Parker et al v. Austin et al

Filing 129

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by Chief Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 1/5/18. (jv)

CLERK' OFFI U, DI COURT
S
CE S. ST.
t AT ROANOKE,
VA
FIED
L

I THE UNI
N
TED S
TATESDI TRI COURT
S CT
FOR TH 2 W ESTERN D I TY CT OF W RGI I
S
N A

HA oNs
ums uRsol l
wsoN

J 25 2 1
AN
28

J

I C. UDL OL
A
EY, ERK
DEPUW

'EFK
L I

SU SAN V I
RGI I PARK ER ,ctpky
N A
.

Ci lActon N o. 5:4c
vi
i
: 1 v00035

Ili kif
3u rtfsy
V.

M I AE L AU STI ,ptsk,
CH
N
.

By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l

-

ClifUnie S a e Di ti t udge
le
t d t t s src l
D ef ndant
e
s.
M EM O RAN D U M O PI I N
N O

Onl one cnm r m a nsur es ve i t sc e- countS x oft com pli a gi
y
li e i
ol d n hi as
i
he
ant ie ng

ne l nc a ans d fnda t La r Re a , k a W i naPo t, e a Mis
gke e g i t ee ns u a g n Mie nd no
wesBrnt nd sy
Rud l a t He y& W iim Ev n Ho ftChlrn l .rEva Home'. ls
oph, nd he nr
la a s me o ide , nc f ns
l
' Tli
)
ne l e ecnm aie o tofa a l IJ. alg dl s ti d b pli f us
gi nc li ts s u n nke '/ le e y usnne y andf J ds
g
I
I
.
Funlhous r whie hew a i f tt c r a t Eva H om ei 201 Be us t doc rne of
c
el l
s n ose a e t he
ns
n
2. ca e he ti

c ttbl i niyba st i sae1w c m,d fnd nt' do f rs
haia e mmu t r hs tt a bi e e a s mo n o umma yj g n wil
r ud me t l
beG RAN TED a t sca eD ISM ISSE D .
nd hi s
1.

I tl a do fldJ l 2 , 01 pantfsc ntndt c lt nwee
n li c n l uy 4 2 4, li if o e wo hi e r
s
e
d
uncons u i lyr m oved fom t hom e oft i pa ent a pl c att Eva H om e
dt tonal e
z he
he r r s nd a ed he
ns
,

wh z te rci di r pe me ia te t nta weesbjc t ph scl n e éo l
ee h y eeve mp o r dc lrame nd r u e t o yia a d mo na
a s a ne lc. c ur d s se wih pr j c t va tmao yoft cnmsr ie
bu e nd ge tThe o t imis d t eudie he s jdt he li as d
1 'nro sr samio a tef tec mplit sse i uy2 1 ; c odn l, eprc e e tr u hhs
FAI u e wa n r t h i h o an wa d nl l 0 4 ac zigy h o e d d h o g i
b
me
p rnsa dne tde d . h ssn erahe tea eof jdt a mo e t besb due a ap rypan f, l h
ae t n x f n sHe a ic ec d h g mao y nd v d o u s ttd s at lidfwlc
i
m odon wa gr nt d by O r re e e O c o r30 2
s a e
de nt r d t be , 015.

.

i pli f 'c pli byM e or ndum Opi on a Oz re e ed Apzl28,2015 The
n anéfs om ant
m a
ni nd de nt r
i
.

s l r manig c m,Cou S x asaelw t l cnm c nc t ig a a l i j y o o of
oe e i n bi
nt i , t t a o4 li o e nn n nk e nut f ne
t c lt n, ss h d e f rtilOn t e oft ds o r de dh , andfJ rs
he hi e wa c e uld o za. he ve he ic ve y a ne pli f us
d
d
Fu ho e mo e f ravoun a yds sa ofCo tSx, t ut eudc , rua t
nk us r v d o
l tr' imisl
un L wiho pr j ie pu s nt o

Rte4 a()ofteFe ea Rue o Ci l o e ur. are Or e,hec ut g a td
z 1()2 h d rl ls f viPr c d e By ge d d rt o t rne
l
t tm oton on N ove be 24,2016.
ha
i
m r

