Shelton v. Colvin
Filing
18
MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Michael F. Urbanski on 11/23/2016. (jat)
I
!
l
1
CLERK' OFFI U, Dî COURT
S
QE S. ST.
AT Y OKE,
VA
FIED
L
I THE UNI S
N
TED TATESDI RI COURT
V CT
FORTHE WES
TERN DI TRI OFW RGI A
S CT
NI
H ARM S
ONBURG DI SI
XI ON
I
y2V 23 2 1
22
J
u
L V cu
E EM
BY:
L
RO N N I T .SH E LTO N ,
E
Pl ntf,
ai if
Ci lA cuon N o.5:5- 0027
1
vi
1 CV1
I
M.
2
I
CARO LY N W .CO LVI ,
N
Com m i i
ss onetofSoci Securt
al
iy,
By: M i
chaelF.U r
bansd
l
Unie S a e Diti t udge
l d t t s s rc J
:
D ef
endant
.
!
l
M EM ORAN DUM oél oN
Nl
I
Thimatri beo et c ur onpli ifRo : i S lon' rs lo 'f tonfr
s te s fr he o t antf lne het s fhetn' T i o
) Mo
'
'
lon ks he
't e
t
i r t pt m r 3
Rec i r éon. ECF N o.16.Shet as t coutio r consde isSe e be 1 , 2016
onsde a
o d rds si t i c s f rlc ofs jc ma trJ tsl ton ( No. 5 . rt
r e imisng h s a e o a k ub e t te l icc i ECF
x i
1 ) Fo he
r as t tf l Shet sm oton i D EN I D .
e ons ha olow, lon'
i s
E
1.
'
I
'
.
Shelon fld li c antonApdl23,2015. hec ai se fom as resof
t ie ls ompli
T ompl nt tms r
ei
s biiy ns a e nef , l
a i donsShelon m ade f Soca Se iy I
pplca
t
or il cutt ncom e! d D ia lt I ur nc Be hs al
an
I
ofwhih we ede e lShet s
c
r nid.
lon oughtt vi w oft Soc a SecziyA rm i sz don'
e e
he i l lrt l nita
s
;
I
ds asa o l smos r c ntcnm f rbe û sonr sjdiaag ou .Caoln Covi t
in isl f n
i
t e e li o ne t e u c t r nds t y l n,he
I
I
Co sine ofS ilS cuiy tcovn' f e amq t dimis a g i t tt c t
mmiso r oca e t t f li ' û d
f
l
don o s s, r ang ha he o ut
I
wa wih tjrsl d t c i e Sh lo sc mplI . No. . mo n wa
s t ou u icc on o onsd r et n' o znt ECF 7 The éo s
i
I
:
I
1F
1
o ad ti dlso yo S et nsa miita v a djcca a p as seECFNo 1 , t r eal l tr f h lo ' d nsrd e n ul jl p e l,e
e i
i
. 2 a 1 3.
ng
rfrdtMaireugleCHop,h iudareportzecom m endi the coutt
eee o gttldeol. pew oseI
z
sa
s
g a Col n' m odon.ECF N o.12.
t nt vi s
l
Th rpo tnotdt tj iil e iw i o cnsi p elde wheea a l a nf
e e r e ha udca rve s rl tl rcu d r n ppi éo ot
i Iy
c
1
s i s ctrt be si din is on r ' caagr
ocal e jiy neft s s ased es udi t ounds 1 at4.Howe r c t si
. da
ve , ours tl
l
i
ha ejrsito t c i rc s ato lsue. d.1 rpo.i ntfe o s his :
v uidcin o onsde on ét ina is sI The e' t de iid ne uc sue
z
' t
!
u rS r d rv. ri,6 F.d 2 7 (t Ci. 9 0 ,f he me a ine sp e lde apr
nde h a e Ha rs 31 2 9 4 h z 1 8 ) fwl n ntll s r cu d o
g
l
'
'
z cll a fom unde sa ng how t obt i a e dç ir he rng a t re pa t de a of
t nm nt z
t t ndl
o an n vi nta y a i fe x r e nil
.
hi a i ton f beneft,77 (im is 1oft tc m a ' s e ntm oton f a hea on
s pplca i ot
is ls s a
ha bi nts ubs que
i or
dng
rsu iaago n s iltsted epo esca s o l eCo stt n J (u t gSl dt
e dct zu d voae h u rcs lu e fh néa i .A q oi la e,
t
zo
n t
'
l
6 F.d a 3 0 . mpo tf und t tt el l adc ltdi Sla rcd n sveS lo s
31 2 t 0 ) The r o ha h ' e r u ae n l de l ot a het n'
u
,
r
i
cli fom dinas a f t sm pl r a on t tShet 1 wa r pê ent by a a t ney
sm r
s is l or he i e e s ha
lop s e es ed
n tor
I
durng hi a i éon pr es .I at6.
i
s pplca
oc s d.
