'
n
antfs e t o he ne 6, 015 de it si
s
4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13 and 14 oft com pli and as f r
he
ant
k or econsder i oft cotr '
i aton he zts
t i Pl ntfsadvance ar ent and cie e dence i an ef or t dem onsiat t t cour
ulng. ai if
gum s
t vi
n
f to
t e hat he
t

er oneousy di s ed t
r
l smi s hese cai s.
lm

Asi a ist t co tsdimislofCount 3 4, 8( rvai caml 9,1 ,11 1 1
t pple o he ur' s sa
s , 7, dei tve li y 0 , 2, 3,
a 1 oft c antpli ifsmodonfis a t c tsr lngi notaKf lj gme , de
nd 4 he ompli , antf'
al, s he our' ui s
tma ud ntor t

o p ocel g'r m whihpan i sc n se rl fu d eRue6 @ .A ds sa wih u p eu ie
t r e ci 'fo
n
c litf a e k ei n e l 0
f
e
imisl t o t zjdc
i notaf lot rs e tt a pelunls fheg o
s
ma de ubjc o p a es t r undsoft dimislma cert tno
t
he s sa ke la ha
am encm entcoul cur t def si t pli fscas ....' D om i Su arCo , Su a
l
d e he ect n he a ndf
e
'
no
v, r

W or r Loc lUni 392 1 F. 1 4,1 6-7(t Ci.1 ) s e28U. C.j1 .
kes a on , 0 3d 06 06 6 4h t 993; e
S. 291
Evauai t patc a g o f t dimislofCount 3, 7,8( rvaiecam)9,
l tng he riulr r unds or he s sa
s 4, dei t li ,
v
1 1 1 ,13 a 1 la t c ut t c l t tisJ 1 201 Or twa notafna one.
0y 1, 2 , nd 4 e ds he o t o oncude ha t une 6, 5 de s
il

Thec ur dir se wiho prj c Count 3,4 7 8( rva cam) 9,1 1 ,a 1
o t snisd t ut eudie
s , , dei dve li , 0, 3 nd 4
( tvai cam)be a epli if fie t alget yha sa ngt brngt camsdei tvey
dei t li c us antfs ald o le he d tndi o i he li zvai l
ve
on be l ofM i os A san Fuson,TJE and f ied t es a i t t ha m ett s atzor
ha f
m a i
i
al o t blsh hat hey d
he t at y

rquie nt f doi s I a ton,Co 7, lei avi a ofVigni Codej1 11 ,
e tme s or ng o. n ddii
unt algng oldon
ri a
3.-036

wa dimisdwihoutptj c be a etl c antfie t alget e se eofet ratce
s s se t
eudie c us le ompli ald o le he xitnc ihe rils
ofor ni tonora opeai a t me oralg t tdefnda J Shuma ha rc i da
ga zai
n rtng gee nt le e ha e nt ohn
n d e eve
diti i fom Mi aAsa Fuson,LLC i voain ofVigi aCodej1 11 ,a rq rd
stbuton r
mos in i
n ilto
t ni
3.-035 s e uie
byt saat.Thec tdimisdwiho prj c c s11a 1 be a et c antdi
he ttze
our s se t ut eudie ount nd 2 c us he ompli d
nots fc e l s at a cli f faud,asi cont ned no alegadonsast whe orw her t al
ufi i nty t e am or t
t
ai
l
o
n
e he leged
m ire ent
s pres adonsw e m ade,norany ot t det lconce ni t nat e oft aleged
te
he
ai
r ng he ur
he l

mirpr snttons Count1 (ndi dua cam)fie t pla t rquiiec etofa don f a
se ee ai .
4 i vi l li ald o e d he e st onct c or

co piayc m a wa l wiedimisdwihoutprj ie.I fc,hec antc ane no
ns rc bi nd si s s se t
ke
eudc n a tt ompli onti d

alg donwhas ve t tdefnda sc ne a s itd,a e dorot t s c pie t i e
le a
toe r ha e nt ombi d, socae gte
hewie ons td o t
jur
pli if.Fi ly Cou 1 wa dimisdwihoutprj c be a et alg to wee
antfs nal, nt 3 s s se t
eudie c us he le ains r
i ufi entt s at a cai f gtos ne i
ns fci o t e l m or
s glgence.

Thegoundsf dimisloft s camsstf t i t c ur'J 16 2 5
r
or s sa hee li e or. n he o ts une , 01
h
M e ot ndum O pi on e t bls t tpr pe a e
m a
ni sa ih ha o t m ndm e oft c pli w oul pe m i pli if t
nt he om ant
d t t a ntf s o

c niu t i lkain,Ac o dn l,h c u t a epant f t o p ru iyt a n , n a
o t e hsi t
n
t o
c r igy t e o r g v li i s he p o tnt o me d a d n
f
am e
nded com pli hasbeen fl See ECF N o.53. W het otnotpl ndf s a ended com pl nt
a nt
led.
her
ai f ' m
ai

i fc c e t deecsilCount 3, 7 8( rva cam) 9 1 ,11 1 1 a 1 rmanst be
n a t ur s he f t t
'
s 4, , dei dve li , , 0 , 2, 3, nd 4 e i o
se Ho ve,f pur e oft sRul 6 a l i,hec tsds sa oft ec sdoe
e n. we r or poss hi e 0>) naysst our' imisl hos ount s
notope aea af ludg ntoror rfom wlihrle cnbegrntd.
r t s ma j me
de t
tc eif a
a e
I a e nt-a a pli ifsmotona ist t dimisl t prj ceofCount 5,
n ny ve
nd s antf' i pple o he s sa wih eudi
s

6 a 8(ndi dua cam)whihdoe opeaea af lj gme -pbi if' i fist
, nd i vi l li , c
s rt s ma ud nt
ntfsmoton al o

ie tf a ye ta ti r c u tn e warn igrl f nd rRue6 $() Smpypu , lidfs
d n iy n x ro dnay /c msa c s ta tn ei u e l 0q 6. i l tpan f
e
aguet tt c ur gotiwt Thi i notapr rbai framodonf rle fom j gme
r ha he o t t ong. s s
ope ss o
or eif r ud nt

u e Rue6 9 6.Thst l d e no gv pant f a a e u t rasr p e i u l tie
nd t l 0 $() i ue o s t ie li i s n v n e o e set rvo s as d
f
y
ar ent and i r
gum s
nt oduce new onesi an efor t gett cour t r vauat isnli Pli if
n
f to
he
t o ee l e t lng. antfs'

dia e me wiha objci t t c ut'J 1 ,2 5Me r ndum Opi ona Or rae
sgre nt t nd e tons o he o ts une 6 01 mo a
ni nd de r
pr rydr tdt t FouthCic to a a, t t sc ti apos-udg ntmodon.
opel iece o he
t rui n ppe lnot o hi our n
tj me
A ccor ngl pli fsm odon wilbe D EN IED .
di y, anéf'
l
A n appr i e O r w ilbe ent ed.
oprat der l
et

Ent
oT - 1 - /
% r
ered:

/
w/- 42- 7 /.W *-# r
' .
, .w

Mi
chaelF.Ur ns
ba ki

Unie Sae Ditit ud
td tts src l ge
4

- -