Pli if t r fe a a e t dimi s lofCount One t ough Fi oft
antfs he ea t r ppe l d he s s a
s
hr
ve he

c l t Onl 6 201 , heFo t Cic i Cot ofAppe l din is dt a a f r
omp zn . une , 7 t urh r ut ut
as s ase he ppe l o
lc ofj idit a d r ma e t c s f tc mp e n a t Cou Sx, l g n
a k uts cbn n e nd d he a e o o ldo s o nt L Sncn o
i

a pe lbl f ld csonh dbenis dsnc Cot Sxwa dimis dwih utprj c
p aa e ma y ii a e sue i e mt i s s se to eudie
purua t Ru e 41.Bac bef et sc zt pli f m ove t a e t c pl ntt a
s nt o l
k or hi olr, anéfs
d o m nd he om ai o dd
as ve h count al gng i e
e nt
, le i nt ndona i lcéon ofe odona dite s The cour deled t t
l nfi
m
l st s .
t ri ha

m oéon by M e or
m andum Opi on a O r te e e O c obe 27,2017.Tli m a t ri now
ni nd de nt r d t r
ls te s

b fr t c t o dee da smoto f sl r jd me a t Cou Sx
eo e he ou t n fn nt' in or lmmay u g nt s o nt L.
I
I.

Pu s ntt Fe rl l ofCiiPt c d e5 () tec zt s T rntsx r
tua o dea Rue vl o e ut 6a,h ol mu tf a l
r
g
mmay
j g nt ft emo nts wst tt r i noge li ds t a t a ymaeilfc a
ud me i h va ho ha he e s
nane ipu e s o n tra a t nd
t mo n i e ildt jd me a amatroflm 'Fe . Ci P. 6 a; l e Cor . .
he va t s nt e o u g nt s te a ' d R. v. 5 () Ceotx
t
v
Car t, 7U. 3 7 3 2 ( 9 69Gln v.
te t47 S. 1 , 2 1 8 )
n EDO Co .71 F.d 2 9 21 ( h Ci. 01 )
, 0 3 0 , 3 4t t 2 3 .
W he m a ng t sde e m i éon,t cour s zd consde ft pl alngs deposdons
n ki hi t r na
he
t hotl
i r fhe e ci ,
i
,

a we st i er g t is a a e si nso û e t g t r* t1. .gny a ûd v t' f e b
ns r o ntro aore , nd d so n l, o ehe . . a ) f a is'i d y
1
l
t pa de .Ceot x,477 U . a 322.W het ra f c i m aera de
he r s l e
S. t
he a t s t il pendson t r lva
he ee nt
2

sbsa velw. es nv. bet Lob ,nc, 7U.. 4 , 8(9 6.f yds e
u tnd a And ro Li ry by I .47 S 2 2 24 1 8 )f
onl iputs
ove f t t m i afe t out om e oft s tunde t gove ri lw wilpr zy
r ac s hat ght f ct he c
he ui
t he
tlng a
l ope l

prcud t e r o s
el e he nty f ummayj g ntFa tzlds e ta aeirlva o u c say
r ud me . caa iputs h t r ree nt r nnee st
wi hotb c u e . I .(iai o itd . emo i gpat be r t i i l d n of
l
l e o nt d' d ctton nl e ) Th v n ty a s he nda but e
'
t
de onst tng t abs nce ofage nnei s ofm a e i lf t Cel e 477 U . a 323.I
m t ai he e
npi s ue
t ra ac . ot x,
S. t
f
t tbur n hasbee m e ,t non- ovi patym us t n com e f wa d a esa h t
ha
de
n t he
m ng t
t he
or r nd t bEs he

s cfcmaeila t i dsut t s ti smmayj g n. tu hi Elc I us Co.
peii tra fcs n ip e o uvve u t ud me tMas s t e .nd .
a
v. nt Ra o Co .4 5. .. 7 ,5 6 7 (9 6 .
Ze ih di
, 7 1 5 5 4 8 -8 1 8 )
7
I de evni ngw het ra ge nneis ofm a e i lf te ss t c utvi wst
n t t ni
he
nli s ue
t ra ac xit , he ot
e he
f c sand dtw salr as
at
a l e onabl i e e esi t lghtm os f vor bl t t non- ovi
e nf r nc n he i
t a a e o he
m ng

pat. y 7 0F.da 2 3(ingBon v. a it6 9F.d36 , 8 (t Ci. 1 ).
ry Glnn, 1 3 t 1 cé
ds Levt, 2 3 9 3 0 4h t20 1)
l e d fi i a fxo t ti tln o amo f rs mma yj g nt t e i n eof
nd e , fl s n a im ha n lig n
gt
l
don o u r ud me , he v de c
t non v nti t bebeive a alus ibl i e e e a et bedtwn i hi fvo .'
he mo a s o
le d, nd l j dfa e nfr nc s t o
a n s a r'
'