Thus dinas à ofhi cli doesnotvi a edue
, s i sjl
s lm
olt
pz s . d.a 7.
oce s I t
OnSe e t1 , 0 6 ti c t , fe X no rve ofS lo ssn l o e do
ptmbe 3 2 1 ,hs outatr
vo e iw hetn' ige bjc n
I
( No 1 ) a op e J d Ho ' rpo ti iseliey a dimi s dt c s f rlc
ECF . 3 , d t d u ge ppes e r n t rttt' nd s se he a e o a k
,
ofsbjc matrjrs cin. No 1 . OcoIr11 S lo fldhi mo fr
u e t te uidito ECF . 5 On tse , het n i s éon o
e
r consde ai ECF N o.1 t whi Col n s e 'e l fl d ar s
e i r ton,
6, o ch vi ubs qu nty ie e pons i opposton,
en
ii
I
ECF N o.17.
II.
M odonsf r onsde adon, l notunc m on i f a pr c ie,a enot
or ec i r
whie
om
n eder l a tc r
I
2
t cogni d unde t Fe r Rul sofCii Pr ede e See Am bln M
e
ze
r he de al e
v l oc
.
i
'
t Co. U ni
. v. v.
I
!
Viw Pat r.
e rnesLLC, . DQ-72 71 20 0WL 45 0 , t* n. ( M d Fe 3, 1 )
No W
0 -0 , 1
l75 8 a 1 3 D. . b. 20 04
I
l
Abo et Betl c v. l ha a Ro
v he l n . Me Bo nn n ofn I .9 F. D. 9 1 0( D. . 9 3.
nc, 9 R. 9 , 0 E. Va 1 8 )
N e r he e s c t ha hel t tt s m otonsc n pe f m avaua e f
ve t l s , ours ve d ha he e
i
a r or
l bl uncdon.
Above
l
t Bet I ,99 F. D .a 1 Suc a m odon w oul bea opra ewhe e f e m pl,
he l, nc.
R. t 01. h
d ' ppr i t
r , or xa e
I
I
t Cour ha pa e l r s r t
he
t s t nty niunde s ood a pa t or has m ade a
ry,
d cso ou sd t a ves ra is sp) sent t t Colr by
e ii n tie he d r ailsue ;e ed o he zt
t pa ée , or ha m a a e t not of r as ng but of
he r s
s de n r or
e oni
a e nson.A f t rbass f am ofon t t onsde woul
ppr he i
urhe
i or
i o ec i r
d
be a c t lng orsg fc ntc ngei ihe 1w orac ssncet
ont oli
inii a ha
nt a
t i
he
s ison oft i s t t Cot .Sûc pr e sr r l a ie
ubnnsi
he s ue o he ut I h obl m a ey ts
a t m odon t r c i rs zd be'qual r r .
nd he
o e onsde hotl
e ly a e
'
f
I I ed,be us oft i e es i fnaiy courss zd g a m odonsf
d. nde
ca e he ntr t n i lt ,
t hotl r nt
ot
I n. e
r consde a s i y.Uni ofV a Pat Found. G e El c.Co.755 F.Supp.
e i r éon parngl
v.
. ent
v.
,
2d
1 De Die o Co.,
l t ct
7 , 4 - ( D. . 01 )(uot Da o bv. n
38 7 3 44 W. Va 2 1 q i
ng
u Pe n636
,
9 F. up 2
0 S p. d
j
6 7( D. 2 0 ); e Do i v. vc Dic fntDr Cts, 30 c 0 2 , 0
3 E. Pa 0 0) se wne Re o sou
u r.No. :5 v0 0 1 2 06
W L 1 7 9 0 a * ( . Va Ma 1 20 6. moi t reconsdershoul notbeused t
1 1 6 , t 1 W D. . y , 0 )A tok o
i
d
o
,
r ie a ea gum e spt vi l m a or
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?