McAili I . l mbel-clr Co .No.1 - 0 4 2 4W L 2 71 9 ,a * (t Ci.
tads nc v.ti r ak
3 2 4 , 01
8 4 2 t 1 4h r
J ne2 , 01 )( ena atrdo o te )(i gToa v. t ,1 4S. . 8 ,1 6
u 5 2 4 i z l lea n mitd cdn ln Coton 3 Ct1 61 8 3
nt
( 1 )( rc zn lMo e ve,Tcrdiit deemi do ,heweg ngoft ei nc,
20 4 pe uiml. r o r fje bly tt na ns t ihi
g
i
he vde e
a t dtwi g oflgHmaei f r n e fo t fc sa ej yf nc , t eofa
nd he a n e i t n ee c s r m he a t r ur u dons not hos
j g . .. And r o 4 7U.. t25 . we r t no mo i gpa t f ts tf rh
ud e . 7 e s n, 7 S a 5 Ho ve, he n- v n ty f
'
mus e o t
s c fc f st tgo be
pe i act ha
yond t f e e e sence ofas i il ofe dence''G lnn,710 F.
he m t xit
cntla vi
.'
3d

a 2 3(uoigAn ron, 7 U.. t25 )I ta ,heno mo n p rymus s w t t
t 1 q tn des 4 7 S a 2 .nse d t n- vig at
t ho ha
The ei s fiinte i e c fvoi g t non vngpat f raj yt r tln aveditf
f r s u fce v d n e a ln he mo i ry o ur o e l' r c or
t
t
t tpat . Re . nk h r sCo . S . u Mec I . .4 F.d 6 , 35(t Ci.
ha ry' s Ba s a e
;
v. t Pa l r
ns Co, 07 3 31 6 4 h r
3

2 0 )(uo gAndes 47 U. a 2 9.fnote wo dst ga smmayj g r t
0 5 q dn
ron, 7 S. t 4 )ï h t r ,o rnt u t ud meg he
l
(

rl l mus d t= i t tnor ao bej. c z fndf rteno vngpat o t
cou' t ee ne ha e s na l ur otd i o h nmo i ry n he
t
y l
e de ebeo ei'Mos v. tsCo .9 5F. 7 , 3 (t Ci. 9 3 (i gPei
vi nc fz t' s Pak
, 8 2d 36 7 8 4h r 1 9 ) ce
rni
Co . Pe i Con t I .9 5F. 1 ,1 4 (t Ci.1 9 ).
v. rni s. nc, 1 2d 21 2 4h r 9 0 )
1 .
11

I Cou Sx o t c mpli , l gngne h e e J dsFt t us tcnmst the
n nt i f he o ant al i g g nc , us ml e li ha
e
ho
s ft d a a l i yb wa no alwe t s ead t r a d fnda t bt a he t i
ufe e n nke t
jur ut s t l d o e oco , nd e e n s e c d her
o
dut ofc r t pr de pr tm edi ltea m e t f t rc l e A sar s t Funkhous r
y a e o ovi
ope
ca r t nt o os e hidr n.
e ul,
e
cli she T ufe e wih a fac ar ankl a lc ofm e c lte % e f a l s t ee
nm
f f r d t r t ed
s
.
e nd a k
dia r a nt or t ea t ht
we ,a gr a m e a a e otona a s pan a s f
eks nd e t nt l nd m i l nguih, i nd ufedng r uli t r fom .'
es tng he e r '

Co l, No. , t! 1 2 De e a sagu t tbe a et Eva Ho i ac ttbl
mp .ECF
1 a 1 . fnd nt r e ha c us he ns me s haia e
or ni éon,Funkhous rsne i ncec m i ba r d by t docti ofchatt bl
ga za
e ' glge
bi s t e
he
tne
ia e
i m uniy.
m
t The c ta ee .
our gr s

The doc rne ofc rt bl i uniyf sm ounded i t publcpolc t tt
ti
ha ia e mm t d
i
n he
i iy ha he
r our esofc rt ei dt donsa e bete us t f t rt i dt i sc dt bl
es c
ha iabl ns u
r l r ed o urhe he ns uton' ha a e

pum os s t n t pa t tcnm sl
e , ha o y or li odged by t c rt sbe
he ha iy' neûca i s' O 1 v. CA ofS.
ite .' a YM

Ha t n Roa l .27 Va 55 , 5 , 21S. 2 7 , 2 (00 ) I e d a t eVigli
m o
ds nc, 0 . 0 5 5 6 E.d 0 7 2 5 . nd e , s h ti a
a
Supr m e Cour hasz cogniqd,Ti i m a f ty desz bl t tt y s d be e
e
t
e
z ft s niesl
ia e ha he houl
ncour ge t
a d o
do t i good wor a t t send pr e t s f .a i i consse wih publc s f y a
he.
r
k, nd o hi
ot c ed o a s t s
r
it nt t
i a et nd

t publcgood f om pec za yla lt t t ew ho a e t i beneft . W eson' Acm '
he
i
r
urir ibiiy o hos
cc pt het
is'
' t s l x

v.
Hos . S . nc ntofPa l 1 1Va 5 7, 0 SE. 7 5 (9 ) a r ae on o he
of tVi e
u, 3 . 8 1 7 . 7 8 1 21, b o td t r
4

ounds M c onad v.H a t Tr i n Sch.f N ut es 254 Va 79,486 S. 2d 299
, D
l
m on ani
or
s ,
.
E.

(9 7 .
1 9)
Vig' l f vor alm ied f m ofc t bl i m uniy,e m ptng c dt e
r m ' a s i t or
a
hria e m
t xe i ha abl
or niatonsfom s e butnota l t tla lt O 1,270V a a 555,621 S. 2d a 72
ga z i
r
om ,
l, or i biiy. a
.t
E. t

(iigW et sAd xv,1 Va a 61 , 0 S. a 7 29 )I niyprcud sa
ctn son' m' 31 . t 0 1 7 E. t 9 -3 .mmu t el e
c a fsb n fcaisfom rc veigda g sfrt ne l e at o isswa so
h dt e eiite r e o rn ma e o he gi nt cs f t e nt r
g
a nt ,s l a due c z wasexe c s d i t i hii and r t ndon.I a 556,621 S. 2d
ge s o ong s
ae
r i e n het rng
ee
d. t
E.

a 7 Ana e to sra tofac rt s ae t c tt i
t 2. g n r ev n
haiy h rs he haifs mmunt fo l bit wll
iy r m i ly a e
a i i
e ge i t c tt ' w or a ac i die ty f t be f oft c tt Se Bha ' .
nga d n he ha iys k nd tng t c l or he nek
he ha ip e
dav

Me k I c, 6 Va 5 4 5 1SE. 35 ( 0 )M o r v. arn 25 Va 4 , 2 , 3
ha , n .2 2 . 4 , 5 . 2d 8 20 19 o e W re , 0 . 21 4 5 46
S. 2 45 , 61( 9 5 . mmutt d sno e e t i v te o st n e sh v n no
E.d 9 4 1 9 ) I n y oe t xtnd o n ie s r ta g r a i g
i
be fc a r ldons p t t c rt bl i dtzi how e r O 1,270 Va a 555,621 S. 2d
ne ii l ea
hi o he ha ia e ns tton,
ve . a
.t
E.

a 7 N o do si e tnd t l bit f ta t ofg o so wZII a wa o ne l e e L a
t 2. r e t x e o i ly o c s r s r fI nd nt n gi nc . d
a i
'I
.
g

trl coa isl i c rtbet r i
fl o l k tef n haia l o tmmunt , n o g nia mus e tbh ht ti i
iy a r a m don t sa s ha t s
fha ia e'f pum os soft t ti m uniydoc dne a t tt pli ifwasa
c rt bl or
e
he or m
t
t , nd ha he antf
be hc a y oft ot ni éon' c rt bl a dvi satHm e oft al dl t dous
ne i r
he ga ma
s ha ia e c ée
he lege y or

c nd t'Da ds v. l il i ms t Fo md, 7 F. u 61 ,6 3( D. .
o uc. vi on Coon a W l bu t .81 S pp. 1 1 E. Va
'
b
1 3;a c r O1, 7 Va a 5 5 6 SE. a 7 Co t e o at - r t s t
99 ) c o d a 2 0 . t 5 , 21 . 2d t 2. urs mply wo pat e t o
de e i whet ra ot ni don i fc rt bl' a t quaii t as e ti m uriy
t v ne
he n ga za
s rha ia e : nd hus lfed o s r m
lt

unde t sdoc dne.Fis,t <c t ri e m i d f t sa ed pur e' a s c
r hi
t
r t he rhare s xo ne or he t t
pos ,' nd e ond,ft
fhe

c t c e oft ac u lope a
ha a t r he t a
r don ofa i étz i anayz ' Ra e cv. a I e m ont
n ns tdon s l ed. dos vi V . nt t
'

Colge 6 3F. u 1 8 ,1 7 ( D. . 9 6 .ffa o g nm donsc ne s t f rh a
l , 3 S pp. 0 4 08 W. Va 1 8 ) f n r a ia ' ha t e s o t
e
l
5

c dt bl ozeee os r pum os t ei az buta epr lmpdon i ope a e asa
ha a e l m yna y
e, het s e t bl esl
t t ts
c lt bl i dm ton i ac or nc wil t pur e H owé r i t m a ri whi h t
haia e ns i n c da e tn hat pos .
ve , f he nne n
c he
or ni don ac tal conduc sisafar i noti ac or wih t cha a epur e t n
ga za
tz l
y
t t fis s
n c d t he dt bl
pos , he
t pt s pton m a ber buted a t ba ofc dt bl i m uniy doeshota p' O l,
he e um i
y
e t nd he r ha a e m
t
ppl ' a

2 0Va a 5 7 6 SE.da 73( en lcttonsomitd.
7 . t 5 , 21 . 2 t i r a iai
nt
te )
H e e t e de esa ihest t Eva H om ewa i om or t d i 1952 a a
r , he vi nce t bls
hat he ns
s nc
ae n
s

n pt f c dtbeo g nia nta q lisa a5 ()3 e iyfrtxpu p e a i
on oh, ha a l r a m éo h t uaie s 01c() ntt o a r oss nd s
f
ca she a ap lcc a iyund rt I tr a Re n Co . el c a dAf.ECF N o
lsi d s ubi h rt e he n e n l ve ue de Se a c r f,
.

1 8 1 a 1 2, 9 A & B t J c ad Af.ECF No 1 82, 83. tha o r t da a
1 - , t 5 4 Ex.
o a c r f,
. 1 - 11 - I s pe ae s
n pr ht c aia l o g nia n snc isi e éo l c r Af.ECF No.1 8 1 a !6 i
on o , h rtb e r a z éo i e t nc p n, a ad f,
1 - , t J ,s
f nd dptma i t ou h p iaedo do ,d a ! 1 , ndi g ve ne b avoun e rboad
u e i rl hr g tv t na ns i a t ( 0 a s o r d y l t e r
y
o dz co s L. a ! 1 . Eva Ho ' p r ei t pr viec t a aho - fe o
f ie t r ,d t 4 The ns mes u pos s o o d ae nd me r e f
,
a
c
hrge t c l e plce i isc t by t Com m onweat ofVigi a,orpl c by
- o hidr n a d n t a e he
lh
r ni
a ed

h ls o i di ntfmie i ne d ofs me net tk c r o t erc i e J c adAf.
omee s r n ge a l s n e
i
o o o a e a e f h i hl n. a c r f,
dr

ECF No. 1 -, t ( 1 1 .
1 8 1 a !( 2-3
!
Pli f us Funk usrdoe no d s et a t Eva Ho ' c a tts t f rh
nndf J ds
ho e s t iput h t he ns mes h re e s o t
ac iabl pur e,nordoe he diput t ti ope ut i ac da e wi. t tpur e
hart e pos
s
s e ha t l es n cor nc t ha
h
pos .
Ra he ,Funkhous rc m snott be abe i i y oft c dt ' s r es bec us hedi
t r
e bi
o
nefcat
he ha ys e dc , a e
d
notwilngl a ce t .Funkhous ti i t hewaspl e a t Eva H om ea ns li
li y c pt hem
e nss s
ac d t he
ns
gni t as
wiland t wilofhi f r l tm s he ne re e ed i o avolm t t t l donslp wih t s
l
he l
s s niy; l ,
ve nt r nt
t ay e a
li t hi
c ia eor ni don a c tt bl i m uniy doe notba li c m .
hart bl ga za
nd ha ia e m
t
s
r ls bi

6

TheVigi aSupt m e Cout hasdeo e abe k ir f t e put esa <a
r ni
e
'
t
d
nei a y ot hes
pos s T
pe s who r eve s e hi ofvaue whih t or nia
r on
ec i s om t ng
l , c he ga m éon by isc ka e put e,
t har bl
pos
unde t st pr de. B r The te Found. Ba ne t 287 Va.
rake o ovi ' d' a r
'
v. t t,
291,29 754 S. 2d 299,
7,
E.

30 ( 01 )(mphai o te )(i g O1, 7 Va a 5 3 6 SE. a 7 ) I ot rwo ds
22 4 e
ss mitd cdn a 2 0 . t 6 , 21 . 2d t 7 . n he r ,
<ape s i a bene:car1 ofc rt i he ors ha a f ne i lr l
< r on s
i y ha iy f
he s be Hc a eadons p' o t
hi t he

c aia l o g nia n. O1, 70Va a 5 3 6 S. 2 a 7 (in Roa k Hos . sn
h ttbe r a z do ' a 2
?
. t 6 , 21 E.d t 7 ct g no e
i
As'
v. e, 4Va 7 3, 0 ,1 3SE.d5 9 5 2(9 3) Ani i du ln e no rci
Ha s20 . 0 7 7 3 . 2 5 , 6 1 6 ). ndvi a e d t eeve
ûna ila ssa fom achadt bl or ni ton t be a t nehc a y' f put e of
nca s it nce r
a e ga ma i o
f
be
i r ' or pos s
f

<
<

<

cha ia ei m uniy.1 a 564,621S. 2d a 77. A n i vi li abe i it of
rt bl m
t d. t
E. t
ndi dua s
nefcay

(haia e bo y i t ti ii a' i ea éo wih t e iy< r ltd t t c rtb e
c rtbl) unt'f ha ndvdu l ntt c n t he nt i ea e o he haia l
s
t s
pt eoft gr a z don .' d
upos he o g nia j' I .
'
Funkhous rc e t tbe aus he di notwa orne d t s r i esoft Evans
e ont nds ha c e
d
nt
e he e v c
he

H om e hedi note e i o abeneûc a r l donstp wih t or ni éon a i nota
,
d
nt r nt
il ea
li t he ga za
nd s
be fca y f cha ia e i m uniy pur e .
ne ii r or rt bl m
t
pos s Funkhous rsposdon hndsno s
e'
i
uppor ilt
t t he
ca e lw.I ed,t c s her le on sa f t ge r lprndpl t tchatt bl
s a nde he a es ei s
t nd or he ne a i e ha
ia e
i m uniyba sc m sofne i
m
t r bi
glgence T t ewho ac eptt chart bl i dt
f hos
by
c he
ia e ns udon'
s
be f .' ni ofVa H eat Se vs Found. M or i e t l M ori ,275 Va.319,331,657
ne hs'U v.
. lh r .
v. rs x e . rs

S. 2 5 2 51 ( 0 ) s eas Me Hos .I . Oa e , 0 Va 8 8 8 5 1 8S. 2
E.d 1 , 7 20 8 ; e lo m.
nc v. k s 2 0 . 7 , 8 , 0 E.d
3 ,3 3( 9 9 ( c a ia ei dt do i Vign afsl b et b ne ire o t c tt f r
88 9 1 5 ) a h rtbl ns a n n ti i d i l o e ûcais f he ha'y o
z
i a
i
ne i nc ofise pl esi i f ist e t ie or nay ca ei t s l don a t e
gl
ge e t m oye f t al o xe c s di t r n he eec
nd et néon

ofise o e s); etn'Ad x 1 Va 5 7 1 7SE. a 79 rf as fdn ma
t mply e' W so s nf , 31 . 8 , 0 . 2d t 1 i ufe g n
f
a ishi s l oft i chadt ,he t kest rs ofm apm c ,i t i c
val m ef he r
y
a
he iks
l éce f he r hadt bl a nt ha
a e ge s ve
7

be n c r f l s lc e ' Hos . StVi e to Pa l Tho s n,1 6Va 1 ,8 SE.
e ae ul ee td);
y
of . nc n f u v. m o 1 . 01 1 .

1 ,1 (9 4 rabe eiit oftec tt c n hodt as ca nts i efr
3 4 1 1 ) < n fcay h haiy a not l he so iéo eponsbl o
n gke ti uis). nl usrami ra t tme wa plc di t c r oft Ev ns
e l n njte' Fu t e, no t he i , s a e$ n he ae he a
ho
'
,

.

H om e by t D e r e ofSoc a Se i szwhe ehe sa d a wasc r d f ,t c i ng
he pa % nt
i l rvce ,
r
t ye nd
a e or e evi

spe vso l gng me l a ot ra nie . e a cr Af.ECF No. 1 - , t !1 u r iin,od i , as nd he me d s S el cad f,
1 81 a! 5
16.Funkhous rr eved s e hi ofvauewhi t Eva H om eunde akest pz de
e ec i
om t ng
l
ch he ns
rt
o ovi ,
s eB z The t eFound. 287 Va.a 297,75 S. 2d a 302,a li i ez don w11 t
e
d
ar
,
t
4 E. t
nd ls nt ac
:, he
1

EvansH om epli y i r lt d t t ot ni éon' c tt bl pur e s Ol ,270 Va.a
anl s ea e o he ga za s ha ia e pos , ee a
t
564,621 S. 2d a 77.
E. t The f tt i w a notli wil ort wilofli f m iy,t he be
ac hat t s
ls l, he l ls a l hat

pl ed i t Eva H om e i t fr tplc i ofno m om ent H ewasnota st nge ozm e e
ac n he ns
n he ls a e s
.
ta t
z

iw ie oft Eva H om e ha ng no be
t t e he ns
vi
nehca r léons p t t chatt bl i tt i Cf
il ea
hi o he
ia e ns iuton. .

B r TheteFou , 7Va a 2 7 75 SE.da 3 2Sodn o g ne husatwho
d at nd.28 . t 9 , 4 . 2 t 0 lig r a nt is
unde t t z pa ra r sor By d The r or wasnotFounda
r ook o e i nd e t e r
ate gan
don' be i it
s nefcay

be a ehçwa not e ev n s r e c nsse tw11 c rtbl o g n m t snms;
c us
s r c ii g e dc s o itn t1 haia e r a iai i ) Hos .
.
on'

ofS. n e of ul1 6Va 1 ,8 SE. t1 Sodngpli fwh ac mpa e he
tVic nt Pa , 1 . 01 1 . a 4 li andf o c o nid r
sc fi nd t t hos t lf te entwa a Tsr r'a notabe
ik re o he pia or r a%
s ftange ' nd
nefcat oft
i y he

c rt) Rahe , k us rier cs l t t p ofbe ûcayc ptmp ae b t
haiy. t t Fun ho e sp e iey he y e
ne ir o e ltd y he
c tt bl i m uniy docti .Thus hi ne i ncec nm i ba r d.
ha ia e m
t
tne
, s glge
li s re 3

2Asde e nt poi out t D e rm e ofSoca Se vc ha l g lc t ofF' lhous a t tm e a
f nda s nt
he pa t nt
il r ies d e a usody
m r er t he i , nd

Fl l o srh db e rp ee tdb ag ada a le a teprce ig i J vzl Do scRea o sCo z
z r ue a en e rsne y u rin d i m th o e dn sn u eze med ld n ut
nh
t
i
3Flnlhous rr ie no a gu e - nori t r a s ge don i t r c d - t tt Eva H om e d d note r e due
l r e a s s r m nt
s he e ny ug s
n he e or ha he ns
i
xe ds
c e i t hii a r t ndon ofise oy es
ar n he rng nd e e
t mpl e .

8

1 .
5,

Fo teeraon , fn nt'
r h s es s dee da smodo f smmayjd me ( No. 1 ) lbe
n or u r u g ntECF
1 7 wil
GRANTED,h pe i moé i l n ( No. 8 DENI asmoo , ndt sc s
te ndng on n i e ECF
mi
6)
ED
t a hi ae
D ISM I D . n a opra e Ot twilbeent t d.
SSE A ppr i t de l
ee

Enee: a / - o f - u o /
ttd
z. Jr
.
..

/ fM -zr g' .. . ?
+ . . .a . . .
j'
z
r
,
M i lF. r nsd
chae U ba l

Che Urie S ae D iiit u g -- 'if t d tts src l d e' 't

9